Yes, 50% at least. The people don't legalized laws, sign treaties, nor responsible for national defense. And yes, communism can be better than fake/impotent Democracies.
😂 communist party are trying hard to hide the true economy growth. Right now Vietnam real estate are messed up so many abandon building. The local market are struggling due to online shopping (Chinese products)
Correct, our government make the right decision. I don't underestimate our government. But, the US and China is also very significant factors. Maybe you don't know, ASEAN was established to anti-Vietnam and communism expansion. Thailand, Philippines, Singapore, South Korea have let US to use its airports and bombed Vietnamese territory, sent troops to kill Vietnamese at that time. Also, US, China, ASEAN have blamed Vietnam for destroying Khmer Rouge after Cambodian genocide invaded Southwest border region and Phu Quoc islands. China took advantage to invade our territory in Paracel islands (1974), Sino Vietnam war, (1979-1991) , Spartly Islands (1988). An independent, united, communist-led Vietnam is thorn for China and US. In 1991, Soviet Union collapsed and China became biggest threat of the US. In 1994, the U.S. lifted its 30-year trade embargo on Vietnam. It leads to the skyrocketing trend in FDI, export, trade and continuous economic growth from that time until now. In conclusion, Vietnam only have 30 years to develop and sprint with our Asian neighbors. Hope with the bamboo policy, we will be high-income country in 2045.
"limit civil liberties'? My country is one of the most democratic country in the world. Democracy means we can freely have fun, enjoy peace, enjoy happiness, dont have to bother protest and riot. We Vietnam is not similar to the countries which self-identify "democracy' but bring thousands tons of bombs to others!
@@nhatlongphanle6636 Nhà nước của Nhân dân, do Nhân dân, vì Nhân dân ở Việt Nam được thể hiện qua: - Nguyên tắc “tập trung dân chủ” - Phương châm “Dân biết, dân bàn, dân làm, dân kiểm tra, dân giám sát, dân thụ hưởng” Dân chủ ở Việt Nam không được thể hiện qua: số lượng đảng, biểu tình, tự do vô chính phủ, đa số thông qua nhưng thiểu số không làm, toàn dân có quyền thảo luận nhưng lợi ích lại không về tay nhân dân…
Westerners "vote" every 4 years and nothing changes for the good of the people. Always turmoil and chaos, but they think they have the most free country 😂😏
Việt nam cực tự đó về nhiều mặt rất dễ sống tuy nhiên 1 bộ phận quan chức rất quan liêu hách dịch nhũng nhiễu....hi vọng thời gian tới chấm dứt điều đó
@劉兆崴-h7c why are chins so jelous of vietnam? And yes I would move if i could. Only problem i wouldn't be able to stay longer than a permit visa. But one thing for sure i sure as hell would never live in china. I went there once, the place is like a bigger version of north korea people are depressed asf.
Tôi có tìm hiểu qua về "tự do" tại phương tây thông qua những người bạn việt nam sang các nước phương tây định cư. Nói chung, sự khác biệt lớn nhất giữa tự do của việt nam và phương tây như sau: - tại việt nam, người dân là chủ đất nước và chính quyền do dân bầu lên để lãnh đạo đất nước và phục vụ lợi ích của người dân, người dân có quyền làm bất kỳ điều gì trong đất nước miễn nó không vi phạm pháp luật và các nguyên tắc cộng đồng. - còn tại phương tây, các luật lệ dành cho cá nhân hà khắc hơn, tự do ở đây bị kiểm soát bởi các luật lệ nghiêm khắc, người dân phải sống trong khuôn mẫu và sự tự do thiên về cá nhân đến mức cực đoan
The Communist Party of Vietnam is leading the country very wisely. Controlling important areas is not for negative purposes, but to maintain strategic stability in these areas. The Vietnamese people have great confidence in the leadership of the Party, and hate to hear opinions that having many parties is better for Vietnam. Because the Communist Party of Vietnam is a large organization, with high democracy in decision-making, always putting the interests of the people first. Important decisions are made with the opinions of the people or the National Assembly. Meanwhile, many "Democratic" countries, as mentioned in the video, but at one point in time, there is only one dominant party in leadership, sometimes an individual president also decides everything. Therefore, I completely disagree with the exaggeration of one-party leadership as analyzed in the video. Please respect the political institutions of different countries!
Đúng rồi bạn những người biết tiếng Anh như bạn cần phải nói rõ cho cái bọn móc máy nước mình này hiểu được lòng dân Việt Nam mình như thế nào để chúng vỡ mộng làm cách mạng ở Việt Nam đi
Bọn chúng muốn chia rẽ dân tộc ra thành nhiều đảng phải để chúng dễ dàng tiếp tay và can thiệp vào đất nước. Bọn chúng muốn nhằm vào các ngành như an ninh lương thực, an ninh năng lượng... chúng quên đi sự tôn trọng, không dám hiểu rằng chế độ nào không quan trọng, vấn đề là nó vó phù hợp hay không.chúng quên đây là 1 dân tộc tồn tại hơn 4000 năm. Chúng luôn là kẻ tiêu chuẩn kép và độc tài , khi sẵn sàng công kích bằng truyền thông báo chí, thậm chí cấm vận bất kỳ chế độ nào không thân chúng. Những kẻ đế quốc đi cướp khắp thế giới hàng thế kỷ giờ đây tẩy trắng thành những người hùng thế giới, thật buồn nôn.
Tôi thấy mấy vấn đề lớn lớn mà Đại biểu quốc hội hoặc các bộ đề xuất mà dân phản đối nhiều là chính phủ dẹp luôn không thông qua. Tính ra lãnh đạo nước mình cũng sợ dân lắm 😂
Of course, Vietnamese government rightfully decided to Đổi Mới (Renovation) policy at the right time. But, the US and China is also very significant factors. Maybe you don't know, ASEAN was established to anti-Vietnam and communism expansion. Thailand, Philippines, Singapore, South Korea have let US to use its airports and bombed Vietnamese territory, sent troops to kill Vietnamese at that time. Also, US, China, ASEAN have blamed Vietnam for destroying Khmer Rouge after Cambodian genocide invaded Southwest border region and Phu Quoc islands. China took advantage to invade our territory in Paracel islands (1974), Sino Vietnam war, (1979-1991) , Spartly Islands (1988). An independent, united, communist-led Vietnam is thorn for China and US. In 1991, Soviet Union collapsed and China became biggest threat of the US. In 1994, the U.S. lifted its 30-year trade embargo on Vietnam. It leads to the skyrocketing trend in FDI, export, trade and continuous economic growth from that time until now. In conclusion, Vietnam only have 30 to develop and sprint with our Asian neighbors. Hope with the bamboo policy, we will be high-income country in 2045.
The words democracy and dictatorship to us Vietnamese people are not worth a penny. Because those words are directly proportional to the friendliness of your country with America.
I once watched a movie by Stephen Chow about the Qing Dynasty emperor Kangxi of China. He said something that I really liked: "Anyone can be king, as long as the king is good." As an ordinary citizen, what I need is stability, peace, economic development and the freedom to enjoy life.
Look at the election now in US. No, thank you - we don't want that. No party focuses on the citizen and the country, they only focus on how to make the other party looks bad. How much money and time have been wasted on these ridiculous elections? And how many parties do you really have? Two? One advantage of a stable political system is we can think long-term and work on long-term plans. Politics is always politics, everyone is making sure they have and maintain the power. If you can make the majority of people happy, maintain social security, keep growing the economy... you have the power. That happens everywhere no matter systems you are following. Communist is just a name of a political ideal, we should treat it that way. Any country can follow any ideals that work for them. The media always portraits Communist is evil, how is is not a propaganda? I have travelled to many countries, I don't see people in so call "rich and democracy" countries are any happier - I only saw more stress, anxiety, disconnection, un-balanced life... that's why I have declined many offers to move to other developed countries to stay in VN and take on opportunities that I have here. I think we're doing fine. Leave us be and move on with your life.
As a Vietnamese, I am incredibly grateful that the Communist party is leading the nation. Given the current situation of the world right now: War, destruction, and death at every corner of the globe, Vietnam still managed to balance its relationship with major superpowers and bring peace to its people. I don't have to worry about when a draft officer will come and drag me to the battlefield, my family and all the ones I love are protected and well-fed, I can watch the sunrise instead of looking out for bombers, and I can enjoy a cup of coffee without being mag-dumped by a soldier. It's a blessing, for real. Sure, there are a lot of problems, but at least in Vietnam, I went from being empty-handed to being able to support a family. The Party gave prosperity and happiness to its citizens, just as they promised when they called on all Vietnamese people to rise and earn freedom. We paid blood for a bright future and a bright future we received. I would gladly live and work under the Communist leadership, as long as my friends and family members are safe and sound. Cheers!
I believe the more we Vietnamese look outside, the more we love our country. Any party or government have it pros and cons, but Vietnam suit the Communist more
1) If your communist party is so wonderful as your propaganda suggests, then why is your communist party so scared of contesting a general election with other political parties? 2) Why are other political parties not allowed to be formed in communist Vitnam?
call it authoritarian as you will, the main point is that the system, though has its flaws, worked beautifully and the majority of the vietnamese people including me have better lives now thanks to the state and the party.
the thing is that it didn't have to take so long to get here, it was the wrong system to adopt, it's already been shown from VNCH's economy and state prior to reunification that it earned its "pearl of the orient" title from how well things were going, it literally would've been alongside the top economies in the world with the American aide and cooperation that VNCH had, alongside the other countries America partnered with. What countries? South Korea, Taiwan, Japan, GERMANY. but the country reunified under communist rule and then experienced the absolute worst two decades after reunification thanks to rule under shit head Le Duan. There was a reason Do Moi had to happen, because things just were not working AT ALL. there's a good reason even Russia and all former soviet states abandoned Communism. What good did taking Soviet/Russian influence do? turned china into a dystopia, froze cuba in the 1950's, absolutely demolished former East Germany to where the effects are seen in how much worse eastern germany is today.....and of course helped North Korea become as weird and as poverty struck as it is today. Vietnam took the wrong route sadly. Thanks to the fall of the Soviet Union, it helped all soviet aligned countries switch to a capitalist based system. The collapse Forced North Korea to undergo famine, and China/Vietnam to change to a capitalist based market, something South Vietnam had already proved working decades earlier. So now, many decades later, the system is somewhat helping Vietnam, but think about how much better, stronger, and quicker Vietnam would've achieved this if only reunification occured under the South. And guess what? it's not gonna improve all that much continued under this stradegy, there is a ceiling to all this, and it's already proven how non-existant the middle class has already become, with only either super rich or super poor for it's people!
All the success or progress in Vietnam is described by the western media as thanks to capitalism, while all the bad things such as drugs, human trafficking, bribery, corruption, gangs, shootings are due to communism. 🤣😂
Under the control of communist party, our life has been improving so much. In the 2000s, my family even didn't have enough money to buy a sofa, we had to borrow our neighbor. Now we still borrow money, but to buy land
1) How much money did you receive from the corrupt and thieving communist party to tell lies on the internet? 2) If the communist party is so wonderful and beneficial to so many poor Vietnamese people, they why is your corrupt, thieving, and very stupid communist party so afraid of competing against other political parties?
limit civil liberties ??? Ask Singapore my friend, ask Singapore, where a same party runs that country continuously 60 yrs since it became independence.
The Vietnamese government plays a decisive role in the success of the Vietnamese economy. However, some Vietnamese people in America, writers and artists in Vietnam believe that the Vietnamese government is weak.
Bạn nói đúng, các thành phần chống đối không từ những người lao động, những người kinh doanh mà luôn là giới văn nghệ sĩ, tâm hồn ở trên mây (không kỳ thị tổng thống Ura, hehe!).
Look at the conference that Vietnamese PM dedicates to private businessmen, Vietnamese government now put much more importance to the private sector. You can't say this is a communist way of governing the country any more.
