This is an excellent account of the facts. The statement, “any indigenous people would have resisted others trying to disposes them of their land” confirms why this war predates 7 October and remains unresolved.
Are you forgeting all the other countries that have supported the genocide of Palestinians & the USA & us Christians are the biggest supporters of the genocide including 1930s Deutschland.
Thank you for asking insightful, comprehensive questions and for not interrupting your guest Rashid Khalili's detailed, cogent answers on this tragedy of humanity.
Proud of my Palestinian fellow very thorough explanation .I am a victim of Nakba 1948 .Palestinians are very resliant and will never give up and we will liberate Palestine and end the occupation.I am hopeful.
There is no way to correct all the wrongs of the past. I don't like the fighting. I think either Jews and Palastinians need to get married(every adult gets 1 vote), or divorced. Draw a border, and let's go. See if the Boring company would send a Prufrock 3 to connect Gaza and West Bank with bunches of tunnels. Once you get to 3, you can put utilities in one, and traffic in the other 2. Desalination plant on the mediteranean. You would want a port too. Independent, but no shooting. Needless to say, drawing that border would be contentious, and none of it is worth it if the fighting continues. I have no idea why we(US) give unconditional support to this apartheid situation.
excellent interview, one of the best thanks to Rashid Khalidi and Novara Media. so eye opening. please do more comprehensive interviews on the details of the past negotiations to null this ridiculous notion that the Palestinians have rejected realistic chances of having a state of their own.
Don't forget the history of Apartheid South Africa. The ANC under which Mandela was a member of bombed parts of South Africa to bring attention to the oppression of the South African. Consequently, Mandela was arrested and prosecuted as "terrorist" and the ANC was considered a "domestic terrorist organization.
This was so so so good; information was presented to very easily to understand the sheer horror of Zionism supported by USA & UK mostly, towards demise of Palestinians & their land.
Imagine when confronted by pro Palestinian protesters the US congressman claimed in front of the camera they will always back Israel and one even came to the office door with the Israeli flag in hand.
More Psychotic Propaganda, Dont believe this Guy, he is against the Jews, actually The present Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas said that the greatest single mistake of the Palestinian Arab delegates was to refuse the offer of an independent State which was offered to them in 1947 by the UN, this newly formed State would have been in areas of old Palestine that are now referred to as the disputed territories of the West Bank and the Gaza Strip In the Camp David agreements (in the 1970s)held in the USA, Israel offered the Palestinians a State in these disputed territories. Again in the Oslo accords (in around 1993) the Palestinians were offered an independent state in the disputed territories. Many times over the Israeli Government has offered the Palestinian representatives an Independent State
Western governments, that is, esp the US. Most governments of the rest of the world had not be silent. Most people in the rest of the world is aware of this more or less in the details. But most people in the so called free world, free speech world, the western world is not. They look at the world from a height which prevent them from seeing the details. Their 'exceptionalism' blinds them from what most of the rest of the world (world majority actually) see everyday. But most abhorrent is the US geopolitic that supports Israel no matter what. The US government (and perhaps its majority citizens) is the real guilty party.
@@chrislambert9435are you naive or simply hardheaded? If the offers were so great & just, why wouldn’t have the Palestinians taken them up? The only way that you could believe that, is if you don’t see Palestinians as humans, capable of seeing & determining what’s good for them. Btw, Israeli officials have admitted that the way they see it, they won over land thru the various wars. But int’l law doesn’t recognize such a thing. Int’l law states that you can’t gain (aka confiscate) land thru military means. Which is partly why what Russia has been doing is illegal.
@@chrislambert9435the U.N. also recognizes Israel as an occupying power. Which is why everyone describes certain areas as “the (Israeli) occupied territories”.
Great interview. Just shared it. was especially impressed by how Khalidi sensitively recognized the antisemitism that drove many Jews to political Zionism.
Excellent account. Thank you Ash for very relevant questions and thank you Mr Khalidi for such a knowledgeable summary of key events and motivations. Well done.
🙏🏽 Sorry for your tears but so happy to hear someone come awake from watching the areal True History of the lllllong Conflict… it was NOT JUST Oct 7Th 2023 … it’s been well beyond my generation and my mothers generation and hers before that…. It’s not as black and white and easy and no sides have been always honest…. There are so Many areas of GREY & Much Hypocrisy & Dishonesty all around. There’s so much more than just one thing or one side or the other here. Happy to hear you’ve leanrt some things here…& wish u well 🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽
Thank you for interviewing professor Rashid Khaledi, and for asking the right myth-debunking questions. Professor Khaledi's book "The 100 years war on Palestine" is a must read.
