Nightwish Ghost Love Score Tarja-Anette-Floor 2005-2009-2012
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ต.ค. 2024
- Compilation of three versions of Ghost Love Score, performed by Nightwish and the three different frontwomen: Tarja Turunen @Lowlands 2005, Anette Olzon @Hartwall 2009 and Floor Jansen @El Teatro Flores 2012.
When I saw the NightwishOfficial video of this song: • NIGHTWISH - Ghost Love...
I was amazed by how well Floor fits into Nightwish only after having sung with them for two and a half months. A lot of fans argue about who is the best singer for Nightwish, and with this compilation I want to show that I believe Floor is the best singer for Nightwish today, the same as Tarja was in her early days. I know lots of you do not agree but the crowds prove otherwise.
Please leave your comments and thoughts if you want, but remember to be respectful towards the artists and your fellow fans. A little irony never has hurt anyone but please know your limits.
All rights to the music and performances belong to Nightwish and the Copyright owners.
The three videos I have used are courtesy of: NightwishOfficial, n1ghtwish4ever and chiriko87.
Anette absolutely could not do Tarja’s songs, but she nailed the songs made for her. She’s one of the reasons why I love Imaginaerum so much.
Agreed. She shines brightly on songs written for her, and she's the singer I first heard with Nightwish.
No other singer can do “Slow, Love, Slow” or “Scaretale” like her. It's a shame she only got one album of songs written for her voice, but you can really see what she's capable of there. She's good at drama, at emoting. Tarja could have never pulled those songs off, truth be told. Her main flaw was that she didn't have as wide an emotional range.
Yes, I did not like Annette singing Tarja songs live,years later I heard her collab with Russell Allen, and she sounded great. So Nightwish was not the right place for her.
@@jondelosarcos5983 completely agree storytime is made uniquely for her
Hurts to say but, floor couldn't do better imaginaerum better than annete
Floor absolutely took Imaginarium to a whole new level
I've had the privilege of seeing Nightwish with all three singers, once with Tarja and twice with Annette and twice with Floor. The band's dynamic was different with each singer. Each show was amazing. Such a fantastic band.
Tarja full opera, Anette pop, Floor symphonic metal all three has given their contribution for the band and their own flavor to the songs
This is probably Nightwish’s most vocally punishing song. It is not suited to Annette’s voice so she made changes to suit her voice. Tarja and Floor can both handle this but Floor has more power and uses it to her advantage. I mean no disrespect to Annette. She did well on her two albums. This piece is just not suited for her and given that she put in an excellent effort.
Tarja has a lot of outfit changes, so I think she needs a little extra time there. Floor just REALLY likes this song....a lot....and it shows. I absolutely love Tarja so it kinda pains to say that Floor edges her out on this song on the versions I have heard. I have noticed Tarja will go 90% sometimes. Floor seems to go 100% more. Tarja did say she found the tours to be exhausting.
Tarja seems like she’s lagging behind the beat, if that’s a thing. It’s just off with the music.
Annette couldn’t handle a lot of their songs, she was a bad fit for Nightwish
@@vickieeh1 Annette has a nice voice, but not the kinda voice you need for the Nightwish songs. I really like what she does with The Dark Element and the songs really fit her voice (or vice versa)
Excellent analyze, I 100% agree.
Emppu smiling at the end says everything to me. The level of compromise of Floor and their friendship made it possible. She was the missing piece for them.
Абсолютно точно!
Floor the Warrior, Tarja the Sorceress, Anette the Fairy xD
because in a fairy tale, everyone gets a happy ending
Holy shit that is correct!! I enjoy them all but yes Anette is the softer and weaker one...not bad but yes...the Fairy, Tarja like you said...Sorceress but Floor...Damn...you hit it on the dot...WARRIOR! Your comment is probably the best and most accurate and fun
Tellulun
Tellulun You summed it it perfectly x
80 LVL
The very problem is that Anette has got a completely dirfferent voice, so (of course) it is hard for her to sing Tarjas songs. But... I wouldnt want to hear Tarja singing Bye Bye Beautiful either... Literally!
Actually, I think it would be really interesting to hear Anette singing Elan.
Tarja singing Bye Bye Beautiful would be intriguing due to the subject matter of the song...
Anette is pretty weak on stage even with her own songs...i mean with song that was written for her. Even Tarja has some difficulties. Thats why everyone loves Floor: her performances are always polished.
believe me she would have sung and even better than Fleur and Anette
Well Annette can’t sing Tarja songs Tarja shouldn’t sing Annette’s songs………and floor can sing the phone book on stage and everyone would rock out!!!!
Emppu's reaction after Floor hits that last high note is the cutest thing ever.
I have listened to all 3 versions a few times, in my opinion, Floor puts the most emotion into the song.
Man, if I wasn't team Floor already, this video really would have convinced me. The song was written with Tarja's voice in mind, so it makes sense that she can pull it off really well. Annette is fantastic in her own way, but she just isn't made for Nightwish's older stuff. Floor though... Floor almost seems like she was born to be Nightwish's singer. Here's to hoping that she's there so long as Nightwish is going!
Five years later and she's still kicks ass, she's a keeper alright...
Truth be told, the ending is Floor's addition to the song. Tarja and Annette did not sing it because it's not an original part of the song. But that said, this "addition" briliantly fits the song and once one heard this version it's difficult to imagine this song without it. Even the CD version sounds "lacking" :)
Erm no. It doesn't belong there. Shows you are missing the point of the ending.
