In this era there are people (especially kids) who dont know what it feels to have ,music with actual instruments . So i brought this song to the new kids in my music class that only listen to certain people.When this song was over every single kid was about to cry :).
someone very precious to me gave me this song, instead of giving me this song i keep wondering why he didn't step up and told me he likes me.. then our story could have changed
The protagonist of the story, the elderly gentleman, is the boyfriend. We're made to believe that he is the soldier, but the whole time, he was the one who got the girl. They got married and lived happily ever after. This is shown through their hands interlocking... doing what they used to when they were young
I've been repeating this song again and again. It portrays my feeling perfectly. Everything from the lyrics, melody and music video. I wish you'll be happy 😊❤
I listened to this song everyday since it came out. And on tonight the first night Iv cried since the day she left. I burst into tears and sent the link to this song And said "I want you to listen to this. I don't know if you'll care but I have to tell you. This song is everything I want to say to you but I can't find the words to say" and now I feel la little at peace just knowing she knows.
He is really a lucky guy. I wish that he is much better person than I was because she deserve the best, but still sad to think about the future that has no HER in it.
the beginning it's deceiving because its tricking the audience into believing that the old man is the unlucky guy that didn't get the girl but it turns out the old man was the lucky guy all along. The song is saying basically 'i hope he treats you right, he's a lucky guy' and its showing that even after all these years he has indeed been treating her well and is still a very lucky guy
I'm pretty sure the old man is the gentleman at the doorstep since toward the end, the MV flickers between the old couple and the young couple. They are also sharing their little hand hug :)
StrixSymphony or maybe he has already having feeling for her since she didn't have that boyfriend :") but he just could tell her when he thought there would be no other time (yes, he was going to the war)
+Woojong Kinda the reason i'm listening to this, my girlfriend left me (after five and a half years which hurt) and is now with one of her work friends and is happy, but we are still very good friends which is rare tbh. But now I go to cover a placement though my job for a few months and now I meet someone who has a partner and I truly feel for her and she likes me to, we are good together have lunch every day go to see bands and do dating esc stuff for awhile, but she wont admit it to me, because just saying it means cheating in her eyes (even though she has said she does to others and everyone else sees it). But she is a good honest person and would never cheat and though past experiences I would never allow and not bother with a lady that would do such a thing. which makes me like her even more, I have now been offed a permanent position there and turned it down as I don't want to bring anyone to feel the pain I went though when it happened to me, as I feel that maybe something may happen and I wish it did but on reflection i decided to move on as I remember the pain I felt in basically the same situation my ex did...
I think it is showing that even tho things didn't work out with them it was kinda worth it because she really loved the other guy and they grew old together
This is very beautiful. It persuades us to get into heartbroken perspective, but then we see the ending of the lucky guy instead. This sad story actually also gives us a chance to be sincerely happy - for other person.
I actually shed tears while watching this. Old couples loving each other always makes me cry because it inspires me to go out there and find someone who will love me and grow old with me. =]
I think the old guy is the unlucky guy. And in the end, he's just like the lucky guy that got his dream girl, he has his own love. Thumb up so people can see
I jus heard dis song last nite and jus hav been playin it over and over I think I knw da whole think by heart :) it reminds me of my friend (also my first lov) who passed away 6yrs ago :')
2 years ago the girl that meant the world to moved halfway across the country before I could tell her how I feel. She came to visit a few months ago and every feeling I had for her hit me unbelievably hard. Then behind her as she walked in was her boyfriend. I dot hate the guy at all I hate that I can't get over her. She means everything to me and has for many years. We had been thru so much together. And
I didn't expect the twist considering I had my own idea of the song...but I love the twist... I was pleasantly surprised! Thx David, for making the song n helping me release some of my pent-up sadness abt how lucky was the other girl... n Thx Wong Fu, for making me feel that i shud be happy for the other side of the story!
I just discovered this singer about a week ago. I think I've watched this video 8 times lol. I was searching specifically for Asian singers because there seems to be so few in the music industry, and I found this. How David Choi, was not more popular, is beyond me. He has several very good songs.
oh my gosh. amazing. I was going to make a comment on something in this video but i've decided to withhold it b/c of the amazing emotions in this video. From sadness to happiness =) just goes to show, we can find love at any age.
David Choi is very talented guy..i x knw him until just now when i accidently click the wrong link n brought me to his songs. i like his songs! awesome!
AHHHH!!!! Was just chillin and trying to watch some Kpop and then an ad pops up in the middle of it and just about when I was to rage, I hear David Choi and totally fangirl. It was a Hyundai commercial but it had a lot of his songs in it so I ended up watching the whole 2 minutes of it and singing along... I love you David
8 years later and I'm still sobbing to this song
Same here.😪
Aye
Me too
“We can’t be together”
“Can’t really be friend”
It hits you so hard
Thanks for watching everyone! :)
i remembered watching this 9 years ago, and it still pulls the string till this day
Old man is not the young soldier!
In this era there are people (especially kids) who dont know what it feels to have ,music with actual instruments . So i brought this song to the new kids in my music class that only listen to certain people.When this song was over every single kid was about to cry :).