I've been working hard to educate myself on this complex subject, learning a patchwork of information, from documents, interviews, some very challenging articles; chasing up every comment I've read which mentioned something I hadn't heard about. I knew quite a lot before about events in my lifetime, but have only been able to explore the context since, surprisingly recently, gaining access to the resources on the internet. This is the first time I have heard someone put all these threads together so I can see how they interacted and combined to create the history and the ongoing oppression and conflict which currently exists. I now feel far better prepared to form cohesive responses to challenges to my comments. Thank you so much.
The best hour anyone could spend on trying to understand this conflict. Excellent interview questions from Ash, excellent presentation from Rashid. Thanks both. Viva Palestina.
I think this is the first Palestinian historian I’ve listened to, the testimony from the horses mouth(see Jabotinsky’s own writing) and Israeli historian(of various political bends), this is so grotesque, and it’s so grotesque that one has to read and watch so much content to just cut through the hasbara
What occupation ? Dont believe this Guy, he is against the Jews, actually The present Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas said that the greatest single mistake of the Palestinian Arab delegates was to refuse the offer of an independent State which was offered to them in 1947 by the UN, this newly formed State would have been in areas of old Palestine that are now referred to as the disputed territories of the West Bank and the Gaza Strip In the Camp David agreements (in the 1970s)held in the USA, Israel offered the Palestinians a State in these disputed territories. Again in the Oslo accords (in around 1993) the Palestinians were offered an independent state in the disputed territories. Many times over the Israeli Government has offered the Palestinian representatives an Independent State
@@chrislambert9435 Take your head out of zionism cult-speak. It's an ethno-nationalist political ideology created in the 19th century. Actually WATCH the interview.
@@LisaTrippas abrahamic religions are poorly plagiarized from a dozen older religions. It's nonsense fiction created by a ruling class to manipulate the people's perception of reality in service of the ruling class. So don't worry about Voldemort, the muggles are going to be just fine (unless a religious extremist death cult targets them because religion is used to manufacture consent for psychopathic leadership).
Ash Sarkar continues to shine. Rashid Khalidi gives a clear and succinct explanation of Palestinian history, Israel's dispossesion of Palestine and it's actions which led to the present day war. Disgusting, disgraceful and dispicable aren't enough to describe Israel.
Are you anti asylum for Jews? That's the main reason for modern antisemitism isn't it? "Not in my backyard"! And this Muslim schoolar looks like a European Jew, so he's welcome, just not Jews. Have I understood that?
@@chrislambert9435 He said the Palestinians were offered a State but Israel'sTerms and conditions did not give Palestinians sovereignty and Israel would remain in control. Also, each offer took away more land away from Palestine than the one before.
Palestinians deserve to first be treated as humans. And they definitively have the right to self defense and self determination un an armed struggle. Gaza is the largest concentration camp in human history and Hamas fighters have shown higher standards of professionalism than the IDF, which operates under the Hannibal Directive. Details are found in article written by Max Blumenthal and his interview by Chris Hedges.
thank you for these historical clarifications which should the whole world know but I don't know what they teach their pupils in history classes. You should remind them cause remembrance is beneficial to the believers ذكر فإن الذكرى تنفع المؤمنين
I remember Rashid from AUB Lebanon in late seventies, God bless him, this show is history in a nutshell, it should be shown in every school and university all over the world.
Wow that blew my socks off. That was sooo good. Thank you Novara Media and thank you Rashid Khalidi for the privilege of being able to sit and listen to your erudite explanation of a complex and vexed conflict. I have been becoming more and more depressed with what I have been seeing on even on alternative media let alone MSM but this has restored my faith somewhat as it is powerful truth and common sense based on facts. Can’t thank you enough.❤
So, now you think you know all. Can you imagine you shock when you comprehend how limited view you proclaim "best, clearest and..." Being IGNORANT. Simply, YOU ARE IGNORANT but youclaim it is "BEST". Foolish , isn't it ?
First-rate synopsis of the factual history of Israel's founding and the denigration of the Palestinians by Rashid Khalidi, as well as a synopsis of his scholarly book, The Hundred Years' War on Palestine. Stellar interview by Ash Sarkar.
