I’m so glad I found someone who had the same problem with the original concealer. If I didn’t immediately blend it it would dry soooo fast and I couldn’t blend it out.
@@larissahonda3053 i accidentally got the matte one without even knowing there was a different one (hydrating one) until after and it’s bad like dries fast so i ordered the hydrating one today. hope it works better
the hydrating is a life saver for my dry under eyes . i can even build on the dark spot, i dont have to set it and it doesnt crease!! total game changer!
The other day I was about to buy one of those but then saw there were two different ones (hydrating v matte) and didn’t end up buying it bc I wanted to see first if I could see someone comparing it. Long story short: you read my mind! You’re honestly my favorite TH-camr, I love your content too! 😁 love from Texas!💕
I have medium sand in the original and bought light beige in the hydrating and they match really good! It drives me crazy they’re not the same shades 🤦🏽♀️
Interesting, bc i found hydrating light beige to be MUCH whiter than medium sand from the OG matte. Medium sand (matte)is my skin color but brighter, whereas the light beige (hydrating) makes me look goofy ghosty everytime i wear it if i dont add a ton of bronzer 😅
I just made this mistake :( got light sand in camo and it's perfect figured the same shade in hydrating would work....ugh....nope....too dark, so I'll be returning it for a lighter shade
@@bitsofpolish hey! Did you find any shade in hydrating variant that exactly matches the matte light sand(the original one). I was using the original one in light sand, it exactly matched me, but the hydrating one in light sand settled darker on my skin, i'm unable to find the exact shade in hydrating one now. Will be happy if you help me finding the shade! Ty.
@@tahreembutt5952 I managed to find a close match by checking my original shade in store with the hydrating one beside it...however, I do feel that the current hydrating shade I have is a bit pale in me 😔
The elf website has a chart that compares the 2 and says the original dries darker and new one does not but both end up being the same colors. I have tried and is true.
I think you should try a shade lighter for the new concealer. I feel like that might have an effect on the coverage. It doesn't seem fair them being two different shades. Who knows, maybe I'm wrong
So glad I came across your video Emily! For the past few weeks I've been in search of the perfect concealer for me. I've tried the original 16hr Elf concealer. At first, I loved it but by the afternoon, I began to see creases and fine lines. I'm 43 so def don't need those...lol! I didn't appreciate that I had to work very quickly due to quick drying time. I just bought the new hydrating formula yesterday and will be trying it today. Loved that you showed what it actually looks like without foundation. I don't wear foundation. Instead, I use blushes that I can blend throughout. Thank you so much for the review as it was very helpful. Will def be watching your videos!
I think elf purposely made the original lighter because it's formulated for oily skin which oxides and make the color darker so it's supposed to end up matching the hydrating one. But wow what a color difference!
What bb cream shade you used ? And the elf one is medium peach the hydrating one does it get darker after few hours I mean concealer elf ? Thanks ! And webiste did you buy the bb many thx
Yeah I saw a new display of concealers so I took my shade in the matte and held it against that shade in the hydrating version and could immediately tell a difference! I'm med sand in matte and I have to get light peach or light beige to be similar. The mediums in the hydrating formula are like the tan or darks in the matte! They should have made a statement on the website to recommend going up a few shades... But over all I love it
I’m been binge watching all of these types of videos and I’m glad someone finally did some type of makeup look with them ty I’m getting light sand in the hydrating but hopefully not to dark :)
I’m not sure if im using it wrong I have both and when I put them on it gets real cakey looking:/. I’m kind of new to concealer so I tried a little dot of the concealer but it still looked real cakey! I put primer under my eyes and blend them out but I can’t get it to look flawless:/
Although the original one is problematic in blending that I have to blend quick I still love this. Because the coverage is phenomenal. What I do with it is the less is more theory. I have a bit lined underneath but my skin is a bit oily as well so hydrating one would only make my makeup slide away.
