@@beingamultistanismylife1872 Aespa is incredibly talented but this is not live. Or at least if it is their mics are very quiet. You don't hear any breathing at all while they're moving. Also you would probably hear ningnings earrings hit the mic etc. Not saying that they cant sing like this live but this performance isn't live. And I think its important to comment cause of other groups who are getting shit on for their bad live vocals while other groups are getting praise for "live vocals" when it definitely isn't live.
@@beingamultistanismylife1872 girl, please stop, it is very obvious when they are singing live and when they are not. I'm not hating on them and I know they are amazing vocalists, but aespa is one of the groups that you can clearly see/hear when they aren't singing live. Just compare their circle chart music award for example or the coachella one and you will see the difference. First of all Aespa when they aren't singing live they don't even move their mouth (it even happened so many times when they forgot to sing) and one thing which is very obvious is that they use all the time the same pre-recorded video (if they sang live it wouldn't sound the same all the time). I know that you want to praise your idol, but these days 90% of the performances that Sm groups does are pre-recorded
@@yeonhee1767 Just breath. That's because their mic is still on. but still uses backtrack sound. You can see comments like this from other people who have good observations. Don't be a stupid fans.
@@nalla4428 no matter how many proof they provide you guys will always deny it. You favs need backtrack and when it's their mr removed video. Stupid fans like you be like, "awww they r still young, they got had choreo" etc excuses. Aespa is perfect aespa is improving unlike your favs.
To those who says "Our idol couldn't sing because of the hard choreography! " needs to see AESPA . Yall the choreography can't always be the excuse, just admit they are weak vocalist.
yeah but aespas choreos arent difficult as compared to other groups as most kpop groups nowadays are dance oriented. Most groups with stable vocals are ones who have mild choreos.
@@jistarsBut aren't vocals way more important than dance though? If 'idols' cannot sing because they are 'dance oriented', they are just dancers. Having the ability to sing properly is what differentiates idols from dancers. A nice, simple dance which isnt heavily demanding is more than enough to capture the attention of the audience. For e.g., BABYMONSTER.
@@jistars Still not an excuse for groups that perform terrible encore stages while standing still. Some of them don't even bother singing in actual performances anymore because they focus TOO MUCH on their dancing. Probably would be a little better if they dance like Momo, Lisa, or Hyoyeon but nah.
@@doesleeknowreallyknowtho wow expecting sm idols sound breathy while "prerecording" is so stupid. you guys dont know sm's famose trademill vocal training that is to for not sounding breathy during performance as they r still getting experiences they r improving.
Aespa definitely sets the standard for their gen.. Great vocals, difficult choreo, and even sophisticated unique concept that not everybody can pull off 👏
아니 미친 르세라핌 스마트 mr제거보고 아니 복부에 힘이 들어가니까 라이브가 좀 힘들긴하겠다 복부에 계속 자극들어가는데 쉣 성량이 배에서 나오는건데 계속 그걸 움직이니까 진짜 라이브 힘들긴라겠다 심지어 거의 대부분 곡이 그런데..라고 생각하고 딱 쇼츠 내렸는데 염@병 수퍼노바가 더 복부 많이씀ㅅㅂㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ근데존나잘하내
Guys let's not assume.. The fancam only focuses on the main people singing so they only put winter ningning and Karina because they were the main people singing
Love when they sing the chorus together!! Full with voices.. After listening to this, I just found out my pet peeve in mr removed videos.. which is WHEN THE IDOLS DOESN’T SING THE CHORUS! Like that where the catchy beat come from and you dont sing it live???? Whyyy!! that your song..
This is clearly Live AR. This is exactly like studio version with no sounds of breath. Damn these fans will fall for anything. I love Aespa but they are given a free pass for prerecorded vocals while other artists get hate comments and death threats. Hypocrisy at its best
에스파 실망시키지 않는다.. 역시 짱스파👍🏼
닝닝 머리 비대칭인것도 모를정도로 ㅈㄴ아름다움
와 댓글보고 알았음 ㅋㅋㅌㅌㅋㅌㅋ
??무ㅗ야 진짜네
얼굴만 보느라 머리를 못보고있었음 ㄷ
머리 비대칭이었음????????
