F. Schubert - Sonata D 821 "Arpeggione" - Martha Argerich - Mischa Maisky
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 พ.ค. 2021
- Franz Schubert - Sonata per violoncello e pianoforteD 821 "Arpeggione" - Martha Argerich - Mischa Maisky - Milano 2016
0:29 I. Allegro moderato
12:58 II. Adagio
17:22 III. Allegretto - เพลง
![Schubert : Arpeggione Sonata A minor D.821 [ Mischa Maisky & Daria Hovora 971116 ]](/img/n.gif)
World's best musical duo.
La pianista Martha Argerich è eccezionale bravissima!
Li trovo incantevoli. Grande musicalità degli artisti e grande musica di Schubert, del rubato..... non mi curo
Recensione perfetta.
Bravissimi e Bellissima questa Sonata un CAPOLAVORO del Grande Schubert il Maestro delle melodie malinconiche... Schubert uno dei miei compositori preferiti del romanticismo!!!
I am a cellist and I can appreciate every single second of this!
This is absolutely amazing
Edge of my seat playing and I was only listening. Thanks for the posting.
È una bellissima sonata e questi interpreti sono favolosi. Singolare è il fatto che questa è una delle pochissime sonate scritte per Arpeggione, un strumento a 6 corde tastato che assomiglia a un po' al Violoncello, un po' alla Viola da Gamba ed un po' alla Chitarra che condivide l'accordarura ma, come il violoncello, si suona con l'archetto; ebbe una vita molto breve.
esattamente 🙂
Chello dense et puissant.... Délicat et confortable au piano.... Ce sont les contrastes élevés qui créent cette atmosphère qui frise tous les cheveux de ma crinière.... ❤😂
einfach furios, grandios, gefühlvoll, voller geheimnis, jugendlicher verspieltheit, und eine schier grenzenlose, vorausahnende altersweißheit. das geht nur bei schubert. ich liebe dich so sehr!!! spielmann!
Merci pour ce partage magnifique ! Quel bonheur !!! Merci !!!
What a joy to listen to, thank for uploading !
Heard them playing it in Lugano in 2016. What a fantastic memory!
Normal, pour une oeuvre de ce niveau -‼️.
il y a pas mal de " comas" faussés ds cette version, aucun chant sublime ds ce jeu là, quel dommage, très déçue.
c très sec,, peu sensîble, pour Schubert, c'est peu croyable.‼️😮
Grazie mille per la condivisione, moltoooo gradito 💕
Браво..
La madurez musical de cuerpo entero,bravo
Due mostri di bravura
Thank you
=Schubert Cello Sonata Arpeggione=
•Allegro Moderato• (0:30)
•Adagio• (13:00)
•Allegretto• (17:24)
Do grande mestre Mischa Maisky.
As a cellist, it's hard for me to say anything negative about Maisky (even less about Martha). I grew up with his recording of Arpeggione from the 80's (or 90's, I don't remember). Already in that recording, the tempo fluctuations were notorious.
Perhaps this is not the best performance of Maisky and Argerich, the rubati and tempo changes are even more exaggerated and Maisky's intonation is not the best, however, things have to be put in context. Considering how difficult the Arpeggione sonata is, that Maisky goes out to play it from memory and at his age, it is truly remarkable.
Having said that, I think this performance is brilliant. 👍👍
Thank you for your observations. Only someone that plays the cello can notice this tempo variations. It's always good to get comments that contribute something from someone that know what she/he is talking about. Once more thank you for bringing thus up.
I noticed the tempo fluctuations (not a cellist). I found them funny and thought - isn't this a bit too much? But then the quality of their play and their listening goes beyond those irritations and it's just wonderful.
Almost all interpretations have the WEIRDEST idea of "Allegro Moderato" and I too find the tempo fluctuations far too excessive, sometimes by as much as half or double speed.
Merci infiniment
Due Giganti
Simplesmente, Magistral... A simplicidade de caráter é o resultado natural da profundez de pensamento. Obrigado!
0
🙌🏻🙌🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻❤️
♥️♥️
❤
Povo vai num concerto desse só pra tossir! Ave Maria!
Благодарю! Восхитительно!