Fun fact: Because of democratic free will, there are some religions like "Church of Scientology" control a lot of political view, or like South Korea when free will made a religion that can vote and control the president of a Nation. In Vietnam, there a monk name "Thích Nhất Hạnh" wanted to made a religion that not being control by anyone including the State, Party and made suggestion that wanted to change the name of the country to "Vietnam or Republic of Vietnam" and change the Party name to something other than the _Communist Party of Vietnam_ (Làng mai 31). Can you imagine suggesting that when he DIDN'T DO ANYTHING to help liberate the country from the France, the Japan or the American. If they threaten the people of Vietnam, the nation, it is your duty, everyone duty to protect Vietnam with everything you have *"CHÚNG TA THÀ HY SINH TẤT CẢ, CHỨ NHẤT QUYẾT KHÔNG CHỊU LÀM NÔ LỆ"* - Hồ Chí Minh.
You can see that in East Asian cultural countries, a moderate degree of dictatorship is needed for development. South Korea developed under the dictatorship of Park Chung Hee, Japan under Meiji and Douglas Arthur, the Chinese Communist Party is more oppressive than the Vietnamese Communist Party. Only the dictatorship of the Kim family in South Korea is condemnable. Both single-party and multi-party have their strengths and weaknesses, so you should not judge one-sidedly in a binary way, only good and bad, good and bad depends on the talent and morality of the manager.
Economic power and political power will always be on the hand of the elite class no matter what the kind of goverment is. In Vietnam, the Communist Party dominated the elite class and control both economic power and political power. In the US, the US billionaires class that dominate both Republican Party and Democrat Party. No difference.
I think there is a difference. The party in America will be for the benefit of the tycoons. But if the communist party is for the benefit of the tycoons, it cannot be a communist party anymore. Will it be no different from America? If it is no different, then why does America always want to overthrow Vietnamese communism? In a communist country, the interests of the tycoons and the people will be balanced, because the communists know that the people are a very great force.
Have you ever looked beyond Hanoi and HCM? Whatever is developed only serves the “elite” of the nation, the rest is being left behind heavily and nothing much is being done to lift these people up, you support something like this?
Did your communist leaders not say in 1975 that communist Vitnam will be richer than Japan in 20 years? Did your communist leaders not say in 1975 that communism will defeat American capitalism?
@@MichaelCollinge-r7dWhat's your point? This isn't necessarily about competition, we're just happy that Vietnam is flourishing after everything it has been through in the 20th century. Vietnam and China doesn't even practice OG communism all that much anymore, their market is more capitalist orientated now.
the thing is that it didn't have to take so long to get here, it was the wrong system to adopt, it's already been shown from VNCH's economy and state prior to reunification that it earned its "pearl of the orient" title from how well things were going, it literally would've been alongside the top economies in the world with the American aide and cooperation that VNCH had, alongside the other countries America partnered with. What countries? South Korea, Taiwan, Japan, GERMANY. but the country reunified under communist rule and then experienced the absolute worst two decades after reunification thanks to rule under shit head Le Duan. There was a reason Do Moi had to happen, because things just were not working AT ALL. there's a good reason even Russia and all former soviet states abandoned Communism. What good did taking Soviet/Russian influence do? turned china into a dystopia, froze cuba in the 1950's, absolutely demolished former East Germany to where the effects are seen in how much worse eastern germany is today.....and of course helped North Korea become as weird and as poverty struck as it is today. Vietnam took the wrong route sadly. Thanks to the fall of the Soviet Union, it helped all soviet aligned countries switch to a capitalist based system. The collapse Forced North Korea to undergo famine, and China/Vietnam to change to a capitalist based market, something South Vietnam had already proved working decades earlier. So now, many decades later, the system is somewhat helping Vietnam, but think about how much better, stronger, and quicker Vietnam would've achieved this if only reunification occured under the South. And guess what? it's not gonna improve all that much continued under this stradegy, there is a ceiling to all this, and it's already proven how non-existant the middle class has already become, with only either super rich or super poor for it's people!
@@Dominicn123 Perhaps you're right, but there's no point in saying things like "it would've been better if...etc...etc." since we can't change history. History already happened and the only way forward is to learn from the past and improve (which is what everyone's already doing by implementing reforms and strengthening diplomatic ties). I see no point in thinking about alternative scenarios in history since it doesn't really change whats the reality today. I'm sure most of the government understands that economic reforms were the right decision and hopefully they will continue improving. I hope things work out in the future and hope that we don't make the same mistakes again.
That could be very good, but if the ASEAN tiger is growing together to become top 20 in the world (Thailand, Malaysia, Philippines, Viet Nam, Singapore) with not much different like today, being in top5 is a good position for Vietnam. P.s Indonesia will become top 10 of the world.
Already is . Real GDP of Vietnam must be over 600 billion dollar at least. Because no other countries has its GDP much lower than its total export + import combines, which in the case of Vietnam more than 600 billion already. The Vietnamese goverment deliberately lower its official GDP to have more favourable loans 😂
We have 2 dots in East Sea representing our 2 archipelagos Hoàng Sa and Trường Sa, despite China’s claim on Google maps. We have sound evidence of Chinese dynasties admitting that they belong to Vietnam 🇻🇳
Now, you can see a world that has so many problems, war, unfair society. Having so many not good around your life. When you come in Vietnam, you can see a peaceful life, no war, no use gun. Everyday, we can earn money, make everything to take care of the life, family, friends... You can invest in Vietnam, mustn't worry for anything of your business. Everything is also ok and safe for you! At the present, Vietnam is looked as the star of South East Asia this year.
Đừng nói vậy. Kênh này ở Phi-lip-pin, bọn họ đã bị Mỹ đế tẩy não cả hằng trăm năm nay rồi. Nên não của họ không có suy nghĩ nào ngoài suy nghĩ rằng: đảng cộng sản thì xấu, 1 đảng thì không có “dân chủ”, “nhân quyền”. Bạn có tranh cãi với ếch đáy giếng thì chỉ mệt mình thôi. Mà cứ cho như vậy đi, nhà mình ít dân chủ, nhân quyền nhưng mà lắm gạo, nên nước nhiều dân chủ nhân quyền như bọn họ phải sang nhờ mình bán gạo cho lại còn nhờ đảm bảo an ninh lương thực cho họ nữa chứ.
Dân chủ? 😂😂😂 Chẳng phải "dân chủ" đã đến Việt Nam năm 64 và rút khỏi Việt Nam năm 73 rồi hay sao 😂😂😂😂😂😂. Các bạn bảo chúng tôi không có quyền tự do ngôn luận ? Đó là bởi vì suy nghĩ của bạn quá hạn hẹp. Tới Việt Nam và cảm nhận thế nào mới là tự do, dân chủ 😊😊😊
2 or more leading political parties is not certainly democratic than one. Because the key issue is on ability, moral values, virtue of political members, willingness to serve their country/citizens that a political party should have had. It's ridiculous that some parties in some countries are corruption and enjoy their own expediency.
There are a lot of smaller factions in VCP , like mini party. And every decision required voting from a group of 200 elite party members so actually it is more " demoracy" than most Westerner think. The leader of the party, the Prime Minister and the President of the State were elected to execute the vision of the Party, not to execute their OWN vision. So a Trump personality actually may have a pretty hard time leading the party in Vietnam ironically 😂😂😂
Việt Nam không độc tài nhé tác giả. Quyền con người ở Việt Nam luôn được đảm bảo. Quyền bình đẳng giới ở Việt Nam thuộc top đầu thế giới. Người dân Việt Nam sống hạnh phúc và hài lòng với cuộc sống của mình. Toàn dân luôn ủng hộ chính quyền nhà nước, đó mới là điều quan trọng, hầu như không có sự chia rẽ trong đất nước chúng tôi
What is Dictatorship? What is Democracy? Why is dictatorship necessarily bad? Democracy must be good? Is it really a dictatorship? Is it really democracy? What is the best system? Is it dictatorship or democracy? Why are you so sure that your answer must be right, did God tell you? Give me your answer
Vietnam implemented market economic reforms in the mid-80s along with the Soviet Union in the Gorbachev era but Vietnam succeeded and the Soviet Union failed in reforms.
NO.discussion on Vietnam's economy is accurate or complete without the imoact.of the comprehensive sanctions imposed on Vietnam after defeating the US and its 100 years of.war.
Tự do - Dân chủ của Việt Nam là lẽ tự nhiên như nước, không khí mà chúng tôi hít thở hàng ngày. Nên người Việt Nam không cần bận tâm hay đưa ra mức đánh giá như người Mỹ và Châu Âu.
First of all, Đ in Vietnamse is equal to D in English. There is no Z sound in "Đổi". Secondly, "moi" is "me" in French. The word "mới" in Vietnamese has nothing to do with "moi" in French. No Vietnamese can understand Zoi moi's meaning. 😁
How many more centuries do Vietnamese people have to wait for the coming of the propagandistic mirage of communit Vitnam's advancement? Did your stupid communit leaders not say in 1975 that communism will defeat American capitalism?
Viet nam đang theo mô hình của Singapo...độc tài về chánh trị + tự do hóa kinh tế tối đa...và vẫn kiểm soát chi phối CP một số Tập đoàn Nhà nước có ảnh hưởng đến an ninh chánh trị đời sống của người dân
@ĐạiĐếPutin-q6k Please stop this f*cking Russian whataboutism. If you really want to debate against his arguments of freedom of speech and election you should provide your counter-arguments for the similar topic. Don't use whataboutism to switch to another topic by running away from the main point.
There is a fact that the Communist Party of Vietnam was founded in the spirit of patriotism during the anti-colonial era of Vietnam's invasion. Patriotism will always be a thing of high importance in Vietnam. Another interesting thing is that when you are in Vietnam you will hear about the leader of Ho Chi Minh and the formation of the Communist Party of Vietnam, which was integrated by the leader of Ho Chi Minh City from other parties. We always believed that as a group we would overcome everything. Through many political reforms and upheavals, it is considered one of the most powerful parties in which it is difficult to have a political party replace it. Although there are conflicting opinions that it is authoritarian and does not raise the democratic spirit of Vietnamese people, it must be true to you that Vietnamese people do not complain about the democracy of the Vietnamese Communist Party. General Secretary Nguyen Phu Trong who just passed away said that a party is not undemocratic because democracy is expressed in many aspects. We hope that we will not only become rich but also happy in the future
Thanks to VN Communist Party, our lives have improved a lot and we live more prosperous. My family used to be poor according to VN criterion. The gov encouraged us to study, local gov and school rewarded us with many items and money when we achieved academic results, gave us loans or "student loans" with low interest rates. Thanks to that, I and 2 my sister was able to go to university and thus, helped me broaden my worldview. I just laugh 😂when information spread from Western countries is not called 'propaganda'. But when it comes from Communist countries, it is "definitely" called 'propaganda'. How ridiculous! The West countries always claim *fair, civilized, objective*. So where is the word "FAIR" in this case? Oh, you hypocrites who sow war?! Always use the words "unfree, undemocratic, dictatorial..." to judge others based on your criteria. Where you talk about "unlimited, diverse" but "force others to live within your limits"
Big investors, like Nike, don't care about communism government. But what they want is a "stable" political system to guarantee the long term safety of their investments.
Đã tìm hiểu để làm nội dung về Việt Nam vậy tại sao không tìm hiểu xem từ "Đổi mới" đọc như thế nào??? Why don't look up on Google how to pronounce "Đổi mới" when you already did research about Vietnam??? I'm Vietnamese and I don't even understand what you said.
Nếu như nhà nước vẫn giữ được trạng thái ổn định như hiện tại, quyết liệt và tiếp thu những cái mới với sự cởi mở và tích cực. Tôi tin sẽ có ngày nền kinh tế Việt Nam sánh ngang với Nhật Bản.