@Michael Vedal: According to the smile on Emppu's face he does not agree with you
True, I always liked Tarja's version till I heard what Floor did with it, she owns the song in every way possible. I never noticed before that Tarja didn't sing the operatic part that Floor does. I always assumed she did. I knew Anette didn't, but it was clear from the get go that she struggled with this song cause it is too demanding for her voice. However I applaud her for having the guts to perform it live, that must not have been easy for her. @Michael Vidal from what I heard the whole band loves what Floor did with the ending, or did you really think Tuomas would let her change something in his song that he didn't like? Get real.
@@littleraven28 I never said that Tuomasor tha band didn't approve of Floor's ending to GLS. I said that it ruins the song, at least for me and a whole bunch of others. There is more to a song than belting like she does.. But to each our own I guess. I just don't like it.
@@michaelvedal1907 Floor's ending, It's perfect in its expression and also keeps the ending measures from dragging. The ending measures after Floor's addition provide enough cool down to take in the actual ending. It also amplifies the vocals of the background choir. It's a fitting epic climax, a resolve much like the ending of Phantom of the Opera.
With all due respect to Tarja (who IS the "original" vocal of Nightwish, and the "sound" that made it what it was, and what it has become).... and the same due respect for Anette (she was AMAZING on "Dark Passion Play")... but seriously - NO ONE is better suited for this genre than FLOOR - she rolled this song up and SMOKED IT.
PERIOD!
Floor was MADE for this, and with her amazing vocal range, IS the new voice of Nightwish!
🙄
I can bet that since her first appearance she was claimed as perfect singer for this song. Like annette for imaginaerum (this song shows everything she's got and sound pretty cool), like Tarja is the only one who can sing Nemo properly.
@@angeltensey I agree, they all have songs that only they can sing best. Especially Tarja had like Phantom of the opera, nemo etc. That's why those and songs like stargazers etc were skipped much by Annette. But to say storytime was best with Annette.. I think the clip was awesome but the live version of her was like the first performance of floor really, skipping the end and high parts that floor started doing at her 2nd or 3rd show. But Annette seemed a more smooth in the difficult lines of storytime for sure.
And I agree that floor was really what Nightwish needed with their wide range of amazing masterpieces. Tarja was keeping them into the opera too much, Annette was too "weak" (with respect) and floor is well... Tuomas his Nightwish Dream
Agree 💯🤘
I'm in a wierd position when it comes to the different vocalists! I mean, Tarja is the one we all "Old" Nightwish-fans fell in love with in the beginning with the most epic album in that time period (My opinion), 'End of an Era'. Then Annette came along and made my favourite album, Dark Passion Play. And then it was Floor who just wipes the two before her to dust in live performance! So everyone has their pros and cons, but i think the band we all love so much has found their voice and for that, i am forever grateful, because that means I have the chance to see them live before they quit! :D
I don't agree with you when you say that that album was the most epic album or concert by Nightwish.
In truth, it was a performance where Tarja was below par due to the illness she brought with her from their South American tour.
She was sick, exhausted and psychologically affected by the shenanigans between her and the boys.
If you want to compare live concerts with Tarja, both "From Wishes to Eternity" and the "Summer Breeze Festival" are more epic than "End of an Era".
Don't get me wrong, I'm truly grateful, as a Tarja fan, that she was able to save her voice, during the day, so she could still give us that amazing performance, regardless of how sick she was
@@carlossilva7530 to be fair Floor was also sick and feverish during that performance in Buenos Aires. She still sang like an angel. I think this is the fair comparison. If Floor's performace was used from Wacken 2013 it would sound even better.
I think you mailed it right there I was saying the other day that Tarja sounds better in Studio, but Floor sounds better live and then there's Anette. I just don't know where she fits in...
@@carlossilva7530 give me a break, Floor just completed a whole tour while having breast cancer and a few years ago while doing the tour in Latin America she sang the whole tour while sick meanwhile still hit every F5 and every G5
@@myspacewolf Floor was diagnosed in October 2022 and had the tumor removed on November 18th. She was hopeful of joining the band for the European tour 2022 and not for any South American tour. Do you Floor emphatuated kids think we don't know how to look things up?
Poor Anette, i was hard on her in the past. She got dealt a low blow and I was all too happy to join the mob in her scathing exile when all she did was want so desperately to sing the songs I enjoyed as lullabies during my darkest evenings. How could anyone hate a woman who wanted nothing more than to stir their hearts... forgive me Anette. I forgot to keep the love going. You are a daughter of a night's wish, a goddess among her sisters and forever in our hearts. The Sorceress, the Faerie and the Champion, forever the bearers of our wishes, this night until the last.
+Krystal Myth Wonderful!
Look:in my heart Dark Passion Play and Imaginaerium WIll always be my favourites,i don't Even want to start,so it is hard for me,for example"Poet and Pendulum"and that 's just one heavy example,Anette bought Heavy contribution...of course everyone loves Tarja,but sometimes that is life stuff happens...and The CHOSEN ONE APPEARS FLoor Floor Floor!
Krystal Myth
You wisked my heart away...I'm a defender of Annette. She sang her heart out only to be met with diminishment and rejection. Tarja at that time was the top artist in the buisness and the pressure Annette was under was just so immense.
im not anrgy at anette but the band for kicking Tarja. Anette is also more a pop singer and just is awefully misplaced in a metal band. Floor is the most metal singer of the 3 but sadly thats the issue, for me nightwish was always unique and special cause they got a classical opera voice. with that special tarja gone it was just another metal band and i know better metal vocalists than floor. Nightwish is still a good band but its not among the best anymore
Well said! It’s all good. The “competition” is getting old.
Tarja: Opera
Annete: Pop
Floor: Metal!!
🤘
*Floor: everything!!!
Prefiero el dramatismo operistico de la potente voz de Tarria .
thats true, but I like all of them
Heavy duty/top
@@giacomocolturato2920 Agreeeeee!!!
