ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 5 ก.ย. 2016
- Bono discusses U2's "Sunday Bloody Sunday" for the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame's special 2016 exhibit Louder Than Words: Rock, Power and Politics. Courtesy of the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame, shared exclusively with atu2.com.
- เพลง
"borders are in the heart and how we see each other" - Bono
Brilliant!!!
Borders are very real. I love Bono, but he's been a superstar since he was 16, he flies over borders enroute to million dollar gigs.
@@petehill8885 Oops 😊
Think he may have missed the "peace walls" last time he visited Belfast. Such a sad thing to see in a 21st century city.
@@bmac8993 It was us who created those walls in our hearts before we built them in reality. The more we recognize the humanity in the other, then the fewer walls we'll feel we must have.
"It's not much of a lyric, really" I love how humble, but how wrong he is.
The trenches dug within our hearts
And mothers, children, brothers, sisters torn apart
So beautiful, and so hard, and so true.
They sure have written some killer songs on their first few albums and the gigs back then we're electric.
How can you say such a thing about a man who is speaking about a song which he wrote?
With all due respect to Bono, it's easy to look at a centuries old conflict with the eyes of the 20th & 21st century. People had land taken from them that existed in their family for centuries. My great-grandfather's family was one of those. The British came in and just took the land. Others in the Republic lived under oppressive landlords. I agree with his modern vision because now most have migrated and there's really no reason to live there if you can migrate to another place. The British, in my mind, are and will always be, the guilty party of this conflict. I appreciate Bono's "reach for peace" and I agree what's it worth to fight now but to my great grandfather I don't think they saw it that way. They really felt they had no options.
EXACTLY. WELL SAID
Beautiful Bono have a wonderful soul and heart
Sunday Bloody Sunday is such a power song, no better band to play and man to sing this song. Bono is a pure legend 💚
Imagine all the people in 1916 taking back Ireland 🍀🥊❤️
U2 have more than enough great songs.I remember buying this album, I was 14 when it came out and I proudly carried it home outside of the bag.Haha
God I love this man.
nadine doremus I know right
Definitely my favorite song
God I love this man.
This is f-ing amazing to watch. Thank you @U2.
Whenever there is a Terror Attack, I play this Song in my head.
Aww such an expectional good man..totally in love with him his music his soul. God bless you Bono ♥️
BEEN MY FAVORITE BAND SINCE THE BEGINNING!!
i would like to meet bono he is a very smart man i would like to drink beer an talk that would a fun time
wow how bitter you are.
bet your a loser in life.
bono isn't he's a winner
I was lucky enough to have met him a couple of times with Jim Kerr, when they were looking at investing in Celtic fc, great guy, extremely intelligent and very tuned in
Actually sounds a right Dick!!!
My great grandfather faught for a united Ireland ❤️
United Ireland 🍀❤️
I love your Dublin songs 🍀❤️
I love you Bono.
@Mark Gauvreau lmao, what?
The Derry massacre and the IRA reprisal bombings in England (notably, the Guilford pub bombing) were recent memory when "War" was released.
If U2 didn't think this song would be adopted out of the context they intended, they were quite naive.
I'm descended from Irish immigrants, myself. Like Bono, Catholic on my father's side and protestant on my mother's. My mother converted, but not until after they were married.
Even removed by two generations and thousands of miles, it was still a big deal. My paternal grandmother referred to my mother as "the protestant girlfriend" until she died. By that time, my parents had been married for 18 years, had three children, and my mother had been a baptized, confirmed, and practicing Roman Catholic for well over a decade.
Kent...this is may have been very difficult to assist. It shouldn't be like this religion should not divide but the unify ..is in the bible. I am catholic too .
@@stefaniacostrini1946
Grazie, Bella.
Remember how young the band was when the song came out. They just wanted to express their feelings in music.
I want to meet this amazing man so much. He is the love of my life and I love seeing him smile. He seems like he would be a good person to talk to. I once saw a video when Bono invited a girl on stage and they layer there while he sang to her. Then at the end he gave her a kiss. I would do anything to be that girl. I love Bono so much
Also, the United States shot and bombed its way to independence it was not granted to them through a peaceful vote from the British parliament.
Bono’s dad reminds me such much of my own
Incredible sadness,😭🍀
Bono is very kind and he loves to help people that's why he won 3 Nobel prices, 2 golden globes, 2 Oscars, and academic award and also he is knight of the British Order ❤️😍😍🇮🇪
This is f-ing amazing to watch. Thank you @U2.