I have the same issue but I don’t want to waste the product so I use the maybelline age rewind concealer (shade neutralizer) as a base…works well and I’m not wasting either product.
The shades are driving me crazy and I’m not even the one using them! I completely understand the frustration. I have super oily skin and like the original camo concealer, apart from the insanely fast drying time. Do you think you could film an update on the hydrating concealer? Maybe just sharing how it wore in your oily t-zone? Thanks for sharing such great content, you’re one of my FAV TH-camrs 💛
Hi I have dry skin (not super dry, a little dryer than normal) and I tend to get a tiny bit oily at the very end of the day do you think the regular would be okay if I moisturized well and used a hydrating primer?
I’ve got fair/light skin and wear the original in medium peach, which always made me laugh. I wonder if they kind of corrected that inconsistency which is why the shades don’t match between the two formulas.
Same! Medium peach is my perfect shade in the original concealer and I bought that color in the hydrating but way too dark. Now I’m not sure which shade I should get
Same. Very fair and medium peach was my best match in the original, which makes me laugh. I've never been medium in anything! If anyone knows a good match in the new one, please let us know!
I am really excited to try the hydrating one. It looks glowy and so pretty. I think the matte side looks great too. How is that real techniques powder blending sponge? Almost bought it the other day but didn't. Thanks! Oh and wow that BB cream looks so freaking pretty.
Emily Freybler so u think it’s worth getting that sponge just for powder instead of using just the normal real techniques sponge? And do u use the powder one wet or dry?
Yes I believe it is worth it. It applies so smoothly and doesn’t make your powder as wet as the original sponge does. I dampen it just like I would a regular sponge!
Hi Emily, I’m almost a year late in finding your video, we haven’t had the product in UK very long but I found the coverage is great but what is going on with the shades and their names?!? I bought my usual shade AND fortunately got a fairer shade too but how annoying! Great demo. Look forward to seeing more of your TH-cam videos x
Omg this helped sooo MUCH, I bought the original and didn’t realize it dries fast so I was trying to blend it out and it was so HARD, but omg thanks so much for this vid girlie 🤗💕
hey girl think your description is wrong, you said "this is supposed to be a more hydrating formula for normal to oily skin" i dunno if you were supposed to put dry as the new hydrating concealer is for normal/dry skin types as ELF had complaints about the matte one being too dry on dry skin types. There is a comparing on their website and it says the matte camo concealer is for normal/oily skin types and the hydrating one is for normal/dry skin types:)
i thought it was just my skin because i always had such a hard time blending w the original one and it would be all dry but ima try to be more faster now
From 7:16 to 10:06 you say "right off the bat" 6 different times. LOL It started happening so often that I had to go back and count! Anyways, great comparison and I'm amazed you managed to make them look pretty much the same with only a BB Cream!
I like the Elf cosmetics so I may try this concealer Iam also looking for a new primer and foundation that's why I love your videos on drug store cosmetics I trust your opinion on the product ! Thanks 💐
Call me cynical, but I'm guessing ELF mismatches the shade names so people will end up buying more units. They sell such inexpensive products that marketing has to be... *creative* to make up for lost revenue (compared to other companies).
I remember buying the original and i bought light peach and i was like ummm this is super light! Then i bought medium peach and was like um ok this is like still very light! I feel like the hydrating shades seem a little more on target
My local Walmart needs to pick up the pace with restocking the fair skinned colors.. I can find a contour shade but all the fair shades are snatched up. Guess I can always order online I’m so. Bad at matching over the internet Thanks for the vid ! Need a elf cc cream vid
Soon as you said “medium sand” I got scared because well I’m a black light skinned woman and you’re white lol then you put it to the camera and I guess I’m safe because it’s darker 😂
Ugh! I ordered mine from Ulta online n got the same shade I have in the original! The same concealer (even if different formulas) from the same brand should b the same shades!!! N if they are NOT the same shades then they definitely should NOT have the same names!!! 🤦♀️😡🤬
Emily Freybler it really is!!! Why couldn’t they of just named them different!! Then it would still b a little annoying having different shades since they are the same brand n even from kind of the same line (camo concealers) but since they’re different formulas. But understandable cuz they’re different formulas n the shade names are different. But making the same exact shade names implies they will b the same as the original!! 🤦♀️
I’m so glad I found someone who had the same problem with the original concealer. If I didn’t immediately blend it it would dry soooo fast and I couldn’t blend it out.