I really like both Tarja and Annette, and I think we can all agree they both were fundamental building blocks in Nightwish's career, but Floor really was meant for Nightwish. She is nothing short of incredible with them.
Tarja is the myth, Anette the fairy and Floor is the fucking legend ❤️
True story
@ Primadonna I agree with the description. (but I also cannot not laugh at "fairy tail", sorry, it's just too funny lol)
@@julianne_warren omg it is DASHKJDAHKASDJ
Fuck yeah!
She looks like goddess
She sings like goddess
she is goddess
Floor has actually transformed every NW song I never liked into a song I do like. Why? The emotion, the interpretation....but above all the fact that she TRULY UNDERSTANDS this is symphonic rock, not opera or pop or alternative rock or whatever genre. She is one of the best live performers for all time.
Good job pissing on their history and their previous vocalists.
@@michaelvedal1907 Geez, so much hate. One could love one over the other without pissing on the bands history. Whats your problem? Can't handle another ones admiration for the current singer?
That’s funny, she’s transformed all the songs I used to like into ones I hate.
You still ask why?
Cause you're a moron, that's why
I like most of the songs better with Tarja...she does gls and devil and the deep dark ocean better but the rest suggs....Just listen to slaying the dreamer, deep silent complete.... Floor cant do Stakkatos and thats a Problem too...she is great but she didnt make the old songs bette
Floor is the type of a woman who can easily succeed in any other band or solo be that metal, pop, rock, opera or whatever.. her vocal range is a gift to humanity.
😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣
Nop, she can't sing opera
@@vol.145 yeah sure hehe,,,
come on...
@@vol.145 th-cam.com/video/UeTyAZtV5wI/w-d-xo.html
I always loved Tarja, but to be very honest, if I hear her now I find her voice a bit annoying. Don't get me wrong, she is a fantastic singer, but it all sounds the same to me. Especially compared to Floor, I love her voice, I love her range, I love how she can sing in different ways. And she totally rocks the stage. I wasn't a big Nightwish fan anymore when Annette joined, sweet girl and a nice voice, but no Nightwish material. Now that Floor joined she made me fall in love with Nightwish all over again, even more than the Nightwish with Tarja back then.
I feel exactly the same!!!! 100% agree with you!
Your comment is the best!
I feel sometimes that people think they can't love Tarja and Floor.. It's weird
She's a soprano, that's why
I have the same opinion! Floor is so much more versatile, flourishes every verse and takes all Nightwish song to herself, making her interpretation so much more convincing. Plus, she has an amazing stage presence!
Tell everything you want but for me Tarja and her voice in Nightwish is unreplecable. This song won't sound good without her. Of course Anette and Floor have got a beauty and power in their voices but for me to the first five albums fits only Tarja's voice. This albums ware made especially for her. I'll miss her forever. Nightwish became different since she had left. Of course still was and is fantastic band but... For me the previouses albums with Tarja indeed are the most dark, and truly gothic. Her opera-sound voice always send shivers down my spine,
"I think all 3 singers are equally great! I am first and foremost a Tarja fan. Then I got to listening to Floor and, yes I was 'FLOORED', as for Anette I respect her and I do think she is extremely talented in her own way! My point is, I got tired of the whole 'who's better than who' debate a long time ago. I mean, they're ALL EQUALLY AWESOME!!!!! Let's face it!"
lol
Floor is absolutely the best in my opinion, but the other two videos weren't the best quality as far as audio goes(in defense of Annette). that being said, I think Nightwish has the best vocalist for their sound now with Floor. she is absolutely phenomenal.
Look at the smile on that guitarists face when Floor nails that high belt. Even he had chills down his spine from that goddess
WITH FLOOR THE GUITARIST FINALLY GET`S WHAT HE WANTS TO HEAR.
:) Compare 5:08 vs. 10:46 ... Nothing more to say!
I can see a little bit of difference. Not too much tho xD
ToniAmsterdam Lmfao he looks so sad in the first one, and the second clip, he's having a floorgasm. XD
2005? Wasn't that right before Tarja was kicked out in that sexy drama open letter thing? If yes then you could say they just can't wait to get this over with lol.
@@toniamsterdam3910 facts
The song is amazing period. But Floor singing it gives the vibe of "didn't know a piece was missing until we found it". Takes it from one of the best metal songs ever, to simply one of the best songs ever.
I was at Floor’s third or fourth show with Nightwish. Even though she was sick and not in complete sync yet, you could just tell it was going to be magic.
This is definitely going to be Nightwish's most EPIC era. I mean, Tarja was an icon, as we all know, but she just wasn't into it it seems, sometimes. I mean she has the voice and the presence, and she can completely blow you away with it, but it was like "my part's over, lemme go" for her.
I like Annette, and I feel she is a good singer, but her voice isn't meant for songs like this! I feel they shouldn't have even performed these songs when they had Annette. I mean, it's like asking Tarja to sing pop. It just won't sound good! However, Annette really owned the songs which were written for her: Poet and the Pendulum, guys!? Annette had a different style, I don't think she deserves all this hate just because she didn't fit well into Nightwish's sound.
Do I even need to talk about Floor? My mind is blown. The epicness of that ending just made me stop breathing for a minute and think of the world, earth and everything else. This is a singer who goes SO well with the band! She's into the music, is headbanging, pulling off killer vocals and has the voice for Nightwish. I can't wait for the album!
***** Nice analogy! I agree :D
*****
If you can't shit, get off the pot.
well after listening to 4 songs, i guess there was too much hype, endless flop most remixes
floor is the girl!!
