16:51 "home" for any ethnic Korean is not just South Korea. Sure not everyone is from the Changchun and Liaoning Provinces of China. But many ethnic Koreas have actually lived north of the Yalu and Tumen for centuries. Paektu Mountain is near the source off both rivers. The historical kingdoms of Goguryeo and Balhae which are both considered Korean have territory mostly in modern day Manchuria in China.
Actually almost every so-called ethnic Korean living in China is supposed to have an ancestor immigrating from the Peninsula in the late 19th century. That's why they're considered as the 3rd or 4th generations of immigrants. Although Goguryeo is regarded as part of Korean history, the descendants are totally sinicized after long-time living among Han Chinese. In my hometown, there're some villages which were established by Goguryeo people and the residents also regard themselves as descendants of Goguryeo, but they don't speak any Korean and have the same identity with Han Chinese. Speak of Balhae, which is also called Bohai in Mandarin, interestingly, Manchu people think it belongs to Manchuiran history but not Korean. Although many Goguryeo people contributed to the construction of Balhae, we can't deny that the majority and ruling group of the nation is Manchu but not Korean, which you could tell from the history records.
Most of Koreans living in NE China region pre-Qing dynasty had already been grouped as "Banner people", either Han banner or Manju banner by Qing emporers.
@@joyzhang9675 nay most of them came in late 1870s and later, mostly 1910-1940s. not really a long time ago. Manchus were the indiginous one, Han only in southern Liaoning , Koreans were immigrants. Most Manchuria before 1870s had few residents.
@@kyoumalee2675 ？？A small river like Yalu river can stop human being's immigration? Some Koreans had crossed the river during Ming dynasty and submitted to later Jin. They changed their identity and their name into tungus style and were viewed by others as manju. Some Koreans had be captived and remained some of their korean identity, like they perserved their surname and they were grouped as Korean Baoyi(包衣）(Baoyi means slaves in Manchu). Shujia concubine （淑嘉皇贵妃）of Qianlong is a Korean Baoyi with the surname"Kim". Both Koreans, assimilated or not, had been viewed as Manju now. Actually Manju today should be called Banner people, which includes original southern tungus manju , eastern mongol, korean, han and even russian immigrations. Pre-Ming dynasty that's another story. Kaema Highlands (north part of North Korea) were not part of Koryo Kimdom.
Beautiful story the food looks so delicious l like korean food is my favorite my kids to lm only eat seafood and begetables korean food is so delicious l love that ❤😊
I hope someday eat Soondae mmmm.... In my country Ecuador we have a similar dishe called "caldo de salchicha" or "rellena" thank you so much for this fabulous and incredible video, greeting from Ecuador
Hanja is still use in this place or mix script just not like in south korea they forget hanja for as they writing system like they forgeting they ancient history
Most young Korean Chinese no longer speaks Korean. They prefer speaking Chinese. Older generations are the only ones that speak Korean frequently now. Neither do USSR Koreans speak Korean anymore.
Dani Boy This is most. Not all. My gf is Kyrgyz Korean. And my teacher was Chinese Korean. Both say most ethnic Koreans prefer to not speak Korean. My best friend, Korean American, speaks Korean, but doesn't write, and only speak it, only if absolutely necessary. But like I said, a minority of my hyphenated Korean friends do speak Korean fluently and call themselves Korean over their nationality.
Those Koreans who live in the Yanbian Korean Autonomous Prefecture , do speak Korean. It's often the Koreans who have moved out of those areas who may not speak it. As for Korean Americans, most of them are first or second generation, so it makes sense that they can speak Korean well, but most do have a foreign sounding accent none the less, which is quite noticeable to Koreans in Korea. At least most Yanbian Koreans do speak Korean with an authentic accent similar to that of North Koreans.
It does not matter what language we speak. As long as it is not the language of hate and division. Most Chinese in Malaysia and Singapore speaks a few languages. Sometimes we call this Chinglish.
