Sorry but : in Nami, Kata and Gyaku Jime, you have to bring BOTH your elbows to your chest and lower your head. By opening the elbows the way you do, your in for immediate counters in a live situation. In Kataha Jime, your right hand's goal is to try to go as deep as possible under your left elbow and not above (still a matter of counters, it is easier to remove your right hand if it is above instead of under and by going under, the choke will be way more efficient). You should also turn more to your left, Uke must be put out of balance otherwise you open yourself to counters too. NEVER pull on your toes in Sankaku Jime, it's the best way to get broken toes or worst, a broken ankle in a live situation ! Pull on the lower part of your shin if you have to. Just my two cents ;)
Thank you for sharing your two cents. You have made some interesting points. to start with, lets separate a demonstration of how to do a technique from a demonstration of how to apply a technique. The first being for initial learning and grading purposes (and the purpose of these videos) and the latter being for randori/competition purposes (not the purpose of this video). I disagree with your comment regarding the elbows, if you read the Kodokan Judo book, the description talks about bringing your elbows to the tatami, so actually, in this demonstration you could argue that my elbows are not wide enough. I agree with the comment about bringing my head down, which I do...as my uke taps at the point I reached, I did not need to bring it down further (maximum efficiency). For Kataha Jime, if you read the Kodokan Judo book, the description outlines how you place your hand at the back of your uke's neck and does not mention going as deep as possible behind the elbow on your other hand. If you do not have access to the Kodokan Judo book, you can see how these techniques are demonstrated on their TH-cam channel. To an extent I understand the point you are making with Sankaku, you are correct, if possible, take hold of your shin of course, but this potentially is not possible depending on a persons flexibility and the size of their limbs and the size of their uke plays into it...I did not and have not broken my toes by doing this (anecdotal evidence is a low form of evidence I know, but I am assuming you are also using this form of evidence to structure your opinion...if you have any studies exploring this I would be very interested to read them and happy to wrong if there is empirical evidence showing broken toes rates in Sankaku). As I state at the beginning of the reply, these videos show how to do the technique not how to apply...these can be very different looking versions of the same technique, however, you use the points you learn in "how to" when looking at "how to apply"...first learn how to do a technique, then learn how to apply. Again, thank you for taking the time to share your thoughts...it is very much appreciated.
@@TheJudoWayofLifePlenty of Kodokan videos out there. Video is always better than a book. You should go have a look at them and make the adjustments according to them. You'll see my comments are perfectly legit. Cheers...
@@danle3181 it's a shame that after 7 months, the best you can come up with is plagiarising my advice to you. Thank you for taking the time to reply...however, I still stand by what I said.
amazing video gentleman! hello from Canada.
Thank you. Where in Canada are you? I've been out to Montreal and Saskatoon for training/coaching. Both where great fun.
I used too lived and practice judo inAbbotsford ,BC. Right now I practice judo in Ottawa. @@TheJudoWayofLife
Great techenics ❤
Sorry but : in Nami, Kata and Gyaku Jime, you have to bring BOTH your elbows to your chest and lower your head. By opening the elbows the way you do, your in for immediate counters in a live situation. In Kataha Jime, your right hand's goal is to try to go as deep as possible under your left elbow and not above (still a matter of counters, it is easier to remove your right hand if it is above instead of under and by going under, the choke will be way more efficient). You should also turn more to your left, Uke must be put out of balance otherwise you open yourself to counters too. NEVER pull on your toes in Sankaku Jime, it's the best way to get broken toes or worst, a broken ankle in a live situation ! Pull on the lower part of your shin if you have to. Just my two cents ;)
Thank you for sharing your two cents. You have made some interesting points. to start with, lets separate a demonstration of how to do a technique from a demonstration of how to apply a technique. The first being for initial learning and grading purposes (and the purpose of these videos) and the latter being for randori/competition purposes (not the purpose of this video).
I disagree with your comment regarding the elbows, if you read the Kodokan Judo book, the description talks about bringing your elbows to the tatami, so actually, in this demonstration you could argue that my elbows are not wide enough. I agree with the comment about bringing my head down, which I do...as my uke taps at the point I reached, I did not need to bring it down further (maximum efficiency).
For Kataha Jime, if you read the Kodokan Judo book, the description outlines how you place your hand at the back of your uke's neck and does not mention going as deep as possible behind the elbow on your other hand.
If you do not have access to the Kodokan Judo book, you can see how these techniques are demonstrated on their TH-cam channel.
To an extent I understand the point you are making with Sankaku, you are correct, if possible, take hold of your shin of course, but this potentially is not possible depending on a persons flexibility and the size of their limbs and the size of their uke plays into it...I did not and have not broken my toes by doing this (anecdotal evidence is a low form of evidence I know, but I am assuming you are also using this form of evidence to structure your opinion...if you have any studies exploring this I would be very interested to read them and happy to wrong if there is empirical evidence showing broken toes rates in Sankaku).
As I state at the beginning of the reply, these videos show how to do the technique not how to apply...these can be very different looking versions of the same technique, however, you use the points you learn in "how to" when looking at "how to apply"...first learn how to do a technique, then learn how to apply.
Again, thank you for taking the time to share your thoughts...it is very much appreciated.
@@TheJudoWayofLife th-cam.com/video/bq3cwrcS1-c/w-d-xo.html
@@TheJudoWayofLifePlenty of Kodokan videos out there. Video is always better than a book. You should go have a look at them and make the adjustments according to them. You'll see my comments are perfectly legit. Cheers...
@@danle3181 it's a shame that after 7 months, the best you can come up with is plagiarising my advice to you. Thank you for taking the time to reply...however, I still stand by what I said.
Excelente una vez más.
👍
Buenas tecnicas
Fantastic
Regards from India 🕉️
Thank you and welcome to the channel.