머리 비대칭이었음????
닝닝 왜이렇게 이쁨?? 얼굴 미쳤네
라이브 실력이 르세랑 차이가 읍는뎅
조만간 시혁이한테 밟히겟다..
?
@@수현-l3o맞춤법 무슨일.. 근데 왤케 말투가 댓글알바 같냐ㅜㅜ ㅋㅋ
@@케이-f5z 내댓글 다 봣냐 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 보면 알바아니라는거 바보도 알텐대 ㅋㅋ
숨은 언제 쉬냐고요
ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
아니 저 춤을 추면서 어케 이정도까지 라이브를 하냐고....미쳤다 진짜
다 안 지워진 듯
저 에어로빅같은 춤을추고 목소리 하나도 안떨리네
신기하노
@@룰루랄라-z7k이건 뭔 ㅋㅋㅋ
립싱크인거 같아요
@@user-djsoaqo 귀가 어릴적부터 안들리는거임 아니면 판단력이 유아인거임? ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
에스파 밟을 수 수 수 수퍼노바
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
넌 올라가라 😂😂
아이씨ㅋㅋㅋㄱㄱㄱㄱ😂
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
조아요 999개 건들기가 싫네
SM artist is another level, they're best at singing live. How can you make your voice stable while you make it powerful dance??
Because they dont sing live? This is prerecorded
@@Kpop_stan165 This is very obviously live don't doubt aespa
@@beingamultistanismylife1872 Aespa is incredibly talented but this is not live. Or at least if it is their mics are very quiet. You don't hear any breathing at all while they're moving. Also you would probably hear ningnings earrings hit the mic etc. Not saying that they cant sing like this live but this performance isn't live.
And I think its important to comment cause of other groups who are getting shit on for their bad live vocals while other groups are getting praise for "live vocals" when it definitely isn't live.
@@Kpop_stan165
The members' voice change sometimes
@@beingamultistanismylife1872 girl, please stop, it is very obvious when they are singing live and when they are not. I'm not hating on them and I know they are amazing vocalists, but aespa is one of the groups that you can clearly see/hear when they aren't singing live. Just compare their circle chart music award for example or the coachella one and you will see the difference. First of all Aespa when they aren't singing live they don't even move their mouth (it even happened so many times when they forgot to sing) and one thing which is very obvious is that they use all the time the same pre-recorded video (if they sang live it wouldn't sound the same all the time). I know that you want to praise your idol, but these days 90% of the performances that Sm groups does are pre-recorded
Ningning is really pretty 😊
카리나 도입부도 너무 쩌는듯 ㄷㄷ
카리나도 호동생이네.. siu siu siu 수퍼노바..
목소리가 기계음같이하네진짜 짱
카리나보다 닝닝은 그야말로 사기캐
@@sbnxem8059 같은 그룹 멤버끼리 비교질이여 둘 다 사기캐인데 쳐맞을래? 댓글 똑바로 써라
@@sbnxem8059카리나 칭찬하는데 왜 갑분 닝닝 얘기하면서 카리나 내려치기하는 거임
퍼포먼스 하면서 부른거치고는 만족한다는 어떤그룹이랑은 차원이 다르네요ㅋㅋ
@ovoo.v 카리나가 버블로 라이브 맞다하지 않았어요??
@ovoo.v 아 그려요?? 뭐가 맞나 햇는디 감사혀유
@ovoo.v원래 엠카가 첫방이라 항상 립싱크 아니였나용??
풀 립싱크한 영상 가지고 다른 여돌 까는것 좀 그만하면 안됨?
@@daad-r3g하지만 걔들은 라이브를 아예 안하는걸?? 여기는 라이브 하잖아
They are so stable Omg
@@nalla4428no it's live this time, you can't hear any backtrack also them breathing is heard.
