Doctor REACTS to BOJACK HORSEMAN | Psychiatrist Analyzes "A Horse Walks into a Rehab" | Dr Elliott
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 ก.ย. 2022
- #bojack #bojackhorseman #drelliott #doctorreacts #psychiatrist #mentalhealth
Check out my reaction to Bojack Horseman: • DOCTOR REACTS TO BOJAC...
It's a Sin reviews: • DOCTOR REACTS TO IT'S ...
This Doctor Reacts episode of Bojack Horseman has been requested A LOT. It's Season 6, Episode 1, called "A Horse Walks Into Rehab". Unsurprisingly, its about addiction and its treatment and I talk to you about techniques like motivational interviewing, different forms of psychotherapy, how to get people to accept treatment, managing mental illness alongside addiction and much more.
SUBSCRIBE for new videos every Sat and every Wed: / @doctorelliottcarthy
Connect with my on socials:
Twitter: @elcarthy
Instagram: @dr.elliott.carthy - บันเทิง
What really breaks me about the last scene is how the music sounds like from a broken record and only when bojack drinks the alcohol, it turns into a beautiful memory, implying that bojack already used the alcohol at that age to fix his family problems and feel safe.
7:10 Finding a non-church/spiritual affiliated program was key for me when dealing with sex addiction. I did not feel comfortable at all with the sort of implicit judgement that a lot of those programs seemed to have baked in and going to them delayed my seeking of help by at least a year due to how put off I was.
What program did you find?
The fact that even supposedly secular AA meetings often have to take place in churches as they're some of the only remaining community spaces is too much for me
@@SteelCityJW I think they're only local but they're sponsored by "Acuity"
Yup, doesn’t help that a lot of community programs for addicts and homeless people are often directed by church groups, so it gives people very little choice. It’s either subject yourself to a religious environment that more often than not is going to impose judgment upon you, or just wing it on your own because the better alternatives are too expensive for you. It’s a horrible cycle.
Always good to see the doctor talk about the horse
An episode I'd love to see you do a video on is Good Damage, episode 10 of season 6.
It feels like one of the most relateable depictions of depression I've ever seen, and a really powerful message.
YES! More Diane focused eps please!!
That might be my favourite episode of the show, plus “Stupid Piece of Shit” which both have very similar “view from inside their head” aspects to them.
Yes, I agree! Especially how it effects her writing (because I’m a writer) with how she thinks she should write something hard-hitting and impactful for readers to help them, but can’t seem to get the words to come out onto the page.
As someone who has been to rehab 3 times. Bojack is in the best position he can pay for personalised but expensive treatment. Where I am it's all run by "charities" that value quantity over quality as the government pays them per patient.
Edit: the biggest thing most addicts need is routine and stability. Housing, food, social and hopefully stable employment. Addiction is sometimes giving up. So giving people security and reasons to live plus plenty of psychiatric/psychological care. Addiction is often a response to other issues and trying to avoid them
I actually don't know any examplws for addiction not being the symptom of another problem.
I am not an addict, but from observation, I think people would really be doing something by starting to treat addiction like the illness it is, the symptom of an undetected mental illness, or a real life problem that has been ignored and now manifested in that way.
Even if I'm wrong with this assumption, it can't be wrong to react with compassion, when someone opens up, and support them to get the help they need...
I love the fact that for the rehab, everything is therapy is a dig at the Malibu resort rehabs which are over priced and sometimes call everything therapy. Also the gag with the horse therapist. As in "horse therapy"
I would really love to hear your views on “The View from Halfway Down” it’s a beautiful take on death
My two favourite things together: Bojack and professional analysis reactions
For my abusive ex. His substance use always seemed like a way to self-medicate his increasingly severe mental health issues. Alcohol and weed gave him a sort of calming effect. Problem was, he needed more and more to get the same effect and the withdrawals increased his instability. For the genetic component, his dad was a drug addict who died from and overdose.
