Messing up a Maserati
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 4 ต.ค. 2024
- The plaintiff parked his car in the defendant’s parking garage. When he picked it up, the plaintiff claims the vehicle was damaged, so he is suing for repairs. The defendant insists the plaintiff is lying about the damages as retaliation because the defendant raised his parking lot prices.
Someone is jealous in that parking garage
Yup
My thoughts exactly.
I was thinking maybe people were taking photos on the car
Very!
💯
The fact that he only wanted to be called Robert, and not Dr So and so shows his humility and down to earth Cardiologist..... fix the man's car
I think it has more to do with him having a professional reputation, so he doesn’t want his last name blasted onscreen.
@@mikesteele05 he could have said call me Dr. Robert. 🤷🏿♀️
I came here to say the same thing. And he damn well should be Dr. Robert, he's earned that.
Doctor Robert displayed much more patience than I’d have displayed in these instances !
That’s becuz he’s 🐱
@@TROLLzenbergRAWthat perspective of this Cardiologist is flawed to say the least!
Me too
The fact that the plaintiff was just going to eat the first couple of damages shows how humble he is.
His car is being damaged INTENTIONALLY! 😒
Agree 💯
Yes
Yessss 😢
It never surprises me when incompetent people(the defendants) show up in court with ZERO evidence to defend themselves, then tell the Plaintiff to take them to court, hoping that this prominent doctor would just drop it. They were wrong...
And I wish that judge Milian could have awarded the Plaintiff the rental fees.
Let the defendants go after the incompetent attendant that caused the damage & deliberately failed to report it to save his own ass.
Defendant knows his employees damaged the car and thinks playing dumb will get him out of his responsibility. NO WAY JOSE!
i’m dying no way Joseeeee not this time
@@AshliMarieTVlove the microaggression
The way they treated the plaintiff is horrible as if he’s a low class citizen . He makes more money than these vile defendant and has class .
The plaintiff has a good heart. ❤
He should have gotten all 3, in my opinion
Legally he didn’t report the first one so they can’t be ordered to pay for it.
@hadley407
"That's not LEGALLY" it's just a procedure between to private parties not a Law
This is my favorite of all! I’ve watched this about 20 times. I love how calm and reserved and collected the plaintiff is.
They should’ve had to pay for all three incidents
I agree!!! It’s pretty evident after the second and third time who the problem was.
That’s foul he should have gotten his money for each incident. Wtf.
@@INDIGO.GODDESS_573AGREE 💯
The smirk the plaintiff had at the beginning of the case when it was mentioned about the price increase. 😂
It's true, you need a private garage with a nice car.
Can't do it in NYC.
The day after I picked my Audi up from a parking garage I noticed the passenger side dented and scratched . I had picked my car up at night, so I didn’t even notice the damage until the next morning.
I couldn’t prove that it happened at the garage, their cameras didn’t work, but the owner volunteered to pay the total bill, over $3500.00 and gave us a nice gift card to PF Changs. He owned that restaurant.
That was nice!😊
@@kimr5479 I agree. What a nice man.
It's nice to read stuff like this to remind me that there are good business owners still out there. Getting harder to find these days, as evidenced by the defendant in this case.
Young, black & successful!! Love it! 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
The plaintiff has a good heart! (Get it? Cause he’s a cardiologist?)
Hee haw
😂
🙄
Boooooooooooooo
@Amelia, one day you'll have a thought of your own.
What an intelligent handsome guy the plaintiff is ❤
After you found out he was a cardiologist?
@@Peter-yz4rm Gold diggers....If he worked at the parking garage he would be absolutely grotesque to her...
@@Peter-yz4rm no incel
If he was the valet, would he still be so handsome?
@@EduardoGonzalez-qm2uk ur insecurities are very loud
I’d trust him with my heart ❤
❤ definitely me too lol 😂
@@dominiuqewaston2492 Ladies keep it in your pants....If he worked in the parking garage you wouldn't even notice him
@@josha.bdoge2 dang, thats quite the assumption 😂that’s not true for me. I would have said the same thing if he had a different occupation.
@josha.bdoge2
he's a Cardiologist..
do u not get it? 🙄🤦🏾♀️
❤❤❤❤, im so glad he won, it couldn't have been any other way.
Defendant looked very bad, no legitimate defense, a total scammer.
Plaintiff super handsome, well spoken, composed, owns a Maserati and he's a cardiologist ❤❤❤❤
Not sad, angry and stupid.
A young, successful black man in the medical field. I love to see it👏🏾
You don't see that often?
