We have some exciting news! We’re launching channel Memberships for just $0.99 a month. You’ll get access to members-only posts and videos, live Q&As with Bloomberg reporters, business trivia, badges, emojis and more. Join us: th-cam.com/users/bloombergjoin
Not just workers. Materials, machinery, expertise gained from building. Pakistan is left with a huge bill, puppet status on China, infrastructure. Latter is the only positive but even this may have limited benefit if other powers stop the Belt n Road project from reaching its target
This is how developed economies power their economies through aid and things like this, use your own money to stimulate your own economy while giving other nations "stuff"
@@pudanielson1 Aid and loan are different things. Especially Chinese loan. Following example is on the extreme side but it helps to illustrate the issue. China gave Ethiopia a huge loan, making big fanfare about how it helps developing nations. Same year, western countries gave same amount as aid, though UN. Chinas contribution to that aid was flat 0. Aid doesn't leave receiving country as dependent politically, while loans from China stipulate unfavorable terms, like use of Chinese workers and materials, in case of defaulting on loan, handing over infrastructure for up to 100 years, puppet status in UN, leading to comical status where we are now, with World Health Organization being effectively a mouthpiece to China's Communist party and China being member of UN human rights council. There are positive effects obviously, plus some countries are desperate for investments and have no other choices, Belt and Road can actually materialize in the future and pay back the loan cost. But I doubt the latter
@Lawrence Weston so its a win win for both. Gwadar is no use of Pakistan so why not join the silk road. No wonder why pakistan took over half of Kashmir and china helped pakistan. Long term planing smart
@Lawrence Weston i believe the only reason Pakistan will stick to china instead of US even if they fulfill all three point that you mentioned, is because the US history of not keeping its promises and agreements. After the chinese sanctions on canada and eu counties and there sanctions on china. Pakistan will stay neutral and choose whats best for Pakistan’s economy. China for the first time has put sanctions on western countries to show that its the time now , china is strong and has allies who will backup their position like pakistan, iran and many African countries. A proper strong answer in sanctions is a prove of ( no more bullying ) iran is happy to receive 400 billion. So is Pakistan
@@thomasthumim7630 The word cockroach is the one used during the Rwanda genocide. It makes things simpler. It makes hating and killing simpler. Be careful my friend.
Could be that they couldn’t find a pakistani parliament video, the footage makes the point which is to demonstrate a parliament not necessarily implying that its visually the pakistani parliament.
Well, if you have a spare $1 trillion, it is better to spend it on infrastructure around the developing world - than fritter it away in a single misguided war (Operation Iraqi Freedom).
Moreover China cannot “spend” its spare USD, so the alternative to investing the developing world is to lend those money back to the US, which I’m afraid, the Americans are not very happy either
Shipping in their own workers then building them housing that keeps them separate. Locals can apply to be the janitor or checkpoint security I expect. Maybe not even security, not with CCP management.
What else do you expect the local populace does not have the expertise nor education to take on such highly intellectual jobs of engineers. Training their children would take a decade or more. Think logically. It's all based on Equity not equality.
Its like a person who constantly fights within his family , he will ask for help and support from any random stranger on street without thinking of consequences! Even after getting so many setbacks and humiliation it learns nothing. If and only if he would realise that making amends with the family is the best solution for stable future and there is nothing lacking if the house is in peace and family united!
Chinese love to gamble, such chinese plans are failing, doesn't matter if you pour billions in material, capital if local people, administration, bureaucracy are corrupt nothing will get done. Many projects in Africa, Venezuela stalled due to corrupt, chinese are digging their own grave
Looks like a Debt trap to me... they walked right into it, that’s what happens when you get hand outs in the first place! There’s no partnership there 🤦🏻♂️
@@chocolateboy4959 sure lol we were the ones who suffered a country wide electrical outage a few weeks ago right? You guys are still dealing with Polio while it got wiped out when I was a kid in India. Plus our PM and military generals don’t have to go to Saudi to beg them for loan extensions and go to China to beg for vaccines. We supply vaccines to Saudi. No Indian wants to be a Pakistani lol. We genuinely feel bad for you Talibanis.
@@sfb1219 @Sfb what you mean farmers? The farmer strike is in India. And who told you China got Pakistani land, don't put your head in your a** only, look for alternative media to open up your brainwashed head. Right now their is one terrorist nation who is running coups back to back on different countries.
@@Arash157 no, that's what I just told you, it does not go to show how much whoever is reporting about the project really know about it, but instead goes to show how much the CCP understands about the basic functionality of roads and waterways seeing how it was not taken from the reportage but the official ditty.
But it doesn't help in local employment. It's like giving money from right hand and taking it back from left hand. Even basic labours are coming from China.
@@kokuyocamlin07 Are you serious ? As an engineer in the Middle East, half of our company’s staff come from local employees, and we continue to learn from the cooperation and communication with employees. Local employees have mastered the technology, and local employees can complete the maintenance and operation in the later stage, and even drive the later stage. The development of small projects can be done by locals。At the same time ,as a Chinese, we never export troops and so-called democracy to foreign countries. We just want to develop with brother countries and make the world better and more peaceful.
It goes both ways. China and Pakistan both won't reveal how much of the project is donation by the Chinese, and how much of the project is funded by the commercial banks of China at a high interest rates to Pakistan. 80% of the products will be build in China and shipped to the world via belt and road infrastructure. Pakistan exports very few products and will end up being responsible for the maintenance and up keep of the infrastructure.
@@rtshchand you are wrong, Chinese loans is less than IMF and world bank, much lower than commercial rates. Singapore also a port that transit goods and they got rich from the trades.
@@madsam0320 Then why is Chinese and Pakistan government not willing to show the funding of the project. CPEC started almost a decade ago, where is the prosperity that was promised. Pakistan is no Malaysia.
Why are no Pakistani/Chinese interviewed, in order to have a balanced view on the topic they should have been interviewed too, I am neither Pakistani or Chinese, just want a balanced reporting
Thos was a propaganda piece most likely created by Indians working for Bloomberg. You do know they are slowly taking over not only high government positions but also media outlets and all major US corporations. Soon, we will all be working for Indians.
Thats how they make propaganda if you see middle east coverage too they don't interview locals but they out their agendas and make propagandas on behalf of us
Lol. These western propagandists assumed that CPEC has some problems ergo all BRI projects are stalled out... 🤣 Seriously, CPEC is just one of the corridors planned. The Maritime belt is strong as ever with countless of ports have been established and constructed for the past few years in Africa. In Indonesia alone, the HSR project is in full swing and will be finished much earlier than Japan's project in india that even a singnificant single post for rail wasn't even erected... The Loas-CHINA corridor is in full swing and most of railway, expressways will be opened in 2022. Russia-CHINA pipleline 2 is already underconstruction and Kazakhstan-CHINA gas pipeline is currently expanding. No to mention the projects Africa is still in full swing. It's like their propaganda about debt trap diplomacy when always parroting the 1 time of debt equity swap of Hambatota port in Sri Lanka yet they hide the fact that CHINA has restructured, debt relief and rescheduled 87 times of those countries which owed to CHINA. Sensationalism is the core of these western propagandists....🤣
@@samalenyo It's true that many sections of western media portray China as some evil state that is on the mission of bringing the whole world under China's regime. And many westerners don't buy this. But this report seems fair and unbiased. The lady and other stated the truth about the CPEC.
The main challenge is the CCP and its financial traps layed out to later on control whole states in Asia, Africa, South America and even Europe. People have figured out their BS.
@@DarxKies Well, this is far from reality. I wish it could happen if China has any plans to control the poverty stricken countries with corrupted leaders. At the end of the day, a person wants peace and prosperity. And that’s what you can see through out the China now. Who wouldn’t want development in Africa? And I would half credit western media and half blindness of people that cannot see the other side. Western institutions such as IMF and world bank are in the game of debt trap for long time now. So, don’t worry no one is taking over other countries.
No... All projects are working with rapid speed ...and CPEC is under a saperate authority which is called CPEC Authority. There is no bureaucratic influence in this authority
Mobility and logistics more product out more debt built more influence secured. Maybe not exactly like that but I do think they’re trying to control routes once held by India
The report is completely misleading. The project is supposed to complete in 2030. First phase of CPEC, which include 12K megawatt electricity, has already completed, the 2nd phase which include Special Economic Zones is underway. Already 10 Special Economic Zones have approved by PM in March 2020 and 3 of which are already working. More than 3000 km roads are either completed or about to complete this year. Moreover, China is building two big dams which will complete in 2025.
Keep thinking like that and u will end up China's province!😂😅🤣 Eventually u all will be next Uighurs. Core problem is Pakistan now Totaly depends on China...for loans, highways, defence, IT, Port and what not...even thier vaccine comes from china. Only a fool put all the eggs in one basket. Ever heard a word 'Diversity' This is new colonialism, Look at sri Lanka and other african Countries. Your army is compromised and in direct control of CCP.
@@Anonymous-hp1tg we have strong and reliable ties with China.... China is not only investing in Pakistan but also sharing its technology which will make Pakistan sufficient i.e Nuclear technology, JF 17 etc. I don't know why the Indian and the west are so obsessed with Chinese loan to Pakistan but the bitter truth is that 9% of our total debts belong to China. The rest 91% either belong western countries or institutions, like World bank and IMF. When it comes to lay all eggs in one basket, it is not true either. The USA is the biggest export market of Pakistan. Pakistan still has strong relation with many western and Muslim countries.
@@sajidmosvi6364 guess what many Muslim nations like Turkey and Bangladesh hate China now after what they did to Uighur muslims converted mosques into toilets. I heard many Pakistani people as well have started to hate China.
@@simriths.s5976 I don't think so .... Uyghur issue is highly exaggerated one by western media. Many of my friends studying there on scholarship. They never found such allegations there. As Uyghur is also neighbor to our province(GB) we have strong trade relation with them as well. And traders from both sides visit each other. Yes, in past this region was facing Islamic extremism because of spillover effect of Taliban and All Qaeda led Afghanistan. The west and especially the USA want to rekindle it again.
What do you expect? Hire people from another country that have no knowledge or skill or be able communicate to them to build these massive projects? Build these massive projects so the citizens will then have jobs and training to run and operate them?!
@@itsurcooffy I'm sure there are plenty of Pakistanis being exploited in construction in the middle east. Hire them to build in their own country, except this time actually pay them.
Pakistan ask US for help to build the port. US: No. Pakistan ask China for help to build the port. China: Yes. US: China intend to build a naval base in Pakistan.
Pakistan owes the world 239 billion dollars, and Chinese money is only 25% of it. Considering that the debt is used to build critical infrastructure, the CPEC project is essential to Pakistan. And why does no one talks about the other 75% debt 🤔
Details: Pakistani economy is 278 billion US dollars. At 85.9% debt to gdp ratio, thats 239 billion US dollars of debt. The 60 billion US dollar CPEC project in discussion makes up= 60/239 ×100= 25% of debt. If you consider that the remaining debt was basically used in currency manipulation, meaning wasted, this project is a dream come true, as it gives critical infrastructure to a country that badly needs it to pull itself out of poverty.
Nice try pak, the other 75% of debt is from the IMF and occurred becuz Pakistan got sanctioned after developing nuclear weapons. Maybe instead of building nukes and fighting with India u guys focused on not being bad at being a functioning country, u wouldn't have to worry abt this debt.
Yes, because is the cause of debt trap of Sri Lanka and made it hand over their port to china for 99 years! The very same thing china will be doing to every other small countries.
