The difference is that fantasy settings have a tendency to make greatswords weigh as much as your whole body for some reason. In real life they are quite fast, nimble weapons. Large and awkward to carry? Yes. But not super heavy or unwieldy.
@@robinswords over the last year and a bit, ive started calling the greatsword by this descriptor 'the ultimate attack sword' for when a halberd is too long and cumbersome, and when a longsword or rapier just doesnt have the power or reach to cover a wide area you want the greatsword, 'the ultimate attack sword' "building interiors, city streets, gateways, wall breaches or ships decks, it can do it all'
@@elgostine not really, greatswords are still more ineffective in more close and city-like areas, and halberds are usually even less heavy and cumbersome than them sure, in the end, halberds are still more clunky in tight spaces if it matters, but nobody would use either weapon in a situation if they had a choice and the halberd is like... literally the most often used weapon in the battlefield by knights who aren't mounted very few people in comparison to other weapons actually use the greatsword there's a reason that zweihanders are almost the only "greatswords" ever used in medieval europe
Yes, it was, but I bet in real vicious medieval wars of blood and bone, guys were swinging their weps like baseball bats freaking out with all their might. 😡🤬AhhhHHHH!!! 🛡🏹👑⚔️🛡
@@themadhi-hatter6849 it depends Less trained combatants, definitely. Spearmen in ranks would just take stabs forward. Armored knights could be considered skilled, but them being all armored would lead to their fights looking much more chaotic. Still, swinging around like crazy just leaves you open.
You parried the first one but prepared to strike despite the fact that the momentum from the first strike I did, was being used to enhance my second attack, this blunder left you wide open and is why you are now, a head.
@@katiebarber407 nah, as long as it is in a controlled setting, the weapons are dulled, and there is no nefarious intent on either side, it is perfectly legal to do At least, thats true where I live
@@pressaltf4forfreevbucks179 My name is Yoshikage Kira. I'm 33 years old. My house is in the northeast section of Morioh, where all the villas are, and I am not married. I work as an employee for the Kame Yu department stores, and I get home every day by 8 PM at the latest. I don't smoke, but I occasionally drink. I'm in bed by 11 PM, and make sure I get eight hours of sleep, no matter what. After having a glass of warm milk and doing about twenty minutes of stretches before going to bed, I usually have no problems sleeping until morning. Just like a baby, I wake up without any fatigue or stress in the morning. I was told there were no issues at my last check-up. I'm trying to explain that I'm a person who wishes to live a very quiet life. I take care not to trouble myself with any enemies, like winning and losing, that would cause me to lose sleep at night. That is how I deal with society, and I know that is what brings me happiness. Although, if I were to fight I wouldn't lose to anyone.
Self-preservation is a key component of why the montante works as a 1vX weapon. Congratulations on outflanking the swordsman, but how badly do you want to risk getting clobbered on the backswing to stab them in the back?
@@robinswords I guess many people forget that irl you won't be respawning, and loosing an arm was basically dying with extra steps. I would rather call artillery before trying to evade that... I guess thats why gunpowder became mainstream...
@@TsulaAngenati2292 You probably won't spin against a polearm, as it'd most likely have to be a 1v1 scenario for you to win since it's a more even fight. The greatsword will in essence become a spear fighting them. Spins are for the five or six rapier fighters on all sides of you.
I'm no sword expert, but one other factor may be reach. A longer sword means your enemy needs to close a larger gap while you have your back to them, thus giving you more time to complete the spin safely.
The other factor is that the greatsword will go right through body parts and even torsos without stopping, and according to the masters who comment on this, cannot be parried as an single handed sword will either break or be knocked from your hand when struck by a greatsword. The energy on the receiving end is substantial.
@@swissarmyknight4306well in a battlefield you would rarely find people without Armor. Even flexible armor like chainmail has a chance of stopping the cut (but not blunt impact). Plate armor or even plate chestpiece would be enough to stop it completely. And that is not even mentioning shields.
