Hi Jordan - I’ve been told that I have TWO hot/live wires coming in to my home from the DNO … could you please advise as to what someone would be capable of loading to this “single phase“ line (s) ? [ looking to do some preparation for an EV and mass solar + battery installation - perhaps you could quote perhaps too 🤔🤷♂️ - in due course ] - Thanks In Advance. Aled - PS: keep up the fantastic work and the electrifying⚡️ content 👌
Hiya just about to get a Tesla and already switched to octopus. What charger do I need to get on the intelligent tariff ? Also my drive is around the back of my house so do I need wifi for a charger ?
@@EverydayLife621 I just plug it in and let it do it's thing. It will charge outside of the normal hours (at the cheap rate) if it feels like it. I actually have two zappis, the 2nd isn't controlled by octopus and we never have issues with the 2nd car charging. But without a compatible charger I wouldn't be able to be on intelligent go, and the tarrifs are not as good then.
@EverydayLife621 not sure what you're getting at. I needed a compatible charger (which zappi is) in order to be able to access intelligent go, which means my overnight charging is 7p/kwh rather than 8.5p/kwh and lasts 6h rather than 5. I don't really care about the "intelligent" aspect, but without a compatible charger I would he paying more.
Probably the best way of getting onto Intelligent Octopus Go. Works much better than any EV integration and probably the best of the charge point integrations.
@@EverydayLife621 The point of Intelligent Octopus Go is that Octopus control when your car charges (rather than being just a fixed cheap period like most other EV tariffs). In order to do that they need to be able to control either the EV or the charge point. That's how they give the very cheap price - you can get well over 6 hours of cheap rate per day.
Zappi customer.... unit failed for a known MCB issue within a week of installation and that was frustrating, felt like they were shipping out units that "might" fail and dealing with those that did rather than fixing them all upfront. But I always say it's how a company reacts that matters. Part was on site within 24 hours and the original installer was given the funding approval to get in and fix it next day. 48 hours later all done and running again and it hasn't skipped a beat in the last 14 months. Overall I'm happy with it and the solar integration has saved me so much money. Late April to September I have paid ZERO for recharge on My Tesla M3P with everything coming from the excess solar.
I have the Simpson and Partner for two reasons only. It looks amazing and just as important, it does not need a mobile signal (I do not get a cell signal at my house). Only Bluetooth and WiFi are used so I can monitor it from the house. I had to discount many other chargers because they stated that they require a mobile signal to supply operating information.
Owning a Zappi has been brilliant for me. It works so well with my solar panels and batteries, charging the car instead of exporting, yet still allowing me to charge the car when I want to. Their service has been brilliant throughout - I had an issue with the front screen after 4 years of use, (Mark 1 version), and then sent me (free) a complete replacement front. If you have solar generation, I would definitely recommend this charger.
An essential criteria for me was the charger had to be compatible with Octopus Intelligent Go. One of the reason I chose a Ohme Pro charger, which has been fine so far. Easy to use, good app, decent support, and reliable. I was put off the Zappi by my next door neighbour's experience. He has had two units totally fail in 12 months. Both replaced swiftly by MyEnergi I must add.
The thing that frustrates me no end is that I have, sat on my drive, a 77kWh battery, most of which gets used only for local trips up to 120 miles, and every few months a longer trip up to 500 miles (on a single charge.. yes!) but I still cannot get a charger in the UK that works to permit vehicle to home or vehicle to grid which with solar PV or off peak charging would just make so much sense. How long before these hit the walls of our houses?
I've been thinking that an Ioniq 5 battery would be good for home electricity storage. Interfacing it with other systems is the trick of course, as you say.
I see your point but because of the cost of the car I would personally not degrade the battery by doing that. Different f its a leased EV that you dont care about.
Completely agree with your point regards MyEnergi Zappi quality - mine failed just outside of warranty - I'm left with useless plastic brick on the wall, hence watching of this video researching for a replacement. Thanks for the video.
One of the main areas that is not addressed by this video is the support for OCPP protocol integration and the ability to communicate to secondary systems by Wifi or Ethernet. This is now becoming more important to allow integration of a EV car charger into household systems eg Home Assistant
Does OCPP support mean that the charger doesn't need to access the manufacturer's server? I think depending on an internet connection to the manufacturer is a big problem if companies go bankrupt, or have outages or cyber-attacks. The apps should be able to talk directly to the devices over the local network, not use the cloud.
Good vid mate ! I am a one man band installer about 30 mins south of Cambridge. Installed all but the Simpson & Partners model ! Agree, all have their own idiosyncratic issues or advantages ! Like that you pointed out that it really is horses for courses out there in the real world. I do all surveys on site so I know what I am dealing with !
I as a consumer have an Tesla Wallconnector Gen 2. Got it installed by an certified electrician, and it works great. Have it for almost 4 years and still looks great and works on 3 phase (11kW). It’s not a smart charger, but I always control it trough the app of with the car, which works fine for my use case. But it would be nice to have some more control.
I had a Zappi installed with a non functioning screen. It was fixed under warranty (Jan 2024), but not a good start. No problems since. There was instructions about not installing in direct sunlight (UV damage to plastic body, I assume). The unit does get the sun later in the day, so I cover it with a rucksack waterproof cover when not using it during the day.
Yep they added API support for it not so long ago.....Zappi is best allrounder imo, also well established so not likely to suddenly go bust and leave customers in the lurch.
Octopus now support the cars directly, so you can use intelligent go if you have a compatible charger and/or a compatible EV. Which means you can use intelligent go with Tesla wallbox + model 3 because the model 3 is supported by octopus even if the wallbox is not.
@@iambenmitchellNot all cars and I've heard people say that they're not adding support for any more cars. Some of the vehicle manufacturers don't like third parties controlling their cars. If you have a Zappi or Ohme you can charge any car with IO. It makes much more sense to control chargers rather than cars. That way octopus get more coverage for less effort.
@@rugbygirlsdadg Yeah I know that. I wouldn't consider a car that didn't have an API anyway. Being that proprietary in 2024 is ridiculous, it's always the old fashioned legacy brands too that refuse to modernise. Easee have an open API too, but octopus don't yet support them, however, octopus do support Tesla cars so I'm going to go with Easee because they're designed and made in Scandinavia and built very well. Plus I suspect they'll be added to octopus natively soon too. Myenergi products all look so old and outdated. It suits the 2013 Nissan leaf but looks out of place for other cars, unnecessarily large
What about the security aspects? Can you lock the chargers so other people can’t use them? How good are the cyber-security capabilities of the manufacturers? Will you have an inoperable charger if the manufacturer is attacked?
An installer isn't going to know all the vulnerabilities of each product. If they did, they'd probably be manufacturing their own units. You can't expect an installer to know this.
@@mattblackledge9068 This is a video advising on which units to buy, and I personally think that the security features of the units would be an interesting thing to comment on. On the cyber-resiliency of the manufacturer's maybe not every installer will know this, but perhaps the ones putting out videos on which charger to pick should do some research? As the number of EVSEs and home battery systems increase, the security of kit that can connect to the grid will become increasingly important, I think. I can see a point where manufacturers offering cloud management capabilities that manage hundreds of installations will need to sign up to a recognised standard such as the SEC or CE+. G99 sign-offs in future might involve sharing the manufacturer's cyber attestations.
Normally with these kinds of vids I assume extreme shilling but for some reason I think these guys have real integrity on top of their obvious knowledge.
