Matt Renshaw's boundary catching controversy explained
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 ก.ย. 2024
- Mathew Wade's shot was caught brilliantly by Matt Renshaw & Tom Banton at the edge of the boundary but was it a legal catch? Find out the complete analysis.
Like our work? Consider supporting us through Patreon.
/ thecricketdigest
#MathewWade #BigBashLeague#MattRenshaw
Matt Renshaw Catch
Mathew Wade catch BBL
Thanks man for considering my request. Great to see that.
What I really enjoy about this channel is the way you can explain the law in layman's terms. Keep up the good work.
Thank you for your kind appreciation. We will try to keep up with your expectation.
What happens if the ball is in the air and the fielder touches the boundary rope before making contact with the ball and then completes the catch. Btw nice explanation.
After touching the boundary rope if the fielder comes back inside the boundary line before taking the catch then it will be out.
Thanks.
Anyone saw adil rashid catch yesterday ? He touched the fence before touching the ball and as the umpire claims , he lifted his foot by the time he caught it. That is not out
@@im_ranjan17 yes I saw it. I understood the rule incorrectly then. I read through the rules, if the fielder touches the boundary rope before making contact with the ball, it's okay. Fielder shouldn't be touching the rope while taking the catch. So it's out. Now if the fielder is completely outside the boundary rope before touching the ball, that is not allowed. For example, fielder cannot be outside the rope when the batsman hits, and then jump and take the catch and throw it in while he is in air - this is not allowed. That's why you always see fielder trying to stretch and take the catch while being within the ropes.
He is not out. No matter what u do first everything should be done inside boundary. Check bumrah's catch against australia. First he touches boundary when the ball is in the air and this is given as six
Very well explained bro:)👍
i ve got a question. out or not
If a bowler bowls a noball can they still do a runout like india vs pakistan 1989 incident?
Run out is valid on no-ball. So, yes it is out.
Law of Cricket is just opposite to the Law of Football 😂
Le mathews: boundary ke bhar jaakr ball rokna koi mujhse seekhe😂😂
Rule should be: Once you go outside the boundary after fielding the ball while inside, the next time you touch the ball you are either already inside or if airborne, must land inside the boundary.
That's the correct rule.
Exactly. Same opinion here👍 Angelo Mathews save should be given Six
Once you go outside the boundary, it should he signalled a 6!
Nice explanation bro....could you please explain Trevor Chappell Underarm bowling controversy in detail
We will try to cover that incident sometime. Thank you for your suggestion.
Tq bro...
Very clearly explained..🏏❤️😘
I think ,mathews effort to stop the six is still the best ever effort by any fielder since 2009
Can u explain if a fielder before touching the ball touches the rope while the ball was in the air but as soon as he realizes that he touched he comes inside the field and then he catches ..what should be the decision
If the fielder is already touching the rope while the ball is being bowled then he is an illegitimate fielder
He cannot claim the catch
But if he steps on the rope after the batsman plays his shot and realizes it and comes inside the field and takes the catch its completely fine
If we are already outside the boundary and then jump when the ball in the air and throw it inside the boundary, will it count as six?
Ball: I will go over
Renshaw: Gangnam at boundary
Ball: Never mind
So that means if the ball wud touch Matt renshaw with In the boundary then wud go out of the boundary cross the fence and go in the crowd and still Matt renshaw cud jump in the air and push it in boundary and other fielder wud catch it and then still the player is out... THIS WHT THE RULE SAYS.. AS SHOWN.. SO THE RULE IS WRONG AND HAS TO B CORRECTED.... I hope u got what I am saying.. i cud just show and prove it practically all wud understand what I wana say that it's a wrong rule
Well, we are just presenting what the official rule book talks about. MCC portal takes in law questions and suggestions. You can write to them about it if you are really unhappy with the rule.
@@TheCricketDigest .. yes I got u r point tht u guys r just presenting and letting us knw about the law of cricket 😊... Yes will try suggesting them and practically can demonstrate and show tht why the rule is wrong.. thanks for replying.
Hello gud eve sir
Its Chirag Pawar here
Its a scenario from one my match
Batsman hits straight long off fielder started running from outside the boundary to cover max distance
Meanwhile he jumps from outside of the boundary and comes into contact with the ball to save boundary
It makes no sense . What do you mean by covering max distance? He can well be placed right at the boundary.. fielders don't by themselves to stop doubles and can throw the ball back to restrict the batsman to singles
If a fielder has gone outside the boundary line before touching the ball then he has to step inside the boundary line before he can touch the ball. He isn't allowed to jump and make contact with the ball in the air in that case. If he does so then boundary will be awarded.
