Fair Use for YouTube (Ep 1) CRITIQUE
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 ก.ค. 2024
- FAIR USE FOR TH-cam (APPROACH #1) CRITIQUE // Have you ever heard of the Fair Use Critique method for your TH-cam video? TH-cam Fair Use can be tricky, but if you watch today’s video, Fair Use on TH-cam becomes a breeze! Fair Use copyright law provides that you qualify for Fair Use if you critique or criticize the song or video clip you are using in your TH-cam video. How does Fair Use work on TH-cam? That’s what I, Ian Corzine, get into in this video. I discuss how to Fair Use copyright. I give you TH-cam Fair Use explained and provide you with TH-cam Fair Use examples. If you have ever needed to know TH-cam Fair Use policy or how to use Fair Use on TH-cam, this video is for you! Thank you for watching!
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
⭐️ JOIN the “Ian Corzine" DISCORD server HERE: / discord
🔴 For more on the LAW TH-camrs need to know, SUBSCRIBE: th-cam.com/users/IanCorzine?...
🔥 Check out my video on FAIR USE here: • Fair Use on TH-cam - ...
💟 Watch my video on How to Use Music on Instagram here: • How to Use Music on In...
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
AUDIO MUSIC & SOUND FX: Epidemic Sound, “Melancholy” by Ooyy.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
👀 WATCH Todd in the Shadows TH-cam Channel HERE ➡️ / carlos10009
🧶 WATCH MauLer TH-cam Channel HERE ➡️ / themauleryt
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
FAIR USE ATTRIBUTION (Title 17 USC Section 107)
I used the following clips from the Todd in the Shadows and MauLer TH-cam channels in this video, as criticism, comment, news reporting, and teaching and compliant with TH-cam’s copyright guidelines and United States Federal Law:
Clip No. 1 (Todd in the Shadows): • POP SONG REVIEW: "God'... (7:09 - 7:42)
Clip No. 2 (MauLer): • A Critique of Star War... (33:51 - 34:58)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
✳️MAILING ADRESS: ✳️
Ian Corzine - Your TH-cam Lawyer
3835 E. Thousand Oaks Blvd., Ste. 472
Westlake Village, California 91362
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
⭐️And also please say "Hi!" on Social Media⭐️:
Twitter: / iancorzine
Instagram: / iancorzine
Facebook: / iancorzinehotm
LinkedIn: / ian-corzine
www.iancorzine.com
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The content of this TH-cam channel is provided for informational purposes only and is not intended to constitute legal advice. You should not rely upon any information contained on this TH-cam channel for legal advice. Viewing this TH-cam channel is not intended to and shall not create an attorney-client relationship between you and Ian Corzine or West Corzine, LLP. Messages or other forms of communication that you transmit to this TH-cam channel will not create an attorney-client relationship and thus information contained in such communications may not be protected as privileged. Neither Ian Corzine nor West Corzine, LLP makes any representation, warranty, or guarantee about the accuracy of the information contained in this TH-cam channel or in links to other TH-cam channels or websites. This TH-cam channel is provided "as is," does not represent that any outcome or result from viewing of this channel. Your use viewing of this TH-cam channel is at your own risk. You enjoy this TH-cam channel and its contents only for personal, non-commercial purposes. Neither Ian Corzine, West Corzine, LLP, nor anyone acting on their behalf, will be liable under any circumstances for damages of any kind.
© 2019 Ian Corzine. All rights reserved.
#iancorzine
#youryoutubelawyer - แนวปฏิบัติและการใช้ชีวิต
TH-cam was founded on ⭐️FAIR USE ⭐️Critique or Criticism -- What is your favorite CRITIQUE video of all time?
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
@@maidenx2736 SAME HERE
hey drake song has kids- on youtube are these guys getting coppa hits???
Please, can you make a video on how to make copyright claim free music reaction videos from the go, w/o having to dispute it later?? I'm not sure if this falls into this category. Thanks for all this valuable infomation.