***** I agree wholeheartedly, although this is my first listen to Endless Forms Most Beautiful. Floor's vocals are well and good (as always) but they weren't wow. None of the songs did it for me, except for maybe Yours Is An Empty Hope. Then again, Troy Donockley's joining of the band should have been a hint to the folk direction Tuomas was taking it. tl;dr: excellent album, but lacking the epicness from Floor. sounds more like Once than anything new.
To people saying this is an unfair comparison because Anettes version was filmed with a cellphone. I can find a unedited clip from a cellphone with Floor that is even better than Floors version here (not as good quality of course) better performed.
you are right, but you dont need a high fidelity sistem to " see " that she cant even come close to Tarja or Floor on the high notes.
Just what i said.
That can be fixed:
Anette (+ over dubs/choir)
th-cam.com/video/bQl-Th-2vBI/w-d-xo.html
Floor
th-cam.com/video/gbn9GczYBkw/w-d-xo.html
And its not only the voice, it is also the emotion and stage presence. Anette is not a bad singer, but Nightwish is not her style.
Basically all say the same, that Anette was great with her songs and had difficulty reaching the vocal quality of the earlier songs for Tarja, who is a wonderful singer. Just Floor can perform all of them and more, even adding her own style and even more so enhancing songs written before she joined. That makes her one of a kind and so outstandingly awesome.
Tarja has a great voice and talent, Anette also with a different nice voice of a lighter color and she made a lot of effort, now Floor has the most versatile and super great voice and style, and she worked so hard to "not screw up" the songs she loved, that she now owns them all.
This story of Nightwish also gives hope, shows that never giving up in a crisis, which started with Tarja leaving, daring to go new ways will not only help to go on, but in the end all can become better than before. Nightwish and Floor found each-other, and now so many feel it is as if they have always belonged together.
"Floorgasm" is my favourite new word.
floor is a poser who simply tries to immitate the Queen Tarja.
GamerDares wins go f.. your self Floor have her style and she sing better than Tarja go lisen her stupid albums
ManowaRrrior88 haha we all know if Tarja wanted to re join them they'd ditch floor in a heart beat.
Tarja destroys floor
And Tarjas albums are the best, floors albums suck.
GamerDares wins Tarja sucks she only sing i opera style :D :D her voice dont have rock and puts everybody tо sleep :D and her albums she try to be a Nightwish copy :D phaha but ... she cant be Toumas is the heart of the band
Can't we just agree that Annette, Tarja and Floor are all pretty good singers? Personally I prefer Floor on the whole, but there are some songs Tarja does better.
I love Emppu´s face in the in "Floorgasm"!!!!!!
he is nice with Flor
10:04
Empuu is so damn cute. Annette can't sing the songs written with Tarja's voice in mind, BUT Floor does better than Tarja, with so much power. To be fair to Annette those songs are likely VERY HARD to sing unless you have a very special voice. Floor has a very great "look" that adds to the whole experience, and she has great "presence" her moves along with the voice, no wonder Empuu is grinning so much, and all of them are looking so damn happy with the performance, and you can tell that Floor is totally in synch with all of them, not detached like Tarja seemed walking offstage, UNLESS, she had done a costume change for the next song, and HAD to leave the stage or something like that.
@@juliegogola4647 Floor have very good singing technique, and what is most important she is artistic. Well dear Annette looks very lost and don't know how to move, what to do with her body and she totally didn't care about stage outfits, Tarja and Floor have very solid stage outfits
@@cree_VI I totally agree with you. I WILL say that I do love "Dark passion play" the CD, and Annette sounds good on it. Before seeing Annette onstage trying to sing songs written for Tarja, that Floor just does wonderful at singing, I would've NEVER had a clue that Annette could NOT sing them. I hadn't seen the outfits that Annette had worn (or hadn't worn) while performing until you had mentioned it. I hadn't really sought out to see Annette performing live, when I had seen her on the video where all 3 vocalists had been shown singing those songs which really show you who can't quite do the songs justice (which IS the video we are commenting on of course) Annette does a few of the songs on DPP better than Tarja or Floor ever could, because they were written for her kind of vocals, a more "pop" type of vocal delivery, it's kinda how it would be better to ride a jetski for short trips in the water vs sometimes you would need to have a nice speedboat/yaught for a longer trip. If that sounds stupid sorry tonight is "vodka drinking night" for me. Floor and Tarja ARE the "yaught/speedboat" and Annette is the "jetski" BUT, we should all be glad that Annette had been there to keep Nightwish performing and putting out good music. Annette and Marco on "The islander" does sound mighty good, Annette did only some harmonizing along with Marco, BUT, she did do a great job on DPP. I'm sure that most do agree on that.
Anette without a doubt is a refined singer, but her voice just can't stand up to the thunder this music requires. Tarja, so artful and intense, beautiful. Floor? Thunder, passion⁵, refinement, art of singing from here to kingdom come… Just so bloody perfect!
Mmm... I don't think so...
While I enjoyed the compilation a lot, the negative snipes at Anette are really off-putting.
Agreed. And like I said in another comment.. you can love all 3 singers and it's ok.
It's also a low quality recording compared the other two with Tarja and Floor.
The sad part is, probably no one in this comment section will be able to sing as well as Anette in their lifetimes
Truth hurts!
yep only a garbage human being would do captions like that, definitely not a channel worth any more of my time
Team Floor ❤
Edit. Floor has everything. The look, the stage presence, the dance moves and most importantly the voice of an angel on earth. I love her ❤
I can't imagine the joy and relief of original Nightwish fans when Floor joined. I've never known a singer slot in so perfectly to a band. The feeling of "Yes, now everything is going to be alright" must have been amazing.