He is 1st reach with boundary rope and coming inside the boundary caught a ball is out or not out
Nice explanation bro👍
This should be changed. Last contact should be inside boundary before any touch...
Please explain Michale Nesser controversy catch(2022 Big Bash) I’m From Sri lanka 🇱🇰
I have doubt....while running towards a catch near boundary the fielder going out side boundary by mistake and coming in and taking the catch....is that legal??
Yes, it is completely legal.
Thanks a lot
Bro going outside the boundary line and push the ball inside the line .that is out or not
We have explained this in the video. Do watch the complete video.
@@TheCricketDigest I will not understand please tell bro wicket or not
Going outside the boundary and then pushing the ball inside is not allowed. That will be considered six. However if the fielder touches the ball before going outside the boundary line and then contacting the ball in the air is allowed. Just like what Renshaw does in the incident we have explained.
If it is still not clear for you then you can ask your question in any Indian language you are comfortable.
Let's go into the world of IPL through a poem
MI always rocks
RR have great traditional folks
DC have pet frogs
CSK are get set go!
How I wonder where to go
But one thing is sure
LSG have vacant jobs
GT got some pure talent!
KKR have an OP jersey
Oh oh oh have some mercy!!
But wait I have a twist for your guys!!
Mi always rocks
But,
RCB will remain dogs
And, Aakash sir (The commentator) will be the GOAT
AAP party KO Punjab me kariega vote
Thank you!!!
The teams finishing in top four according to me are-
1) Mumbai Indians ( because I am their fan and I know their power, not looking good on paper but can get many in trouble)
2) LSG ( They are looking strong on paper and can perform good, they have Gautam Gambhir as a mentor KL Rahul as a captain Ravi bishnoi is a great spinner too, they have Deepak Hooda and Krunal Pandya and fierce Jason holder now it depends but for me they can make it there.)
3) RR ( Halla bol are looking the best and may be the pre tournament favourites, they had a fantastic auction bowlers are very good Trent Boult, Yuvzi, Ashwin, Parashid Krishna and NCN. They have Jos butter, Sanju Samson and devedut padikal and the interesting factor is that all of these three are in form and scored centuries in the last season they also have James Neesham and Daryl Mitchell and also Rassie Van Der dussen they will make it only worry is management.)
PBKS/(will let you know) after an edit by till then!!!
బ్యాట్స్ మెన్ బాల్ ని కొట్టాడు అది బౌండరీ కి వెళ్తుండగా ఫీల్డర్ బౌండరీ బయకి వేలి బాల్ వచ్చేసరికి లోపలికి వచ్చి బాల్ ని పట్టుకున్నాడు......అది ఫోర్ గా ఇస్తారా ఇవ్వరా..!!!
What about today's incident? It looks like the fielder's shoe touched boundary line before taking the catch and not sure that the shoe was still in contact with the boundary line at the point of time when he first touched the ball.
(Washington sundar caught by adil rasheed , 4th T20 between India vs England, 18th march 2021)
Nicely explained
If person touchs the ball from outside of boundary line and then throw inside the boundary means his first touch is outside the playing field
I dont agree with this catching law at all.., no matter what ICC thinks just for sake of TV eyeballs. The law should be...'any contact with the ball..1st, 2nd or 3rd...should be made only if the last contact of the fielder was withing the playing area(minus the ropes)' Period. If a batsman is given a six, when a catch is taken comfortably inside the field, but the fielder's shoe touches an mm of the rope by oversight, then conversely, any contacts from outside the playing area should not be given out. Any fielder should not be allowed to claim a catch if he jumped from outside the boundary line to inside. Let him come inside the playing area first, and then get in contact with the ball for a catch.
Please explain slow over rates penalties... what is the time allotted per over in different formats...and how penalties are imposed if not satisfied..??!
If the player touching the boundary and jumping for a catch then land in side the boundary?
Should be not out. At 0:24 fielder is clearly over the rope and so is the ball. The boundary is there for a reason, no? What is this nonsense of ball not touching the ground so you can relay it back into the field of play? Wake up MCC and change this ridiculous batsman friendly rule.
Latest rule is that fielder claim catch/saving runs only if his last body touch was in/under boundary line.
in above instance fielder went and touch above boundary line, later he jumped and throws the ball in the boundary (but his last touch to the land/ground was over the boundary line) so his claim should/get be declined.
According to the law as it stands today, if the fielder makes his first contact with the ball inside the boundary then he is subsequently allowed to go outside the boundary line and jump from there to catch it. That is what we have explained in the video and it is a valid catch.
@@TheCricketDigestwhat about Angelo Mathews case. Is it boundary or not?
