Hey friends! If you liked this video, I'm sure you'll love our case study about Indian Railways! Check it out over here: th-cam.com/video/5H-phI9Z2_8/w-d-xo.html
Problem is paying high taxes. Most things that improve your life come from private companies. The things that you get from the government are the ones where you are forced to buy from the government like roads, rails, etc. If the government took much less taxes and only handled essentials like courts, military and legislation, we would have much better quality of life as private companies would compete to make a profit.
@@lostledgerbut in that sinario govt is actually working monopoly..so there will be no competition among private companies. Prices will increase severally..
One point related to taxing the farmers is the concept of true income. Cash is untraceable. As soon as we start taxing them they will start hiding it. The first thing we need to remove all currency above Rs. 100, then after a few years 50 and later completely. When all transactions happen online, thanks to UPI, we will have end to end visibility. Everyone's real income will become visible.
YOU ARE AFTER FARMERS INCOME ?? THEY ARE NOT GETTING VALUE FOR THEIR PRODUCT AFTER LOT OF EXPENSES , HAVE YOU NOT HEARD THE SUICIDES OF FARMERS ALL OVER INDIA . THEY FEED ENTIRE NATION , AND THEY DONT GET PENSION . INFACT FARMER SHOULD BE CONSIDERED AS A GOVERNMENT WORKER . I AM NOT TALKING ABOUT FARMER LOOTING BUSINESS MEN . THEY ARE REALLY DISGUISED AS FARMER BUT BUSINESS MEN .
As a tax payer, I'm not asserting that we don't wish to pay taxes. However, it would be beneficial to provide additional benefits to tax-payers as they are the ones financially providing for the needs (loots) of our leaders as well.
@@abrahamg-kc7cx We are also paying 30% Tax + cess and average 18% GST and many other taxes to the goverment. Alteast goverment should have to provide good education and health infrastructure for every individual. That is all we want Because privatization in education and health sector is not good at all.
@@abrahamg-kc7cx look at uk and then look at india also. Major difference. Governement uses most of the tax payers money in underlying corruption and distributing freebies to different communities so as to secure their vote
We needs to focus on - 1) Controlling corruption and scams - Longer jail punishments for convictss, stricter regulations on working bodies in government departments - Proper ulitizations of government must be a priority for centre and state government. 2) Taxing farmers who earns more than 50 lakhs in profits 3) Finding ways to tax unorganised sectors individuals who earns more than 15 lakhs in profits in a year - These inculdes - Pan show owners, Kirana store owners, Vendors & Sellors of goods with shops at some scale etc - They will gives lakhs crores of taxes 4) Encoraging people if they earn good enough to spend back in economy as it puts a lot of money in circualtion casuing interest rates to go down if followed for long enogh period in all sectors.
सरकार को सभी सरकारी कार्यों में पारदर्शिता लाने की आवश्यकता है एक सुई से लेकर महल , पुल या जो कुछ भी सरकारी पैसे से बनता है उसकी सभी जानकारी सार्वजनिक रखने की आवश्यकता है ताकि यदि कोई व्यक्ति सरकारी पैसों का गलत इस्तेमाल करे तो जनता उसके जानकारी के साथ विरोध कर पाए।
The second you say tax the profits, like all businesses these people will start showing less profits nd more deductables. There should be a tax on their revenue like the salaried class nd then income tax returns need to be filed. The slabs can be decided upon but based on revenue and not profits
It's high time GOI should tax rich farmer as well. Recently we have seen how 3-4 farmers have earned more than 4-5 cr by selling tomato. If they incurred any loses than they should get a chances to offset that loses similar to what we do in case of loses in equity or mutual fund while filing IT returns.
@@abhishekpawar5888dosta, tyani je 4-5 crore kamvale na te tu ani me sudha nokari karun 100 varshat pan kamau shknar nahit. jar nokri karat asel tar ajibatach nahi.1 CR choti amount navhe , KBC madhe core jinkle tari tax kapun rakkam milte ti pan one lotterich na..ase kityek sadhan shetkari ahet je thode thode navhe tar 50lkhs cha profit varshala kamvatat mag tyani tax ka pay Karu naye? Ani tumhi Amhi 10 -20 lkh kMavun direct tax tar bhartoch sobat indirect taxes hi bhartoch. Pratyekachya kaminusar tax charge zhalach pahije..tax che burden fakt private sector varach ka lavycha mag..saglyana fyda pahije facility havi ahe tar tyani tax suddha bharla pahije..me ithe fakta sadhan shetkari ani chote dukandar Ani dhandewalyanbabat bolat ahe. kyupaya personally gheu naye
@@SUSHILYADAV-jm2ed please understand that tomato is a perishable food. You can't store it for long time or else it would get rotten and how many cold storage would required to do that do you have any idea?. Also, we know this year rain has got worst in most place and destroyed most the crops. So blaming Government for natural calamities won't make sense. Recently, government have ban Rice export to make sure people in India people won't suffer due to low production. So they have make sure to take action where ever it possible.
@@SUSHILYADAV-jm2ed did government control petrol prices, gas or phone recharge why they have control agriculture goods, farmers doing sucide , because of less profit in agricultural,, this season tomato price increase because of low supply high demand,
I saw some idiot asking why farmers are paying tax but not big companies. Farmers do not pay tax. That's why even Amitabh Bacchan registered himself as a farmer. As per section 10(1), agricultural income earned by the taxpayer in India is exempt from tax. Agricultural income is defined under section 2(1A) of the Income-tax Act. Farmers are the most exempted and overrated citizen in India. They do not pay taxes, they do not even have to repay loans. But a salaried person who pays 30% income tax has to repay loan with 25-40% rate.