"you were never mine to
begin with".....hits me home every time.
That bridge..was genius!
I'm feel so lucky to be DAVID CHOI'S FANS
every time wong fu direct one of davids videos, its like an asian drama or movie. i always end up crying
I have to give prop to Teo, his acting is what really conveyed the heart of this song.
Kudos to this young man, with an Italian accent.
someone very precious to me gave me this song, instead of giving me this song i keep wondering why he didn't step up and told me he likes me.. then our story could have changed
The protagonist of the story, the elderly gentleman, is the boyfriend. We're made to believe that he is the soldier, but the whole time, he was the one who got the girl. They got married and lived happily ever after. This is shown through their hands interlocking... doing what they used to when they were young
I've been repeating this song again and again. It portrays my feeling perfectly. Everything from the lyrics, melody and music video.
I wish you'll be happy 😊❤
thank you! :)
DAT LAST MINUTE PLOT TWIST THO. Didn't expect that. Awesome song and vid.
You can't have me watch an elderly without sobbing like a helpless baby! Seriously! That was so moving yet simple! Ack my feelings!
im surprise this song doesn't have much views sad
+Mai Lee True
I listened to this song everyday since it came out. And on tonight the first night Iv cried since the day she left. I burst into tears and sent the link to this song And said "I want you to listen to this. I don't know if you'll care but I have to tell you. This song is everything I want to say to you but I can't find the words to say" and now I feel la little at peace just knowing she knows.
He is really a lucky guy. I wish that he is much better person than I was because she deserve the best, but still sad to think about the future that has no HER in it.
Yeah, all david's song actually have "meaning" in it. But when we're talking about david choi, no matter what song he produces, it's the best.
I love this song. really..
no matter how many times i watch this video, that young guy's acting is so heart breaking!
david choi should make piano tutorials. would love to play this song! :-)
the beginning it's deceiving because its tricking the audience into believing that the old man is the unlucky guy that didn't get the girl but it turns out the old man was the lucky guy all along. The song is saying basically 'i hope he treats you right, he's a lucky guy' and its showing that even after all these years he has indeed been treating her well and is still a very lucky guy
He is so fkn talented
I'm pretty sure the old man is the gentleman at the doorstep since toward the end, the MV flickers between the old couple and the young couple. They are also sharing their little hand hug :)
Sigh, I sincerely hope this doesn't happen to me.
I guess it's not a good idea to go after a girl who has feeling for someone else :O
StrixSymphony or maybe he has already having feeling for her since she didn't have that boyfriend :") but he just could tell her when he thought there would be no other time (yes, he was going to the war)
Lol that's more of a positive way of looking at it ;)
+Woojong Kinda the reason i'm listening to this, my girlfriend left me (after five and a half years which hurt) and is now with one of her work friends and is happy, but we are still very good friends which is rare tbh. But now I go to cover a placement though my job for a few months and now I meet someone who has a partner and I truly feel for her and she likes me to, we are good together have lunch every day go to see bands and do dating esc stuff for awhile, but she wont admit it to me, because just saying it means cheating in her eyes (even though she has said she does to others and everyone else sees it).
But she is a good honest person and would never cheat and though past experiences I would never allow and not bother with a lady that would do such a thing. which makes me like her even more, I have now been offed a permanent position there and turned it down as I don't want to bring anyone to feel the pain I went though when it happened to me, as I feel that maybe something may happen and I wish it did but on reflection i decided to move on as I remember the pain I felt in basically the same situation my ex did...
TAGSProle if you don't mind me asking, since it's been a year, how are you now?
ah! how does this not have a million views yet?! this is one of the greatest songs i've ever heard!
After watching this so many times, I just realised the video tries to trick you xD.
Miss these times, thanks David
Is it me or does it make more sense if the old man was the solider?
Agree
Tagalog's
I think it is showing that even tho things didn't work out with them it was kinda worth it because she really loved the other guy and they grew old together
Simon Tan yeah it woudlve. Doesn't really make sense the way the ended this mv. He acted like he knew/felt/understood it as if it was him.
Why hasn't this hit a million views yet? c'mon guys!
David deserves the best!!!
How did you read my feelings for my crush who likes someone else ???? T_T
This is very beautiful. It persuades us to get into heartbroken perspective, but then we see the ending of the lucky guy instead. This sad story actually also gives us a chance to be sincerely happy - for other person.
this song deserves sooooooo much more credit...
he is AMAZING.
This video placed a smile on my face. When creativity meets meaning. Wong Fu's specialty, aint it ?
I actually shed tears while watching this. Old couples loving each other always makes me cry because it inspires me to go out there and find someone who will love me and grow old with me. =]
I cry every time I listen to this song . So beautiful
I am a 20 year old male, and I seriously shed a single tear at 4:00.
He will be! It's just the beginning. Have faith :)
David's song and WongFu really know how to make me cry...
David sang this song last night in Taiwan. It was awesome!! Had to come back and listen again...
David have the best song choice. He's a true artist.
Maaaan the tears were flowing right from the first chorus! ='( A very beautiful video. Amazing actors there too.
