Was Suryakumar Yadav's catch legal? Rules say.... | Sports Today
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 ต.ค. 2024
- We talk sport 24x7, 365 days a year. Come join us for the latest analysis, exclusive interviews, news, and updates. Part of the AajTak and India Today Group.
For more content follow us on -
Instagram - / sportstodayofficial
Facebook - / sportstodayofficial
Twitter - / sportstodayofc
#suryakumaryadav #t20worldcup2024 #viratkohli #rahuldravid #jaspritbumrah #AxarPatel #hardikpandya #cricket #latestnews #rohitsharma #viratkohli #hardikpandya
There is no cure for jealousy. Our neighbors couldn’t accept India's victory yet.
True😂
Never will
U mean pakistanis😂😂😂
Sri lankans are filled with jelous
@@netaji-thebritishslayer Kanglus hate India much more than Pakistanis
catch is perfect,,,, suryakumar yadav is the man of the worldcup
These guys are so funny. Believing a desert man talking to god, but doubting everything legit.
@@kumarakil8449These delusional barbarians dream of conquering the world, what can you expect from them?
Superb clarification! Also, when the ball falls on the ad rope without touching the ground it is considered six and the white line or any other previously marked line is insignificant in that case. Ad rope is always considered the boundary in ICC T20's. Third umpires with high resolution tv camera replays are not fools to give OUT. Only, dimwits who hate India's success create such controversies.
So rightly said Sir
These guys are so funny. Believing a desert man talking to god, but doubting everything legit.
We have seen so many such catches at the boundary
When those were legitimate then this is 100% legitimate
End of story
Jealous souls cant accept this fact and if it's their country, then they will accept it
1. If the toblerone boundary was few inches before, SKY would have adjusted the catch accordingly
2. 3rd umpire had all the time to rule either way factoring in the rules. once it was adjudged out, no point arguing
India won by cheating and fixing. Why the 2nd over to maharaj when he took 2 wkts in his first over? Why markaram bowled himself? why markaram did not bat well? all because was fixed match
Hey I have checked it every single thing, that line doesn’t make any sense as you can clearly see that white line is slightly faded & not properly aligned.
Next you can clearly see some boundary personnels were sitting there if the boundary was moved then they would have moved it back to their original position.
If you see surya’s catch from top angle you can clearly see the boundary is perfectly aligned.
If you put boundary cushion on white line then it doesn’t make any proper alignment.
Last but not the least if you see the catch in a slow motion you can clearly see surya’s shoes didn’t touch any boundary.
Guys it was a marvellous catch ❤
Well no one talks about the wide balls not given when SA were bowling but wide was given when India was bowling within the line
He was a honest guy before and do all analysis very accurately. India still is winner but be honest when u post videos.India is still champions.
Inzamam: India did boundary tampering 😢
Tell him to p.....off
surya took an exceptional catch and he did it according to rules
Surya took exceptional catch no doubt , But outside boundary
If rules has not to be followed in international cricket than just watch street cricket where there is no rules followed
@@skyshop4428 Sir, Since you are talking about rules, can you confirm, in case, the ball landed on the vague marking on the ground and bounced over the cushioned boundary line, will that be declared 6 or 4. Sir, Even grete soccer player Maradona was accused for hand handling the ball at Goal point, for which Maradona himself declared that may be God's hand guided the ball to the goal. But in Suraya Kumar's catch, it should be construed that Surya's God himself could have gone into surya's body to complete the impossible catch for the Praying Indians all over the world. Above all, the catch was reviewed by the third umpire and declared fair. Further, the world Cup T20I -2024 was very fair and the deserving team lifted the Cup. BELIVE MIRACLES DO HAPPEN AND SURYA CATCH IS SIMPLY A MIRACLE.
Catch is well taken and legitimate.
Rope was distributed by klassen in the first inning while fielding
yes virat's 3rd boundary while diving klassen disturbed the boundary rope
@@agamyakulkarni we were lucky
@@agamyakulkarni but remember boundary personnel were their all the time, our surya took fabulous catch.
@@yashvardhan5323 how do you know that it was the same place
@@Samaksh-yx4xi because of the straight drive of Kohli
Catch of The ERA ❤❤
Recently....Was not in women's cricket, one of the Indian players took a similar catch ?
