Fair Use for YouTube (Ep 2) COMMENTARY
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 ก.ค. 2024
- FAIR USE FOR TH-cam (APPROACH #2) COMMENTARY // Have you ever heard of the Fair Use Commentary method for your TH-cam video? TH-cam Fair Use can be tricky, but if you watch today’s video, Fair Use on TH-cam becomes a breeze! Fair Use copyright law provides that you qualify for Fair Use if you comment on the song or video clip you are using in your TH-cam video. How does Fair Use work on TH-cam? That’s what I, Ian Corzine, get into in this video. I discuss how to Fair Use copyright. I give you TH-cam Fair Use explained and provide you with TH-cam Fair Use examples. If you have ever needed to know TH-cam Fair Use policy or how to use Fair Use on TH-cam, this video is for you! Thank you for watching!
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
⭐️ JOIN the “Ian Corzine" DISCORD server HERE: / discord
🔴 For more on the LAW TH-camrs need to know, SUBSCRIBE: th-cam.com/users/IanCorzine?...
🔥 Check out my video on FAIR USE here: • Fair Use on TH-cam - ...
💟 Watch my video on How to Use Music on Instagram here: • How to Use Music on In...
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
AUDIO MUSIC & SOUND FX: Epidemic Sound, “Genesis” by Ooyy.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
👀 WATCH Linus Tech Tips TH-cam Channel HERE ➡️ / linustechtips
🧶 WATCH Charisma on Command TH-cam Channel HERE ➡️ / charismaoncommand
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
FAIR USE ATTRIBUTION (Title 17 USC Section 107)
I used the following clips from Linus Tech Tips and Charisma on Command TH-cam channels in this video, as criticism, comment, news reporting, and teaching and compliant with TH-cam’s copyright guidelines and United States Federal Law:
Clip No. 1 (Linus Tech Tips): • Apple's New Mac Pro - ... (2:00 - 2:47)
Clip No. 2 (Charisma on Command): • 5 Embarrassing Mistake... (1:50 - 2:44)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
✳️MAILING ADRESS: ✳️
Ian Corzine - Your TH-cam Lawyer
3835 E. Thousand Oaks Blvd., Ste. 472
Westlake Village, California 91362
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
⭐️And also please say "Hi!" on Social Media⭐️:
Twitter: / iancorzine
Instagram: / iancorzine
Facebook: / iancorzinehotm
LinkedIn: / ian-corzine
www.iancorzine.com
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The content of this TH-cam channel is provided for informational purposes only and is not intended to constitute legal advice. You should not rely upon any information contained on this TH-cam channel for legal advice. Viewing this TH-cam channel is not intended to and shall not create an attorney-client relationship between you and Ian Corzine or West Corzine, LLP. Messages or other forms of communication that you transmit to this TH-cam channel will not create an attorney-client relationship and thus information contained in such communications may not be protected as privileged. Neither Ian Corzine nor West Corzine, LLP makes any representation, warranty, or guarantee about the accuracy of the information contained in this TH-cam channel or in links to other TH-cam channels or websites. This TH-cam channel is provided "as is," does not represent that any outcome or result from viewing of this channel. Your use viewing of this TH-cam channel is at your own risk. You enjoy this TH-cam channel and its contents only for personal, non-commercial purposes. Neither Ian Corzine, West Corzine, LLP, nor anyone acting on their behalf, will be liable under any circumstances for damages of any kind.
© 2019 Ian Corzine. All rights reserved.
#iancorzine
#youryoutubelawyer - แนวปฏิบัติและการใช้ชีวิต
Who is your favorite COMMENTATOR on TH-cam? Does that person comply with ⭐️ FAIR USE ⭐️rules?
Why dont you make arabic captions ? It will be great
أنا محمد i’m Mohammed l OK. That sounds like a good idea!
Mine would be... not sure
Ian Corzine
Hi Ian,
I wanted to try a new concept of showing videos from different perspectives, then having my audience & I work towards a solution. Obviously this will take much longer then the 3-5 second rule. I assume it would be ok to “link” these videos in the description of the show, play them in their entirety & that way I am not violating “fair use.” Would that still meet guidelines?