@@kamirostorino9416greatswords are a civilian weapon primarily- used to guard things, hence one trained wielder is expected to face many unarmoured opponents or at least delay them. They are not a formation weapon and do not have much utility on a battlefield- unusually for a big weapon. There was some claims of their use vs pike blocks to sweep asside polearms but the effectiveness is questionable. Point being, lopping off 5 peasants head in one swing is what they're designed for, (or at least looking like they could) not warfare. You can block an entire street back when they were narrow and let your patron escape or what have you.
@@mandowarrior123 they are literally called "war swords" in old books and manuals from the time they were used. therefore you are incorrect. They were popular for those who were higher as bodyguards but that does not mean they were used only for that or that this was even their primary use. I am a part of one of many knight brotherhoods in Poland and we do historical reaanactment. I know the history.
Don't ever spin in a fight that's unbelievably stupid. I thought this guy knew his stuff but apparently he's just another "Shadiversity" talking out of his ass with no practical experience. No, play fighting is not practical experience, fights are to the death not to the hit.
He's actually wrong on this, any fencer will tell you spinning in a real fight of any kind is asking to be killed. You absolutely NEVER turn your back to your opponent, you cannot spin faster than the human reaction time especially with a sword sticking way out slowing you down. I don't use greatswords but the way to redirect any slashing weapon is by spinning the weapon only not your body.
@@vyvianalcott1681 I'm curious if fencing multiple combatants is normal in a real fight. Surly what you said is true. However the dude in the vid is explaining an outmanned scenario, not a chivalrous duel.
@@Salisbury_SteakIt is not, as soon as you are outnumbered in melee combat you are dead. If one guy is behind you spinning isn't going to help, you're dead no matter what. Real life fights end VERY quickly. But you're right I did ignore the context where he was talking about fighting multiple enemies not just one, but that just makes the video even more silly to me. What you do when you have enemies on multiple sides of you is run like fuck to a better position lol.
I am loving all of these explanations with all these sword techniques. I have a huge interest in making animations involving swords and this helps me a learn a lot
Pretty standard HEMA attire. His pants are a little nicer than mine though. There is some padding to soften blows to the thighs hips and knees to a degree. It's also a cut resistant fabric. Having a little extra loose fabric also help resist cuts. Not that he is sparring with sharp weapons, but weird accidents happen when swinging steel around.
God,the spining slash you showed at the end of the video is so glorious,it looks so swift and powerful wish more videos games portrayed big swords like this
Now I really wanna rewatch Berserk. Also pretty sure Guts does make those kinds of moves, he's just doing it with a much heavier sword cuz he's built different (unrealistically so, but it's fantasy and he is quite literally superhumanly strong and tough because magic)
Well remember, Guts was trained in standard longsword but given a sword that (to a 7-year-old) was absolutely gigantic and expected to fight in the exact same way as an adult soldier. That's how he conditioned himself to wield a giant sword; he just kept having them forged larger and larger as he grew so the proportion stayed roughly the same.
In a sparring match, the best form would be to spam half-swording thrusts. Use it’s reach as a spear pretty much. In the battlefield, swing it like a madman. You’ll wear plate armor and riveted chainmail all over, so you’ll be safe. Even the back is protected.
While spinning looks like it would keep people away out of fear of being hit, as soon as the sword hits something it's going to stop and leave them open anyway.
Medieval knights didnt use greatswords. It is weapon of elite footman mercenaries of pikemen batallias times. Knights were like 99% cavalry at that times, unlike of early knights from 9-10 centuries, when they may not have horse. And greatswords are not for horseback combat at all.
I always assumed big swords served a more crowd control function but seeing it consistently being shown and explained really does put my fantasy and history nerd heart at ease 😂
Because the greatswords in souls games are literally 300 pound hunks of sharpened metal, no human on earth can even pick up one of those in the games….they are slightly longer than this sword and the blade is about 5 times as wide and 10 times as thick….this sword blade is probably about a quarter of an inch thick at most and about 3 inches wide (edge to edge)….souls greatswords on the other hand are like 5 inches thick and probably almost a foot wide edge to edge…..huge difference
For gameplay reasons. They are edgy rhythm games. If they were fast they'd be too similar to the smaller weapons, and you are exchanging risk in committed movements for effect which reflects reality in spirit but doesn't replicate it like say kingdom come deliverance
I would love to use this concept in a game somehow, probably implement it as a more committal version of the spin attack from Zelda, so that you have an attack that's great versus groups but struggles against singular enemies
not that heavy actually, a greatsword like that likely won't weigh more than 3 or 4 kilos. Swords needed to be super light in order to actually be quick enough for the user to defend themselves.