@@rethinkkk LOL. Like Mr Tarek Fatah says, how does P*kistan produces such huge number of rectums, that says even if I loose both my eyes it is OK, but that other guy who is happy must lose one.
Turkey and Pakistan: "We are the guardians of the worlds Muslims!" China: "Can we put Muslims in concentration camps, ban their religion and forcefully sterilise them?Well give you some trade deals..." Turkey and Pakistan: " Yes please"
Wasn't Pakistan the one who went to China with the idea to build a Port in gwarder, which gave China the idea to revitalized the old silk road, aka B,R,I
What will happen if they default. China will take over the infrastructure built by their money just like the Gwadhar port, China is already in control over the Hambantota port for 99 years.Chinese consortium has taken over 40 per cent stake in Pakistan's stock exchange. Simple..... Chinese money Chinese Labour Chinese construction goods and materials Chinese companies What the host countries are basically doing is buying up the infrastructure
@@sounoks3180 You don't worry about that. Pakistan and China's friendship is more than 70 years old. This CPEC Project is important for both countries. It's more important to Pakistan because we need better infrastructure so our economy can rise. Pakistan will pay China back the loans when economy of Pakistan improves. Pakistanis are optimistic and in ease when it does business with friend China because there is a lot of trust between the two friendly countries.
it's not too cheap but ur mentality is too cheap that comparing a port price with us army budget actually Gwadar port is priceless for Pakistani people it bullshits other countries will not understand it and make it controversial like just u are trying to
@@saadshah1005 Did I say this is cheap? I can smell your lack of confidence across the Indian Ocean and the Pacific Ocean. My point is that the United States can spend money to transport ice cream to frontline soldiers by air, but it cannot build a port properly. Now let China get this important port.
Lol only some chinese engineers are on field. And why wouldn't they? It's a joint project. Many of projects have been completed including the motorways and metro trains on which we dialy travel. Its quite when media acts to know more than pakistanis🤣🤣
Many posters on this forum don't understand that the objective of the Pakistan corridor is to save time and money for Chinese goods. By travelling via the Pakistan corridor, travel time will be cut by up to 60%, as compared to travel via the South China Seas. Pakistan will make tens of billions each year from Transit fees by enabling Chinese companies to use the corridor to save time and money. Its a win-win situation for both China and Pakistan.
The port is not drawing enough business. Pakistan will therefore, not be able to repay its debt. Under the terms of the deal, in such a situation, China will take possession of the facility. It will then be able to convert it (or part of it) to a naval base. The same plan was successfully completed in Sri Lanka. The overall strategy, is to surround India.
@@mombaassa At the moment. Once its finished, they will be transporting oil and products via Pakistan. The corridor is still be built. Once complete, they will be able to transport goods via the corridor to China, saving time and money. Sri Lanka was a different case - there is no corridor to China, as it rely on India joining the BRI. But India turned down the offer to join the BRI, which made Sri Lanka's port unprofitable. Pakistan is different - it does not need India's permission to transport their goods to China - the corridor goes straight into China.
@@mombaassa Further information on situation of Sri Lanka. Only 70% of the Port is lease to the Chinese for Commercial Use. The other 30% is used by the Sri Lankan Navel Base.
@@vanwong6768 Nobody ever believed that India would join the BRI, and make the port viable. China was a driving force behind this Indian rejection, by its constant, border provocation on the Himalayas. The plan was always to aquire, a potential naval facility. Nice try, Wumao.
@@vanwong6768 "Only 70%...". That's an oxymoron. Do you actually read what you type? Wumaos are meant to write things in favour of China. Don't type too many more idiotic statements, otherwise they'll send you back to Wumao School, or put you on the list for organ donors.
Mr. Jonathan Hillman, a small history lesson here for you. Pakistan didn't got it's independence in 1947, it was formed on the basis of religion by dividing Indian mainland into two. Erstwhile Punjab and Bengal province divided into two. Muslim majority East Bengal and West Punjab formed Pakistan along with Balochistan, Sindh, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. Mr. Mohammad Ali Jinnah, then member of All India Muslim league later founding father of Pakistan had come to believe that the Muslims of the Indian subcontinent should have their own state to avoid the possible marginalised status they may gain in a Hindu-Muslim state. In the year 1940, the Muslim League, led by Jinnah, passed the Lahore Resolution, demanding a separate nation.
It was independence. Endia was not called Endia before British first proposed this name. Secondly, it was a subcontinent of different nationalities. Even today there's nothing common in Endia about all nations, races and religions. Pakistan have same national language, religion, culture but Endia is completely diverse in all aspects of society without common integration and with no natural unity.
@@Tirth727 No way better than Pakistan. Yup your economy is big but compare to size n population its poor, racist, illiteracy, uncivilized, uncultured, world's largest slum is in Endia not in Pakistan. The most poor people here are still living better quality life, air, water, greenry but Endia is a mess.
@@IrfanKhan-resistance I understand your love for Pakistan and hate for India. So no grudges. Few questions though, If Pakistan got its independence in 1947, then Why the name Pakistan was only came to exist after the Indian Independence Act 1947 passed in British parliament? Why in Pakistan, still to this date Buddhist and Hindu sculptures are discovered in regular interval linking it to different Indian Kingdoms? There were no particular evidence about etymology of Indian mainland because there were no marked borders back then. There were constant battle between Mughals, Turks, Mongols, Sikhs and Afghans in North. In south and West of India there were Marathas and Dravidian Kingdom. So those lands always changed hands.
Let me just say that : China is not in it for Pakistan. China like US in the past, is there for its own benefit. Its always a red flag when a foreign government creates a community inside your borders (Port City).
Well yes your right, but why would China just want to help Pakistan ? Surely it would want to look after its own interests as well? Pakistan accepted it because they saw the benefits it would bring them. Everyone is looking out for their own interest dude
@@tianyicai6482 funny point, its not a choice its obvious you cant financially burden a rapidly developing nation just like you can do to a debt ridden extremely poor nation
Is that why America didn’t even consider it. Or was it to stop this exact move. Humm ???? Anything connected to China comes with hesitation on anyone’s part
Brother I wonder if India helps you for liberating baloch from Pakistan will you let a Indian government community manager the government of baloch, or you strictly only want baloch goherment to rule the balochi, knowing that how much progress India make since its independence?
@@whsjdndshsjsjs7774 India would not want to manage Balochistan. Don't worry. Balochistan should be an independent country with its own government. Don't try to instigate the people of Balochistan by misleading them. Pakistan has made Balochistan the poorest province, with highest infant mortality rate and they receive the lowest money from the Pakistani government. They're literally treated like outcastes. Moreover, India has progressed far better than Pakistan. India has the fastest growing economy in the world, it has the highest number of FDIs, 600 billion dollars in foreign reserves, they're the third largest economy in the world and are improving in all aspects. Getting support from them to form a new country is much better than being with Pakistan. The Indian government should openly support Balochistan's freedom struggle just the way Pakistan does in Kashmir. The only difference would be that Kashmir will be in loss if administerated by Pakistan. Balochistan would be benefited if they're liberated.
@@fulkrumsukhoi1941 that was exactly I was saying, sorry if I wrote something inappropriate in previous comment, but I mean will The independent Baluchistan will trust India, if India wants to help them for development purpose?
We live in Pakistan, and we know the ground realities of this project, hundreds of kilometers of roads are constructed, work of few small and 3 large dams in going on, railways lines are being installed under this project, new fiber optic cables are installed and lot more. So we don't need west or america to lighten us about it.
.... You don't need but what about the rest of the world? This is their take on it, if you have problem that this video aren't true/false then argue the part that you know are false/wrong.
Exactly! Few hundred kilometers of road, railway and fiber means nothing when considering the whole country. And all those roads and dams and fiber will be used by Chinese and not ya’ll
@@aadipandey8237 few hundreds of kms of road is constructed and a total of 3000 km under construction and other dams and infrastructure project and who told u that we only china will use them??? indian media??
China's Belt and Road initiative has left many financially weak countries trapped in "secret debt". It is claimed that China owes 36.5 billion to these countries. China has invested a total of, 64.3 billion in roads, bridges, ports and hospitals in 173 countries. These countries include many countries in Africa and Central Asia. According to experts, 80 per cent of the, 64.3 billion has been lent to the central bank of the country concerned or to a joint venture between China and that country. But the government of many financially weak countries could no longer borrow. As a result, China has taken a different path. They have lent to a coalition of several companies. The government of that country is not directly in that alliance. But in many cases, the government has taken the responsibility of repaying the debt if the alliance of the companies is not able to repay the debt. As a result, the actual debt of those countries to China is not clear to the concerned government in many cases. According to the expert agency, the debt of China in 45 countries is more than 10 percent of their average national product. According to the expert agency, the debt of China in 45 countries is more than 10 percent of their average national product. There is strong dissatisfaction among some locals over the huge Chinese investment in provinces like Pakistan's Balochistan. They claimed that they did not benefit from the project. Militant groups have repeatedly targeted the Chinese project in Balochistan.
Chinese love to gamble, such chinese plans are failing, doesn't matter if you pour billions in material, capital if local people, administration are corrupt nothing will get done. Many projects in Africa, Venezuela stalled due to corrupt, chinese are digging their own grave
...but the port is supposedly fenced by the Chinese and not accessible even for most of the Pakstanis, so....? According to a retired bridagier or general (of course it being Pakstan, there's probably one retired army person every 10 steps or so), the Chinese fenced it to protect their investment so, it was ok that an average local Baloch or pakstani couldn't be allowed in the area.....
@@tiangcs8069 they are mad about the fence around gwadar mad about the fence at afghanistan border. Doesnt it make u wonder why? Like what's so wrong about a fence unless they have some kind of plans to enter that place illegally.
Im from india and i don't hate pak, usa has used them for their own benefits and now china is doing the same but imran khan( worst pm) had let them to do so. Pak and india should join hand together for development , we r the same ppl with different nationality
@akhilesh yadav• IF ONLY. INDIA HAS BECOME A DICTATORSHIP COUNTRY, INDIA WILL DESTROY ITSELF FROM WITHIN ,IF THAT HAPPENS CORRUPT MODI AND HIS RSS CRONIES WILL PAY A HEAVY PRICE.
1000 percent agree.. i am Pakistani but live in the us since i was 10. In america Indian and pakistanis live as neighbors lol. we are literaly the same people haha there is not one out there like us + Bangladesh
The whole Afghanistan got into never ending civil wars that killed millions of their own and pushed the country 50 years back economically. Thats what happened
From neutral point of view, this project is huuuuggee so it will take a long time to realise this and obviously everyone also understand that. So stalled is not the right word imo
It's not stalled. Couple of ships have started coming to this port and off course it will take time as you said it's a huge project which depends on some other things to be operational also but you will hear a lot of negative press against it from US affiliated media in an attempt to scare away the investors because china is involved.
@Mohammad Raza How? Both usa and uk had sent warships to threaten India to support pakistan. Didn't want to recognise Bangladesh immediately. India just prepped better and laid low before launching a blitzkrieg of diplomatic (taking USSR into confidence) and military hammer on Pakistan. India infact didn't got into the war and waited for the right time to train fighters inside the Bangladesh territory and to make multiple strategies incase one goes bad. Pakistan didn't fight a winning war. Rather usa supported pakistan by not giving access to gps data to India during many later conflicts between the two parties. P.S. Russia didn't attack, they had hinted to step in in case usa steps in.