PewDiePie And Me
Quality relevant content✅
Good production values ✅
Clear and concise ✅
Commentary on commentaries✅
Tasteful tie✅
Thank for your high rating!! 👊😁
This series MUST continue. Thanks for this, Ian.
Awwww...Thank you for watching AND for your kind words. I hope I am providing content that is useful to creators. 👊😁
@@iancorzine useful AND thought provoking. I'm sure it sparks imaginations of those out there based off the examples you use. When it's all said and done, the clips one would "use" would be comparable to how Hip Hop producers USES "SAMPLES" TO MAKE BEATS.
Pat Condell is my favorite TH-camr. He does all his own original material. So I can’t imagine him ever having a problem.
Hopefully not. The problem is that sometimes people claim other's work as their own and they are successful in getting the other person's video blocked. So frustrating. Thanks for watching. 👊😁
You also make commentary on your example. Thank you for sharing this info =)
Thanks so much for watching, I really appreciate it!
i am so glad i found your channel, whenever i read a creator comment about copyright anywhere i let them know about your channel it helps us all make better videos
ok so i want to use videos from youtube or wherever to do reaction videos. do I need to be watching the video live while recording myself doing the reaction in obs or do I acquire the video by wtv means and add my overlay after? thnx if you answer
Great series. Can’t wait for the next one. I appreciate the work put into these videos 👍
Thanks so much Whiskey!!!
I understood this to be the case in the context of video essays, however I've been struggling to find information on what would be considered commentary in reference to something like a game mod. What I mean is, would someone basing their mod off of copyrighted material be considered a commentary on the material itself in that it's their interpretation of and expression of said material showing appreciation? If so, what would be the limitations and exemptions in this regard?
I'm asking due to the current situation with Nintendo going after modifications for the game Garry's Mod, an 18 year old game, out of the blue and very harshly. Do these creators have any legal standing or defense?
I'd love to get more information about this and considering how well you explained this I hope you'd consider covering this topic!
Just to add, in case you're not aware of the situation, these mods made by the community are not for profit (as far as I am aware, if there are outliers they are not the norm and shouldn't be taken into consideration anyway, however I'd be interested to know how this would affect the majority if there was a small few that were profiting where they shouldn't be, and if this would basically destroy any defense others who were not being scummy would have) but I'm sure if you cover this you'll look into it. I just thought I'd add some extra info that could help you decide whether it's worth you're time or not
Thanks for the information. How did you obtain (download) the Linus clip to embed in this video?
Thanks for the tips and pointers to what to do to avoid copyright issues. Commenting regarding the last video to with gaming copyrights. Love your stuff man and helping to create legit TH-cam channels
Besides getting Fair Use literate-ish, I love all the channels you introduce us to, "charisma on demand" definitely going on my list, thank you MA
MA -- it is an AMAZING channel -- I love its discussion about other people's impressions of us.TQMA
Hi, Ian. You've once answered my a question I had in this video, and you replied about using portions of the video and commenting and/or reacting to it. Based on this, I have a follow-up question from you: where you said about clips being short (2 to 5 seconds long) at 6:28, is it possible to do a longer clip of the copyrighted work, but comment or react during most of it?
My channel is centered around reaction/review/commentary/critique (mostly of movie trailers). When I get copyright claims I often use the "review" fair use argument (in the beginning I used "reaction"). But I've wondered if I should use "commentary" instead. Because that is what I often do in reaction to a trailer I watch. I don't just play the trailer and film my facial reactions. At the end, I discuss my thoughts about the trailer, the story, the actors, review how well the trailer was done, etc - various things. So is "commentary" more accurate than "reaction" or even "review?"
Does it matter which section of the reuse content my commentary is added?
Example: can I play a clip in its entirety and then comment at the end of the clip or does my commentary have to be in the middle of the clip or at the beginning of the clip?