I went with the Hypervolt 2 as it was the best there was at the time I had it fitted (2021). The Zappi was another option but I didn’t like the aesthetic of it. I understand the Hypervolt 3 is better with regards durability but the v2 is terrible. The white shell has went a yellow colour and the black holder for the charging cable has faded to gray. It’s all just very tired looking. Can’t fault the functionality. It’s just what was a pleasing looking unit when first fitted nos looks like an antique.
Good advice. I’m on MyEnergi for EV and immersion but selected Sigen for battery because it served 3 phase best. I now have Myenergy, Elios4you and now Sigen operating together - all behaves itself with Battery maintaining control around the zero point and achieving 98% self consumption.
I've also got a Zappi , I've been on to their help desk a few times with software upgrade issues .... So more trouble with this than the Ohme .. to be fair to the Zappi , since the last upgrade , about 2 years ago , it's been as good as gold ...
One thing you haven’t taken into consideration: usability if internet is down - or if company goes bump like Anderson’s did - you’ll end up with a dumb device. Only one of them will pass that test - Zappi
Can't fault my Hypervolt 2, had it almost 3 years now with no issues from the unit. Had a couple of issues with the app that were quickly remedied by the superb customer service they offer.
Have come across this after ordering a HV 3 Pro. There was an offer on a third party site that includes the five year warranty... hopefully the installation cam be arranged without fuss.
What is the minimum height, for an EV wall charger? I'm wondering where I might have mine located. Can you recommend a metal post ? I might use one of those instead of on the wall.
No love for Ohme? The only must have feature on an EV charger for me is reliable Intelligent Octopus Integration which the Ohme and Zappi have. I have read of problems with the Hypervolt, does anyone have experience with the Hypervolt and Intelligent Octopus? I have a Zappi and integrating that, my heat pump, battery storage, and Octopus Intelligent with home assistant saves a small fortune on electricity. Solar integration is not as important anymore as now you can get 15p per kWh on export it's better to send your solar to the grid and charge off peak.
Where is one from the manufacturer who had invented it , the term WALLBOX? The manufacturer WALLBOX is not in your list, the company who let others yours their brandname ? Ours do work quite well and perfectly as surplus charger in conjunction with the freeware called evcc.
Pod Point Pro or Ohme. The downside to the Ohme is they will definitely start charging for the 4G soon enough. Both are compatible with Intelligent from Octopus.
More than happy with our ohme pro, if it goes dumb, then fine, i'll just use the car (or will get someone to add a simple timer in the consumer unit) to set the timer.
Most chargers have a mobile data sim, as does your smart meter. There are no contractual conditions nor mechanisms in place for any manufacture to bill consumers for mobile data.
The vast majority of us are not given a choice, as its usually sorted out by the car dealer / Lease company / your electric company. I was given an ohme pro (£600 installed, albeit it by bill n ben - but is does have an extra 'PEN' consumer unit + charger its self - I think it was a special offer, as you cant even buy it for the price): It just works every time (and yes I live in a very poor smart meter area/mobile phone signal, but it seems to work on text/2G) - I'm not sure what else is required, I just plug in and it will charge at cheap rate (or via solar), as per my requirements (by again luck I have Octopus Intelligent Go, and will give me cheap rate as soon as I plug in - what ever the time) - this does seem a little dated?
You are under no obligation to buy an EV charge point from the car dealer / lease company / electric company. You can approach a local EV charge point Installer from which you will get much better service especially when it comes to charge point faults and subsequent warranty claims.
@@gadgetman36he probably refers to discounts or offers provided by manufacturers. BMW and Audi have at times offered free chargers with any car you order, even if it’s used
Can you still install EVSE on a TT island? That’s how my TWC gen 2 was installed several years ago. No need for PEN fault protection if it’s earthed to a cathode?
I'm hoping to get an EV charger installed soon and atm I plan to use the Ohme ePod charger (because I don't want a cable). What's your view on this charger?
Enjoyed the video. Interested in the pen fault protection advice - you mentioned older cabling, does that mean a new build potentially wouldn't have this issue?
Very rare I watch a long TH-cam like this in one go but found it so fascinating did this time. Only worry about the 'paid promotion' and hope it wasn't one of the charger companies which would spoil the comparison. I've had an Anderson 22kW since 1999 and it did worry me when they went into administration however I was told it would work without the app but (re one of the comments) perhaps that's wrong. Its never put a beat wrong over that five years and suerly thats what makes a good charger. What you dont want is any hassle with charging. A reliability chart would be good and perhaps a poll could be organised?
Hi Jordan. The whole electric car and charger is all new to me. Would you be able to do a video giving reasons why / why not choose a cheap charger for under £250 from Amazon. Aesthetics is not an issue for me due to the location of my house and where the charger will be installed.
Octopus recommend for us to work with a Hyundai Ioniq or Seat Mii to work with their tarrifs an Ohme is that the defining value the csr thst will be plugged in and the suppliers tariff?
I went for the Andersen a2 based on aesthetics, if it’s on the front of my house it’s got to look good. In 3 years it broken twice but the internal core replaced both times under warranty. If it brakes again out of warranty I won’t replace it
I have a PodPoint 7 kw charger. Charges my MG4 in less than 7 hours from 25%. This is the level, I make the decision to avoid getting caught out with an unexpected long journey.
Interested as to why you don't rate the Ohme charger here, eothyits Intelligent go support for a long time. Are there known issues with it reliability wise ?
Is there any regs still stopping people from installing a charger if they don’t have a driveway? I live out in the countryside with a parking space in front of a wall of the raised garden, would like to go electric but we are not allowed to put a driveway in.
Have you ever had an issue with Hypervolt 3pro? The PEN (according to Hypervolt) took a dislike to my supply which peaked at 252volts. It’s constantly hovering around the 250-251 Volts and only drops to around 247 at peak times and at those times the charger is happy. I think this is possibly to do with the substation being 100 metres away. My neighbour electrician tells me the NDO won’t reduce their output and he suggested a voltage optimiser to pull the voltage down to the charger. 🤷🏻♂️ Your thoughts are appreciated.
@@artisanelectrics Certainly not 'cheap junk'! As for 4G, that is an answer to a poor wifi signal that besets many chargers. Anderson is overpriced and no Ethernet connection, that is poor design, never mind how 'nice' it looks!
@@ianmenai The 4G signal sounds like a terrible idea. Instead of being able to talk to your charger on your home network, you need your wifi to be working on your phone, the Ohme server to be working and the 4G network they use to be working. If you connect with ethernet to your house connection, you only need your phone's WiFi to work and you can connect to the charger, even if the whole of the rest of the internet is down (unless the charger software is bad at this).
@@rjmunro Several things in your surmise are not correct. The 4G phone signal is incredibly reliable! How often, when stationary, have you dropped a call on a mobile? The answer is very, very really if ever! Next, your connection to the charger via Wifi is via the Ohme server, not direct, so you need a good internet connection, and that is no better than a 4G signal! So the 4G connects to the server and then comes back to you via the internet and then to your phone, not from the charger itself! As many have found out, the Wifi signal outside the house can be flakey at best, non existant at worst. 4G solves this, as outside the 4G signal is strong in most of the country. It chooses the strongest signal, a be it Vodafone, Three, EE or O2. So that trumps a Wifi signal trying to get out of the house! So no it isn't a terrible idea, it is actually a very GOOD idea, and proven to work reliably over many years!