@3,29 I dont believe Chinese Officials prefer or like Korean Kimchi. The Korean style "KImchi" tastes so much different than the real one , The Chinese one. I really prefer the Chinese one, please try, you´ll see the awsome difference! ^^°^^
Ummm you should come to Yanbian yourself. Han people in our region orders soybean soup and kimchi on their own. It still kinda weird to see them actually eat Korean food daily.
Does Arirang realize that Korea was divided prior to the Korean War? The Korean War didn't cause the division, but was fought BECAUSE OF IT. America imposed a division on the Korean people soon after WWII.
@@hanj31 Technically and legally, you can make that argument. But it was Washington that proposed the idea to the Soviets and the Soviets passively agreed. The Soviets, however, underscored the need to allow the Korean people to exercise sovereignty ASAP while Washington wanted to prolong its "stewardship." Eventually, this "stewardship" led to opposing governments arising in the South and North, and the emergence of permanent division.
Many countries all around the world has been divided by the Western Allies @ Colonizer . They are the one that making chaos All Around The World with their Divide and Rule doctrine
The Korean they speak is almost same with the Chungcheong Dialect in SK because their ancesstors are from there. So, the Korean they speak is different from the Standard Korean in SK.
@James Wang no, free ____ comments most of the time are not from marginalized groups, but from people who know nothing about China and blindly believe in all anti-chinese rhetoric in western media. Nobody I've met that says free tibet are actual tibetens from tibet.
Kimchi is Chinese food, its made with Chinese cabbage!!! When I was a child I used to eat the Chinese style fernented cabbage, really delicious!❤️ Not the way korean people Copy!😠
How come you think Kimchi is Chinese food? Convince us correctly. If you are not dumb, most of us around the world already knows that KIMCHI IS ONE OF KOREAN UNIQUE FOOD that everyone loves and enjoy. First of all, 'Kimchi' named with our Korean language, not Chinese. If you say so, then explain us what 'Kimchi' means exactly, and who named it from beginning. And not only China, Korea also do have cabbage, duh. 🙄 And we are not copycat. Kimchi was already existed from long time ago in the past over several centuries in our KOREAN history. You guys just jealous of us, our culture, and try to make ours 'yours'. If you say we copycat, then u guys cultural thief. *You need to watch this video over and over again. Even people (who lives in China) in the video introducing Kimchi is Korean food. People in the video migrated from Korea to China or Russia due to war or because of Japan (forcefully sadly). Their family taught them how to make Korean food include Kimchi. This doesn't mean Kimchi is Chinese food because they lives in China??? During the war, they've just been taught how to cook kimchi from their parents whose originally from Korea so they know how to make kimchi and enjoy for themselves.
At the end of the day, they all share the same ancestor and let's not fight over preserved fermented vegetables. No one cares where noodles or tofu are coming from. We are all not living in the past. Let's build the North East China so every ethnicities can live long and prosperous life.
@@2urheart1Because, when kimchi is translated to Chinese, it refered 辣白菜，spicy Chinese cabbage. if you define kimchi as Korean style spicy cabbage, of course it is korean. But if you are saying all spicy cabbage are from Korea, then that is not true. Korean should start using Chinese characters like they used to, otherwise it will be very easy to be misunderstood each other.🫠🫠🫠🫠😉
That means Korea wasn't split into two but three. Yanbian Korea is actually North Korea, North Korea is actually Middle Korea and South Korea is.....? Well Just South Korea. But at least both S. Koreans and Yanbian Koreans can own a car than N. Koreans.
They are one of China's ethnic group, they are Chinese not Korean, also the language they use is one of the Chinese dialects, I believe it's a bit different than the Korean language used in Korea.
No, it's not a dialect of Chinese. They speak Mandarin and Korean. They speak Korean similar to that of North Koreans, which makes sense since most of their ancestors came from North Korea.
This comment.. LOL You also need to read my comment above somewhere or watch the video again. They are just explaining you why they are 'Korean Chinese'. LOL Sounds like u didn't focus or think whatever you want it to be. They are not (FULLY) Chinese just because they living in China. For example, oh then you think I'm American?? LOL I'm originally from S. Korea, but got U.S. citizenship few years ago. Then you think I'm American? I can be but this doesn't mean I'm not Korean just because I lives in the U.S., or have citizenship?? So we call it as 'Korean - American' kiddo. And Korean is definitely NOT even one of Chinese dialect. How come you think Korean language, Hangeul, is ONE OF Chinese language or dialect LOL Then for example, if one Chinese living in US. Then that Chinese language is English? LOL you are saying that now LOL And I cant really say but to me, they sometimes sounds like North Korean; Once again, because they lives in China, that doesnt mean they are NOT Korean.