Indeed. I fell in love with NW in 2004, Tarja was fired in 2005, I waa SOOOOOO gutted. I had a lot of hope for the following singer but while I loved the songs I just didn't like Anette's voice. Impossible to enjoy the magnificence of NW at that time.
I bought the Wacken show a few years ago, I had forgotten about NW at that point and BAM, massive surprise, new singer, hope was back. I literally cried hearing the first song of the show with Floor.
So yes, it was an intense feeling to be able to be in awe again, I feel so lucky to have discovered Nightwish twice!
Tarja put Nightwish on the card with her operatic voice and stage presence. She will never be forgotten for that.
Anette seems to be a very nice, upbeat person. But, her stage presence wasn't in sync with the Nightwish image. Her "poppy" voice worked in the studio with all the overdubs. But boy, it's unbelievable how bad she was live. It was like having a bad Britney Spears impersonator on stage. Even live she had to rely on the many vocal overdubs.
And then came Floor: a match made in heaven. She has the voice, the looks, the attitude. And besides that, she has no problem performing Nightwish songs from any era.
I can't help but thinking that this current lineup will bring Nightwish to a new level. Can't wait to see them live
+Albert van den Berg I have seen them live in Stuttgart a few months ago, a stop during their "Endless Forms most Beautiful"-Tour.
It was epic!
And they played Ghost Love Score there as well. That performance is something I will tell my grandchildren about. :-)
I cant hate on Tarja she was the origninal and this was one of her songs she wrote and performed. But its nuts how good Floor to take a song written by and to another strength and make it her own.
And now Floor owns almost all of Nightwish songs from the first album to the last... She is so easily singing all Nightwish songs on stage better than the originals...
@@GregSBTheEagle so not true
Prove it, StuntGamer...
So Anette's not a bad singer, but changing the rhythm of a song just for the hell of it can be annoying for diehard fans (of the song) like me :P.
Btw there are no regrets from me about Nightwish. Both former singers made awesome music, but Floor has done an incredible job of revitalising the old classics that were never the same once Tarja left. I for one am immensely happy and believe that Floor could allow Nightwish to surpass their awesomeness this time round.
Thanks Dude!
I wasnt up to date the last years, just listened to the cds. Never heard Anette live.
But since i heard Floor is singing for Nightwish ... =)
You really pointed it out:
- Tarja "left the stage"
- Anette "is still trying her best"
- and Floor ... well ... she fits perfect.
I never had so much fun listening to Nightwish.
And i know (everybody can see it) the band fucking knows what they just got.
Look at them in ghost love score. They all seem to have fun (again?).
I didn't even know Anette existed...I thought once Tarja was gone it was never going to be as good so I stuck with the old songs. I liken the situation to this, when Christian Alvestam left Scar Symmetry...they had to replace him with TWO guys. That is how epic some vocalists are. Floor had some big shoes to fill...and she absolutely owned it, and I will say, out shines even the best of Tarja. She has the soul for this music and is absolutely perfect for Nightwish. Forget Mozart...I'm glad I was around to hear Floor sing Ghost Love Score!
I love Tarja. I really love Annette. There’s no denying that Floor is a legend.
Here’s a positive comment that acknowledges all three singers are amazing I can get behind that..
I think the same, I have my own personal feelings and likes, but all of them are great, each one in their unique way. :)
Floor is the QUEEN!
Floor = Nightwish resurrected. Finally a talented singer again (who can compete with Tarja), with an insane vocal range might I add, not mention soprano abilities!
The little vocal parts Annette and Floor do at the end makes complete sense for the song. In the original, the last couple of notes for the vocals move upward, implying that something should come after, but there's nothing. Anette's isn't wonderful, though I appreciate her trying to capitalize on the moment and do something to relieve that tension. Floor's is, obviously, masterful.
Am I the only one _always_ getting full of emotions when Floor sings the parts at 5:42 and 10:42? Happens literally every single time I hear it, she's awesome!
I have just the same. It even give tears in my eyes every single time and no matter which performance of GLS it happens all the time when Floor sings this!! 🤘🏻🇳🇱
@@fritsyt2090 I didn't even know the last part was put in by Floor, and didn't exist before.
I was wondering if I'm the only one that ALWAYS ... yes you are so true :)
Nope you're not the only one 🥰
I love Trajas voice, the voice of an angel, not so impressed with Anette, but Floor is incredible, so much power, unbelievable. I think the most powerful female singer in the world
Tarja was and still is amazing I liked Annette she was good floor is amazing I hope ppl dont rank the singers off of this video it would be sad tarja helped this band become what it is floor will take it to the the next step
I'd say that Tarja has an amazing Opera voice, Anette has a very good poppy kind of voice, and then there's Floor who just has EVERYTHING!!!!!
That's pretty much exactly what I say
But Floor can't sing opera, she uses falsetto
@@vol.145 yeah that's why she just did phantom of the Opera with Henk Poort and the reviews are off the chart, but also she's not an opera singer and she's coming out and said that but then again Tarja can't belt, can't growl can't sing with grit simply because of her deep accent and vibrato...
@@vol.145 Definitely not always
@@vol.145 Floor NEVER claimed to be an opera singer, but you might wanna back that up - she just did Phantom Of The Opera with Henk Poort & the reactions were off the chart, and then she did the same with Nightwish with the same results! I'd LOVE to hear Tarja attempt to do Tribal, or 7 Days To The Wolves, or Greatest Show On Earth or Weak Fantasy - it wouldn't sound right cuz her deep accent and her strong vibrato - so you're talking TWO completely different singing styles! But we get it, you're stuck on Tarja...
Floor Jansen OWNS this song now! Tarja was great but the way Floor finishes it almost makes me cry every time I watch that Wacken performance. *and Anette was a pop singer who never really belonged in this band.