That's a major difference between Japanese and Korean curved sword techniques. The Korean styles often favor momentum compensation or redirection, creating fluid movement and reducing wrist/forearm strain. There is some of that in Japanese styles, sure, but it's more prominent in Korean curved sword techniques.
Everyone talks shit about spinning a sword until the swordsman does an actual pirouette and not a spin attack. Even if you do hit them in the back, that zweihander is still gonna wreck your shit with the momentum that's already going.
@@roffels11-gamingandhistory69 no, no their really not, getting poked by a rapier is much more preferable than getting slammed by something that heavy and able to pick up and carry through so much momentums
Been watching these shorts the last few days. Very cool to learn how swords were used and the techniques behind them. I never thought this much thought went into their design/use
It particularly makes sense for greatsword users since historically they were often in the vanguard used to break up the adversary's pike formations. So a move set that allows a wide area of effect while advancing efficiently would fit them perfectly.
Also trained in European swordsmanship here and I can confirm everything this man says. He's also one of my personal favourite sword content creators for this reason. Also Marcus Vance
Congrats to this guy on the community he has built this is the only sword related comment section I’ve ever seen where people generally seem to have real knowledge on the topic.
greatsword forms really put a new perspective on how geralt uses his swords when you think of it it showcases that his style isnt AS alien and unthinkable as one might think
@@Kingdomkey123678 noit really, the style works. its just that greatswords were often specially deployed as space clearing swords, you can do it with a longsword.. just not as well...
@@elgostine 1. Zweihander only came into existance in the 1500s when metalurgy allowed for stronger steel and thus a lighter blade that is just as strong. With this one only weighing 6 pounds. 2. Zweihanders were mainly used to break pike formations and to flank enemy formations.
The combination of niche knowledge, a very nice physique, and smoldering nerdy hots hasn’t made me this sexually confused since seeing Henry Cavil shirtless.
In Warhammer Fantasy 4e, I made a Brettonian Errant Who's entire focus, is the longsword. Did he already win two jousts? Yes. Did he dominate against a Pegasus Knight Commander and break his arm? Also yes. Did he end up being mentored by said knight? Yes. Did he end up along with another errant discovering a conspiracy of hirophants and traitor knights? Yes. Did he charge a bridge full of hirophants holding back loyalist knights? Oh hell yes, he is a bloody linebreaker.
Perfect demonstration! The speed from the momentum of a spin is much faster than an opponent trying to step past the sword's reach. They'd have to also use a very long weapon, in which case you likely wouldn't use it
Thank you for showing this off. I hate when people write off spinning even when considering Greatswords and Warswords. Momentum is important to carry! Spinning and momentum are best friends!
Thinking the greatsword was only good in fantasy settings only to find out how versatile it is irl is so cathartic
It's also surprisingly light. Mine is only 6 lbs.
The difference is that fantasy settings have a tendency to make greatswords weigh as much as your whole body for some reason. In real life they are quite fast, nimble weapons.
Large and awkward to carry? Yes. But not super heavy or unwieldy.
@@robinswords damnnnn how is that only 6 lbs
@@robinswords over the last year and a bit, ive started calling the greatsword by this descriptor
'the ultimate attack sword'
for when a halberd is too long and cumbersome,
and when a longsword or rapier just doesnt have the power or reach to cover a wide area
you want the greatsword, 'the ultimate attack sword'
"building interiors, city streets, gateways, wall breaches or ships decks, it can do it all'
@@elgostine
not really, greatswords are still more ineffective in more close and city-like areas, and halberds are usually even less heavy and cumbersome than them
sure, in the end, halberds are still more clunky in tight spaces if it matters, but nobody would use either weapon in a situation if they had a choice
and the halberd is like... literally the most often used weapon in the battlefield by knights who aren't mounted
very few people in comparison to other weapons actually use the greatsword
there's a reason that zweihanders are almost the only "greatswords" ever used in medieval europe
Damn. That final sword move was just downright graceful. Had to rewatch it.