🧿🧿🧿.........just imagine Surya Kumar's UNISON CONCENTRATION OF MIND....BODY....EYES.....AND OUTSTRECHED HANDS IN AN ETERNAL EFFORT ENSURING A DREAM CATCH.........heartiest congrats from me ( at 81+ ) 🌹 🌻 🕊 🎉
🙏💐🙏
THANK YOU VERY MUCH SIR FOR CLARIFICATION
AND TO SHUT THE HATERS OF INDIA 🇮🇳 AND INDIAN CRICKET TEAM.
Thankyou for clarifying
What stupid logic.. they moved the boundary by few inches for final.. really??
The board was moved early in the game after straight four by Kohli.. 1st over 6th ball..
India won.. these things happen..umpire missed it so India won fairly. Indian fans should not come up with such stupid excuses.
ICC still has the film/video of the catch. So for all doubting people plz go and check and make sure. SKY catch was completely LEGITIMATE and India won the game fair and square . By 7 runs. Welcome to the next tournament and be very well prepared.
See the white line in the video.. and see of other areas also where it was covered by physical rope
आदर करो सत्कार करो सूर्य को नमस्कार करो🙏♥️🇮🇳
this is not the first time such an awesome catch was taken as long as the fielder as inside the rope when the ball is hand it is legal period SKY magic was legal
I was also confused about the boundary line. Guess luck was favoring India this time
Boundary was moved about 1.5 to 2 feet away... Umpires didnt check. Sorry south africa
Boundary was moved by African fielders in 1st over by notrij
South Africa : Sorry Vijay. Be loyal to your country. One catch has not sealed the fate of the match. Team SA still had 5 balls to win that match. The third umpire had seen from a very close quarter. Don't forget...the third umpire was none other than Mr Kettleborough. A man who most of the time gave the wrong decisions against India.
@@mtminds1132 Me being loyal to my country has nothing to do with this, you should stop judging others and stop thinking you represent South Africa. :)
@@VijaySP I know it is your birthright to represent South Africa. So .Good luck. Vijay bhava!!
even If the boundary line wasn't moved, surya would have taken the catch a little bit in front of the line.......haters, World cup is safe in India😂
Thanks for the clarification. It was a legitimate catch and was examined by the third umpire from different angles before pronouncing his official decision. If that catch had changed the life SA team is not our problem. Out of two teams one team must win. SA was unlucky as they were closer to the win but we were lucky. Our win also was genuine. Hence let's stop debating on the unworthy topic. Even 50 over World Cup finals last year in india many were saying the catch of Rohit sharma was grounded by the Australian fielder, that means his wrist was on the ground while catching Rohit Sharma and hence he was not out. But third umpire gave him out. Had he been batting continuously we would have won that final also.
It's very funny that they call it a six only when the ball pitches on the rope or crosses it but doesn't call it a catch when the fielder's foot doesn't touch the rope!
The greatest cricketing catch ever.
I have seen such catches only in American Major League Baseball, even where they occur rarely.
Got to be eternally called “The Catch” in cricket.
whatever the jealous lot is saying, if the third umpire declared the batsman out, he is out. likewise in the last world cup also, in the final match between New zealand and england, the umpire's decision about runout in the last over was questioned. But that time the same people kept their moths shut. At the same time, whatever the decision, it has to be accepted.
Big teams like england and india get benefit of doubt. Australia used to get benefit of doubt too earlier before 2010. Now its india and to some extent england given their world cup win against newzealand.
❤❤❤........such was the involvement ( heart & soul ) And The Will""; To Win Of Team India 🎉🎉🎉
Man of the match Surya Kumar Yadav (SKY)
Excellent Explanation.
Puts all Controversies to Rest.
When SA batted the boundary was the same, so same rules and conditions applied for both teams. Stop crying haters!!
SKY’s catch is legal and Indian victory is real and worthy. India haters may bury themselves.
Is there point discussing this nonsense just to gain few views. No need to raise this point.
Bilkul yeh sale khud hi controversy karna chahte hai😅
when you have no answer you can only say this. India also cheated in odi world cup 2011, this is not first time. Cheating is in your nature. It was a six which was given out by BCCI umpires according to BCCI rules.