Loving the BoJack episodes, really glad that you're doing more
These and the Simpsons are my favorite series he does
Same these are some of my favorite videos to watch
I like your point about six weeks not being enough treatment, and to add to it, we find out in I believe the very next episode that the doctor on premises isn't a licensed therapist. He very clearly tells us that he's more akin to a real-world therapy animal. Bojack isn't getting the proper help for everything he's been through and the base issues behind his addictions, which leads him to spending months at rehab because he's in that stage where he's desperately trying to get real help from the best source he knows of.
Really love your Bojack videos. One thing to note, when the bottle turns into the stars spinning just before Bojack runs into the bathroom, I think that was a visual cue to show that thinking of drinking again was reminding him of the planetarium and Sarah Lynn. He has that negative association now really prominent in his mind now that he's been sober for some time.
If you enjoyed BoJack there's a high chance you'll like Tuca & Bertie as well. I particularly recommend reacting to season 2 episodes 1 and 5.
Thank you so much! I've never heard about it before your comment, just started watching, and it really is great and very similar to Bojack's style and humor!
@@yanagelfand4337 The same woman (sadly forgot her name) who created the visual artstyle of Bojack Horseman, had a hand in creating Tuca & Bertie
I'm Sorry. Big fan of Bojack and I hated Tuca and Bertie. I tried to watch many times but not for my taste. The personalities were so annoying. 😔
Didn't they cancel that show by the end of season 1?
@@xavierxrc No, Netflix ditched it but luckily it was picked by Adult Swim. It's currently on season 3.
Finally watched the whole show, so amazing wish you could react to every episode haha 😄 I find your videos really helpful, especially when you talk about parts of bojack, depression/ self destructive behaviours, which I can recognise in myself
Also would love to see a review of the view from half way down
Dealing with addictions, particularly opioids, is one of society's and healthcare's greatest failures in my opinion. It's gotten so bad that some of the doctors I have been to shut down the second pain is mentioned. They don't run any tests, ask anymore questions or even look at the area that's hurting. Meanwhile whatever is wrong continues deteriorating, so it's no wonder people turn to self medicating. That's just the tip of the iceberg too.
Finally more BoJack episodes. , We need more House MD 🙈
You skipped the part I actually wanted to hear your take on the most, the part where Bojack says that maybe rehab is an industry that profits off of repeat customers, which I truely believe it is, especially with basically all rehab models being religious, and all religions being majorly traumatizing.
Finding a rehab without religious ties I hard. Especially when a lot of your issues come from Religious Trauma.
Love when you cover Bojack!
I LOVE these Bojack videos keep them coming. I want to note that I'd be interested to get your thoughts on the movie 28 Days starring Sandra Bullock. I feel like a lot of people missed when that movie came out but it's a really fascinating film about addiction.
I don't have an alcohol addiction, but my therapist speculates that I used my addiction the same way as Bojack did (escapism) and I lot of stuff resonated with me before i even learned I had an addiction (and thus it hit me harder upon rewatches).
I often say therapy is hard. I feel like the statement by itself doesn't carry the weight of the actual difficulty but.
The relapses, even knowing it's NORMAL and expected, there's still a sense of shame I felt every time it happened cuz it's like 'failed.' I think the hardest part was getting myself to try again and not just quit right there after 'failing' again.
By the end of the day, I had to keep reminding myself "If change was easy then everybody would do it" and if I quit it was my choice and my choice alone. I knew by that point that...while I was afraid of the changes and what those changes bring, I think I was afraid of who I was/where I was in my head before, and I didn't want to go back to that.
I'm glad you are responding to more Bojack Horseman episodes. It's a superb show and there are still more excellent episodes to do
Alexithymia being so common with autistics is a big deal; but can we also discuss that dyslexia a word impossible to spell correctly is the word for people with trouble with reading and spelling.
You deserve so many more subscribers, great video quality, fantastic in-depth analysis and gives another portion of food-for-thought on my favourite show - great job 👌
The LOOK Dr Carthy gave at the selfie sent me lmao 🤣
Amazing video as always and as addiction psychology is my academic and professional specialty you covered it incredibly well!
You’re exactly right, six weeks simply isn’t enough treatment. It could be argued that the real work (dismantling maladaptive coping strategies and building up new, healthy ones) takes months if not years, depending on the history. And I would go so far to say substance misuse disorder is a ramification of mood disorders or other types of mental illnesses.