@Mohammad Raza weren't Pakistan a proxy state while US and USSR were fighting and didn't you guys send mujahideen and help US create Taliban in Afghanistan? Well if you want to deny that cool, but your General Musharraf would agree with me here as he has said it on interviews time and again
@@kdeb3374 And by the way, Mukti Bahini were trained by USSR. Bengali nationalism was a Soviet project. Indira could never have dared to take such a step without USSR. And USSR wanted to hurt Pakistan because Pakistan was in Western camp and USSR desperately needed access to Indian ocean. It was also trying to instigate separatist elements in Balochistan.
CPEC is a great success. Gwadar has grown into a major port rivaling Dubai. Chinese engineers are safe in Pakistan and loved by Baloch people. CPEC is minting money, and Pakistan is becoming the next Asian tiger. This is all due to the honest and selfless leadership of Pakistani politicians and the establishment. Long live the great leader Xi Jinping.
@@chocolateboy4959 nobody is jealous of pakistan, actually indians are laughing and celebrating seeing your current economic condition and complete dependency on china.
@@chocolateboy4959 we're enjoying the beautiful show actually. It's time that you saw what reap. from the common man to your parliament, they're all lunatics there dancing on one leg. just look at your country's condition today. its laughable. poor joke. but also its bad that we dont have a competitive neighbour. you're a disgrace as a neighbour. 😑
@Syed Zaeem Ali Mohsin who says india depends on usa? India is self reliant in space,, army education,, food ,, infrastructure,, is USA coming and making roads in india?
"the local people fear that they will be left behind" go ahead and show local people employed to build the residential community... seriously blomberg?
there is no point of building the port first and then connects it to the country. So, Pakistan and china is currently building the road connectivity first and then build the port later for the use.
@UDDIPAN MONDAL Yeah by making a large population of Chinese workers they have an excuse to have more control over it. Most of their foreign infrastructure projects are like this.
China gets to use their excess labor, state-owned enterprise capacity, and keep strategic allies indebted to them. The leaders of the target country get to tout achievements and are paid under the table. The general population gets desperately needed infrastructure. It's a win-win-win strategy. I'm not implying China cares about the target country, but why would/should they?
Does the infrastructure serve them, or bypass them? Remember that entire self-sufficient communities have died and slums in the cities have grown because of otherwise straightforward changes to the national transportation network.
While in the beginning these projects look like they are very important and will bring forth much needed boost to the target country's economy, it usually always results in a massive failure, because China almost always puts on the execution on the target countries and then they are not able to make use of it, resulting in failure of the entire project
@@ben8718 not much currently, just textiles, opioids and cheap labor but if the Belt and road initiative went as planned, they could've set up thousands of new factories to start production and then use the highway corridor to ship it to Gwadar port from where it would've been distributed globally. But the Belt and road initiative has gone nowhere in the last 3 years and China has already seized operations at the port of Gwadar
the loans frm china is less then 10 pct then the loans we(pak) get from IMF and world bank so dont worry we r in phase two in which agriculture industry and education are priorities with infra structure in far flung areas aswell...btw IMF and Worldbank would hv defaulted us if it were not for the 4 billion dlrs from saudia and china
@@ISyedZainUlAbideen 22 Times IMF bailed you out and you think they would have defaulted you? FYI...IMF Did not ask Pak to take loan... Yourr PM went to IMF literally on knees. 🙄
Update : Pakistan has given the Gwadar port to China on 40 yrs lease means china now practically own that port of Pakistan . Looks like China's debt trap working very well .lol Edit : it's not 100 yrs but 40 yrs , but main thing is one country has given up there land to another country just becoz they don't have money to pay .
Why is CPEC failing? It’s because of the Pakistanis themselves, China has invested a lot of its money and wants to get it done, but they’ll never be able to complete it because it should pass through Pakistan’s heartland which is Punjab, Punjab is Pakistan’s farm land, because of the zamindari system, majority of the land in Punjab belongs to Pakistan’s elite, the army and the politicians, all of which hold dual citizenship and businesses abroad and their families live there, so it’s doesn’t matter to them if CPEC fails and they will never let CPEC pass through their land without demanding a royalty which China will never pay, so China now became predatory, let’s not forget that balochistan is not Pakistan’s land so they’ll resist, this was bound to fail from the beginning.
@@innershadow3615 I got this data from pakistan institute of labor, education and research (PILER) and securities and exchange commission of Pakistan (SECP)(a gov institution) they are my sources and it's officially on record that 5% of the agricultural families who do not contribute anything to agri productions own 2/3 rd of the agricultural land in pakistan, fedual/zamindari system of pakistan is well covered by both international agencies and local institutions of pakistan,(PILER) also states these 5% make up 1500 to 2000 families of pakistan,which is mainly composed of armed forces officials, and the political class, and a 2007 report stated that 2/3 rd of lower house of pakistan was made up by these zamindars, and the single largest land owner in pakistan is the army and it's subsidiaries. Balochistan has resistance because pakistan illegally and forcefully occupied it, pakistan had signed stand still agreement with Balochistan and there was an embassy of Balochistan in Karachi. This is not misinformation I'm Citing my sources and these sources are your government institution.
It’s got nothing to do with india you fool it’s all within the boundaries of Pakistan it will never be yours your lucky enough you control Jammu even that which you illegally took control of and where your Indian army harms the Kashmir locals
so basically Pakistan as snookered itself. Joined in the Soviet war, won and then joined in the Afghan war, ongoing, suffered loss now indebted to Chyna.
China plans decades ahead, saying their goal failed after only few years shows how shortsighted other people are. They started some projects in 1970s that will only be finished in 2050, like the Great Green Wall.
@@yourdaddy3571 I don't know why USA and Uk media men are so naive? They think a lie repeated thousands of times will become truth. Ridiculous! Still a lie, a hypocritic one.
I think this fundamentally misunderstands Chinese planning. China often builds infrastructure for expected demand that doesn't yet exist. Western media was writing a lot about Chinese ghost cities years ago, which have largely been filled up. Give it more time. Yes the infrastructure projects provide jobs to Chinese people, but the economic growth the infrastructure will enable will bring jobs to pakistanis. This is pretty simple to understand. There was also a dearth of actual data in this video.
What will happen if they default. China will take over the infrastructure built by their money just like the Gwadhar port, China is already in control over the Hambantota port for 99 years.Chinese consortium has taken over 40 per cent stake in Pakistan's stock exchange. Simple..... Chinese money Chinese Labour Chinese construction goods and materials Chinese companies What the host countries are basically doing is buying up the infrastructure
@@sounoks3180 Who cares. The infrastructures will still be located in the countries hiring locals thereby creating opportunities even if it's owned by foreign entity. And do you know what's the true alternative that no one's talking about? That the land would've been left without any purpose. If you've ever played civ / Catan you'll understand what I mean.
and what about the % million Muslims currently being "re educated" in a chinese internment camp? Do you not care about your Muslims brothers? I know Indians who care a lot about whats happening in China , there are protests happening in front of Chinese high commission here in Delhi every day.
Pakistan will be next Singapore. Economy booms and life gets better. If China has made someone salty feel, it means China has done a right thing. Respect Pakistan leader that has right vision for his own people.
USA have given aiding all these years to Pakistan wondering all these have gone on terriorism... now you guys talking about minding their own business... I remember a quote “don’t shell a quarter without looking at the begging bowl”
Some nations are greedy mercenary nations that will fall into bed with any rich nation ("We will fight your War on Terror" "We are victims of the war on terror" blah blah blah), so blaming the "money powers" for preying on such nations is ridiculous!
I think they always knew waterways can never be replaced by any other means. Saudi to India cost rs.800 for more than 2000km. mumbai to pune cost rs.7000 for just 250km. Debt give diplomatic advantage to china . these countries would never dare to go against china.
1:43 - 1:53 This is all footage from the Constituent Assembly of India and from a parade outside Rashtrapati Bhavan. As if all the white Gandhi caps weren't a glaring clue, you can clearly see Sardar Patel in the footage. Who is your video producer? Fire them. This makes me wonder if even the dam construction footage was from Pakistan. Very sus.
@@luckypruthvi8354 of course he knows that difference. And that’s why that is this is hoe propaganda works…. Footage form random palaces and some seemingly reliable but totally irrelevantly people talking.
Dealing with the devil... it's all part of a plan to assert naval, economic and structural dominance across the world. If countries along the way continue to default on debts, China will be a hegemon within no time at all. It will have so much reach and influence from indebted countries in a way that no other country would be left to replicate. This is the worst thing to happen to individual rights and freedoms you have ever seen, and will only get worse.
@@vonschenck6464 surely China is seeking economic and structural dominance across the world, but it makes no different at all as now we have USA dominance with same levels of human right abuse but China is not covering their human right violation as well as USA because they don't have as powerful media I would love to see a shift of power from western countries to China as I believe China usually makes win-win trade deals with 3rd world countries while US tends to support a dictator who would allow them suck resources and walk away without profiting that poor country western powers had their chance during colonization era and they traumatized these countries with worst imagined memories now it's China's turn and I see places such as Africa flourishing which is great for all of us btw I'm not an African, I'm from Saudi living in Poland as I study there
Pakistan produce its own MG3 since decades. Though I agree we should produce our own even if it's inferior. We will improve by time. That's how thing works I guess.
@@MrMkn1991 Actually, Pakistani MG-3s have been manufactured as per German standards since the very beginning that is why the German Army ordered them from Pakistan a few years ago because the Germans had stopped making them and they were in need of them,
Belt and road is like a fungus. It spreads its tendrils out and absorbs resources from far away locations. But the difference is that nothing beneficial is returned.
@@shardovl586 OK! Checked :) Well, the very original is an inhabitant of a villa (big, country estates) and so not only villagers lived there ;) Buuuut later just any country estate and theeeen the rest ;)
My honest opinion on why Pakistan is Poor and failed State 1. Half of money is spent on Army. 2. Half of the money goes to nurture terrorism. 3. Remaining money goes into development activities.
soon or later everyone will realise the consequences of this.i know if i said something about this a Pakistani will come to say that India is jealous of Pakistan.
Look brother, I understand your concern from across the border. But, the biggest help that an indian brother can give is to stick their nose in their own territory. Letting us know consequences will not affect anything since EVERY government is controlled by an agenda prewritten.
@@tonystark-gx7tx that's what I have said.idk why every Pakistani thinks that Indians hate them. btw congratulations on this project of china and Pakistan. may this help all of the peoples out there
@@Amandeep-kx8jl You seriously don't know the reason for the hate? Come on, man! We have to accept facts; India and Pak have fought 3 major wars with countless other skirmishes... There is extreme hate on both sides and it is for not one, but several reasons. (And I can assure you there is way more hate on the Indian side in recent times) Well, regardless, thank you for well wishes btw same to you with the US Indo Pacific deal!
As someone who’s into road trips, and has travelled across Balochistan’s coastal Highway. It’s amazing how much propaganda the western media machine’s doing on China… I guess this is what Noam Chomsky calls “manufacturing consent”, for more conflict. CPEC has been phenomenal for Pakistan, they’ve helped increase our agricultural yields (some of our poorest Pakistanis are subsistence farmers).
@Motorsoul ss What exactly did we loose. The western countries with a past, present, and most likely a future, full of exploitation - do a lot of propaganda feigning worries about China being exploitative.
I doubt Mike is micromanaging every freaking Bloomberg article and video, lol. No doubt he is a China drone, but I’ve read plenty on Bloomberg that points out Chinese flaws. A lot of propaganda too, to be sure.