@@zk6239Cry Hard 😂
@@lidhinr2178
I think you have cried soooo many times...Especially last year...😂😂😂
so...please enjoy but you can't hide the cheating...😅😊😂
@@mendissri...6200 cryy
Boundary पर तीन बार T 20 w c लिखा है । तो पहले camera angle से left पैर दूसरे print - जो t20 wc लिखा है उसके सामने है जो कि सही है क्यों कि सामने से दिखाया गया है और दूसरे camera angle से Left पैर अगले print जो कि तीसरा print है उसके पास दिखाई दे रहा है जो कि पिछे से side angle की वजह से दिखाई हे रहा है। और जो movement Boundary पर दिखाई दे रही है जो की shoes कि वजह से मिट्टी के खिसकने कि वजह से है - तो यह साफ - साफ OUT है।
HE ACTUALLY TOUCHED THE BOUNDRY COUSHIN WITH HIS FOOT WHILE HOLDING THE BALL, GO SEE IN SLOW MOTION THE BOTTOM OF THE COUSHIN MOVED SLIGHTLY WHEN HE WAS HOLDING THE BALL! ITS A SIX. the umpire missed it and its poor that he lied about it
Boundary pushed a bit back to add more advertisements(ads).
i think my guess is when virat hit 3rd boundarry sa players dived to save that boundary and while doin that the boundary was displaced the groundsmen failed to notice it and surya took the catch on the exact same spot the boundary where it had displaced earlier
Where is the front side angle..... I want india to win... Such a high profile game, where is the front Angle... Then only we can say foot has not kissed the board....
Match dekhna tha sir....they showed the front angle as well...🤣
And he/she claims that .. h/she wants india to win
I am sure that you have some occupation and work to do. Please do that.
This guy has interpretted rule 19.2.2.2. incorrectly....the conjunction "and" implies that line serves as the legitimate boundary. So, its not about being disgruntled at India winning, its about fair play. On another matter, the BCCI-controlled ICC ensured that team India had the best advantage behind the scenes, in terms of logistics of the tournament. Did you ever hear of Indian team being stuck at the airport for 6-10 hours? Did you ever hear of the Indian team travelling 2 hours to their practice sessions? Ask Afganistan, Pakistan, Sri Lanka and South Africa. Not to mention the horrible pitches these teams had to play on. So, yes, accept that India has highly advantaged logistically for this WC, just like in the 2023 50-over WC. So, I think people are not jealous against India winning, but against the umpiring and unfair advantage that India seems to have over other teams (not to mention their per-existing knowledge of playing venues and opponents). Lastly, why schedule matches at 10.30am , during work times, only to appease the Indian population? Results could have been different if matches were played in the evenings.
There was no white line near the boundary , there are videos available that can be watched . Like and dislike could form a nation all by itself !! What the big deal about a photo shopped line on a photo !!
Umpires officiating the match were ICC umpires ( not India umpires) and they asked for third umpire’s decision considering that there is no way on field umpires could see clearly what happened at the boundary line !! 3rd umpire had reviewed from 2 angles and confirmed that catch was legitimate!!
Umpires are from England whose team was beaten by india !!
Why would any ICC umpire help team India , that too in a World Cup finals?? ( as it would be scrutinized 1000 times ?? )
As someone has correctly pointed out there is no cure for jealousy!!
Well, i am very disheartened to say this but the boundary rope was clearly moved, i checked it again , and when Miller hits it in the air, you can see from the above angle that the ropes were clearly moved further. (I am not talking about replays, i am talking about real time from the above angle over Surya's head)
It remained the same for both the sides sirji😂😂😂even during India's batting it was same...so now what's the fuss about just bcoz India won some controversies need to be created just like our neighbours do😅😅
Yeah, while the bowl was traveling to boundary for a six, SKY was busy pushing the boundary, eventually to take such an easy catch. Such an trivial thing people fail to see…
I hope you are not a Pakistani with a fake username
@@Damn-Age that's what bro...people just can't digest the fact that India won..be it our lovely neighbours or some of our own people...🥲
It's stupid to say that boundary is moved..if thats your logic of giving a six then how many places in the ground would have the boundary that is accurate and not moved? Not a single place is accurate and is continuously moved by the fielders. All that is practically possible is to accept the boundary rope or the toblerone to be the boundary line and not the actual line.
Who was talking about the boundary line was moved back or not our aurgument is sky touched his feet to the roof and is absoultely legiment "6" no question about that donot spread your misconception or deliberating manupulating the matter of the fact.
Nope baby. Don't trust the leaked vedio from black African. His feet was milimeter behind. It's the grass which moves. This ground is like MAT of GRASS. If you watch in another angle at high quality zoom, his shoe didnot touched the blue cloth. It's when his shoe slides on the soil the grass uprooted a bit for force and that grass touches the blue rope. Bit frictional force and grass uprooted a bit which touches the rope but his feet. It's milimeter away. Thank you.
Boundary line was moved by African fielders in 1st over
Boundary line is the real confusion. He did not touch the ads.