Yes, it was, but I bet in real vicious medieval wars of blood and bone, guys were swinging their weps like baseball bats freaking out with all their might. 😡🤬AhhhHHHH!!! 🛡🏹👑⚔️🛡
@@themadhi-hatter6849 it depends
Less trained combatants, definitely.
Spearmen in ranks would just take stabs forward.
Armored knights could be considered skilled, but them being all armored would lead to their fights looking much more chaotic.
Still, swinging around like crazy just leaves you open.
Same here
@@themadhi-hatter6849You can bet, but you'd be largely wrong
Imagine getting decapitated by this dude and he just stands over your body with his feet together explaining the mistakes you made in your fight
You parried the first one but prepared to strike despite the fact that the momentum from the first strike I did, was being used to enhance my second attack, this blunder left you wide open and is why you are now, a head.
I would pay for that
NooOOOOOOOOoOOOO
@Nezha_Main that head's last words: ...sir... this.. is.. a Wendy's.. blurgghh
This is how I want to die
I've never felt so threatened by someone wearing overalls before
Dude looks like a lesbian...
Don't meet a farmer with a shotgun xD
I gave you 69 likes.
@@MachineMan-mj4gj nice!
Have you never met a shredded lesbian
Bro's hiding the most diabolical physique under that shirt. I can tell.
Lmao. How else could he swing with such grace?
Unpacking video when??
Y'all thirsty af 💧
Gay-ass reply (supportive)
he looks skinny fat
Wow, this Clark Kent guy seems really good with swords
Yea when he’s fighting air. Give him an actual combatant
@@corywilkins9648 unfortunately that's probably illegal
@@katiebarber407 nah, as long as it is in a controlled setting, the weapons are dulled, and there is no nefarious intent on either side, it is perfectly legal to do
At least, thats true where I live
@@theroyalgamer6560where do you live? Asking for a friend
Fruity Clark kent
If he takes off his glasses he becomes swordsman Superman.
Superknight
@@yichlyichl4204 that's a good name.
Jojo reference
@@pressaltf4forfreevbucks179 My name is Yoshikage Kira. I'm 33 years old. My house is in the northeast section of Morioh, where all the villas are, and I am not married. I work as an employee for the Kame Yu department stores, and I get home every day by 8 PM at the latest. I don't smoke, but I occasionally drink. I'm in bed by 11 PM, and make sure I get eight hours of sleep, no matter what. After having a glass of warm milk and doing about twenty minutes of stretches before going to bed, I usually have no problems sleeping until morning. Just like a baby, I wake up without any fatigue or stress in the morning. I was told there were no issues at my last check-up. I'm trying to explain that I'm a person who wishes to live a very quiet life. I take care not to trouble myself with any enemies, like winning and losing, that would cause me to lose sleep at night. That is how I deal with society, and I know that is what brings me happiness. Although, if I were to fight I wouldn't lose to anyone.
Super Swordsman
I would also think that nobody is stupid enough to try to frame perfect your back when if it fails you will be hit by a massive sword.
Self-preservation is a key component of why the montante works as a 1vX weapon. Congratulations on outflanking the swordsman, but how badly do you want to risk getting clobbered on the backswing to stab them in the back?
@@robinswords I guess many people forget that irl you won't be respawning, and loosing an arm was basically dying with extra steps.
I would rather call artillery before trying to evade that... I guess thats why gunpowder became mainstream...
Fellow adeptus mechanicus, hello there
If you’re quick you could use something like a spear or spear tipped polearm when they try it
@@TsulaAngenati2292 You probably won't spin against a polearm, as it'd most likely have to be a 1v1 scenario for you to win since it's a more even fight. The greatsword will in essence become a spear fighting them.
Spins are for the five or six rapier fighters on all sides of you.
Homie here is low key stacked.