I agree with you on that, but the problem is as follows: - many channels associate Palestinians with Hamas, but they are not! - Hamas is using civilian infrastructures for assaults & is using those people as human shields! Yes, there are civilian casualities on the both sides: Israeli & Palestinians die! And to be clear, I'm no fun of Bibi... and there should be worked out a solution... ...but all that Israel-Palestine mess is just a discraction!!! Вова (Poo-tin) 🤡💩 screwed it up, bigly... Hamas & Hezbollah could not pull it without external help and I'm sure the timing is not coincidental! Russia & Iran are involved: - weapons were delivered by them (also western weapons, which Russians have captured in Ukraine) - Wagnerites have trained Hamas and some of them were even involved in attacks (yeah... there are vids floating on internet and on terrorussian channels) - the same playbook: killing civilians, hospitals... millitary targets are hit just by accident! / the hospital in Gaza was destroyed by missile fired by Hamas - kinda oopsy! / Я говорю тоже по-русски!😈
Dont believe this Guy, he is against the Jews, actually The present Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas said that the greatest single mistake of the Palestinian Arab delegates was to refuse the offer of an independent State which was offered to them in 1947 by the UN, this newly formed State would have been in areas of old Palestine that are now referred to as the disputed territories of the West Bank and the Gaza Strip In the Camp David agreements (in the 1970s)held in the USA, Israel offered the Palestinians a State in these disputed territories. Again in the Oslo accords (in around 1993) the Palestinians were offered an independent state in the disputed territories. Many times over the Israeli Government has offered the Palestinian representatives an Independent State
This is an excellent video. The amount of clarity and calmness he has as he describes the horrors of his own people is incredible. Settler colonialism is murderous and horrific.
Great interview. I wish this was on a major western tv channel so that the literacy of people here on this topic could be improved. There are too many myths about Israel here that need to be dispelled
It’s almost comical to know Israel declared independence in 1948. Independence from what, when you literally ethnically cleansed people in 1948 and bring about a new settler-colonial project.
This is called great journalism with true history clearly exposed. Really liked the Rashid Khalidi's full insights and well done to Ash Sarkar to ask the right questions.
Having not known much about the history of palestine and israel, i feel a little more informed on the subject. Excellent interview and fascinating information. Thank you.
That was a brilliant interview, showing the intricate and shocking history of oppression and genocide, from so many greedy sources, against the rightful occupiers of Palestine, including Muslims, Jews, Druze, Christians and others, which needs to be spread far and wide. Thank you, Ash.
Love this video....helps understand everything la verdad de Palestine... I will order the book....just excellent information narration and questions.... Gracias
It "was outstanding" psychotic propaganda, Dont believe this Guy, he is against the Jews, actually The present Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas said that the greatest single mistake of the Palestinian Arab delegates was to refuse the offer of an independent State which was offered to them in 1947 by the UN, this newly formed State would have been in areas of old Palestine that are now referred to as the disputed territories of the West Bank and the Gaza Strip In the Camp David agreements (in the 1970s)held in the USA, Israel offered the Palestinians a State in these disputed territories. Again in the Oslo accords (in around 1993) the Palestinians were offered an independent state in the disputed territories. Many times over the Israeli Government has offered the Palestinian representatives an Independent State
Israel has lost it’s “right” to be a “neighbor” in the region. Israelis may return to their pre Haavara homelands, or be absorbed by their allies, or become Palestinian citizens ❤
This has been the best compressed historical explination of events leading up to the current violence against the native palestinian population i have heard to date. Thank You so much.
Excellent video, indeed. Partly thanks to Prof. Khalidi's beyond excellent command of the topic but also Ash's fresh, insightful questions. I can only recommend that she interviews others solid scholars on the matter such as Norman Finkelstein, Illan Pappe, Amira Haas and others. Thank you, you got a new subscriber!
Thank you so, so much for this! I have been searching all over for solid, unbiased information on the complicated continuum of Palestine-Israel history. This was fantastic.
It's great that you have explained some of the injustices & the USA being the largest since 1948 but there are some supporters of Israel that are the most unsavoury seem to have not mentioned.
I'M A JEW and VERY fond of arabs. I usually bump into brilliant guys like you. Happy to live in a country with 11 million 'Lebanese'. No one else treat us so well fairly and friendly. Thank you
Amazing video!!!! Novara! Incredible interview! Intelligent questions. Best of the best interviews I’ve seen yet! Finally someone with brains asking real questions and great answers as well! Bravo! Keep up the great work 👍🏼
Thank you for this comprehensive lecture. It’s worth sharing!
