என்ன ஒரு அழகான பாடல் அது. அத குத்தி , கொலைபண்ணி அடக்கமும் பண்ணிட்டிங்களாயையா.. என்ன கேக்குறவன் கேணைணைருந்த எரும மாடு கூட ஏரோபிளான் ஓட்டுமமலே !!!! நோ ஒன்ஸ் மோர். இந்த மோரே போதும்.
After listening to this performance, I realize what great singers TMS and PBS were. Shankar Mahadevan has proved that he is just INCAPABLE of singing a truly melodious song.. He can at best sing songs where you have to scream your guts out!! As for Hariharan his voice is so tinny.. Despite being such professional singers, they are so much out of Shruti at so many places. This perhaps proves the point that though these compositions were made to look very simple by the sheer genius of singers like TMS and PBS, they are really difficult compositions even for Hari and Shankar to sing. Hari should get his eyes checked and change his specs, because even with specs on he is not able to read the script!!!
Thanks for posting this!. We need to listen such singing to remind us how great TMS/PBS were...seriously, if these two are great singers as some folks here make them out to be, why are they faking and spoiling this golden oldie instead of coming out with something of their own! Have to wash my ears with dettol and listen to the original another 10 times to forget this!
MahaaMaestro T.K.Ramamurthy's touch of incomparable genius is indelibly etched in this timeless tune, the composition, orchestration and the entire presentation of the song in the vocals that perfectly match the style and personality of the characters played by Sivaji The Greatest and the suave K.Balaji in this sequence in the incomparably brilliant film!! The dynamic duo's version does have their high points,though,in the end it makes everyone appreciate&yearn for the Original song a hundredfold more,bringing sadness and wistfulness together in the form of spontaneous tears, reminiscent of a never-again bygone Golden Era!!
if MSV might have been there at the stage, he might have tapped them on their face to teach this song even better. But no luck. Atleast MSV was able to tap their shoulders. Great Show!
I have listened more than 100 times this song... Wowwwwww Hariharan Sir and Shankar Mahadevan Sir!!!! Little bit mistakes are there but I never mind.... Because people may listened more than 1000 times of the original one But this improvisation is mesmerizing... Could have special taste to hear this version.... I don't want to blame any one here because their taste were different.... But they must want to know that they should not expect the same as original from everyone...
Both r absolutely superb singer ...but When they choose to sing a legends song they should know proper lyrics ... Other wise it will look like this performance ...
ஒரிஜினலாக இந்தப்பாடலை பாடியவர்களை நான் பெரிதும் மதிக்கின்றேன்,, ஆனால் இது மேடை, இதில் ஒரிஜினலை எதிர்பார்க்கக்கூடாது.. ஆல் இந்தியா பாடகர்கள் ஹரி சேர்,சங்கர் சேர், அவர்களுக்கு இசை கற்றுத்தராதீர்கள் ,, இது சும்மா பண்,,
There is nothing wrong in improvisation. But what is important is pronouncing the words correctly. I find these two have not shown enough seriousness in ensuring that. Some words were forgotten and some times doubts came in between. But their voice is sweet and blends well. But Shankar should understand that while singing the line 'vinnodum vilayadum' should be sung in clear High pitch with perfection as 'vin' means sky and the Great composer MSV kept the high pitch note to make that impact.I hope people will understand the importance of the lyric as MSV blends the word musically which is his unique quality.
அந்த இரு லெஜண்ட்ஸின் அருமையை இருவரும் புரிய வைத்து விட்டீர்கள். அவர்களே அழகாகத்தான் பாடி வி்ட்டுதான் போனார்கள். மேலும் அழகு படுத்த அந்த பாட்டில் வாய்ப்பில்லை. சங்கர் சார் நீங்க எவ்வளவு பெரிய சிங்கர்.. உங்களு்க்கு தெரியாதா எங்கு கமக கொடுக்க வேண்டும் என்று?? எம்எஸ்வி அந்த இடத்தில் இருந்திருந்தா உங்க இரண்டு பேரையும் மும்பய் எக்ஸ்பிரஸ்ல பேக்கப் பண்ணி இருப்பார்.. உங்க விளையாட்டையெல்லாம் மும்பய்ல காட்டுங்கடான்னு..!!..