Stupid comment and no logic What can we expect from a muslim 🤮 Great pakistan team is full of expert cheaters go and count how many times this muslim are warned or ban for cheating
@@JayantaBera-yt8ls hey racist look at the African cricket team majority of them are fairer than you brown indian [ Skin tone par jaogae to chir dange]
I don’t think that the line in question is a “white line” that was marked using a grass marker. It is a line caused by grass turning yellow due to lack of sunlight because earlier the boundary rope/ hoarding was in that position. However it was evident that the rope was not pushed back by Surya. It is also not known when the rope got pushed back. Probably it was in this position since the start. Hence the brown line of dormant grass can’t be used as the boundary line in this case. Also keep in mind that the length of the rope is fixed. If it gets pushed outwards in one place it will compensate by getting pulled inwards in another place. Maybe the ICC should do away with the rope to mark the boundary and instead use a grass marker or whatever they use to mark the batting crease. This will prevent any such controversy in future.
The boundary line does not move throughout the first innings. When Kohli hits a six in the 18th over, the long on boundary does not move even when Dube gets the wicket in the 19.4th over. In the second innings, when Surya blocks the ball, the boundary is seen to have moved. By this it is clear that the boundary line is moving in the second innings but you can't blame the players for this, they are concentrating on the game. This is the umpire's fault and he should have monitored it.
Congrats Sports Today for the correct explanation. I wish this video to go viral throughout the world. Already a fake video portraying ABD's voice on Surya touching the rope is under circulation.
catch was fair but how could u proved it that boundry kusan has not been disturbed and onething for your video can explain from how many angles camera has showed cathing position..just 2 i guess where is the drone shots and front view where the catch have been taken upper camera was blocked by roof of stadium balcony..so rules has been made by india this is not real rules and their is no issue of winning india but according to ICC umpire and third upmire are the reason to south africe lost the game..if boundry has not beed disturbed then where is full view of boundry rope has been kept..only in that place if boundry has been moved it means when the catch was taken surya foot was outline boundry and not crying this ball should be six or deadball not out actually..
I can guarantee if this catch taken buy pakistani player it would be checked from every angle and given six
ICC is not International Cricket Control
ICC is Indian Cricket Control
I thought some of the videos had surfaced which suggests the front portion of the Surya's shoe had touched the boundary cushion.. Now they say it is the line which was changed....bottom line is this...this was a catch declared by the umpire and they declared it by following the rules they follow..so stop the shit
I think this guy is supposed to have one presentation ready every few days. So all he does is watch all other youtube sites and vomit out something he heard somewhere. He was probably listening to ClubPrairieFire last night.
As rule says the object or flagposts are not considered as boundary and the actual boudary is all that white line , and here, Surya Kumar Yadav crossed the white line so it's a six and not catch .All that i said in accordance with the ICC rule as shown .If someones want to deny my words reply me I am a coach in cricket academy.
new rules must be made..once u catch ..u can't step out of boundary...that will stop this controversy
You say that absolutely correct 200 percentage sky catch history of world cricket in all formats of match
Did you mean , that the white line appearing before the object i.e some piece of cardboard like that, is not boundary line for final match? Or other wise.
Thank you for the great review and honest analysis.
Perfectly right Sir.
If that was boundary tampering, then it's for the whole match right
It's the duty of the ICC, ground men and umpire to watch for before the game started
And to end it, the unbeaten Indian team lift the trophy
So there ends the debate
The two teams are not a part of it
You are only looking at the boundary line. What about the foot position. Zoom into the foot position. He actually touch the rope with his foot while holding the ball. Sir please look at all possibilities not only the position of the rope.
The boundary rope at that position was disturbed by a SA fielder in the Indian innings and stayed so till the end of the match. Hence the rope becomes the de facto boundary line and not the white line.
This catch is live looking three comentor person one is ian smit, Ravi shatri and third is SA old player is shan polak.
th-cam.com/video/j5m5aFv6c3w/w-d-xo.html
Clear Evidence the catch is clean.
this line was not for this match, different matches are played in this ground and the boundaries are shifted a bit depending upon the pitch. please do not confuse.
If the catch was illegal, it should have been sorted out then n there. There is a third umpire. Why discuss it after it is all decided n done ?
It's clearly a six .....but only if surya wasn't there😂😅😅
It's stupid to say that boundary is moved..if thats the logic of giving a six then how many places in the ground would have the boundary that is accurate and not moved? Not a single place is accurate and is continuously moved by the fielders. All that is practically possible is to accept the boundary rope or the toblerone to be the boundary line and not the actual line.