@@artisanelectricshad one for a few years never let me down. I live in not great 4g area, I get one bar on my phone but the Ohme always connected and asks me to authorise the charging within seconds of connecting to the car. I tell it my highest kw per hour price from Octopus and it works within that. Only thing cheap about it is the cable holder.
I guess you've gone for the Anderson and Simpsons because you are an upmarket installer. We went for the Givenergy EVSE because it would go with our solar/battery inverter and all work from one app. Has @artisan got any thoughts on this one?
The biggest issue with my energy quality I find is that every single zappi is different. The colour of connector blocks is always blue or green. Colour of lid washers are black or white and different. Now that sounds daft but it basically tells me they’re not using the same suppliers/it’s what ever is available and not streamlining the product. Love the charger but questionable on quality control!
I really enjoyed the comparison of the different EV charge points which you did very well. The Tesla wall box is as ugly as sin and lacks safety features which all the other EV charge points have. I wouldn’t have included it here.
Great video Jordan informative as ever! Its left me thumping my head hard though! I don't have an EV charger yet, but am currently remodeling the house, the sparky who did all the CU and wiring said 6mm swa cable, if I wanted to do some of the footwork myself! About a year ago after looking about online, I got some Doncaster EV ultra but I think it only has 2 core screened data cable! Is it worth taking that out and putting in a EV ultra with cat5 capabilitiy? I did think about purchasing just cat5 swa cable and running it in conjunction with the other already in place... but that would mean having 2 glands in the EV charger itself! Do any of the "New" EV's have room for that? I hoped to see this in the video, some looked really tight, does anyone have any thoughts on this... ?? Jordan is that even possible/ allowable? At the moment apart from the expense no harm done, but before the walls are plastered etc I'd really appreciate some thoughts/ guidance!
My Zappi's been on Octopus Intelligent for almost a year and I waited for it to be officially supported (was supported as Alpha before that). Octopus list the main chargers that work with them.
They also recently added car support so they can control the charging via the car instead of the charger. Means you can have a compatible car but not compatible charger and still use intelligent go. And vice versa
It's a really good simple to work and easy to fit charger. It has the same features as the ones Jordan talked about but will work with intelligent and OVO no problem
Had one for 3 months now. Been reliable, easy to use, and app is very good. I use the app to set charging schedules for Octopus Intelligent Go, which gives you at least 6 hours every night for 7p/kwh. You also get as many additional hours as you need to fully charge your car if you need to.
S&P did work with Octopus Agile but they buggered that up in April and haven't fixed it yet (despite a load of emails from me asking them to do so). Picks the wrong slots. Maybe you can ask David about that. Reinforces what you said about poor tech support.
This must have been recorded some time ago as Myenergi has been working with Octopus “intelligent Go” for at least the last year. On the question of my install I had the first Zappi mk1 that became faulty and was replaced in warranty for the Zappi 2 it was also faulty as the connection terminals wouldn’t tighten up on the cable so a second Zappi 2 was sent out and now that Zappi 2 which is just over 3 years old is faulty! Thankfully I paid for the extended warranty and am now waiting for it to be replaced. Not a very good customer history! Hopefully fourth time lucky. Would I buy the Zappi again? Yes as it integrates with the rest of my system of solar and batteries so well, but I would definitely buy the extended warranty. My real concern is if the company were to go into liquidation.
The free (crap) BP smart charger I got with an EV purchase a few years ago has stopped being smart so I just use the car to control when I charge - which is always overnight on Octopus GO at 8.5p. I know exactly when the charge will happen and what state of charge I will have in the morning. Any spare solar then gets exported at 8p so the price I actually pay for being lazy is 0.5p / kWh. It would take many years for any fancy solar diverter kit to pay back. Of course this all depends on Octopus tariffs
Simpsons and partners is managed locally. No dependency on a remote server / cloud service so no subscription to pay down the line and no loss if anything happens to the company
Anything is better than the Tesla wall box. It's so ugly especially with the cable around it and it has no pen fault protection which makes for a costly installation as another box needs to be installed somewhere on your property.
Depends on whether you want to charge on cheap rate or not. Also is hybrid gonna be with you for a long time or is it a stop gap until you get a proper EV?
@@artisanelectricsthanks for the reply. There doesn't seem much info on TH-cam re charging hybrids. Just bought the car preferred a hybrid as we tow a caravan and do plenty of local driving car has 30 miles electric range. I use a 3 pin charger and have a electricity tariff with an off peak rate (00:00 to 5:00) at 10p per kwh discount from standard rate (so approx 12p per kwh) , smart meter sends half hourly readings. The car is fully charged in 6 hours at 10 amps. As a bonus all electricity is at cheap rate 00:00 to 5:00 so run dishwasher during that time. Appreciate with a 7kwh charger and a full ev tariff might be 6p per kwh cheaper, but that is only 80p per charge (13.5 kwh battery) so even if charged every day a saving of £250 per year compared to £1000 for a charger & instalation.
You don’t mention security of licking out the device to someone just hooking up to your charge when you are at work. Also what about at rest consumption?
@@EverydayLife621 I plugged in last night and got cheap rate from 8.20 and car fully charged by 3 this morning so never found Car always charged by 8 in morning. I find it a great tarrif
I bought the Simpson and Partners on the strength that it would work with octopus intelligent. It doesn’t. They argued that it would do and it plainly doesn’t. My car supposedly does support octopus, but it’s so flaky I went back to using Go and wasted a ton of money. Not impressed.
Having fitted numerous charge points over the years, after care service is a big factor in choosing a chargepoint. Andersen is non existent and went into administration earlier in the year. All looks but build quality hasn't lasted the 3 year warranty and the new team won't fix anything. Support has been awful. Functionality, tariffs and support has been better from the Myenergi team over the past few years.
No people want an intelligent charger that can read the cars state of charge and deliver the correct amount charge to the car at the cheapest cost which means communicating with your energy supplier. No one wants to plug in a car and overpay when it can be charged intelligently.
Don’t forget you don’t actually need an EVSE unless you do a lot of miles. A ‘granny lead’ type charger at 2kW plugged in for ten hours overnight for example will give you 20 kWh which should be good for at least 100 miles (YMMV).
@@artisanelectrics Are there special sockets available that can deliver 10 amps for long periods? Recall that EU sockets are rated at nominal 16 amps so presumably a bit tougher than 13 amp UK ones? Have you experience of them?
Tell that to any electrician and they will disagree heavily, unless you know for sure that your circuit that your socket is on is totally sound and the socket fronts are of decent quality, i would be very wary long term using one, most sockets are not designed to withstand continuous use of 10A or more, you can get specialist sockets for ev and that would be more suitable for that use as they are built to a higher standard
What happened with "Going back to basics?" You said this a few months ago in a video, that you were going back to basics. In that video, you said about getting back on the tools, etc... what happened? However, videos like this, 51 minutes with no meat on the bone except for 1 minute where you recommend Hypervolt, are not going to work IMO. Many of us subscribed for the actual electrical work, such as EICR, fault finding, new circuits, even a basic socket replacement. Not for solar PV or EV chargers. You need to do what you said you were going to do, and go back to basics. You need to get back on the tools, back to being an electrician, and not a suit. Your older videos were excellent, but these are just dull.