@@yeonhee1767 Just breath. That's because their mic is still on. but still uses backtrack sound. You can see comments like this from other people who have good observations. Don't be a stupid fans.
@@nalla4428 no matter how many proof they provide you guys will always deny it. You favs need backtrack and when it's their mr removed video. Stupid fans like you be like, "awww they r still young, they got had choreo" etc excuses. Aespa is perfect aespa is improving unlike your favs.
@@nalla4428 if it’s pre-recorded, why didn’t she make the same for le serafim it’s Mr removed are you deaf?
@@lina-9652 Wow! I won't discuss other groups here. If yo're smart, you can differentiate between live and pre-recorded singing. Poor you
one the many LIVE SINGING QUEENSS
닝닝 진심 이쁘다
짱
말같지도 않은 소리하지마라
말같은 소리만 해라.
교도소에서 먹었던 뜨끈한
보신탕 생각나는 구먼
쩝쫩쭵 후루룹촵촵 짭짭스~
?@@갱월쥐
@@갱월쥐얘 짭인데?
They always slay. And Ningning ate her part, man. Love you, Ning!
*Of course its Aespa, the least you can do is to doubt their live vocals❤❤*
this is obv pre-recorded but their live vocals still slay the same
AESPA 진짜 잘해요 멤버들 보컬, 비주얼 다 완벽해요 ❤
어케 저런 은박지 옷을 입고도 아름다울 수가 있음!?!?
와씨 닝닝 미모.. 존예다
To those who says "Our idol couldn't sing because of the hard choreography! " needs to see AESPA . Yall the choreography can't always be the excuse, just admit they are weak vocalist.
yeah but aespas choreos arent difficult as compared to other groups as most kpop groups nowadays are dance oriented. Most groups with stable vocals are ones who have mild choreos.
@@jistarsBut aren't vocals way more important than dance though? If 'idols' cannot sing because they are 'dance oriented', they are just dancers. Having the ability to sing properly is what differentiates idols from dancers. A nice, simple dance which isnt heavily demanding is more than enough to capture the attention of the audience. For e.g., BABYMONSTER.
@@youcanstayyeah do you guys think idols are singers, why are they called idols?
@@jistars Still not an excuse for groups that perform terrible encore stages while standing still. Some of them don't even bother singing in actual performances anymore because they focus TOO MUCH on their dancing. Probably would be a little better if they dance like Momo, Lisa, or Hyoyeon but nah.
@@jistars Is it more important now to have a difficult choreo than to maintain a stable vocal?
Ningning you’re out of this world omg 💗❤️
Them literally slaying smm hard!! Aespa with their rap, dance,vocals
Edit:Oops why there is a war in the replies?? Lol I was just praising Aespa💀😭
This isn’t live???
@@rdpa4019they can still sing???
@@rdpa4019 FYI THIS IS LIVE AESPA DID IT LIVE. YPU CAN HEAR THE BREATH.
@@yeonhee1767 pre-recorded audios include breathing nowadays to give the illusion of live stages - i doubt this is live
@@doesleeknowreallyknowtho wow expecting sm idols sound breathy while "prerecording" is so stupid. you guys dont know sm's famose trademill vocal training that is to for not sounding breathy during performance as they r still getting experiences they r improving.
닝닝이가 이 곡과 찰떡인지 몰라보게 이뻐지고 당당해짐
소극적인 분위기 였는데 이제 앞에서 적극적이고 씩씩함.
비쥬얼도 같은 사람인데 이쁘게 확!! 달라짐 !!!
Hello?! Ningning??? Next level beauty❤❤❤❤
プロすぎる。さすが我が推し、、🥹
닝닝이 너무 예뻐❤❤❤
아니 춤 추는데도 너무 잘한다ㅠㅜ 이러니 에스파 짱이라는 말이 나오지
안무 잘 짰다. 닝닝 춤선도 너무 예쁘고
춤도 격해보이는데 어떻게 흔들림 없이 노래를 저렇게 잘함..? 역시 짱스파ㅏ
ning lu cantiknya cantik buanguet
They are really slaying so much this era. Also ningning why are you so perfect ??