I am sure Indians are involved in this propaganda piece, as they are vehemently against CPEC. Not only is the report contradictory, but full of blatant lies. Note that they didn't interview any locals and just had an anonymous recording. The Balochistan provincial government is very sensitive about jobs for locals and have established quotas which it monitors. Subject header says that the projects are stalled but in the end the video admits that the projects, such as the largest airport to be built in Gwadar, are ongoing.
Greetings, my dear 50 cent army boi. What a great, _GREAT_ comment that is. I hope this awesomeness of a comment will assure you climbing up the carrier ladder of the 50 Cent braindeads, one day becoming a full 1 Yuan army boi. And, oh, please: give my dearest regards to *Xi Pooh* , uuh, I mean *Winnie Jinping* .
Trade along the BRI has reached more than U$ 1 trillion annually. British Airways started flights to Gwadar two years ago. There is no more electricity shortages in Pakistan.
We have some exciting news! We’re launching channel Memberships for just $0.99 a month. You’ll get access to members-only posts and videos, live Q&As with Bloomberg reporters, business trivia, badges, emojis and more.
Join us: th-cam.com/users/bloombergjoin
would love to join but I have to wait until I have somemoney! :)
So much for stalling out. Communism is beating Capitalism into a bloody stump!
G2, China
Our original master
From Mokpo, South-West Korea
Be objective and look from local people's lense, not from Western's strategic advantageous position.
@@yangying7758 agree
“Hire Chinese workers who ultimately take wages home.” It’s the small things that matter folks
Not just workers. Materials, machinery, expertise gained from building. Pakistan is left with a huge bill, puppet status on China, infrastructure. Latter is the only positive but even this may have limited benefit if other powers stop the Belt n Road project from reaching its target
This is how developed economies power their economies through aid and things like this, use your own money to stimulate your own economy while giving other nations "stuff"
@@pudanielson1 Aid and loan are different things. Especially Chinese loan. Following example is on the extreme side but it helps to illustrate the issue. China gave Ethiopia a huge loan, making big fanfare about how it helps developing nations. Same year, western countries gave same amount as aid, though UN. Chinas contribution to that aid was flat 0. Aid doesn't leave receiving country as dependent politically, while loans from China stipulate unfavorable terms, like use of Chinese workers and materials, in case of defaulting on loan, handing over infrastructure for up to 100 years, puppet status in UN, leading to comical status where we are now, with World Health Organization being effectively a mouthpiece to China's Communist party and China being member of UN human rights council.
There are positive effects obviously, plus some countries are desperate for investments and have no other choices, Belt and Road can actually materialize in the future and pay back the loan cost. But I doubt the latter
@Lawrence Weston so its a win win for both. Gwadar is no use of Pakistan so why not join the silk road. No wonder why pakistan took over half of Kashmir and china helped pakistan. Long term planing smart
@Lawrence Weston i believe the only reason Pakistan will stick to china instead of US even if they fulfill all three point that you mentioned, is because the US history of not keeping its promises and agreements. After the chinese sanctions on canada and eu counties and there sanctions on china. Pakistan will stay neutral and choose whats best for Pakistan’s economy. China for the first time has put sanctions on western countries to show that its the time now , china is strong and has allies who will backup their position like pakistan, iran and many African countries. A proper strong answer in sanctions is a prove of ( no more bullying ) iran is happy to receive 400 billion. So is Pakistan
Idea is to belt Pakistan on the Road. (That's the whole belt and road initiative)
😜😂🤣🤣🤣
Bhai bhai bhaii... 😂😂😂
🤣🤣🤣 this got me 🔥
Hahahaha 😂😂😂
Have your Gandutva people got enough bread to feed themselves?
"The US decided the port would not be economically viable..."
China: THAT'S MY JAM
Cockroach diplomacy
1. Secretive
2.Done in the dark
3. Pest
4. grotesque
@@thomasthumim7630 The word cockroach is the one used during the Rwanda genocide. It makes things simpler. It makes hating and killing simpler. Be careful my friend.
@@waldenli9232 iam referring to the policies not the president
and the US was right, the port is not economically viable.
But it's a strategic gem (especially for china)
Meanwhile USA wants females who identify as males to be in the frontline in the army
The 1947 footage was of Indian parliament lmao
I saw Mahatma Gandhi
these white journalists couldnt care less about it
@@AP-do6sv racist
Could be that they couldn’t find a pakistani parliament video, the footage makes the point which is to demonstrate a parliament not necessarily implying that its visually the pakistani parliament.
@@jimcummings7758 yes before august of that yeat. But the parliament video they used is of indian parliament post partition.
Well, if you have a spare $1 trillion, it is better to spend it on infrastructure around the developing world - than fritter it away in a single misguided war (Operation Iraqi Freedom).
right
Moreover China cannot “spend” its spare USD, so the alternative to investing the developing world is to lend those money back to the US, which I’m afraid, the Americans are not very happy either
@@johnwang9730 where are you?
underrated comment.
@@jamesflannery-serle3489 why does it matter?
Hilarious that at 1:46 they have used footage from the Indian parliament from 1940s when talking of Pakistani independence 😂
@Heisenberg Says why is there always one armed crusader ready to fight for everyone in every political videos comment section lol😂😂😂
@Heisenberg Says my man i agree with you and hope with all my heart that you are successful in your future crusades.
@Heisenberg Says No one will die if you don't brag. I will accept your blind confidence in this. Why don't you take over the whole world?
@Heisenberg Says please do the needful
This video, I an sure, was created by Indians working for Bloomberg. Lol.
China building road for themselves and charging the bill for it as loan to Pakistan 😂😂
@The Green Line lOL, Pakistan pays for the roads, it's the debt they owe China.
@The Green Line agar beech ka pok chala gya to road kaha se jayega bhaiya ? 😌😂😂
China building economy road to move there supplies fast so there currency becomes stronger . Usa is jealous China thinks about this .
people there are starving bro why the money is the first thing that you focus on ?
@@pushkarmitra1928 Afghanistan kyoki wo ab taliban ke pass hein 🤣
6:05 Oh, the CCP will install 5,000 cameras, and install CCP trained police to 'maintain a high standard of human rights.'
😂😂😂
I think it’s the CIA who has a history of training murderous secret police into other countries. Like Iran
and to put cameras is violating human rights? yes? tell that to all countries having cameras. when the smugglers gonna rob you remember that
@@hellqar910 you don't know the meaning/definition of human rights do you?
Show me a single video of an abusive Chinese police. I have plenty to show regarding the American police.
Shipping in their own workers then building them housing that keeps them separate. Locals can apply to be the janitor or checkpoint security I expect. Maybe not even security, not with CCP management.
I smell salty sour jelly🤡💩
What else do you expect the local populace does not have the expertise nor education to take on such highly intellectual jobs of engineers. Training their children would take a decade or more. Think logically. It's all based on Equity not equality.
@Tom Riddle Nobody thinks that. Mind your own business.
@@sherryp3452 Dont forget china was this poor in 1980s but it didn't bring engineers from abroad to make their highways and infrastructure
@@MAC-vi7fy China as a whole was poor but it was never short of educated people even in its lowest days after WW2
With the kind of leaders pakistan has, and it's never ending dependency to rely on others, it will always remain a stooge of other super powers.
I discovered what 'sycophant' REALLY meant when I saw Pakistani VIP visitors meet my Saudi bosses
@Arrogant Australian Socialist of VictoriaMaybe look at how many "allies" the US has backstabbed.
Its like a person who constantly fights within his family , he will ask for help and support from any random stranger on street without thinking of consequences! Even after getting so many setbacks and humiliation it learns nothing.
If and only if he would realise that making amends with the family is the best solution for stable future and there is nothing lacking if the house is in peace and family united!
@@ea3414 what allies?
Chinese love to gamble, such chinese plans are failing, doesn't matter if you pour billions in material, capital if local people, administration, bureaucracy are corrupt nothing will get done. Many projects in Africa, Venezuela stalled due to corrupt, chinese are digging their own grave
Looks like a Debt trap to me... they walked right into it, that’s what happens when you get hand outs in the first place! There’s no partnership there 🤦🏻♂️
Jelous indian spotted 😂
@@chocolateboy4959 sure lol we were the ones who suffered a country wide electrical outage a few weeks ago right? You guys are still dealing with Polio while it got wiped out when I was a kid in India. Plus our PM and military generals don’t have to go to Saudi to beg them for loan extensions and go to China to beg for vaccines. We supply vaccines to Saudi. No Indian wants to be a Pakistani lol. We genuinely feel bad for you Talibanis.
@@boroboro4294 Actually you are wrong! I am jelous of Pakistan indeed. Look at their women. They are hot af.
@@boroboro4294 we gave the long to Saudi Arabia back
simply because the report is biased... China has helped Pakistan pay off debt to the west
Debt trap diplomacy.
Is a theory which is not backed up by evidence
@@TH-camMadeMePickHandle hey m*ron ! 😀🙏
@@anirudh964 hello bot 🤖
Fragile white posters who ignore centuries of colonial pillage and theft via the IMF and World Bank debt.
Love your comment. Sour grapes.
so the road is the belt and the sea is the road.
makes sense
That goes to show how much they really know about this project.
@@Arash157 they who? I got that from the little commercial ditty the CCP used as an advert
@@chrisrosenkreuz23 who ever is reporting about this project
@@sfb1219 @Sfb what you mean farmers? The farmer strike is in India. And who told you China got Pakistani land, don't put your head in your a** only, look for alternative media to open up your brainwashed head. Right now their is one terrorist nation who is running coups back to back on different countries.
@@Arash157 no, that's what I just told you, it does not go to show how much whoever is reporting about the project really know about it, but instead goes to show how much the CCP understands about the basic functionality of roads and waterways seeing how it was not taken from the reportage but the official ditty.
Sending out engineers are better than sending out troops
But it doesn't help in local employment. It's like giving money from right hand and taking it back from left hand.
Even basic labours are coming from China.
@@kokuyocamlin07 once built Pakistán can maintain their new roads
@@kokuyocamlin07 No, only engineers or skilled labor with specific skills are coming. There are thousands of locals employed in cpec projects
@@goata007 we sri lankans thought the same thing in 2010. And now we know that it would never ever happen. We have no sovereignty now
@@kokuyocamlin07 Are you serious ? As an engineer in the Middle East, half of our company’s staff come from local employees, and we continue to learn from the cooperation and communication with employees. Local employees have mastered the technology, and local employees can complete the maintenance and operation in the later stage, and even drive the later stage. The development of small projects can be done by locals。At the same time ,as a Chinese, we never export troops and so-called democracy to foreign countries. We just want to develop with brother countries and make the world better and more peaceful.
Showing footage of india when guy is talking about Pakistan
Whats the difference?
@@homealone5087 economy and culture
@@homealone5087 Showing a country of 3 Trillion dollars GDP in place of poor Paxtan😂 huge difference
@@homealone5087 Hilarious, why are you watching this if you don't understand simple differences.
@@PoorPakistanisSurrenderwasFant India is lower than Paxtan and Bangladesh in hunger index.
Phase 1 CPEC
Phase 2 Provide Loans
Phase 3 Bankrupt Pakistan
Phase 4 Provide Trust
Phase 5 Take over Pakistan
What do you think about Imf?
First go and pay back Chinese loans taken by America 😂
@@itxhamza5543 go eat zakkat rice that you borrowed from Saudi with some Chinese sauce
All of the videos concerning the belt and road initiative are not detailed enough.