@@2urheart1 This understanding is hard for non Chinese, China is less like a country, more of an old empire, kind of comparible to EU. Saying Chinese Koreans are Chinese is like saying French people are European. Mongolian Chinese, Tibetan Chinese, Manchurian Chinese, Han Chinese and Korean Chinese are all Chinese. Remember it’s 中国, the Middle Empire that have been ruled by everyone, not tied to a specific people or culture.
봉사하신분들 감사합니다 수고많았습니다.
16:51 "home" for any ethnic Korean is not just South Korea. Sure not everyone is from the Changchun and Liaoning Provinces of China. But many ethnic Koreas have actually lived north of the Yalu and Tumen for centuries. Paektu Mountain is near the source off both rivers. The historical kingdoms of Goguryeo and Balhae which are both considered Korean have territory mostly in modern day Manchuria in China.
Actually almost every so-called ethnic Korean living in China is supposed to have an ancestor immigrating from the Peninsula in the late 19th century. That's why they're considered as the 3rd or 4th generations of immigrants. Although Goguryeo is regarded as part of Korean history, the descendants are totally sinicized after long-time living among Han Chinese. In my hometown, there're some villages which were established by Goguryeo people and the residents also regard themselves as descendants of Goguryeo, but they don't speak any Korean and have the same identity with Han Chinese. Speak of Balhae, which is also called Bohai in Mandarin, interestingly, Manchu people think it belongs to Manchuiran history but not Korean. Although many Goguryeo people contributed to the construction of Balhae, we can't deny that the majority and ruling group of the nation is Manchu but not Korean, which you could tell from the history records.
Most of Koreans living in NE China region pre-Qing dynasty had already been grouped as "Banner people", either Han banner or Manju banner by Qing emporers.
@@joyzhang9675 nay most of them came in late 1870s and later, mostly 1910-1940s. not really a long time ago. Manchus were the indiginous one, Han only in southern Liaoning , Koreans were immigrants. Most Manchuria before 1870s had few residents.
@@kyoumalee2675 ？？A small river like Yalu river can stop human being's immigration?
Some Koreans had crossed the river during Ming dynasty and submitted to later Jin. They changed their identity and their name into tungus style and were viewed by others as manju. Some Koreans had be captived and remained some of their korean identity, like they perserved their surname and they were grouped as Korean Baoyi(包衣）(Baoyi means slaves in Manchu).
Shujia concubine （淑嘉皇贵妃）of Qianlong is a Korean Baoyi with the surname"Kim".
Both Koreans, assimilated or not, had been viewed as Manju now. Actually Manju today should be called Banner people, which includes original southern tungus manju , eastern mongol, korean, han and even russian immigrations.
Pre-Ming dynasty that's another story. Kaema Highlands (north part of North Korea) were not part of Koryo Kimdom.
Beautiful story the food looks so delicious l like korean food is my favorite my kids to lm only eat seafood and begetables korean food is so delicious l love that ❤😊
wonderful video. very touching
Very interesting video . For me the Korean food is healthy and delicious especially the "Kimchi"
For me too, I am Han Chinese in Shanghai. I always keep a kilo of Kimchi in my fridge, which I enjoy at every dinner.
@@首席绅士学院 泡菜并不健康，再早二十年，整个北方冬天只有白菜，吃到吐。
I hope someday eat Soondae mmmm.... In my country Ecuador we have a similar dishe called "caldo de salchicha" or "rellena" thank you so much for this fabulous and incredible video, greeting from Ecuador
I am also from Ecuador
섭씨 영하 20도는 화씨 영하 4도입니다. 정말 추워요!🥶
치킨이 맛있어 보이네요.😋
their sundae stuffing looks more flavourful than sk's lmao
There are more ingredients available within China. When it comes to natural resources like food, China is richer than South Korea
I love Korean food !