Definitely!!
it gets flacky for me :(
OHH SAME!!
it happens to me as well, havent been able to make it work :(
my skin looks so dry when i use it its bad, even with a powerful moisturizer
@@larissahonda3053 i accidentally got the matte one without even knowing there was a different one (hydrating one) until after and it’s bad like dries fast so i ordered the hydrating one today. hope it works better
the hydrating is a life saver for my dry under eyes . i can even build on the dark spot, i dont have to set it and it doesnt crease!! total game changer!
That's so awesome!!
I have nars radiant cream concealer and it creases on me. Do you know if this one is better for not creasing? Thank you
@@sorayabranco the hydrating one is better than nars,for me with fine lines
The other day I was about to buy one of those but then saw there were two different ones (hydrating v matte) and didn’t end up buying it bc I wanted to see first if I could see someone comparing it. Long story short: you read my mind! You’re honestly my favorite TH-camr, I love your content too! 😁 love from Texas!💕
Aww I'm so glad!! Thank you so so much! :) I hope this helped clarify!
I’m glad the shades changed because I wasn’t able to find a shade match in the regular version. Plus I didn’t like the formula of the original.
Yes I am glad they changed as well because I thought they didn't make sense before. I just think they should make up different shade names.
I have medium sand in the original and bought light beige in the hydrating and they match really good! It drives me crazy they’re not the same shades 🤦🏽♀️
Interesting, bc i found hydrating light beige to be MUCH whiter than medium sand from the OG matte. Medium sand (matte)is my skin color but brighter, whereas the light beige (hydrating) makes me look goofy ghosty everytime i wear it if i dont add a ton of bronzer 😅
I just made this mistake :( got light sand in camo and it's perfect figured the same shade in hydrating would work....ugh....nope....too dark, so I'll be returning it for a lighter shade
@@bitsofpolish hey! Did you find any shade in hydrating variant that exactly matches the matte light sand(the original one). I was using the original one in light sand, it exactly matched me, but the hydrating one in light sand settled darker on my skin, i'm unable to find the exact shade in hydrating one now. Will be happy if you help me finding the shade! Ty.
@@tahreembutt5952 I managed to find a close match by checking my original shade in store with the hydrating one beside it...however, I do feel that the current hydrating shade I have is a bit pale in me 😔
@@bitsofpolish ooh! Okay, tysm
The elf website has a chart that compares the 2 and says the original dries darker and new one does not but both end up being the same colors. I have tried and is true.
Yes I know the one dries darker and such but I still don’t like that I got the same shade name in both and they are different colors
I think you should try a shade lighter for the new concealer. I feel like that might have an effect on the coverage. It doesn't seem fair them being two different shades. Who knows, maybe I'm wrong
I definitely agree. Like I said in the video, I thought it was the same color as the original, but it was darker.
So glad I came across your video Emily! For the past few weeks I've been in search of the perfect concealer for me. I've tried the original 16hr Elf concealer. At first, I loved it but by the afternoon, I began to see creases and fine lines. I'm 43 so def don't need those...lol! I didn't appreciate that I had to work very quickly due to quick drying time. I just bought the new hydrating formula yesterday and will be trying it today. Loved that you showed what it actually looks like without foundation. I don't wear foundation. Instead, I use blushes that I can blend throughout. Thank you so much for the review as it was very helpful. Will def be watching your videos!
Did you end up liking the hydrating one?