VN mở cửa kinh tế thị trường nhưng 5 cái an ninh chủ chốt vẫn phải kiểm soát. 1 . An ninh lương thực. 2 . An ninh văn hóa. 3 . An ninh năng lượng. 4 . An ninh tài chính. 5 . An ninh quốc phòng chính trị xã hội. VN độc lập tự chủ không chọn phe. Trung lập. Không như nhật Bản. Hàn Quốc. Đài Loan. Philippines........... Được Mỹ bảo kê nhưng Philippines vẫn bị mất đảo vào tay TQ như bãi cạn Scarborough 2016. VN chơi với tất cả các nước trên thế giới 194/195 nước. VN chơi với mỹ. Với Nga. Với TQ không sợ mất lòng ai. Ở biển Đông nếu không có VN thì TQ đã đã hốt trọn biển Đông rồi. Căn cứ quân sự của Mỹ ở Philippines không ảnh hưởng đến việc TQ bành trướng ở biển Đông . Mỹ tạo vùng xung đột để kiếm tiền từ các nước như. Nhật Bản. Hàn Quốc. Đài Loan. Philippines........ hàng năm phải nộp phí bảo kê cho mỹ và phải bỏ ngân sách ra để mua vũ khí của Mỹ. Hàng hóa của Mỹ chỉ có vũ khí khí tài. Giá bán thì trên trời. Nên nhớ đồng minh của Mỹ chính là các nước đối lập với mỹ như TQ. Nga. Triều Tiên. Iran. ....... Không có các nước này mỹ bán vũ khí khí tài cho ai. Tại sao các nước giàu có phương Tây như Đức. Balan. ...... Nhật Bản. Hàn Quốc. Đài Loan lại không sản xuất vũ khí khí tài để sử dụng mà phải nhập của Mỹ. Vì mỹ không cho phép 😂😂😂. Các nước đó ho he là mỹ bụp liền. Việt Nam Hùng Cường. Việt Nam độc lập. Việt Nam muôn năm. Chủ tịch Hồ Chí Minh vĩ đại sống mãi trong sự nghiệp của chúng ta. ❤❤❤❤❤.
Vietnam's biggest problem is that there is no basic industry to support the country. Very high dependence on foreign companies. It would be nice if foreign companies continued to invest. Currently, foreign companies are leaving Vietnam due to rising wages in Vietnam. In addition, Vietnamese young people study a lot with a high passion for education, but there are few companies that are as good as the investment they make in education. Their GDP will reach 4,000-5,000 dollars, but with the current growth rate of 5%, it is not known when it will reach it. 10 or 20 years? Before then, the US-led paradigm will come, and we cannot be sure of their success.
That's where you're wrong. Vietnam have already built it's own basic industry since reformation. We alrwady have plans for the future, especially technology.
You forgot the growing domestic companies of Vietnam and the rise of A.I. and digital economy. It's understand thqt a foreigner like you don't even know them, thús i shall give you information. Vietnam will rise!
Vietnam currently growth rate os still 7%, not 5%. Vietnam already have world-class education system, and now we are developing high-tech industry to prepare for the prosperity in the near future.
@@angKhoaNguyen-ko3nj You don't need a world-class education, it's enough for everyone in Vietnam to be interested in innovation and have an entrepreneurial culture so that this will create a new industry founded by locals
I did not know that Behind Asia is so Behind. Empty phrases and no analytics or reflections. Must be a work of a C student testing GPT. It is only business, not personal, as they said.
Bạn chỉ nhìn vào một vấn đề xấu của Mỹ. Bất an như Mỹ mà hiện tại có hơn 20 triệu nhập cư bất hợp pháp. Một phỏng vấn ở Nga khi hỏi nước nào người dân Nga muốn di dân đến nếu được phép thì theo thứ tự như sau: 1. Mỹ 2. Đức 3. Úc và Canada Cho phép tôi nói một mặt tốt của Mỹ mà 100 năm thậm chí 200 năm nữa Việt Nam đang ước mơ hiện tại và tương lai cũng không làm được đó là trong 10 đại học danh tiếng nhất thế giới thì Mỹ đã chiếm hơn phân nửa. Nói đơn giản vậy thôi chứ không dám nói đến VN ngày nào đó chế tạo được tàu vũ trụ hay thực tiễn và cấp bách hơn nhất là VN tự chủ chế tạo được tàu ngầm, phi cơ chiến đấu, các khu trục hạm thiết giáp hạm đối đầu với TQ đây.
@thumtlnguyen3626 nước nó có công nghệ thì nước mình có kinh tế đi, có tiền thì thiếu gì đồ chơi, ko mua của mỹ đc thì mua của nước khác thân mình, hồi đó nước mình còn nghèo ko có học vũ khi thì thiếu thốn đủ thứ, nước khác viện chợ, còn đánh bậc cả mỹ, nhật, pháp,trung,,,, giờ Nước mình cũng hơi khắm khá rồi cũng mua rất nhiều vũ khí hiện đại r,,,anh đừng có lo sợ với trung quốc quá, mấy thằng Mỹ ko có tốt đẹp gì đâu nó giàu dân nó vô gia cư nhóc, nó có trường đại học danh tiếng nhiều đi chăng nữa nó đi thi cũng thua việc nam thôi, nước nó chiên đâm thọc nước khác toàn đi đánh lộn rồi nó ngồi đó hưởng lợi,
@@thumtlnguyen3626chính vì hơn 20 triệu ng nhập cư bất hợp pháp mới bất an đấy😂 1 đất nước mà cảnh sát thay vì kiểm soát dân nhập cư thì lại đè đầu người da đen😂
@@thumtlnguyen3626 Vậy phải hỏi nước Mỹ có bao nhiêu năm để phát triển rồi? Giáo dục ư? Hãy hỏi đại học Bắc Kinh, đại học Thanh Hoa của Trung Quốc. Họ vượt qua hầu hết các đại học ở Châu Âu, và đang bám sát mấy đại học của nước Mỹ đó. Trong cái vũ trụ này chẳng có cái gì là mãi mãi cả, đợi xem.
@@Hatbuinho79 Tôi đang nói VN anh bạn đem TQ ra so sánh làm gì? TQ và VN khác nhau một trời một vực. Một ví dụ nhỏ TQ đạt bao nhiêu huy chương Olympic còn VN thì sao? Các lãnh vực khoa học khác từ không gian, đến công nghiệp quốc phòng...VN sao có cửa với TQ.
u know india, bangladesh and pakistan ? they have multi parties politism but u know how poverty they are ? i think perhaps u have watch some video about these countries, and yes, it's exactly like in the video, worse then vietnam pretty much, vietnam rural area now are the same with thailand.
you are looking at the lowest of the low. Thats not a great example of "every day people". There is a province call Quang Ninh which "everyday people" are too rich to the point they refused to accept help so the fund could be given to other provinces.
I respect your criticism of the government but your example of the recent hurricane doesn't hold much weight since it was a good effort from the government to mitigate and recover from damage. All I see and hear from friends from many provinces is that their lives and businesses were back in two days. Hold your weight of words when it counts and criticize the government when they actually made a bad decision not when they made a good effort, be objective.
Is that why more and more foreigners try to move to Vietnam every year I wonder? Also also the government's response against the hurricane was highly celebrated by the people, so... maybe pick a better example?
BBC is not a good source when it comes to mentioning foreign countries in Asia. They always have a distorted view without critical thinking and thorough research. Vietnam is much different from the Western, an Asian country rose from war. War with artillery may end in 1975 but the ongoing cold war, sanctions, media accusations continues until at least 2015 when the globe starts changing their view on Vietnam (which Vietnam always have been). It's unofficial war, but the damage done is real. Calling Vietnam lacks of civil rights or tight political control is not quite true when we do a comparative analysis. In fact, Vietnam laws have less constraints than EU and US law. Maybe we are a new country still figuring out, maybe we are less controlled. Who knows. When I was young, i believed those articles were titled. But as I grew, many of them are untrue
There were many parties that led Vietnam in the past. You voted with paper ballots and we voted with guns and bullets. The election lasted from 1945 to 1975. The freedom you talk about is 5 million Vietnamese people and 58 thousand American soldiers and several tens of thousands of French soldiers.
Vietnam has democracy and freedom, but it followed its laws. Vietnam didn’t have same democratic structure politic like many Western countries because it is communist state and can’t apply the same structure like that, instead of using the same structure with both positive and negative things why does they use another way that can bring democracy to Vietnam and avoid negative things? Vietnam adopted the democratic ideal and created a concentrated democratic policy that can provide the same benefits and avoid bad things from democratic countries. You can have freedom in Vietnam as long as you followed their rule: do not use your freedom to make damage to the benefits or another person or organization, when you criticize someone please remember to have evidence to prove your words, otherwise you got trouble.
Thanks to "Đổi Mới" (reform), our government realised that capitalism had a lot of good things to learn, it should not wipe out all of the capitalism's achievements.
Actually, we don't really care about the issue of one-party or multi-party, or even who is the president or prime minister, sometimes we don't care. What matters is that we live in peace, stability, freedom to do what we like, freedom of thought and communication via the internet (not being led by the nose like what the West often thinks about Vietnam), reasonable cost of living. We don't have to strain ourselves to pay taxes to the government. We enjoy a life without too much competition. Come and feel what real democracy is like. Trust me!!!
Everybody should know. You can have authoritarian in both multi-party or single party regime, its up to the people who is in power to lead which direction the country follow. Venezuela, canada, russia, uk, cambodia are just easy examples of a supposed democracy that is now authoritarian that have been failing their people when a facist party elected... Vietnam has their local elections which is a form of democracy. Also Vietnams economy is not centralized it is a market economy which does not follow the example of a communist society. The communism in vietnam is by name, it hold its appreciation for helping vietnam gain its freedom and independence. Those who accuse vietnam of being a authoritarian and north korea or china style government are just foolish mocking bird with no knowledge of vietnam.
The laughable thing about a "democracy" is when you elect your party. You have no further say. In canada they give 10 billion to Ukraine, they let flood of illegal immigrants, they trampled us when we protested for our freedom, now they censor us from saying things online. We never asked for this when we voted we want the dictator trudeau to step down but he wont. Where is the democracy?
when I see young generation earning between 8 to 15M VND, knowing that they will never be able to buy house or land, not sure it’s rising economy. The country is preventing the gen z to have better salary to continue to be attractive in the outsourcing or labour force market. This is leading to no future generation. Of course they still can enjoy everyday life as living cost is still pretty low and they can buy cheap clothes from Shoppee. But saving is quite difficult.
Most young Vietnamese people inherit houses from their parents without paying any tax. Not being able to buy another house does not mean they do not have a house.
@@thangnguyenvan1072Lets be real, what percentage of Gen Z is actually inheriting houses? Can that even meet the demand of a population of 100 million people (double the number in 1975)? And for those poor souls working in factories in big cities and living in horrendous conditions, how are they supposed to afford a house if inheritance isnt an option? Stop the cap with "most young Vietnamese people inherit houses." as i said above, stop finding/make up excuses and start finding solutions
The thing is, there wont be any easy solutions. This is the problem with the market, the more the demand, the higher the price. To this day, i have not seen any sustainable solution promoted by anyone/any countries about this problem and it will only be a bigger and bigger problem when the population grow
People say communist government don't have freedom but in here we are free in our own way. Like in the house you don't talk shit with your parrents so in our country we don't talk shit about government but we can comment about them
Dân Việt giờ hiểu rõ về đường lối chính trị của các nước thông qua internet không kiểm duyệt. Chúng tôi tự nguyện 1 Đảng lãnh đạo, để k phải đấu đá biểu tình, bất ổn chinh trị như mấy cái nước lấy dân chủ để quậy phá. Thái Lan, Pháp, Đức, và nhất là Bầu cử tổng thống Mỹ. Việc nhiều không làm mà đổ tiền bạc, thời gian, bạo loạn để đổi lại 4 năm chính sách mỗi ông lên thì mỗi kiểu. BEHIND ASIA nói về bầu cử Mỹ, thay đổi chóng mặt chính sách thì không ổn định, bạo loạn, cướp bóc, vô gia cư. Hãy tìm xem Việt Nam có không? Dân chủ kiểu Mỹ người Việt Nam không cần
The VCP heeded Deng Xiaoping's reforms and implemented it nearly a decade later. Unlike Xi Jinping that wanted the old failed model of state controlled enterprise back again; that may have lead China to it's current deflation. Plus the One Child Policy implementee by Deng; that was a huge demographic aging mistake that Vietnam avoided. Vietnam has problems, but charismatic dictatorship that plagued China, particularly under Mao Zedong, the Soviet Union under Stalin and all the Kims of North Korea has somehow luckily escaped Vietnam. Maybe it's a cultural trait of the Vietnamese not to have the cult of personality in their top leaders.