The best interview ever about Palestine / Israel problem. Thank you
This is an excellent account of the facts. The statement, “any indigenous people would have resisted others trying to disposes them of their land” confirms why this war predates 7 October and remains unresolved.
@@GoodMan_000"colonized" doesn't serve history justice the original population haven't changed and wasn't replaced but they were arabized
Stick to the subject. Throttle down. Your position is clear, so don't shout@@GoodMan_000
Jews are indigenous to the region
👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Conveniently forgot to mention the 600,000 Jews expelled from Arab countries
Excellent video - the best factual introduction to the crime perpetrated by the British against the native people of Palestine.
@@chrislambert9435 You've spammed this so many times.
Are you forgeting all the other countries that have supported the genocide of Palestinians & the USA & us Christians are the biggest supporters of the genocide including 1930s Deutschland.
@@RadiantStar8997because he’s right!
@@redpapuangoblinredpapuango2755 so where do you get yours from?
@@majorlenses2225 If he's right then why has his comment disappeared?
Thank you for asking insightful, comprehensive questions and for not interrupting your guest Rashid Khalili's detailed, cogent answers on this tragedy of humanity.
Totally agree, Ash did an excellent job here.
I am so impressed with your interviewing skills. I will leave an interview when host keeps interrupting.
They never came to share the land, it was all of it with the absence of the Arab population.
A settler colonialist apartheid project.
British government must clean itself before calling other like ANC, terrorists.
You'll never see an interview like this on US or UK mainstream media.
You haven't but many of us awake people have many sources of the truth & reality which seems novel to ya.
Proud of my Palestinian fellow very thorough explanation .I am a victim of Nakba 1948 .Palestinians are very resliant and will never give up and we will liberate Palestine and end the occupation.I am hopeful.
Stand with Israel ✊🏻 🇮🇱
@@TobiasDaniels-z9c
Why would anyone stand with thieves
There is no way to correct all the wrongs of the past. I don't like the fighting. I think either Jews and Palastinians need to get married(every adult gets 1 vote), or divorced. Draw a border, and let's go. See if the Boring company would send a Prufrock 3 to connect Gaza and West Bank with bunches of tunnels. Once you get to 3, you can put utilities in one, and traffic in the other 2. Desalination plant on the mediteranean. You would want a port too. Independent, but no shooting. Needless to say, drawing that border would be contentious, and none of it is worth it if the fighting continues. I have no idea why we(US) give unconditional support to this apartheid situation.
@ Israelis haven't stolen anything.
@@TobiasDaniels-z9cconstantly stealing land and human lives. Its shameful. Wake up. Nobody likes liars and thieves.
Outstanding. Thank-you Ash, thank-you Rashid Khalidi.
excellent interview, one of the best thanks to Rashid Khalidi and Novara Media. so eye opening. please do more comprehensive interviews on the details of the past negotiations to null this ridiculous notion that the Palestinians have rejected realistic chances of having a state of their own.
Thanks for this work; very important to educate people about all this if anything is ever going to change for the better.
Prof. Khalidi's book is execellent - it explains the history very well
NOPE.
It is onlyone view on history.
His view.
I agree.
It is very one sided.
paulinekaplin6039
GoodMan_000
It's just because we grew up in a different narrative that we feel like our beliefs are all true.
Exactly, his book “The 100 years war on Palestine ” has really covered everything about Israeli - Palestine conflict.
@@pluto9000 Right, and that is more comfortable for many people.
Don't forget the history of Apartheid South Africa. The ANC under which Mandela was a member of bombed parts of South Africa to bring attention to the oppression of the South African. Consequently, Mandela was arrested and prosecuted as "terrorist" and the ANC was considered a "domestic terrorist organization.
@melissamouton5665: 'Bombed parts of South Africa'????? A measure of specification is required.
The ANC had an air force?! Next you'll be suggesting that Madiba was an ace pilot
Really good video to summarise the history. Thanks Ash for the pertinent questions and Rashid for the thorough and thoughtful responses.
Hm… he skipped 20 years when Gaza was an Egypt territory and West Bank was Jordan territory. What prevented them to create a sovereign state then?
P
This was so so so good; information was presented to very easily to understand the sheer horror of Zionism supported by USA & UK mostly, towards demise of Palestinians & their land.