Nice food culture .
김치!🥰
Hanja is still use in this place or mix script just not like in south korea they forget hanja for as they writing system like they forgeting they ancient history
Most young Korean Chinese no longer speaks Korean. They prefer speaking Chinese. Older generations are the only ones that speak Korean frequently now. Neither do USSR Koreans speak Korean anymore.
No, we are still required to speak Korean at home tho!
Dani Boy This is most. Not all. My gf is Kyrgyz Korean. And my teacher was Chinese Korean. Both say most ethnic Koreans prefer to not speak Korean. My best friend, Korean American, speaks Korean, but doesn't write, and only speak it, only if absolutely necessary. But like I said, a minority of my hyphenated Korean friends do speak Korean fluently and call themselves Korean over their nationality.
Those Koreans who live in the Yanbian Korean Autonomous Prefecture
, do speak Korean. It's often the Koreans who have moved out of those areas who may not speak it. As for Korean Americans, most of them are first or second generation, so it makes sense that they can speak Korean well, but most do have a foreign sounding accent none the less, which is quite noticeable to Koreans in Korea. At least most Yanbian Koreans do speak Korean with an authentic accent similar to that of North Koreans.
It does not matter what language we speak. As long as it is not the language of hate and division. Most Chinese in Malaysia and Singapore speaks a few languages. Sometimes we call this Chinglish.
USSR is dead
@3,29 I dont believe Chinese Officials prefer or like Korean Kimchi. The Korean style "KImchi" tastes so much different than the real one , The Chinese one. I really prefer the Chinese one, please try, you´ll see the awsome difference! ^^°^^
Ummm you should come to Yanbian yourself. Han people in our region orders soybean soup and kimchi on their own. It still kinda weird to see them actually eat Korean food daily.
So sad....may they be happy wherever they are.
Does Arirang realize that Korea was divided prior to the Korean War? The Korean War didn't cause the division, but was fought BECAUSE OF IT. America imposed a division on the Korean people soon after WWII.
America and the Soviet Union
@@hanj31 Technically and legally, you can make that argument. But it was Washington that proposed the idea to the Soviets and the Soviets passively agreed. The Soviets, however, underscored the need to allow the Korean people to exercise sovereignty ASAP while Washington wanted to prolong its "stewardship." Eventually, this "stewardship" led to opposing governments arising in the South and North, and the emergence of permanent division.
Yes it was just because of Korea's strategic geographic location. A tragedy imposed by foreign powers.
It was USA that disbanded the Koreans' true Democratic Party of Korea before Korea Divide.
Many countries all around the world has been divided by the Western Allies @ Colonizer . They are the one that making chaos All Around The World with their Divide and Rule doctrine
Where is the video of this year
The question is: are they north koreans or south koreans ?
Thank you.
They're all Koreans.
🤔
Isn't Cuisine only one part of a nation's culture?
7:00 couldnt they just build a boat or something?
yea and risk getting shot by north korean guards.... probably not a good idea
I wonder if the language these people speak sounds Korean to South Koreans today
They have a different accent compared to us in SK but it's no problem to understand them.
ɈѦ$ѲИ ϺⓞƝƐȲ thanks
The Korean they speak is almost same with the Chungcheong Dialect in SK because their ancesstors are from there. So, the Korean they speak is different from the Standard Korean in SK.
Their Korean is similar to the Korean spoken in North Korea. It's still understandable to a South Korean.
waiting for "Free Yanbian" comment
@James Wang no, free ____ comments most of the time are not from marginalized groups, but from people who know nothing about China and blindly believe in all anti-chinese rhetoric in western media. Nobody I've met that says free tibet are actual tibetens from tibet.
Free Inner Mongolia!!!