Difficult to be on the tools when he now lives in France and remote manages the business, except for a few days a month iirc. I don't mind these type of videos, but i guess if what you originally sub'd for was domestic installs & problem fixing then i can see why you're disappointed in the direction the channel has gone.
Thanks for your feedback. The opportunities to film in depth electrical content are fewer than they used to be now that I am running a company and not just a one man band. I must admit I am a bit rusty on the tools now as well! Its a constant battle because I love being on the tools but I have to put the company first and "you can't steer the ship while stoking the boilers" as they say... Maybe we can persuade Lee, Luke & Reuben to get back in front of the camera and do more videos for you guys! 80% of our work is Solar PV & EV Chargers now though so you may have to buckle up for more renewables content... its the future! Also 70% of our subscribers are new and have subscribed for the renewables and EV content so I can't please everyone (they might find an EICR or in depth electrical content boring...) Right now, my motto is to put out content that I think our audience will find valuable and let the algorithm work its magic and put it in front of people who want to see that kind of content. I do have an archive of all the footage from when I was working on my own back in 2019-2021 if you would be interested in a "from our archives" series! We could do a re-edit of the "Scout Hut" series for example. Just a thought. Let me know what you would like to see the most.
One thing you forgot to consider is how much power the charger wastes when not charging. I have Hypervolt 2 for last 4months as 3 wasnt around. It burns 100watts with lights off and 200wstts with them on. Which is between 2.4kw and 4.8kw a day which in my case doubles my houses daily consumption. So I have to switch the charger when not charging to avoid waste full energy loss. I was lead to believe generally when off most chargers burn may be 10,watts or so like a TV but mine is really wasteful. I checked and my charger is working how hypervolt say it should 😵💫
Ugh! thats horrendous, not that it helps you but according to Hypervolt for the V3: The Hypervolt Home 3 Pro EV Charger has an average standby power consumption of 4.2 watts when set to the lowest LED brightness setting. When the LED brightness of the Hypervolt Home 3 Pro EV Charger is set to its peak it consumes 8.4 watts Maximum LED Brightness Power: 8.4W Other Standby Functions: These typically include maintaining network connectivity, internal diagnostics, and status displays. Given that LED brightness accounts for 8.4W of power, and assuming additional standby functions draw approximately 1-2W, the total standby consumption can be estimated to average around 9.4 to 10.4 watts. To summarise: Lowest LED setting 4.2W Full LED Brightness: 8.4W Additional Standby Functions: 1-2W Total Average Standby Consumption: 9.4-10.4W
In terms of future proofing, because the Zappi uses your home router, not a sim, if the mobile signal dies or 4g becomes obsolete (which it will at some point as has 3g), you still have a functioning car charger. You also have a touch screen display to control it with if your phone dies.
The Zappi doesn't have a touch screen, it has physical buttons. It's like using a 1990s mobile phone, and it's startup sound is from the same era. Like Jordan said it's technology is behind the other charge points bar the Tesla.
When too many hands go into the jar, people end up paying too much for very little benefit. Why we need so many things to make ev work, is the reason ev has not taken off like the internet browser and the internet.
@@artisanelectrics Yes, really! Look it up in Google, In Modern Greek, where Greek has had several consonant shifts, it has further become Vee-ta. American scholars adhered to Classical, while British adhered to Koine (Biblical). Hence, US-> Bay-ta, UK-> Bee-ta. Bee-tuh this is Britain not the USA!
None of the chargers you listed appear to be future compatible with Vehicle to Grid or Vehicle To Home which will become a major feature from 2025 when EV manufacturers will start to mass produce cars that allows bidirectional charging e.g so cars can power your home or grid too. There is already a charger that has that feature that is recommended by Octopus to be used with their Power Pack tariff called the Wallbox Quasar 1 V2G charger but surely other major charger manufacturers should have incorporated bidirectional charging by now.
Vehicle To Home would be nice to have that feature, Several times i looses the power maybe 7 times in one day when the line into the house is disconnectted from the grid because stormy weather or fault on the power line (and they work on fixing the problem testing differt things. its very annoying
Need a quote for an EV charger? Get a tailored quote here: evchargers.artisanrenewables.co.uk/?
Hi Jordan - I’ve been told that I have TWO hot/live wires coming in to my home from the DNO … could you please advise as to what someone would be capable of loading to this “single phase“ line (s) ? [ looking to do some preparation for an EV and mass solar + battery installation - perhaps you could quote perhaps too 🤔🤷♂️ - in due course ] - Thanks In Advance. Aled - PS: keep up the fantastic work and the electrifying⚡️ content 👌
Hiya just about to get a Tesla and already switched to octopus. What charger do I need to get on the intelligent tariff ?
Also my drive is around the back of my house so do I need wifi for a charger ?
Zappi has worked with octopus intelligent go for ages!
@@EverydayLife621 I just plug it in and let it do it's thing. It will charge outside of the normal hours (at the cheap rate) if it feels like it. I actually have two zappis, the 2nd isn't controlled by octopus and we never have issues with the 2nd car charging.
But without a compatible charger I wouldn't be able to be on intelligent go, and the tarrifs are not as good then.
I think we all do - I dont see what the challenge is? - we all just charge off peak at home, however we do this?
@EverydayLife621 not sure what you're getting at. I needed a compatible charger (which zappi is) in order to be able to access intelligent go, which means my overnight charging is 7p/kwh rather than 8.5p/kwh and lasts 6h rather than 5.
I don't really care about the "intelligent" aspect, but without a compatible charger I would he paying more.
Probably the best way of getting onto Intelligent Octopus Go. Works much better than any EV integration and probably the best of the charge point integrations.
@@EverydayLife621 The point of Intelligent Octopus Go is that Octopus control when your car charges (rather than being just a fixed cheap period like most other EV tariffs). In order to do that they need to be able to control either the EV or the charge point. That's how they give the very cheap price - you can get well over 6 hours of cheap rate per day.
Zappi customer.... unit failed for a known MCB issue within a week of installation and that was frustrating, felt like they were shipping out units that "might" fail and dealing with those that did rather than fixing them all upfront. But I always say it's how a company reacts that matters. Part was on site within 24 hours and the original installer was given the funding approval to get in and fix it next day. 48 hours later all done and running again and it hasn't skipped a beat in the last 14 months. Overall I'm happy with it and the solar integration has saved me so much money. Late April to September I have paid ZERO for recharge on My Tesla M3P with everything coming from the excess solar.
I have the Simpson and Partner for two reasons only. It looks amazing and just as important, it does not need a mobile signal (I do not get a cell signal at my house).
Only Bluetooth and WiFi are used so I can monitor it from the house.
I had to discount many other chargers because they stated that they require a mobile signal to supply operating information.
Owning a Zappi has been brilliant for me. It works so well with my solar panels and batteries, charging the car instead of exporting, yet still allowing me to charge the car when I want to. Their service has been brilliant throughout - I had an issue with the front screen after 4 years of use, (Mark 1 version), and then sent me (free) a complete replacement front. If you have solar generation, I would definitely recommend this charger.
Love our zappi do much we installed a second one for our second ev. Love that they talk to each other.
An essential criteria for me was the charger had to be compatible with Octopus Intelligent Go. One of the reason I chose a Ohme Pro charger, which has been fine so far. Easy to use, good app, decent support, and reliable. I was put off the Zappi by my next door neighbour's experience. He has had two units totally fail in 12 months. Both replaced swiftly by MyEnergi I must add.