That is on purpose, if they report with enough details might not support what they intend to implant into your minds
They only can keep the message negative, if the information isn't complete
It goes both ways. China and Pakistan both won't reveal how much of the project is donation by the Chinese, and how much of the project is funded by the commercial banks of China at a high interest rates to Pakistan. 80% of the products will be build in China and shipped to the world via belt and road infrastructure. Pakistan exports very few products and will end up being responsible for the maintenance and up keep of the infrastructure.
@@rtshchand you are wrong, Chinese loans is less than IMF and world bank, much lower than commercial rates. Singapore also a port that transit goods and they got rich from the trades.
@@madsam0320 Then why is Chinese and Pakistan government not willing to show the funding of the project. CPEC started almost a decade ago, where is the prosperity that was promised. Pakistan is no Malaysia.
So basically China is developing a military base outside China in some other country
Lol
Like Europeon union ? Yeah might be
They had to get in the game. The US has over 1000 bases outside the states. They already invaded the world
@@sebasmana5798 the correct number is around 850 bases
Like usa
Why are no Pakistani/Chinese interviewed, in order to have a balanced view on the topic they should have been interviewed too, I am neither Pakistani or Chinese, just want a balanced reporting
Thos was a propaganda piece most likely created by Indians working for Bloomberg. You do know they are slowly taking over not only high government positions but also media outlets and all major US corporations. Soon, we will all be working for Indians.
Because the Pakistani and Chinese government will prosecute you, and force you to stay in prison.
@@RaZoRFoX396 idk about china but that doesnt happen in Pakistan.
Thats how they make propaganda if you see middle east coverage too they don't interview locals but they out their agendas and make propagandas on behalf of us
India is 1.3 billion population and these foreigners grab this commuity to earn money and make propaganda against Pakistan and China
Pakistan PM :"Our economy now linked to china "this is the big statement . Pakistan on the way to srilanka .
Bhai ye sab sirf humko gharne k liye kar raha hai china agar naval base uska pakistan meh ban gaya toh bohot badi ladai ho jaayegi
yes
@@gautam5144 true pakistan bas ek pyada hai inke liye
your prophecy came true😂
rule no. 1: don't mess with the Fisherman in the area. It leads to delayed projects worldwide, f.e. in Jakarta
Coastal road in Mumbai.
@@pawaratharva6371 lol exactly
Yeah lol. But also don't mess with environmentalists.
@@blehh...9598 Nihilists*
Environmentalists on their way to save 5 trees came in the way of development project
The main challenge is the slow-paced bureaucracy and lack of transparency within Pakistan.
Lol. These western propagandists assumed that CPEC has some problems ergo all BRI projects are stalled out... 🤣 Seriously, CPEC is just one of the corridors planned. The Maritime belt is strong as ever with countless of ports have been established and constructed for the past few years in Africa. In Indonesia alone, the HSR project is in full swing and will be finished much earlier than Japan's project in india that even a singnificant single post for rail wasn't even erected... The Loas-CHINA corridor is in full swing and most of railway, expressways will be opened in 2022. Russia-CHINA pipleline 2 is already underconstruction and Kazakhstan-CHINA gas pipeline is currently expanding. No to mention the projects Africa is still in full swing. It's like their propaganda about debt trap diplomacy when always parroting the 1 time of debt equity swap of Hambatota port in Sri Lanka yet they hide the fact that CHINA has restructured, debt relief and rescheduled 87 times of those countries which owed to CHINA. Sensationalism is the core of these western propagandists....🤣
@@samalenyo It's true that many sections of western media portray China as some evil state that is on the mission of bringing the whole world under China's regime. And many westerners don't buy this.
But this report seems fair and unbiased. The lady and other stated the truth about the CPEC.
The main challenge is the CCP and its financial traps layed out to later on control whole states in Asia, Africa, South America and even Europe. People have figured out their BS.
@@DarxKies Well, this is far from reality. I wish it could happen if China has any plans to control the poverty stricken countries with corrupted leaders.
At the end of the day, a person wants peace and prosperity. And that’s what you can see through out the China now. Who wouldn’t want development in Africa?
And I would half credit western media and half blindness of people that cannot see the other side. Western institutions such as IMF and world bank are in the game of debt trap for long time now. So, don’t worry no one is taking over other countries.
No... All projects are working with rapid speed ...and CPEC is under a saperate authority which is called CPEC Authority. There is no bureaucratic influence in this authority
Why are the Chinese acquiring or controlling ports - from Sri Lanka to Darwin? Not so much BRI as military and food security for China.
Mobility and logistics more product out more debt built more influence secured. Maybe not exactly like that but I do think they’re trying to control routes once held by India
Well, yes, so whats the problem?
it's to surround India.
In order to bypass the Strait of Malacca, comrades
And oil.
To all nations, don't compromise your value.
The report is completely misleading. The project is supposed to complete in 2030. First phase of CPEC, which include 12K megawatt electricity, has already completed, the 2nd phase which include Special Economic Zones is underway. Already 10 Special Economic Zones have approved by PM in March 2020 and 3 of which are already working. More than 3000 km roads are either completed or about to complete this year. Moreover, China is building two big dams which will complete in 2025.
Keep thinking like that and u will end up China's province!😂😅🤣
Eventually u all will be next Uighurs.
Core problem is Pakistan now Totaly depends on China...for loans, highways, defence, IT, Port and what not...even thier vaccine comes from china.
Only a fool put all the eggs in one basket. Ever heard a word 'Diversity'
This is new colonialism, Look at sri Lanka and other african Countries. Your army is compromised and in direct control of CCP.
@@Anonymous-hp1tg we have strong and reliable ties with China.... China is not only investing in Pakistan but also sharing its technology which will make Pakistan sufficient i.e Nuclear technology, JF 17 etc. I don't know why the Indian and the west are so obsessed with Chinese loan to Pakistan but the bitter truth is that 9% of our total debts belong to China. The rest 91% either belong western countries or institutions, like World bank and IMF. When it comes to lay all eggs in one basket, it is not true either. The USA is the biggest export market of Pakistan. Pakistan still has strong relation with many western and Muslim countries.
@@sajidmosvi6364 guess what many Muslim nations like Turkey and Bangladesh hate China now after what they did to Uighur muslims converted mosques into toilets. I heard many Pakistani people as well have started to hate China.
@@simriths.s5976 I don't think so .... Uyghur issue is highly exaggerated one by western media. Many of my friends studying there on scholarship. They never found such allegations there. As Uyghur is also neighbor to our province(GB) we have strong trade relation with them as well. And traders from both sides visit each other. Yes, in past this region was facing Islamic extremism because of spillover effect of Taliban and All Qaeda led Afghanistan. The west and especially the USA want to rekindle it again.
@@simriths.s5976 lulli worshippers satanic dharam Sanatan is for so l you don't know?
So, give loans and only hire your own people to build so that the local people get no benefit... I've seen this movie before...
What do you expect? Hire people from another country that have no knowledge or skill or be able communicate to them to build these massive projects? Build these massive projects so the citizens will then have jobs and training to run and operate them?!
@@itsurcooffy I'm sure there are plenty of Pakistanis being exploited in construction in the middle east. Hire them to build in their own country, except this time actually pay them.
You get roads
@@zapfanzapfan bro they are building together, not only Chinese
Sugar daddy diplomacy
Pakistan ask US for help to build the port. US: No.
Pakistan ask China for help to build the port. China: Yes.
US: China intend to build a naval base in Pakistan.
Very impressive port.
Very busy as well, I counted 6 cruise ships, 8 tankers, 12 cargo ships and
20 industrial cranes 😂😂
Greetings from Germany...🍺🖐
"Flagship" of the BRI 😂😂
In progress boy
First study
Phase 1 and 2 is completed and phase 3 is in progress and will be completed before time. A game changer project in the region.
@@tahirhussain4051 Brother these are Indian Bots ignore
@@homeuser1015 bro everyone is Indian!!! Even your ancestors 😂😂😎👌
Pakistan owes the world 239 billion dollars, and Chinese money is only 25% of it. Considering that the debt is used to build critical infrastructure, the CPEC project is essential to Pakistan. And why does no one talks about the other 75% debt 🤔
Details: Pakistani economy is 278 billion US dollars. At 85.9% debt to gdp ratio, thats 239 billion US dollars of debt. The 60 billion US dollar CPEC project in discussion makes up= 60/239 ×100= 25% of debt.
If you consider that the remaining debt was basically used in currency manipulation, meaning wasted, this project is a dream come true, as it gives critical infrastructure to a country that badly needs it to pull itself out of poverty.
Because the other debtors are not seen as pressuring Pakistan to cede sovereign land in lieu of payment on loans as CCP China is .
Look at the interest on the loan mr blind
Also the money is flown back to China
Nice try pak, the other 75% of debt is from the IMF and occurred becuz Pakistan got sanctioned after developing nuclear weapons. Maybe instead of building nukes and fighting with India u guys focused on not being bad at being a functioning country, u wouldn't have to worry abt this debt.
Are you Pakistani? This is a pretty impressive case of Stockholm Syndrome if so.
One can always expect US media to put dirt on whatever Chinese does.
Yea like covid 19 didn’t come from China but it did.
What? Because genocide isn’t worth the time of day to report and criticise?
Yes, because is the cause of debt trap of Sri Lanka and made it hand over their port to china for 99 years!
The very same thing china will be doing to every other small countries.
5:30 Completely leaves out the fact that Balochistan was occupied by Pakistan in 1947.
Haha tmhari bund ma itni mirchain kion lag rahi Hain? Khalistan ki tension lay beta
@@rethinkkk hamne to Bangladesh ki tension li thi bas 😂
@@ankitkr7763 🔥😂🔥🔥🔥
@@ankitkr7763 oh burn :)
@@rethinkkk LOL. Like Mr Tarek Fatah says, how does P*kistan produces such huge number of rectums, that says even if I loose both my eyes it is OK, but that other guy who is happy must lose one.
Wtf erdogan shaking with xi 3:00
Uighers : bro!!!
Turkey deports the Uyighurs back to China.
Especially the ones that escaped Chinas dragnet and is of special interest to them.
Turkey and Pakistan: "We are the guardians of the worlds Muslims!"
China: "Can we put Muslims in concentration camps, ban their religion and forcefully sterilise them?Well give you some trade deals..."
Turkey and Pakistan: " Yes please"
We don’t take Jihadists to our country from China. Peaceful Uighurs live as Han in Xinjiang, others end up in vocational programmes.
@@theallseeingeye9388 Saudi Arabia even said that's the right decision from China.
1 million dead Iraqi civilians two wars weapons of mass destruction depleted uranium ????
Wasn't Pakistan the one who went to China with the idea to build a Port in gwarder, which gave China the idea to revitalized the old silk road, aka B,R,I
Pakistan is not complaining the western media are complaining and we are confused why 😕
@@muslim_first CZ jealous about something cn achieved but they failed.
@@mingsun7356 You are right. China is Pakistan's most trustworthy friend and ally.
Long Live China-Pakistan Friendship and Cooperation.
What will happen if they default.
China will take over the infrastructure built by their money just like the Gwadhar port, China is already in control over the Hambantota port for 99 years.Chinese consortium has taken over 40 per cent stake in Pakistan's stock exchange.
Simple.....
Chinese money
Chinese Labour
Chinese construction goods and materials
Chinese companies
What the host countries are basically doing is buying up the infrastructure
@@sounoks3180 You don't worry about that. Pakistan and China's friendship is more than 70 years old. This CPEC Project is important for both countries. It's more important to Pakistan because we need better infrastructure so our economy can rise. Pakistan will pay China back the loans when economy of Pakistan improves. Pakistanis are optimistic and in ease when it does business with friend China because there is a lot of trust between the two friendly countries.