I'll still say, farmers do not pay tax. Poor farmers do not pay tax, ultra rich millionaire farmers also do not pay tax. A salaried person has to pay tax and GST. Farmers can get 100% return on the GST. A salaried person does not get GST return on the products he bought for his job/earning like phone, laptop, internet, car, bike. A farmer gets 100% return on every item they buy for farming. Farmers could have sold directly to market. But they did no accept that law. @@secretstudy07
@@secretstudy07 that is why people ask to tax farmers who are earning a certain amount and exempt everyone else. For eg every farmer earning over 50 lakhs has to pay taxes. This naturally excluded all the small ones
Till my graduation i too have goal to become one of the good salaried person., but after knowing that 1/3 of tax on income looks very pathetic. Ofcourse its helps politician rather then needs !.My father is farmer who doesn't pay income taxes. This is what my insense pushing me through.
Exactly what you said only 6% of India pays the taxes. We are with a population of 1.4 billion and only 6% of our population pays the taxes of these people. And these 6% people are from the private sector and job population. One of the reasons why many Indians leave India is because of tax and not good facilities. There are a lot of farmers who have a lot of property and money but they cry about taxes and injustice. Things need to be changed for greater good. Also stop giving votes in the name of freebies! In the end it's your tax! The country won't run just by giving freebies, instead of that focus on development. Thanks a lot for covering this topic. Really appreciated it!
Government don't care about taxpayers, might be because of vote bank , as most of them not able to cast their votes due to their job location is far away from voting constituency. Remote voting should be there , but then comes security. Not sure how this will be resolved, private sector people will get some relief from tax
@@sachinparate8671 We have a lot of farmers and they are a huge vote bank. They will not give votes if tax would be implemented or they will do riots. One of the reasons the government is hesitant towards taking steps. If you ask me there is no person living better than a farmer in this country. They don't pay taxes, they get relief funds and beneficiary schemes. And they generate a good amount of money. There should be a benchmark for such farmers so they can pay taxes.
My law teacher once told me:Law(kanoon) sirf ameer logo aur company ke liye bna hai. 7:58 it is basically a scam but company has some benefit in law for saving tax. It is pure legal. New tax law should be ammended/modified accordingly to the companies and citizen living in the country.
I never comment on videos in TH-cam… this is probably the first. You/your team does amazing work and your approach to issues is fantastic. Best of luck and keep educating India!
India should also focus on other revenue sources such as making tourism industry better than ever. This will increase the income of individuals and will definitely create more demand for goods ans services and create more tax revenue. India should focus on quantity of people paying taxes.
A point to Add : Tax free countries won't invest much on Army, Space and arms research. These countries depend on other countries arms when thr is war. While India invest most of tax amount in research development of Arms, Army, ISRO etc. But yes, as said in the video, the remaining tax amount can be properly managed.
Yes, you both are absolutely right. Management k liye state and central government k beech co-operation bahut jaruri hai but yha toh state government ko rewariyan batne sey fursat hi nhi.
1) Remove Income Tax 2) Increase Indirect Tax 3) Whatever deficit print the money (Yes inflation will cross 20% but we will just have to adjust to this) Indian Economy will grow 13%+ guaranteed as NRIs will flood the economy with their dollars.
1) Remove Income Tax 2) Keep Transaction tax 4% on everything. 3) Decrease Excise Duty 4) Custom Duty should be same 5) Foreign companies should be taxed 6) Corporate Tax policy India : 2.5% Foreign : 10% - 20% 7) No property tax or other taxes
If tax is decreased Per capita income and gdp will be more. And all the black money comes out. As a result we will be able to get more tax then the present tax.
From many days I was thinking about the tax on agriculture, whenever Political parties talk about agricultural revenue. According to my knowledge, there was time when farmers used to pay taxes based on their production even during golden era of our history and india had good economy but after independence India didn't took any taxes from farmers still their condition is not good
The problem is that only 10% farmars have their own land and others are working as a labour in their land. The owners get rich and they buy those luxurious thing but called as a farmar they get exempted
Hello Abhi & Niyu. I watch your videos daily. I do miss some but I do watch as much as I can. So in this video when you said About taxes on Agriculture, I think you should have also mentioned about what was the Agriculture income recorded for last 3-5 years so as a viewer I have a gist of what figures we are looking it. I might be wrong here but these are just my thoughts. Thank you for creating quality and super informative content. Keep up the good work. Is Desh to apke jaise crisp clear clean information conveyors ki zarurat he. You think this would be really cheesy but yes ye cheez muje aap take pohochane see farak padtha he :)
Abolish Income Tax and levy 1%BTT with 7%Gst on all including fuel while simultaneously pronouncing to gradually in 2 years remove high denomination currency's without affecting informal sectors
I have been paying tax for 8 years, a huge tax, still I do not have that much money so that I could buy a home, but the one who is not even earning is getting money from the government to build a home.
Very good content as always. I wish indian government watch this and take some points into consideration. Btw tax payers are increasing every year but you got valid point. I am one of the 6% people paying tax and I hate the injustice in the Indian taxation system. Wish you luck and hope you grow fast and reaches many more
Mpl jesi gamingg company ne 350 logo ko job se nikal diya he. 58 percentt taxx ke karan. Gamingg fantasyy industry me kai jobs jane wali he aane wale time me.