If player cross the boundary line before touch the ball & return & complete the catch.
In this situation what's the decision?
So going by this cricket rule, if a hook shot going for a 6 into the stands, just brushed a micro mm of a close in fielder, then a boundary line fielder can go to the first tier spectator stand, jump and punch the ball back, so that another fielder inside can 'claim' the catch !! How ridiculous ! ICC needs to change the rule...'last contact of any fielder before touching the ball for the nth time should be from inside the playing area, else its a 6 or a 4 as per the shot !!' Even jumping from outside the boundary line and catching the ball airborne and falling inside should be given a 6.
Nicely Explained ❤️
Please explain slow over rates penalties... what is the time allotted per over in different formats...and how penalties are imposed if not satisfied..??!
I've got a random question.
If a bowler got 2 Consecutive Wickets, Then a wide or no ball then another wicket, would that count as a hatrick?
Yes, it will be considered as a hat-trick
@@TheCricketDigest Also can you make a video on legal and illegal catches
@@TheCricketDigest I have a doubt, if in the IPL 2019 final shardul Thakur was not out by using the drs (given out on field) and had taken the run, would the match be tied? Or will the ball be considered a dead ball or no run??Pls reply..
Good question. Unfortunately, no run would have been awarded and Mumbai would have won the match. The ball is considered dead right after the umpire gives his decision.
@@TheCricketDigest woah that's a loophole
I am not a fan of this.. The catch can't be valid if it's caught back by the same player.. And my reason is simple.. "YOU CAN'T FIELD FROM OUTSIDE"
.
If you toss the ball up and you go over the boundary and the ball is caught by another fielder then that's fine..
.. But if you are the one coming back into the game to complete the catch then that should be illegal (you should never be able to make a 2nd contact with the ball, with you coming from outside the boundary because you can't field from outside)
I saw a situation in the ipl and the officials must have missed it..
The fielder tossed the ball in the air, his momentum took him over the boundary and then he leaped from outside (his last point of contact with the ground was from outside the boundary), into the air, caught the ball.. That should have been 6 runs
What if the fielder touch the boundaries before ball came and comes in take the catch.
Can player touch boundary line and come inside before he take a catch for first time.?
if a fielder first cross the boundry before touch the ball and then came inside the field and take the catch ..its out or not ? plz cmnt .
This channel is underrated I have been bingeing all ur videos. Awesome vids👏👍
I think the laws could be changed here. Simply define a player, when airborne, is inside the ground if his last contact with the ground was inside the boundary, and outside if his last contact with the ground was outside. With that simple rule this catch would be illegal and I think that is the fair result.
One way of thinking, yes. But ICC feels that if the fielder catches inside the boundary then he should be given another chance if he is off balance.
@@TheCricketDigest But to what degree? With my definition it would be quite legal to catch off-balance, throw the ball, step outside the boundary, and return inside the boundary to complete the catch. What I feel is questionable is to handle the ball when the last contact was outside the boundary, and I would disagree with the ICC here. Note that with the current definition, it would be legal to run into the stands, jump up to catch a ball, while in the air throw to a fellow fielder inside the boundary, before landing back down spilling the beers of the spectators, theoretically catching a ball that would otherwise be a huge six, unless I am mistaken.
@@squirrelpatrick3670, @The Cricket Digest
My points are
1. There is no sentence in law 19 in MCC rules book like "First contact and last contact". But you said. How?
Please make video about it.
2. I have idea another idea if fielder is outside the boundary line before and after touching the ball. It should be give six run. Example Angilo mathews and Matt ranshaw catch. First touch or second touch doesn't to play any impact.
Because it will create controversy in future like 2019 world cup final super over draw and boundary count winner.
3. Other than these 2 boundary catches are acceptable, keep the same rule.
@@squirrelpatrick3670 It is not legal to run to the stand because the first touch should be inside the boundary line.
Why haven’t you uploaded any video from a long time? I know that there are no matches going on right now but I think that there are many more things that can be done in this period...
We have uploaded quite a lot of videos recently, kindly watch it.
The Cricket Digest
Sure!
I love your videos,
Very informative.
The Cricket Digest
But I don’t know why but your videos are not coming in my recommend even tough I have subscribed.
A lot of viewers have reported this problem. Kindly turn on the notification so that you won't face this problem again.
IMO the fielder's contact to the ground before touching the ball should always be inside the boundary.
This just doesn't seem right.
This rule is very advantageous for preventing sixes just like mathews. Jump and push ball outside boundary
But it is very difficult and may even injure your fingers
Thanks bro
I don't like this law... Look Mathews case.. how can you jump outside the boundary to save the run...