I think elf purposely made the original lighter because it's formulated for oily skin which oxides and make the color darker so it's supposed to end up matching the hydrating one. But wow what a color difference!
What bb cream shade you used ? And the elf one is medium peach the hydrating one does it get darker after few hours I mean concealer elf ? Thanks ! And webiste did you buy the bb many thx
Yeah I saw a new display of concealers so I took my shade in the matte and held it against that shade in the hydrating version and could immediately tell a difference! I'm med sand in matte and I have to get light peach or light beige to be similar. The mediums in the hydrating formula are like the tan or darks in the matte! They should have made a statement on the website to recommend going up a few shades... But over all I love it
Yes thank you!!!!
I’m been binge watching all of these types of videos and I’m glad someone finally did some type of makeup look with them ty I’m getting light sand in the hydrating but hopefully not to dark :)
I think they changed the color because the new one is more accurate with the name. The original is too light to be called sand Shade :)
I’m not sure if im using it wrong I have both and when I put them on it gets real cakey looking:/. I’m kind of new to concealer so I tried a little dot of the concealer but it still looked real cakey! I put primer under my eyes and blend them out but I can’t get it to look flawless:/
Although the original one is problematic in blending that I have to blend quick I still love this. Because the coverage is phenomenal. What I do with it is the less is more theory. I have a bit lined underneath but my skin is a bit oily as well so hydrating one would only make my makeup slide away.
I have the same issue but I don’t want to waste the product so I use the maybelline age rewind concealer (shade neutralizer) as a base…works well and I’m not wasting either product.
Should I get one ?!
The shades are driving me crazy and I’m not even the one using them! I completely understand the frustration. I have super oily skin and like the original camo concealer, apart from the insanely fast drying time. Do you think you could film an update on the hydrating concealer? Maybe just sharing how it wore in your oily t-zone? Thanks for sharing such great content, you’re one of my FAV TH-camrs 💛
Ugh the shades are crazy! I can try to do an update sometime! I will probably share quicker on Instagram stories!
Emily Freybler thank you!
Would you say that the claim about the hydrating concealer is true, it dries to color in bottle?
Yes! Definitely!
so do you think the original camo dries darker than the bottle colour? should i go up a shade?
No definitely doesn't dry darker. It just is darker out of the bottle. I would go a shade lighter.
What shade is she using in both? I didn’t catch her saying. And which shade would be most likely need, I can’t figure out what I need
medium sand
Hi I have dry skin (not super dry, a little dryer than normal) and I tend to get a tiny bit oily at the very end of the day do you think the regular would be okay if I moisturized well and used a hydrating primer?
Yes I think it should be okay.
@@EmilyFreybler thank you!
It looks like the matte one has more coverage, you should try mixing the two!
Yes I will definitely try that!
What shade is it ?!
The hydrating one creases and makes my eye wrinkles deepen..I’m 17. I’m new to makeup so I was wondering if I put powder on top will it stop creasing.
Yes putting powder on top to set the concealer will definitely help!
it will
Definitely picking up the hydrating concealer!! Thanks for filming this review, Emily!! xoxo
You're so welcome! Hope you love it!
@@EmilyFreybler Thank you lovely!
What shade of lipstick are you wearing in this video?
I’ve got fair/light skin and wear the original in medium peach, which always made me laugh. I wonder if they kind of corrected that inconsistency which is why the shades don’t match between the two formulas.
Yes I'm sure that's why but it is still so annoying they had the same names as the original if they did that.
Same! Medium peach is my perfect shade in the original concealer and I bought that color in the hydrating but way too dark. Now I’m not sure which shade I should get
Same. Very fair and medium peach was my best match in the original, which makes me laugh. I've never been medium in anything! If anyone knows a good match in the new one, please let us know!
hbarlaam I found light ivory to be a perfect match
Your eyelashes are so pretty😍 what mascara do you use??
