I've spent countless hours ( maybe days ) listening to that version of the solo in the last 12 years! No version has come remotely close to this. This might as well be the best thing to happen to the solo since 1994!
Coming from a Gilmour enthusiast i must say this is spot on. The technique, The Bends, The right note at the right time and the guitar movement are also spot on. The sound was spectacular. Very, very well done my friend.
You have duplicated every part of this solo perfectly, The timing, every bit of vibrato, every bend, every pinched harmonic ! The sound is also identical and your stance and the way you hold the guitar and move with it to get the sound is flawless. I’ve seen many great guitarists and musician friends of mine do a very very good cover of this but I would have to say that your version is on a different level 👍 magnificent!!
This is the 1st cover iv heard of this that sounds exactly like david gilmour and iv heard many covers of this solo what a guitarist and what a sound brilliant take my hat off to you sir👏
Wow !!! That was by far the best version of that solo I have ever heard in my life. I Can’t stop aiir guitaring to the whole thing with headphones on !! Bravo Heres I’m sure Dave Gilmore would be very impressed.
This is an absolutely amazing cover of this masterpiece - the fidelity of your performance, everything from the sound to the way you hold the guitar is staggeringly Gilmourish! Most of all though you captured Gilmour's 'taking a Sunday drive' way of playing this despite it being one of the greatest solos all time. Well done sir, great tip of the cap to one of the best! 👏🏼 EDIT: Also it is criminal that this does not have at least a million views on here!!
This is an outstanding performance! By far The Best cover of the Pulse version ever made in the history of youtube! Thank you ! Im still waiting for that full Telegraph Road cover!
You are a true artist and this is THE BEST cover of this truly great guitar solo. I’ve listened to this awesome solo thousands of times since Pulse was released and I know it note for note….. you absolutely nailed it….. respect ✊
Escucho a Pink Floyd desde mis 6 o 7 años de edad. Esta parte de esta canción siempre me emocionó. Escucharte, es volver a vivir estas mismas sensaciones. En mi humilde opinión, el mejor solo de guitarra. Tu versión, a la altura de la impresionante interpretación de Gilmour. GRACIAS!
Hombre esto es sencillamente maravilloso, es cerrar los ojos y escuchar a David G, tienes un talento extraordinario, gracias por esta excelente versión.
It's literaly the best version of this solo (wich is for me the best solo ever). The best cover I could find on TH-cam. The work and the precision of the sound is just... WoW ! INCREDIBLE ! Good Job
First time on TH-cam i have same feelings like warching Pulse concert. Great, Great job! All notes are played properly but also sound of the guitar is perfect. Respect dude!
Salut Heres. En tant que fan de toujours de pink floyd. Plus particulièrement de gilmour et de sa manière de jouer avec sa fender je dois dire et reconnaître que tu es sa parfaite doublure avec une guitare dans les mains. C est tout simplement magnifique. Comme je t ai mis dans un autre commentaire en fermant les yeux on a l impression d écouter David. Merci pour eux et pour nous pour ces interprétations magistrales. 🙌👍🎸😉 Surtout ne change pas
Merci Heres Si c est la version qui dure 9 minutes oui je l ai regardée. C'est vraiment génial. ✌ Comme je te l ai dit je suis un fan inconditionnel des Floyd. J ai eu une période où je ne faisais que ça les écouter. Il a fallu que je me calme parceque la famille en avait un peu ras le bol et les voisins je pense aussi parceque je faisais vibrer la maison. Mais bon quand on aime on ne compte pas. Continue comme ça et surtout ne change pas 🎸 Est que gilmour a vu tes interprétations et t à laissé un mot ? A+ de t entendre. 👌