There's another version where spb and spb Charan singing together this song.... Pls you craps watch it and learn how to sing such legendary songs without spoiling them....
Eanda pea punda ar patta nalla keazhuda ogommala pottu okkka inthea keana kuthiyanuga padichathukku ar ra ilukkura ar rahman patteallam nalla kealu o pondadiya pakkathu vittu karanoda anupittu
Thayavu saithu old song padi athai kedukatheengada. Etho unga luck negalum pada vanthuteenga. North side chance illa. So inga vanthachu. Tamizhayin azhgayum keduthachu. Spb and yesudas the ever green voice in India.
You must know the logic that singing a song by other singer never damage the voice of own singer o that song. You are a big fan of TMS and therefore you try to comment negatively to the great legend Hariji every time...
Kaj Sel Please do not say legend that fellow is an Idiot changing the song to his convenience. If these two idiots can't sing leave It, nobody bothered. For that do not put JALRA to Hariharan.
Seeing most of the negative comments. What is wrong with some spontaneous improvisation? If you didn't like it, it doesn't mean experimentation is wrong. Obviously they chose this song because of its iconic quality and popularity. Just reproducing the original is one thing. Adding their improv touches is expected from these two modern day legends who are the two most qualified (after Yesudas and SPB) to sing this. I'm sure, if they were asked to reproduce and rerecord the song in a studio, they would (almost) match the original. But this is live performance. OK to improvise. That said, i do like the original more 😍
இந்தப் பாடல் எல்லாம் எங்களுக்குப் பொக்கிஷம் மாதிரி ஐயாக்களே...இதில் நீங்கள் விளையாட வேண்டாம்..
Yes correct
என்ன ஒரு அழகான பாடல் அது. அத குத்தி , கொலைபண்ணி அடக்கமும் பண்ணிட்டிங்களாயையா.. என்ன கேக்குறவன் கேணைணைருந்த எரும மாடு கூட ஏரோபிளான் ஓட்டுமமலே !!!! நோ ஒன்ஸ் மோர். இந்த மோரே போதும்.
தெரியாமல் கேட்டுவிட்டேன். நல்ல வேலை எழுதியவர்,இசையமைப்பாளர் பாடி டிஎம்எஸ் இறந்துவிட்டனர்.எல்லாம் காலத்தின் கோலம்.
The speciality of TMS and Srinivas Sirs cannot be matched anyhow....
i agreed
Original is original.. Nothing can beat it.
I didn't know these guys said they were trying to match anyone. Isn't fantasy a marvellous bedfellow!
இரு ஜாம்பவான்களும் பழமையை கடைபிபிடித்து பாடினால் இன்னும் அழகாயிருக்கும்.உலகம் முழுவதும் பாடலை தூவிவிட்டார்கள்.
காலத்தை கடந்தும் வென்று என்றும் வாழும் தெய்வங்கள்.
6:37
Morning I awake up open my phone fast see the video myself really mind bowling today so happy the hole day thanks for you tube Tamil channel videos
Very well said...!!
this segment shows the quality of current days so called legends !!
They just killed a wonderful song !
Thooooooo naaigalaaa ivargal iruvarum thimir pdithavargl
My Guru Hariharan, Shankar mahadevan Serthale Vera Leval 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🥰😍😘
After listening to this performance, I realize what great singers TMS and PBS were. Shankar Mahadevan has proved that he is just INCAPABLE of singing a truly melodious song.. He can at best sing songs where you have to scream your guts out!! As for Hariharan his voice is so tinny.. Despite being such professional singers, they are so much out of Shruti at so many places. This perhaps proves the point that though these compositions were made to look very simple by the sheer genius of singers like TMS and PBS, they are really difficult compositions even for Hari and Shankar to sing. Hari should get his eyes checked and change his specs, because even with specs on he is not able to read the script!!!
These two singers do not do justice to such a song. It is just a performance. Sad
Hariharan eppovum konjam overahh tha pannuvan......stagela......
Taare zameen par song kelunga.
TMS - BPS 🔥🔥🔥 காம்போ எந்த கொம்பனாலயும் உடைக்க முடியாது.. செத்த கம்முனு போங்க ஹரி.. சங்கர்
தயவுசெய்து மீண்டும் எங்கள் அபிமான பாடகர்களின் உண்மையான சுருதியை மாற்ற வேண்டாம்.