That spin awakened my inner 99 endurance stat
I'll try spinning, that's a good trick!
Dangit! You beat me to the joke. Good thing Palpatine made it legal.
@@Salt_Master_Queue *Screams in Senate*
It's working, ITS WORKING!
You wouldn't spin a CAR, would you??
Now this is swordfighting!
I'm no sword expert, but one other factor may be reach. A longer sword means your enemy needs to close a larger gap while you have your back to them, thus giving you more time to complete the spin safely.
Correct, distance is time
The other factor is that the greatsword will go right through body parts and even torsos without stopping, and according to the masters who comment on this, cannot be parried as an single handed sword will either break or be knocked from your hand when struck by a greatsword. The energy on the receiving end is substantial.
@@swissarmyknight4306well in a battlefield you would rarely find people without Armor. Even flexible armor like chainmail has a chance of stopping the cut (but not blunt impact). Plate armor or even plate chestpiece would be enough to stop it completely.
And that is not even mentioning shields.
@@kamirostorino9416greatswords are a civilian weapon primarily- used to guard things, hence one trained wielder is expected to face many unarmoured opponents or at least delay them. They are not a formation weapon and do not have much utility on a battlefield- unusually for a big weapon.
There was some claims of their use vs pike blocks to sweep asside polearms but the effectiveness is questionable.
Point being, lopping off 5 peasants head in one swing is what they're designed for, (or at least looking like they could) not warfare. You can block an entire street back when they were narrow and let your patron escape or what have you.
@@mandowarrior123 they are literally called "war swords" in old books and manuals from the time they were used. therefore you are incorrect. They were popular for those who were higher as bodyguards but that does not mean they were used only for that or that this was even their primary use.
I am a part of one of many knight brotherhoods in Poland and we do historical reaanactment. I know the history.
God, those spins were fine as hell. Especially with that glasses push at the end. You couldn't have choreographed that to be any smoother.
Yeah I can't how many takes it took to get that spin and the framing to come together that well. Fantastic craft.
Zweihander + rolling = win against any gank squad boss.
Everything about this was exemplary usage of time and energy well-spent! Thanks for your efforts.
Don't ever spin in a fight that's unbelievably stupid. I thought this guy knew his stuff but apparently he's just another "Shadiversity" talking out of his ass with no practical experience.
No, play fighting is not practical experience, fights are to the death not to the hit.
This is what happens when Clark gets sent to report on the ren-fair in metropolis.
God damn it I wish I had a Zweihänder
Honestly who doesn't
We all do king.
Don’t get anything from Cold Steel
Their Greatsword’s Blade actually flew out of the handle during testing, and almost injured the camera man.
Yea same
@@fallencrusader2975 was about to suggest this!
So you're telling me my whirlwind spin move in elementary school was justified. That is hands down the best news I’ve heard all year
On the other hand, I know a guy who has the FF lightning sword replica and it took 3 men to move up into a cabinet frame 🙃
He's actually wrong on this, any fencer will tell you spinning in a real fight of any kind is asking to be killed. You absolutely NEVER turn your back to your opponent, you cannot spin faster than the human reaction time especially with a sword sticking way out slowing you down. I don't use greatswords but the way to redirect any slashing weapon is by spinning the weapon only not your body.
@@vyvianalcott1681
> Fencer
> Greatsword
> "I don't use greatswords"
Invalid statement, next please
@@vyvianalcott1681 I'm curious if fencing multiple combatants is normal in a real fight. Surly what you said is true. However the dude in the vid is explaining an outmanned scenario, not a chivalrous duel.
@@Salisbury_SteakIt is not, as soon as you are outnumbered in melee combat you are dead. If one guy is behind you spinning isn't going to help, you're dead no matter what. Real life fights end VERY quickly.
But you're right I did ignore the context where he was talking about fighting multiple enemies not just one, but that just makes the video even more silly to me. What you do when you have enemies on multiple sides of you is run like fuck to a better position lol.