Liberty Wagon Wow, so glad I bumped into you! The asshat store called & they're all out of you.
Liberty Wagon you're such a fan!!!
nadine doremus he knows a lot about their songs. bono is not everybody's cup of tea. but u cannot deny his is clever huge brain behind those tinted specs
best version of the song is from the "Rattle and Hum" movie,he preludes the song saying why it shouldn't be in the movie,but I'm glad it was,he's so fuckin enraged singing it,and justly.
I saw that for the first time recently and was pretty moved. He was going off!
@@Rawker101 Enniskillen
I like the slane castle version
Best song
I was fortunate I was born a girl from Galway ❤️🍀 l
No troubles ❤️🍀🥊 a united Ireland ❤️ 🍀🌙🇮🇪⚓
Now I know why Bono incorporates a lot of Gospel and Christian elements in his lyrics and the band in their song structures. I knew that growing up in war torn Ireland played a part in how they view religion but I didn’t realize it was that deep until I started learning about The Troubles and hearing Irish folks candidly talk about how divided they are on religious and political lines.
U2 IS THE MOST GREAT BAND IN THE WORLD...
I'm a republic of Ireland 🍀🥊🌙🇮🇪⚓
To vacate your country ✔️ I love Bobby Sands ❤️👍🍀🥊
You sang for culture 👍🍀
I cry for Omagh 😭 I had a fortunate life 🍀➕🌙
Only omagh??????
Major Tom 👍✔️
Genius
I was eight years old 😭
Real borders are in people’s hearts.
And not a Boy 👍🍀❤️
That "martial beat" (3:11) that he talks about.
It reminds me of a short burst from a Lewis gun (the "ba da da" in particular), which brings it connects it even more to easter Sunday, the Lewis being a gun from ww1.
(If you don't know the gun, the sound or the history behind it. Here's a link to a video that explains all 3 of those question: m.th-cam.com/video/edbDa9knxwE/w-d-xo.html )
whaaaaaaaaaaaa
A united Ireland ❤️🍀🌙🇮🇪⚓
are you genuinely thick or just lazy - listen to what hes saying!!!!!
I want to see a United Ireland, Catholics and Protestants manage to live with each other in England without segregation,and in peace,so why not Ireland ?
It's not really to do with religion it catholics identify as being Irish under an oppressive arm of brittish, and the Protestants identify as loyal to England and the crown with their foot on the Catholics head... But that was then, its more equal now,
They say that if you say you're an atheist in Northern Ireland, they ask you if you're a Protestant atheist or a Catholic atheist.
Good idea. You should speak with Sinn Fein and the Queen about it. I'm completely serious.
@@oldones59 actually the Orange Order is who he needs to talk to.
Many have told me to hate this man Bono. I'm like why? I love him and don't even know him. May he come to Torah, but from a Hebraic perspective.
🔥😳🤪😂🙏☝️💪🤙🔥
I wrote a song called someday bloody someday
James Adcock i wrote a song called "i wanna hold your ham"
I wrote a song called "my beer has gone"
I'm Roman Catholic church Australian 🍀🥊🌙
So it's a good song for some silent soup for dinner
United Ireland 🍀 i
The problem with a lot of people, like Bono is that when talking about the 1916 Rising, which was a violent uprising and the Civil war which followed to get Independence from Britain they like to talk about the other IRISHMEN & WOMEN who were thrown into a racist state ( N Ireland) Which was manufactured to give the ruling Prodestant population complete control over every aspect of living a normal life ( l know, all I remember was murder, and the feeling of being a second class citizen) We were left to ACCEPT our future. A few generations did but come the 60s enough was enough, people weren't having it anymore and BLOODY SUNDAY was the answer lawful marchers got in DERRY. So that's why we were first of all forced into physically protecting ourselves then that didn't suit the powers that be, and UNFORTUNATELY it escalated to fuu blown armed resistance. Let's not make the mistake either, the only reason we have moved forward and claimed EQUALITY was by ARMED RESISTANCE.....
ONE MANS TERRORIST
IS ANOTHER MANS FREEDOM FIGHTER...... I Pray for a new Ireland for everyone and I'll be the first one to go to the 12th March's
UNITED........