Luật đất đai 2024. Điều 81. Các trường hợp thu hồi đất không bồi thường do vi phạm pháp luật về đất đai 1. Sử dụng đất không đúng mục đích đã được Nhà nước giao, cho thuê, công nhận quyền sử dụng đất và đã bị xử phạt vi phạm hành chính về hành vi sử dụng đất không đúng mục đích mà tiếp tục vi phạm. 2. Người sử dụng đất hủy hoại đất và đã bị xử phạt vi phạm hành chính về hành vi hủy hoại đất mà tiếp tục vi phạm. 3. Đất được giao, cho thuê không đúng đối tượng hoặc không đúng thẩm quyền. 4. Đất do nhận chuyển nhượng, nhận tặng cho từ người được Nhà nước giao đất, cho thuê đất mà người được giao đất, cho thuê đất không được chuyển nhượng, tặng cho theo quy định của Luật này. 5. Đất được Nhà nước giao quản lý mà để bị lấn đất, chiếm đất. 6. Người sử dụng đất không thực hiện nghĩa vụ tài chính với Nhà nước. 7. Đất trồng cây hằng năm, đất nuôi trồng thủy sản không được sử dụng trong thời gian 12 tháng liên tục, đất trồng cây lâu năm không được sử dụng trong thời gian 18 tháng liên tục, đất trồng rừng không được sử dụng trong thời gian 24 tháng liên tục và đã bị xử phạt vi phạm hành chính mà không đưa đất vào sử dụng theo thời hạn ghi trong quyết định xử phạt vi phạm hành chính; 8. Đất được Nhà nước giao, cho thuê, cho phép chuyển mục đích sử dụng, công nhận quyền sử dụng đất, nhận chuyển nhượng quyền sử dụng đất để thực hiện dự án đầu tư mà không được sử dụng trong thời hạn 12 tháng liên tục kể từ khi nhận bàn giao đất trên thực địa hoặc tiến độ sử dụng đất chậm 24 tháng so với tiến độ ghi trong dự án đầu tư; trường hợp không đưa đất vào sử dụng hoặc chậm tiến độ sử dụng đất so với tiến độ ghi trong dự án đầu tư thì chủ đầu tư được gia hạn sử dụng không quá 24 tháng và phải nộp bổ sung cho Nhà nước khoản tiền tương ứng với mức tiền sử dụng đất, tiền thuê đất đối với thời gian được gia hạn; hết thời hạn được gia hạn mà chủ đầu tư vẫn chưa đưa đất vào sử dụng thì Nhà nước thu hồi đất mà không bồi thường về đất, tài sản gắn liền với đất và chi phí đầu tư vào đất còn lại. 9. Các trường hợp quy định tại các khoản 6, 7 và 8 Điều này không áp dụng đối với trường hợp bất khả kháng. 10. Chính phủ quy định chi tiết Điều này.
How Vietnam grew: capitalists operating factories in China moved them to Vietnam due to geopolitical tension, tariffs, and rising labor costs and moved them to Vietnam, which is friendlier to America and has lower labor costs.
Yes, this is the main reason. In addition, the culture there is closer to China, Taiwan or South Korea than that of the Philippines, which is also one of the main factors that capital prefer to choose Vietnam. The labor issue just can be left to the Vietnamese government. However, due to Vietnam‘s huge trade surplus with the United States, it is impossible for the States not to deal with this problem, and the government has noticed this situation.
Vietnam got the best economists from all over the world . IMF and World Bank economists still green and gold, walking textbook teach us how to run the economy and the country 😂
Many cointries tried to be developed countries like the Western World. And consequently East Asia could be it. But Even in Mid-term of 20c, Many Asian countries were poorer than average of Sub-Saharan Africans and rather, Other countries had GDP per capita closed to the West like Southern American countries (except Brazil, Paraguay, Bolivia, Guyana, Suriname), many Caribbean countries, Southern Africans and some Middle East or Arab countries not East Asians. Why did they fail and how could East Asians grow then? Many problems like Civil wars or Group conflict can be cause but ultimate factor is failure of industrial diversification. It's required for becoming stable developed country. The countries with high growth speed (Vietnam, India, Indonesia, Mexico, Elsalvador and Botswana) need it.
Đảng cộng sản Việt Nam muôn năm! Đó là tôn chỉ nam cho mục tiêu phía trước. Một Đảng lãnh đạo nhưng không có độc tài ( cha truyền con nối, vua chúa,...). Mỗi lãnh đạo Chính phủ luôn phải làm tốt nhất vai trò của mình cho nhân dân Việt Nam được hạnh phúc, hoà bình, tự do (dân tộc). Hãy nhìn nhận vào thực tế là 4 lãnh đạo đã ngoại giao và tham gia thăm các nước trên thế giới với mục tiêu là gì? Đó là vì Dân tộc Việt Nam. Đặc biệt, thế giới bây giờ bạo loạn, chiến tranh, bè phái chia rẽ dân tộc như Myanmar, Bangladesh, ...hãy sang Việt Nam xem người dân chúng tôi đã làm gì? Có việc làm, thưởng thức cafe, vui chơi giải trí, không xẩy ra hiện tượng nổ súng chết chóng, vào nơi thờ tự không có bom,... Vậy tự do dân chủ là cả dân tộc được hưởng bầu không khí hoà bình, an ninh chính trị ổn định, người dân có cuộc sống hạnh phúc. Các bạn Đa đảng có không??? Tôi yêu tổ quốc tôi ,🇻🇳🇻🇳🇻🇳
@@andyt3343Why do you say that when corruption cases in Vietnam are all public? If we pretend there is no corruption, who exposed and investigated and arrested those corrupt officials so that you know about these cases?
Do you think Vietnam's economic rise is due to the government?
Yes, 50% at least. The people don't legalized laws, sign treaties, nor responsible for national defense. And yes, communism can be better than fake/impotent Democracies.
😂 communist party are trying hard to hide the true economy growth. Right now Vietnam real estate are messed up so many abandon building. The local market are struggling due to online shopping (Chinese products)
Communist party are trying hard to hide the real economy growth. real estate in Vietnam are messed up and local market are struggling😢
Correct, our government make the right decision. I don't underestimate our government. But, the US and China is also very significant factors.
Maybe you don't know, ASEAN was established to anti-Vietnam and communism expansion. Thailand, Philippines, Singapore, South Korea have let US to use its airports and bombed Vietnamese territory, sent troops to kill Vietnamese at that time. Also, US, China, ASEAN have blamed Vietnam for destroying Khmer Rouge after Cambodian genocide invaded Southwest border region and Phu Quoc islands. China took advantage to invade our territory in Paracel islands (1974), Sino Vietnam war, (1979-1991) , Spartly Islands (1988). An independent, united, communist-led Vietnam is thorn for China and US.
In 1991, Soviet Union collapsed and China became biggest threat of the US. In 1994, the U.S. lifted its 30-year trade embargo on Vietnam. It leads to the skyrocketing trend in FDI, export, trade and continuous economic growth from that time until now. In conclusion, Vietnam only have 30 years to develop and sprint with our Asian neighbors. Hope with the bamboo policy, we will be high-income country in 2045.
Yes
"limit civil liberties'? My country is one of the most democratic country in the world. Democracy means we can freely have fun, enjoy peace, enjoy happiness, dont have to bother protest and riot. We Vietnam is not similar to the countries which self-identify "democracy' but bring thousands tons of bombs to others!
Đúng ta không nên theo dân chủ kiểu đó mà chỉ nên lấy những thứ đủ tốt và cho nó vào thôi chính cái tên nước ta cũng nói lên điều đó rồi
Proud of you, good voice my friend!
Vẫn là chiêu bài Dân. Chủ!😑
@@nhatlongphanle6636 Nhà nước của Nhân dân, do Nhân dân, vì Nhân dân ở Việt Nam được thể hiện qua:
- Nguyên tắc “tập trung dân chủ”
- Phương châm “Dân biết, dân bàn, dân làm, dân kiểm tra, dân giám sát, dân thụ hưởng”
Dân chủ ở Việt Nam không được thể hiện qua: số lượng đảng, biểu tình, tự do vô chính phủ, đa số thông qua nhưng thiểu số không làm, toàn dân có quyền thảo luận nhưng lợi ích lại không về tay nhân dân…
Westerners "vote" every 4 years and nothing changes for the good of the people. Always turmoil and chaos, but they think they have the most free country 😂😏
I live in Canada we have an authoritarian regime here. there are more freedom in some things in vietnam than canada. Trust me.
Việt nam cực tự đó về nhiều mặt rất dễ sống tuy nhiên 1 bộ phận quan chức rất quan liêu hách dịch nhũng nhiễu....hi vọng thời gian tới chấm dứt điều đó
@劉兆崴-h7c why are chins so jelous of vietnam? And yes I would move if i could. Only problem i wouldn't be able to stay longer than a permit visa. But one thing for sure i sure as hell would never live in china. I went there once, the place is like a bigger version of north korea people are depressed asf.
Welcome to VietNam. Ha Giang is a suggest for you.
Tôi có tìm hiểu qua về "tự do" tại phương tây thông qua những người bạn việt nam sang các nước phương tây định cư.
Nói chung, sự khác biệt lớn nhất giữa tự do của việt nam và phương tây như sau:
- tại việt nam, người dân là chủ đất nước và chính quyền do dân bầu lên để lãnh đạo đất nước và phục vụ lợi ích của người dân, người dân có quyền làm bất kỳ điều gì trong đất nước miễn nó không vi phạm pháp luật và các nguyên tắc cộng đồng.
- còn tại phương tây, các luật lệ dành cho cá nhân hà khắc hơn, tự do ở đây bị kiểm soát bởi các luật lệ nghiêm khắc, người dân phải sống trong khuôn mẫu và sự tự do thiên về cá nhân đến mức cực đoan
@@Cuoc_song_hai_phong phương tây là tự do trá hình quyền lực tập trung trong tay 1 ông nào đấy không lộ diện ông đó có quyền quyết tất
The Communist Party of Vietnam is leading the country very wisely. Controlling important areas is not for negative purposes, but to maintain strategic stability in these areas. The Vietnamese people have great confidence in the leadership of the Party, and hate to hear opinions that having many parties is better for Vietnam. Because the Communist Party of Vietnam is a large organization, with high democracy in decision-making, always putting the interests of the people first. Important decisions are made with the opinions of the people or the National Assembly. Meanwhile, many "Democratic" countries, as mentioned in the video, but at one point in time, there is only one dominant party in leadership, sometimes an individual president also decides everything. Therefore, I completely disagree with the exaggeration of one-party leadership as analyzed in the video. Please respect the political institutions of different countries!
Đúng rồi bạn những người biết tiếng Anh như bạn cần phải nói rõ cho cái bọn móc máy nước mình này hiểu được lòng dân Việt Nam mình như thế nào để chúng vỡ mộng làm cách mạng ở Việt Nam đi
Bọn chúng muốn chia rẽ dân tộc ra thành nhiều đảng phải để chúng dễ dàng tiếp tay và can thiệp vào đất nước. Bọn chúng muốn nhằm vào các ngành như an ninh lương thực, an ninh năng lượng... chúng quên đi sự tôn trọng, không dám hiểu rằng chế độ nào không quan trọng, vấn đề là nó vó phù hợp hay không.chúng quên đây là 1 dân tộc tồn tại hơn 4000 năm. Chúng luôn là kẻ tiêu chuẩn kép và độc tài , khi sẵn sàng công kích bằng truyền thông báo chí, thậm chí cấm vận bất kỳ chế độ nào không thân chúng. Những kẻ đế quốc đi cướp khắp thế giới hàng thế kỷ giờ đây tẩy trắng thành những người hùng thế giới, thật buồn nôn.