தமிழன் தலைஎழுத்து அற்புத பாடகர்களின் பாடல்களை எல்லாம் தாறுமாறாக நாசம் செய்யும் இவர்களுக்கு என்ன தண்டனை தமிழின் சாபகேடு
Thanks for posting this!. We need to listen such singing to remind us how great TMS/PBS were...seriously, if these two are great singers as some folks here make them out to be, why are they faking and spoiling this golden oldie instead of coming out with something of their own!
Have to wash my ears with dettol and listen to the original another 10 times to forget this!
abaswara Good reply to those spiked idiots.
சாகாவரம் பெற்ற பாடல் .. இவர்களால் பாட முடியாது.
Two legends are slaughtering the original flow of the song
MahaaMaestro T.K.Ramamurthy's touch of incomparable genius is indelibly etched in this timeless tune, the composition, orchestration and the entire presentation of the song in the vocals that perfectly match the style and personality of the characters played by Sivaji The Greatest and the suave K.Balaji in this sequence in the incomparably brilliant film!!
The dynamic duo's version does have their high points,though,in the end it makes everyone appreciate&yearn for the Original song a hundredfold more,bringing sadness and wistfulness together in the form of spontaneous tears, reminiscent of a never-again bygone Golden Era!!
Hariharan sir and Shankar sir practice first. This is one of our evergreen songs. Singer's TMS and PBS nailed it.
They can learn to sing this song.. but cant beat TMS.. old song is such a gift for all of us to listen....
உண்மையில் பாடலை மதித்து அதே போல் பாடி இருந்தால் சிறப்பாக இருந்து இருக்கும். இவர்களுஉம் திறமைசாலிகளே
T.m.s, p.b.s., m.s.v, கவிஞர் கண்ணதாசன், நடிகர் திலகம் மற்றும் இவர்கள் காலத்தில் நாமும் வாழ்ந்தோம் என்று பெருமை மற்றும் திமிர் கொள்வோம்.
ABASWARAM..................
அருமையான எளிமையான பாடலை இப்படி கெடுத்து விட்டார்களே . நீங்கள் திறமையானவர்கள் என்று சொல்லிக் கொள்ளுங்கள் அதற்காக இப்படி பாடியது மோசம்
Ora thimiru,rendu perukum,periya hair innu naniupu, lovable and beautiful song a destroy pannitanga
சூப்பர் பாடலை குட்டிச்சுவராக்கிவிட்டனர் இருவரும்.
100% True
Creative இசை விரும்பிகளுக்கு இது தேன்...... Creative singers 🙏🙏🙏🙏... What a improvisational
Shankar Mahadevan, a great legend but simple at heart.
This is a great wonderful emotional expert song lots of good luck and love from Thiagaraj
ஹரிஹரன் சங்கர் மகாதேவன் பெயரை கேட்டாலே சும்மா அதிருதில்லா வாழ்க வளமுடன்
if MSV might have been there at the stage, he might have tapped them on their face to teach this song even better. But no luck. Atleast MSV was able to tap their shoulders. Great Show!
Yaanaikkum adi sarukkum... Fantastic example for this !!! :-)
Aarthi Balu
Missing their nut
தேவையில்லாமல் ஓவரா ஆக்ஷ்ன் இருவரும்.ரசிகக்கும்படியாக இல்லை.
The top two singers sankar mahadevan and hariharan
Eppa neenga unga paatta mattum Kola seingappa
don't waste the legendary song
ஆஹா.பிரமாதம்.
பெரிய வெங்காயம் என்று நினைப்பு கடைசியில் கறிவேப்பிலை
Unfit for that also
ஐயோ, நீங்கள் கறி வேப்பலையை குறைவாகச் சொல்கிறீர்கள். ....
loved this rendition from hari and shakar sirs 🙏 😍thank you
But their kill the song
evergreen song sung again by 2 wonderful singers in the country! thanks a lot for uploading!!!