Watching ur videos really enhances our way of thinking about our surrounding n our society. In this respect I would request u to make a video on the following 1. Can a common person like me start a new religion 2. Is there any constitutional provision related to this 3. What type of problems may I face 4. What benefits may the society get with one more religion when there r already so many 5. Compare whether new religion will b better or improvement in existing ones r better
"Your content has truly changed my perspective and enriched my life. Your passion and dedication shine through every video, making it an absolute joy to watch and learn from you. Thank you for being an inspiration! 🌟🙏"
Very relevant topic! Thanks 🙏 ...also, how/ what % of tax collected fr one zone/ state is ploughed back to that zone/ state has to be transperently stated! Citizens should hv the right to information and this aspect should be declared every quarter by all govts - Centre and state ( barring which relate to national security) ...
In this era of super high inflation where there is no pension,no welfare schemes still FD rates are very low which was 12-13% during 2012-13 when inflation was not so high but now despite being high inflation there is no relief.
If you term current inflation as super high, then 2010-13 would be super super high pro max inflation. FD rates would definitely be such high, when you got inflation in double digit during 2010 beginning
Your content is so simple and connecting. My grandma who who don't know anything about taxes and all also liked this video. Aur y complement aapko dene se mujhe farak pdta h 😂❤
Hi Abhi and niyu Can u pls make a video on fundraising platforms like Ketto/ Milap etc .? Are they 💯% genuine or fake ? Should we make donations through them or not ?
Aap Jo bol rahe ho woh bhi sahi hai, Lekin financially socho, Karjmafi karna, Awas, Girls ke liye policies, Naya Infra structure, specially Tremendously Increased , Population sabse badi problem lag rahi hai, ab Isko control karna Important hai, Ispe aap ek Informative video banayiye, Bahot important hai.
Thanks team for making the video on this topic, topics raised by TH-cam channels like this will definitely bring attention and I hope in future our government will come up with the solutions on this critical concern.
actually most of the ppl and charted accountants search ways to evade taxes in all possible ways. this is because of higher rates of taxes... if the rate of taxes comes down, the number of tax payers will also increase. everyone wants to be relaxed by paying a small or simple amount of tax and no one wants to evade it. this way number of tax payers will increase a lot from 6%. taxation is right but heavy taxation is wrong.
Agriculture income tax should be imposed but also farmer should be paid atleast 1.5 times to his produce even if the food is surplus. Also weather unpredictability and his loss should be covered under insurance. Meaning Farming should be made easy and less risky
Keep it up Guys we are with you! One thing i that i wanna ask to you be honest can you make a vedio about 2024 election prediction and in past 5 years what does ruling party do that i have to say that i goona vote to them again. Happy Independence Day!Jai Hind Jai Bharat!
our govt charges half of the domestic air ticket fare for citizens . we pay 100 usd just to go home and visit our parents who are in the same country . (400km). govt charges 50 usd as tax for domestic airfare for own citizens . so just imagine how much they will charge for tourists. i request to include maldives 🇲🇻 in your videos next time . this place has interesting stuffs to make videos about
Damn the solutions!! 💯 Just 6.25% of us pay taxes and loads the burden of the whole country's development on the shoulders. And then ironically who don't pay taxes starts the blame game on the country's development. Also around 60% of people are just saved from paying taxes just like that! I mean what even!!? BTW thanks for the informative content. I hope it reaches everyone and open their eyes!✨
If you want benefit which is not under government control, its just not possible. Central govt use taxes for building infrastructure in highways, airports, railways, education, defense. Now, most taxpayers cry of local roads in bad condition, always filled with potholes. And that's not under central gov.
Sir you make a video on Swami Vivekananda. There are many things that many of us do not know about Vivekananda. For this you can use the Bengali book of "aochna aojana Vivekananda" author Shankar. Here we know Vivekananda anew. All information is logical.
What about the celebs..bolly celebs who buy property with complete mislead information..like suhana, Shahrukh's daughter bought properties by showing herself as farmers... These celebs buy huge properties unethically so that they could avoid tax
If people from agricultural, transport and industries pay appropriate taxes then millions of skilled formal employees will see a slight reduction in taxes but taxes coffers will be set ringing. Niyyat is required to show/educate how policies will work and how they will help india propel to 10 bn $ economy and household incomes raise to over 7k$ on average. Niyyat means intention... An intention for sabka vikas.
Good Video you can remove all taxes, because now a days everybody are using digital payment, so by removing all taxes, my suggest is to implement BTT Tax only that is bank transaction tax, so the govt is also benefited and also it lowers the burden on tax payers. Thankyou and your videos are very good.
Absolutely, integrating financial education into the Indian education system from an early age is essential. It would empower children with crucial life skills for managing money and making informed financial decisions, so people will know about taxes and it would directly or indirectly be beneficial to the country. A financially literate population can contribute to a stronger economy and better fiscal management.
1) Lord Macaulay impact in Indian education system 2) how improve Indian education system 3) Sex education important or not Place make video on that topic
Two issues One charging agriculture tax will cost the loss of vote bank for any ruling government. Even if you tell it will be only for rich farmers. Secondly, transparency in tax system is highly debatable. Honestly citizens of India are trained to evade taxes.
Definitely i also think the same. Tax collection is not wrong but It's utilization must be well. If our country utilizes its tax well, then it can become a strong, developed and powerful nation. Secondly, Tax payers should also increase. These two points are very important for development of India.
“Problem is not we are paying high tax. Probably is we don’t know that tax is spent at right place or not.” For addressing this RTI act was introduced, but some people are too much busy with hate politics that they are not utilising RTI.