Tôi thấy mấy vấn đề lớn lớn mà Đại biểu quốc hội hoặc các bộ đề xuất mà dân phản đối nhiều là chính phủ dẹp luôn không thông qua. Tính ra lãnh đạo nước mình cũng sợ dân lắm 😂
Vào đọc cmt của các bạn toàn thấy những bl phản biện tích cực mình rất vui. Tôi yêu Việt Nam ❤❤❤❤
I smell propaganda.
Vietnam does not need to compare with another country, just be better every day.
Of course, Vietnamese government rightfully decided to Đổi Mới (Renovation) policy at the right time. But, the US and China is also very significant factors.
Maybe you don't know, ASEAN was established to anti-Vietnam and communism expansion. Thailand, Philippines, Singapore, South Korea have let US to use its airports and bombed Vietnamese territory, sent troops to kill Vietnamese at that time. Also, US, China, ASEAN have blamed Vietnam for destroying Khmer Rouge after Cambodian genocide invaded Southwest border region and Phu Quoc islands. China took advantage to invade our territory in Paracel islands (1974), Sino Vietnam war, (1979-1991) , Spartly Islands (1988). An independent, united, communist-led Vietnam is thorn for China and US.
In 1991, Soviet Union collapsed and China became biggest threat of the US. In 1994, the U.S. lifted its 30-year trade embargo on Vietnam. It leads to the skyrocketing trend in FDI, export, trade and continuous economic growth from that time until now. In conclusion, Vietnam only have 30 to develop and sprint with our Asian neighbors. Hope with the bamboo policy, we will be high-income country in 2045.
Chỗ bạn đánh với TQ tới tận 1991 à, ghê vậy 😂
Vietnam cannot become developed country.
@@huuthien188m k đc học sử à?
@@crayon3041 ngáo đá
@@huuthien188 1989 ta vs trung quốc vẫn có các cuộc giao tranh nhỏ lẻ,nhưng phải đến 1991 mới chấm dứt thực sự
The words democracy and dictatorship to us Vietnamese people are not worth a penny. Because those words are directly proportional to the friendliness of your country with America.
😂😂😂 what a dumb ass. If Vietnam is so awesome, why do so many Vietnamese want to leave the country and come to the West?
I once watched a movie by Stephen Chow about the Qing Dynasty emperor Kangxi of China. He said something that I really liked: "Anyone can be king, as long as the king is good." As an ordinary citizen, what I need is stability, peace, economic development and the freedom to enjoy life.
Look at the election now in US. No, thank you - we don't want that. No party focuses on the citizen and the country, they only focus on how to make the other party looks bad. How much money and time have been wasted on these ridiculous elections? And how many parties do you really have? Two? One advantage of a stable political system is we can think long-term and work on long-term plans. Politics is always politics, everyone is making sure they have and maintain the power. If you can make the majority of people happy, maintain social security, keep growing the economy... you have the power. That happens everywhere no matter systems you are following.
Communist is just a name of a political ideal, we should treat it that way. Any country can follow any ideals that work for them. The media always portraits Communist is evil, how is is not a propaganda? I have travelled to many countries, I don't see people in so call "rich and democracy" countries are any happier - I only saw more stress, anxiety, disconnection, un-balanced life... that's why I have declined many offers to move to other developed countries to stay in VN and take on opportunities that I have here.
I think we're doing fine. Leave us be and move on with your life.
Good job. It is so profound and wonderful,
As a Vietnamese, I am incredibly grateful that the Communist party is leading the nation. Given the current situation of the world right now: War, destruction, and death at every corner of the globe, Vietnam still managed to balance its relationship with major superpowers and bring peace to its people. I don't have to worry about when a draft officer will come and drag me to the battlefield, my family and all the ones I love are protected and well-fed, I can watch the sunrise instead of looking out for bombers, and I can enjoy a cup of coffee without being mag-dumped by a soldier. It's a blessing, for real.
Sure, there are a lot of problems, but at least in Vietnam, I went from being empty-handed to being able to support a family. The Party gave prosperity and happiness to its citizens, just as they promised when they called on all Vietnamese people to rise and earn freedom. We paid blood for a bright future and a bright future we received. I would gladly live and work under the Communist leadership, as long as my friends and family members are safe and sound. Cheers!
I believe the more we Vietnamese look outside, the more we love our country. Any party or government have it pros and cons, but Vietnam suit the Communist more
Quá là thông thái 👍
@@MrOrange119chuẩn bạn . đất nước ở vị trí như Việt Nam mà đa đảng thì chỉ tổ bị các nước lớn thao túng
1) If your communist party is so wonderful as your propaganda suggests, then why is your communist party so scared of contesting a general election with other political parties?
2) Why are other political parties not allowed to be formed in communist Vitnam?
@@MichaelCollinge-r7d it's true that they are scared of political rival, but that has nothing to do with their good performance on the economy, lol
call it authoritarian as you will, the main point is that the system, though has its flaws, worked beautifully and the majority of the vietnamese people including me have better lives now thanks to the state and the party.
the thing is that it didn't have to take so long to get here, it was the wrong system to adopt, it's already been shown from VNCH's economy and state prior to reunification that it earned its "pearl of the orient" title from how well things were going, it literally would've been alongside the top economies in the world with the American aide and cooperation that VNCH had, alongside the other countries America partnered with. What countries? South Korea, Taiwan, Japan, GERMANY. but the country reunified under communist rule and then experienced the absolute worst two decades after reunification thanks to rule under shit head Le Duan. There was a reason Do Moi had to happen, because things just were not working AT ALL.
there's a good reason even Russia and all former soviet states abandoned Communism. What good did taking Soviet/Russian influence do? turned china into a dystopia, froze cuba in the 1950's, absolutely demolished former East Germany to where the effects are seen in how much worse eastern germany is today.....and of course helped North Korea become as weird and as poverty struck as it is today. Vietnam took the wrong route sadly.
Thanks to the fall of the Soviet Union, it helped all soviet aligned countries switch to a capitalist based system. The collapse Forced North Korea to undergo famine, and China/Vietnam to change to a capitalist based market, something South Vietnam had already proved working decades earlier.
So now, many decades later, the system is somewhat helping Vietnam, but think about how much better, stronger, and quicker Vietnam would've achieved this if only reunification occured under the South.
And guess what? it's not gonna improve all that much continued under this stradegy, there is a ceiling to all this, and it's already proven how non-existant the middle class has already become, with only either super rich or super poor for it's people!
All the success or progress in Vietnam is described by the western media as thanks to capitalism, while all the bad things such as drugs, human trafficking, bribery, corruption, gangs, shootings are due to communism. 🤣😂
Chắc chú cũng biết ơn Đẻng luôn vụ chuyến bay giải cứu hay Kit test Việt Á nhỉ? 😂😂
Hail Viet Nam
@@Dominicn123hòn dái viễn đông đấy.và nó được xây dựng bằng tiền của mỹ và pháp chứ việt nam cộng hoà thì làm được cái gì
communist but no dictator is good system..vietnam is on right track...bravo vietnam
Có nhà độc tài vĩ đại thì sẽ cực thịnh còn nhà độc tài rác thì cực tệ như hiện tại cũng tốt khi ko có độc tài
@@binhnguyen-jd4ry MAY NGU CHET ME..3 QUE CUT..
@@binhnguyen-jd4ry MAY NGU CHET ME...CUT
One party or multi-party is fine, as long as they care for the people.
Under the control of communist party, our life has been improving so much. In the 2000s, my family even didn't have enough money to buy a sofa, we had to borrow our neighbor. Now we still borrow money, but to buy land
1) How much money did you receive from the corrupt and thieving communist party to tell lies on the internet?
2) If the communist party is so wonderful and beneficial to so many poor Vietnamese people, they why is your corrupt, thieving, and very stupid communist party so afraid of competing against other political parties?
limit civil liberties ??? Ask Singapore my friend, ask Singapore, where a same party runs that country continuously 60 yrs since it became independence.
Còn nữa quatar. Ả rập xê út. UAE. Vương quốc Anh. Thái Lan.......... Rất nhiều.
Như mỹ trước kia là một đảng nhưng tách ra làm hai đảng như bây giờ.
The Vietnamese government plays a decisive role in the success of the Vietnamese economy. However, some Vietnamese people in America, writers and artists in Vietnam believe that the Vietnamese government is weak.
Bạn nói đúng, các thành phần chống đối không từ những người lao động, những người kinh doanh mà luôn là giới văn nghệ sĩ, tâm hồn ở trên mây (không kỳ thị tổng thống Ura, hehe!).
Look at the conference that Vietnamese PM dedicates to private businessmen, Vietnamese government now put much more importance to the private sector. You can't say this is a communist way of governing the country any more.
I love you vietnam bless up
"Me love you long time!"
Love Vietnam, hate the corrupt and thieving communist party of Vitnam.
@@misterbig9025 "Scoreboard! Scoreboard!"
Fun fact: Because of democratic free will, there are some religions like "Church of Scientology" control a lot of political view, or like South Korea when free will made a religion that can vote and control the president of a Nation.
In Vietnam, there a monk name "Thích Nhất Hạnh" wanted to made a religion that not being control by anyone including the State, Party and made suggestion that wanted to change the name of the country to "Vietnam or Republic of Vietnam" and change the Party name to something other than the _Communist Party of Vietnam_ (Làng mai 31). Can you imagine suggesting that when he DIDN'T DO ANYTHING to help liberate the country from the France, the Japan or the American. If they threaten the people of Vietnam, the nation, it is your duty, everyone duty to protect Vietnam with everything you have *"CHÚNG TA THÀ HY SINH TẤT CẢ, CHỨ NHẤT QUYẾT KHÔNG CHỊU LÀM NÔ LỆ"* - Hồ Chí Minh.
Communist party-led Vietnam is growing fast, while non-communist party-led Philippines is growing slowly. That is why Vietnam needs the VCP.
What a good commie boy you are. Here, one dollar for you to buy lunch to fill your empty stomach.
Meanwhile Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand, are they a joke to Vietnam?
You can see that in East Asian cultural countries, a moderate degree of dictatorship is needed for development. South Korea developed under the dictatorship of Park Chung Hee, Japan under Meiji and Douglas Arthur, the Chinese Communist Party is more oppressive than the Vietnamese Communist Party. Only the dictatorship of the Kim family in South Korea is condemnable. Both single-party and multi-party have their strengths and weaknesses, so you should not judge one-sidedly in a binary way, only good and bad, good and bad depends on the talent and morality of the manager.
Economic power and political power will always be on the hand of the elite class no matter what the kind of goverment is. In Vietnam, the Communist Party dominated the elite class and control both economic power and political power. In the US, the US billionaires class that dominate both Republican Party and Democrat Party. No difference.
I think there is a difference. The party in America will be for the benefit of the tycoons. But if the communist party is for the benefit of the tycoons, it cannot be a communist party anymore. Will it be no different from America? If it is no different, then why does America always want to overthrow Vietnamese communism? In a communist country, the interests of the tycoons and the people will be balanced, because the communists know that the people are a very great force.
@@hongli6541there are a lot of provincal factions in the VCP fighting for their own interest
Let's hope more reforms will be implemented and the economy flourishes in the future! Vietnam has a bright future ahead!
Have you ever looked beyond Hanoi and HCM? Whatever is developed only serves the “elite” of the nation, the rest is being left behind heavily and nothing much is being done to lift these people up, you support something like this?
Did your communist leaders not say in 1975 that communist Vitnam will be richer than Japan in 20 years?
Did your communist leaders not say in 1975 that communism will defeat American capitalism?