You’re so real and honest on your reviews which is why you’re the only youtuber I trust lol
Thank you so so much!! 😍
Mariah Delorme Go check out brittany nichole. You might change your mind
what do you have on your lips in beginning of the video it looks bomb af
I am really excited to try the hydrating one. It looks glowy and so pretty. I think the matte side looks great too. How is that real techniques powder blending sponge? Almost bought it the other day but didn't. Thanks! Oh and wow that BB cream looks so freaking pretty.
The best sponge ever!! I am in love with it! Applies much better than a traditional sponge does.
@@EmilyFreybler I'll be picking it up right away :) Thanks for replying back. 💜
Emily Freybler so u think it’s worth getting that sponge just for powder instead of using just the normal real techniques sponge? And do u use the powder one wet or dry?
Yes I believe it is worth it. It applies so smoothly and doesn’t make your powder as wet as the original sponge does. I dampen it just like I would a regular sponge!
@@onewhisper22005 I bet it is because it's made for powder. When I was checking it out it felt like a nice sponge.
Keen to try this one as i have more dry skin!
so worth it. i actually look my age now with concealer
My tzone and acne is dry which one would you recommend for me? :)
I just tried the 16h camo concealer and like it, now I really want to try the hydrating concealer to see if I’ll love it .
I think you will!
I love this! Can you tell me how you applied your BB Cream? Brush or sponge? I want to try without moving the concealer :)
Either one should work. :)
Hi! What mascara did you use? It’s so pretty!!
She used essence lash princess
Oriani Luna thank you
What shade did she use i aint got 14minutes to sit and listen to this
Hi Emily, I’m almost a year late in finding your video, we haven’t had the product in UK very long but I found the coverage is great but what is going on with the shades and their names?!? I bought my usual shade AND fortunately got a fairer shade too but how annoying! Great demo. Look forward to seeing more of your TH-cam videos x
Great video, & so glad to know I'll have to adjust my shade!!
Thank you! Yes definitely go lighter than before!
Litterly bought this today before watching the video and I'm scared that they are gonna be different colors
Omg this helped sooo MUCH, I bought the original and didn’t realize it dries fast so I was trying to blend it out and it was so HARD, but omg thanks so much for this vid girlie 🤗💕
Thank you for the review! What’s your lip color??
My favorite! rstyle.me/+AYo0sF-CLLd0o81R1mO68w
@@EmilyFreybler what was the lip color?? really love it but the link isn’t working for me😭😭
@@EmilyFreybler this link doesn't open...could you please write the lip product name?
Elf sent me a sample of this same product in the same shade
I need help finding my shade in my concealer ? What shade are you
"right off the bat" must be your favorite phrase, You said it at least 5 times.
I was wondering if anyone else noticed lol
@@rachelsrandoms1670 Me too. I scanned the comments before posting, but didn't see anyone mention it.. I was shocked. LOL
Lol sorry!!
@@EmilyFreybler No worries, girl! It was just an observation.. I hope you didn't think I was taking a stab at you.. I wasn't. ;) thanks for the video!
🤔 it looks like the colours are the same after you powdered it... Is that just me?
You're so pretty! I just got that concealer today, and I can see I got the wrong shade, but I'll try to make it work.
Loved your review! I'm going for the hydrating one since I do only want to use it for under my eyes.
Hope you like it!
hey girl think your description is wrong, you said "this is supposed to be a more hydrating formula for normal to oily skin" i dunno if you were supposed to put dry as the new hydrating concealer is for normal/dry skin types as ELF had complaints about the matte one being too dry on dry skin types. There is a comparing on their website and it says the matte camo concealer is for normal/oily skin types and the hydrating one is for normal/dry skin types:)
Yes I definitely messed that up. Sorry!
i thought it was just my skin because i always had such a hard time blending w the original one and it would be all dry but ima try to be more faster now
From 7:16 to 10:06 you say "right off the bat" 6 different times. LOL It started happening so often that I had to go back and count!