I have listened more than 100 times this song... Wowwwwww Hariharan Sir and Shankar Mahadevan Sir!!!! Little bit mistakes are there but I never mind.... Because people may listened more than 1000 times of the original one But this improvisation is mesmerizing... Could have special taste to hear this version.... I don't want to blame any one here because their taste were different.... But they must want to know that they should not expect the same as original from everyone...
Both r absolutely superb singer ...but When they choose to sing a legends song they should know proper lyrics ... Other wise it will look like this performance ...
Thevai illatha sangathis.. yen intha veri? Wonderful song for all ages and these two murdered this song. Please don't kill old beauties.
90 கிட்ஸ் ஆனாலும் பழைய பாடல் அருமை.உங்களுக்கு சரியில்லை.நீங்கள் நல்ல பாடகர் தான் .பழைய மாடலிலே பாடி இருக்கலாம்
ஒரிஜினலாக இந்தப்பாடலை பாடியவர்களை நான் பெரிதும் மதிக்கின்றேன்,, ஆனால் இது மேடை, இதில் ஒரிஜினலை எதிர்பார்க்கக்கூடாது.. ஆல் இந்தியா பாடகர்கள் ஹரி சேர்,சங்கர் சேர், அவர்களுக்கு இசை கற்றுத்தராதீர்கள் ,, இது சும்மா பண்,,
Rendu Parathesipayalukalum Namma ooril Padinal Serupadithan.
These are two great singers no doubt that ...... they have their own style
both of you exellence
Two of my favorite singers! Thanks for posting this. hopefully, I'll be able to be able to sing kind like them someday ;)
Over acting very bad
This is exactly why we watched live concerts those days.. for these jugalbandi n live jamming of aalaps!!🥰🥰
Saagavaram,Petra,padalgal,payapadalgal,
The doubt is you'll are old people are young with 62 years like me Thiagaraj.
Lovely and warm up sòng for the weather good dance also.
Thiagaraj B B lore
இரண்டுபேரும் ஒழுங்காக பாடினால் அருமையாக இருக்கும் but overacting பண்ணி நாசம் செய்துவிட்டனர்.. அதிலும் ஹரிஹரன் ரொம்பவும் over
Semma comedy.......
I felt the same thing
Naasama pochi
Too much egotistical
ஆமாம் .over doing
நல்லதோர் வீணை செய்தே அதை நலங்கெட புழுதியில் எறிவதுண்டோ ?
Prasad Rajaraman
Thalai kaal puriyala
Vedieo vere suzhattuthu
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Etharku per thaan kaalakodumai
Yes correct
Padalin GOWRAVAM athai mathikanume
There is nothing wrong in improvisation. But what is important is pronouncing the words correctly. I find these two have not shown enough seriousness in ensuring that. Some words were forgotten and some times doubts came in between. But their voice is sweet and blends well. But Shankar should understand that while singing the line 'vinnodum vilayadum' should be sung in clear High pitch with perfection as 'vin' means sky and the Great composer MSV kept the high pitch note to make that impact.I hope people will understand the importance of the lyric as MSV blends the word musically which is his unique quality.
exactly what was in my mind.
muraliny eh, it’s not important. Meaningful text is subordinate to the musicality of text.
What a melodious voice simply awesome
Ean !! Ean !! Intha Veri -- Killing the Golden Great Voice Tms & Srinivas
Ya this song should feel inside n bring out...real sentiment song..they sung it like disco song
❤
அந்த இரு லெஜண்ட்ஸின் அருமையை இருவரும் புரிய வைத்து விட்டீர்கள். அவர்களே அழகாகத்தான் பாடி வி்ட்டுதான் போனார்கள். மேலும் அழகு படுத்த அந்த பாட்டில் வாய்ப்பில்லை. சங்கர் சார் நீங்க எவ்வளவு பெரிய சிங்கர்.. உங்களு்க்கு தெரியாதா எங்கு கமக கொடுக்க வேண்டும் என்று?? எம்எஸ்வி அந்த இடத்தில் இருந்திருந்தா உங்க இரண்டு பேரையும் மும்பய் எக்ஸ்பிரஸ்ல பேக்கப் பண்ணி இருப்பார்.. உங்க விளையாட்டையெல்லாம் மும்பய்ல காட்டுங்கடான்னு..!!..
There's another version where spb and spb Charan singing together this song....