Imagine when confronted by pro Palestinian protesters the US congressman claimed in front of the camera they will always back Israel and one even came to the office door with the Israeli flag in hand.
Excellent information, thanks Novara.
More Psychotic Propaganda, Dont believe this Guy, he is against the Jews, actually The present Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas said that the greatest single mistake of the Palestinian Arab delegates was to refuse the offer of an independent State which was offered to them in 1947 by the UN, this newly formed State would have been in areas of old Palestine that are now referred to as the disputed territories of the West Bank and the Gaza Strip
In the Camp David agreements (in the 1970s)held in the USA, Israel offered the Palestinians a State in these disputed territories. Again in the Oslo accords (in around 1993) the Palestinians were offered an independent state in the disputed territories. Many times over the Israeli Government has offered the Palestinian representatives an Independent State
Excellent and heartbreaking interview. The international community's silence is abhorrent.
Western governments, that is, esp the US. Most governments of the rest of the world had not be silent. Most people in the rest of the world is aware of this more or less in the details. But most people in the so called free world, free speech world, the western world is not. They look at the world from a height which prevent them from seeing the details. Their 'exceptionalism' blinds them from what most of the rest of the world (world majority actually) see everyday.
But most abhorrent is the US geopolitic that supports Israel no matter what. The US government (and perhaps its majority citizens) is the real guilty party.
Thanks for sharing this discussion, I have been eagerly awaiting to hear Rashid Khalidi’s input.
@@chrislambert9435😂😂😂 over and over again 🤓🤔
@@chrislambert9435are you naive or simply hardheaded? If the offers were so great & just, why wouldn’t have the Palestinians taken them up? The only way that you could believe that, is if you don’t see Palestinians as humans, capable of seeing & determining what’s good for them. Btw, Israeli officials have admitted that the way they see it, they won over land thru the various wars. But int’l law doesn’t recognize such a thing. Int’l law states that you can’t gain (aka confiscate) land thru military means. Which is partly why what Russia has been doing is illegal.
@@terriej123 The UN recognised Israel as a Sovereign Nation State in 1948 and still the UN recognises Israel today
@@chrislambert9435yes, and? That’s not what I argued. Nowhere in my comment did I say anything about that. What does it have to do with what I said?
@@chrislambert9435the U.N. also recognizes Israel as an occupying power. Which is why everyone describes certain areas as “the (Israeli) occupied territories”.
Great interview. Just shared it. was especially impressed by how Khalidi sensitively recognized the antisemitism that drove many Jews to political Zionism.
Excellent account. Thank you Ash for very relevant questions and thank you Mr Khalidi for such a knowledgeable summary of key events and motivations. Well done.
Thank you. the ever awaking enormity of crime and injustice against the Palestinians brings me to tears.
🙏🏽 Sorry for your tears but so happy to hear someone come awake from watching the areal True History of the lllllong Conflict… it was NOT JUST Oct 7Th 2023 … it’s been well beyond my generation and my mothers generation and hers before that…. It’s not as black and white and easy and no sides have been always honest…. There are so Many areas of GREY & Much Hypocrisy & Dishonesty all around. There’s so much more than just one thing or one side or the other here. Happy to hear you’ve leanrt some things here…& wish u well 🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽
So you are going to cry a lot in the coming months.
@@ilanklinger2573Bye Hasbara
Thank you for interviewing professor Rashid Khaledi, and for asking the right myth-debunking questions. Professor Khaledi's book "The 100 years war on Palestine" is a must read.
I've been working hard to educate myself on this complex subject, learning a patchwork of information, from documents, interviews, some very challenging articles; chasing up every comment I've read which mentioned something I hadn't heard about. I knew quite a lot before about events in my lifetime, but have only been able to explore the context since, surprisingly recently, gaining access to the resources on the internet.
This is the first time I have heard someone put all these threads together so I can see how they interacted and combined to create the history and the ongoing oppression and conflict which currently exists. I now feel far better prepared to form cohesive responses to challenges to my comments.
Thank you so much.
Bless you for going through all this effort and "fighting the good fight" online. Inspiring!
@@BrRizzy1 Thank you. I couldn't bear to do nothing.
You are doing great. I am trying to do the same.😊
@@moragmckay3779Awesome 💯❤️👍🏼
@@hajirahussain1744💯❤️👍🏼
The best hour anyone could spend on trying to understand this conflict. Excellent interview questions from Ash, excellent presentation from Rashid. Thanks both. Viva Palestina.