@@MichaelCollinge-r7dWhat's your point? This isn't necessarily about competition, we're just happy that Vietnam is flourishing after everything it has been through in the 20th century. Vietnam and China doesn't even practice OG communism all that much anymore, their market is more capitalist orientated now.
the thing is that it didn't have to take so long to get here, it was the wrong system to adopt, it's already been shown from VNCH's economy and state prior to reunification that it earned its "pearl of the orient" title from how well things were going, it literally would've been alongside the top economies in the world with the American aide and cooperation that VNCH had, alongside the other countries America partnered with. What countries? South Korea, Taiwan, Japan, GERMANY. but the country reunified under communist rule and then experienced the absolute worst two decades after reunification thanks to rule under shit head Le Duan. There was a reason Do Moi had to happen, because things just were not working AT ALL.
there's a good reason even Russia and all former soviet states abandoned Communism. What good did taking Soviet/Russian influence do? turned china into a dystopia, froze cuba in the 1950's, absolutely demolished former East Germany to where the effects are seen in how much worse eastern germany is today.....and of course helped North Korea become as weird and as poverty struck as it is today. Vietnam took the wrong route sadly.
Thanks to the fall of the Soviet Union, it helped all soviet aligned countries switch to a capitalist based system. The collapse Forced North Korea to undergo famine, and China/Vietnam to change to a capitalist based market, something South Vietnam had already proved working decades earlier.
So now, many decades later, the system is somewhat helping Vietnam, but think about how much better, stronger, and quicker Vietnam would've achieved this if only reunification occured under the South.
And guess what? it's not gonna improve all that much continued under this stradegy, there is a ceiling to all this, and it's already proven how non-existant the middle class has already become, with only either super rich or super poor for it's people!
@@Dominicn123 Perhaps you're right, but there's no point in saying things like "it would've been better if...etc...etc." since we can't change history. History already happened and the only way forward is to learn from the past and improve (which is what everyone's already doing by implementing reforms and strengthening diplomatic ties). I see no point in thinking about alternative scenarios in history since it doesn't really change whats the reality today. I'm sure most of the government understands that economic reforms were the right decision and hopefully they will continue improving.
I hope things work out in the future and hope that we don't make the same mistakes again.
Càng đọc những bài viết này. Người dân càng bực mình với cái bọn tự cho là "tự do, dân chủ"
Tất cả người Việt Nam đồng ý với bạn. Bọn người mễ nói tiếng Việt thì không chắc.
Vietnam will surely become the 2nd largest economy in ASEAN.
That could be very good, but if the ASEAN tiger is growing together to become top 20 in the world (Thailand, Malaysia, Philippines, Viet Nam, Singapore) with not much different like today, being in top5 is a good position for Vietnam. P.s Indonesia will become top 10 of the world.
Điều này là chắc chắn và nó sẽ sớm xảy ra
Có lẽ chúng ta xếp sau philip vì đó là thống kê của ngân hàng tg ai biết được nhỉ tương lai có thể thay đổi mà 😅
@@HuyNguyễn-n1dWorld Bank nó hay đoán mò lắm. Philippines không phải là đối thủ của Việt Nam.
Already is . Real GDP of Vietnam must be over 600 billion dollar at least. Because no other countries has its GDP much lower than its total export + import combines, which in the case of Vietnam more than 600 billion already. The Vietnamese goverment deliberately lower its official GDP to have more favourable loans 😂
We have 2 dots in East Sea representing our 2 archipelagos Hoàng Sa and Trường Sa, despite China’s claim on Google maps. We have sound evidence of Chinese dynasties admitting that they belong to Vietnam 🇻🇳
Congrats to the Vietnamese people
Now, you can see a world that has so many problems, war, unfair society. Having so many not good around your life. When you come in Vietnam, you can see a peaceful life, no war, no use gun. Everyday, we can earn money, make everything to take care of the life, family, friends... You can invest in Vietnam, mustn't worry for anything of your business. Everything is also ok and safe for you! At the present, Vietnam is looked as the star of South East Asia this year.
Không theo ý các bạn thì gọi đó là độc tài. Bạn có dám đối mặt với người dân việt nam để hỏi về tự do và nhân quyền không.
Đừng nói vậy. Kênh này ở Phi-lip-pin, bọn họ đã bị Mỹ đế tẩy não cả hằng trăm năm nay rồi. Nên não của họ không có suy nghĩ nào ngoài suy nghĩ rằng: đảng cộng sản thì xấu, 1 đảng thì không có “dân chủ”, “nhân quyền”. Bạn có tranh cãi với ếch đáy giếng thì chỉ mệt mình thôi. Mà cứ cho như vậy đi, nhà mình ít dân chủ, nhân quyền nhưng mà lắm gạo, nên nước nhiều dân chủ nhân quyền như bọn họ phải sang nhờ mình bán gạo cho lại còn nhờ đảm bảo an ninh lương thực cho họ nữa chứ.
Trên thế giới này không có nước nào có tư cách nói chuyện nhân quyền ở Việt Nam
Dân chủ? 😂😂😂 Chẳng phải "dân chủ" đã đến Việt Nam năm 64 và rút khỏi Việt Nam năm 73 rồi hay sao 😂😂😂😂😂😂. Các bạn bảo chúng tôi không có quyền tự do ngôn luận ? Đó là bởi vì suy nghĩ của bạn quá hạn hẹp. Tới Việt Nam và cảm nhận thế nào mới là tự do, dân chủ 😊😊😊
2 or more leading political parties is not certainly democratic than one. Because the key issue is on ability, moral values, virtue of political members, willingness to serve their country/citizens that a political party should have had. It's ridiculous that some parties in some countries are corruption and enjoy their own expediency.
There are a lot of smaller factions in VCP , like mini party. And every decision required voting from a group of 200 elite party members so actually it is more " demoracy" than most Westerner think.
The leader of the party, the Prime Minister and the President of the State were elected to execute the vision of the Party, not to execute their OWN vision. So a Trump personality actually may have a pretty hard time leading the party in Vietnam ironically 😂😂😂
Việt Nam không độc tài nhé tác giả. Quyền con người ở Việt Nam luôn được đảm bảo. Quyền bình đẳng giới ở Việt Nam thuộc top đầu thế giới. Người dân Việt Nam sống hạnh phúc và hài lòng với cuộc sống của mình. Toàn dân luôn ủng hộ chính quyền nhà nước, đó mới là điều quan trọng, hầu như không có sự chia rẽ trong đất nước chúng tôi
By the way, the map is wrong ❌, missing alot and not correctly display.
What is Dictatorship? What is Democracy? Why is dictatorship necessarily bad? Democracy must be good? Is it really a dictatorship? Is it really democracy? What is the best system? Is it dictatorship or democracy? Why are you so sure that your answer must be right, did God tell you? Give me your answer
They are paid to propagate "freedom, democracy, multi-party" hahah
❤❤
Vietnam is one of the country that proves communism isn't the worst thing.
Then what is stopping you from coming to live under the rule of communist Vitnam?
🇨🇳：不需要🇻🇳证明
No, it proves that giving up the communist way brings prosperity to Vietnam.
@@ChuckN516bố thằng điên có hiểu vì sao siêu cường như mỹ mà nghèo rất nhiều ko
Wrong, but going away from some communist practices did it improved itself. Get rid of communism completely and it will be even better.
:))))) kênh này có biết mình đang nói gì ko vậy? Xử lí thế lực chống phá mà kêu là media control :)))
toàn thấy rao dảng dân chủ, tự do, đa đảng, =))
Thế đúng la control chứ còn gì ? Bên Mỹ chửi Trump chửi Biden cả ngày trên tivi hay MXH có sao đâu, miễn là k dọa giết là được
vitnam education is very good..
Vietnam implemented market economic reforms in the mid-80s along with the Soviet Union in the Gorbachev era but Vietnam succeeded and the Soviet Union failed in reforms.
NO.discussion on Vietnam's economy is accurate or complete without the imoact.of the comprehensive sanctions imposed on Vietnam after defeating the US and its 100 years of.war.
While in the Philippines, people remain poor aside from the few. Democracy is overrated
Ăn pagpag ở nghĩa trang đó là dân chủ đa nguyên đa đảng mang lại cho người dân
Yeah..
Tự do - Dân chủ của Việt Nam là lẽ tự nhiên như nước, không khí mà chúng tôi hít thở hàng ngày. Nên người Việt Nam không cần bận tâm hay đưa ra mức đánh giá như người Mỹ và Châu Âu.
I love how he pronounced "Đổi mới"!
First of all, Đ in Vietnamse is equal to D in English. There is no Z sound in "Đổi". Secondly, "moi" is "me" in French. The word "mới" in Vietnamese has nothing to do with "moi" in French. No Vietnamese can understand Zoi moi's meaning. 😁
His pronunciation threw me off
Just wait and see when the era of Vietnam's advancement is coming. Just wait and see, it will show you items you won't believe.
How many more centuries do Vietnamese people have to wait for the coming of the propagandistic mirage of communit Vitnam's advancement?
Did your stupid communit leaders not say in 1975 that communism will defeat American capitalism?
Thời của việt nam đã đến giờ có đủ mọi thứ để bùng nổ 20 năm tới
Viet nam đang theo mô hình của Singapo...độc tài về chánh trị + tự do hóa kinh tế tối đa...và vẫn kiểm soát chi phối CP một số Tập đoàn Nhà nước có ảnh hưởng đến an ninh chánh trị đời sống của người dân
No, Singapore has elections and a certain degree of freedom of speech, but not in Vietnam.
@ĐạiĐếPutin-q6k Please stop this f*cking Russian whataboutism. If you really want to debate against his arguments of freedom of speech and election you should provide your counter-arguments for the similar topic. Don't use whataboutism to switch to another topic by running away from the main point.
Singapore has total of more than 5 parties, People Action Party (PAP) under Lee Kuan Yew is the main party that won election through many years
you should have learn more about Singapore before you speak
There is a fact that the Communist Party of Vietnam was founded in the spirit of patriotism during the anti-colonial era of Vietnam's invasion. Patriotism will always be a thing of high importance in Vietnam. Another interesting thing is that when you are in Vietnam you will hear about the leader of Ho Chi Minh and the formation of the Communist Party of Vietnam, which was integrated by the leader of Ho Chi Minh City from other parties. We always believed that as a group we would overcome everything. Through many political reforms and upheavals, it is considered one of the most powerful parties in which it is difficult to have a political party replace it. Although there are conflicting opinions that it is authoritarian and does not raise the democratic spirit of Vietnamese people, it must be true to you that Vietnamese people do not complain about the democracy of the Vietnamese Communist Party. General Secretary Nguyen Phu Trong who just passed away said that a party is not undemocratic because democracy is expressed in many aspects. We hope that we will not only become rich but also happy in the future
Những thứ nhìn thấy như bản đồ còn vẽ sai thì tin chắc rằng thông tin của bạn đưa ra đã dựa trên góc độ khách quan chưa
Thanks to VN Communist Party, our lives have improved a lot and we live more prosperous. My family used to be poor according to VN criterion. The gov encouraged us to study, local gov and school rewarded us with many items and money when we achieved academic results, gave us loans or "student loans" with low interest rates. Thanks to that, I and 2 my sister was able to go to university and thus, helped me broaden my worldview.
I just laugh 😂when information spread from Western countries is not called 'propaganda'. But when it comes from Communist countries, it is "definitely" called 'propaganda'. How ridiculous!
The West countries always claim *fair, civilized, objective*. So where is the word "FAIR" in this case? Oh, you hypocrites who sow war?!
Always use the words "unfree, undemocratic, dictatorial..." to judge others based on your criteria. Where you talk about "unlimited, diverse" but "force others to live within your limits"
First China, now Vietnam - Is there a growing case of communism for growth now?
Big investors, like Nike, don't care about communism government. But what they want is a "stable" political system to guarantee the long term safety of their investments.
Why don't you come to live under communism and find out for yourself? Are you scared now?