The thing that frustrates me no end is that I have, sat on my drive, a 77kWh battery, most of which gets used only for local trips up to 120 miles, and every few months a longer trip up to 500 miles (on a single charge.. yes!) but I still cannot get a charger in the UK that works to permit vehicle to home or vehicle to grid which with solar PV or off peak charging would just make so much sense. How long before these hit the walls of our houses?
I've been thinking that an Ioniq 5 battery would be good for home electricity storage. Interfacing it with other systems is the trick of course, as you say.
I see your point but because of the cost of the car I would personally not degrade the battery by doing that. Different f its a leased EV that you dont care about.
@gusnilsson6928 or if you have no space and also have to find room for a boiler replacement heat pump system!
@@gusnilsson6928 how does it degrade the battery?
Completely agree with your point regards MyEnergi Zappi quality - mine failed just outside of warranty - I'm left with useless plastic brick on the wall, hence watching of this video researching for a replacement. Thanks for the video.
One of the main areas that is not addressed by this video is the support for OCPP protocol integration and the ability to communicate to secondary systems by Wifi or Ethernet. This is now becoming more important to allow integration of a EV car charger into household systems eg Home Assistant
Very true, I believe Zappi has OCPP now, Easee has had it for ages, I am not sure about the others.
Does OCPP support mean that the charger doesn't need to access the manufacturer's server? I think depending on an internet connection to the manufacturer is a big problem if companies go bankrupt, or have outages or cyber-attacks. The apps should be able to talk directly to the devices over the local network, not use the cloud.
Good vid mate ! I am a one man band installer about 30 mins south of Cambridge. Installed all but the Simpson & Partners model ! Agree, all have their own idiosyncratic issues or advantages ! Like that you pointed out that it really is horses for courses out there in the real world. I do all surveys on site so I know what I am dealing with !
I as a consumer have an Tesla Wallconnector Gen 2. Got it installed by an certified electrician, and it works great. Have it for almost 4 years and still looks great and works on 3 phase (11kW). It’s not a smart charger, but I always control it trough the app of with the car, which works fine for my use case. But it would be nice to have some more control.
I had a Zappi installed with a non functioning screen. It was fixed under warranty (Jan 2024), but not a good start. No problems since. There was instructions about not installing in direct sunlight (UV damage to plastic body, I assume). The unit does get the sun later in the day, so I cover it with a rucksack waterproof cover when not using it during the day.
Setup the myenergi zappy with intelligent octopus go yesterday...so they are compatible.
Yep they added API support for it not so long ago.....Zappi is best allrounder imo, also well established so not likely to suddenly go bust and leave customers in the lurch.
Octopus now support the cars directly, so you can use intelligent go if you have a compatible charger and/or a compatible EV.
Which means you can use intelligent go with Tesla wallbox + model 3 because the model 3 is supported by octopus even if the wallbox is not.
@@iambenmitchellNot all cars and I've heard people say that they're not adding support for any more cars. Some of the vehicle manufacturers don't like third parties controlling their cars.
If you have a Zappi or Ohme you can charge any car with IO.
It makes much more sense to control chargers rather than cars. That way octopus get more coverage for less effort.
@@EverydayLife621 the Zappi charger is also so big and ugly in my opinion. Looks like it’s from 2013 for a Nissan leaf lol
@@rugbygirlsdadg Yeah I know that. I wouldn't consider a car that didn't have an API anyway. Being that proprietary in 2024 is ridiculous, it's always the old fashioned legacy brands too that refuse to modernise.
Easee have an open API too, but octopus don't yet support them, however, octopus do support Tesla cars so I'm going to go with Easee because they're designed and made in Scandinavia and built very well. Plus I suspect they'll be added to octopus natively soon too.
Myenergi products all look so old and outdated. It suits the 2013 Nissan leaf but looks out of place for other cars, unnecessarily large
Reversing into a charger was not something I thought about and now I can't stop thinking about it 🤣
What about the security aspects? Can you lock the chargers so other people can’t use them? How good are the cyber-security capabilities of the manufacturers? Will you have an inoperable charger if the manufacturer is attacked?
An installer isn't going to know all the vulnerabilities of each product. If they did, they'd probably be manufacturing their own units. You can't expect an installer to know this.
@@mattblackledge9068 This is a video advising on which units to buy, and I personally think that the security features of the units would be an interesting thing to comment on. On the cyber-resiliency of the manufacturer's maybe not every installer will know this, but perhaps the ones putting out videos on which charger to pick should do some research? As the number of EVSEs and home battery systems increase, the security of kit that can connect to the grid will become increasingly important, I think. I can see a point where manufacturers offering cloud management capabilities that manage hundreds of installations will need to sign up to a recognised standard such as the SEC or CE+. G99 sign-offs in future might involve sharing the manufacturer's cyber attestations.
I have an Ohme Pro charger, which can be locked via the app. There's also a feature to approve each charge with your finger print.
Great that is the one I am having the hypervolt 3 pro. Would you install ?
Normally with these kinds of vids I assume extreme shilling but for some reason I think these guys have real integrity on top of their obvious knowledge.
How good is the Easee One charger? My understanding is that it is reliable and less prune to a fault.
I am getting one on the 10th October.
Does Artisan install in the north west (Manchester) area
I went with the Hypervolt 2 as it was the best there was at the time I had it fitted (2021). The Zappi was another option but I didn’t like the aesthetic of it.
I understand the Hypervolt 3 is better with regards durability but the v2 is terrible. The white shell has went a yellow colour and the black holder for the charging cable has faded to gray. It’s all just very tired looking.
Can’t fault the functionality. It’s just what was a pleasing looking unit when first fitted nos looks like an antique.
Have you installed the Sigen AC charger yet? Thoughts on that if you have the Sigen PV inverter and battery.
Not yet but we have one coming up soon, I would say its probably a no brainer to keep everything within the same ecosystem
Good advice. I’m on MyEnergi for EV and immersion but selected Sigen for battery because it served 3 phase best. I now have Myenergy, Elios4you and now Sigen operating together - all behaves itself with Battery maintaining control around the zero point and achieving 98% self consumption.
Tip: Peblar Rock Solid Charger by ProDrive technologies.
These guys are growing fast now, device is A quality but cheap as well.
What about the ohme charger I've got it with mobility what are your thoughts?
I'm still waiting for a response
I've had an Ohme Home Pro for just over a year , works pretty flawlessly with Octopus Intelligent...
Good charger , no issues ...
I've also got a Zappi , I've been on to their help desk a few times with software upgrade issues .... So more trouble with this than the Ohme .. to be fair to the Zappi , since the last upgrade , about 2 years ago , it's been as good as gold ...
Thanks for this information. 😊
Great video just what I was looking for as my car arrives next week hyper volt it is
Glad I could help
One thing you haven’t taken into consideration: usability if internet is down - or if company goes bump like Anderson’s did - you’ll end up with a dumb device.
Only one of them will pass that test - Zappi
My BP one never was smart, so I added a simple relay to control it - it’s a smart charger now.
@@JohnR31415 can you change the settings, ie make it use your solar panels only to charge your car? 👀
You could say that about loads of household kit, and the risks are equal across all brands.
The S&P doesn't need Internet. Can work solely off bluetooth
Can't fault my Hypervolt 2, had it almost 3 years now with no issues from the unit. Had a couple of issues with the app that were quickly remedied by the superb customer service they offer.