All about that commentary life! haha
You know it!! 👊😁
Great rule to have and know the in and outs of, Thanks for the info brother!👍
Hey Cliff! Thanks so much for watching!
Why doesnt this have more views!? Liked, subed and shared! Thanks for the vid.
hello Ian great video this is exactly the info i needed, i ask if you do all this, and properly to fall under fair use through commentary, would you still be constrained to using minimal amount of video/song 3-5seconds?
Great video once again :) Thanks for all your help Ian
Hey Cam! Thank YOU!
Appreciate these videos so much. Would you happen to have any advice for doing commentary on lengthy clips? Sometimes the really crucial one-liners I want to reference can run longer than 5 seconds. Thank you so much!
Thank you so much! You’re amazing and I appreciate this channel 🎉
Can 'Fair Use' apply to videos that are being interpreted to English, where the video was originally posted on social media, in a foreign language other than English? In other words, would I be able to post videos by using other people's content that I translated into English with added voice interpretation and English subtitles?
Best channel on the subject!
I've been searching for this information. Thank you
The Copyrights Club!!! I mean Copyrights Squad!! Yeah!!! Hahaha! Thanks Bro Ian and got a lot more new idea for commentary.
More power to you. 😎👍
Thanks so much Deso for all your support!!!
Excited to hear your ideas on commentary!!!
EXACTLY what i needed to hear.
Thank you.
Best video on this topic! Good work
Appreciate the information, thank you.
Hello! Does the audio source used for a reaction video matter, whether it's a TH-cam video on the artist's official account, a YT video uploaded by a fan or audio from a CD? Thanks!
I would like to know if written quotes in a video would be an issue or are they
subject to copyright also?
Written words are subject to copyright, too, and so you have to put Fair Use principles to work!
Awesome
Thank you for watching!! 👊😁
@@iancorzine welcome sir
Don’t really have a favorite commentator. . . 🤷🏻♂️ Here’s a question for you- if you use copyrighted material and get a strike from TH-cam, is there a way to remove the strike, either by taking the video down or altering the copyrighted material? Or is the strike permanent?
No -- the strike drops off in 90 days, unless you get another.
Hi Ian, I'm thinking of starting a TH-cam channel where I'd teach plot structure using TV episodes as examples. The way that I wanted to do it was by having my voice talking about the structure of the particular episode that I'm talking about (say, The Office Season 4 Episode 1), and while I'm talking about the structure of that episode, I'd have relevant clips from that episode playing, although the audio from those video clips wouldn't be playing, just the video.
My questions are: if I monetize the video, does that fall under fair use, and am I okay to start making videos like that? If not, then would I be alright to do that WITHOUT monetizing the videos? And failing that, what if I used pictures of the SCRIPT from that episode instead of actual video clips? As in, the video would just be me and then images of relevant portions of the script from that episode?
Thanks in advance for any help that you can provide. I love your videos!
Kindly advise If the commentary can be a non-verbal one? For example, me reacting to a copyrighted video and giving my opinions in the form of texts displayed on the screen. Can I do that? Thank you...
Hi! Love your youtube channel. I am only starting out and would like to ask if below is copyright if i post on youtube..
I take an online survey like a "personality test" or "which disney character i am", etc. give my thoughts about myself. Thanks!
spot on bud
I love the vid! Very relevant.
Quick question..
What if my commentary is in a form of text? No voice and with noncopyrighted background music
Would it still qualify the fair use?
Thanks!
So if any youtuber talks about memes,music,gameplays, or even paintings and they pull out of that picture video clip or audio, will that consider as a fair use?
Bless you for this video! I'm just starting out and have been looking for this precise information! Awesome content huge thumbs up!
Hi, im pretty new to this TH-cam adventure. I’m trying to understand Fair Use on historical pictures, newspapers clips, and pictures/ drawings out of books in a series I’m working on my other channel.
Basically it will be me revisiting locations and wanting to show and talk about a historical event.