I’m very lucky, my father was what is commonly known as a “high functioning” alcoholic, and I’ve never been drunk in my life! I’ll have a maximum of two drinks if I’m out and then I kinda fell like that’s enough? But it’s something to always be vigilant because the risk factors are there, as you say.
In good news though, St Thomas’ in London has opened up a new substance dependency ward for those who need supervised tapering or withdrawal management! It’s a drop in the ocean, but it’s a start.
Looking forward to the next video!
just rewatching your bojack episodes while waiting for a new one, and im happy that a new one is here
I've been following you doctor for the past couple of days; I just completed bojack horseman, and it was something.. I'm really loving your reactions and reviews to the series.
Wow, the world is crazy. Tonight, after a few months of working hard and fairly successfully to cut down my covid-worsened drinking problem to only drinking one bottle of wine per week and only on weekends, and/or having a couple drinks while with friends (paying per drink or just talking to people slows me down), I bought a bottle on a Monday and ended up drinking the whole thing without thinking about it, and I feel pretty shitty and guilty about it. At some point I ended up clicking on Bojack (which I’ve watched many times) on my “keep watching” on Netflix. Then, at some point while watching, I was trying to think of that wonderful line you’ve said, “insight does not equal change,” and popped over to TH-cam to try to find that video, but instead I found this, posted yesterday. Getting to that Action stage took me two years despite the nagging feeling that things weren’t right and I needed to make a change. The Maintenance stage has been so much harder than I expected. You think once you’ve “solved” a problem it will be over, but no. Right now I’m not really in a place where I can go to therapy and I’m not comfortable talking about it in depth with my friends. But this video really helps me feel seen, and reminds me I’m not alone and not the first person to struggle with this. It reassures me that my problems are not permanent, helpless flaws, and that I can make progress, even if it’s not as fast as I want. You have a very kind, non-judgemental vibe, and it makes me feel supported. So thank you, for doing what you do, and for being clever enough to do it through a show many of us already turn to in our darker moments.
Been looking forward to this potential breakdown for a long time, can't wait!!
This reminds me I want to watch the documentary Dosed (2019), about people with addiction who try taking a recovery journey with psychedelic therapy. As I understand it the doc mainly follows one user so it's not a here's why psychedelic therapy works but more of a glimpse into the experience (?).
I love these. Thanks for doing more :)
This episode was my first time truly understanding that substance addiction can just be a small part of someone's list of problems. In anti-drinking campaigns for kids they are often blamed as the sole source of all problems. It as a coping mechanism was only mentioned in passing.
I always learn something from your videos. Thanks
Does Dr. Elliott do counselling through zoom😂? I've been severly depressed for 6 years and changed many doctors and drugs, I've been to psych ward for attempted suicide and yet I've never felt understood like I did when watching his video analysis of behaviours similar to mines. I wish I could find a doctor like him in my city or even my country (Italy) :(
Your reaction videos are making me watch shows that I'd otherwise never dream of starting lol
Watching this makes me think that Season 6 Episode 1 of How To Get Away With Murder, would be a good reaction for you to do! I love your channel!
This was great, I’m glad you’ve started skipping forward in the series. Thanks for another great video!
I feel like all of those models can be correct depending on the person’s circumstances. They’re all potentially useful for analysing any particular person’s situation.
I’d say models one and two feel the most relevant to me, and it can be especially “exciting” to remain self-aware of those aspects, since I also have a genetic chronic pain disorder and rely on some pretty heavy painkillers to even be functional.
I’ve got to tread a fine line between not having enough and my body pain being totally debilitating, but also avoid chasing 100% complete pain relief. Keeping the middle ground of enough to be functional without building tolerance or chasing something unsustainable is a lot of work - especially since I know I could theoretically take a bigger dose of some of these painkillers for “recreational” experiences instead.
Though perhaps model three is as well since I have no point of reference for how anyone else experiences these substances. Though I have my doubts, since I socially smoked as a teen but never developed a habit, cravings, or dependence on nicotine.
I correctly guessed the relapse rate of opioids before you said it - those withdrawal symptoms are enough to get most people to give-up.