@@heresguitar Bonjour, Merci et bravo pour ce moment! 👏👏👏 Je vous ai découvert, il y a peu, recherchant "Iron hand", Mark Knopfler étant celui qui a inspiré mon jeu, et je dois dire que vous êtes bluffant. 😲 Pour preuve, la vidéo n'était pas arrivée à la fin que je m'étais déjà abonné, avec les deux traits sur la cloche. 😉 Ici, c'est particulièrement prodigieux!!! 😱 Heureusement que vous ne jouez pas 100% comme David Gilmour car on aurait pu croire que vous faisiez un playback parfait (bons positionnements et mouvements). Mais très probablement que c'est encore meilleur que je ne le constate, depuis un peu plus d'un an que je ne peux plus utiliser mon système et je ne passe que par un smartphone. Franchement, encore une fois, bravo! Vraiment impressionné. 😏 Je me suis même dit que j'allais vous kidnapper (Ne faites pas ça les gens, je ne veux pas être accusé et nous n'aurions plus ce plaisir!!!). 😅 Niveau matos, j'ai de quoi (11 guitares. Je crois que seules le DoBro, l'Ovation et la Flying V ne sont pas sur la photo de ce que j'appelle "le mur". Je ne sais pas comment aller sur ma page.) Je vais continuer à prendre plaisir de votre travail. 😉👍
@@lavergnemichel5665 Bonjour, Je vous rejoins, comme je l'ai mentionné, en réponse à un Brésilien, M. HERES s'est vraiment approprié le morceau, la finesse du toucher et ses subtilités, les attaques. Il est dedans (pas dans la torpeur), comfortably off... Me permettez-vous une question? Puisque vous êtes fan, j'aimerais savoir la version que vous préférez, s'il vous plaît? "Pulse" est magique mais je conserve cette préférence pour celle de "Delicate Sond of Thunder". Je pose la question car tout le monde place celle-ci en premier lieu. Serait-ce encore un de mes "défauts" lié à mes origines du classique?!? 🤔
Many Congratulations and warm kudos to you Sir! You paid tribute with Great Respect, Passion and Spirituality of another level to this historic Solo... Mr. David Gilmour would be so proud of you Cheers Sir
Some people are saying Andreys version is better - trust me, I was learning both versions, Andreys version is extremely good, but the tone is different (not saying worse, just it is not very Gilmour sound) and some parts are really different to the original, but its just how Andrey wanted to play it probably, he simulates rotary speaker with ping pong delay to give more surround sound, I am not sure about using chorus, only reverb+delay. He uses 2012 Fender Standard American with stock pickups, I hear a bit of typical Strat "twag", but its good, I like it, even if it is humbucker. Version from Heres has compressor, maybe chorus (or flanger?), EQ other to me uknown fx, Gilmour signature pickups (setting of SPC and EXG can be spotted on the video) and the most important thing - he plays it really the same as in the live version. I would be quite interested in the Kemper profile used in Heres version though... I was not able to create the profile, mine lacks the power and some kind of roundness... hard to explain. Probably based on Hiwatt? Maybe rotary speaker, delay seems to be some Two tap delay and Reverb with higher mix (it can be heard at the end of the song). Maybe delay is also as VST plugin, to be synced with backing track tempo. I think you should keep the secret anyways, its like recipe for Cocacola :) but if you want to share some insight, would be cool. Both are using audio interface with more than 2 audio inputs, so probably also re-amping possible, so more comfortable adjustments in finding the right tone in postprocess? Regarding backing track, Andrey took backing track and make it longer, Heres created much better backing track from the scratch, which is less MIDI-ish however its MIDI anyways probably :) Just better sample bank. I think just Heres wins in general but both are kings of the castle :)
Heres has done a great job, but for me Andrey Korolev has "perfected" the solo. I am HUGE Gilmour fan but I don' know why i enjoy more listening to Andrey's version. I have analyzed both solos (Andrey vs David) a million times, played them back to back, note for note , at different speeds, i even had them playing in loop while i sleep. :) But i have to say Andrey's solo is light years away from everyone on youtube.
I'd be interested in more details about where you think this one falls short? I do like that Andrey one better, but I would have thought they are on a par, not lightyears apart...