If you are into 30% slab and you buy any Electronic goods and need to pay min 18-28% GST which will be in total 30+18=48% tax which is min. So ull end up working 6 months to Govt or may be more. There is a solution for this ...what ever the GST paid should be exempted from income tax irrespective of slab
Hey friends! If you liked this video, I'm sure you'll love our case study about Indian Railways! Check it out over here: th-cam.com/video/5H-phI9Z2_8/w-d-xo.html
Hi my father is a small farmer
Paddy prices so chip price how to improve prices solutions and and you are video in paddy prices in india
I like taxes increase taxes but kindly increase my savings also 😅😅😅😂😂😂
Bihar me jo bridge gira hai uska sara paisa company degi kyuki vo bridge under construction tha thoda search krlo aap phele
Ek rupees v government ka waste nhi hua bihar ke bridge girne se na public ka 1 rupees ka nuksaan hua h
But jo gujrat me bridge gira jisme bouth log mar gye uska kya hmesa bihar ke bare me hi kyu bolte hai log
Truly said. Problem is not paying high taxes. Problem is knowing that the tax I pay is not getting utilised at correct places and goes in corruption.
Its political marketing investment 😅
So true
Problem is paying high taxes. Most things that improve your life come from private companies. The things that you get from the government are the ones where you are forced to buy from the government like roads, rails, etc.
If the government took much less taxes and only handled essentials like courts, military and legislation, we would have much better quality of life as private companies would compete to make a profit.
@@lostledgerbut in that sinario govt is actually working monopoly..so there will be no competition among private companies. Prices will increase severally..
🤣😆100% corruption evry citizen knows but wht to do lol
One point related to taxing the farmers is the concept of true income. Cash is untraceable. As soon as we start taxing them they will start hiding it. The first thing we need to remove all currency above Rs. 100, then after a few years 50 and later completely. When all transactions happen online, thanks to UPI, we will have end to end visibility. Everyone's real income will become visible.
My dad talks about this same thing and his prediction is that government will stop notes of 500 and 100 within next 5-10 years.
@@FOH-with-Dr.KabirManchanda highly doubtful. Politicians distribute a lot of cash during elections. I don't think they will stop doing that
YOU ARE AFTER FARMERS INCOME ?? THEY ARE NOT GETTING VALUE FOR THEIR PRODUCT AFTER LOT OF EXPENSES , HAVE YOU NOT HEARD THE SUICIDES OF FARMERS ALL OVER INDIA . THEY FEED ENTIRE NATION , AND THEY DONT GET PENSION . INFACT FARMER SHOULD BE CONSIDERED AS A GOVERNMENT WORKER . I AM NOT TALKING ABOUT FARMER LOOTING BUSINESS MEN . THEY ARE REALLY DISGUISED AS FARMER BUT BUSINESS MEN .
@@jkj1459 my dumb friend I am referring only to the rich farmers.
@@jkj1459FOR rich farmer sir .. who earn more than 1 crore in a year .. 😊
As a tax payer, I'm not asserting that we don't wish to pay taxes. However, it would be beneficial to provide additional benefits to tax-payers as they are the ones financially providing for the needs (loots) of our leaders as well.
If 20-30% of population starts paying taxes, most of the problems will get fixed automatically
Most of the government employees refund their TDS without any good reason
@@abrahamg-kc7cx We are also paying 30% Tax + cess and average 18% GST and many other taxes to the goverment.
Alteast goverment should have to provide good education and health infrastructure for every individual.
That is all we want Because privatization in education and health sector is not good at all.
@@abrahamg-kc7cx i think most people who are financially stable and paying taxes would jump to uk if given a choice!!
@@abrahamg-kc7cx look at uk and then look at india also. Major difference. Governement uses most of the tax payers money in underlying corruption and distributing freebies to different communities so as to secure their vote
I was thinking of agriculture tax and planning to write up a document to the ministry.. good to know someone else is also feeling the same way
jab bade bade tech gaints tax pay nahi karte tab theek hai kya??
We needs to focus on -
1) Controlling corruption and scams - Longer jail punishments for convictss, stricter regulations on working bodies in government departments - Proper ulitizations of government must be a priority for centre and state government.
2) Taxing farmers who earns more than 50 lakhs in profits
3) Finding ways to tax unorganised sectors individuals who earns more than 15 lakhs in profits in a year -
These inculdes - Pan show owners, Kirana store owners, Vendors & Sellors of goods with shops at some scale etc
- They will gives lakhs crores of taxes
4) Encoraging people if they earn good enough to spend back in economy as it puts a lot of money in circualtion casuing interest rates to go down if followed for long enogh period in all sectors.
सरकार को सभी सरकारी कार्यों में पारदर्शिता लाने की आवश्यकता है एक सुई से लेकर महल , पुल या जो कुछ भी सरकारी पैसे से बनता है उसकी सभी जानकारी सार्वजनिक रखने की आवश्यकता है ताकि यदि कोई व्यक्ति सरकारी पैसों का गलत इस्तेमाल करे तो जनता उसके जानकारी के साथ विरोध कर पाए।
Right
The second you say tax the profits, like all businesses these people will start showing less profits nd more deductables. There should be a tax on their revenue like the salaried class nd then income tax returns need to be filed. The slabs can be decided upon but based on revenue and not profits
@@alokapte7308 Thanks bro for correcting my mistake !!!! 👌
Population control for limited resources
Despite paying so much tax, you can't get any work done in any government department without giving bribe to government employee.
Abhi indian gamingg fantasyy par 58 percent taxx lagaya he is sarkar ne world ka highestt 😅😅😅😅😅😅
Agree but we don't vote for party who say we will work for you without corruption
Tax is killing us
58% of people have registered as agriculture as their source of income. But most of them are not into agriculture.
True. I have seen that in real life.
elaborate pls
@@GoGnBowlTorChowrMany people do agriculture to hide their black money.These are richest among them.