In my opinion it should be right if the fielder doesn't touch ball and boundary at the same time.
For the same reason while a batsman running b/w the wickets the ball Hits the stump and batsman 's bat is on air although it seems to be crossed the line it will be called out.
If a batsman has crossed the line if the bat still is on air how can be this out?moreover why it is important for a batsman to be grounded at the time when the bail is off although the batsman has already inside the line in stumping?
The Law talks of Condition 1, 2 &3 applying to just ONE SINGLE fielder and not two in tandem. So that catch is invalid and the batsman considered Not Out. (As to whether it is then considered a six or not is a different question).
It was given out.
th-cam.com/video/1uNdFyAG_2c/w-d-xo.html
Please explain in hindi
dekha jae to yaha koi controversy thi hi nahi.. wo out hi mana jaega.
If a player touches the boundary rope for judging the catch & then he come inside 3/4 step & complete the catch then what happen???
Out / six ???
Out.
Now days this happens in every t20 match😂
This specific scenario hardly happens. I have only seen 2 cases till now. Both covered in this video.
@The Cricket Digest I have one doubt when ball in the air fielder unintentionally crosses the boundary line and checks the boundary and he then come back from the boundary and takes the catch while taking the catch only he has first contact with the boundary please answer
After crossing the boundary, if he comes back inside the field and takes the catch, then it is out.
It is OUT.
this law is not right. when you cross the boundary line one time and after that if you touch the ball on anyhow it should be a six or a four. otherwise, someone stands on the boundary line board and then jump and catches the ball will be considered as out.
What if the fielder 1st goes out side the boundary line and he airborne the ball inside the boundary line?
It will be a six.
Bowl or Fowl
Agar boundary k bahar ja kar, ground k andar aa kar catch pakde to ??
Thanks
If a fielder goes outside the boundary line before touching the ball and comes in take catch is out or not out
If the fielder comes entirely inside the boundary before taking the catch then it is out. He can't jump from outside the boundary to take the catch.
Thanks for the information 😊
Can you please share the name of the law book you are referring
Official law book of cricket. MCC law book.
A batsman hit the ball towards boundary line during judging the catch fielder goes outside the boundary line than return back inside the boundary and take catch is player out or not out
I have a doubt when a player going to catch the ball unfortunately he crossed the boundarie rope and he completed the catch inside the rope is it out or six?
I have a doubt.. Pls clarify
When batmen hit a ball towards the boundary and to stop that ball two fielders came quick.. One of the fielder stopped the ball inside the boundary.. But other guy without touching the ball he over stepped the boundary to avoid hitting the fjrst fielder.. Without touching the ball and overstepping the boundary do considered as a no ball????
According to this rule , Harley Deol ka catch to not out hi hoga. Please explain this in a video.
if a fielder goes out boundary before touching the ball and comes inside boundary again and takes the catch after coming inside is it catch or not ???
Well explained, but I think the law is wrong here.
It should be that if in the process of a catch the fielder touches the ground outside the boundary before touching the ball, then it's a six.
If a fielder taken catch in air from outside of the boundary line and jumps into the inside of boundary line. Then what it will be out or 6?
When the fielder touch the boundary and catched the ball inside the boundary then batsman is out or not
Why international cricket coaches wont be of the same country,most of the time....?
I don't understand why he could not complete in first attempt itself.
But with second touching he could have easily jumped inside the rope with the ball.
You have very good knowledge in cricket....why can't u make videos like sports Tak, aakash Chopra, cricbuzz ....iam pretty sure that u will do best...
What about Harleen Deol's catch?
It was almost like this catch.
@@TheCricketDigestso technically both are out right? But in both the catches, fielder's last leg contact was outside the boundary..
Harleen was jumped from outside and took the catch..
Suppose if there is a wall or fence on boundary line just like baseball boundary., Then these catches are impossible to take.. I don't know whether icc corrected this rule or not..
Very nicely explained. All the best 👍
This rules are already involved in international cricket.
Bro...What will happen when a fielder touch the boundary before touching the ball...?
If a fielder has touched the boundary line, he has to step inside the boundary line to make any further contact with the ball. If he doesn't step inside before further contact, boundary will be awarded
Finally video after a long time!!
Btw nice explanation.
If felder catch the ball inside the boundary line and thorows the ball air and go to outside boundary line again same Felder jump into air took the catch what that is six or out?
The roul is last contact of the Felder Foot out side the boundary line? What is that six or out?
This will be out.
Hello...i need one small clarification..
Wt if batsman hit the ball at the same time the fielder he is in outside of the boundary line ...and he comes in and catch the ball .....
Wheather it is out or six???
Out.