You Tube best guitarist imho right here and ive been trying to play like this for 30 years and was always said to have really got the essence of Gilmour well not like this guy. 21 people are very jealous
@@heresguitar Wonder if you check out my version horrible sound quality recoded with my phone but maybe you could tell me how i go about getting better and if its just learning production skills. My whammy broke off in my bridge so i know i got to get that element back in. Opinion on the solo and how to get started on gear to make better you tube videos if you ever have the time thanks!
OMG what have i just listened to... wow wow wow!! that was amazing and the closest to David gilmours version i have ever heard. that tone is bang on love it !! Thankyou for uploading this
The quality of this video, the playing, the sound, everything is perfect. I will be listening to this on repeat! Absolutely nailed the tone and feel of Gilmour. Great work! :) Also what effect pedals were you using? I’m looking to recreate this sound? I assume the usual big muff, compressor, delay and chorus I guess.
La versione Pulse di Comfortably Numb è secondo me (ma non solo) il miglior assolo di chitarra di tutti i tempi in assoluto. La cover di Andrey Korolev è bellissima ma questa è stupenda, superlativa, incredibile e assolutamente fantastica!!! Grandissimo Gilmour per averla inventata e grande tu per averla eseguita in modo impeccabile ed impressionante! Bravo bravo bravo e bravo! 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏 🎶💞🎵❤️💓🎵💞🎶🎵🎶
2:20 chills bro. You're a beast. Sounds just like it you got the Gilmour touch. Congratulations.. how are you recording and what are you using for the tone?
Thank you. I use a daw to make the backing track and record the guitars/bass parts as for the tone I use EMG DG20 pickups, a Kemper and different effects like chorus delay and reverb.
Love the drum section at 2:50 giving that emphasis. Killer playing and tone! Are you using chorus and flanger for your modulation or just chorus? That waving part gives me chills every time.
Thank you very much, this is a Fender 1995 Plus Deluxe Stratocaster, if you like what I do you should check my new video th-cam.com/video/gvpuy8MR_L8/w-d-xo.html
![ทุกครั้งที่หลับตา (Lucid Dream) - AYLA's [ Official MV ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4i1OBAQyv58/mqdefault.jpg)
All my PINK FLOYD covers : : : th-cam.com/play/PLYXDI6BnP-ksQhTGtHKQP2gQyPz9hUGu4.html
Better than David Gilmour Man... Omg... Jesusss!!!!
@@sanguedepescador9964Confirmed!!
You and Andrey korolev give the best covers of this I have ever heard. Big thumbs-up
exactly.
Thank you
;)
Andrey korolev is super good, but I love this tone
Как сыграл Андрюха Королев не сыграл никто, разве сам Гилмор
3:20 - favorite part: it sounds like a guitar is crying from its heart, with a scream and a wail. This is absolutely a masterpiece.
Thank you very much, this part is indeed one of the most beautiful things I've ever heard!
@@heresguitar so true when i first seen Gilmour play this on pulse and playing this part it give me goosebumps. fairplay to you
The seagull effect
They cut it in half on the remix of Delicate Sound of Thunder for no reason. Thankfully we have the original and Pulse.
Yes. He was perfect with the wammy.
Playing this solo is always such a trip and I suggest everyone learn it cause it really is so so powerful
David Gilmour would be very proud of you.
Comfortably Numb best song ever. OMG I loved the solo. perfect.
Thank you
HERES 👌👌👌👌👌👌👌🎸🎸🎸🎸🎸🎸🎸
Bro can you give me the backing please
That solo should never end.
Perfect!!!!
I've spent countless hours ( maybe days ) listening to that version of the solo in the last 12 years! No version has come remotely close to this. This might as well be the best thing to happen to the solo since 1994!
Thank you very much !
Bro watch Andrey korolev cover ..this is so close but Andrey's cover is very close to me🙂..but I like this one 😍too..hats off 🙌🏻
Best solo for me!!!
2nd best cover ! Simply outstanding
See Kfir Ochaion Comfortably Numb
Until this day I tought Andrey Korolev had the best cover of this solo, you just changed my mind sir what a masterclass performance.