Is it possible to use images from a movie to review a movie on the TH-cam channel
Has anyone ever mentioned how you yourself are avoiding copyright strikes on these videos? I love how you break things down. And go further into it by giving us detailed information with your own short clips of others even if they are violating rules. Your critiques, evaluations, explanations and opinions protects you from strikes 🤙
Hey Whiskey! Well, thank you bro! Yeah, I work hard to follow Fair Use rules.
Paul Teich I like learning new things.🥃
Paul Teich oh I did. It’s bound to happen one day. I’ve seen it happen to others.
First? Other than Ian’s comment? 😝[edit] jokes aside, I think the commentary of drake’s video works because of the overlay of commentary over the original video. The problem is that a lot of people use too much unedited footage from the original work, then get claimed, and then think they’re access to fair use has been impeded. The essential criteria I consumer is whether or not the use will drive traffic towards, or ssyphon traffic from, the original work. If it is the former, OK. If it is the latter, no no no. ✌️
Yea I made this mistake in terms of the lack of editing the clips in some respects. no matter how you do it you're siphoning traffic from the original work because you likely chose to base the subject matter of your video on that particular piece of original work because it was trending and drawing traffic.
Hey VF! Thanks for being the WINNER! I'll give you the GOLD medal later next month at VidCon 😄 I appreciate the analysis but Fair Use is a bit broader than that -- your new art (using the borrowed content) can siphon away the audience and still count as Fair Use -- lots of examples of this when a musician re-makes a copyrighted song and it blows up way more than the original -- my immediate thought (because I am an old school rap nut) is "It Takes Two" by Rob Base & D.J. EZ Rock
@@TheSupinesmokey Yeah, I see this ...
Bro- 13k!!!! I’ve been with you since the early days. You are KILLING it man. Flippin’ genius channel. Keep going man. You’re gonna be up there with Brian G, Nick Nimmin, and the rest of those channels which help all the other channels on TH-cam.
Side question- what do you use for your editing? Your animations with the text, etc?
Hey Stormy ⛈ Thank you so much for booooosting me up! I use Final Cut Pro and PixelMation, Stupid Raisin, and AleFX plug-ins for titles.
Super great information thank you for sharing
Thank you again!! 😀
My favs include the ones like Anna That Star Wars Girl's rant about the Captain Marvel Deleted Scene, which was released by Disney on Twitter (I guess for some Girl Power schtick). Anna and others pointed out that the scene portrayed Classic Villain Behavior.
Several of these videos were either taken down or blocked. But restored after the content creator's protests.
So glad they were restored. Let Fair Use reign!!
Very informative great video on Fair Use
Great video
Thanks for the info, and videos
Fantastic to hear you will handel all 8 !!!
Breaking it down!
What?! I love Todd in the shadows! Nice example!
Great Video! Thank You! informative.
These next 6 videos will help everyone immensely I have already taken a lot from this first video already thank you Ian
Hey Supine Smokey! I love this!
What about thumbnails tho? Is it fair use when you use like a movie poster or screenshot a scene from a show and then you do some photoshop activity with it? I’ve seen some podcasters and TH-camrs of the reviewer/reactor types have thumbnails with some images (surely copyrighted) or at least edited versions of the images of the topic, whether they put together images into one thumbnail or use a copyrighted image and just paste their faces (usually their reactions) next to it, and these same people are monetized.
I’m planning to do reviews myself and I wanna make something off my channel, and I’m just wondering if I can just photoshop images together for the thumbnail or if I’m better off drawing from scratch.
Nice. Thank you!
Really glad I don’t need/ want music...these are great examples
Hey Gene! Thanks for always being supportive!
I appreciate the amazing content and how difficult it is to produce it. You rock! Thanks!
Very helpful and helps the teeming TH-camrs out there to be circumspect in order not to have copyright issues.
I love this new series...Your hard work really pays off in your production.
Thanks Maddy Moo!
Thank you for this, really needed to know about this as I will be doing movie reviews and this video and examples helped me soooo much!
AWESOME
Thanks so much for supporting me, Ramiz!
@@iancorzine welcome please do give us more information about copy right more like this though.