If a fielder goes out of boundary before touching the ball, and comes inside boundary again, and takes the catch after coming inside, is it a catch or not?
Yes, it is a fair catch.
If a fielder goes out of boundary before touching the ball, and comes inside boundary again, and takes the catch after coming inside, is it a catch or not?
It is a valid catch.
If the feilder out in the ground and thy thorw ball inside the ground what is givan by umpire 6 or 1 run
6 runs.
What if while two fielders attempting to save a boundary, one fielder was outside boundary line while the other fielder who is inside the boundary line touches the ball and the fielder outside the boundary line pushes the ball to inside while he is on air jumping outside the boundary line, is it a boundary or a save?
*The fielder who thouches the ball first-time is inside the boundary line, and the fielder pushing the ball is jumping from outside the boundary line.
It's a boundary. Every fielder involved in the event needs to make their first contact inside the boundary line to prevent boundary.
if filder first outside and jump from outside and touch ball airbone and comeside then its six or out??
Six.
Plz explain a bowler can bowl both spin and fast in over. Is it allowed.
Yes, it is allowed.
What about the last catch attempt and thrown to inside while airborne? Batsman get how many runs? Is it 6?
It is not a 6. Batsman will get how much ever he runs.
Deemed Legal because of amended rules by ACB
It is legal in all ICC matches.
Sir can a bowler can bowl a one over spin and one over fast .what does cricket laws says. please reply
Yes it is allowed.
Tell me something if a player caught the ball and at the same time caught ball through out side the boundaries . Batsman out or he get six
Your question is not clear. You can ask your question in Hindi if you are comfortable.
when will u upload?????? ):
Good explanation
Fielder agar first touch out off boundary se kare to a kya hoga decision
Six !
It will be a six.
Please share your instagram id, so we can dm you our doubts..!!
You can mail us at thecricketdigest@gmail.com or find us on instagram by the name 'thecricketdigest'
Here is our insta id
instagram.com/thecricketdigest/
How about that Angelo save!!
It wasn't given a six. His stunt saved 3 runs.
But. He was in the air outside the boundary When he touched the ball again. It should be given 6. Law should be amend
I saw the incident live and thought it was a umpiring error or maybe BBL don't abide with all international rules.
But now I am clear with this ✌🏼
Nice video 😘😘😘
what if the batsmen gets out on freehit wideball by stumpout
Stumped is not valid on a free hit delivery. So the batsman won't be given out.
Only run out is valid on free hit.👍
Is Obstructing the field out is valid on free hit??
Yes, Obstructing the field is valid on free hit.
Well explained, but note to mention that if the fielder's person touches any other object person after crossing the boundary he can't even be airborne to throw it out.
No, there is no such restriction.
@@TheCricketDigest Please check below, a fielder is considered to be grounded beyond the boundary in that case.
19.5.1 A fielder is grounded beyond the boundary if some part of his/her person is in contact with any of the following:
- the boundary or any part of an object used to mark the boundary;
- the ground beyond the boundary;
- any object that is in contact with the ground beyond the boundary;
@@viswakirank We are well aware of this. This law explains what exactly can be considered beyond the boundary.
If the fielder has made his first touch with the ball well inside the boundary line then he can go outside the boundary, can touch anything there but when he makes the subsequent contact he has to be either in the air or has to be inside the boundary line.
@@TheCricketDigest No, a fielder can be grounded and then be airborne while pushing the ball onto the ground but if he / she goes beyond the boundary post the first contact within the field and touches an object as per third point then the ball will be considered grounded beyond the boundary.
- any object that is in contact with the ground beyond the boundary
Which law states explicitly about this point?
Touching the boundary line, grounding beyond the boundary line, or touching anyone beyond the boundary is all the same.
So if it is allowed to ground beyond the line, it should be allowed to touch anyone or any object as well. Let us know if you have come across any law that specifically states that 'it is not allowed to touch any object'.
No its not out ..why ? Let me explain you must have to touch ball when you inside field and then jump in air not go outside and then jump in air. If you go outside then you have to touch your feet inside field and then if you jump air and throw ball that should be acceptable but what its happened here not a out.
It will be of great help if you can tell us where this is written in the law book. Looks like you are well educated with it. Kindly help us by showing the direction.
Excellent job! Thank you for the clarification.. one question that stems from this - how long in seconds do you need to hold on to the ball for it to be a catch?
Let’s say he caught it for 5 seconds and then threw the ball in the air while going outside the boundary line?
This video will give you a better perceptive about this topic.
th-cam.com/video/CudP8BIJyoA/w-d-xo.html
There is no time boundation for a catch , fielder hv to maintain balance only after caught the ball.