Have come across this after ordering a HV 3 Pro. There was an offer on a third party site that includes the five year warranty... hopefully the installation cam be arranged without fuss.
What is the minimum height, for an EV wall charger?
I'm wondering where I might have mine located.
Can you recommend a metal post ? I might use one of those instead of on the wall.
if i dont have solar i can still use zappi just no need for clamps right?
If you are a customer looking for an EV charger then make sure to get a quote from us: app.openquote.net/company/artisanelectrics 😎
Looking for one but I’m up north
We have a network of installers all across the country who work to our high standards so feel free to put in a request
No love for Ohme?
The only must have feature on an EV charger for me is reliable Intelligent Octopus Integration which the Ohme and Zappi have. I have read of problems with the Hypervolt, does anyone have experience with the Hypervolt and Intelligent Octopus?
I have a Zappi and integrating that, my heat pump, battery storage, and Octopus Intelligent with home assistant saves a small fortune on electricity.
Solar integration is not as important anymore as now you can get 15p per kWh on export it's better to send your solar to the grid and charge off peak.
Where is one from the manufacturer who had invented it , the term WALLBOX?
The manufacturer WALLBOX is not in your list, the company who let others yours their brandname ?
Ours do work quite well and perfectly as surplus charger in conjunction with the freeware called evcc.
@@typxxilps Did not know about evcc, thanks for the tip.
Hi, DNO asking for Single line diagram (showing the location of the emergency isolation switch what do they actually want have you got an example?
Would you do an install quote in East London, Redbridge?
Btw your channel is excellent and a real differentiator .
I appreciate that!
Pod Point Pro or Ohme. The downside to the Ohme is they will definitely start charging for the 4G soon enough. Both are compatible with Intelligent from Octopus.
Never fitted the PodPoint Pro - whats it like to install?
More than happy with our ohme pro, if it goes dumb, then fine, i'll just use the car (or will get someone to add a simple timer in the consumer unit) to set the timer.
Ohme pro has been faultless for me so quite happy to stay with it
Most chargers have a mobile data sim, as does your smart meter. There are no contractual conditions nor mechanisms in place for any manufacture to bill consumers for mobile data.
The vast majority of us are not given a choice, as its usually sorted out by the car dealer / Lease company / your electric company. I was given an ohme pro (£600 installed, albeit it by bill n ben - but is does have an extra 'PEN' consumer unit + charger its self - I think it was a special offer, as you cant even buy it for the price): It just works every time (and yes I live in a very poor smart meter area/mobile phone signal, but it seems to work on text/2G) - I'm not sure what else is required, I just plug in and it will charge at cheap rate (or via solar), as per my requirements (by again luck I have Octopus Intelligent Go, and will give me cheap rate as soon as I plug in - what ever the time) - this does seem a little dated?
You are under no obligation to buy an EV charge point from the car dealer / lease company / electric company. You can approach a local EV charge point Installer from which you will get much better service especially when it comes to charge point faults and subsequent warranty claims.
@@gadgetman36he probably refers to discounts or offers provided by manufacturers. BMW and Audi have at times offered free chargers with any car you order, even if it’s used
Hypervolt all the way ⚡
We agree
@@artisanelectrics Can you turn the LED lights off?
Can you comment on any short circuits inside any of these units?
Can you still install EVSE on a TT island? That’s how my TWC gen 2 was installed several years ago. No need for PEN fault protection if it’s earthed to a cathode?
My zappi (Gen 1) died after 3.5 years, the PCB was fried!
But the myenergi offered be a refurb Gen 2 for £200.. i was happy with that 😊
Does hypervolt integrate with the British gas tariff
I'm hoping to get an EV charger installed soon and atm I plan to use the Ohme ePod charger (because I don't want a cable). What's your view on this charger?
I won't waffle...... love this
Enjoyed the video. Interested in the pen fault protection advice - you mentioned older cabling, does that mean a new build potentially wouldn't have this issue?
No. All EV charge point installations require a pen fault protection device, whether it's built into the charge point or it's a separate unit.
It depends on earthing arrangements, a tt system does not require any pen fault for example
Should do some feedback on the Sigenergy DC EV charger. Game changer.
Very useful. I will look forward to the sigenergy review ... I have high hopes
Very rare I watch a long TH-cam like this in one go but found it so fascinating did this time. Only worry about the 'paid promotion' and hope it wasn't one of the charger companies which would spoil the comparison. I've had an Anderson 22kW since 1999 and it did worry me when they went into administration however I was told it would work without the app but (re one of the comments) perhaps that's wrong. Its never put a beat wrong over that five years and suerly thats what makes a good charger. What you dont want is any hassle with charging.
A reliability chart would be good and perhaps a poll could be organised?
Hi Jordan. The whole electric car and charger is all new to me. Would you be able to do a video giving reasons why / why not choose a cheap charger for under £250 from Amazon. Aesthetics is not an issue for me due to the location of my house and where the charger will be installed.
Octopus recommend for us to work with a Hyundai Ioniq or Seat Mii to work with their tarrifs an Ohme is that the defining value the csr thst will be plugged in and the suppliers tariff?
I went for the Andersen a2 based on aesthetics, if it’s on the front of my house it’s got to look good. In 3 years it broken twice but the internal core replaced both times under warranty. If it brakes again out of warranty I won’t replace it
I have a PodPoint 7 kw charger. Charges my MG4 in less than 7 hours from 25%. This is the level, I make the decision to avoid getting caught out with an unexpected long journey.
Interested as to why you don't rate the Ohme charger here, eothyits Intelligent go support for a long time.
Are there known issues with it reliability wise ?
Is there any regs still stopping people from installing a charger if they don’t have a driveway?
I live out in the countryside with a parking space in front of a wall of the raised garden, would like to go electric but we are not allowed to put a driveway in.
Have you ever had an issue with Hypervolt 3pro? The PEN (according to Hypervolt) took a dislike to my supply which peaked at 252volts. It’s constantly hovering around the 250-251 Volts and only drops to around 247 at peak times and at those times the charger is happy. I think this is possibly to do with the substation being 100 metres away. My neighbour electrician tells me the NDO won’t reduce their output and he suggested a voltage optimiser to pull the voltage down to the charger. 🤷🏻♂️
Your thoughts are appreciated.
Thanks Pro en regards from Holland ,And missing the great Wall box charger thats runs one sunpanels
Great video ! Thankyou
Glad you liked it!
Why no Ohme? Quality is OK, and it is integrated with Octopus which is very important.
Cheap junk and 4G sim not ideal
@@artisanelectrics Certainly not 'cheap junk'! As for 4G, that is an answer to a poor wifi signal that besets many chargers. Anderson is overpriced and no Ethernet connection, that is poor design, never mind how 'nice' it looks!
@@ianmenai The 4G signal sounds like a terrible idea. Instead of being able to talk to your charger on your home network, you need your wifi to be working on your phone, the Ohme server to be working and the 4G network they use to be working. If you connect with ethernet to your house connection, you only need your phone's WiFi to work and you can connect to the charger, even if the whole of the rest of the internet is down (unless the charger software is bad at this).