Problem with Bono? Write your own song. Speak your own mind.
you forgot about bloody sunday 1920 and Ballymurphy massacre, Bono
@Derek Trump i dont know how many jews was killed by accused for killing Jesus. you are right that it was Roman killed Jesus for politic reason .so?? what is execution of Jesus with the big trouble to do??
Bono is what is known as a West Brit.
He did NOT grow up in a "war torn Ireland".
And if not for the IRA who ended the Crown violent occupation he would still be living in an occupied Ireland as a 2nd class citizen.
The following war crimes were just the tip of the iceberg.
1913
Labour's Bloody Sunday
Sunday, August 30th was a day of bloody and prolonged terrorism, commencing with the batoning of thousands in O'Connell Street by the members or the Dublin Metropolitan Police, assisted by hundreds of R.I.C. men specially imported into the city and made drunk for the brutal campaign.
1920
Croke Park - Dublin's Bloody Sunday
More than 30 people were killed or fatally wounded by the crown forces.
1921
Belfast's Bloody Sunday was a day of violence in Belfast, Northern Ireland on 10 July 1921, during the Irish War of Independence.
1971
The Ballymurphy massacre was a series of incidents between 9 and 11 August 1971, in which the 1st Battalion, Parachute Regiment of the British Army killed at least nine civilians in Ballymurphy, Belfast, Northern Ireland....
1972
Derry massacre (for which Bono wrote his song)
has Bonio and U2 played in Derry Londonderry , just asking
LondonDerry doesn't exist. I think you mean Derry.
@@lochlannenright2344 londonderry? never heard of it, have you?
@@Sergio-hf1kn nah I definitely never heard of it.
my GOD you inbreds in northern Ireland's fighting over a bit of land that is z shithole anyway
Sunday blood Sunday 🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧
500 years now...technically...because of the 2000 y2k glue society
1916👍
MUSIC 🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶 AND POLITICS AND HEALING PEOPLE FROM DA VIOLENCE AND ABUSE ,CHILD ABUSE, ELDERLY ABUSE, ANIMAL ABUSE, AND DOMESTIC VIOLENCE TO GIRLS & WOMEN REGULARLY
Derry 1971
My god I'm a 1995 boomer...: Let that bird 🐦 fly .... It's going to break it's beak in the butter....
I got washed on an empty beach 👍✔️
For a man who wrote the song. I've never heard tell of him ever setting foot in Derry nevermind even playing in the place. The least he could have done was perform a concert for people of both community's to attend, and maybe even creating something for the people to celebrate together! Honestly I think it's just his way of selling music and he really doesn't give a shit about Derry!
Lucan...mmm is point of view here. He is just trying to make this awful event public with the channel he knows which is the music and spread the fact around the world by singing about it. I do actually like it what he said on this interview about the horrible things that happened to Derry community simple because they are catholic. I am catholic too but i can understand the frustration this interview may have caused to the people that have actually lived the experience.
Nope. Many ultra nationalist wannabe aka pro-IRA keyboard warriors frustrate the hell out of them, I can understand if they refuse to play this song in Derry. This song can easily be misinterpreted and used as a rebel song by Neo IRA
He couldn't find Derry on the map.
Am pretty sure he could.
He has plenty of old sterling in him I'd imagine.
I'm Irish Catholic church Australian 🍀➕🌙
He dyes his hair.
Our own sin and depravity have made Christianity look so bad.so sad! I understand why Gandhi said what he said.
Religion is a highly personal matter, not a PR campaign. I needn't to to a building with a cross.and.stained glass to be near God, as I understand.it. My relationship with God is built on communication, not worship. It works for me.
Thought bloody sunday was danzig when the germans took it from poland
jacob graven how did you get that idea
How did you get that idea
History
jacob graven Bloody Sunday is when British Army killed 11 Irish in Derry Ireland
jacob graven that’s also apart of history as it happened in 1970s
A united Ireland or nothing ✔️🌙🌖🌓🌜🌒🌙❤️🌗🌕🍀
Hong Kong would become north ireland soon
This video is a good example of why, even though I'm an atheist and Bono is super Christian, I agree with his politics more than many other "political artists". I remember being turned off to Rage Against The Machine in the early 90s when I read in their liner notes that they supported the Shining Path in Peru, a communist terrorist militia that was literally lining up peasant villagers, men, women, children, and shooting them dead, for the alleged crime of supporting the government.