I have complicated feelings about that matter in particular when it comes to myself, since I’ll probably need to take them forever for my joint pain, and I definitely have a chemical dependency after a decade. But the dose isn’t high enough to feel anything cognitively, just physically; and it’s definitely not an emotional coping mechanism or anything for me. So, being able to relate to the chemical neurological side, but not to the social emotional side when people talk about it can feel… quite strange sometimes. Especially since some of my pain doctors prefer to say “chemical addiction”, while my generalist doctors specifically dislike that term and choose to instead say “chemical/neurological dependence” since it’s not harming my ability to function but enhancing it.
Something else I found interesting is how your graph of addiction recovery can also absolutely apply to my chronic fatigue management. Whether it’s about household chores, hobby activities, or being consistently social with friends and loved ones. In a fatigue flare-up I’m usually anxiously trapped in that “planning” stage while I can’t do much of anything but sleep. When my fatigue is lessened I always go into the “doing” stage - but my fatigue never stays low enough for that fifth “maintenance” stage!
Heh, that all ended up a bit longer than I’d intended! But hey, it’s all important to me, and all relevant to what you’ve said, so I’ll keep it all in. Thanks again for the video!
Yay! More sad horse show reactions! I never knew the chances for relapse after rehab is high.
The next Bojack episode can you please react to Bojack and Dr. Champ in The Kidney Stays in the picture.
"I don't have a problem with alcohol. I can drink a fifth every night and still speak, function and drive as though I am sober. I can handle it better than anyone I know. I don't act the fool when I get drunk. I just drink because I like the way it tastes. I don't have a problem because I'm smart about how I drink and I don't get myself into trouble."
Now, with 341 days of sobriety under my belt, I realize just how deep my denial, and just how dangerous my habit had become.
Wonderful video. Also, may I say, you are glowing this video. Whatever your skin routine is, its working!
I really enjoy your insights and was wondering if you were interested jn doing some reactions to 'The Boys' and specifically how they handle the topic of toxic masculinity.
I reccomend checking out moral orel, its fantastic on repesenting trauma and substance abuse and so much more!
Is this the episode where they do the "therapy horse" joke, or is that in a later episode? That one cracked me up so much!
Later
Man those guys in your iPad are really good at holding an expression
The ending of that episode gets me every time, it's extremely sad..
Circumferential is a word I’ve never heard before but I love
My dad's alcoholism relapsed after about 25 years of sobriety. It started when he and my mom decided they could handle a glass or two of wine a day. My mom has never had a drinking problem, but for my dad, he gradually fell back into it over the span of a decade. Thankfully he's gotten help (surprisingly AA works for him) and has been sober for 2 years.
Great reaction!
I love these so much 💞
"You can't put a price on clean living"
"And yet you've found a way"
How most with addiction and mental health issues never get help reasons A-Z
Love your videos
Oh Dr Elliott..... You are amazing
Very interesting video as usual!
Btw what is the deal with that tablet on your side?
If you know you know
@@DoctorElliottCarthy oh no, you can't do that
@@MarcosLopez-ky5yg guess you’ll just have to binge all his videos to try and find the answer
Hey... isn't that the horse from Horsin' Around...?
Id like to see your breakdown of the song Surface Preassure from the movie Encanto.
i always love the bojack horseman episodes but you should totally react to never have i ever! i watched it thinking id hate it but it actually deals with a lot of mental health issues that are really interesting to look at
An episode I'd love to see done is "Still Broken" from Season 2
Sir, cant you just watch the entire serie in one go, react to it, and then put everything on TH-cam? Thanks in advance! Love from Holland ❤️
im new here why is that picture of bob and peppermint there 😭😭😭
I love your videos! I’ve been binging all of your reaction videos! I would love to see you react to El getting bullied in the newest season of Stranger Things
Oh, the fracking?? ❤
Are relapse rates like divorce rates in that they count multiple attempts by the same person? In other words, are there a smaller number of people that relapse multiple times that make the relapse rate so high or do 90% of people who are addicted to opioids actually relapse?
Please react to more This is going to hurt and heartstopper!