I think this is the first Palestinian historian I’ve listened to, the testimony from the horses mouth(see Jabotinsky’s own writing) and Israeli historian(of various political bends), this is so grotesque, and it’s so grotesque that one has to read and watch so much content to just cut through the hasbara
Fantastic informative interview. Thank you
The Ashkenazi Jews are mostly descended from converts during the Roman era (Ha aretz newspaper Oct 11.2013) so no legit “historical claim “
“The Israeli occupation is an insult to human dignity.” ~ GHASSAN KANAFANI
What occupation ? Dont believe this Guy, he is against the Jews, actually The present Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas said that the greatest single mistake of the Palestinian Arab delegates was to refuse the offer of an independent State which was offered to them in 1947 by the UN, this newly formed State would have been in areas of old Palestine that are now referred to as the disputed territories of the West Bank and the Gaza Strip
In the Camp David agreements (in the 1970s)held in the USA, Israel offered the Palestinians a State in these disputed territories. Again in the Oslo accords (in around 1993) the Palestinians were offered an independent state in the disputed territories. Many times over the Israeli Government has offered the Palestinian representatives an Independent State
Every nation whatever the ethnicity will rise against eachother. Jesus will come in glory nobody will escape judgement not even me.
@@chrislambert9435 Take your head out of zionism cult-speak. It's an ethno-nationalist political ideology created in the 19th century. Actually WATCH the interview.
@@LisaTrippas abrahamic religions are poorly plagiarized from a dozen older religions. It's nonsense fiction created by a ruling class to manipulate the people's perception of reality in service of the ruling class. So don't worry about Voldemort, the muggles are going to be just fine (unless a religious extremist death cult targets them because religion is used to manufacture consent for psychopathic leadership).
Basically no one wanted the jews in their country.. very clear throughout history.
Thank you both for an eye opening history lesson. This should be a requirement for all in US schools. World will be a much better place.
Long live Palestinians resistance
Ash Sarkar continues to shine. Rashid Khalidi gives a clear and succinct explanation of Palestinian history, Israel's dispossesion of Palestine and it's actions which led to the present day war. Disgusting, disgraceful and dispicable aren't enough to describe Israel.
🎯
💯💯💯
Are you anti asylum for Jews? That's the main reason for modern antisemitism isn't it? "Not in my backyard"!
And this Muslim schoolar looks like a European Jew, so he's welcome, just not Jews. Have I understood that?
@@chrislambert9435 He said the Palestinians were offered a State but Israel'sTerms and conditions did not give Palestinians sovereignty and Israel would remain in control. Also, each offer took away more land away from Palestine than the one before.
I second that.
Palestinians deserve to first be treated as humans. And they definitively have the right to self defense and self determination un an armed struggle.
Gaza is the largest concentration camp in human history and Hamas fighters have shown higher standards of professionalism than the IDF, which operates under the Hannibal Directive.
Details are found in article written by Max Blumenthal and his interview by Chris Hedges.
@@chrislambert9435👹😂
@@chrislambert9435we get it, you can cut and paste crap. 😮
@@Max-rh1wt The UN recognised Israel as a Sovereign Nation State in 1948
@@chrislambert9435 and what. The british gave them the land because they wanted rid of them.
thank you for these historical clarifications which should the whole world know but I don't know what they teach their pupils in history classes.
You should remind them cause remembrance is beneficial to the believers
ذكر فإن الذكرى تنفع المؤمنين
Thank you for this excellent interview with Professor Khalidi.
I remember Rashid from AUB Lebanon in late seventies, God bless him, this show is history in a nutshell, it should be shown in every school and university all over the world.
@@chrislambert9435😂
@@chrislambert9435😁😳
@@chrislambert9435nice try
Brilliant insight. Thank you Ash and Novara
Such an informative Interview
@@chrislambert9435👽
Great interview, so very informative and heartbreaking 💔.. thank you Novara 🙏🇵🇸🕊️
Wow that blew my socks off. That was sooo good. Thank you Novara Media and thank you Rashid Khalidi for the privilege of being able to sit and listen to your erudite explanation of a complex and vexed conflict. I have been becoming more and more depressed with what I have been seeing on even on alternative media let alone MSM but this has restored my faith somewhat as it is powerful truth and common sense based on facts. Can’t thank you enough.❤
Wow. This is the best, clearest and most comprehensive history lesson I've come across. Great interview.