Ningning is so pretty 🤩
에스파는 진짜 짱이구나...❤❤❤
닝닝이 진짜 레전드다 춤도 졸라 잘추고 저렇게 끊어추는 춤 추면서 노래도 진짜 잘부르는디 외모까지 졸래 아름답네 어깨라인도 너무예쁘고 육각형
NINGNING PLEASEEE YOU ARE SO GORGEOUS
밟으실수수수퍼노바!에스파는 절대로 밟히지 않아!
에스파는 뭐든지 너무 잘해요!! 무대에서도 앙코르에서도 노래를 꽤 잘하더라구요!! 에스파 계속 힘내세요! 너희들 다 너무 예뻐🫶🫶
와 노래 개잘부른다 🔥
카리나는 예쁜데 노래까지 잘부르나 매력에 빠질수밖에없다…🤍
Ateee
Its so easy to find you here😭
@@Cherii214🙃
NingNing my bias, and she look really good 💯
ningning is so good at dancing too
Ningning is such a cutie
Their vocals are literally on point
Love the oufitts❤ (and aespa too ofc)
You can say anything you want about sm but at least they give vocal training to their artists
This is Aespas year!! Like I might start to stan them..😊like their so good..
Why didn't anyone notice that Giselle was missing? Where's she?
please never separate the members, they are a team. Gisele is also an idol...
Real, I was looking for more comments that talked about it but no one said anything
불가능한 것 같지만 정말 비현실적인 것 같아요. 마치 비디오 게임 속에 있는 것 같아요 ♥️♥️♥️
어이 그들은 노래를 하면서 춤을 추고 있어 와 대박 정말 멋져 그의 목소리는 여전히 안정적이야
에스파 이 무대 라이브 아니라서 mr 제거해도 음원처럼 나오는거임
The way their voices are so stable even tho that dance is so intense- sm artists>>>
This is insane your vocal is perfect
🤩
닝닝언니 계속 사건은 다가와 아오에~ 부르는거 넘기엽다규❤❤
ㅎㅎ 그니까 누가 누굴 밟는다는거냐고 ㅎ 수준차이가 어마무시한데
Aespa definitely sets the standard for their gen.. Great vocals, difficult choreo, and even sophisticated unique concept that not everybody can pull off 👏
난 여돌 아무도팬 아닌데,
(지나가는 제로즈임돠)
사실 르세라,아일릿등 라이브 사태보며.. 춤추며부르기 빡세서 노래가 부르기힘든가?
했는데, 에스파보니 저빡센안무에 리듬감짱에 발음도잘들리고..진짜 다르긴하네여~~
외모도 넘 이쁘고..
화이팅 에스파~♡
이게 바로 완벽체라고 할 수 있죠...ㅠㄷㄷㄷㄷ
*Bang PD wishes, he wanted Minheejin to step on aespa but Hybe cant even surpass Aespa's vocals oh damn😂*
This is what singing means!
My girls are one of the best singers in 4th gen!❤
Thats not live,its prerecorded
Ningning🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
라이브 대박!에스파가 진정한 완성형 아이돌이다!이거 듣고 에스파 덕질 시작!❤MR제거가 더 나은 듯!😊😊
Stable queens💗💗
this is pre recorded but yes they r stable
@@ventaliq its literally live what??
@@ventaliq if it’s pre-recorded, why didn’t she make the same for le serafim it’s Mr removed are you deaf?
Ningning so gorgeous 😻
닝닝 안무마다 깨알 어깨 튕기는거.. 컨트롤력 경이롭다 진짜
진짜 에스파 멤버들 다 예쁘쟈나 각자 다 개성이 있음..
Las amo ❤ son tan buenas cantando ❣️
omg they’re so good
김민졍 아팠었는데 이렇게 부르는게 하….
아니 이래서 에스파가 짱이지!
타팬인데 지젤님도 좀 넣어주라.. 3명 다 잘만 넣고 한 명만 안 넣는게 더 이상하지 않냐ㅠㅠ
지젤이 이번에 파트가 머무 읎음 중간에..