Thank you
You should here the 10 Minute Instrumental Version of “Comfortably Numb” by Kfir Ochaion 😀
Korolev is better!
thanks so much
Coming from a Gilmour enthusiast i must say this is spot on. The technique, The Bends, The right note at the right time and the guitar movement are also spot on. The sound was spectacular. Very, very well done my friend.
You have duplicated every part of this solo perfectly, The timing, every bit of vibrato, every bend, every pinched harmonic ! The sound is also identical and your stance and the way you hold the guitar and move with it to get the sound is flawless. I’ve seen many great guitarists and musician friends of mine do a very very good cover of this but I would have to say that your version is on a different level 👍 magnificent!!
Really? I’d say he took liberties and made it his own… which is even cooler.
His timing is actually quite different.
@@pjinchoit’s faster. Most covers of this solo are from what I can tell.
A few guitar performances have made me cry out of emotion. This has been one of them. Absolutely magnificent!
This is the 1st cover iv heard of this that sounds exactly like david gilmour and iv heard many covers of this solo what a guitarist and what a sound brilliant take my hat off to you sir👏
Thank you very much, if you like what I do you might want to check this video of mine th-cam.com/video/gvpuy8MR_L8/w-d-xo.html
Unbelievable. Absolutely the best cover. Timing and feeling are stunning. Wow!
Glad you like it! Thank you
See Kfir Ochaion Comfortably Numb
OMG, I've listened to the original pulse solo almost 1000 times and for sure I'm not able to tell the difference. Awesome man, congrats from Italy 🇮🇹
Grazie !
exactly
@@heresguitar u r awesome.. senpai
@@brandonrinzuala6247 Thanks
This solo cover is by far the best cover I've ever heard.. no one can do like you did it amazing!!! phenomenal 🙏🙏🙏
Thank you so much, if you like what I do you might want to check this video of mine th-cam.com/video/gvpuy8MR_L8/w-d-xo.html
Wow !!! That was by far the best version of that solo I have ever heard in my life. I Can’t stop aiir guitaring to the whole thing with headphones on !! Bravo Heres I’m sure Dave Gilmore would be very impressed.
Thank you !
You should here the 10 Minute Instrumental Version of “Comfortably Numb” by Kfir Ochaion 😀
This is an absolutely amazing cover of this masterpiece - the fidelity of your performance, everything from the sound to the way you hold the guitar is staggeringly Gilmourish! Most of all though you captured Gilmour's 'taking a Sunday drive' way of playing this despite it being one of the greatest solos all time. Well done sir, great tip of the cap to one of the best! 👏🏼
EDIT: Also it is criminal that this does not have at least a million views on here!!
So far the BEST cover I've ever seen! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 Please, let On the turning away be the next video!
Thanks! I already made a cover of "On The Turning Away" th-cam.com/video/vHElMYLzPsM/w-d-xo.html
How the hell has this only got 80k views? Best cover of this solo on yt
Good question! 😀.... Thank you very much, if you like what I do you should check my new video th-cam.com/video/gvpuy8MR_L8/w-d-xo.html
Has been said already but you absolutely smashed the timing and feeling better than anyone else. Bravo 👏
Thank you very much!
This is the best on the internet. Perfect, perfect, perfect. The tremolo is spot on
Thank you very much
Nailed it. Absolutely mind blowing 💙
Thank you very much, if you like what I do you should check my new video th-cam.com/video/gvpuy8MR_L8/w-d-xo.html
100% eargasm listening to this masterful rendition...this is perfect.
This is an outstanding performance! By far The Best cover of the Pulse version ever made in the history of youtube! Thank you !
Im still waiting for that full Telegraph Road cover!
lol...Thanks, it's coming soon hopefully !
Best cover of this solo out there, others are extremely good but this tops them all.
Thank you
See Kfir Ochaion version
You are a true artist and this is THE BEST cover of this truly great guitar solo.
I’ve listened to this awesome solo thousands of times since Pulse was released and I know it note for note….. you absolutely nailed it….. respect ✊
Thank you very much, if you like what I do you should check my new video th-cam.com/video/gvpuy8MR_L8/w-d-xo.html
God Damn! There's no words for this...total eargasm.