Atleast 58percent ppl are smart
Hostel Or pg par bhi ab student ke liye 12 percent gst taxx laga diya he.
feeling goosebumps in every video when u say. aur yahi baat ,aap tak pahuncha ne se.. MUJE FARAK PHADTA HAI
It's high time GOI should tax rich farmer as well. Recently we have seen how 3-4 farmers have earned more than 4-5 cr by selling tomato.
If they incurred any loses than they should get a chances to offset that loses similar to what we do in case of loses in equity or mutual fund while filing IT returns.
It's one lottery bro did u see before farmers thorw their goods because of less price even they did not get what they invested farm
@@abhishekpawar5888dosta, tyani je 4-5 crore kamvale na te tu ani me sudha nokari karun 100 varshat pan kamau shknar nahit. jar nokri karat asel tar ajibatach nahi.1 CR choti amount navhe , KBC madhe core jinkle tari tax kapun rakkam milte ti pan one lotterich na..ase kityek sadhan shetkari ahet je thode thode navhe tar 50lkhs cha profit varshala kamvatat mag tyani tax ka pay Karu naye? Ani tumhi Amhi 10 -20 lkh kMavun direct tax tar bhartoch sobat indirect taxes hi bhartoch. Pratyekachya kaminusar tax charge zhalach pahije..tax che burden fakt private sector varach ka lavycha mag..saglyana fyda pahije facility havi ahe tar tyani tax suddha bharla pahije..me ithe fakta sadhan shetkari ani chote dukandar Ani dhandewalyanbabat bolat ahe. kyupaya personally gheu naye
I disagree with you , it's government failure to not control price of tomato, so imposing heavy tax on govt own failure does not sound reasonable.
@@SUSHILYADAV-jm2ed please understand that tomato is a perishable food. You can't store it for long time or else it would get rotten and how many cold storage would required to do that do you have any idea?. Also, we know this year rain has got worst in most place and destroyed most the crops. So blaming Government for natural calamities won't make sense.
Recently, government have ban Rice export to make sure people in India people won't suffer due to low production. So they have make sure to take action where ever it possible.
@@SUSHILYADAV-jm2ed did government control petrol prices, gas or phone recharge why they have control agriculture goods, farmers doing sucide , because of less profit in agricultural,, this season tomato price increase because of low supply high demand,
In last five years UAE, Oman, Qartar have introduced 5% VAT on all Goods & Services.
I saw some idiot asking why farmers are paying tax but not big companies.
Farmers do not pay tax. That's why even Amitabh Bacchan registered himself as a farmer. As per section 10(1), agricultural income earned by the taxpayer in India is exempt from tax. Agricultural income is defined under section 2(1A) of the Income-tax Act. Farmers are the most exempted and overrated citizen in India. They do not pay taxes, they do not even have to repay loans. But a salaried person who pays 30% income tax has to repay loan with 25-40% rate.
Then go and do that. And If you don't want to do it than don't give this judgements. Farmers hardly earns 5-6 lacs(except some farmers)
@@secretstudy07 check income of punjab hariyana farmers 🤣
You said farmers not haryana&punjab farmers. And farmers means farmers from everywhere around the world
I'll still say, farmers do not pay tax. Poor farmers do not pay tax, ultra rich millionaire farmers also do not pay tax. A salaried person has to pay tax and GST. Farmers can get 100% return on the GST. A salaried person does not get GST return on the products he bought for his job/earning like phone, laptop, internet, car, bike. A farmer gets 100% return on every item they buy for farming. Farmers could have sold directly to market. But they did no accept that law. @@secretstudy07
@@secretstudy07 that is why people ask to tax farmers who are earning a certain amount and exempt everyone else. For eg every farmer earning over 50 lakhs has to pay taxes. This naturally excluded all the small ones
Till my graduation i too have goal to become one of the good salaried person., but after knowing that 1/3 of tax on income looks very pathetic. Ofcourse its helps politician rather then needs !.My father is farmer who doesn't pay income taxes. This is what my insense pushing me through.
Exactly what you said only 6% of India pays the taxes. We are with a population of 1.4 billion and only 6% of our population pays the taxes of these people. And these 6% people are from the private sector and job population. One of the reasons why many Indians leave India is because of tax and not good facilities. There are a lot of farmers who have a lot of property and money but they cry about taxes and injustice. Things need to be changed for greater good. Also stop giving votes in the name of freebies! In the end it's your tax! The country won't run just by giving freebies, instead of that focus on development. Thanks a lot for covering this topic. Really appreciated it!
Government don't care about taxpayers, might be because of vote bank , as most of them not able to cast their votes due to their job location is far away from voting constituency. Remote voting should be there , but then comes security. Not sure how this will be resolved, private sector people will get some relief from tax
@@sachinparate8671 We have a lot of farmers and they are a huge vote bank. They will not give votes if tax would be implemented or they will do riots. One of the reasons the government is hesitant towards taking steps. If you ask me there is no person living better than a farmer in this country. They don't pay taxes, they get relief funds and beneficiary schemes. And they generate a good amount of money. There should be a benchmark for such farmers so they can pay taxes.
@@ryuzen789did u visit any farm lands or ask any farmers what is their situation I am farmer farmer have to work day night to grow their goods
@@abhishekpawar5888 I am talking about the ones who make crores and above 50 lakhs.
Just use Punjab and Haryana farmers to be specific then. Up, Mp, Bihar farmers are barely surviving and even MH farmers have high suicide rate.
The best thing you do is giving solutions...
Thanks a lot...
😊❤
My law teacher once told me:Law(kanoon) sirf ameer logo aur company ke liye bna hai.
7:58 it is basically a scam but company has some benefit in law for saving tax. It is pure legal.