@@rjmunro Several things in your surmise are not correct. The 4G phone signal is incredibly reliable! How often, when stationary, have you dropped a call on a mobile? The answer is very, very really if ever! Next, your connection to the charger via Wifi is via the Ohme server, not direct, so you need a good internet connection, and that is no better than a 4G signal! So the 4G connects to the server and then comes back to you via the internet and then to your phone, not from the charger itself! As many have found out, the Wifi signal outside the house can be flakey at best, non existant at worst. 4G solves this, as outside the 4G signal is strong in most of the country. It chooses the strongest signal, a be it Vodafone, Three, EE or O2. So that trumps a Wifi signal trying to get out of the house! So no it isn't a terrible idea, it is actually a very GOOD idea, and proven to work reliably over many years!
@@artisanelectricshad one for a few years never let me down. I live in not great 4g area, I get one bar on my phone but the Ohme always connected and asks me to authorise the charging within seconds of connecting to the car. I tell it my highest kw per hour price from Octopus and it works within that.
Only thing cheap about it is the cable holder.
Andersen A2 for me
I guess you've gone for the Anderson and Simpsons because you are an upmarket installer.
We went for the Givenergy EVSE because it would go with our solar/battery inverter and all work from one app. Has @artisan got any thoughts on this one?
The biggest issue with my energy quality I find is that every single zappi is different. The colour of connector blocks is always blue or green. Colour of lid washers are black or white and different. Now that sounds daft but it basically tells me they’re not using the same suppliers/it’s what ever is available and not streamlining the product. Love the charger but questionable on quality control!
did i miss the price for the hypervolt
I really enjoyed the comparison of the different EV charge points which you did very well. The Tesla wall box is as ugly as sin and lacks safety features which all the other EV charge points have. I wouldn’t have included it here.
Thanks for watching!
So these are all uk brands?
Great video Jordan informative as ever! Its left me thumping my head hard though! I don't have an EV charger yet, but am currently remodeling the house, the sparky who did all the CU and wiring said 6mm swa cable, if I wanted to do some of the footwork myself! About a year ago after looking about online, I got some Doncaster EV ultra but I think it only has 2 core screened data cable! Is it worth taking that out and putting in a EV ultra with cat5 capabilitiy? I did think about purchasing just cat5 swa cable and running it in conjunction with the other already in place... but that would mean having 2 glands in the EV charger itself! Do any of the "New" EV's have room for that? I hoped to see this in the video, some looked really tight, does anyone have any thoughts on this... ?? Jordan is that even possible/ allowable? At the moment apart from the expense no harm done, but before the walls are plastered etc I'd really appreciate some thoughts/ guidance!
It all depends on what charger. Hypervolt works with the EV ultra data for normal CT but not sure on the solar integration yet.
@@jacktissington thanks Jack 👍
My Zappi's been on Octopus Intelligent for almost a year and I waited for it to be officially supported (was supported as Alpha before that).
Octopus list the main chargers that work with them.
They also recently added car support so they can control the charging via the car instead of the charger.
Means you can have a compatible car but not compatible charger and still use intelligent go. And vice versa
@@iambenmitchellsee my previous comment regarding octopus integration of cars.
The Konnect app has been replaced. Its quite sexy and modern now.
What are your thoughts on the ohme home pro?
It's a really good simple to work and easy to fit charger. It has the same features as the ones Jordan talked about but will work with intelligent and OVO no problem
Had one for 3 months now. Been reliable, easy to use, and app is very good. I use the app to set charging schedules for Octopus Intelligent Go, which gives you at least 6 hours every night for 7p/kwh. You also get as many additional hours as you need to fully charge your car if you need to.
Hoping you actually decide to help out Tom! Would be amazing to see you go over and help him with his project!
Haha lets see if he gets in touch!
S&P did work with Octopus Agile but they buggered that up in April and haven't fixed it yet (despite a load of emails from me asking them to do so). Picks the wrong slots. Maybe you can ask David about that. Reinforces what you said about poor tech support.
This must have been recorded some time ago as Myenergi has been working with Octopus “intelligent Go” for at least the last year. On the question of my install I had the first Zappi mk1 that became faulty and was replaced in warranty for the Zappi 2 it was also faulty as the connection terminals wouldn’t tighten up on the cable so a second Zappi 2 was sent out and now that Zappi 2 which is just over 3 years old is faulty! Thankfully I paid for the extended warranty and am now waiting for it to be replaced. Not a very good customer history! Hopefully fourth time lucky. Would I buy the Zappi again? Yes as it integrates with the rest of my system of solar and batteries so well, but I would definitely buy the extended warranty. My real concern is if the company were to go into liquidation.
Any thoughts on the sigenergy 25kw dc charger?
Not fitted one yet but coming soon
The free (crap) BP smart charger I got with an EV purchase a few years ago has stopped being smart so I just use the car to control when I charge - which is always overnight on Octopus GO at 8.5p. I know exactly when the charge will happen and what state of charge I will have in the morning. Any spare solar then gets exported at 8p so the price I actually pay for being lazy is 0.5p / kWh.
It would take many years for any fancy solar diverter kit to pay back. Of course this all depends on Octopus tariffs
Simpsons and partners is managed locally. No dependency on a remote server / cloud service so no subscription to pay down the line and no loss if anything happens to the company
I’m getting a model 3 soon and I’m deciding between Easee and Tesla Wallbox, I think Easee makes the most sense, thoughts?
Anything is better than the Tesla wall box. It's so ugly especially with the cable around it and it has no pen fault protection which makes for a costly installation as another box needs to be installed somewhere on your property.
@@gadgetman36 PEN fault isn't a problem for me, I'm already having an outdoor consumer unit installed next to my supply box outside.
I would go for the Tesla Wall Connector, I used both when I had my Model 3 and I preferred the ease of use with the TWC
What about V2H chargers ?
What about hybrids? Is worth the expense of getting an EV charger?
Depends on whether you want to charge on cheap rate or not. Also is hybrid gonna be with you for a long time or is it a stop gap until you get a proper EV?
@@artisanelectricsthanks for the reply. There doesn't seem much info on TH-cam re charging hybrids. Just bought the car preferred a hybrid as we tow a caravan and do plenty of local driving car has 30 miles electric range. I use a 3 pin charger and have a electricity tariff with an off peak rate (00:00 to 5:00) at 10p per kwh discount from standard rate (so approx 12p per kwh) , smart meter sends half hourly readings. The car is fully charged in 6 hours at 10 amps. As a bonus all electricity is at cheap rate 00:00 to 5:00 so run dishwasher during that time. Appreciate with a 7kwh charger and a full ev tariff might be 6p per kwh cheaper, but that is only 80p per charge (13.5 kwh battery) so even if charged every day a saving of £250 per year compared to £1000 for a charger & instalation.
Tesla Owners ? Are there any circumstance where you might recommend a Non Tesla charger to a Tesla Owner ? If so why?
You don’t mention security of licking out the device to someone just hooking up to your charge when you are at work.
Also what about at rest consumption?
Just about to have the zappi 2 installed by Octopus, becuase of the integration BUT perhaps I should have gone for your recommended one instead :(
No Easee charger??
Zappie has been working with octopus intelligence for ages
... but how often do you need the extra charge outside of offpeak hours?
@@EverydayLife621
I plugged in last night and got cheap rate from 8.20 and car fully charged by 3 this morning so never found
Car always charged by 8 in morning. I find it a great tarrif
I bought the Simpson and Partners on the strength that it would work with octopus intelligent. It doesn’t. They argued that it would do and it plainly doesn’t. My car supposedly does support octopus, but it’s so flaky I went back to using Go and wasted a ton of money.