Gwadar port itself will cost about 200 million. You know what else will cost 200 million? US military! Every 2 hours.
Only difference is the US military can operate, unlike Pakistan.
@@Alex632 Considering that they only paid one-sixth of India's military expenditure, I would say that they are very effective.
it's not too cheap but ur mentality is too cheap that comparing a port price with us army budget actually Gwadar port is priceless for Pakistani people it bullshits other countries will not understand it and make it controversial like just u are trying to
you can't even pay your debt to Saudi
@@saadshah1005 Did I say this is cheap? I can smell your lack of confidence across the Indian Ocean and the Pacific Ocean. My point is that the United States can spend money to transport ice cream to frontline soldiers by air, but it cannot build a port properly. Now let China get this important port.
Debt trap...thats what it is
Follows by death trap
Lol only some chinese engineers are on field. And why wouldn't they? It's a joint project. Many of projects have been completed including the motorways and metro trains on which we dialy travel. Its quite when media acts to know more than pakistanis🤣🤣
@@safiullah3441 ha ha...u didn't realize that u guys are ruled by the chinese.....
It's a business deal, not a forced sale. It's a win-win deal. You think you can bomb other countries like the US?
I'm glad that She Pumpkin's CPEC is stalled. His real aim is to encircle India completely.
Many posters on this forum don't understand that the objective of the Pakistan corridor is to save time and money for Chinese goods. By travelling via the Pakistan corridor, travel time will be cut by up to 60%, as compared to travel via the South China Seas. Pakistan will make tens of billions each year from Transit fees by enabling Chinese companies to use the corridor to save time and money. Its a win-win situation for both China and Pakistan.
The port is not drawing enough business. Pakistan will therefore, not be able to repay its debt. Under the terms of the deal, in such a situation, China will take possession of the facility. It will then be able to convert it (or part of it) to a naval base. The same plan was successfully completed in Sri Lanka. The overall strategy, is to surround India.
@@mombaassa At the moment. Once its finished, they will be transporting oil and products via Pakistan. The corridor is still be built. Once complete, they will be able to transport goods via the corridor to China, saving time and money. Sri Lanka was a different case - there is no corridor to China, as it rely on India joining the BRI. But India turned down the offer to join the BRI, which made Sri Lanka's port unprofitable. Pakistan is different - it does not need India's permission to transport their goods to China - the corridor goes straight into China.
@@mombaassa Further information on situation of Sri Lanka. Only 70% of the Port is lease to the Chinese for Commercial Use. The other 30% is used by the Sri Lankan Navel Base.
@@vanwong6768 Nobody ever believed that India would join the BRI, and make the port viable. China was a driving force behind this Indian rejection, by its constant, border provocation on the Himalayas. The plan was always to aquire, a potential naval facility.
Nice try, Wumao.
@@vanwong6768 "Only 70%...". That's an oxymoron. Do you actually read what you type? Wumaos are meant to write things in favour of China. Don't type too many more idiotic statements, otherwise they'll send you back to Wumao School, or put you on the list for organ donors.
Mr. Jonathan Hillman, a small history lesson here for you. Pakistan didn't got it's independence in 1947, it was formed on the basis of religion by dividing Indian mainland into two. Erstwhile Punjab and Bengal province divided into two. Muslim majority East Bengal and West Punjab formed Pakistan along with Balochistan, Sindh, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. Mr. Mohammad Ali Jinnah, then member of All India Muslim league later founding father of Pakistan had come to believe that the Muslims of the Indian subcontinent should have their own state to avoid the possible marginalised status they may gain in a Hindu-Muslim state. In the year 1940, the Muslim League, led by Jinnah, passed the Lahore Resolution, demanding a separate nation.
That is how minorities become majorities.
It was independence. Endia was not called Endia before British first proposed this name. Secondly, it was a subcontinent of different nationalities. Even today there's nothing common in Endia about all nations, races and religions. Pakistan have same national language, religion, culture but Endia is completely diverse in all aspects of society without common integration and with no natural unity.
@@IrfanKhan-resistance Still India became better than porkistan
@@Tirth727 No way better than Pakistan. Yup your economy is big but compare to size n population its poor, racist, illiteracy, uncivilized, uncultured, world's largest slum is in Endia not in Pakistan. The most poor people here are still living better quality life, air, water, greenry but Endia is a mess.
@@IrfanKhan-resistance I understand your love for Pakistan and hate for India. So no grudges. Few questions though, If Pakistan got its independence in 1947, then Why the name Pakistan was only came to exist after the Indian Independence Act 1947 passed in British parliament? Why in Pakistan, still to this date Buddhist and Hindu sculptures are discovered in regular interval linking it to different Indian Kingdoms? There were no particular evidence about etymology of Indian mainland because there were no marked borders back then. There were constant battle between Mughals, Turks, Mongols, Sikhs and Afghans in North. In south and West of India there were Marathas and Dravidian Kingdom. So those lands always changed hands.
Let me just say that : China is not in it for Pakistan. China like US in the past, is there for its own benefit. Its always a red flag when a foreign government creates a community inside your borders (Port City).
Well yes your right, but why would China just want to help Pakistan ? Surely it would want to look after its own interests as well? Pakistan accepted it because they saw the benefits it would bring them. Everyone is looking out for their own interest dude
funny point， China could chose between Pakistan & India , but China finally choose Pakistan.
@@tianyicai6482 funny point, its not a choice its obvious you cant financially burden a rapidly developing nation just like you can do to a debt ridden extremely poor nation
Is that why America didn’t even consider it. Or was it to stop this exact move. Humm ???? Anything connected to China comes with hesitation on anyone’s part
@The Alchemist japan is not a great power ?!!!
Keep up balochistan ،، بڑے گا بلوچستان بنے گا بلوچستان۔
Brother I wonder if India helps you for liberating baloch from Pakistan will you let a Indian government community manager the government of baloch, or you strictly only want baloch goherment to rule the balochi, knowing that how much progress India make since its independence?
@@whsjdndshsjsjs7774 India would not want to manage Balochistan. Don't worry. Balochistan should be an independent country with its own government. Don't try to instigate the people of Balochistan by misleading them. Pakistan has made Balochistan the poorest province, with highest infant mortality rate and they receive the lowest money from the Pakistani government. They're literally treated like outcastes.
Moreover, India has progressed far better than Pakistan. India has the fastest growing economy in the world, it has the highest number of FDIs, 600 billion dollars in foreign reserves, they're the third largest economy in the world and are improving in all aspects.
Getting support from them to form a new country is much better than being with Pakistan. The Indian government should openly support Balochistan's freedom struggle just the way Pakistan does in Kashmir. The only difference would be that Kashmir will be in loss if administerated by Pakistan. Balochistan would be benefited if they're liberated.
@@fulkrumsukhoi1941 that was exactly I was saying, sorry if I wrote something inappropriate in previous comment, but I mean will The independent Baluchistan will trust India, if India wants to help them for development purpose?
@@whsjdndshsjsjs7774 you should have realised that they don't want india in Pakistan when they comment in Urdu .
Pakistan should be thankful that it is located between China ( famous for its manufacturing capacity and Iran for having oil and gas reserves)
are you Pakistan
And yet Pakistan could not even use its one percent of its true potential and relies heavily on bothe of the nation's you have mentioned
Riza, considering the recent developments, do you still think people should be thankful for being located between China and Iran?????
5:32 dude has absolutely no muzzle control. Swept that kid and man
Halal snackbar
Scary 😱
As long it’s not loaded or pull the trigger by accident it’s ok....for him
Lmao, damn near swept that car passing by too. Doing some acrobatic shits with that gun
@@hirondelle8734 All gun safety violations are non-issues. Until the day they become an issue. And someone dies.
The title needs to be amended to specify the focus on gwadar.
No, it’s doesn’t. Only 1/3 of CPEC projects have been completed 😂
Gwadar is the focal point of CPEC
Ikr
@@brianjamds6617 Such info is never mentioned in the video tho..
@@arbaz79 Is it? Do you know percentage of investments or
Pakistan is the next sri lanka
We live in Pakistan, and we know the ground realities of this project, hundreds of kilometers of roads are constructed, work of few small and 3 large dams in going on, railways lines are being installed under this project, new fiber optic cables are installed and lot more. So we don't need west or america to lighten us about it.
.... You don't need but what about the rest of the world? This is their take on it, if you have problem that this video aren't true/false then argue the part that you know are false/wrong.
Exactly! Few hundred kilometers of road, railway and fiber means nothing when considering the whole country. And all those roads and dams and fiber will be used by Chinese and not ya’ll
@@aadipandey8237 few hundreds of kms of road is constructed and a total of 3000 km under construction and other dams and infrastructure project and who told u that we only china will use them???
indian media??
China's Belt and Road initiative has left many financially weak countries trapped in "secret debt". It is claimed that China owes 36.5 billion to these countries. China has invested a total of, 64.3 billion in roads, bridges, ports and hospitals in 173 countries. These countries include many countries in Africa and Central Asia.
According to experts, 80 per cent of the, 64.3 billion has been lent to the central bank of the country concerned or to a joint venture between China and that country. But the government of many financially weak countries could no longer borrow. As a result, China has taken a different path. They have lent to a coalition of several companies. The government of that country is not directly in that alliance. But in many cases, the government has taken the responsibility of repaying the debt if the alliance of the companies is not able to repay the debt. As a result, the actual debt of those countries to China is not clear to the concerned government in many cases. According to the expert agency, the debt of China in 45 countries is more than 10 percent of their average national product. According to the expert agency, the debt of China in 45 countries is more than 10 percent of their average national product.
There is strong dissatisfaction among some locals over the huge Chinese investment in provinces like Pakistan's Balochistan. They claimed that they did not benefit from the project. Militant groups have repeatedly targeted the Chinese project in Balochistan.
Chinese love to gamble, such chinese plans are failing, doesn't matter if you pour billions in material, capital if local people, administration are corrupt nothing will get done. Many projects in Africa, Venezuela stalled due to corrupt, chinese are digging their own grave
@@evolveelectricvehicles8551 you are a copy paste bot.
@@alexomar2010 no moreno, you had too much tequila
The person who made this video should actually go to gwadar and see how it is developing into something truly amazing
...but the port is supposedly fenced by the Chinese and not accessible even for most of the Pakstanis, so....? According to a retired bridagier or general (of course it being Pakstan, there's probably one retired army person every 10 steps or so), the Chinese fenced it to protect their investment so, it was ok that an average local Baloch or pakstani couldn't be allowed in the area.....
N NBG , lol, which port is not fenced up with security. Effectively, they are bonded warehouses.
@@nnbg8000 why are you Indians so obsessed with Pakistan
@@tiangcs8069 they are mad about the fence around gwadar mad about the fence at afghanistan border. Doesnt it make u wonder why? Like what's so wrong about a fence unless they have some kind of plans to enter that place illegally.
@@tiangcs8069 Sure darling.....
Im from india and i don't hate pak, usa has used them for their own benefits and now china is doing the same but imran khan( worst pm) had let them to do so. Pak and india should join hand together for development , we r the same ppl with different nationality
@akhilesh yadav• IF ONLY. INDIA HAS BECOME A DICTATORSHIP COUNTRY, INDIA WILL DESTROY ITSELF FROM WITHIN ,IF THAT HAPPENS CORRUPT MODI AND HIS RSS CRONIES WILL PAY A HEAVY PRICE.