Apparently, a mix between communism and capitalism can lead to growth
Chỉ có mỗi việt nam và trung quốc thôi khi 2 quốc gia này chịu cải cách và có mối quan hệ tốt với mỹ và châu âu
Communism or capitalism is just an idea. Something is good or bad depends on the people who do it
Hãy đến Việt Nam để được mở rộng tâm trí của bạn trước khi làm bài bình luận. Việt Nam chúng tôi có sự tự do cho người dân đúng nghĩa nhé tác giả.
Đã tìm hiểu để làm nội dung về Việt Nam vậy tại sao không tìm hiểu xem từ "Đổi mới" đọc như thế nào???
Why don't look up on Google how to pronounce "Đổi mới" when you already did research about Vietnam??? I'm Vietnamese and I don't even understand what you said.
Hoàng sa cà trường sa đâu?
Where are VietNam's archipelagos?
Đảo Hoàng Sa tiếng Anh là Paracel Island dòn đảo Trường Sa là Spratley Island.
I laughed so hard whenever I heard the word "Đổi Mới" in the video.
Tiếng Việt quá tệ nên xem lại cách phát âm 😂😂😂
Nếu như nhà nước vẫn giữ được trạng thái ổn định như hiện tại, quyết liệt và tiếp thu những cái mới với sự cởi mở và tích cực.
Tôi tin sẽ có ngày nền kinh tế Việt Nam sánh ngang với Nhật Bản.
VN mở cửa kinh tế thị trường nhưng 5 cái an ninh chủ chốt vẫn phải kiểm soát.
1 . An ninh lương thực.
2 . An ninh văn hóa.
3 . An ninh năng lượng.
4 . An ninh tài chính.
5 . An ninh quốc phòng chính trị xã hội.
VN độc lập tự chủ không chọn phe. Trung lập.
Không như nhật Bản. Hàn Quốc. Đài Loan. Philippines........... Được Mỹ bảo kê nhưng Philippines vẫn bị mất đảo vào tay TQ như bãi cạn Scarborough 2016.
VN chơi với tất cả các nước trên thế giới 194/195 nước.
VN chơi với mỹ. Với Nga. Với TQ không sợ mất lòng ai.
Ở biển Đông nếu không có VN thì TQ đã đã hốt trọn biển Đông rồi.
Căn cứ quân sự của Mỹ ở Philippines không ảnh hưởng đến việc TQ bành trướng ở biển Đông .
Mỹ tạo vùng xung đột để kiếm tiền từ các nước như. Nhật Bản. Hàn Quốc. Đài Loan. Philippines........ hàng năm phải nộp phí bảo kê cho mỹ và phải bỏ ngân sách ra để mua vũ khí của Mỹ.
Hàng hóa của Mỹ chỉ có vũ khí khí tài. Giá bán thì trên trời.
Nên nhớ đồng minh của Mỹ chính là các nước đối lập với mỹ như TQ. Nga. Triều Tiên. Iran. ....... Không có các nước này mỹ bán vũ khí khí tài cho ai.
Tại sao các nước giàu có phương Tây như Đức. Balan. ...... Nhật Bản. Hàn Quốc. Đài Loan lại không sản xuất vũ khí khí tài để sử dụng mà phải nhập của Mỹ. Vì mỹ không cho phép 😂😂😂. Các nước đó ho he là mỹ bụp liền.
Việt Nam Hùng Cường.
Việt Nam độc lập.
Việt Nam muôn năm.
Chủ tịch Hồ Chí Minh vĩ đại sống mãi trong sự nghiệp của chúng ta. ❤❤❤❤❤.
Japan and South Korea are not American puppet states
0:18! Please don't pronounce Đổi mới as if it's french. That's just cringe. If people can't speak a foreign word, then just avoid it. Smh.
OK commie boy, we shall pronounce doi moi as moi ro vit cong.
@@MichaelCollinge-r7d húc mỗi cái cổng mà dỗi lâu thế. Đu càng tụt cả quần bây giờ khát nước quá à 😂😂😂
@@its_leotran
Why are communists so stupid that they cannot read or write in English?
@@MichaelCollinge-r7d thằng ngụy Cali
@@MichaelCollinge-r7d ok ducanger, you mean vit ngang cong hanh?
Vietnam's biggest problem is that there is no basic industry to support the country. Very high dependence on foreign companies. It would be nice if foreign companies continued to invest. Currently, foreign companies are leaving Vietnam due to rising wages in Vietnam. In addition, Vietnamese young people study a lot with a high passion for education, but there are few companies that are as good as the investment they make in education. Their GDP will reach 4,000-5,000 dollars, but with the current growth rate of 5%, it is not known when it will reach it. 10 or 20 years? Before then, the US-led paradigm will come, and we cannot be sure of their success.
That's where you're wrong. Vietnam have already built it's own basic industry since reformation. We alrwady have plans for the future, especially technology.
You forgot the growing domestic companies of Vietnam and the rise of A.I. and digital economy. It's understand thqt a foreigner like you don't even know them, thús i shall give you information. Vietnam will rise!
Vietnam currently growth rate os still 7%, not 5%. Vietnam already have world-class education system, and now we are developing high-tech industry to prepare for the prosperity in the near future.
@@angKhoaNguyen-ko3nj You don't need a world-class education, it's enough for everyone in Vietnam to be interested in innovation and have an entrepreneurial culture so that this will create a new industry founded by locals
@juanmiguel-557 Those things are happening right now and growing rapidly!
Bright future for Vietnam 🇻🇳
FEEDING THE WEST WITH PROPAGANDA WITH THIS ONE
I did not know that Behind Asia is so Behind.
Empty phrases and no analytics or reflections.
Must be a work of a C student testing GPT.
It is only business, not personal, as they said.
Người Mỹ dân chủ mỗi người dân đều có thể mua súng, dân chủ kiểu mỹ dân bất an,
Bạn chỉ nhìn vào một vấn đề xấu của Mỹ. Bất an như Mỹ mà hiện tại có hơn 20 triệu nhập cư bất hợp pháp. Một phỏng vấn ở Nga khi hỏi nước nào người dân Nga muốn di dân đến nếu được phép thì theo thứ tự như sau:
1. Mỹ
2. Đức
3. Úc và Canada
Cho phép tôi nói một mặt tốt của Mỹ mà 100 năm thậm chí 200 năm nữa Việt Nam đang ước mơ hiện tại và tương lai cũng không làm được đó là trong 10 đại học danh tiếng nhất thế giới thì Mỹ đã chiếm hơn phân nửa. Nói đơn giản vậy thôi chứ không dám nói đến VN ngày nào đó chế tạo được tàu vũ trụ hay thực tiễn và cấp bách hơn nhất là VN tự chủ chế tạo được tàu ngầm, phi cơ chiến đấu, các khu trục hạm thiết giáp hạm đối đầu với TQ đây.
@thumtlnguyen3626 nước nó có công nghệ thì nước mình có kinh tế đi, có tiền thì thiếu gì đồ chơi, ko mua của mỹ đc thì mua của nước khác thân mình, hồi đó nước mình còn nghèo ko có học vũ khi thì thiếu thốn đủ thứ, nước khác viện chợ, còn đánh bậc cả mỹ, nhật, pháp,trung,,,, giờ Nước mình cũng hơi khắm khá rồi cũng mua rất nhiều vũ khí hiện đại r,,,anh đừng có lo sợ với trung quốc quá, mấy thằng Mỹ ko có tốt đẹp gì đâu nó giàu dân nó vô gia cư nhóc, nó có trường đại học danh tiếng nhiều đi chăng nữa nó đi thi cũng thua việc nam thôi, nước nó chiên đâm thọc nước khác toàn đi đánh lộn rồi nó ngồi đó hưởng lợi,
@@thumtlnguyen3626chính vì hơn 20 triệu ng nhập cư bất hợp pháp mới bất an đấy😂 1 đất nước mà cảnh sát thay vì kiểm soát dân nhập cư thì lại đè đầu người da đen😂
@@thumtlnguyen3626 Vậy phải hỏi nước Mỹ có bao nhiêu năm để phát triển rồi? Giáo dục ư? Hãy hỏi đại học Bắc Kinh, đại học Thanh Hoa của Trung Quốc. Họ vượt qua hầu hết các đại học ở Châu Âu, và đang bám sát mấy đại học của nước Mỹ đó. Trong cái vũ trụ này chẳng có cái gì là mãi mãi cả, đợi xem.
@@Hatbuinho79 Tôi đang nói VN anh bạn đem TQ ra so sánh làm gì? TQ và VN khác nhau một trời một vực. Một ví dụ nhỏ TQ đạt bao nhiêu huy chương Olympic còn VN thì sao? Các lãnh vực khoa học khác từ không gian, đến công nghiệp quốc phòng...VN sao có cửa với TQ.
Tôi người Viêt Nam và chúng tôi không cần thứ được gọi là đa đảng
as a vietnamese it actually hurt to hear this pronouciation of doi moi lol
Success for the elites, but not for everyday people; just look at what happened with the húrricane and how it impacted the working class.
u know india, bangladesh and pakistan ? they have multi parties politism but u know how poverty they are ? i think perhaps u have watch some video about these countries, and yes, it's exactly like in the video, worse then vietnam pretty much, vietnam rural area now are the same with thailand.
How? Most people in the working class have houses, trying to have the 2nd ones.
They can buy cars without mortgages. :D.
you are looking at the lowest of the low. Thats not a great example of "every day people". There is a province call Quang Ninh which "everyday people" are too rich to the point they refused to accept help so the fund could be given to other provinces.
I respect your criticism of the government but your example of the recent hurricane doesn't hold much weight since it was a good effort from the government to mitigate and recover from damage. All I see and hear from friends from many provinces is that their lives and businesses were back in two days.
Hold your weight of words when it counts and criticize the government when they actually made a bad decision not when they made a good effort, be objective.
Is that why more and more foreigners try to move to Vietnam every year I wonder? Also also the government's response against the hurricane was highly celebrated by the people, so... maybe pick a better example?
BBC is not a good source when it comes to mentioning foreign countries in Asia. They always have a distorted view without critical thinking and thorough research. Vietnam is much different from the Western, an Asian country rose from war. War with artillery may end in 1975 but the ongoing cold war, sanctions, media accusations continues until at least 2015 when the globe starts changing their view on Vietnam (which Vietnam always have been).
It's unofficial war, but the damage done is real. Calling Vietnam lacks of civil rights or tight political control is not quite true when we do a comparative analysis. In fact, Vietnam laws have less constraints than EU and US law. Maybe we are a new country still figuring out, maybe we are less controlled. Who knows. When I was young, i believed those articles were titled. But as I grew, many of them are untrue
There were many parties that led Vietnam in the past. You voted with paper ballots and we voted with guns and bullets. The election lasted from 1945 to 1975. The freedom you talk about is 5 million Vietnamese people and 58 thousand American soldiers and several tens of thousands of French soldiers.
Vietnam has democracy and freedom, but it followed its laws. Vietnam didn’t have same democratic structure politic like many Western countries because it is communist state and can’t apply the same structure like that, instead of using the same structure with both positive and negative things why does they use another way that can bring democracy to Vietnam and avoid negative things? Vietnam adopted the democratic ideal and created a concentrated democratic policy that can provide the same benefits and avoid bad things from democratic countries.
You can have freedom in Vietnam as long as you followed their rule: do not use your freedom to make damage to the benefits or another person or organization, when you criticize someone please remember to have evidence to prove your words, otherwise you got trouble.
They are much more free unlike China or North Korea
Thanks to "Đổi Mới" (reform), our government realised that capitalism had a lot of good things to learn, it should not wipe out all of the capitalism's achievements.
Actually, we don't really care about the issue of one-party or multi-party, or even who is the president or prime minister, sometimes we don't care. What matters is that we live in peace, stability, freedom to do what we like, freedom of thought and communication via the internet (not being led by the nose like what the West often thinks about Vietnam), reasonable cost of living. We don't have to strain ourselves to pay taxes to the government. We enjoy a life without too much competition. Come and feel what real democracy is like. Trust me!!!