You are a rock star in this realm. you deserve more subscriptions, Ian
Great stuff! Thanks!
How does this pertain to doing analysis of let's say, golf swing technique? It might only be 5-10 seconds of a video clip, but it is the main focus of the video and played back several times and different speeds and with pauses while critiquing the player's technique and also marking up the video and/or doing a side by side analysis with another player or same player before/after.
Thanks Ian
Awesome video break down.
Keep up the good work.
Thanks so much for watching!
Another Informative vid from Ian! More Power 😎
Hey Yshmael! Your praise is so kind.
Hi Ian ☺️👍🏿
If I want to use a movie.
"Burning Bed". In a Premiere or Livestream. Discussing Narcissistic, and Domestic abuse. Breaking down the Red flags in the movie. Using the entire movie. That can be done??
If we copy someone else game clips (say 8 secs of each clip and combine) from outside or inside TH-cam and then make a video like Top 3 games you should play now and use my own voiceover and my own music just to explain why you should play those games , will there be any copyright strike ? Pls suggest
Love the production of your videos. Did you use a transition pack? If so, I'd be interested to hear who you got it from?
Hey P&P! Thanks so much -- Yes, I use Stupid Raisins, PixelMations, and AleFX -- really good plugins for FCP!
@@iancorzine thank you!
Left a link to this video in my latest tutorial :)
Man this is great, but how do I get the actual video onto my own video?? The one I'm talking about?
First, I would like to applaud 👏🏽 you, for trying to answer comments( Most don’t do that).
My question is…
Does critiquing and criticizing always have to be verbal?
Example: I wanted my audience to listen to a very short clip of a song to listen to the point that I was making about it. I had text under the song to listen to it, so that they could hear for themselves of what I was criticizing. I believe the music clip was 17 seconds. Does that qualify for fairuse?
Thanks ☺️
See. Maulers example is exactly what I wanted to refer to. If you observe, Mauler never uses latest movie clips and does screenshots instead. For older movies he uses a few seconds footage and sometimes even random stuff while commentary is still on the actual movie. Makes it feel like this whole Copyright thing is a damn Russian Roulette 😑
Great video and looking forward to the rest of the series, thanks MA
Thanks so much for taking the time to watch -- it means SO much TQMA
Copyright Law - Google and You Tube both have clear community guidelines. If you "Google" these You will See.
Yes! They do have guidelines, but most creators believes YT does not apply them fairly to everyone; AND it would be in their best interest to point out to the creator what they did wrong so they could correct their mistakes and do better. That is my a social media attorney is important. Thanks for watching. 👊😀
Hi Ian,
I commented on a video of yours regarding fair use as I had been given a false copyright claim. I do reactions to tennis matches and only show my face on the screen with no video or audio from any of the match. I have again been falsely copyrighted. How can I object this claim and get my live streaming ability back?
Thanks for the helpful videos really appreciate it :)
Kind Regards
Cam Williams
Hey Cam -- I am sorry that happened. I want to understand the problem more. Who filed the copyright claim?
@@iancorzine thanks for the quick reply
Here are all the details:
Video title: 🔴 NADAL vs THIEM - LIVE Stream Reaction - Roland Garros 2019
Video url: www.youtube.com/watch?v=BhgQkb...
Takedown issued by: 3antS Development & Strategies SL
Email: 3ants.development@gmail.com
Does it transform the video if my critic was through text and not a voice overlay?
Hey Clark! Thanks for watching! Yes, text criticism is perfectly fine for Fair Use.
Perhaps I just write the words “This is a critique” in tiny font on the bottom of the screen...🤔 lol. RIP Han Solo...while he was rebel scum, I still loved the guy. (Don’t tell Vader 🤫 )
Hahaha! Really funny comment Stormy!
Thanks brother. Salute.
Can you answer a question about the jurisdiction on Fair Use? I'm a UK creator and upload content to TH-cam, so which laws apply? Because the content was created in the UK do UK Fair Dealing laws apply? Or do the American Fair Use laws apply? I appreciate TH-cam is an American company but it also has servers and offices worldwide. It, therefore, is subject to the laws wherever it is based. So, how should non-US Creators interpret Fair Use?