@光宗耀祖啊 You’re typical damn Chinese who doesn’t give sh** about other people’s culture and language.
exticntion for mongolians@@turuus5215
Thank you. Yanbian will definitely regain its independence, break away from the Communist Party of China, and return to Repubulic of Korea
Kimchi is Chinese food, its made with Chinese cabbage!!! When I was a child I used to eat the Chinese style fernented cabbage, really delicious!❤️
Not the way korean people Copy!😠
Every country has fermented veggies. We also have fermented cabbage. But not similar style to kimchi. Kimchi is unique to Korean peninsula
How come you think Kimchi is Chinese food? Convince us correctly.
If you are not dumb, most of us around the world already knows that KIMCHI IS ONE OF KOREAN UNIQUE FOOD that everyone loves and enjoy.
First of all, 'Kimchi' named with our Korean language, not Chinese.
If you say so, then explain us what 'Kimchi' means exactly, and who named it from beginning.
And not only China, Korea also do have cabbage, duh. 🙄
And we are not copycat.
Kimchi was already existed from long time ago in the past over several centuries in our KOREAN history.
You guys just jealous of us, our culture, and try to make ours 'yours'.
If you say we copycat, then u guys cultural thief.
*You need to watch this video over and over again.
Even people (who lives in China) in the video introducing Kimchi is Korean food.
People in the video migrated from Korea to China or Russia due to war or because of Japan (forcefully sadly).
Their family taught them how to make Korean food include Kimchi.
This doesn't mean Kimchi is Chinese food because they lives in China???
During the war, they've just been taught how to cook kimchi from their parents whose originally from Korea so they know how to make kimchi and enjoy for themselves.
You can look at his/her account ; he or she is neither of Han ethnicity nor of another Mainland Chinese ethnicity !
You don't recognize the trolls ?
At the end of the day, they all share the same ancestor and let's not fight over preserved fermented vegetables. No one cares where noodles or tofu are coming from. We are all not living in the past. Let's build the North East China so every ethnicities can live long and prosperous life.
@@2urheart1Because, when kimchi is translated to Chinese, it refered 辣白菜，spicy Chinese cabbage. if you define kimchi as Korean style spicy cabbage, of course it is korean. But if you are saying all spicy cabbage are from Korea, then that is not true.
Korean should start using Chinese characters like they used to, otherwise it will be very easy to be misunderstood each other.🫠🫠🫠🫠😉
That means Korea wasn't split into two but three. Yanbian Korea is actually North Korea, North Korea is actually Middle Korea and South Korea is.....? Well Just South Korea. But at least both S. Koreans and Yanbian Koreans can own a car than N. Koreans.
@zhang Zhusui But it was populated by Koreans
E
They are one of China's ethnic group, they are Chinese not Korean, also the language they use is one of the Chinese dialects, I believe it's a bit different than the Korean language used in Korea.
No, it's not a dialect of Chinese. They speak Mandarin and Korean. They speak Korean similar to that of North Koreans, which makes sense since most of their ancestors came from North Korea.
How uneducated
This comment.. LOL
You also need to read my comment above somewhere or watch the video again.
They are just explaining you why they are 'Korean Chinese'. LOL
Sounds like u didn't focus or think whatever you want it to be.
They are not (FULLY) Chinese just because they living in China.
For example, oh then you think I'm American?? LOL
I'm originally from S. Korea, but got U.S. citizenship few years ago.
Then you think I'm American?
I can be but this doesn't mean I'm not Korean just because I lives in the U.S., or have citizenship??
So we call it as 'Korean - American' kiddo.
And Korean is definitely NOT even one of Chinese dialect.
How come you think Korean language, Hangeul, is ONE OF Chinese language or dialect LOL
Then for example, if one Chinese living in US. Then that Chinese language is English? LOL you are saying that now LOL
And I cant really say but to me, they sometimes sounds like North Korean;
Once again, because they lives in China, that doesnt mean they are NOT Korean.
@@2urheart1 This understanding is hard for non Chinese, China is less like a country, more of an old empire, kind of comparible to EU. Saying Chinese Koreans are Chinese is like saying French people are European. Mongolian Chinese, Tibetan Chinese, Manchurian Chinese, Han Chinese and Korean Chinese are all Chinese. Remember it’s 中国, the Middle Empire that have been ruled by everyone, not tied to a specific people or culture.
@@2urheart1 LOL : Laugh Of Loud