As much as I appreciated Tarja's singing (I mean, dayum son!), the only one that I actually care for is Floor. I remember her voice and power moving me in the After Forever days and what-if'ing about her somehow becoming lead for Nightwish.
Strange how the universe made that actually come true. But I am sure glad that it did.
I miss Tarja in Nightiwsh so much 😢😢😢
Floorgasm! Floor is the best that has happened to this band, ever!
Great video! Thanks! Floorgasm!
Floor is the only singer that gives me chills no matter what she sings and how many times i hear her. Loved the Floor encore you put at the end. Happy Emppu face.
Floor Jansen finally made Nightwish complete, and made the band really worth listening to. Floor has been the best thing that could happen to Nightwish, - she really rocks, and has a strong, broad vocal range, unlike the other singers. This video clearly demonstrates how Floor's talent and raw passion goes the extra distance and really connects with her audience.
I cant stop hear and watch this, hello from 2018! FLOOR WE LOVE YOU!
Great mash up, I also noticed that the band shows more energy with Floor and it looks like they have more fun with it too.
Good you noticed that, that was always my opinion too. I watched quite a few of their documentaries and Floor really seems one of the guys with no diva behaviour. Towards the end of the Tarja stage apparently she wasn’t ever bothered to show up for rehearsals anymore. That was one of the biggest issues that they made public. She had become a Diva putting herself above the band. Their breakup was very emotional for especially Tuomas. Hè wrote the Pendulum piece about his pain breaking up.
You sir, deserve an Oscar for cut, mixing and another one for your comments (which made me laugh)!
Good work, keep going!
With Floor, Nightwish is back to awesomeness. Appreciate it!
I choose Floor bc of her ability to use both chest voice and head voice perfectly. Tarja and Anette are doing an awesome job too.
Floor. The last piece. Nightwish is now perfect.
All you need to do is watch the band. The energy Floor injects into the performance is infectious. Not only that, Tarja and Anette have recorded chorus behind them at the end. Floor carries the entire song, without the recording, until the end. The song may have been written for Tarja, and she always did it well, but Floor has made this her song, hands down. It's her signature song for NW now.
Actually relistened to the piece and the recording is there for Floor, but pushed so far back as to be nearly unheard.
One other thing I noticed about the performances. Notice how Floor rules the stage from the center. Watching any number of videos with her and NW I can count on one hand the number of times she moves more than 3 steps from the center. This allows the band to be the band. She is rock steady and still pulls the audience in.
@@titus02906 That's also part of her vocal technique too. She stays grounded to give herself the correct breath support to pull off those spectacular notes like the ending of GLH. It's a big reason why she sounds as good as she does, she's not wasting breath and physical energy running around but putting it all into delivering the songs well.
Tarja is very good. But Floor. She is just on another level. Man I like Floor and Ghost Love Score.
What astounds me is how this song is like has always been meant for Floor's voice. It's almost next to impossible to better a studio version and yet she did it. Our valkyrie goddess did it. It's 2 weeks straight now i can't stop watching and listening to this song as soon as i get home and in the car also. And hell it brings me to tears every single time at the end with Floor.
Thanks for making this.
Floor is on another level !can't listen to her without getting goosebumps!
I agree though i love Tarja too, Anette has more of a "pop" song voice in my opinion. "Storytime" and "Ghost love score" from Wacken 2013 are just insane i think, i get teary every time i hear them
Awesome video, love Floor so much !
Floor is totally the best choice for the band. I love all the singers equally, and I mean, Dark Passion Play isn't the same without Anette, Century Child isn't the same without Tarja, and Endless Forms would not be the same without Floor. The thing is, Floor is the most versatile singer, I can't imagine Tarja being able to sing the songs made for Anette either Anette doing the songs meant for Tarja, but Floor can do at least a decent job in both cases. Not better, but capable of being as good as the past legends. Tarja and Anette are showing their full potential in their solo carriers, everyone should check it out! And floor is doing a good job keeping the legacy of the previous vocalists alive while also giving the fans her wonderful singing style. All I ask is respect since all the vocalists guided the band to the direction it is today, which is the perfection.
Past is past. Floor for the WIN.
They need to tour with Tarja and Floor singing harmonies. That would be the ultimate Nightwish lineup.
Duett? There are some Mixed Videos out there but...
... the only real one as i know was Tarja Turunen & Floor Jansen 'Over the hills' at Wieze in Belgium 20/10/13
Have a look: th-cam.com/video/57WsNYItbSU/w-d-xo.html
or: th-cam.com/video/XGwmQk_bBNg/w-d-xo.html
After Tarja left, I was heartbroken. Anette is not bad, but she was not right for the songs written for and performed by Tarja. To me at that time Nightwish lost their special touch. When Floor was announced, I didn't really recognize they could improve that much. I refused to believe another singer could top Tarja. Floor did it! It feels as if this song was written for her!
Only years later I discovered Nightwish again watching their live performance at Wacken 2013 (recording, not live, sadly enough). Since then I say... Tarja was great at this song, and unfortunately Anette could not hold a candle to Tarja in these songs asking for such vocals (but at least she made a best effort for the fans!), and after the split it was as if a miracle had happened... Floor came on short notice and soon made this song her own!
Sorry, Tarja, where Floor makes all audience have tears of joy in their eyes, goosebumps everywhere, cause racing hearts bursting with emotions, you were already gone from the stage. And Floor stayed with the band all the way rocking with them full of power. What a symbolic act. Floor rightfully earns her position, and her variability of the voice shows so much in this song. Floor really fits best to Nightwish after all, as she can add belt and grit, as well as classic singing where the other two nice ladies were simply staying with each of their one iconic styles.