Everybody should know. You can have authoritarian in both multi-party or single party regime, its up to the people who is in power to lead which direction the country follow. Venezuela, canada, russia, uk, cambodia are just easy examples of a supposed democracy that is now authoritarian that have been failing their people when a facist party elected... Vietnam has their local elections which is a form of democracy. Also Vietnams economy is not centralized it is a market economy which does not follow the example of a communist society. The communism in vietnam is by name, it hold its appreciation for helping vietnam gain its freedom and independence. Those who accuse vietnam of being a authoritarian and north korea or china style government are just foolish mocking bird with no knowledge of vietnam.
The laughable thing about a "democracy" is when you elect your party. You have no further say. In canada they give 10 billion to Ukraine, they let flood of illegal immigrants, they trampled us when we protested for our freedom, now they censor us from saying things online. We never asked for this when we voted we want the dictator trudeau to step down but he wont. Where is the democracy?
Communist or not, just because it is communist doesn't mean it has to follow 100% way of doing things. It's just a name.
Vietnam's political system only has the cover of a communist party, but in reality it is not like that, because it varies a lot from communist theory.
when I see young generation earning between 8 to 15M VND, knowing that they will never be able to buy house or land, not sure it’s rising economy. The country is preventing the gen z to have better salary to continue to be attractive in the outsourcing or labour force market. This is leading to no future generation. Of course they still can enjoy everyday life as living cost is still pretty low and they can buy cheap clothes from Shoppee. But saving is quite difficult.
Same to other countries, the young is suffering.
Lack of land, so much people will lead to that, same as Korea
Most young Vietnamese people inherit houses from their parents without paying any tax. Not being able to buy another house does not mean they do not have a house.
@@thangnguyenvan1072Lets be real, what percentage of Gen Z is actually inheriting houses? Can that even meet the demand of a population of 100 million people (double the number in 1975)? And for those poor souls working in factories in big cities and living in horrendous conditions, how are they supposed to afford a house if inheritance isnt an option? Stop the cap with "most young Vietnamese people inherit houses." as i said above, stop finding/make up excuses and start finding solutions
The thing is, there wont be any easy solutions. This is the problem with the market, the more the demand, the higher the price. To this day, i have not seen any sustainable solution promoted by anyone/any countries about this problem and it will only be a bigger and bigger problem when the population grow
Communism Vietnam or Capitalist Philippines. It is clear at a glance whose prospects are better.
People say communist government don't have freedom but in here we are free in our own way. Like in the house you don't talk shit with your parrents so in our country we don't talk shit about government but we can comment about them
your pronunciation of "Đổi mới" needs some work.
I hate it that there are TH-camrs who often downplay native pronunciation. We have all resources nowadays to check how foreign words are pronounced.
thật, nghe không giống từ đổi mới tí nào luôn á
@@cendahng True. All they had to do is put the term in Google Translate and listen to the pronunciation but they couldn't even do such a simple thing.
Corruption’s county you may see a lot of officer they are rich but their salary low…
LOL still crying about it, this happens anywhere around the world. People who say that like you, when they have the chance they will do it
Dân Việt giờ hiểu rõ về đường lối chính trị của các nước thông qua internet không kiểm duyệt. Chúng tôi tự nguyện 1 Đảng lãnh đạo, để k phải đấu đá biểu tình, bất ổn chinh trị như mấy cái nước lấy dân chủ để quậy phá. Thái Lan, Pháp, Đức, và nhất là Bầu cử tổng thống Mỹ. Việc nhiều không làm mà đổ tiền bạc, thời gian, bạo loạn để đổi lại 4 năm chính sách mỗi ông lên thì mỗi kiểu. BEHIND ASIA nói về bầu cử Mỹ, thay đổi chóng mặt chính sách thì không ổn định, bạo loạn, cướp bóc, vô gia cư. Hãy tìm xem Việt Nam có không? Dân chủ kiểu Mỹ người Việt Nam không cần
U make this video, u don’t know about Vietnam 😂
Joi Moi like the French colonisers never left^^
🤣 IKR? I'm dumfounded how đổi turned out as joy.
Người VNCH cũ hãy trả lời giùm : Mỹ cho các bạn tất cả từ tiền bạc , vũ khí . Vậy các bạn đã cho Mỹ điều gì để họ tốt với các bạn ?
The VCP heeded Deng Xiaoping's reforms and implemented it nearly a decade later. Unlike Xi Jinping that wanted the old failed model of state controlled enterprise back again; that may have lead China to it's current deflation. Plus the One Child Policy implementee by Deng; that was a huge demographic aging mistake that Vietnam avoided. Vietnam has problems, but charismatic dictatorship that plagued China, particularly under Mao Zedong, the Soviet Union under Stalin and all the Kims of North Korea has somehow luckily escaped Vietnam. Maybe it's a cultural trait of the Vietnamese not to have the cult of personality in their top leaders.
Why are you pronouncing đổi as joy? The đ is pronounced as a regular d in English. As for the mới, why are you saying it as if it's a French word?
Luật đất đai 2024. Điều 81. Các trường hợp thu hồi đất không bồi thường do vi phạm pháp luật về đất đai
1. Sử dụng đất không đúng mục đích đã được Nhà nước giao, cho thuê, công nhận quyền sử dụng đất và đã bị xử phạt vi phạm hành chính về hành vi sử dụng đất không đúng mục đích mà tiếp tục vi phạm.
2. Người sử dụng đất hủy hoại đất và đã bị xử phạt vi phạm hành chính về hành vi hủy hoại đất mà tiếp tục vi phạm.
3. Đất được giao, cho thuê không đúng đối tượng hoặc không đúng thẩm quyền.
4. Đất do nhận chuyển nhượng, nhận tặng cho từ người được Nhà nước giao đất, cho thuê đất mà người được giao đất, cho thuê đất không được chuyển nhượng, tặng cho theo quy định của Luật này.
5. Đất được Nhà nước giao quản lý mà để bị lấn đất, chiếm đất.
6. Người sử dụng đất không thực hiện nghĩa vụ tài chính với Nhà nước.
7. Đất trồng cây hằng năm, đất nuôi trồng thủy sản không được sử dụng trong thời gian 12 tháng liên tục, đất trồng cây lâu năm không được sử dụng trong thời gian 18 tháng liên tục, đất trồng rừng không được sử dụng trong thời gian 24 tháng liên tục và đã bị xử phạt vi phạm hành chính mà không đưa đất vào sử dụng theo thời hạn ghi trong quyết định xử phạt vi phạm hành chính;
8. Đất được Nhà nước giao, cho thuê, cho phép chuyển mục đích sử dụng, công nhận quyền sử dụng đất, nhận chuyển nhượng quyền sử dụng đất để thực hiện dự án đầu tư mà không được sử dụng trong thời hạn 12 tháng liên tục kể từ khi nhận bàn giao đất trên thực địa hoặc tiến độ sử dụng đất chậm 24 tháng so với tiến độ ghi trong dự án đầu tư; trường hợp không đưa đất vào sử dụng hoặc chậm tiến độ sử dụng đất so với tiến độ ghi trong dự án đầu tư thì chủ đầu tư được gia hạn sử dụng không quá 24 tháng và phải nộp bổ sung cho Nhà nước khoản tiền tương ứng với mức tiền sử dụng đất, tiền thuê đất đối với thời gian được gia hạn; hết thời hạn được gia hạn mà chủ đầu tư vẫn chưa đưa đất vào sử dụng thì Nhà nước thu hồi đất mà không bồi thường về đất, tài sản gắn liền với đất và chi phí đầu tư vào đất còn lại.
9. Các trường hợp quy định tại các khoản 6, 7 và 8 Điều này không áp dụng đối với trường hợp bất khả kháng.
10. Chính phủ quy định chi tiết Điều này.
People only care input and output. Who care what inside the black box (political box)
Its just sad though because that vietnamese real estate lady stole billions from the viet economy.
The way he pronounce Doi Moi give me all kind of rage.
Edit: Nvm, just realized this is an AI chanel.
Damn, you really made the word ‘Đổi mới’ sounds so sexy 😂😂 good try though
Vietnamese government donated this channel
How Vietnam grew: capitalists operating factories in China moved them to Vietnam due to geopolitical tension, tariffs, and rising labor costs and moved them to Vietnam, which is friendlier to America and has lower labor costs.
Yes, this is the main reason. In addition, the culture there is closer to China, Taiwan or South Korea than that of the Philippines, which is also one of the main factors that capital prefer to choose Vietnam. The labor issue just can be left to the Vietnamese government. However, due to Vietnam‘s huge trade surplus with the United States, it is impossible for the States not to deal with this problem, and the government has noticed this situation.
Hardly. Vietnam mostly develops by it's own ability.
0:18 Man. You can just let google translator speaks it.
Vietnam got the best economists from all over the world . IMF and World Bank economists still green and gold, walking textbook teach us how to run the economy and the country 😂
Theo bạn Dân chủ là gì ? =))
Many cointries tried to be developed countries like the Western World. And consequently East Asia could be it. But Even in Mid-term of 20c, Many Asian countries were poorer than average of Sub-Saharan Africans and rather, Other countries had GDP per capita closed to the West like Southern American countries (except Brazil, Paraguay, Bolivia, Guyana, Suriname), many Caribbean countries, Southern Africans and some Middle East or Arab countries not East Asians. Why did they fail and how could East Asians grow then? Many problems like Civil wars or Group conflict can be cause but ultimate factor is failure of industrial diversification. It's required for becoming stable developed country. The countries with high growth speed (Vietnam, India, Indonesia, Mexico, Elsalvador and Botswana) need it.
Good geography, climate, resource base and moderate population size also maters.
High GDP per capita does not mean good quality of life in that country. The quality of life in the countries you mentioned is worse than in Vietnam.
Economic diversification? Worry not, Vietnam has already done that!
Đảng cộng sản Việt Nam muôn năm! Đó là tôn chỉ nam cho mục tiêu phía trước. Một Đảng lãnh đạo nhưng không có độc tài ( cha truyền con nối, vua chúa,...). Mỗi lãnh đạo Chính phủ luôn phải làm tốt nhất vai trò của mình cho nhân dân Việt Nam được hạnh phúc, hoà bình, tự do (dân tộc). Hãy nhìn nhận vào thực tế là 4 lãnh đạo đã ngoại giao và tham gia thăm các nước trên thế giới với mục tiêu là gì? Đó là vì Dân tộc Việt Nam. Đặc biệt, thế giới bây giờ bạo loạn, chiến tranh, bè phái chia rẽ dân tộc như Myanmar, Bangladesh, ...hãy sang Việt Nam xem người dân chúng tôi đã làm gì? Có việc làm, thưởng thức cafe, vui chơi giải trí, không xẩy ra hiện tượng nổ súng chết chóng, vào nơi thờ tự không có bom,... Vậy tự do dân chủ là cả dân tộc được hưởng bầu không khí hoà bình, an ninh chính trị ổn định, người dân có cuộc sống hạnh phúc. Các bạn Đa đảng có không??? Tôi yêu tổ quốc tôi ,🇻🇳🇻🇳🇻🇳
đổi mới❌
join more✔
Vietnam is literally mini China, look at the flag, 1 star compared to 8 star in China flag
Vietnam flag existed before China flag for 15 years.
Inaccurate description!
Trời ơi là vui thế
Fix corruption and money will flow
Name 1 country with no corruption
@@thonassvn1024 classic Vietnam response. Yes you're right many countries are but they don't pretend they are free and noncorrupt.
@@thonassvn1024 Switzerland
@@andyt3343Why do you say that when corruption cases in Vietnam are all public? If we pretend there is no corruption, who exposed and investigated and arrested those corrupt officials so that you know about these cases?
@@hongli6541 hahaha welcome to 2008.. about time, corruption is unfortunately ingrained for decades. Will take long time to fix.
10.......10 Việt Nam
Wow, endlich kann Vietnamesische Charakter beweisen ...........