Breaks my heart that at the core of it all everyone's all sorts of broken or self-doubting. In the moment it lays the foundations of an actual feeling of family among the other members, but in hindsight it's the perfect caliber of person who would be attracted to and willing to be used by Dutch
Wow this is really great, thanks for posting this. There's so many times you're in another part of camp or hearing someone else talking in camp instead of who you want to so it's nice to be able to listen to the stories in their entirety.
Fr I always missed so much stuff in camp or id catch like the very ass end of the story or song their singing, plus I don't really have the patience to sit around camp doing nothing like some can lol
Im replaying this game for the 3rd time now and i missed so many of these campfire stories and the camp interactions! You learn so much more about the gang with these so thank you for posting this
kinda shame that arthur has only one campfire talk (the last one in vid). it's sad that arthur opened corners of his soul with barely familiar people (sister calderon, rains fall i mean) than with the gang. they don't deserve him.
I think in hindsight it makes sense. Sadie is the gang’s newest member (unless you count Kieran but he’s killed about two months later) and she mainly fraternises with Arthur, Abigail and John, and to a lesser extent, Dutch. She’s also not brought into the gang’s jobs that much and I think that because of her trauma she details her feelings about her life with Arthur only, because “he’s the only one of these fools that I trust”.
Brilliant writing here fellers. If youve played cyberpunk 2077 you know what i mean, in that game they talk and talk and talk. They try soo hard to be an action movie with endless pointless dialogues. But in red dead a simple conversation by the bunfire hearing Npcs cry their hearts out is all you need. 57:30 youre right one hundred percent uncle John
59:57 I think that’s a reference to meeting the strange man when he mentions about forgetting people and how he’s forgotten more important people than him. Also, foreshadowing his death
I like to think Javier ran into Dutch stealing chickens and said "What are you doing here?" and Dutch replied "Same as you, I suppose." Then the American Venom theme plays as they laugh together.
I put on Hosea’s stories to help me fall asleep at night, every night. The man’s so relaxing to listen to. Side note: Kieran breaks my heart man. His life…his story is soul crushing. I feel so sorry for him. I wish Arthur would’ve warmed up to him a little more and he could’ve experienced a decent amount of peace and happiness and acceptance before…you know 😔
I love the Hosea Quote Number 5, “My pa used to say you could stare into the fire and see the whole world pass by”. It really symbolizes something, I just don’t know the words for it. 😂
Wasn’t expecting the first two to be Abigail. But one thing I’ve noticed, other than the obvious story / background. I’ve noticed Abigail seems to be more comfortable or atleast less worried standing next / close to uncle compared to anyone else. Almost like they’ve already bonded / became close and again. Their history is a dead give away. But still. Makes you wonder since them two live together in the end while you play as John and go everywhere for weeks on end exploring and racking up bounties 😂
Alright so I am trying to hear Mr. Matthews. Tell a story but you know someone who I like has to ruin it.He ruined three times for me. Next time Dutch wants to tell me something he can wait.
im surprised karen doesnt have any campfire stories, shes certainly talkative & outgoing at least early on also props to bills actor for how he sounds so much like a real regular person with all the stammers & pauses, or getting unexpectedly embarrassed/emotional. plus it really contrasts him with dutch who almost always knows what he wants to say & how to say it effectively
To Abigail: Oh you don't mean that. You love that kid more than life itself. To Bill: you're so damn lost you don't even realize it... He's not a god. To Charles: don't worry... None of us know why we were born or how to get along with others.
Charles out here breaking my heart 😭 My guy needs a hug
Bro fr when i heard him say this i literally said “i just want to hug you”
Every one sharing their stories
Arthur:🧍♂️
Well he atleast has 1.
"You ok, Arthur? There's plenty of room here by the fire"
I found 1 and uploaded it
@@djfaded420a@0❤
Breaks my heart that at the core of it all everyone's all sorts of broken or self-doubting. In the moment it lays the foundations of an actual feeling of family among the other members, but in hindsight it's the perfect caliber of person who would be attracted to and willing to be used by Dutch
23:30 Dutch honestly pulled out his lighting power
You should donate to camp NOW!
You should go to Tahiti NOW
You should have some faith NOW!
You should have a plan NOW!
You should get some money NOW!
23:08 the thunder strike after Dutches rage filled speech is great foreshadowing.