I think the old guy is the unlucky guy. And in the end, he's just like the lucky guy that got his dream girl, he has his own love. Thumb up so people can see
I jus heard dis song last nite and jus hav been playin it over and over I think I knw da whole think by heart :) it reminds me of my friend (also my first lov) who passed away 6yrs ago :')
You may not be a lucky guy in that ONE situation. But in all situations. You're a great guy. I love your music.
Been listening to your music for two years.
I hope i still get to listen to your music in the future.!!
i finally managed to watch this without crying,, like the 20th time xxx
11 Years later and this song still hits hard.
Agreed!
2 years ago the girl that meant the world to moved halfway across the country before I could tell her how I feel. She came to visit a few months ago and every feeling I had for her hit me unbelievably hard. Then behind her as she walked in was her boyfriend. I dot hate the guy at all I hate that I can't get over her. She means everything to me and has for many years. We had been thru so much together. And
Old couples are truly the cutest!!!! Shed a tear ^_^ Very beautiful David Choi! ^_^
Makes me cry, every time. Reminds me of my parents...
Why do i always fall in love with sad songs that i can relate to? Every time i hear this song, i end up sobbing.
Why dont vevo except him Such a talented guy I love all his song Fan of him Keep the good work You are fantastic DAVID
Para sa mga Filipino, THAT WAS SO NAKAKAIYAK
Stop crying . No stop. ._. It's just so touching!
Just magnificent. Souvenir, souvenir, lucky guy.
HOLY CRAB!! WHY AM I CRYING?! I never cry!!!! I NEVER!! SO TOUCHING!!
Ikr! Been watching this since it came out. Still gets teary each time I watch this
I didn't expect the twist considering I had my own idea of the song...but I love the twist... I was pleasantly surprised!
Thx David, for making the song n helping me release some of my pent-up sadness abt how lucky was the other girl...
n Thx Wong Fu, for making me feel that i shud be happy for the other side of the story!
Ah, David Choi.. I love your songs..
this song made me cry like a baby >.> ughhh such a good song
David, this song and video made me cry like a baby, that's how a feel about my Mr Stache. Thank u for ur inspiration David Choi! ;)
Some people these day can't realize the beauty of good song anymore
yep i started crying near the end of the song, this song is just so beautiful!!
today i woke up with singing this song, after like 10 years of forgeting about it... still as good!
I just discovered this singer about a week ago. I think I've watched this video 8 times lol. I was searching specifically for Asian singers because there seems to be so few in the music industry, and I found this. How David Choi, was not more popular, is beyond me. He has several very good songs.
David CHoi... I assimilate my self with you so so much. Best subscription I've made on TH-cam... So shy. So classy!
David, your hair is glorious.
Glad to have met you, you took my hand at the meet and greet with Clara in Philly!
xo
oh my gosh. amazing. I was going to make a comment on something in this video but i've decided to withhold it b/c of the amazing emotions in this video. From sadness to happiness =) just goes to show, we can find love at any age.
unfold 2 + ur song = ultimate power!!
Yup. Thanks. Crying like a baby. Beautiful song and great video. Well done!
Wait, what?! I can't wait for that one!
Love this David! Sacrament of marriage what a beautiful gift.
Dude, who's cutting the onions? Awesome!
David Choi is very talented guy..i x knw him until just now when i accidently click the wrong link n brought me to his songs. i like his songs! awesome!
rollercoaster! from his forever and ever album, it's really good :)
I cried. Oh, God. These feels.
It goes both ways you know. It hurts just as much for us girls if get turned down by a guy we like with "i'm sorry".
This is one of the cutest music videos ever. :)
All of David Choi's songs are beautiful
awww. old couples are so cute. this song is really lovely david. good job
Choi you are simply amazing .. you have talent .. its incredible how there is such undiscovered talent out there..... your awesome I'm amazed
Omg i cried through most of this song. So beautiful.
This is so beautiful. I've never ever cried at a video before.
how can i explain you that
YO TE AMO!
thanks for each song,cuz your telling the hole history !
this is touching and i cried badly... love it...
all of you should but this on itunes
AHHHH!!!! Was just chillin and trying to watch some Kpop and then an ad pops up in the middle of it and just about when I was to rage, I hear David Choi and totally fangirl. It was a Hyundai commercial but it had a lot of his songs in it so I ended up watching the whole 2 minutes of it and singing along... I love you David
Oh man. I'm tearing up now. So touching,
This song is so beautiful and I'm crying right now!!
OMG i cannot stop cryin when i watch this holy smokes:'') he did it again whew!
U made a hard guy cry. This is touching
AWwwwww with what im going through right now.....this brought me to tears
It's been 5 years now since you post your comment on this song.. hope the years gotten better and you are okay now.
This song is so beautiful,it made me cry
I love this video. There's quite a twist in it towards the end for me and I like that twist!
Another awesome song by David Choi and another amazing production by Wong Fu!
David, i just wanted to say that your videos are very touching and makes me almost shed a tear.
"We can't be lovers, Can't really be friends"
Struck a dark hole in my heart that was hidden from the world
Holy crap.....tears and chills
I'm crying.... Thank you!