@@Imissyoulou I said I love to see it. I didn’t say I don’t see it often
@@Imissyouloudid she say she didn’t see of often?! Reading is fundamental!!!!
What does the skin color matter? I don’t get what’s people obsession with skin color
@@AlbertoHernandez-up3cs I just knew there would be someone like you 🙃 just keep it moving.
It sounds like they WANT HIM TO TAKE HIS CAR elsewhere.
Or maybe they should take their business elsewhere if they don’t understand American rights and constitutions
Nah, It sounds like they were jealous
This parking is where he LIVES. He said it's happening overnight. Sounds like the building needs a new company to do the parking management.
It’s NYC. It’s most likely a garage within a few blocks of his high-rise or brownstone. His car is being parked in a section of the garage for people who take out their cars daily, which means there’s a lot of shuffling as cars go in and out. It’s not a self-service parking garage where every car has its own space.
He lives in the building where the car is parked according to testimony he said it is convenient.😊😊
Cardiologist ...
Love it
YES, me too!👍
It sounds like someone in that parking garage has been taking his car out for a spin without his permission...
Someone in that parking garage is doing that on purpose
Or very careless! The judge should have made them pay. If it walks like a duck, then it is a duck.
jealousy
The garage (just like at large dealerships when you take car for service) will have a carbon copy drawing of the car and will check off on the drawing any areas with scratches or dents at the time the car is dropped off. Then they give a copy to the customer. This garage should be doing that EACH DAY.
He could fix my heart any day. ❤
defendants are dishonest and clearly jealous. I would even say racist. The number of incidents suggests that this is done knowingly and with malice.
Why does everything have to surround racism? Maybe people are just as$h0les!
Why the fuuuu you telling to get a Honda?! He works hard for his money he can drive whatever he wants!!!!!!
That's why you can't drive a precious car? That's like saying that's why you can't live in an expensive house because it keeps getting burglarized.
yea that’s the dumbest shit she ever said he’s paying for private parking to protect his investment that was so idiotic of her ugh
@@AshliMarieTV Agree especially since she's rich just like him and likely drives an expensive car herself - And Doug at the end saying buy a Honda 🙄 bet he doesn't drive some little Honda to his six figure job either.
Why so serious? C’monnn, It was a joke lol. Dont look too deep into it, she was making lighthearted jokes with plaintiff thru the hearing.
In NYC, I would strongly advise against it without a private garage. We have to parallel park 90% of the time (people also drive like complete a**holes) so expect rear bumper dings and dents on the regular. Also, most of the private parking lots are run by valets, so you have zero control over who moves your car to a spot once you hand over the keys. It's a huge risk to have anything too expensive in NYC! I drive a beat up Corolla for that exact reason- I come back to a new scratch weekly- after a while you just give up.
You heard how she said it....@@Lenora-nv5yg
Hes a Cardiologist? Wow. AWESOME.
Cardiologist.... I'm impressed! Someone is definitely jealous.
He's not a surgeon. Cardiology is actually very easy to do.
@@stratfordbaby8572jealous
@@stratfordbaby8572 Even a non-invasive cardiologist makes over a quarter million dollars per year on average so it isn't "very easy" to do otherwise we'd all be doing it and able to afford new Maserati's - Not to mention he never said what type of cardiologist he was anyway - Sounds like you're the hater damaging his car.
@Stressless2023 I agree and I'm still impressed.
@@stratfordbaby8572ooo you must be a cardiologist? Do you have a Maserati or a Porsche? 🤡
Defendant tried to play the young successful brother
He's not THAT young. To be a practicing cardiologist he's already pushing 40.
He is not 'playing'! It is what he is. Jealous?
@@stratfordbaby8572don’t matter how old the guy is the young brother look early 30’s stop hating 😂 smh
Successful man.. just simply a hard working successful good looking man!
If you are talking about the Cardiologist, he is the PLAINTIFF not the defendant and he doesn't have to 'play' at being successful, he is!...
The judge thinks like a judge…. Some ppl have the ability to know to record, but most don’t think “I need proof in case this ends up in court”
If you drive a luxury car, you take a 360 video of your car before you leave it in anyone else’s hands. Otherwise, it’s very very difficult to prove a valet or garage caused minor damage. The plaintiff is lucky that the garage admits to the things they told him.
Places that deal with vehicles always use this tactic (car came in like that) to avoid paying out. Happened to me with 4 brand new wheels at a car wash.
He better not park in that garage EVER AGAIN …because they’re definitely gonna attack his car after this lawsuit !!