Great solo
Thank you for this
I'm a very real pink Floyd fan and this is the best cover I ever heard
See Kfir Ochaion Comfortably numb
I close my eyes and I hear David Gilmour!! 😎👍
IGUAL ME PASA A MI
Escucho a Pink Floyd desde mis 6 o 7 años de edad. Esta parte de esta canción siempre me emocionó. Escucharte, es volver a vivir estas mismas sensaciones. En mi humilde opinión, el mejor solo de guitarra. Tu versión, a la altura de la impresionante interpretación de Gilmour. GRACIAS!
Muchísimas gracias
Hombre esto es sencillamente maravilloso, es cerrar los ojos y escuchar a David G, tienes un talento extraordinario, gracias por esta excelente versión.
This is a beautiful example of age's effect when playing this song. Time. Time is a thing.
Thank you very much but come one I'm not that old! LOL... if you like what I do you should check my new video th-cam.com/video/gvpuy8MR_L8/w-d-xo.html
This right here is a guitar playing a human. Absolute perfection 🥰 just WOW 👌 thats all i can say 😍
I've watched this 9 times and i'm still trying to figure out if it's you or David playing... i'm impressed
Thank you very much, if you like what I do you should check my new video th-cam.com/video/gvpuy8MR_L8/w-d-xo.html
I come back to this video at least once per week, if not more...IMO, this is better than the man himself. 50+ year Floyd fan.
What a treat to have this drop into my recommendations. Absolutely incredible job!
Thank you very much! Check out my other videos! 🙂
New to your Channel and skill. Listening to this on Xmas day 2023. Absolutely amazed. Perfection 😻
Welcome aboard!
It's literaly the best version of this solo (wich is for me the best solo ever). The best cover I could find on TH-cam. The work and the precision of the sound is just... WoW ! INCREDIBLE ! Good Job
Thank you very much, if you like what I do you should check my new video th-cam.com/video/gvpuy8MR_L8/w-d-xo.html
You Sir are such am amazing guitar player. Thank you for this particular live version.
Thanks to you
The cover that stays in mind as the song itself.
So much feeling and technic
Thank you
perfeito, sensacional, melhor cover que ja vi.
Yeah agreed, both you and Korolev give the best versions- ✌️✌️
Incredible cover, listened to it 3 times in a row. wow!
Really nice tone, this is one of the best cover of this solo that i have ever heard thanks you
Thanks to you!
Bravo!! One of the very best Covers of this song I’ve ever heard! I’m a new subscriber.
First time on TH-cam i have same feelings like warching Pulse concert. Great, Great job! All notes are played properly but also sound of the guitar is perfect. Respect dude!
Thank you very much, if you like what I do you might want to check this video of mine th-cam.com/video/gvpuy8MR_L8/w-d-xo.html
Spot on from start to finish. And the tone is excellent as well.
Saw both and you are making David Gilmour proud, Heres! INCREDIBLE!!!
Thank you ! Which one do you prefer ?
@@heresguitar Both of them equally!
Venice 89 i was there on the square!!! The best Pink Floyd concert ever. And the solo of confortably impossible to repeat by gilmour himself
How lucky you are! I wish I attended that show, Gilmour was at his very best that night!
Afirmo, com toda a certeza!!!! Não mudou uma única nota musical da versão do Álbum Puse! INCRÍVEL...!
Obrigado
Amazing man! Perfect tone, perfect execution. This makes me feel the same feelings of the original played by David. Keep it up!
Thank you very much, if you like what I do you might want to check this video of mine th-cam.com/video/gvpuy8MR_L8/w-d-xo.html
Absolutely fantastic stunningly beautiful.
🇧🇷🇧🇷que de mais. Você é muito bom. Fechei os olhos e parecia que eu estava ouvindo Pink Floyd mesmo. Parabéns.
Obrigado
Salut Heres.
En tant que fan de toujours de pink floyd.
