Salam, very good speech sayed. This sayed should be respected, you know why.. its because he has a brain in the head and in the mouth and he has a heart in a chest and in his eyes. Do you wanna know why he has a heart in his eyes, its because whatever he sees, he knows its Allah's creation, so that he's iman gets stronger. Salam and good speech sayed salam
Question for Imam: Why does Allah say he loves and gets angry if he doesn't have emotions? Doesn't it become misleading to speak that way, when it's just easier to say Allah favors/disfavors you? We wouldn't be having this conversation then. Your point about Prophet and Imams being upset makes more sense to me.
Salam alaikum, I think he mentioned that Allah spoke to us in a tangible and understandable language for us. Therefore he used words such as love, anger, etc. Does this answer your question?
Salam sayed. Sayed if allah can't see, why is there a hadith by imam Sadiq (AS) that it says "allah moves half of you and you move half of yourself" (could not memorise the exact hadith words) so does allah not see. I thought you meant he sees without any eyes. Please i am a little confused. Salam
He is a Being, but not through phenomenon of coming into being. He exists but not from non-existence. He is with everything but not in physical nearness. He is different from everything but not in physical separation. He acts but without connotation of movements and instruments. He sees even when there is none to be looked at from among His creation. He is only One, such that there is none with whom He may keep company or whom He may miss in his absence. Nehjul Balagha Sermon 1
Second Question for Imam: You mentioned Hindus believing in an impersonal God, but I know they believe God came down to Earth as Rama and Krishna to establish justice. Is this not then personal Gods?
Hinduism is a highly diverse religion with multiple denominations with their unique opinion on this subject. I’m pretty sure he meant a certain group and not every single Hindu.
@@ab5680 "Hinduism" is too imprecise to be useful. I believe he's referring to the Advaita Vedanta which I believe is the school of thought Buddhism came out of. Basically, creation is just imagination, there is only God, and we are just God observing itself. You work towards ego death through meditation and asceticism and eliminate your individuality so you can perceive reality and your true self. This is the sort of higher-level Hinduism that intrigued the Mughals as a different but interesting take on monotheism.
I am a Hindu and I do not think that Rama and Krisha were real. Just fictional stories. Just like how Islam has a diversity of opinion, it is the same thing with Hinduism. Also, we call it Sanatana Dharma, not Hinduism. But Hinduism is fine.
Good question. If there are questions about personality, surely there are questions of biological signifiers applied to the divine. If God is transcendent, then above biology: male pronouns must be as wrong as female pronouns? Otherwise, to give a physically gendered sex to God would be limiting?
In Arabic language they use either he or she. It's just a way of referring to Allah, as in Quran Allah uses هو not هی، which in English would be he and not she. It doesn't do anything to gender.
Linguistics. Masculine is inclusive in many languages including Arabic and English. If we had a group of males, we could say boys. If we had a group of females, we could say girls. If we have a group with any number of females and one or more males, we are supposed to use boys. Throughout the Quran God describes itself in ways people can relate to, in metaphor. God understands us, we're complex but we are finite, but we cannot understand the God who is infinite. That's why we keep doing stupid things like worshipping rocks or fire or the sun instead of the creator. That's why God sent prophets to guide us, and when we had enough language and enough writing he sent Muhammad and the Quran and told us he would preserve it.
I HAVE A GOOD EXAMPLE AMONG 8 BILLION PEOPLE ON EARTH PLUS THE ONES PAST AWAY NO ONE CAN SAY HE DREAM GOD OR SAW GOD IN HIS DREAM THAT ALONE PROOFS GOD IS UNIQUE AND NOT COMPARABLE
If its not Gods words Find Me a Single Mistake ? There are thousands of Proofs that its God words in the Quran Mathematically, logically and Scientifically
@@loading3961 You say, "Find Me a Single Mistake" . The quran has many dozens of mistakes. If you want to have an honest dialog about those mistakes, let's agree on some simple rules. 1) we will use only Arabic as the base text, its transliteration and a translation from Islamic scholars who are available online to confirm their translation. No words will be inserted. No words will be replaced or added. 2) we will use only the words of the quran, not an interpretation. The assumption is the quran is the perfect, unchanged, unchangeable words of a perfect, unchanged, unchangeable god who does not need any human to explain what god said or means. 3) we will address each other only with words of personal respect. But assertions, ideas and beliefs of either of us may be challenged, questioned or not treated as anything special. If you are
@@loading3961 you say, "No human Can Write a Book Which si this perfect in every way" So, do we agree we agree that any book full of silly errors could not have been written by a god? Yes or no? or does it scare you a little to say that? (UPDATE: 3 months later - I guess the whole idea scared him because he never came back.)