Hey Tosh! Well, for purposes of TH-cam, TH-cam Copyright Guidelines apply. You can review them here: th-cam.com/users/ytabout/copyright/#support-and-troubleshooting . If you were to take dispute further, UK law would apply. Use TH-cam rules and you will be (mostly) safe ... unless you're doing a REACTION video ... that is a whole other can of worms ...
@@iancorzine unless you are doing a reaction video? I just watched one were you said commentary was allowed. Is that different from reactio videos?
Hi I'm from Morocco and sorry for my English, please i want to ask you if i can use 10 seconds from trailers of movies to represent best 10 movies or something like this is that a fair us or not please answer me and help to understand because some channels use this way.
Replied to your previous post. 😁
How do some channels use a lot of footage to make reviews and they don't transform the original content?
Love you
thank you for the hard work to teach us
Thanks Michael!
Hi Ian, would it be possible to use BBC wildlife clips and add a new alternative commentary on the wildlife?
This is what I'm looking for so long about fair use, from a lawyer itself. Thanks for this Ian 😍
Hey Rodel! Thanks for watching -- yeah, want to help you make the best videos you can!
I can't wait for your next series. Cheers Ian ❤
Rodel Galvez Already set to drop TUESDAY!
Very informative. How did you obtain the clips you used in this video?
Yes! Copyrights club. Haha.. I always used this Fair Use. 😎
Hey Deso! Haha! Copyright Club ... Copyright Squad ... I think Copyright Club is better!
Bro. Ian, the latest update about Anime Channels / Fan Animation non - reused content that terrifyng there channels. What can you say about to them?
Like Mastar Media etc ..
Yes. Haha Copyright Club...
When something people walkin infront of you and sayin,
Hey! Bros. Welcome to Copyright Club! Haha!!
Bro, you are awesome! Keep empowering others.
Thank you so much!! I am trying. 👊😀
Can you please, please tell me how do you guys actually get the footage they use in their videos to do critiques on movies or TV shows? Most are not from trailers or clips that were uploaded by the studios.
See if this video answers your question: th-cam.com/video/usQSaZ1mnwU/w-d-xo.html. Thanks for watching and please let me know if you have any other questions. 👊😀
Ian, I'm loving the information you are providing. I am trying to start a new channel and this information is invaluable and easy to understand. I do have a couple, maybe, interesting scenarios/questions, though.
1. If someone appropriately uses fair use to transform a copyrighted work does that new work become an independent copyrighted work entirely removed from the original? Imagine someone transforming a copyrighted work, then, at that point, can someone transform that new work under fair use? That is essentially what you are doing when you are using examples in this video about other's who've transformed work. But I noticed that you didn't touch on directly the work that was previously transformed--you didn't critique Drakes song. You critiqued the person who transformed Drakes song.
2. If this is the case that the new transformed work is a completely new work, couldn't you argue that I could then transform Todd in the Shadows work by removing his critique of Drakes song leaving me with Drake's original song and call it transformative from the original work? My new work, essentially, would be Drake's song, and if I found enough clips of people critiquing this song, I could theoretically reconstruct Drakes song in its entirety and original state. But I would have a brand new transformative work...
I am wanting to make videos that include critique and commentary. At times it will be necessary to use longer segments of video for the commentary. I have specific questions not addressed in your video above, with the objective of avoiding claims, strikes, and being successful in disputing any that arise. 1) There may be segments of video in which I am not speaking but allowing the audience to view and listen to any relevant commentary on the segments. I will then critique or comment. How can any issues be avoided with this scenario? Is it essential to be speaking within small increments of time to avoid hassles? 2) Related to this, can commentary be accomplished by text or annimations? 3) I would prefer to speak and not have an image of myself payed over the videos for the commentary and critique. Is it the case, however, that having an overlay image greatly reduces any TH-cam flags? Thanks very much.