New tax law should be ammended/modified accordingly to the companies and citizen living in the country.
I never comment on videos in TH-cam… this is probably the first. You/your team does amazing work and your approach to issues is fantastic. Best of luck and keep educating India!
India should also focus on other revenue sources such as making tourism industry better than ever. This will increase the income of individuals and will definitely create more demand for goods ans services and create more tax revenue. India should focus on quantity of people paying taxes.
Yes. I used to see lot of foreign tourists at heritage town Badami Karnataka in childhood. But d trend has come down since many years
Hostel Or pg par bhi ab student ke liye 12 percent gst taxx laga diya he.
A point to Add :
Tax free countries won't invest much on Army, Space and arms research.
These countries depend on other countries arms when thr is war.
While India invest most of tax amount in research development of Arms, Army, ISRO etc.
But yes, as said in the video, the remaining tax amount can be properly managed.
Yes, you both are absolutely right.
Management k liye state and central government k beech co-operation bahut jaruri hai but yha toh state government ko rewariyan batne sey fursat hi nhi.
1) Remove Income Tax
2) Increase Indirect Tax
3) Whatever deficit print the money (Yes inflation will cross 20% but we will just have to adjust to this)
Indian Economy will grow 13%+ guaranteed as NRIs will flood the economy with their dollars.
1) Remove Income Tax
2) Keep Transaction tax 4% on everything.
3) Decrease Excise Duty
4) Custom Duty should be same
5) Foreign companies should be taxed
6) Corporate Tax policy
India : 2.5%
Foreign : 10% - 20%
7) No property tax or other taxes
Inflation has to be decreased
To decrease it we have to cut our debt
If tax is decreased
Per capita income and gdp will be more. And all the black money comes out. As a result we will be able to get more tax then the present tax.
There should be distribution of taxes per capita.
@@TechnologyQuest369 right
From many days I was thinking about the tax on agriculture, whenever Political parties talk about agricultural revenue.
According to my knowledge, there was time when farmers used to pay taxes based on their production even during golden era of our history and india had good economy but after independence India didn't took any taxes from farmers still their condition is not good
The problem is that only 10% farmars have their own land and others are working as a labour in their land. The owners get rich and they buy those luxurious thing but called as a farmar they get exempted
I wish government apka ye video jarur dekhe👍 you are doing such a great job 🙏
Consistent videoes from you guys is a blessing. Please keep uploading.
You guys are the only sensible youtubers India have. I feel proud/glad to subscribe you
Hello Abhi & Niyu. I watch your videos daily. I do miss some but I do watch as much as I can. So in this video when you said About taxes on Agriculture, I think you should have also mentioned about what was the Agriculture income recorded for last 3-5 years so as a viewer I have a gist of what figures we are looking it. I might be wrong here but these are just my thoughts.
Thank you for creating quality and super informative content. Keep up the good work. Is Desh to apke jaise crisp clear clean information conveyors ki zarurat he.
You think this would be really cheesy but yes ye cheez muje aap take pohochane see farak padtha he :)
Abolish Income Tax and levy 1%BTT with 7%Gst on all including fuel while simultaneously pronouncing to gradually in 2 years remove high denomination currency's without affecting informal sectors
I’m Canada we pay provincial and federal tax: depending on how much you make , you can pay up to 30💯taxes
Yeah , People pay upto 42% in Scotland.
And it helps to provide public facilities.
We also pay taxes on everything we buy gst tax 13% and property taxes,( if you own property) on top of 30% from our payroll.
@@abrahamg-kc7cx i think most people who are financially stable and paying taxes would jump to uk if given a choice!!
I have been paying tax for 8 years, a huge tax, still I do not have that much money so that I could buy a home, but the one who is not even earning is getting money from the government to build a home.
Very good content as always. I wish indian government watch this and take some points into consideration.
Btw tax payers are increasing every year but you got valid point. I am one of the 6% people paying tax and I hate the injustice in the Indian taxation system. Wish you luck and hope you grow fast and reaches many more
Dear sir if u use only cash then u can save this 6℅also sad reality of india.. 😢
Hostel Or pg par bhi ab student ke liye 12 percent gst taxx laga diya he.
Fanatasyy gaming par 1 oct se 58 percentt taxx lagaya he is sarkar ne 28 percent gst and 30 percent tds. Jo ki world ka highest he 😅😅😅
Mpl jesi gamingg company ne 350 logo ko job se nikal diya he. 58 percentt taxx ke karan. Gamingg fantasyy industry me kai jobs jane wali he aane wale time me.
Moral of the story, Tax is the important things to grow Indian economy 👌
GST is gabbar singh tax
@@abhinavpawar6794 That's what helping the economy to achieve sustainable healthy growth and having record tax collections
@@Global-Netizen Andhbhakt spotted 😂😂
Bhai economy ke chakar mai hamara hi kat Raha hai
You guys define every topic very well, doing great ❤
You both are just great 👍 making good stuff video on very nice topic 😊❤
Watching ur videos really enhances our way of thinking about our surrounding n our society. In this respect I would request u to make a video on the following
1. Can a common person like me start a new religion
2. Is there any constitutional provision related to this
3. What type of problems may I face
4. What benefits may the society get with one more religion when there r already so many
5. Compare whether new religion will b better or improvement in existing ones r better
"Your content has truly changed my perspective and enriched my life. Your passion and dedication shine through every video, making it an absolute joy to watch and learn from you. Thank you for being an inspiration! 🌟🙏"
UPSC crack karlega?
@@rascal.elder6594 bro your name suits your mindset
I spy chat GPT
More than 30% of tax payers money goes to politicians, bureaucrats, government servants and corrupt public works company/tenderers
And your comment made my day!