Plus particulièrement de gilmour et de sa manière de jouer avec sa fender je dois dire et reconnaître que tu es sa parfaite doublure avec une guitare dans les mains.
C est tout simplement magnifique.
Comme je t ai mis dans un autre commentaire en fermant les yeux on a l impression d écouter David.
Merci pour eux et pour nous pour ces interprétations magistrales.
🙌👍🎸😉
Surtout ne change pas
Merci beaucoup, j'ai fait la version entier aussi avec le chant et le premier solo, tu as regardé ?
Merci Heres
Si c est la version qui dure 9 minutes oui je l ai regardée.
C'est vraiment génial. ✌
Comme je te l ai dit je suis un fan inconditionnel des Floyd.
J ai eu une période où je ne faisais que ça les écouter. Il a fallu que je me calme parceque la famille en avait un peu ras le bol et les voisins je pense aussi parceque je faisais vibrer la maison.
Mais bon quand on aime on ne compte pas.
Continue comme ça et surtout ne change pas 🎸
Est que gilmour a vu tes interprétations et t à laissé un mot ?
A+ de t entendre. 👌
@@heresguitar Bonjour,
Merci et bravo pour ce moment! 👏👏👏
Je vous ai découvert, il y a peu, recherchant "Iron hand", Mark Knopfler étant celui qui a inspiré mon jeu, et je dois dire que vous êtes bluffant. 😲
Pour preuve, la vidéo n'était pas arrivée à la fin que je m'étais déjà abonné, avec les deux traits sur la cloche. 😉
Ici, c'est particulièrement prodigieux!!! 😱
Heureusement que vous ne jouez pas 100% comme David Gilmour car on aurait pu croire que vous faisiez un playback parfait (bons positionnements et mouvements). Mais très probablement que c'est encore meilleur que je ne le constate, depuis un peu plus d'un an que je ne peux plus utiliser mon système et je ne passe que par un smartphone.
Franchement, encore une fois, bravo! Vraiment impressionné.
😏 Je me suis même dit que j'allais vous kidnapper (Ne faites pas ça les gens, je ne veux pas être accusé et nous n'aurions plus ce plaisir!!!). 😅
Niveau matos, j'ai de quoi (11 guitares. Je crois que seules le DoBro, l'Ovation et la Flying V ne sont pas sur la photo de ce que j'appelle "le mur". Je ne sais pas comment aller sur ma page.)
Je vais continuer à prendre plaisir de votre travail. 😉👍
@@lavergnemichel5665 Bonjour,
Je vous rejoins, comme je l'ai mentionné, en réponse à un Brésilien, M. HERES s'est vraiment approprié le morceau, la finesse du toucher et ses subtilités, les attaques. Il est dedans (pas dans la torpeur), comfortably off...
Me permettez-vous une question?
Puisque vous êtes fan, j'aimerais savoir la version que vous préférez, s'il vous plaît?
"Pulse" est magique mais je conserve cette préférence pour celle de "Delicate Sond of Thunder".
Je pose la question car tout le monde place celle-ci en premier lieu.
Serait-ce encore un de mes "défauts" lié à mes origines du classique?!? 🤔
This is just too perfect. And lets be honest, how can you be bothered playing any other lead solo after mastering this! Bravo mate
Thank you
Many Congratulations and warm kudos to you Sir!
You paid tribute with Great Respect, Passion and Spirituality of another level to this historic Solo...
Mr. David Gilmour would be so proud of you
Cheers Sir
Thank you very much, if you like what I do you should check my new video th-cam.com/video/gvpuy8MR_L8/w-d-xo.html
...A técnica e a emoção caminham juntas, qnd esse cidadão toca! Parece que a guitarra vai falar! O Homem toca MUITO..
🤘🎻
Obrigado
My old dream of one day playing this beautiful song on the guitar, just like you did. Privilege, feel blessed.
If I can do it, you certainly can do it too !