3rd
Hey Mobile! You did it! You get the bronze medal -- Go for the GOLD on Tuesday! 😅
Can I use the patented topics to educate on tech and use it under education fair use
Hey Ian, do you think anyone can make movie reviews that fall under fair use if the clips are short and and using criticism
Hi NickelNation!! You need to make sure your clips are only 2-5 seconds long (10 secs max) and then you MUST comment and/or react or criticize directly the clip you just showed. The concept of Fair Use and copyright is a tricky topic. If you are interested in learning more, I have done several more recent videos that teach about these ideas. These videos are fun and interactive so you might be interested. Thanks for watching AND please let me know if you ever have any questions. 👊😁
Thanks Ian
Just the video I needed Ian... 😁 thank you so much... You removed all the confusions I had in my mind about fair use... ✌️
You are so welcome. 👊😁 I'm glad I could be of assistance. Please let me know if you ever have any questions.
@@iancorzine yeah sure.. 😁✌️ your the best! 🔥🔥🔥
Great job IC, love the fair use content.
Thanks so much HTS! I really you appreciate you tuning in!
Okay how do you do this with historical videos or even old commercials from like the 1990s? I need help now that i ha e around 15k followers i think the bots are getting me on tiktok my views have gone way down lately and i beed help
If l download a non creative common video, extract the audio and use pictures to create another video, hope am still within fair use and will not get a YT strike?
Hey Augustine! Thanks for watching - well, if the audio is copyrighted you still have an infringement problem - could you use audio from TH-cam’s “Music Policies” section?
@@iancorzine Thanks a million. I have watched your video on YT audio but they are short and l needed a long music. Hope a long creative common video that l will extract the audio is ok?
It's ok!
Mauler Is The Man..
Ian Corzine can I take a video from another person and comment on it thru the whole video like ozzy man and not get a copyright strike
What is considered a "short clip"? 10s or less? 5s or less?
What abt memes, can meme videos be a fair use?
how to put dance videos for the famous songs ?
Us top TEN Videos is copyrights ?
Ian I do lots of 8d music of songs, and I'm doing ok I'm not looking to get paid for doing these.
Do you think it's worth maybe trying for sponsors as I'm working hard not hese 8d songs
YES! It's always worth it to get sponsors behind you. And, remember, just because you are PROPERLY borrowing someone else's content, that does not mean you can't get paid. Go for it!
@@iancorzine thank you Ian. I will give it a try, hope for the best 👍
Hello Sir Ian, hope you will notice me. I am using music on almost all my videos. I'm not really sure if youtube won't give me strikes in the future . I would be accepting criticism or opinions so my channel will not be vanished .Thank you
I want to make a sports channel on youtube....with my own voice and commentary.....I want to know if it will be under fair use
I just answered this question above. 😀
Can I use the fair use option to post a video on Instagram of my record player playing a record?
You have to follow the Fair Use rules unless you have permission from whomever owns the song. See if this video helps you out: th-cam.com/video/owFqmrzrEuU/w-d-xo.html
6:10 can you explain how reaction channels make their money then?
Is it enough to use clips of a car manufacturer's commercial and give the cars specs and then comment "What a beautiful machine"?
Hi, this is a great question. I would love to help out and answer any questions you may have! I have a LIVE Q&A show this Saturday.
You can drop your questions and concerns on my LIVE show and TUNE IN. Kindly check this link to get a notification.
facebook.com/yoursocialmedialawyer/posts/1231061260678010
Ok
Yes? This "FairUSe" Interpretation ?
I just replied to your comment above. Is this a question?? ❓❓
i know of some channels that have clips way longer than 2-5 sec. for example check out the TH-cam channel Dorian Group82. his channel is based on the music industry and he uses so many copyrighted material. could you make a video on how he is getting away with this?
@Ian Corzine, I had a channel for education ot traffic lows and use a software as tools for showing different situations, on which I comment and add addiional meaning. Is that a fair use? What are the rules for using software in a video, a software which is legally bought, of course. By the way, I had not 1 but 21 DMC strikes.