ㅋㅋㅋㅋ왜 안넣었겠냐,,, 비주얼 보컬 둘다 엉망인데 어케넣어줘 역시 넌 타팬이라서 그런가
@@위드-l1l 엥 진짜 에스파 잘 모르긴한디 보컬, 춤, 외모 다 좋은데..???
@@choi3688 진짜 잘 모르네
지젤 춤도못추고 외모도 아줌마라서그럼
진짜 에스파 다 너무 이쁨
닝닝이 헤어 기여워..
They were already so good last year but this time they became even better!❤️
내가 믿고 덕질하는 이유:
NINGNING SOOO PRETTY
I don't know why is everyone talking about Ningning like I know she ate but what about Giselle? She ate too right?!
they have such great vocals while using their upper body..
3人のカットだけあってジゼルだけ無視なの草
I don't generally know this group but WOW! what a stable vocals and breathing control this is what we call actual TALENT
아니 닝닝 왜케 이쁘고 잘부르냐
아니 짱스파 라이브 🐕 잘하네 진짜;;
에스파 이 무대 라이브 아니라서 mr 제거해도 음원처럼 나오는거임
근데 팩트는 에스파는 원래 실력이 좋다는 것❤❤
댓글 알바 왔니??😊
@@leeroyeonss실력이 좋으면 뭐하노 그실력으로 라이브를 안하는데; 실력 좋으면 립싱크해도 됨?
@@djd-w9r7m 누가 립싱크 해도 된다고 했어요?그리고 원래 첫주?는 라이브 거의 안해요
스엠만 거의 첫주에 안하는거임
그리고 모르는 사람 많으니 말해준건데 이게 ㅈㄹ할거임?
Why are they so pretty
Hybe needs SM's vocal trainers
이렇게 잘하는데 어케 밟냐곸ㅋㅋ
닝닝은 다 잘해 진짜
아니 미친 르세라핌 스마트 mr제거보고 아니 복부에 힘이 들어가니까 라이브가 좀 힘들긴하겠다 복부에 계속 자극들어가는데 쉣 성량이 배에서 나오는건데 계속 그걸 움직이니까 진짜 라이브 힘들긴라겠다 심지어 거의 대부분 곡이 그런데..라고 생각하고 딱 쇼츠 내렸는데 염@병 수퍼노바가 더 복부 많이씀ㅅㅂㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ근데존나잘하내
Why didn't you add Giselle's name to your title?
why do people hate little Gisele... I'm so upset..
Guys let's not assume.. The fancam only focuses on the main people singing so they only put winter ningning and Karina because they were the main people singing
진짜 대박이다..박수..
요새 닝닝 왜이렇게 이뻐졌냐
원래 이뻤는데, 초반에 카리나랑 윈터한테만 너무 쏠림 ㅋㅋ 이제 적응하고 보이는듯
Love when they sing the chorus together!! Full with voices..
After listening to this, I just found out my pet peeve in mr removed videos.. which is WHEN THE IDOLS DOESN’T SING THE CHORUS! Like that where the catchy beat come from and you dont sing it live???? Whyyy!! that your song..
은채야 이걸 좀 보고 배워라. 이게 가수다
에스파 이 무대 라이브 아니라서 mr 제거해도 음원처럼 나오는거임
The stability 👌🏻
Aespa x babymonster wah ngeri
Real vocals, technique, breathing, choreography ✨
This is clearly Live AR. This is exactly like studio version with no sounds of breath. Damn these fans will fall for anything. I love Aespa but they are given a free pass for prerecorded vocals while other artists get hate comments and death threats. Hypocrisy at its best
This is what we call talent. Not just pretty faces ❤
ㅋㅋㅋ마이들도 데뷔해야겄는데?
닝닝이 매력있어요
닝닝 개이쁘고 머리 넘 귀요미
머리 지짜 귀엽다ㅋㅋㅋ❤
닝닝 라이브 제일 잘하네❤❤