Muslims STAY with the ORIGINAL ISLAM as given to us by the Prophet MUHAMMAD (sas) Do not get INTO inventions AFTER the Prophet Shia Sufi....etc etc etc. etc Wahabi Tablligi BERELVI DEOBANDI.... ........ ........ .no IMAMS SCHOLARS MUFTIS NO ONE IS AUTHORIZED TO ADD ANY THING TO ISLAM AFTER THE PROPHET
This video is underrated. Every person on the planet should watch this video and agree with Sayed Mohammad Baqer Qazwini because he is speaking facts.
Very good video, thank you. I am not a muslim, but you have correctly described God.
اللهم صل على محمد وال محمد احسنتم وطيب الله انفاسكم وحفظكم
Salam, very good speech sayed. This sayed should be respected, you know why.. its because he has a brain in the head and in the mouth and he has a heart in a chest and in his eyes. Do you wanna know why he has a heart in his eyes, its because whatever he sees, he knows its Allah's creation, so that he's iman gets stronger. Salam and good speech sayed salam
Allahumma sali ala muhamd wa Ali muhamd wajjil farzahom shreef tabarakasmo rabbika yazullzalali Wal ikram
Allahu Akbar I khabira walhamdullahi khtira wa subhaanallahi amma yusrikon layalid walam yolad walam yakollaho kof wan had barakallah ya uztad
U r knwlegable
Jazak Allah alf kher sheykhna
Logical epxplanaption
MaasyaAllah.. it enlightens the soul.. thank you.. may Allah bless you. Allahumma shalli 'ala Muhammad wa aali Muhammad
كلام راقي بارك الله بكم سيدنا
💚💚💚
Ubr damn good
Wow!! Amazing topic...
Btw 99name is enough
Question for Imam:
Why does Allah say he loves and gets angry if he doesn't have emotions? Doesn't it become misleading to speak that way, when it's just easier to say Allah favors/disfavors you? We wouldn't be having this conversation then.
Your point about Prophet and Imams being upset makes more sense to me.
Salam alaikum,
I think he mentioned that Allah spoke to us in a tangible and understandable language for us. Therefore he used words such as love, anger, etc.
Does this answer your question?
@@Mary14114
wa alaykum salam,
Thanks, that helps!
Salam sayed. Sayed if allah can't see, why is there a hadith by imam Sadiq (AS) that it says "allah moves half of you and you move half of yourself" (could not memorise the exact hadith words) so does allah not see. I thought you meant he sees without any eyes. Please i am a little confused. Salam
He is a Being, but not through phenomenon of coming into being. He exists but not from non-existence. He is with everything but not in physical nearness. He is different from everything but not in physical separation. He acts but without connotation of movements and instruments. He sees even when there is none to be looked at from among His creation. He is only One, such that there is none with whom He may keep company or whom He may miss in his absence.
Nehjul Balagha Sermon 1
In quran allah praise himself n talk to himself... Then ppl call him mad after tht
Isbat Ul Kareem what do you mean?
Second Question for Imam:
You mentioned Hindus believing in an impersonal God, but I know they believe God came down to Earth as Rama and Krishna to establish justice. Is this not then personal Gods?
Hinduism is a highly diverse religion with multiple denominations with their unique opinion on this subject. I’m pretty sure he meant a certain group and not every single Hindu.