PS: Just noticed I already wrote a comment 6 months ago. But I leave this one anyway. :-P
I was at the concert in Vancouver which was with there latest singer who is just wounderful, I will say that concert was the best night of my life.
Ghost Love Score BELONGS!!! To Floor. Period!!!!!!!!! I will always Love Tarja and Annette. But comparing this song with Annette vs Tarja vs Floor. Is just soo cruel to Annette lol. Poor girl. She was good for certain songs between Tarja and Floor. She was no contest to these 2 power Ladies!!!
Tarja was, is and will remain forever, the best frontwoman. I can say that it is about Tarja and the rest of the world. Comparisons can be made, but don't mix Tarja in these comparisons. Tarja is the Queen. Everyone has a personal style, talent and strength to convey messages to the public, to the fans.
Floor is the best ever, any genre, anytime. Her octave range is infinity.
Except in studio. Her voice is way too generic and it makes the songs sound more mediocre than they should.
Don't get me wrong, she's one of the most skilled singers on the planet but that doesn't really make her best at everything.
Lol, ok.
@@timestimesx7535 The reason her voice in studio sounds less than her normal, when you mess with perfection you can only negate it.
When I first heard this song with Tarja I didn't think it could get any better. Than I recently heard the version with Floor and I was stunned, because it was the best version of the song I had ever head. Tarja is a brilliant singer but I think Floors voice is more versatile/powerful than hers. Floor has always been my favourite metalsinger. Than for Annette she's a good singer but I don't think her voice is for this song.
Tarja and no one else!👏🔥
another Floorgasm, yet another and one more beautiful than the other, Its magical 😍😍😍, and Emppu face during this is fantastic 😂
I think between Tarja and Floor it’s just a matter of personal preference. I sometimes prefer Tarja, another time Floor, depending on my mood. Tarja has that dark, dark chilling quality to her voice and Floor has all the energy.
As for Anette - it isn’t her fault that she was in the middle of a band that felt it needed to redefine its identity. Had she recorded the original for this song, in her style, it would’ve been great.
Tarja is somehow overrated is blasphemy to compare floor with tarja is not even fair
@@pedjavukmirovic6770 Look, I'm really rather tired of this discussion but here goes:
Tarja has a very unique quality to her voice, her timbre is instantly recognizable and she emotes beautifully. She also has a three-octave voice and is a professionally educated classical soloist. Plainly, her voice has been trained to a standard that very few people are able to achieve even with hard work (or are permitted to even try to achieve, these programs aren't easy to get into) and she also has something that makes her stand out besides technical brilliance. On top of that she's made a complete genre of music go mainstream, 'opera metal' in that sense didn't exist until she as a young girl agreed to the experiment that Nightwish was at the time, while still holding her own successfully in the classical world and having a career there. So give her some credit.
Floor is a truly wonderful singer but it is by no means blasphemy to put these two on the same level. They have chosen to utilize their voices in different ways, yes. Tarja goes fully classical while Floor mixes it up with more chest voice. Floor was also a grown ass woman when she joined Nightwish, with completed training, a background in metal and having found her vocal style long ago; and Nightwish was an established band with an established dynamic and an established catalogue of music. She had the almost inconceivable task of uniting a very scarred and prejudiced fanbase and three vocal styles and I'm still in awe of how she managed that so perfectly.
Tarja was very young, talented but not exactly trained, yet, and jumping head first into an unknown adventure that had no known pattern or dynamic between the band members, while still training and developing her voice and style. Extremely different circumstances and challenges for these two singers that lead to different results.
Are the results "better" for one or the other? Objectively, no, I don't think so. However, music, singing, is art and we are absolutely allowed to subjectively prefer one over the other. Just like you're allowed to enjoy pointillism over cubism. Or to appreciate both equally. So if you love Floor - good for you, I love her, too. But if you insist on being rude without substance in response to my comment, you'll get this wall of text in reply and I challenge you to examine your mindset.
@@glockenrein Very well said!! I personally much prefer the vocal and style range, and stage presence, of Floor but had never really thought about how Tarja started, and the challenges she faced while breaking new ground at a young age. I really enjoyed your description of that - it gives me a new appreciation for her achievements.
i cant understand why some fans think tarja or annette are better than floor????
I think during the Annette era fans somewhat, reasonably, hoped or even expected Tarja's imminent return. Now that Nightwish have Floor Jansen I think that door has been officially closed.
Todas as 3 cantam pra caralho.
Mas a Floor domina a "Ghost Loves Score" de uma forma...
A versão do Wacken 2013 é simplesmente FUDEROSA.
Jajaja .sorry 😅
LLS Photography, thanks so much for putting this compassion together.
This song was made for Floor.....
chio infante That's what makes it's so amazing. It wasn't written for her, but she clearly owns it now.
Annette...sorry but it wasn't meant for her. Tarja...I love her operatic vocals. But this definitely goes to Floor. She hits those high notes with authority.
Opera isn't all about high notes tho its so much more many can hit high notes few can keep it clean and Tarja in her prime was one of the cleanest soprano's around some say Pavarotti and Maria Callas but i disagree Callas is good but the bad recordings kind of mess with the "clean" sound
Never was a huge fan of anette tbh, but tarja has such a nice and clean voice, and floor has such a powerful and touching voice. Love this video!
Nothing against anette ofc, but to me it always sounded kinda boring and didn't really fit the band too well
Sounded Anette a bit like ABBA?@@marsha4253
I love that each singer has their own spin on the song.
Each singer was absolutely fabulous!
Floor is absolutly the best singer for this song, her voice is perfect!!!