I understand anything created before 1927 is public domain. But, some of these pictures I have found are on the local public library website and they ask for permission to use pictures, etc.
My goal is to be factually informative in my videos by helping the viewers to get a better understanding on the history I’m covering in each episode.
I just want to do it the right way from the beginning!! Any suggestions?
I have 2 questions:
1. Is copyright strike and copyright claim the same thing?
2. I used some songs in my video and I wrote comments on the clips but the audio still got copyright claim. I cannot remove the audio because well if I'm giving my feedback on the song, I'll have to play it i guess. What should I do?
I am confused over the time element here. If I want to analyze a photograph and tell why it works, such as where the lights were placed and the depth of field and how the background was handled, I would have to leave the copyrighted photograph up on the screen for most of the duration of the video. Would this not be allowed because of the time?
So far I haven't done this because when you look on Getty, for example, there is a cost for editorial use. Any advice appreciated!
Hey Jill -- I mean, you could. It's just a risk you take. You have to remember we're dealing with TH-cam policies here and bots. What you've described is Fair Use, however, bots sometimes make mistakes. My advice is better be safe than sorry.
@@iancorzine Thank you! So happy to have some guidance.👏
@@iancorzine now i understand
Quick question- creators like Linus and Charisma for sure monetize their videos, so is it still considered fair use even if they're making money off of other people's work? And with that being said, am I allowed to monetize a video of me commentating over a video that I didn't create?
thanks so much for hard work on tips
You are so welcome!! Thank you for watching AND for your kind words. 👊😁
This is really great content. Thank you for this!!
Thanks so much Alisha!!!
Regarding commentary, and I hope someone can answer ...if you are reviewing a song, for example, and you are listening and commenting throughout the video, is that considered fair use? Thank you 🙏
Love the Charisma on Command channel.
As you promised. Thanks Ian. I'll share it to my friends. Expect that you'll be flooded by subs 🙂
Awwwwh! Thank you SO much! I appreciate you!
you my man are a saint
You deserves a million views.
Thank you so much!!! I'm trying to help creators be successful. 👊😀
Thanks for the help Ian! 😉❤️
Well, thanks so much for watching JD!
Hi Ian, I impressed with your video. If I created a video, and put a commentary as a text not voice , is it counts ?
Yes. That should be fine. As long as you abide by the other rules as well. 👊😁
So I was wondering, what if I am interviewing a person that was on a late night talk show? What if I used the clip that featured the person I am interviewing? And we talked about what happened and how did they get to be featured on that talk show after I showed the clip? Does that count as part of the fair use guidelines?
Yes, as long a you follow the Fair Use rules. Make sure the clip is only 2-5 seconds long (10 secs max) and that you comment and/or react directly to the clip you just showed. You may want to watch some of my other videos that talk more about this. Thanks for watching AND I hope this answered your question. 👊😁
Wow. Great video, Im loving this series. Thanks for following up!! BEST YT LAWYER :)
Aww thanks!!! 💗👊😀
i just wanna thank you for making this
Thanks for your videos! I'm learning a lot! I have a question tho, what if I want to create a mashup video of different clips from other TH-cam videos? Like for example, could I use 15 20 seconds of different videos of people talking about motivation and put them all together in one video?. Is that allowed?
And is it possible also, to do this, and use a popular song in the background in a lower volume, but still have the audio from each of the different clips?
Do you think we can monetize videos where we add unique comments to "content uploaded many times by other creators"?
Because while commenting on videos makes using other people's monetizable. "Content uploaded many times by other creators" falls into the content reused policy and seems to imply that using other people's videos are not monetizable. I am confused.
For the Linus Tech Tips example, doesn't that seem more like critique than commentary?
Hey quick question Ian. Are TH-camrs like Ozzy Man within the rights of Fair Use, as he does comical reviews on the various videos on the Internet? Thanks you!
Thumbs up for the quality alone 🙌🏾
What if I want to use video game footage in my video but then I talk about how these clips relate to what I am discussing? Is this considered fair use? I just want to make sure that I won't get copyrighted before I start posting videos. Like if I played a clip then talked about how it helps prove my theory?