So, now you think you know all.
Can you imagine you shock when you comprehend how limited view you proclaim "best, clearest and..." Being IGNORANT.
Simply, YOU ARE IGNORANT but youclaim it is "BEST".
Foolish , isn't it ?
Truly excellent video. Rashid Khalidi's manner and presentational force is exceptional.
Very informative video that obviously more people need to see
Thank you for this very insightful interview.
First-rate synopsis of the factual history of Israel's founding and the denigration of the Palestinians by Rashid Khalidi, as well as a synopsis of his scholarly book, The Hundred Years' War on Palestine. Stellar interview by Ash Sarkar.
Yes, great video, thank you. Why was the Nova festival moved closer to the border and why was increased border activity ignored before 7 Oct?
Pales... People & Children Losing There Life, Land & Existence📣😢
I agree with you on that, but the problem is as follows:
- many channels associate Palestinians with Hamas, but they are not!
- Hamas is using civilian infrastructures for assaults & is using those people as human shields!
Yes, there are civilian casualities on the both sides: Israeli & Palestinians die!
And to be clear, I'm no fun of Bibi... and there should be worked out a solution...
...but all that Israel-Palestine mess is just a discraction!!!
Вова (Poo-tin) 🤡💩 screwed it up, bigly...
Hamas & Hezbollah could not pull it without external help and I'm sure the timing is not coincidental!
Russia & Iran are involved:
- weapons were delivered by them (also western weapons, which Russians have captured in Ukraine)
- Wagnerites have trained Hamas and some of them were even involved in attacks
(yeah... there are vids floating on internet and on terrorussian channels)
- the same playbook: killing civilians, hospitals... millitary targets are hit just by accident!
/ the hospital in Gaza was destroyed by missile fired by Hamas - kinda oopsy! /
Я говорю тоже по-русски!😈
Making peace is probably better than an endless war.
@@chrislambert9435 Israeli bot.
@@chrislambert9435💩🙈
Excellent educational video, should be shown on all MSM networks.
Keep up the vital work Novara 👍
This should be on the bbc, it is damning of the msm that you have to go beyond it to be informed on major issues like these
@@Intrepidthegenuine
BBC !?
Man HOW WRONG YOU ARE.
Superb session of concise, essential information. Thank you Ash & Rashid!
Amazing interview 💖
Dont believe this Guy, he is against the Jews, actually The present Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas said that the greatest single mistake of the Palestinian Arab delegates was to refuse the offer of an independent State which was offered to them in 1947 by the UN, this newly formed State would have been in areas of old Palestine that are now referred to as the disputed territories of the West Bank and the Gaza Strip
In the Camp David agreements (in the 1970s)held in the USA, Israel offered the Palestinians a State in these disputed territories. Again in the Oslo accords (in around 1993) the Palestinians were offered an independent state in the disputed territories. Many times over the Israeli Government has offered the Palestinian representatives an Independent State
This is an excellent video. The amount of clarity and calmness he has as he describes the horrors of his own people is incredible. Settler colonialism is murderous and horrific.
Great interview 👍
But what did we learn? That peace is possible? Or that endless war is preferable?
@@chrislambert9435🤕😴
Truly excellent show! This history is priceless education.
Great interview and very insightful. Thank you for sharing the history of Palestine and shedding the light on the cruelty and plans of occupation.
A sobering and intelligent historical account with great questions!
Great interview Ash 👍
Danke Schön ,, Mr. Khalidi,,Free Palestine,,CeaseFire NOW
Khalidi seems both passionate and exhausted, which is exactly how I feel.
Great interview. I wish this was on a major western tv channel so that the literacy of people here on this topic could be improved. There are too many myths about Israel here that need to be dispelled
Thank you for this superb interview. The complete narrative is even worse than I'd imagined.
This man knows his stuff!
Why does he lie about things when we all know the actual facts? What a sad life.
From the historical record, it looks like it was the British empire that instigated and ignited this downward spiraling destructive conflict.
Yup, then they just leave it all while it’s still on fire hoping the US will clean up the mess. The most incompetent imperialists.
Long live the alkhaldis of Palestine 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉!!!❤❤❤❤
It’s almost comical to know Israel declared independence in 1948. Independence from what, when you literally ethnically cleansed people in 1948 and bring about a new settler-colonial project.