23:25 - that's perfect timing for thunder to strike, while Dutch is preaching about tahiti plan again
Same thing happened to me, I think it's meant to do that.
Yeah it’s programmed to do it during his speech
It's scripted that way. Happened in all 27 of my playthroughs.
@@DietCoke88 it happened in my first 27 playthroughs but not my 28th or my 143rd, you might one to do another playthrough and see
@@cactusfacemcgillicuddy😂
The way Bill says “SHIET” fucking kills me
i kinda love hosea and uncle's friendship shown here, their interactions never feel unequal
Wow this is really great, thanks for posting this. There's so many times you're in another part of camp or hearing someone else talking in camp instead of who you want to so it's nice to be able to listen to the stories in their entirety.
Fr I always missed so much stuff in camp or id catch like the very ass end of the story or song their singing, plus I don't really have the patience to sit around camp doing nothing like some can lol
Im replaying this game for the 3rd time now and i missed so many of these campfire stories and the camp interactions! You learn so much more about the gang with these so thank you for posting this
All this goes to show is how dutch took desperate people and turned them into vicious killers.
kinda shame that arthur has only one campfire talk (the last one in vid). it's sad that arthur opened corners of his soul with barely familiar people (sister calderon, rains fall i mean) than with the gang. they don't deserve him.
Arthur opened up with Mary-Beth quite a bit. She was always there for him.
18:05 irish sitting technique
This made me giggle like a little girl
i was too busy dragging people with my lasso on a horse to even know this exist
Ong Arthur was out there robbing folk while they sat yapping at camp
Funny how almost everybody has one but Sadie. She had so much cut content
Wait, what do you mean? Was she gonna have stories?
@@blakeforkins7375eventually yes.
I think in hindsight it makes sense. Sadie is the gang’s newest member (unless you count Kieran but he’s killed about two months later) and she mainly fraternises with Arthur, Abigail and John, and to a lesser extent, Dutch. She’s also not brought into the gang’s jobs that much and I think that because of her trauma she details her feelings about her life with Arthur only, because “he’s the only one of these fools that I trust”.
What are you talking about she has too much story as it is compared to others
@@commandermike2886in the later chapters yes but not the earlier ones ig
Thank you for putting this together! I wondered how many campfire stories there were to see. :)
Over 2 hours for just camp talks longer than some movies.
"Abigail: im getting too old for this"
*She's 22 saying it in front of the oldest member of the gang and a vet pushing 50*
1:53 i dont think any of them could
19:50
Charles: rambling about how emo he is and how his life sucks
Lenny clearly board asf: “hey arthor”
Brilliant writing here fellers. If youve played cyberpunk 2077 you know what i mean, in that game they talk and talk and talk. They try soo hard to be an action movie with endless pointless dialogues. But in red dead a simple conversation by the bunfire hearing Npcs cry their hearts out is all you need. 57:30 youre right one hundred percent uncle John
bro has done gods work
A tremendous effort. Thanks you
For the second story from Abigail I really don't think she meant that.I think she just hates John being lazy and not helping out.
Charles confusion about life by the fire 😞
Wow, I didn't know most of them could be activated while still in Horseshoe. I thought more would appear only in the fourth or sixth chapter...
@ConwayTwitter That sounds like a pain in the buttocks I'm glad he did the work for us
59:57 I think that’s a reference to meeting the strange man when he mentions about forgetting people and how he’s forgotten more important people than him. Also, foreshadowing his death
Honestly I feel like Bill is less dumb than people think he is. He's just lost and messed up, like a whole lot of people out there
1:22:04 ''See it for what the hell it is🐍🐍🐍''
charles' story makes me feel safe
A really great video , gotta give it to you .
Notice how none of these take place in Chapter 6? Goes to show how nobody really saw each other as family anymore by that point
I like to think Javier ran into Dutch stealing chickens and said "What are you doing here?" and Dutch replied "Same as you, I suppose."
Then the American Venom theme plays as they laugh together.
I put on Hosea’s stories to help me fall asleep at night, every night. The man’s so relaxing to listen to.
Side note: Kieran breaks my heart man. His life…his story is soul crushing. I feel so sorry for him. I wish Arthur would’ve warmed up to him a little more and he could’ve experienced a decent amount of peace and happiness and acceptance before…you know 😔
“Where he talks I walks” -bill
I could listen to bill ramble all day
Dutch No2 was badass from the thunder
23:30 That’s perfectly Timed
A long netsan video?? Imma have a GREAT night
so dame good,thanks bro.