Hi Ian! I find your videos so helpful. Thank you for making this kind of content! I'm trying to upload a reaction to a new music video, and I want to show the entire video pausing along the way to interject with my thoughts. Do you have any suggestions for trying to react to longer stretches of content? Because every time I upload the video it keeps getting a copyright claim and/or taken down entirely despite the fact that I am offering commentary throughout the entire thing. Thank you so much!
I would love to help out and answer any questions you may have!
You can book a call and set up a scheduled 1-on-1 call with me.
iancorzinescheduling.as.me/ian
Thanks so much!
if i edit one minute video and make it 5 secs video without commentary is it fair use?
Hello Mr. Corzine! I was wondering, my friends and I have started this TH-cam channel where we react to and review movies (in separate videos). For the reactions, we watch through the movie together and then cut out most of the movie for the final video. While we record, we usually speak over and discuss the movie as it is playing, thus preventing us from using a short clip, which you mention is preferable. Would this still be considered commentary (or any other form of Fair Use), even though we are not distinctly pausing the movie and discussing it?
Thank you for all of your videos on the copyright and fair use ideas and laws! I am actually starting to understand!
Hi, Ian. I have a question for you regarding your critique/criticism and commentary videos I just saw: at one point, I've seen videos of people talking about certain DVDs from their favorite movies or TV shows they've obtained. Does that count as critique/criticism, commentary, or the creators original work?
Hi Emily. To answer your question, If the creators show portions of the video and then comment and/or react to it, it is considered Fair Use and it becomes their original work. However, they need to abide by the Fair Use exception laws which includes keeping it short and giving credit to the original creator. I hope this answers your question. Thanks for watching AND for reaching out. 👊😀
@@iancorzine, okay, thank you.
Nothing better than getting free advice from a lawyer!
Haha! Thanks man -- I so appreciate it!
Hi alot of info on your channel thank you 😊 i got a question what if the artwork on sale comes with terms such as “cannot be publicly reviewed ...” Can others still review it according to fair use law?
Can you explain how channels like riddle & what if uses copyrighted material without getting strikes? ?
Good day sir am from the UK and I got 16 million views for the month I need some advice from you about fair use I don’t have strikes but another issue. Is there a way to contact you ie discord or something
How to explain watchmojo? They basically use film clips throughout all their videos.
Ben Shapiros copyright team: **shaking**
this information is PARAMOUNT!!!!! does using the copyrighted material/GIFS (7 seconds and under) to comedically comment/compliment what im talking about in the video?
This helps me because I've gotten into music remixes and it can kick me in the behind
Yep! Really hard stuff to do on TH-cam.
@@iancorzine I agree! But I have rights as long as the music is my own work
Commentary-seption... classic.
are you allow to play the full video while commenting on it?
I love your videos. I have a question though. I want to make tech videos in my Native language. Can I use short clips other peoples tech videos and make a voiceover in my Language. Explaining what's happening on the screen. Is it considered fair use?
Can we commentary about image . Plan to commentary about cricket match with cricket images .please give me advice .thank you
What if your doing an episode recap and the. Share your opinions at the end if thr episode run time is 25 mins how much footage can i use
Yoo! ✌️😀 Ian.. thank you so much.. 😁 I just uploaded my latest video on which I've used 25 songs with commentary and only got 2 copyright claims... I already disputed the claims with appropriate reasons and hoping that they'll remove copyright claims..! Thank you so much Ian! You saved me.. 😊
And do you also think positive that they are gonna remove the claims? .. 🤔 let's hope for the best.. ✌️
After all I've given positive commentary and I think it's gonna be promotional for their artworks..
No problem! Happy to help!
Can i add text caption on copyright video instead of commentary?
Question: Are there any approaches for copyright that cover the use of a video for a punchline? or just comedy? Does "Parody" cover this?