Some other great activist artists who think a bit more deeply than shallow fake "revolutionary" wannabe Che Guevara nonsense include Midnight Oil, Tropical Fuck Storm/The Drones, and Marc Ribot/Ceramic Dog.
the ira NEVER blew up a kid in a supermarket, what the fack Bomo
Gary Murtagh Trafford centre Manchester.
19grand; Manchester bomb- IRA phoned in a warning & 75000 ppl were evacuated. There were zero fatalities. IRA issued a statement in which it claimed responsibility, but regretted causing injury to civilians. The reason for the warning was to get civilians out! Killing or harming civilians is never the aim & doesn't gain sympathy. Bringing the war to Britain has always been an IRA strategy. You bring it to us, we'll bring it to you twofold. Also, might i remind you, the UVF first brought the gun into Irish politics to threaten & intimidate Republicans & Catholics before 1916.
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warrington_bomb_attacks
Bono is what is known as a West Brit.
He did NOT grow up in a "war torn Ireland".
And if not for the IRA who ended the Crown violent occupation he would still be living in an occupied Ireland as a 2nd class citizen.
The following war crimes were just the tip of the iceberg.
1913
Labour's Bloody Sunday
Sunday, August 30th was a day of bloody and prolonged terrorism, commencing with the batoning of thousands in O'Connell Street by the members or the Dublin Metropolitan Police, assisted by hundreds of R.I.C. men specially imported into the city and made drunk for the brutal campaign.
1920
Croke Park - Dublin's Bloody Sunday
More than 30 people were killed or fatally wounded by the crown forces.
1921
Belfast's Bloody Sunday was a day of violence in Belfast, Northern Ireland on 10 July 1921, during the Irish War of Independence.
1971
The Ballymurphy massacre was a series of incidents between 9 and 11 August 1971, in which the 1st Battalion, Parachute Regiment of the British Army killed at least nine civilians in Ballymurphy, Belfast, Northern Ireland....
1972
Derry massacre (for which Bono wrote his song)
Perhaps all the Catholics might consider going to live in Rome?
@@Ryzanu couldn't agree more!...but not for any reason other than it should be a united Ireland...we do thank Luther for the reformation! For we did and do PROTEST and STAND (protestant) that the pope is NOT the representative of god on the planet as a ceaser of old. And we do acknowledge and appreciate the current popes reforms in regards to Catholic church, he does not allow anyone to kiss his ring as the ceasers of old.
your Roman Catholic so off you pop to Rome
A i and why you think this is right ? Do you think religion come from the place ? In somehow you get that education yes but religion and belief are a different matter !! And if you think so does the Philippine should transfer to Rome ??!!!
If you ask me hes a hypocrite really.
How?
@@samdoyle3945 How not ?
@@jessebubslebo5231 in what ways does he contradict himself?
@@samdoyle3945 He preaches to us about global warming but he flys him & his children across the world on shopping trips 2 & 3 different countries in one day on his private jet it has been known to have happened .. Hes always banging on about innocent people who has been killed in wars putting up in his concerts on the big screen the American government & things but attends the white house alot & is friends with the ones responsible for the war crimes on innocent people / GEORGE BUSH / TONY BLAIR & so on them two should be in jail for what they did .. Are world is run by people more evil than the people they lock up fs .. Its not just bono its all theses big rich stars .. I cud name alot of them they rub shoulders with the elite but talk about the bad stuff going on wen its the elite thats responsible for all this .. BUT these rich stars just want to be looked apon as if their realy caring people to get attention from everyday average down to earth people .. Its not about the poor people or murdered people or evil people their talking about its all about them wanting to be credit for something that their doing .. Or should I say GUILTY of something their NOT doing lol When you know & see how much your being fcked over because you have your own brain and not a brain that people want you to have you'll see all this as clear as I do my friend. 🤞🏼☮
Borders. blah blah. I'm sure his mansions have real walls.
Iam EUcomanian....with 1 / 8 ! other blood, also writting letters 2 the pope, sometimes( 8 rules.My opinion about it is: When you R replacement, you MUST have the same authorrity.THEY say no cos He is not of GOD, ding-DONG.Its perfectly allright 2 destroy the earth?EZECHAEL: THEY will show themselves OVR the holy place .( WWWWWWOOOOOOWWWW, ET JE TAIME ), MIRJAM
Brexit 👎🔫
Unlike you bono I grew up in n Ireland during the troubles you have no right to write a song and then dictate how people interpretate it.