1000 percent agree.. i am Pakistani but live in the us since i was 10. In america Indian and pakistanis live as neighbors lol. we are literaly the same people haha there is not one out there like us + Bangladesh
it's not possible till Pak don't end it's kashmir obsession and cross state terrorism
Give up Islam and we all can prosper as one nation again.
@@raivolution talkin like a real infidel😂😂
Remember what happened to Afghanistan when 2 super powers were trying to use it as a chess board?
The whole Afghanistan got into never ending civil wars that killed millions of their own and pushed the country 50 years back economically. Thats what happened
Yes but Pakistan is not Afghanistan. It a much richer and it's also nuclear power
@@kopend8638 Pakistan isn't rich. If u look at its percentage debt, its poorer than Afghanistan. Nuclear power isn't a boon but a curse
@@neelscooldude1 he didn't say pakistan is very rich, it's richer than pakistan and also much stronger in term of military
From neutral point of view, this project is huuuuggee so it will take a long time to realise this and obviously everyone also understand that. So stalled is not the right word imo
Non-stop smearing attempt to stir domestic audience is the real aim.
It's not stalled.
Couple of ships have started coming to this port and off course it will take time as you said it's a huge project which depends on some other things to be operational also but you will hear a lot of negative press against it from US affiliated media in an attempt to scare away the investors because china is involved.
Eventually, all the nodes will be in place, and Beijing will “flip the switch.”
True
@Mohammad Raza How?
Both usa and uk had sent warships to threaten India to support pakistan. Didn't want to recognise Bangladesh immediately.
India just prepped better and laid low before launching a blitzkrieg of diplomatic (taking USSR into confidence) and military hammer on Pakistan. India infact didn't got into the war and waited for the right time to train fighters inside the Bangladesh territory and to make multiple strategies incase one goes bad. Pakistan didn't fight a winning war. Rather usa supported pakistan by not giving access to gps data to India during many later conflicts between the two parties.
P.S. Russia didn't attack, they had hinted to step in in case usa steps in.
@Mohammad Raza weren't Pakistan a proxy state while US and USSR were fighting and didn't you guys send mujahideen and help US create Taliban in Afghanistan? Well if you want to deny that cool, but your General Musharraf would agree with me here as he has said it on interviews time and again
In the mean time, USA has been flipping the switch in SWIFT system all the time, look at the poor Iran~ See ? Hypocrite~
@@kdeb3374 And by the way, Mukti Bahini were trained by USSR. Bengali nationalism was a Soviet project. Indira could never have dared to take such a step without USSR. And USSR wanted to hurt Pakistan because Pakistan was in Western camp and USSR desperately needed access to Indian ocean. It was also trying to instigate separatist elements in Balochistan.
CPEC is a great success. Gwadar has grown into a major port rivaling Dubai. Chinese engineers are safe in Pakistan and loved by Baloch people. CPEC is minting money, and Pakistan is becoming the next Asian tiger. This is all due to the honest and selfless leadership of Pakistani politicians and the establishment. Long live the great leader Xi Jinping.
My Pakistani friends told me the port is doing well. I trust them over any US media.
thank you bro
I like how nobody cares until gwadar poses serious threat to them.
Jelous indian spotted 😂
@@chocolateboy4959 nobody is jealous we are concerned that u will have to follow communist regime in some years and they hate Islam😭😭😂🔥😭
@@chocolateboy4959 nobody is jealous of pakistan, actually indians are laughing and celebrating seeing your current economic condition and complete dependency on china.
@@chocolateboy4959 we're enjoying the beautiful show actually. It's time that you saw what reap. from the common man to your parliament, they're all lunatics there dancing on one leg. just look at your country's condition today. its laughable. poor joke. but also its bad that we dont have a competitive neighbour. you're a disgrace as a neighbour. 😑
@Syed Zaeem Ali Mohsin who says india depends on usa? India is self reliant in space,, army education,, food ,, infrastructure,, is USA coming and making roads in india?
"the local people fear that they will be left behind"
go ahead and show local people employed to build the residential community...
seriously blomberg?
there is no point of building the port first and then connects it to the country. So, Pakistan and china is currently building the road connectivity first and then build the port later for the use.
@UDDIPAN MONDAL taking goods through road doesn't make economic sense.
@UDDIPAN MONDAL Yeah by making a large population of Chinese workers they have an excuse to have more control over it. Most of their foreign infrastructure projects are like this.
China gets to use their excess labor, state-owned enterprise capacity, and keep strategic allies indebted to them. The leaders of the target country get to tout achievements and are paid under the table. The general population gets desperately needed infrastructure. It's a win-win-win strategy. I'm not implying China cares about the target country, but why would/should they?
Does the infrastructure serve them, or bypass them? Remember that entire self-sufficient communities have died and slums in the cities have grown because of otherwise straightforward changes to the national transportation network.
While in the beginning these projects look like they are very important and will bring forth much needed boost to the target country's economy, it usually always results in a massive failure, because China almost always puts on the execution on the target countries and then they are not able to make use of it, resulting in failure of the entire project
@@xero4479 what does Pakistan export anyways?
@@ben8718 not much currently, just textiles, opioids and cheap labor but if the Belt and road initiative went as planned, they could've set up thousands of new factories to start production and then use the highway corridor to ship it to Gwadar port from where it would've been distributed globally. But the Belt and road initiative has gone nowhere in the last 3 years and China has already seized operations at the port of Gwadar
I feel like the US is upset when China does this but its ok when they (the US) do it.
So how is the China Pakistan Enslavement Corridor going?
There is a Chinese saying that roads must be built before you want to get rich！
Thats what western media said about all those ghosts cities in china 5 years ago. Today they r 80% fill up
@@alvino2211 evidence?
No evidence needed when a 50 Center states anything 😅
yeah you are right pakistan now is a begging bowl :)
The Chinese would also say that in minecraft, to be rich, first cut down trees
Thank you imran khan for slowing down CPAC 😂😭😂😭😂😭😂
the loans frm china is less then 10 pct then the loans we(pak) get from IMF and world bank so dont worry we r in phase two in which agriculture industry and education are priorities with infra structure in far flung areas aswell...btw IMF and Worldbank would hv defaulted us if it were not for the 4 billion dlrs from saudia and china
Thank Nawaz Sharif not IK.
@@ISyedZainUlAbideen 22 Times IMF bailed you out and you think they would have defaulted you? FYI...IMF Did not ask Pak to take loan... Yourr PM went to IMF literally on knees. 🙄
@@gosliglitzho That's how it works, you pay a loan with a new loan. On and on it goes and people wonder why the world financial system isn't working.
Laughs in uighur.
Update : Pakistan has given the Gwadar port to China on 40 yrs lease means china now practically own that port of Pakistan . Looks like China's debt trap working very well .lol
Edit : it's not 100 yrs but 40 yrs , but main thing is one country has given up there land to another country just becoz they don't have money to pay .
hahahahaha jali na teri bhi jali na kali shakal wale hindutwo.
Perhaps you read it out of Bollywood news network.
@@shehryarkhan51 mere ko baki ka pata nahi but aap janab ko kya lagta hai... Aap log kaha se aaye hai!? ... Wannabe Arabs
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Don't worry
Source??
What about the infrastructure in Afghanistan and it's peace from America
pakistan literally funded the Taliban and other groups for its national interests in Afghanistan, it's the last one that should talk about peace
@Malik lxml propaganda? Your general Durrani thinks y'all are collateral damage for big games in Afghanistan , keep the pan islamic bullshit to urself
Haha atomi taakat
@@prajwalhegde1843 we can understand your pain .
@@prajwalhegde1843 we didn't but US funded them, indirectly😁😁
Why is CPEC failing? It’s because of the Pakistanis themselves, China has invested a lot of its money and wants to get it done, but they’ll never be able to complete it because it should pass through Pakistan’s heartland which is Punjab, Punjab is Pakistan’s farm land, because of the zamindari system, majority of the land in Punjab belongs to Pakistan’s elite, the army and the politicians, all of which hold dual citizenship and businesses abroad and their families live there, so it’s doesn’t matter to them if CPEC fails and they will never let CPEC pass through their land without demanding a royalty which China will never pay, so China now became predatory, let’s not forget that balochistan is not Pakistan’s land so they’ll resist, this was bound to fail from the beginning.
From where did you get this all information and second who told you that Balochistan is not the part of Pakistan?
Don't spread false information
@@innershadow3615 I got this data from pakistan institute of labor, education and research (PILER) and securities and exchange commission of Pakistan (SECP)(a gov institution) they are my sources and it's officially on record that 5% of the agricultural families who do not contribute anything to agri productions own 2/3 rd of the agricultural land in pakistan, fedual/zamindari system of pakistan is well covered by both international agencies and local institutions of pakistan,(PILER) also states these 5% make up 1500 to 2000 families of pakistan,which is mainly composed of armed forces officials, and the political class, and a 2007 report stated that 2/3 rd of lower house of pakistan was made up by these zamindars, and the single largest land owner in pakistan is the army and it's subsidiaries. Balochistan has resistance because pakistan illegally and forcefully occupied it, pakistan had signed stand still agreement with Balochistan and there was an embassy of Balochistan in Karachi. This is not misinformation I'm Citing my sources and these sources are your government institution.
Abhijit iyer Mitra ji se milke aai ho kya? 😂
@Aslan Pak Sar Zameen 1971 liberation of Bangladesh, this is all what i would say to you.
So called CPEC going through Pakistan Occupied Gilgit Baltistan.
POK and Gilgit Baltistan is integral part of republic of India.🇮🇳❤
Keep living in your fantasy land
@@mills9402 one more war and you'll be crumbling again like 1971
@@purshotamranghera even worse than 1971 war right now Pakistan can't afford a war for a week
It’s got nothing to do with india you fool it’s all within the boundaries of Pakistan it will never be yours your lucky enough you control Jammu even that which you illegally took control of and where your Indian army harms the Kashmir locals
Nitinsingh9840 Spreading misinformation again.
Balochistan was an indepedent country. It was overrun and annexed by Pakistan,
so basically Pakistan as snookered itself. Joined in the Soviet war, won and then joined in the Afghan war, ongoing, suffered loss now indebted to Chyna.
Won!!???
@@shividivi5693 yes won
They join soviet war to save balochistan from Soviet and join afgan war also save this baloch , pastun area from india afgan influence ..
And now Pakistan also won The Afghan war. Too bad for India
@@kabz3354 Usa pulled out, get real bro
sour grapes are everywhere....
Wuhmao spotted.😂🤣
@@simriths.s5976 I see you are a bot here, go back to support Trump or whatever will ya
小粉红
Too much wumaos
I smell bat soup
The story of the 21st century:
"(Insert superpower) once again fails to achieve (insert goal)"
China plans decades ahead, saying their goal failed after only few years shows how shortsighted other people are. They started some projects in 1970s that will only be finished in 2050, like the Great Green Wall.
More like "(insert western Enemy) once again fails to achieve (insert goals) "
@@Fauzanarief-n7i western enemy as in enemy from the west or enemy of the west?
@@antoniorsoftware yeah first create a desert then make it green again
GDP doubled in the last 10 years, much faster than that of India. How much of a failure is this? Does this mean India was greatest failure yet?
False. Actually, 7 out of 8 workers on CPEC projects are local Pakistanis, 2/3 completed BOT projects are local Pakistanis!
Let them keep hating. You can’t get upset at dogs for barking… as that is what they do.. Pakistan and China zindabaddddd!!!