4 years of this video and I can't get enough of it!!!
floor is the best singer's nightwish she can make all style with her voice, she is the best ! long life to floor jansen!!!
floor is the best for the kind of music nightwish do. although anette isn't a bad singer. she has a diffrent lighter sweeter voice these songs are just better for tarja and floor. this is why they sound better. also floor i think is the best of the 3 in her technic as well
Coming from a big Floor fan here. There was a distinct difference in the audio recording quality every time you criticised Anette's vocal ability . This was not a fair comparison even if Floor and Tarja could belt it out - You have to be there in the audience to capture the moment and appreciate live music.
Floor best vocal this band ever have !!!
Floor fucking rulez!
Fuck yeah :)
must be the only one who thinks that she's under two others (in this video at least)
I never understood why Annette was hired in Nightwish. I am a singer, classical trained and sing rock (fun fact, I went to conservatorium with Floor) so I really know what I am talking about. The singing technique Annette uses is totally wrong, her breathing technique is wrong, she has NO power in her vocal cords, nor the lungs to hold on to long notes. In concerts her voice was often very off (singing wrong notes, majeur instead of mineur) she had problems to come above the musicians with her pretty weak voice.
Than people tell me Annette is a studio singer. Well lovely people, we can ALL be studio singers because everything can be tweaked, corrected etc. If you play in a Metal band you ARE a live performer. You will spend many more days touring than sitting in a studio.
After Annette said some nasty things about Floor ( how Britney (Floor) could replace Rianna (Annette) while Floor had to memorize the whole concert in 20 hours in the plane towards the USA....
I just don't think she is the sweet person people want to believe she is. She never said anything nice about Floor, Like Tarja did. Floor and Tarja are friends...Annette does not want anything to do with them. I don't think Tarja and Floor really mind :)
Multiple "Floorgasm's!!!!" Well done!
Years ago when I heard Floor first time with Afterforever I got scared, thinking well that¨s that Nightwish has a real competition on this genre and Floor sounded even back then so much more controlled and versatile singer than Tarja. It is Tuomas who kept Nightwish on course with his skills of composing and had some well playing bandmates around. He knew Tarja¨s faults and knew how to get best out of her music wise. Now on this video I want to thank you, you are first one who points out the middle section of this song, Floor¨s high notes and angry notes and oh boy, how does she tells the story!! Another thing is that Tarja used backing vocals ( 5:00) and that made her voice sound more powerful but kind of soft way, nice harmonizing when Anette and Floor did not and maybe that¨s why someone may feel their voices are not so full or rich?? On staccato part is the same with everyone. Floors voice is just so haunting and beautiful. Other thing that got my attention is that Floor seems to be the only one who¨s timing is as accurate as clock, she is hitting the notes on spot and just the right time and on the right tempo with music. Anette seems to sing this like the pop song making her own runs making the caracter of this song change and Tarja is singing the notes just a little bit too long so that seems to me she is just a little bit out of tempo of this song, then again the song can take it. And before anyone starts to debate with me- yes, I love everyone of these three singers with and without their strengths and faults!
You pretty much summed it all up here.
Timing is a tricky thing. I appreciate what Tarja was trying to do, because you can play with timing and make it more interesting to listen to. BUT you have to know when to play with your timing and in my opinion these moments (in this example) it needed the timing to be spot on. Floor can play with timing as well, but she's more subtle and she always chooses the right parts for it.
As for Anette..., she wasn't lucky with the sound quality of her performance, but it felt insecure. I don't have a problem with her using different melodies to suit her vocal qualities. And the lady can sing. But when you need to fill the shoes of someone who helped define the sound of the band and who's being loved by every Nightwish fan..., that's an impossible task. And then comes Floor who can do about everything and who DOES everything to make it work..., it's almost hard not to feel sorry for her.
In the first 4 Nightwish songs I ever heard Floor doing, I counted at least thirteen completely different voices she's capable of using. And she uses these different voices precisely where you'd want to hear them. And it's always the right voice for the right parts to make these parts even better than they already are. I've heard amazingly good vocalists who could alter their own sound for the same reasons, but even the very best ones were 'limited' in the number of different tones they mastered. Five, maybe six....., but thirteen?!?!?! And that's just four songs.
In all honesty, I never really liked Nightwish. But with Floor..., how can you not love her and admire her for everything she's capable of doing? I'm in a Floor flow for weeks now. I'm losing my sleep because of it. She just keeps amazing me. It's ridiculous!
It may not seem that way, but I actually never wanted to participate in that idiotic Tarja vs Anette vs Floor discussion. It's useless and for a huge part it's also a matter of personal preferences and more often than not those personal preferences lie in simple things like 'what was the first thing I heard and why did it emote me so much?' So I tried to be as objective as I possibly can.
Fortunately music is not a competition and everyone can and must relate to and love the musicians that speak for them personally. For me, that would be Floor.
@@mariodriessen9740 Thank you for your reply, it is so nice to have actual conversation here! I hear you..almost obsessed by Floor´s cover of Oblivion.. but not complaining!! And since you seem to be listening a lot of vocalists I recommend Dimash to you..his vocal skills are out of this world!!
@@anko3476 : I know. That guy is almost scary. Amazing. But the music he chooses to sing don’t really suit my taste.
@@mariodriessen9740 well give him time and he will grow in you ❤️ After that there is no turning back.. I keep wishing Floor and Dimash on the same stage.. or even better if Tuomas could write something beautiful yet powerful for Dimash to sing.. I know, high hopes, but I keep dreaming ❤️
Tarja was the one that made nightwish when they started but floor is the one that's taking nightwish to the next level of there journey she's amazing
All three are great but tarja has the magic 🪄
recent convert but Floor is a goddess
Das Lied hat meiner Meinung nach deutlich mehr Charakter, wenn Floor es singt.