Guys, you are amazing.. thanks a ton for working hard and bringing all the hot topics which should be discussed on all the media platforms..
Very relevant topic! Thanks 🙏
...also, how/ what % of tax collected fr one zone/ state is ploughed back to that zone/ state has to be transperently stated! Citizens should hv the right to information and this aspect should be declared every quarter by all govts - Centre and state ( barring which relate to national security) ...
Very well said!
ain't gonna happen
बहुत सही सलाह है आप दोनों की भारत के सिस्टम को 1 कदम इसी विचार पर बढ़ाने चाहिए, ताकि टैक्स देने वालो की संख्या बढ़ सके |
In this era of super high
inflation where there is
no pension,no welfare
schemes still FD rates
are very low which was
12-13% during 2012-13
when inflation was not so
high but now despite being
high inflation there is no
relief.
If you term current inflation as super high, then 2010-13 would be super super high pro max inflation. FD rates would definitely be such high, when you got inflation in double digit during 2010 beginning
@@Global-Netizen Gawaar spotted
@@Global-Netizen Rs.2 has been credited in your account by BJP IT cell!!!!
You Both are doing very excellent work 🎉 👏 👏 Stay blessed forever Abhi niyu🙏
Congratulations in advance for 5 million fam ❤️
5:25 aise hi sirf investment se citizenship de dena national security se compromise krna nhi hoga?
The best alternative to Income Tax is a Land Value Tax. LVT is called the perfect tax for a reason. Please make a video on this topic!
Your content is so simple and connecting. My grandma who who don't know anything about taxes and all also liked this video.
Aur y complement aapko dene se mujhe farak pdta h 😂❤
another video idea can be - Can Indians get/ buy citizenships in other countries? like these Islands nations?
Yes, infact some carribbean islands are visa free for Indians. Though their aren't any direct flights.
The topic covered very well ❤
Hi Abhi and niyu
Can u pls make a video on fundraising platforms like Ketto/ Milap etc .?
Are they 💯% genuine or fake ?
Should we make donations through them or not ?
Aap Jo bol rahe ho woh bhi sahi hai, Lekin financially socho, Karjmafi karna, Awas, Girls ke liye policies, Naya Infra structure, specially Tremendously Increased , Population sabse badi problem lag rahi hai, ab Isko control karna Important hai, Ispe aap ek Informative video banayiye, Bahot important hai.
Love & respect from WB❤
very good nice advice my know uncle farmer has 10cr in his almirah and apid 0 tax.
Abhi and Niyu, in the Gulf there is VAT and municipal taxes too
VAT is not a direct tax. It's indirect tax. 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Fantastic video both. Love from Delhi. ❤
Thanks team for making the video on this topic, topics raised by TH-cam channels like this will definitely bring attention and I hope in future our government will come up with the solutions on this critical concern.
I completely agree with the point of charging the agricultural sector beyond a certain bandwidth! It is extremely imperative!
actually most of the ppl and charted accountants search ways to evade taxes in all possible ways. this is because of higher rates of taxes... if the rate of taxes comes down, the number of tax payers will also increase. everyone wants to be relaxed by paying a small or simple amount of tax and no one wants to evade it. this way number of tax payers will increase a lot from 6%. taxation is right but heavy taxation is wrong.
You are right, this was the law of Chanakya
Videos acche banate ho sir and mam both
You guys should be the adviser to the prime minister or probably try politics, need some sorted leaders like you people!
Pm ko advice.. feku chachu bolenge .. Pakistan chale jao
😅leaders don't work intentionally, though there are more intelligent officers.
@@randomperson000 modi never left intelligents .. makes everyone andhbhakt. Whether anybody .. ias or ips
Agriculture income tax should be imposed but also farmer should be paid atleast 1.5 times to his produce even if the food is surplus. Also weather unpredictability and his loss should be covered under insurance. Meaning Farming should be made easy and less risky
Keep it up Guys we are with you!
One thing i that i wanna ask to you be honest can you make a vedio about 2024 election prediction and in past 5 years what does ruling party do that i have to say that i goona vote to them again.
Happy Independence Day!Jai Hind Jai Bharat!
It is mandatory to one nation one Tex and everything❤
So true.Beautifully explained I agree about the farmers who mint so much money still exempted
i am farmer too we dont earn that much lol🤣
even if you have 20 acres
our govt charges half of the domestic air ticket fare for citizens . we pay 100 usd just to go home and visit our parents who are in the same country . (400km). govt charges 50 usd as tax for domestic airfare for own citizens . so just imagine how much they will charge for tourists. i request to include maldives 🇲🇻 in your videos next time . this place has interesting stuffs to make videos about
Damn the solutions!! 💯
Just 6.25% of us pay taxes and loads the burden of the whole country's development on the shoulders. And then ironically who don't pay taxes starts the blame game on the country's development. Also around 60% of people are just saved from paying taxes just like that! I mean what even!!?
BTW thanks for the informative content. I hope it reaches everyone and open their eyes!✨
Who told you that only 6.25% of us pay taxes?? 😂😂😂😂😂
WhatsApp University Topper spotted 😂😂😂😂😂😂
100% people pay taxes i.e., each and every person living in India pay taxes.
There is a difference between direct and indirect taxes.
6.25% pay direct taxes but 100% Indians pay indirect taxes.
So mind your words.
Our problem not paying taxes our issue is not getting any benifits from Government in return
True that
If you want benefit which is not under government control, its just not possible. Central govt use taxes for building infrastructure in highways, airports, railways, education, defense. Now, most taxpayers cry of local roads in bad condition, always filled with potholes. And that's not under central gov.