The parking Garage manager told him to take him to court because he honestly believed HE WOULDN’T. Surprise Surprise 😅
This is exactly why many drive clunkers in NYC.
Milian's hair was perfection in this
How do you prove a valet damaged your car? They drove it. Has anyone seen the way they handle cars when out of sight???
DUH. YOU HAVE TO PROVE IT WASN'T DAMAGED WHEN IT ARRIVED THERE. ARE YOU THICK???
i lived just around the corner of a VW dealer years ago, they would ride past the street "testing "out the cars, and sometimes they misused the cars, i always said to myself wish i could contact the owner of the car,
Defendant is a scamming piece of garbage. Give that man his money and treat him with respect! He's been more than courteous and respectful! Last person you should ever try to pull this nonsense on. PAY THE MAN!
Handsome black educated man, love to see it!
If a company damages my car I would NEVER use that company again
Why wouldn’t you take pictures each time you noted damaged and sent it to management?
Idk who would just “let go” of the first ding on a Maserati? Why would you continue to work with him? Why wouldn’t you have the cameras reviewed ALL times? 🤨
Because they don’t want to pay anything. They’re terrible.
He implied that it would be less trouble for him to just have the car fixed than to argue with the garage. It seems like he sued because he’d finally had enough.
I kind of agree that he should have been recording EVERY interaction after the first scratches and blow off. I usually dislike people that whip out their phones, but after the first time, better to be precautious. The parking attendants clearly seem to be targeting his car because it is a more prestigious, luxury model. I wouldn't bring a moped to the Defendant's garage. Also, the Defendant's witness is full of cr2p. No Maserati owner is going to be shown a scratch/dent that appeared on their car and say, "No problem, I need to go out(so I don't care)".
Maserati’s and other luxury vehicles definitely need a house with a garage.
I would NEVER park my car in a garage that damaged my car TWICE. He has the money, find another garage.
I bet they tell him, sorry, you cant park here anymore
They will.
I bet he can afford to park somewhere else
If this has happened with your old car then it's going to happen with the new one, maybe not park your car there
Sadly most parking garages have signs saying "Not responsible for lost, damaged or stolen items or vehicles:
"Alright, thank you very much. You lost this case." Chiiiile, Doug is so savage 😂😂
Plaintiff 100% in the right and a good witness
He's a smart black man but kept no record or proof of anything that happened in that carpark. Like it happened 4 times...
Can’t believe for someone of such intelligence keep goin back to that place
You go heart doctor ♥️
So they charge you to park and aren't liable if something happens to your car even if they are negligent smh. Unreal..
They’re liable, but you have to be able to prove they caused the damage.
He should of gotten all three and emotional distress! These people are jealous and evil and treated him like a dog. What a nice man w a lovely soul. I hope he lives a great life !
love it when they talk past and present tense in same sentence ugh.
Anyone else have Ferris Bueller's Day Off in mind? "Relax...I'm a professional."
Yeeeesssss
Sounds like a jealous person on the defendants side. They gonna learn today.
I never understand why the judge laughs when people sue for emotional damages. He should be entitled to something for having to fix his car multiple times, some of which seemed intentional. Theres nothing stopping them from continuing to do this. They face barely any penalty for ruining a nice car they’ll never be able to afford.
Emotional damage would imply that his emotional state has had a meaningful impact on his quality of life. Being annoyed is different from life-altering trauma. He obviously wasn’t emotionally damaged enough to stop parking his car there. If you could sue people for annoying you, we’d all be suing each other.
@@mikesteele05 do you live in New York? Parking isn’t exactly a free for all. When you get a close garage spot, you tend to keep it.
He’s a cardiologist. At the least he should get the hourly rate he’s paid for time wasted arguing back and forth with these lunatics.
I think they are jealous of this successful fine black man in that garage, that's why his car Is constantly being tampered with. Jealousy makes you do things you can't explain
Im glad he won, but he didn't have evidence either, no pictures of his car being scratched or damaged on the days it happened, it could've happened somewheres else...hmm idk what to think 🤔
Considering he complained immediately all three times his car was damaged and had it repaired right after the damage was brought forward I would lean more towards his word being more credible especially since he makes well into six figures per year and drives a $100k car so he has less reason to lie than the defendant.
Don’t worry, she did all the thinking!
I'm shocked by how unprepared people are when they show up at a court of law with no evidence
The defendant shouldn't be the manager. He's completely negligent
They were envious of this guy!!!