You should do the view from halfway down the next tien you do bojack
Loved the episode, but can we talk about Bib and Peppermint on the iPad?
i'd love to see you react to the West Wing s2e10
You should react to Monk!
FORK YES
Hey, I'm a Med-tech, thank you for your insight on mental health. If there is one thing you could say to someone who struggles with depression (is clinically depressed) what would you say?
the rainbow colors been reversed between lego set and the flag on the shelf in the background bothered me more than it should.
thats your personal problem not his problem lol
On my case they used forced toxic psychosis as the tool to help my addiction. Is the only way my parents saw as a possibility.
Yes yes let’s gooooo
Can you react to something, I can't remember whether it was this one but I think it was, Paradise PD episode 3?
Are you going to react to hannibal again?
The fracking?
🤫
I'd like you to react to a historical video that not many people have seen. It is a training film for battlefield psychiatric injuries from Oct 1943. It is called combat exhaustion, 1945 ARC Identifier 35906 / Local Identifier 111-M-1197 . Search above for it.
💖
What is the meaning of the people Doc is showing us on the tablet?
I was wandering the same thing
He said "if you know you know"...
I don't know, but I want to know!!
@@MarcosLopez-ky5yg Same😂
please do view from halfway down
FRACKING?!
Oh the fracking?
🤫
What about hike-terapi?😂
Oh the fracking? 🙅♀️🙅♀️
I love watching you, so thank you for making videos. I would love to watch you react to some medical dramas where psychiatrists are used in emergencies. One I can think of is "Iggy" he is a main character in New Amsterdam, it is an American medical drama television series, based on the book Twelve Patients: Life and Death at Bellevue Hospital by Eric Manheime. However, personally, I find it better down than most medical dramas. Iggy is the Head of Psychiatry at New Amsterdam Medical Center and a respected psychiatrist. I would love to see you react to some of his focus episodes like, th-cam.com/video/wX6TbOIS0ZM/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=MDTV or th-cam.com/video/XSYCrtY0Z3M/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=MDTV. Either way thank you for making videos. ❤
Can you react to more Friends episodes??
react to greys anatomy!!!
The fracking???
What’s on the iPad screen next to you? 😅
people actually have problem with getting up and doing the thing they need to do to have better lives?
is it really so hard?
So I have a question so I have a question about something so my therapist so that's my therapist if I have borderline personality disorder because my actual mother told me told me this that my actual father had borderline personality disorder all right so I asked my therapist this so that's my therapist this the symptoms well heard me up from wrong here I don't believe in the book because the symptoms were pretty interesting drug usage Suicidal Thoughts and I don't have any of those symptoms so I don't I don't think that book he has exactly right now it's good just be my insisted isolating paranoia I don't really get this whole tell me if the book is right granted his book is in the US so for you might be different bye
Can't believe you cut away from one of the most powerful and heartbreaking moments in the show to rapidly blather on about psychological theories of addiction. Let the moment breath.
You should definitly react to the episode “Good Damage”. Diane’s story here is arguably more relatable than Bojack’s.
I have a crush on you... is this transferance? ;) Also good episode.
Never develop Parasocial relationships or longings!! Fell in love with some videos, one was with PhilosophyTube's "Men. Trauma & Shrek" ....watched it 18 times!! For good reasons. Apart from it's brilliance.
Why is no one talking about the drag queen references
he didn't react to the best part which was the end
I was kinda hoping he would touch on the fact that Jamison was a compulsive liar and possible narcissist.
She told everyone her addiction was bc her parents ignored her for her little sister - turned out the kid was hers and her parents spoiled her rotten. When confronted by BoJack she showed no remorse whatsoever. In fact she lied about everything that night, and her ex-friends, while not great people themselves, pointed out that she was a toxic asshole so they cut her out and moved on.
RELAPSES ARE NORMAL YELL IT FOR THE PEOPLE IN THE BACK
Your nose feels especially... nasal, to me.
You ramble sometimes. All I heard rich person speech and I can feel eyes glaze over and my brain turning to ocean noise mode. Then you get back to the good stuff and I switch back on.
is it because hes British?💀