Pls you craps watch it and learn how to sing such legendary songs without spoiling them....
Thanks a lott...
சீன் போட்றத விட்டுட்டு பாட்டை நல்லா பத்து தடவை கேட்டுட்டு பாடுங்க ,
இது என்ன AR ரகுமான் பாட்டா உங்க இஷ்டத்துக்கு கத்திட்டு போறதுக்கு .
Wow...what a comment
Eanda pea punda ar patta nalla keazhuda ogommala pottu okkka inthea keana kuthiyanuga padichathukku ar ra ilukkura ar rahman patteallam nalla kealu o pondadiya pakkathu vittu karanoda anupittu
Super
Thayavu saithu old song padi athai kedukatheengada. Etho unga luck negalum pada vanthuteenga. North side chance illa. So inga vanthachu. Tamizhayin azhgayum keduthachu. Spb and yesudas the ever green voice in India.
Interesting to listen and enjoy with action..Thiagaraj.
i cant understand tamil but i love hariharan and his silky voice .great singer in this decade
ஏன் ஏன் ஏண்டா படுத்துறீங்க
Double stars in stage
Two legends singing together-a real treat.
are you nuts? these idiots just murdered a classic hit and you call it a treat?
Excellent
DEAR HARI AND SHANGKAR - ITS NOT EASY THE WORLD VOICE GOD TMS SIR SONGS PLEASE KAINDLY ASKING DONT DAMAGE THE GREAT GENIUS SONGS
baley baley... fentastic combination...in hindustahni. but the "original is ever original"...
thanks fro this video1
VOICE GOD ONE AND ONLY IN THE WORLD TMS SIR
what great voices ever heard....
Thayavu seithu arumayana
Padalai neenga padi ketukathinka
Manthuku kasdama irukku😎
will sun t.v retelecast this entire programme. I ti is si nice.
Nicely sung by Hari and Shanker in their own way.
..
should respect the such a great song not making fun of it its shame for these two artists
Wow, they both melt my heart man...awesome two!
--Selvam
🙏🏻👍EXCELLENT 🙏
i think nobody has the right to say anything unless you can sing like hariharan of shankar or even better,,otherwise its better to remain silent;)
I sung this sang during my collage days with my friend
Dear boys please don t damage the great voice god voiCe of the woRld king TMS sir song
You must know the logic that singing a song by other singer never damage the voice of own singer o that song. You are a big fan of TMS and therefore you try to comment negatively to the great legend Hariji every time...
Kaj Sel Please do not say legend that fellow is an Idiot changing the song to his convenience. If these two idiots can't sing leave It, nobody bothered. For that do not put JALRA to Hariharan.
superb
Super nice
2018???
Hariharan always Rocks
🙏🙏🌿🌹🌿🌹
Seeing most of the negative comments. What is wrong with some spontaneous improvisation? If you didn't like it, it doesn't mean experimentation is wrong. Obviously they chose this song because of its iconic quality and popularity. Just reproducing the original is one thing. Adding their improv touches is expected from these two modern day legends who are the two most qualified (after Yesudas and SPB) to sing this.
I'm sure, if they were asked to reproduce and rerecord the song in a studio, they would (almost) match the original. But this is live performance. OK to improvise.
That said, i do like the original more 😍
LMAOO!! the intro was hilariouss!! can't believe these are the two singer ruling bollywood as well. love them both
ஐயா T.M.S இன்னும் சாகவில்லை நீங்கள் அழாதீர்... உங்கள்.. விளையாட்டு.. படும்.. மோசம்.
Infact original cannot be matched but this is also diff rendition. Let's enjoy this also since the tune is immortal.
Original original than !!!!manathil antha padalgal sirpangal pol !!!!!!!!
Good song
Super
Beautiful..... Thank you.
Do you have any more links to these guys.
There is no flow to this song. I love the original song.
Nonsence
Nallaa kedutu vachitangaya..
THE GOLDEN VOICE GREAT TMS SIR - PLEASE DONT MAKE IT SHIT THE GREAT SONGS DEAR FRIENDS DO YOURE LOKAL KUTHTHU
Music is all about creativity! Tats what they did! It's simply awesome!
TMS+PBS great
செமமம
Excellent singing by great singers of the era.
Very nice song