Anyways, great comparison and I'm amazed you managed to make them look pretty much the same with only a BB Cream!
What bronzer do you reccomend now since you can't use the Physicians formula?
I love this one! It’s a different shade but it is still beautiful! rstyle.me/cz-n/dqpgwtcfbip
Thanks for the review. What's the purple brush you use for concealer?
Real technics concealer brush
They did you dirty with those shades. I watched this after I bought the concealer, hopefully it’ll match me!! Thanx for the review!!!
Was your blending sponge wet or dry for this application?
Wet! I always use a wet sponge
I thought I grabbed CC cream but I grabbed 16 hour Camo Concealer and it SUCKS. It doesn’t blend and my combo skin made it flaky 😭
7:22 I thought my phone died or the power went out! 😅🤣😂💀😭
When I tried this concealer it literally dries up on my face so fast and then doesn’t blend after. It’s very dry, for me at least
At 7:26, the screen flashes black for a second... is this a glitch? Lol
I think I made a mistake in editing. Sorry!
I recommend. Changed my skin look!
What's her shade ?
I love the old elf
You’re so pretty!! What mascara are you wearing?? :)
Essence lash princess!
Emily Freybler which color of that mascara ?
I like the Elf cosmetics so I may try this concealer Iam also looking for a new primer and foundation that's why I love your videos on drug store cosmetics I trust your opinion on the product ! Thanks 💐
Elf products are great!
What's satin? N is it good for dry skin?
Satin is kind of a mix between matte and dewy. It's right in between. I would say it would work for dry skin for sure!
@@EmilyFreybler thank you!
Call me cynical, but I'm guessing ELF mismatches the shade names so people will end up buying more units. They sell such inexpensive products that marketing has to be... *creative* to make up for lost revenue (compared to other companies).
Yesss I got both light ivory and the original one is lighter!
I Don't find it full coverage
I remember buying the original and i bought light peach and i was like ummm this is super light! Then i bought medium peach and was like um ok this is like still very light! I feel like the hydrating shades seem a little more on target
My local Walmart needs to pick up the pace with restocking the fair skinned colors.. I can find a contour shade but all the fair shades are snatched up. Guess I can always order online I’m so. Bad at matching over the internet Thanks for the vid ! Need a elf cc cream vid
Soon as you said “medium sand” I got scared because well I’m a black light skinned woman and you’re white lol then you put it to the camera and I guess I’m safe because it’s darker 😂
ceo of: right of the bat
Oh how I wish they sold the hydrating concealer here
You can mix both :)
it makes no sense to me why they are different colours but the same name.
Did one concealer crease more?
I don't believe so!
I despised the old one!!!! It was so dry and hard to blend 🤢
The old formula does look like it covers more but I do have to say you are too young to use that much under eye concealer
What lip color?
Here's the link! rstyle.me/+AYo0sF-CLLd0o81R1mO68w
This link does not seem to work anymore.. does anyone know what the lipcolor was? Thanks!
Ugh! I ordered mine from Ulta online n got the same shade I have in the original! The same concealer (even if different formulas) from the same brand should b the same shades!!! N if they are NOT the same shades then they definitely should NOT have the same names!!! 🤦♀️😡🤬
I know! So annoying!!
Emily Freybler it really is!!! Why couldn’t they of just named them different!! Then it would still b a little annoying having different shades since they are the same brand n even from kind of the same line (camo concealers) but since they’re different formulas. But understandable cuz they’re different formulas n the shade names are different. But making the same exact shade names implies they will b the same as the original!! 🤦♀️
Thanks for the review lol you are outraged about the color difference.. take notes E.L.F!
You're welcome! Lol yes it was very upsetting.
The hydrated version makes my under eyes dry 😔
Lip 💄 ?
say mature please
Sorry about that!
I'm confused...I thought they label products with the word "anti-aging."
@@EmilyFreybler no problem hun, thanks for review
🙄
@@trishamurphy3357 lol