@@Global-Netizen Does our tax money goes to Central Government only and not to the state government??
@@Global-Netizen 10 year old kidd spotted
@@Global-Netizen That's not how it works kiddo
Sir you make a video on Swami Vivekananda. There are many things that many of us do not know about Vivekananda. For this you can use the Bengali book of "aochna aojana Vivekananda" author Shankar. Here we know Vivekananda anew. All information is logical.
Tax based Reservation system need to be introduced... Quota should be thr in education, govt jobs, public transports, hospital n even in Rajya sabha..
This is a wonderful idea.
so basically you are asking government that none of these should be provided to tax payers ?
@@kopparapusiddartha4466 u got it absolutely wrong.. Jara dimag ka use bhi kiya kr bhai
@@Shivanishiv823 s it's.. There should be Social credits/points.. Just like loyalty points.. For honest tax payers
@@AJ-ij3cw i think you need to understand sarcasm. I got what the comment is about. I am implying that govt would take this other way around
Thank you....Abhi & Niyu
Jay hind jay bharat ❤❤❤
Bro bihar ke development ke baare me bhi ek video
Kaise hum bihar ko improve kar sakte hai
Kya kya galtiya hai kya kya hum log sudhar kar sakte hai😊
What about the celebs..bolly celebs who buy property with complete mislead information..like suhana, Shahrukh's daughter bought properties by showing herself as farmers...
These celebs buy huge properties unethically so that they could avoid tax
its not illigal
Really u guys had said my words I also agree tax paying is not problem but it's not using nicely by govt. ❤❤love u guys
Tax remove kar dege toh India mai corruption kaise bageda. 😂
If people from agricultural, transport and industries pay appropriate taxes then millions of skilled formal employees will see a slight reduction in taxes but taxes coffers will be set ringing. Niyyat is required to show/educate how policies will work and how they will help india propel to 10 bn $ economy and household incomes raise to over 7k$ on average. Niyyat means intention... An intention for sabka vikas.
India mai toh impossible ka shabd he nhi hai....bcz it's an developing country...yaha paiso ke kami nhi balki buddi ke kami hai😂😂
Bhai population also effect on incometax ...😂
@@nimishgupta5813 bhaiya nhi yaar 🥲 I'm a girl
@@ryzen_Op. par sabhi taraf se dekhe toh sara paisa govt. ko he jayegana😅😅
True hamare yaha sawal pucho to wo hum khate hi nahi hai 😂
Beta singapore garib desh tha tab bohot kam tax leta tha tab jake vaha company's set up hui or country develop hua
Great Solution at the end ❤️🔥
Good Video you can remove all taxes, because now a days everybody are using digital payment, so by removing all taxes, my suggest is to implement BTT Tax only that is bank transaction tax, so the govt is also benefited and also it lowers the burden on tax payers. Thankyou and your videos are very good.
Absolutely, integrating financial education into the Indian education system from an early age is essential. It would empower children with crucial life skills for managing money and making informed financial decisions, so people will know about taxes and it would directly or indirectly be beneficial to the country. A financially literate population can contribute to a stronger economy and better fiscal management.
1) Lord Macaulay impact in Indian education system
2) how improve Indian education system
3) Sex education important or not
Place make video on that topic
Two issues
One charging agriculture tax will cost the loss of vote bank for any ruling government. Even if you tell it will be only for rich farmers.
Secondly, transparency in tax system is highly debatable. Honestly citizens of India are trained to evade taxes.
Well said Abhi and Niyu. Highlighted correct points. Shared your hard work in twiter as this video needs more audience to understand the gap
Thanku sir & madam to teach us thanku so much
Really videos are imporoved🎉😮
you guys are GEM for Us.
Very well explained ❤❤❤❤❤❤
I was present there when this bridge was falling
I think if we're taxing agricultural income we should also give them compensation if their crops are destroyed by disasters.
Political Corruptions bahut zyada hai india mein, us par bhi ek dedicated video hona chahiye. Wo hamare economy par bahut zyada impact karta hai.
Now I know why we have started GST in India....
Thankyou so much ma'am for this amazing video ❤
You guys make very informative videos for our youth. New new things get to learn from your videos love it very much.❤❤❤
Definitely i also think the same. Tax collection is not wrong but It's utilization must be well. If our country utilizes its tax well, then it can become a strong, developed and powerful nation. Secondly, Tax payers should also increase. These two points are very important for development of India.
Thanks for this Knowledgeable Video it will help me.
I think the information you shared is so important. Please try to share in other regional languages also...
I am ready for this challenge 💪
“Problem is not we are paying high tax. Probably is we don’t know that tax is spent at right place or not.” For addressing this RTI act was introduced, but some people are too much busy with hate politics that they are not utilising RTI.
Love from Andaman guys❤ love ur videos👍🏼
Parliament ki karwahi nhi hone se bahut paisa waste hota hai, mp mla ki salary, pensions, lifestyle ghumne firne, corruption se bhi paisa waste hota hai , kuch log loan lekar videsh bhag jate hai usse bhi hota. Keval garibo ko mil rhi chhoti moti rahat wali yojanao ko badha chadhakar dikhane se koi fayda nhi hai. Baat puri batani chahiye
Very informative video, hope it reaches to Indian government
If you are into 30% slab and you buy any Electronic goods and need to pay min 18-28% GST which will be in total 30+18=48% tax which is min. So ull end up working 6 months to Govt or may be more. There is a solution for this ...what ever the GST paid should be exempted from income tax irrespective of slab
bhai edit bhut aacha hai apka...bhut time taking edit hai...but aacha hai.....