This is called great journalism with true history clearly exposed. Really liked the Rashid Khalidi's full insights and well done to Ash Sarkar to ask the right questions.
Rashid is a very, very educated intellectual.
Well spoken too.
terrific interview and history lesson.
Excellent discussion thank you Ash and Prof Khalidi
I always love to listen to Ash but I particularly enjoyed hearing her in conversation with Professor Rashid. As always, thank you NM.
Thank you- really great information.
Having not known much about the history of palestine and israel, i feel a little more informed on the subject. Excellent interview and fascinating information. Thank you.
That was a brilliant interview, showing the intricate and shocking history of oppression and genocide, from so many greedy sources, against the rightful occupiers of Palestine, including Muslims, Jews, Druze, Christians and others, which needs to be spread far and wide. Thank you, Ash.
Great interview. the gentleman appears a little bored at times but he’s a wealth of knowledge. Great questions ash!
Excellent interview! Thank you so much for sharing your knowledge, Mr. Khalidi.
Excellent conversation! Thankyou to both of you, so very much. Clearly Laying out the historical facts is the way to understanding. BRAVO ❤
Thank you 🙏🏻
That was so informative, and a objectively composed interview.
Love this video....helps understand everything la verdad de Palestine...
I will order the book....just excellent information narration and questions....
Gracias
Outstanding.
It "was outstanding" psychotic propaganda, Dont believe this Guy, he is against the Jews, actually The present Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas said that the greatest single mistake of the Palestinian Arab delegates was to refuse the offer of an independent State which was offered to them in 1947 by the UN, this newly formed State would have been in areas of old Palestine that are now referred to as the disputed territories of the West Bank and the Gaza Strip
In the Camp David agreements (in the 1970s)held in the USA, Israel offered the Palestinians a State in these disputed territories. Again in the Oslo accords (in around 1993) the Palestinians were offered an independent state in the disputed territories. Many times over the Israeli Government has offered the Palestinian representatives an Independent State
Clear and on-point conversation. If u want to know about the conflict this is a must watch
Thank you for explaining the history of Palestine. There were lots of questions , got answerers through this interview.
Israel has lost it’s “right” to be a “neighbor” in the region.
Israelis may return to their pre Haavara homelands, or be absorbed by their allies, or become Palestinian citizens ❤
This has been the best compressed historical explination of events leading up to the current violence against the native palestinian population i have heard to date. Thank You so much.
Thank you for this golden opportunity you gave me to learn much needed knowledge about the current situation.
Great interview, with some very intelligent questions asked, thanks for sharing and spreading the truth!
Excellent video, indeed. Partly thanks to Prof. Khalidi's beyond excellent command of the topic but also Ash's fresh, insightful questions. I can only recommend that she interviews others solid scholars on the matter such as Norman Finkelstein, Illan Pappe, Amira Haas and others. Thank you, you got a new subscriber!
Thank you so, so much for this! I have been searching all over for solid, unbiased information on the complicated continuum of Palestine-Israel history. This was fantastic.
Ben Shapiro would NEVER debate this man
Ben shapiro is busy "debating" young college students
It's great that you have explained some of the injustices & the USA being the largest since 1948 but there are some supporters of Israel that are the most unsavoury seem to have not mentioned.
Thank you for the information.
Thank you so much for this wonderful interview. Special thank you to Dr Khalidi. It is an honor listening and watching you speak sir. Bless you.
Thank you very much for Professor Rashid Khalidi for your excellent and informative interview.
Outstanding interview!
Amazing debate !! Novara Media never disappoints 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉 and Ash is a great journalist!
I know a reasonable amount about this but I really didn’t know that Balfour himself was an anti-Semitic exclusionist.
Me neither!
You notice throughout history and today many of Israel supporters are openly antisemetic and/or are evangelical Christians
Very insightful interview! Thank you both
I'M A JEW and VERY fond of arabs. I usually bump into brilliant guys like you. Happy to live in a country with 11 million 'Lebanese'. No one else treat us so well fairly and friendly. Thank you
Amazing video!!!!
Novara! Incredible interview! Intelligent questions. Best of the best interviews I’ve seen yet!
Finally someone with brains asking real questions and great answers as well!
Bravo! Keep up the great work 👍🏼
a concise and factual brief of the palestine modern political history by a brilliant scholar
Love the content you’re putting out!keep going..
Rashid Khalidi, the inheritant of Edward Said’s legacy. Such a good and knowledgeable man! Allah yahfado.