Not impressed.
Having fitted numerous charge points over the years, after care service is a big factor in choosing a chargepoint. Andersen is non existent and went into administration earlier in the year. All looks but build quality hasn't lasted the 3 year warranty and the new team won't fix anything. Support has been awful. Functionality, tariffs and support has been better from the Myenergi team over the past few years.
Most people just want a cheap charger , with no gimmicks, just plug and charge
Exactly 🎉
No people want an intelligent charger that can read the cars state of charge and deliver the correct amount charge to the car at the cheapest cost which means communicating with your energy supplier. No one wants to plug in a car and overpay when it can be charged intelligently.
Don’t forget you don’t actually need an EVSE unless you do a lot of miles. A ‘granny lead’ type charger at 2kW plugged in for ten hours overnight for example will give you 20 kWh which should be good for at least 100 miles (YMMV).
But most overnight tariffs are for 5-6hrs so only half of the 10hrs at a cheaper rate.
@@cgcmitchell114Octopus intelligent gives you as many hours as you need
And you will likely burn out your socket charging a car off it regularly - they are only meant for occasional use those granny chargers
@@artisanelectrics Are there special sockets available that can deliver 10 amps for long periods? Recall that EU sockets are rated at nominal 16 amps so presumably a bit tougher than 13 amp UK ones? Have you experience of them?
Tell that to any electrician and they will disagree heavily, unless you know for sure that your circuit that your socket is on is totally sound and the socket fronts are of decent quality, i would be very wary long term using one, most sockets are not designed to withstand continuous use of 10A or more, you can get specialist sockets for ev and that would be more suitable for that use as they are built to a higher standard
Need to rename it to 5 random chargers - these are certainly not the best
What happened with "Going back to basics?" You said this a few months ago in a video, that you were going back to basics. In that video, you said about getting back on the tools, etc... what happened? However, videos like this, 51 minutes with no meat on the bone except for 1 minute where you recommend Hypervolt, are not going to work IMO. Many of us subscribed for the actual electrical work, such as EICR, fault finding, new circuits, even a basic socket replacement. Not for solar PV or EV chargers. You need to do what you said you were going to do, and go back to basics. You need to get back on the tools, back to being an electrician, and not a suit. Your older videos were excellent, but these are just dull.
Difficult to be on the tools when he now lives in France and remote manages the business, except for a few days a month iirc.
I don't mind these type of videos, but i guess if what you originally sub'd for was domestic installs & problem fixing then i can see why you're disappointed in the direction the channel has gone.
I have to agree, as a long subscriber this is not what I signed up for. I’m hanging on for hope of the content.
How’s he going to be on the tools when he’s in France you clearly have thought this through when you written this comment
Thanks for your feedback. The opportunities to film in depth electrical content are fewer than they used to be now that I am running a company and not just a one man band. I must admit I am a bit rusty on the tools now as well! Its a constant battle because I love being on the tools but I have to put the company first and "you can't steer the ship while stoking the boilers" as they say... Maybe we can persuade Lee, Luke & Reuben to get back in front of the camera and do more videos for you guys! 80% of our work is Solar PV & EV Chargers now though so you may have to buckle up for more renewables content... its the future! Also 70% of our subscribers are new and have subscribed for the renewables and EV content so I can't please everyone (they might find an EICR or in depth electrical content boring...)
Right now, my motto is to put out content that I think our audience will find valuable and let the algorithm work its magic and put it in front of people who want to see that kind of content.
I do have an archive of all the footage from when I was working on my own back in 2019-2021 if you would be interested in a "from our archives" series! We could do a re-edit of the "Scout Hut" series for example. Just a thought. Let me know what you would like to see the most.
@@artisanelectricsAs a long term subscriber from day one I like all of your content Jordan.
I’ve ordered everything GivEnergy. Inverter, Battery and EV charger. I hope it all goes to plan next week.
i rate GivEnergy tbf, the customer support team is fab.
One thing you forgot to consider is how much power the charger wastes when not charging. I have Hypervolt 2 for last 4months as 3 wasnt around. It burns 100watts with lights off and 200wstts with them on. Which is between 2.4kw and 4.8kw a day which in my case doubles my houses daily consumption. So I have to switch the charger when not charging to avoid waste full energy loss. I was lead to believe generally when off most chargers burn may be 10,watts or so like a TV but mine is really wasteful. I checked and my charger is working how hypervolt say it should 😵💫
I have a HV2 as well and it only burns around 8w in standby with leds at 25%. Something is wrong at your end!
Ugh! thats horrendous, not that it helps you but according to Hypervolt for the V3: The Hypervolt Home 3 Pro EV Charger has an average standby power consumption of 4.2 watts when set to the lowest LED brightness setting. When the LED brightness of the Hypervolt Home 3 Pro EV Charger is set to its peak it consumes 8.4 watts
Maximum LED Brightness Power: 8.4W
Other Standby Functions: These typically include maintaining network connectivity, internal diagnostics, and status displays.
Given that LED brightness accounts for 8.4W of power, and assuming additional standby functions draw approximately 1-2W, the total standby consumption can be estimated to average around 9.4 to 10.4 watts.
To summarise:
Lowest LED setting 4.2W
Full LED Brightness: 8.4W
Additional Standby Functions: 1-2W
Total Average Standby Consumption: 9.4-10.4W
How about ohme
In terms of future proofing, because the Zappi uses your home router, not a sim, if the mobile signal dies or 4g becomes obsolete (which it will at some point as has 3g), you still have a functioning car charger.
You also have a touch screen display to control it with if your phone dies.
As does the Simpson & Partners
The Zappi doesn't have a touch screen, it has physical buttons. It's like using a 1990s mobile phone, and it's startup sound is from the same era. Like Jordan said it's technology is behind the other charge points bar the Tesla.
If living in the top of France makes you look like that then stay there. You look great my friend you and your team nuff respect.
When too many hands go into the jar, people end up paying too much for very little benefit. Why we need so many things to make ev work, is the reason ev has not taken off like the internet browser and the internet.
No different to an ice car. The early ones had no petrol stations or garages to go too. We have to go backwards to go forwards sometimes.
Oh it is BETA pronounced beeta not better!
Really?! 🤯
@@artisanelectrics Yes, really! Look it up in Google, In Modern Greek, where Greek has had several consonant shifts, it has further become Vee-ta. American scholars adhered to Classical, while British adhered to Koine (Biblical). Hence, US-> Bay-ta, UK-> Bee-ta. Bee-tuh this is Britain not the USA!
Have you fitted those new amazing toilet chargers?
Why don’t you expand the business to France 👍
Ain’t you allowed to say Alexa on a TH-cam video now?😂
None of the chargers you listed appear to be future compatible with Vehicle to Grid or Vehicle To Home which will become a major feature from 2025 when EV manufacturers will start to mass produce cars that allows bidirectional charging e.g so cars can power your home or grid too. There is already a charger that has that feature that is recommended by Octopus to be used with their Power Pack tariff called the Wallbox Quasar 1 V2G charger but surely other major charger manufacturers should have incorporated bidirectional charging by now.
Vehicle To Home would be nice to have that feature, Several times i looses the power maybe 7 times in one day when the line into the house is disconnectted from the grid because stormy weather or fault on the power line (and they work on fixing the problem testing differt things. its very annoying
I'm still waiting for a response