Some people are saying Andreys version is better - trust me, I was learning both versions, Andreys version is extremely good, but the tone is different (not saying worse, just it is not very Gilmour sound) and some parts are really different to the original, but its just how Andrey wanted to play it probably, he simulates rotary speaker with ping pong delay to give more surround sound, I am not sure about using chorus, only reverb+delay. He uses 2012 Fender Standard American with stock pickups, I hear a bit of typical Strat "twag", but its good, I like it, even if it is humbucker.
Version from Heres has compressor, maybe chorus (or flanger?), EQ other to me uknown fx, Gilmour signature pickups (setting of SPC and EXG can be spotted on the video) and the most important thing - he plays it really the same as in the live version. I would be quite interested in the Kemper profile used in Heres version though... I was not able to create the profile, mine lacks the power and some kind of roundness... hard to explain.
Probably based on Hiwatt? Maybe rotary speaker, delay seems to be some Two tap delay and Reverb with higher mix (it can be heard at the end of the song). Maybe delay is also as VST plugin, to be synced with backing track tempo. I think you should keep the secret anyways, its like recipe for Cocacola :) but if you want to share some insight, would be cool. Both are using audio interface with more than 2 audio inputs, so probably also re-amping possible, so more comfortable adjustments in finding the right tone in postprocess?
Regarding backing track, Andrey took backing track and make it longer, Heres created much better backing track from the scratch, which is less MIDI-ish however its MIDI anyways probably :) Just better sample bank. I think just Heres wins in general but both are kings of the castle :)
That's some analysis man, thanks ! (Hiwatt + Chorus that's right)
Damn you man lol
Andrey is untouchable on that performance. No one is even close to him on youtube. This version is sick too, but still.
Heres has done a great job, but for me Andrey Korolev has "perfected" the solo. I am HUGE Gilmour fan but I don' know why i enjoy more listening to Andrey's version. I have analyzed both solos (Andrey vs David) a million times, played them back to back, note for note , at different speeds, i even had them playing in loop while i sleep. :)
But i have to say Andrey's solo is light years away from everyone on youtube.
Ohh man I can't stop watching you play it omg I can spend my whole life watching this one
Это по-моему лучшее, что я слушал!!!!!!!
Thank you
Perfect Cover.
FULL COVER of the song here : th-cam.com/video/b1H7cHU1B30/w-d-xo.html
Super cover and great sound ! Any chance you link the full backing track ?
I'd be interested in more details about where you think this one falls short? I do like that Andrey one better, but I would have thought they are on a par, not lightyears apart...
@@Martin_Gregory Your comment is not at the right place, I believe you were replying to a comment in another thread below.
great cover! can you share the backing track?
....very very close to the unique Gilmour tone. Superb cover of one of the greatest solos in Rock and Roll
Absolutely beautifully played.. one of the best solos ever.
Thanks, that's true !
Beautifully played. One of my favorite solos of all time. Love watching your channel.
Thank you
amazing just unbelievable
Thank you
Oh my gosh! That was awesome playing! Your and Andreys Kovalev's cover are the best cover on youtube ever!
This is ridicuolously accurate... and i can say that, it's possible only if u have given all your soul to this... God Bless you!
Thank you very much, if you like what I do you should check my new video th-cam.com/video/gvpuy8MR_L8/w-d-xo.html
What a performance, so awesome!
You Tube best guitarist imho right here and ive been trying to play like this for 30 years and was always said to have really got the essence of Gilmour well not like this guy. 21 people are very jealous
Thank you very much, if you like what I do you should check my new video th-cam.com/video/gvpuy8MR_L8/w-d-xo.html
@@heresguitar Didnt see your message on my board. Thanks !!!
@@heresguitar Wonder if you check out my version horrible sound quality recoded with my phone but maybe you could tell me how i go about getting better and if its just learning production skills. My whammy broke off in my bridge so i know i got to get that element back in. Opinion on the solo and how to get started on gear to make better you tube videos if you ever have the time thanks!
U're rly talented man. Seen Knopfler's executions too.. impressive 👍👏
Brilliant 🖤
Thank you !