I am loving all of these explanations with all these sword techniques. I have a huge interest in making animations involving swords and this helps me a learn a lot
First of all, loved the first dainty lil spin. Second, tibbies 😳
Bluigi is out here showing off like damn
"Bluigi" had me cackling lol. 😂
At first, I was like "What's with his outfit?", but by my 3rd time watching this, the outfit grew on me lol
Do you know nothing about the suits people wear for dueling and demonstration of swords?
@@red_menace1829 Obviously not numb nuts. But like I said, I ended up liking the outfit after viewing the video few times. Good day sir.
exactly my reaction. At first glance it looked a bit silly, but there is something about it
those pants are fire
Pretty standard HEMA attire. His pants are a little nicer than mine though. There is some padding to soften blows to the thighs hips and knees to a degree. It's also a cut resistant fabric. Having a little extra loose fabric also help resist cuts. Not that he is sparring with sharp weapons, but weird accidents happen when swinging steel around.
God,the spining slash you showed at the end of the video is so glorious,it looks so swift and powerful
wish more videos games portrayed big swords like this
A lot of them do within the confines of special moves.
This is what guts should’ve done when he fought those 100 men saves him the trouble
SPIN TO WIN BABY!
Now I really wanna rewatch Berserk. Also pretty sure Guts does make those kinds of moves, he's just doing it with a much heavier sword cuz he's built different (unrealistically so, but it's fantasy and he is quite literally superhumanly strong and tough because magic)
@@gsgaming6976 I love that the how/why of berserk ultimately boils down to guts being built differently lmfao
@@gsgaming6976 guts has no magic enhancement at all
Well remember, Guts was trained in standard longsword but given a sword that (to a 7-year-old) was absolutely gigantic and expected to fight in the exact same way as an adult soldier. That's how he conditioned himself to wield a giant sword; he just kept having them forged larger and larger as he grew so the proportion stayed roughly the same.
This guy is a good mix of cartoonishly nerdy and cartoonishly hot
It’s honestly insane
You should see him when he takes the glasses off
If he bulked up he’d be incredibly handsome. Although that would limit his mobility so he’d probably never do it
@@TheUncivilizedNation As if he isn't already.
@@Nhblubirdhe isn't. Dude is like 150 soaking wet
Glad there are ppl out there like you.
Good day young Man
Jesus seeing how fast that thing follows through with the swing… I’d die so quick in so many ways in those times it’s not even funny.
You're really built. No wonder you can lug that thing around with that much finesse!
In a sparring match, the best form would be to spam half-swording thrusts. Use it’s reach as a spear pretty much. In the battlefield, swing it like a madman. You’ll wear plate armor and riveted chainmail all over, so you’ll be safe. Even the back is protected.
Several of these forms imply a civic bodyguard carry where full armor is unlikely which places increased emphasis on how you cover the back.
@@robinswords and increased importance on the reach of the sword. Made you and your company feel safe even if something WERE to occur
Good luck slashing someone else's armor 🤡
Not to mention that in a sparring you see half-swording 1 time out of 100 000
@@satsebeli greatswords can slash but don’t need to, sheer weight and momentum offers blunt force trauma and is more effective against armor
While spinning looks like it would keep people away out of fear of being hit, as soon as the sword hits something it's going to stop and leave them open anyway.
That whistle gave me legit chills
Medieval knights actually saw that grip when they played Dark Souls 2 and adopted it
Who needs a sword when you can have max stats on ADP!
Medieval knights didnt use greatswords. It is weapon of elite footman mercenaries of pikemen batallias times. Knights were like 99% cavalry at that times, unlike of early knights from 9-10 centuries, when they may not have horse. And greatswords are not for horseback combat at all.
@@Uncle_Smallett your reply is way too serious, considering that the original comment is a joke lmao
@@youdonegoofed joke doesnt mean profanity to be good. It is not a joke if someone just tell some ...you get the word, i think.
@@Uncle_Smallett 🤓
damn, i think i'm pregnant
ugh
... didn't think he could get you from behind either, eh?
@@TragoudistrosMPH ha!
Same
Homosexuality is gay.
I always assumed big swords served a more crowd control function but seeing it consistently being shown and explained really does put my fantasy and history nerd heart at ease 😂
That double spin at the end was so clean and beautiful
One of the things that I don't see many people list here is just how large the area you can cover with a greatsword is when you spin it.