Hey Chris -- it's possible that parody covers what you describe but I'd have to see it. Generally, what most YT are doing today is not parody -- it's just using copyrighted material for the punchline, which is not Fair Use.
@@iancorzine thanks for clearing that up Ian! Keep up the great work 😁👍
My question is where to find the downloadable clips such as the Ben Shapiro video?
Can I download someone’s entire workout video, and do a picture in picture of me trying their workout. with me adding commentary about the workout? Maybe add some copyright free music in the background.
I'm unclear what the difference is between critique and commentary. Could you clarify that, please?
What about gameplay commentary 10 - 15 minutes? is it okay?
Im planing to make a channel to review movies and top10list and such,similar to watchmojo channel.is it ok to follow the approach of watchmojo channel????commenting while playing movie parts in background??
Do reaction videos like anime reaction videos considered as commentary and fair use? Lately, anime channels haven been receiving a lot of demonization, claims and strikes and even some being terminated(like mine). It would be great to know your view on this. 😁
~ keep it short? How does New Rockstars spend hours breaking down entire tv episodes?
Hi Ian, thanks for your video. If I am correct in my understanding, you can no longer do music reaction videos where you let the video play and simultaneously describe the musical techniques the artists are using. You would get a copyright claim. If you dispute the claim under fair use, even though You Tube has a category for reaction videos and you can state that you were simply providing a review of the video, if the copyright holder wanted to they could actually cause you to go from a copyright claim to a copyright strike?
Hi
Thank you for your awesome videos. I learned so much and I already subscribed to your channel.
Can you please help me with my questions? I couldn't find a good answer anywhere. How can we use copyrighted movies or videos to make countdown list like top10 lists from watchmojo. I also recommend you to make a video about this because I saw on many forums people were looking for an answer. Thanks
I do language -learning-related content for the somewhat obscure language Esperanto. One idea I've had is to dub and comment on other people's videos into .... uh .... better Esperanto. Ideally, I'd like to get permission to do this, but I wonder if it could be considered fair use - education, commentary.... The clips would probably not be short - which is something you keep saying.
And again, I think I would rather get permission to use the clips because I'm sure people would appreciate feedback better if they knew it was coming and gave permission first.
Yeah, getting permission is best. Thank you for watching!
Favorite? Actually, I have a few.
Midnight's Edge
Nerdrotic
DVD Overlord
Anna That Star Wars Girl
Just to name a few commentators of Pop culture who depend on Fair Use and Commentary
I had never of Nerdrotic! Thanks!
He sir can I make my own sports video and then can use commentry from professional match is that copyright or not?
Hey so I used a clip in a live stream from a flat earther that had a little music in the back. It was under 30 secs and had talking over it. I have been given a copyright notice. Is this right?
Hey there!! Thanks for watching.👊😁 I cannot tell whether you got the copyright violation for the clip you used or the music that was in the background. Usually, any clips you use can only be 2-5 secs (10 sec max) and then you need to comment or react directly to the clip you just showed. If there is music to the clip, you also need to give credit to wherever you got the video and/or music from. This video may help you understand it better: th-cam.com/video/6_WWRJ71Hqo/w-d-xo.html
@@iancorzine I talked over the clip that was playing, do I still need to give credit? Even when the original video didnt?
Yeah, always give credit -- doesn't take that long and go a long way to showing your intent for use of the copyrighted material.
But how can channels like Watchomjo use clips from hollywood movies in their videos without doing commentary over it when giving examples?
Hi! Thanks for this video! I`m preparing a channel that will have commentaries and reviews on fashion shows, editorials and fashion collections, along side video commentary on styling from kpop mvs. So.... just because i will put my opinion, describe and analyze in details what is going on and explain the complicated aspects of them, the videos will be under fair use and not be claimed or struck????
Are videos like what Ray William Johnson did considered fair use? Would it be fair use to play a copy righted video and pause it every 4-5 seconds to commentate it and give your own twist about what is happening?
Toyphotography is a great example of transforming someone else's art into your own.
You made this great video 3 years ago. Are these ways valid in todays date ?