You’re missing one with Micah and Strauss
Honestly I’m putting this on anytime I’m eating so that way I’m entertained
I love the Hosea Quote Number 5, “My pa used to say you could stare into the fire and see the whole world pass by”. It really symbolizes something, I just don’t know the words for it. 😂
Ho gg for this vidéo this is very useful (the best stories is always uncle)
*useless
23:29 Dutch pulling out his Stand during his speech, that's a real Dio right there
1:19:02 Micah speaking facts
Dutch: WE ARE GONNA BE FREE!!! ⚡23:41
RDR3 should be about the young Dutch and how he brought the gang together.
8:13 this is real even today lol.
Nice Video 😭😔♥️
Lmfaoo look at Sean while Bill is telling his story. 6:42
the second abigail one is gonna make me cry omg
Who knew that there was so much.
Wasn’t expecting the first two to be Abigail.
But one thing I’ve noticed, other than the obvious story / background.
I’ve noticed Abigail seems to be more comfortable or atleast less worried standing next / close to uncle compared to anyone else.
Almost like they’ve already bonded / became close and again. Their history is a dead give away.
But still.
Makes you wonder since them two live together in the end while you play as John and go everywhere for weeks on end exploring and racking up bounties 😂
When Dutch was talking and the thunder was crackin mmmhmmm that was good
Back with the boys
Oh this gonna be a good one
My favorite animal is bill getting angry
@2:07:15 - "High, Dutch."
Masterpiece
Now we need all the other camp events, can you do it ?
I'm trusting your word that there's eighty-six.
I'm pretty sure there are more stories
57:32 real
This is dope.
Disappointing that Mary-Beth, Karen & Molly don't have stories
Most of it is basically just the men monologuing 😂
2:26 Reverend behind bill😂
Uncle and bill no2 is funny. I listened to it during my playground and was laughing
I love how they both nod at this 58:24
So there is a 1 in 86 chance you get Lennys request.
Even Kieran has a story
43:10 ELLIS IS THAT YOU!?
You know he’s basically saying Dutch r8ed him….
Who is he? Out of 86 stories you could have mentioned the bame.
Bill was the one doing most of the talking throughout the video…..thought it was implied. Sorry
only the first few @@40YOgamerz
Time stamp? You’re very unclear about who and which story you’re talking abt lmao
23:26
John N2 is really relatable
Pearson is in 10 of 12 hoseas stories
Didn't knew Arthur had a dialogue in here 😢
1:52:45 how did you get this conversation to play in horseshoe overlook?
23:25 TAHITI, FIJI, AUSTRALIA
Alright so I am trying to hear Mr. Matthews. Tell a story but you know someone who I like has to ruin it.He ruined three times for me. Next time Dutch wants to tell me something he can wait.
2:15:09 did they teach him that in the navy?
18:04 what sean doing
Squats
He's just irish'ing
1:40:12 tagging strauss’s for myself
Is missing one by John. He talk about woman, Karen is together, but she stand up and leave.
he only has one about women. I dont find any video on the other one youre talking about
@@nightcartix th-cam.com/video/D2AaJGQtM1E/w-d-xo.htmlsi=EO03cGGM30PORvmf
18:20
23:31 nice timing. This is happend too me to. It's scripted alright. Good one Rockstar
Shouldn't Bill be in front of Micah by alphabetical order, because Marion?
57:32
1:58:49 🤣🤣
I missed about 90% of these
im surprised karen doesnt have any campfire stories, shes certainly talkative & outgoing at least early on
also props to bills actor for how he sounds so much like a real regular person with all the stammers & pauses, or getting unexpectedly embarrassed/emotional. plus it really contrasts him with dutch who almost always knows what he wants to say & how to say it effectively
Damn 2hour
To Abigail: Oh you don't mean that. You love that kid more than life itself.
To Bill: you're so damn lost you don't even realize it... He's not a god.
To Charles: don't worry... None of us know why we were born or how to get along with others.
Bill makes so much more sense to me as a character now. I feel bad for Bill now.
1:15:35
Rockstar one love
She’s to old bro look at uncle he is in the first one and still more active then most
there are some missing there
Why did you put ads in this? Now I'm gonna have to use adblocks
1:13
1:58:50 😂😂
Um, Abigail.. All those guys can't become mothers
Okay buddy
I like to believe she meant this goes for FATHERS too,