In the most appreciative way possible: this is possibly the most mesmerizing and hottest 30 seconds ive ever seen
Me: thirsting (respectfully)
Caught in 4k.. 💀💀💀
@@liesalllies💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀
Thank you handsome sword man
I don't know what I did for the algorithm to bring me here but I sure am glad it did
Watching this relatively small man effortlessly swing that great sword makes me wonder why the swords seem to weigh 300lbs in souls games.
Because the greatswords in souls games are literally 300 pound hunks of sharpened metal, no human on earth can even pick up one of those in the games….they are slightly longer than this sword and the blade is about 5 times as wide and 10 times as thick….this sword blade is probably about a quarter of an inch thick at most and about 3 inches wide (edge to edge)….souls greatswords on the other hand are like 5 inches thick and probably almost a foot wide edge to edge…..huge difference
The heaviest actual weapon I've ever found in a museum (show pieces not meant for fighting excluded) is around 8 lbs. A huge zweihander.
For gameplay reasons. They are edgy rhythm games. If they were fast they'd be too similar to the smaller weapons, and you are exchanging risk in committed movements for effect which reflects reality in spirit but doesn't replicate it like say kingdom come deliverance
@@grimmvand9674 No, stuff like zwei and claymore and just a few pounds, way lighter than other fantasy weapons in their class.
I would love to use this concept in a game somehow, probably implement it as a more committal version of the spin attack from Zelda, so that you have an attack that's great versus groups but struggles against singular enemies
The utility of a big long heavy metal stick cant be ignored
not that heavy actually, a greatsword like that likely won't weigh more than 3 or 4 kilos. Swords needed to be super light in order to actually be quick enough for the user to defend themselves.
Bruh! 😂
Damn dude you're chest is 🔥👍, Hans swollow
That's a major difference between Japanese and Korean curved sword techniques. The Korean styles often favor momentum compensation or redirection, creating fluid movement and reducing wrist/forearm strain. There is some of that in Japanese styles, sure, but it's more prominent in Korean curved sword techniques.
I don’t think I’d recognize him without his glasses
Well that’s just super, man
Unless if your opponent is tired or get distracted by your flamboyant medieval bard clothing.
It may leave your back open, but swinging a sword like that will force them to back away which won’t give them the opportunity to punish you.
As a katana enthusiast, this bad boi is fucking your samurai ass up real fast
Look at how tight that shirt is
We're looking alright 👀👀
Shirtless with suspenders would be more educational
treating it like a light greatsword
Did that guy get that jacked training with swords?! Fucking awesome!
Everyone talks shit about spinning a sword until the swordsman does an actual pirouette and not a spin attack.
Even if you do hit them in the back, that zweihander is still gonna wreck your shit with the momentum that's already going.
Oh, of course a spin will hurt me, but the spinner is hurt worse. :>
@@roffels11-gamingandhistory69 no, no their really not, getting poked by a rapier is much more preferable than getting slammed by something that heavy and able to pick up and carry through so much momentums
What a nice Kansas man, surely he's not related at all to the flying god alien that's been helping everyone lately
Been watching these shorts the last few days. Very cool to learn how swords were used and the techniques behind them. I never thought this much thought went into their design/use
I'm so happy this video exists. Hopefully more who have a passion for this field see this and consider this valid insight.
It particularly makes sense for greatsword users since historically they were often in the vanguard used to break up the adversary's pike formations.
So a move set that allows a wide area of effect while advancing efficiently would fit them perfectly.
Also trained in European swordsmanship here and I can confirm everything this man says. He's also one of my personal favourite sword content creators for this reason. Also Marcus Vance
Bro didn’t level up his stamina enough for the two handed weapons.
this fit looks great on you
Nerd and jock at the same time, peak human
Congrats to this guy on the community he has built this is the only sword related comment section I’ve ever seen where people generally seem to have real knowledge on the topic.
greatsword forms really put a new perspective on how geralt uses his swords when you think of it
it showcases that his style isnt AS alien and unthinkable as one might think
Well it’s pretty alien for the style of sword he uses, but he has super speed so that makes up for it
@@Kingdomkey123678 noit really, the style works. its just that greatswords were often specially deployed as space clearing swords, you can do it with a longsword.. just not as well...