@@ab5680 "Hinduism" is too imprecise to be useful. I believe he's referring to the Advaita Vedanta which I believe is the school of thought Buddhism came out of. Basically, creation is just imagination, there is only God, and we are just God observing itself. You work towards ego death through meditation and asceticism and eliminate your individuality so you can perceive reality and your true self. This is the sort of higher-level Hinduism that intrigued the Mughals as a different but interesting take on monotheism.
I am a Hindu and I do not think that Rama and Krisha were real. Just fictional stories. Just like how Islam has a diversity of opinion, it is the same thing with Hinduism. Also, we call it Sanatana Dharma, not Hinduism. But Hinduism is fine.
Sorry I made a spelling mistake, *Krishna not Krisha
why do we call allah "he"?
Hassan Abbas just for the sake of simplicity and reference just like how Allah refers to himself as "We" because he refers to himself in royal terms
Good question. If there are questions about personality, surely there are questions of biological signifiers applied to the divine. If God is transcendent, then above biology: male pronouns must be as wrong as female pronouns? Otherwise, to give a physically gendered sex to God would be limiting?
In Arabic language they use either he or she. It's just a way of referring to Allah, as in Quran Allah uses هو not هی، which in English would be he and not she. It doesn't do anything to gender.
Linguistics. Masculine is inclusive in many languages including Arabic and English. If we had a group of males, we could say boys. If we had a group of females, we could say girls. If we have a group with any number of females and one or more males, we are supposed to use boys. Throughout the Quran God describes itself in ways people can relate to, in metaphor. God understands us, we're complex but we are finite, but we cannot understand the God who is infinite. That's why we keep doing stupid things like worshipping rocks or fire or the sun instead of the creator. That's why God sent prophets to guide us, and when we had enough language and enough writing he sent Muhammad and the Quran and told us he would preserve it.
Biological Evolution is a fact though.
Yep it is fine, he acknowledged that.
I HAVE A GOOD EXAMPLE
AMONG 8 BILLION PEOPLE ON EARTH PLUS THE ONES PAST AWAY
NO ONE CAN SAY HE DREAM GOD OR SAW GOD IN HIS DREAM
THAT ALONE PROOFS GOD IS UNIQUE AND NOT COMPARABLE
Do you have scientifically verifiable evidence for the existence of a god? (PREDICTION: You will avoid a straight answer.)
If its not Gods words Find Me a Single Mistake ? There are thousands of Proofs that its God words in the Quran Mathematically, logically and Scientifically
No human Can Write a Book Which si this perfect in every way
@@loading3961 You say, "Find Me a Single Mistake" . The quran has many dozens of mistakes. If you want to have an honest dialog about those mistakes, let's agree on some simple rules.
1) we will use only Arabic as the base text, its transliteration and a translation from Islamic scholars who are available online to confirm their translation. No words will be inserted. No words will be replaced or added.
2) we will use only the words of the quran, not an interpretation. The assumption is the quran is the perfect, unchanged, unchangeable words of a perfect, unchanged, unchangeable god who does not need any human to explain what god said or means.
3) we will address each other only with words of personal respect. But assertions, ideas and beliefs of either of us may be challenged, questioned or not treated as anything special.
If you are
@@loading3961 BTW - thank you for fulfilling my prediction that you have no scientifically verifiable evidence for the existence of a god.
@@loading3961 you say, "No human Can Write a Book Which si this perfect in every way"
So, do we agree we agree that any book full of silly errors could not have been written by a god? Yes or no? or does it scare you a little to say that? (UPDATE: 3 months later - I guess the whole idea scared him because he never came back.)
Muslims
STAY with the ORIGINAL ISLAM as given to us by the Prophet MUHAMMAD (sas)
Do not get INTO inventions AFTER the Prophet
Shia Sufi....etc etc etc. etc
Wahabi Tablligi BERELVI DEOBANDI....
........ ........
.no IMAMS SCHOLARS MUFTIS
NO ONE IS AUTHORIZED TO ADD ANY THING TO ISLAM AFTER THE PROPHET
Pretty sure you’re a Sunni