Is this recording perhaps a few years old and from a concerthall in hamburg? Because I had the privilege do witness them perform this piece a few years back and it was stunning!
Milano, 18 march 2016
I witnessed them performing in Lugano 2016.
Too much attachments on standard versions, by some critical comments... Just opening spirit, and listening as a new story, and beauty and deep joy will enter in full range into your heart...
Her er Mischa Maisky i dag
Correct me if I am wrong. I just feel Mischa Maisky doesn't play as well as he was when he was younger. I just felt nervous when I am listening to his playing, feeling afraid that he may make some unwanted sound. How do you feel about his performance?
Perhaps he want to improvise a little bit from the origin piece. Mischa Maisky love to bring lots variation to his piece that he played. In my opinion. As for me to say iam not much care for the difference. Sometimes other variation and interpretation can still be beautiful.
@@classicalmusicreplay got you.
je ne ressens pas la plénitude du son de ce violoncelle, qui me semble parfois faux( qqs Commas) et pas en possession de tous ses moyens.
il y manque de l'espace, de la rondeur, de l'ampleur.En bref, je suis déçue, d'autant plus triste que cette sonate ET Matha Argerich sont magnifiques ✨😭🌟
@@griottembf2405 Je suppose qu'il veut le rendre un peu différent de l'original et l'a improvisé. mais de mon point de vue c'est quand même beau. mais bien sûr nous avons tous des avis différents. et oui il y a peu d'erreurs mais nous sommes humains. et nous faisons toujours des erreurs. juste mon humble avis.
@@griottembf2405 That's what I mean. Thank you.
ㆍ
viola is good match for this sonata !!! pinchas zukerman eg
@ a Paul jones
Mais si, il s'agit bien de la sonate " piano/ violoncelle de Schubert"" Arpeggione".
son interprétation , c'est une autre chose, mais l'oeuvre est écrite o
Par Schubert ‼️
dommage pour Mme Argerich,‼️😱
Lots of rubatooooooo
I agree with it
But it is quite beautiful.
В исполнении Ростроповича эта соната звучит безупречно, а это мне не нравится.
Pas en forme ce jour là, Monsieur Maisky, Trop d'erreurs et d'imprécisions , notamment au niveau de la justesse. Mais comme toujours une belle sensibilité.
You may have to check your hearing. 😁
Normal il avait 68 ans, on peut tous espérer oser l'arpeggione a cet âge:) Ces petits accros font partie de la condition humaine, plus jeune il était un immense virtuose mais la il ne peut plus, il cherche quand même et fait de très belles choses je trouve cela touchant et suis capable de passer outre les imperfections techniques
what is THIS? this is Schubert? I don;t think so. Maisky is more erratic than Argerich. Extravagant,,,,, compare with Rostropovitch/Britten.
I would love to hear your version! Apparently you have a very specific, precise and exquisite way to play Schubert as Schubert should be played! 💪🏼
@@montesmarcelo5749 I agree with you, let him play his version for us! 💓
Careful! I was once listening to a "Bach Busker" in Leicester Square. He bravely had a go at the Bach Chaconne but half-way through his memory failed. I hummed him the next phrase and he foolishly offered me his violin. I carried on through to the end and then collected over £100 for him!@@montesmarcelo5749
@@montesmarcelo5749Die Kritik von Paul Jones ist durchaus nachvollziehbar, wenn nicht sogar naheliegend. Ein Werk für die individuelle Subjektivität zu instrumentalisieren ohne alles Streben in das Erforschen der Intention des Komponisten investiert zu haben entspricht nicht meinem ethischen Verständnis.
Dass MM nicht alles probiert hat, um im Sinne das Komponisten zu spielen, ist natürlich eine Unterstellung meinerseits, aber mein Eindruck von dieser Interpretation hat ja auch seine Ursachen. Und übrigens: Kritik setzt nicht voraus, dass der Kritiker es "besser" kann! MM hat die extremen technischen Herausforderungen dieses Werkes, welches nicht für Cello geschrieben ist, einigermaßen gut gemeistert, obwohl er sicher selbst weiß, dass da, vor allem für ihn, der doch in vielen Interpretationen bewiesen hat, wie gut er spielen kann, noch ein bisschen Luft nach oben ist.
Too much impulse. Not my style at all!!