@@elgostine spinning with a longsword is suicide believe me, my club has tried to make it work. It just doesn’t
It makes total sense for him to use it that way when you consider he fights alone and usually outnumbered
@@elgostine
1. Zweihander only came into existance in the 1500s when metalurgy allowed for stronger steel and thus a lighter blade that is just as strong. With this one only weighing 6 pounds.
2. Zweihanders were mainly used to break pike formations and to flank enemy formations.
You swung that like a damn Jedi
So it does actually make sense for Garen's spin to win strategy!
That double swing at the end was clean
This man will be an asset once the rat men started to rise up
I'm officially down bad.
That spin was so swift I physically backed away from my screen, I'm not getting near someone with that swing!
Link would be proud
I love this guy. He literally answers all of us mens questions that we think about as we try to fall asleep. Keep up the good work
The combination of niche knowledge, a very nice physique, and smoldering nerdy hots hasn’t made me this sexually confused since seeing Henry Cavil shirtless.
You ain’t confused my dude. That’s just what you’re into.
I wish elden ring have that R1 attacks from greatswords.
Kinda has an ash of war that spins
I'll make sure to remember this the next time I get into a duel
Bro is a medieval crip
Oh my god he looks majestic with that move
I didnt know Clark Kent is a sword practitioner
Your Gigachad body language never gets old for me.
This man woke up this morning and couldn't find the highest waisted pants he owned, so he just had to wear those ones💀
Look at that moveset, that stance, that weaponart, that poise
Beautiful technique. Looks effortless
In Warhammer Fantasy 4e, I made a Brettonian Errant Who's entire focus, is the longsword. Did he already win two jousts? Yes. Did he dominate against a Pegasus Knight Commander and break his arm? Also yes. Did he end up being mentored by said knight? Yes. Did he end up along with another errant discovering a conspiracy of hirophants and traitor knights? Yes. Did he charge a bridge full of hirophants holding back loyalist knights? Oh hell yes, he is a bloody linebreaker.
I said longsword, meant greatsword. I irl am trying to learn the longsword.
Bretonnia…gross.
@@theoneandonlymichaelmccormick Better than Imperial bastard with their fire arms and lack of chivalry! Jk jk both are awesome XD
@@theoneandonlymichaelmccormick Hell IRL I practice archery.
@@alendonvaldor5808 Yeah, I’m just messing with you.
I want MMOs and RPGs that let me swing two-handed swords as gracefully as this man
I'll try spinning, that's a good trick
The comments remind me of that AT&T girl, you dont see much but you already know something's there
Look at this man’s fit
Mental blue screen for a solid 40 seconds tryna decide whether those pants were dorky or the coolest shit ever and I want a pair now
I was gonna say something until I saw that second swing...I'm taking my +2 Mace and leaving quietly 😂
The fact this man is wearing overalls and glasses and still looks badass is giving ofd some powerful energy
This dudes outfit is simply incredible. I can’t get over it. This is a guy with a destiny!
I've always adored the rapier/dagger combo. A long thin rapier in one hand and a short dagger in the other
Perfect demonstration! The speed from the momentum of a spin is much faster than an opponent trying to step past the sword's reach. They'd have to also use a very long weapon, in which case you likely wouldn't use it
Bro is graceful with those spins
This dudes form is awesome
Ty for validation spins and treating it like a normal conversation.
You have Gregory Peck’s looks, Matthew Broderick’s geeky charm, and the skill of Donald McBane
I play greatsword in New World.. And yes relentless rush is very effective
sick spin bro. That looks really scary and lethal on the battlefield
Oh my God, in the last part you spin that thing as if it’s made out of feather! So very impressive and mesmerizing to watch
Beautifully well done.
Thank you for showing this off. I hate when people write off spinning even when considering Greatswords and Warswords.
Momentum is important to carry! Spinning and momentum are best friends!