Stunning performance. Hats off. You and Andrey Korolev and Kfir Ochaion have the best cover so far.
..como é fiel ao tempo da música; Que harmonia. Que emoção transcendental!
Obrigado!
OMG what have i just listened to... wow wow wow!! that was amazing and the closest to David gilmours version i have ever heard. that tone is bang on love it !! Thankyou for uploading this
Thank you
The quality of this video, the playing, the sound, everything is perfect. I will be listening to this on repeat! Absolutely nailed the tone and feel of Gilmour. Great work! :) Also what effect pedals were you using? I’m looking to recreate this sound? I assume the usual big muff, compressor, delay and chorus I guess.
Thank you, everything you mentioned but no big muff
Greatest solo ever
Wow! One of the best covers....If not the best cover of the version ive seen so far on YT. And the sound is amazing. Really well done man!!
Thank you very much !
Congratulations! Wow it blew me away!!! The way you play is just fabulous! Thank you so much!!
Thank you too!
La versione Pulse di Comfortably Numb è secondo me (ma non solo) il miglior assolo di chitarra di tutti i tempi in assoluto.
La cover di Andrey Korolev è bellissima ma questa è stupenda, superlativa, incredibile e assolutamente fantastica!!!
Grandissimo Gilmour per averla inventata e grande tu per averla eseguita in modo impeccabile ed impressionante!
Bravo bravo bravo e bravo!
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
🎶💞🎵❤️💓🎵💞🎶🎵🎶
If you ever get a "thumbs Down", It would be from a jealous David Gilmour!
lol thanks !
Excellent, this is my favorite Rock song and solo...Clean and on the money...
Great job !!
Parabéns! Melhor execução que encontrei no youtube... Talvez um dia eu consiga fazer igual com a ajuda de uma tablatura. 🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷
Obrigado
Awesome cover of the best solo version of Comfortably Numb. Great job 👍
Thank you
2:20 chills bro. You're a beast. Sounds just like it you got the Gilmour touch. Congratulations.. how are you recording and what are you using for the tone?
Thank you. I use a daw to make the backing track and record the guitars/bass parts as for the tone I use EMG DG20 pickups, a Kemper and different effects like chorus delay and reverb.
HERES hi which DAW are u using
@@AbhisekChakravorty Studio One
@@heresguitar Thank you for replying
Great job I close my eyes and relive the original. Thank you.
Thank you too!
Love the drum section at 2:50 giving that emphasis. Killer playing and tone! Are you using chorus and flanger for your modulation or just chorus?
That waving part gives me chills every time.
Thanks. A bit of flanger before chorus but not too much.
OK. All I can say is, WOW!!! Thank you for sharing this. WOW!!!
Thank you
There should be atleast a million views on this video wtf
lol thank you. Share it with your friends !
ONE OF THE BEST COVER OF THE EPIC SOLO!!!!! TOTALLY NAILED IT@!!!!
Thank you
Hola...que tal...felicidades...un tono increible...me encanta...una pregunta ...que guitarra es esa?
Thank you very much, this is a Fender 1995 Plus Deluxe Stratocaster, if you like what I do you should check my new video th-cam.com/video/gvpuy8MR_L8/w-d-xo.html
Tone, feeling, bends, everything was perfect
Thank you
Very well rendered ;)
Playing on a Kemper ? Do you share the preset please ? Thanks !
I can imagine, he has done the best version on youtube, probably wont now share simply all secrets. We can just sit and admire :)
Wow! Just WOW! Nailed it, man!
Thank you very much, if you like what I do you might want to check this video of mine th-cam.com/video/gvpuy8MR_L8/w-d-xo.html
Шикарный звук и исполнение!!! Фанаты Гилмора оценят!💪🔥🇷🇺
True master.
Was note perfect closed my eyes and started to fly away though I was listening to dave gilmour himself .
Thankyou so much ❤
the best part 3:20
My favorite too!
Superb performance, superb tone.
There are already three covers sounding personally for me better than Gilmour's original. Yours, Andrey Korolev's and one more.