The whole crew needs to be fired. He shouldve gotten the cost of all 3 repairs not for parking tho. But I knew Judge was gonna make supposedly joking remarks about him owning a high end car. MAYBE YOU SHOULDN'T DRIVE A PRECIOUS CAR 🤷♀️
If he could afford to lease a Maserati I don’t think he would complain about the monthly parking increase.
I loved the plaintiff ❤
Why would you CONSTANTLY park somewhere where your Maserati is getting CONSTANTLY damaged?!?!?
You ain’t never lived in NY with a car lol. Parking space is like a gold mine. You might take your chances
you gotta be from manhattan yo understanding. you know how big a nyc block is …. man
Move to NYC then ask that question.
Ummmm he LIVES there that's why. The garage needs to do better
He's saving hearts for christ sake the defendants can't take care of a car?? smh
Take it easy. He's not God.
@@stratfordbaby8572 you’re right, he’s actually saving people.
The Plaintiff is a cardiologist 😵. Hey boo 🫢😉
Back up off my man haha jk ❤
😂😂😂. All y'all.
Isnt it like loaning something to someone you EXPECT to get it back in the SAME way you loaned it 🤔
Defendant is ridiculous
I want to know where Marilyn gets her jewelry. Wonderful taste!
Why is it so surprising to everyone commenting that a black man is a doctor and is successful? Seems to me that thinking that way is racist.
Because he looked somewhat young probably (under 50).
I can't help but wonder if the plaintiff was a white cardiologist would he have had all those problems? There's old joke that goes like this: "What do racists call a highly educated, successful, and wealthy black person who drives a Rolls Royce"? I will let you guess....
Geoffrey Butler?
@@Quartzquiz333 re-read and try again
What's the answer?
@@thomasskodzinsky3255 A n......
A wealthy educated 🥷
I would trust him to be my cardiologist
They were hating on the plaintiff. Employees was fkn his car up on purpose. SMH
..He can attend to my heart anytime.....😂😂😂
If they see damage they should alert the customer write a report and have the customer sign it just like rental companies do everyday.
I am amazed that someone who owns 40 parking garages hired this incompetent foreigner to a management position.
They must of assume a brother in a nice car must be a drug dealer and wouldn't get litigious on they ass😅
problem #1 giving your Maserati to someone else to drive
There’s no other way in NYC unless you want to park it on the street.
@@mikesteele05 That would suggest that either a Maserati is not an appropriate vehicle for NY or you might have to lower your expectations with respect to dents, dings and scratches.
If I had a car like that, there's no way I'm letting anyone else drive it, let alone some kid I don't know.
Lemme tell you- there are so many complaints where I live of landscaping workers blowing debris, scratching, and bumping against our nice vehicles. It definitely feels like jealousy as we have video footage of them doing it and they still do it knowing they’ve been warned. One of the defendants looks just like our community’s landscaping contractor.
Judge--Verdict for the plaintiff because she thinks cardiologists are inherently better than parking lot attendants. Neither side had any evidence. Frankly, the fact that the plaintiff tried to sue for four months' refund AND the fact that he kept parking there despite constant damage to his car lends a bit of a ring of truth to the defendant's claim that all of this was the plaintiff being upset over the increase in parking fees. Change their professions, and I bet she'd be up ther pontificating about how maybe he's just a lousy driver and how dare he come to court without evidence that the defendant was responsible for the damage.
If it were JMM's car....there would have been HELL to pay🤔
Why does he keep going there!? How doesn’t he have pictures!?
It’s sad they were hating on him because he was doing better than them 😢
It’s called envy, folks.
This judge is so biased. Love the doctor but really does the judge have to be so one sided
I’d give the plaintiff everything
Cardiologist woop..
I used to work for a parking company to record the damage we used to camera of 360 angle of the where you see the to back once you receive the customer car you literally point out the damage for the camera to see in front of the customer it takes literally 5 seconds on the keys they have tags where you mark the camera timeframe how many marks on car and what type of mark honestly the company parking vehicle don’t want to be responsible because the drivers are (not All) careless because it’s not their vehicle
What does it mean? Would that statement have been said to Harvey? Should not be driving in a Mazaradi. What if he can afford it! That situation could happen to anyone, even with a cheaper car. I didn't get it!
What a Horrible business owner. Hopefully people stop going there. Doubtful, it’s NYC.
HEYYYY MR CARDIOLOGIST!!!
Ahhh the little tidbit in the end is interesting
This is exactly what happens when you live for a Masarati we wouldn't be here if it was a Toyota Avalon
They jealous because he a African American in THEY don't think he deserves to have a luxury car he not mad about paying extra money they just hating on him