@@yourdaddy3571 I don't know why USA and Uk media men are so naive? They think a lie repeated thousands of times will become truth. Ridiculous! Still a lie, a hypocritic one.
@@土桥一男 yup, I agree
I think this fundamentally misunderstands Chinese planning. China often builds infrastructure for expected demand that doesn't yet exist. Western media was writing a lot about Chinese ghost cities years ago, which have largely been filled up. Give it more time.
Yes the infrastructure projects provide jobs to Chinese people, but the economic growth the infrastructure will enable will bring jobs to pakistanis. This is pretty simple to understand.
There was also a dearth of actual data in this video.
Laughs in Sinhalese
They want a port, built them a port.
It’s simple.
I want a port.
What will happen if they default.
China will take over the infrastructure built by their money just like the Gwadhar port, China is already in control over the Hambantota port for 99 years.Chinese consortium has taken over 40 per cent stake in Pakistan's stock exchange.
Simple.....
Chinese money
Chinese Labour
Chinese construction goods and materials
Chinese companies
What the host countries are basically doing is buying up the infrastructure
@@rcmc7352 port
@@sounoks3180 Who cares. The infrastructures will still be located in the countries hiring locals thereby creating opportunities even if it's owned by foreign entity.
And do you know what's the true alternative that no one's talking about? That the land would've been left without any purpose.
If you've ever played civ / Catan you'll understand what I mean.
@@sumonechan8514 Signing away your sovereignty for infrastructure sounds like a disastrous move from strategic planning.
That 80 billion dollar aid cost Pakistan unimaginable lost to the economy and deaths.
Poor research and biased documentary.
How?
So true
But Pakistan will be bankrupt soon
Chinese giving high interest loan not investment
Pakistan is getting very poor
and what about the % million Muslims currently being "re educated" in a chinese internment camp? Do you not care about your Muslims brothers? I know Indians who care a lot about whats happening in China , there are protests happening in front of Chinese high commission here in Delhi every day.
Pakistan will be next Singapore. Economy booms and life gets better.
If China has made someone salty feel, it means China has done a right thing. Respect Pakistan leader that has right vision for his own people.
How US’s army Stalled Out
Strongest army on planet earth!
@@RaZoRFoX396 we saw it in syria 😀😃😄😁😆😅🤣😂
@@RaZoRFoX396 hahahaha check her situation in afghanistan why USA decided to withdraw you are looser shame on these looser army
@Keeran Thiyam weak or strong it depends on their performance !!!!!!
@Keeran Thiyam and Korea war
So many critics lol. Love how developed countries meddle in others affairs and avoid their own public questioning of their state affairs.
USA have given aiding all these years to Pakistan wondering all these have gone on terriorism... now you guys talking about minding their own business... I remember a quote “don’t shell a quarter without looking at the begging bowl”
When muslims value profits more than the lives of it fellow muslim brothers
Happens all the time does anyone even pretend to care about the Palestinians
When it comes to money everyone is of the same religion.
dont speak if you are clueless. Its better to be quiet, Pakistan is working with China behind the scenes and most reports are BS and propaganda.
@@rickstorm8948 🤣🤣🤣🤣
"The money powers prey on the nation in times of peace and conspire against it in times of adversity. ..."
Abraham Lincoln
What about this idea? 🤣
Some nations are greedy mercenary nations that will fall into bed with any rich nation ("We will fight your War on Terror" "We are victims of the war on terror" blah blah blah), so blaming the "money powers" for preying on such nations is ridiculous!
I think they always knew waterways can never be replaced by any other means.
Saudi to India cost rs.800 for more than 2000km.
mumbai to pune cost rs.7000 for just 250km.
Debt give diplomatic advantage to china . these countries would never dare to go against china.
wrong
Watching from Philippines😊
O I am watching from east Pakistan now bangaladesh
1:43 - 1:53 This is all footage from the Constituent Assembly of India and from a parade outside Rashtrapati Bhavan. As if all the white Gandhi caps weren't a glaring clue, you can clearly see Sardar Patel in the footage. Who is your video producer? Fire them.
This makes me wonder if even the dam construction footage was from Pakistan. Very sus.
Sshh, don't fact check the report, that's not how propaganda is supposed to work
@@hiyukelavie2396are you mad.dont know the difference between facts and propaganda
@@luckypruthvi8354 of course he knows that difference. And that’s why that is this is hoe propaganda works…. Footage form random palaces and some seemingly reliable but totally irrelevantly people talking.
Who will think that giving ultra corrupt countries so much money will end like this..
Correct title: “How to take over the world without anyone noticing!”
you know china doing things the right way when these western reporters can't find a solid reason to criticize China
Dealing with the devil... it's all part of a plan to assert naval, economic and structural dominance across the world. If countries along the way continue to default on debts, China will be a hegemon within no time at all. It will have so much reach and influence from indebted countries in a way that no other country would be left to replicate. This is the worst thing to happen to individual rights and freedoms you have ever seen, and will only get worse.
Well, we know china is doing the right way if western reporters are criticizing china.:)
@@vonschenck6464 only westerners takes other ppls freedom. Its fact
@@marcso Yeah... right. learn some more about global affairs before you write random things on the internet.
@@vonschenck6464 surely China is seeking economic and structural dominance across the world, but it makes no different at all as now we have USA dominance with same levels of human right abuse but China is not covering their human right violation as well as USA because they don't have as powerful media
I would love to see a shift of power from western countries to China as I believe China usually makes win-win trade deals with 3rd world countries while US tends to support a dictator who would allow them suck resources and walk away without profiting that poor country
western powers had their chance during colonization era and they traumatized these countries with worst imagined memories
now it's China's turn and I see places such as Africa flourishing which is great for all of us
btw I'm not an African, I'm from Saudi living in Poland as I study there
I don't really care about all the politics and stuff, but isn't it cool how the guard had a German Mg3 machinegun?
This is very political 😂
He was not a Guard. Pakistan Army provides security to all CPEC related facilities and the MG3 is the standard Machine Gun of Pakistan Army.
Pakistan produce its own MG3 since decades. Though I agree we should produce our own even if it's inferior. We will improve by time. That's how thing works I guess.
Pakistan arms forces uses G3s
@@MrMkn1991
Actually, Pakistani MG-3s have been manufactured as per German standards since the very beginning that is why the German Army ordered them from Pakistan a few years ago because the Germans had stopped making them and they were in need of them,
The Chinese solar system: Mercury, Venus, China, Mars,.....
Belt and road is like a fungus. It spreads its tendrils out and absorbs resources from far away locations. But the difference is that nothing beneficial is returned.
*Hyphae
Or american military bases that pay off and keep the world at peace
By population you can count Guwader people on fingers
8:52 a small city is called a town, my Lady, if not a village, depending on the industries the people work in
Fun fact, the inhabitants of villages were once called villains
@@shardovl586 Thanks! Yes, fun.
Let me check :)
@@shardovl586 OK! Checked :) Well, the very original is an inhabitant of a villa (big, country estates) and so not only villagers lived there ;)
Buuuut later just any country estate and theeeen the rest ;)
My honest opinion on why Pakistan is Poor and failed State
1. Half of money is spent on Army.
2. Half of the money goes to nurture terrorism.
3. Remaining money goes into development activities.
I would have colonised the entire China if US hadn't interfered.
Didnt you start the beef in the first place?
@@chabola8164 It was all for the Emperor and for the Japanese race and I don't regret anything.
@@mohammadzaid1221 and yes we had to interfere for the mankind
then your children will be Chinese and cannot speak or write Japanese, Like Qing Dynasty
Japan in WW2 was same side with nazis.
soon or later everyone will realise the consequences of this.i know if i said something about this a Pakistani will come to say that India is jealous of Pakistan.
Look brother, I understand your concern from across the border. But, the biggest help that an indian brother can give is to stick their nose in their own territory. Letting us know consequences will not affect anything since EVERY government is controlled by an agenda prewritten.
@@tonystark-gx7tx that's what I have said.idk why every Pakistani thinks that Indians hate them. btw congratulations on this project of china and Pakistan. may this help all of the peoples out there
@@Amandeep-kx8jl You seriously don't know the reason for the hate? Come on, man! We have to accept facts; India and Pak have fought 3 major wars with countless other skirmishes...
There is extreme hate on both sides and it is for not one, but several reasons.
(And I can assure you there is way more hate on the Indian side in recent times)
Well, regardless, thank you for well wishes btw same to you with the US Indo Pacific deal!
@@tonystark-gx7tx no hate from my side. idk about others
Kuch mat bol china pura route pak le liya hai,hume kya karna hai,loan nahi chukaya to land deni hogi
US rejecting Pakistans offer is like them passing the torch of Economic superiority to China, its gonna b interesting
because it's not commercially viable.
tell me an industrial cluster in the area? none
@@saltymonke3682 see in few years then
@@umairtayyab we will 😎
If you want to get rich, build a road first. It's a Chinese proverb.
@@saltymonke3682 yeah but chinas looking 10 years ahead of the US
As someone who’s into road trips, and has travelled across Balochistan’s coastal Highway. It’s amazing how much propaganda the western media machine’s doing on China…
I guess this is what Noam Chomsky calls “manufacturing consent”, for more conflict. CPEC has been phenomenal for Pakistan, they’ve helped increase our agricultural yields (some of our poorest Pakistanis are subsistence farmers).
@Motorsoul ss What exactly did we loose. The western countries with a past, present, and most likely a future, full of exploitation - do a lot of propaganda feigning worries about China being exploitative.
Really, the white lady in the documentary worries about how how fishermen can cross the highway. Wow, don’t she know there is something called Bridge?
OMG, she think the highway can block everywhere.
sounds like a Journalist Karen
lol you nailed her...
That is why she is in bloomberg
I'm extremely suspicious at the fact that Bloomberg is putting out this kind of content considering Mike's history of corruption.
I doubt Mike is micromanaging every freaking Bloomberg article and video, lol. No doubt he is a China drone, but I’ve read plenty on Bloomberg that points out Chinese flaws. A lot of propaganda too, to be sure.
I am sure Indians are involved in this propaganda piece, as they are vehemently against CPEC. Not only is the report contradictory, but full of blatant lies. Note that they didn't interview any locals and just had an anonymous recording. The Balochistan provincial government is very sensitive about jobs for locals and have established quotas which it monitors. Subject header says that the projects are stalled but in the end the video admits that the projects, such as the largest airport to be built in Gwadar, are ongoing.
@@QabilAGhor They had an anonymous recording because he didn't want to be prosecuted by the Pakistani government.
@@QabilAGhor Waah.. apki buddhi ko salam !!! It must be a Yahudi and Hindu sazish..
@@mrniceguy7168 China has even arrested some Bloomberg journalists 🙄
Can we (US) really blame China for trying to expand its influence and economic power, knowing our history and present acts?
how dare u？
@@yanchan9711 LOL. Grow up, perhaps?
Greetings, my dear 50 cent army boi.
What a great, _GREAT_ comment that is. I hope this awesomeness of a comment will assure you climbing up the carrier ladder of the 50 Cent braindeads, one day becoming a full 1 Yuan army boi.
And, oh, please: give my dearest regards to *Xi Pooh* , uuh, I mean *Winnie Jinping* .
Trade along the BRI has reached more than U$ 1 trillion annually. British Airways started flights to Gwadar two years ago. There is no more electricity shortages in Pakistan.
This is what white will never report!!
@@shinchan-F-urmom lol. Electricity goes everyday!