Editing hai 😂
Not editing, check replay again from the above angle. I thought it was editing too
Soothu hai 😂😂😂 cry hard 😂😂😂 India are the champions 🎉🎉🎉
@@Optimum707😂 yes bro
Liars and cheaters....worst than the ones they accuse of the same behavior.
Well said, Sir.
Kettleborough's decision was bound to be contentious.
Even considering if he was unaware of this rule, I felt his decision was made rather hastily.
No sir. The was no replay of foot position. I you zoom into his feet position, his foot touched the rope
That was brilliant. Finding fault is jealousy Momin hate brilliance
What does the rule say if the fielder touches the boundary
Forget the white line his foot touched the boundary with ball in hand
Sky tromadus change catch the game indians way
& now miss worrld 2024 is also India. Be more jealous 👍
Boundary rope is the triangle shaped form cushions, which was not disturbed. Secondly, it was a divine catch, for taking the title.
Catch caught caught... it's not caughted
😂😅 Burnol Moments 😅😂
How can you be sure that it wasnt disturbed? Was there a camera on that rope throught the match making sure the boundry was not disturbed?.....you just proved it was a six cause the white line is the orginal boundry and that holds even if the physical boundry is pushed back.
It was disturbed by nortje in the first over while attempting to stop a boundary
@@yashvardhan5323 Then as per rules the original white line is the boundry and he clearly stepped over it.
The rules are clear. The white line is the boundary. Rest of the markers are outside. If Surya stepped over the line, it is a sixer.
Are you mad? That's what the rules said, the boundary rope is the original boundary and not any markings...the white line that appeared is probably from the previous matches as there are 2-3 different pitches used...and the boundaries are altered according to it. Stop these conspiracies
Brilliant clarification of the rules! Let us cut out the peripheral noise
Great answer for all the bafoons out there who think India cheated.
Inzi crying in corner 😅
The GAME CHANGER in the match wasn't that spectacular catch.. it was the LONG BREAK that DISRUPTED South Africa's momentum.
Wonderful explanation.
Bhai nice clear explanation
ICC still has the film/video of the catch. So for all doubting people plz go and check and make sure. SKY catch was completely LEGITIMATE and India won the game fair and square . By 7 runs. Welcome to the next tournament and be very well prepared.
It's not a RULE. It's a Law
You English is too advanced for Zimbabar and Shakib fans(except some true cricket lovers).
Long on not long off Pl correct
His foot touch the tip of the foam advertising rope/ boundary. It should have looked at closer... definitely a six but congratulations to India. They played exceptionally well throughout the tournament. Jai Hind.🇮🇳
Nope his feet did not touch the toblerone. th-cam.com/video/4iiLuQVMs-w/w-d-xo.htmlsi=H65qeHsm3L9GiKMn
Boundary line clearly peeche push ki gayi hai, pure stadium mein dekhlijiye kahi bhi woh white boundary mark nahi dikh rhi, par jab woh boundary push ho jaati hai tabhi dikhti hai aur clearly jab Surya ne catch pakda wahi par boundary thoda peeche push ki gayi hai, yeh agar upar waale Spidey cam se dekha jaata toh six hota woh,
yeahhh broooo. hahahah... bro, cry like a girl sitting in a corner. we are busy celebrating here. sorry no time for drama
Go to south Africa 😂
The third empire verified it precisely with multiple cameras placed at different angles and then conveyed his final decision!
So you mean Surya pushed the boundary before taking the catch???!
It's not out touch the boundary line
World cup winner south Africa
Not true
He didn't touch line
Editing hai bhai woh😅line
cry harder
In your rule book so keep your rule book within yourself
The parties inimical and intolerant of an Indian win can't be convinced by any argument legal or otherwise; So let them be. The umpires can't be so fraudulently partial in full public glare. These people are insulting these hard working gentlemen.
It is a Six, not Out
Faltu baat
Being a modi hater is really tough..
You mourn when the entire nation celebrates together....!!!!
Finally you guys fixed your audio. Watching this channel after long time. Good audio quality.
This is not the moment, match was over when Klassen nicked behind!!!!
it was six
There is no question of the boundary line. Point is why a much clearer and close replays were not shown? You have such repeated replays on boundary/six or a ground catch, but why there is no much clearer version of the catch when the match was at such crucial stage? This would be dispelling the doubts of the bouncers.
Thanks a lot, this was very comforting. You guys give the proper analysis after all the research and reasoning. Kudis and appreciate your good work.
Brilliant catch well played India 🇮🇳