Chello dense et puissant.... Délicat et confortable au piano.... Ce sont les contrastes élevés qui créent cette atmosphère qui frise tous les cheveux de ma crinière.... ❤😂
Bravissimi e Bellissima questa Sonata un CAPOLAVORO del Grande Schubert il Maestro delle melodie malinconiche... Schubert uno dei miei compositori preferiti del romanticismo!!!
Я иду по темной ноябрьской улице… Рабочий район большого города… Музыка в наушниках, а руки танцуют, в душе светит солнце, все во мне улыбается, какая радость!!! Благодарю!!!❤
einfach furios, grandios, gefühlvoll, voller geheimnis, jugendlicher verspieltheit, und eine schier grenzenlose, vorausahnende altersweißheit. das geht nur bei schubert. ich liebe dich so sehr!!! spielmann!
Ce n'est peut-être pas la meilleure prestation sur cet Arpaggione de Schubert qu'ils aient réalisée ensemble. Mais on ne boudera pas le plaisir d'ecouter ces deux artistes exceptionnels .Martha à 83 ans passés est tout juste incroyable et continue sa carriere genereuse et fantasque comme si de rien n'etait ! Elle a donné tant de joie au public depuis les annees cinquante ! Et Maisky reste un incomparable artiste sensible et inventif. On lui pardonnera quelques imprecisions ici ou là. L'essentiel est une ecoute sans préjugé, apte à admettre les pas de côté et les recherches improvisées. D'ailleurs Argerich adore ces participations impromptues avec ses amis comme elle le fait au Japon ou le fit à Lugano... On est loin d'une carriere convenue , programmée et ennuyeuse ! Tout cela renouvelle avec bonheur le contact avec la musique . On a entendu tant de fois l'Arpaggione qu'il est rafraîchissant d'en decouvrir encore et encore l'inepuisable richesse... La musique apporte tout simplement le bonheur !
È una bellissima sonata e questi interpreti sono favolosi. Singolare è il fatto che questa è una delle pochissime sonate scritte per Arpeggione, un strumento a 6 corde tastato che assomiglia a un po' al Violoncello, un po' alla Viola da Gamba ed un po' alla Chitarra che condivide l'accordarura ma, come il violoncello, si suona con l'archetto; ebbe una vita molto breve.
Normal, pour une oeuvre de ce niveau -‼️. il y a pas mal de " comas" faussés ds cette version, aucun chant sublime ds ce jeu là, quel dommage, très déçue. c très sec,, peu sensîble, pour Schubert, c'est peu croyable.‼️😮
Нравится Миша Майский и нравится Марта Аргерих. Не хочется думать о звуках, а думать о мыслях и чувствах, которые передают нам музыканты. Их отношение к Шуберту. Прекрасно
The musicality of these masters is incredible. They are perfectly synchronized, every tempo change is perfect. It is such a privilege to witness and enjoy this performance!
I love this piece. I play the euphonium, and we have a wonderful transcription of this magnificent work done for us. So very glad for this wonderful performance and its availability. Thank you for posting it.
..no se de música : ..pero..pero...Al ver a estos DRAGONES de la GRAN MÚSICA. donde sin tanta parafernalia, hacen lo que saben hacer bien........... No solo nos enseñan ARTE...también como debemos ser las personas cuando dominamos con tanta dedicación un oficio. Lo cual me hace....que sea un mejor lustrazapatos en mi barrio.!
Вы правы,Миша Майский уже не тот. Это возраст,и ничего тут не поделаешь,я сама скрипачка,и знаю это .мне 70 и я уже не могу играть как играла.но от этого Миша не становится менее велик,он гениальный был ,есть и будет.
Too much attachments on standard versions, by some critical comments... Just opening spirit, and listening as a new story, and beauty and deep joy will enter in full range into your heart...
As a cellist, it's hard for me to say anything negative about Maisky (even less about Martha). I grew up with his recording of Arpeggione from the 80's (or 90's, I don't remember). Already in that recording, the tempo fluctuations were notorious. Perhaps this is not the best performance of Maisky and Argerich, the rubati and tempo changes are even more exaggerated and Maisky's intonation is not the best, however, things have to be put in context. Considering how difficult the Arpeggione sonata is, that Maisky goes out to play it from memory and at his age, it is truly remarkable. Having said that, I think this performance is brilliant. 👍👍
Thank you for your observations. Only someone that plays the cello can notice this tempo variations. It's always good to get comments that contribute something from someone that know what she/he is talking about. Once more thank you for bringing thus up.
I noticed the tempo fluctuations (not a cellist). I found them funny and thought - isn't this a bit too much? But then the quality of their play and their listening goes beyond those irritations and it's just wonderful.
Almost all interpretations have the WEIRDEST idea of "Allegro Moderato" and I too find the tempo fluctuations far too excessive, sometimes by as much as half or double speed.
I discovered this sonata in the version of Rostropovich/Britten th-cam.com/video/8CW6S4gRahY/w-d-xo.html that remains my reference - with more "stable" tempo and, useless to say, a superb cello playing
I’m a cellist and also play the piano, and I have great admiration for both musicians. However, this is not a version I resonate with. I prefer a more whimsical interpretation
The music is one of those miracles of art that makes me feel reconciled to mortality. The playing is magical -- somehow these two did a mind-meld before they started the performance so that every rubato, every dynamic gesture, every phrase was as if one mind were performing. Maisky is not technically flawless, but, seriously, is that bothering you?
I am glad you mentioned that, because I was wondering if my ear was playing tricks on me. That said, yes he hits some notes that are a bit off, but the emotional engagement of his playing far outweighs that.
Is this recording perhaps a few years old and from a concerthall in hamburg? Because I had the privilege do witness them perform this piece a few years back and it was stunning!
Correct me if I am wrong. I just feel Mischa Maisky doesn't play as well as he was when he was younger. I just felt nervous when I am listening to his playing, feeling afraid that he may make some unwanted sound. How do you feel about his performance?
Perhaps he want to improvise a little bit from the origin piece. Mischa Maisky love to bring lots variation to his piece that he played. In my opinion. As for me to say iam not much care for the difference. Sometimes other variation and interpretation can still be beautiful.
je ne ressens pas la plénitude du son de ce violoncelle, qui me semble parfois faux( qqs Commas) et pas en possession de tous ses moyens. il y manque de l'espace, de la rondeur, de l'ampleur.En bref, je suis déçue, d'autant plus triste que cette sonate ET Matha Argerich sont magnifiques ✨😭🌟
@@griottembf2405 Je suppose qu'il veut le rendre un peu différent de l'original et l'a improvisé. mais de mon point de vue c'est quand même beau. mais bien sûr nous avons tous des avis différents. et oui il y a peu d'erreurs mais nous sommes humains. et nous faisons toujours des erreurs. juste mon humble avis.
Warum ist der Deckel des Flügels voll offen...halb oder ein Drittel geöffnet hätte einen ausgewogeneren Balance gegebenenfalls,? Zumal die Pianistin nicht ganz aus ihrer Rolle als Solistin herausgefunden hat.
Diesen Eindruck könnte man haben. Misha ist als Schubert verkleidet, nur, der könnte beileibe nicht so gut Cello, sorry, Arpeggione spielen. Tolle Interpretation der beiden. Bravooooo 🙏😀
Personally, I think they are not strict enough with the tempo. sure , Schubert was a romantic fellow, but his music is in a style of his time, which feels right when it’s played as they played at that time, which was fairly orthodox; this is not Chopin or Rachmaninov!
@ a Paul jones Mais si, il s'agit bien de la sonate " piano/ violoncelle de Schubert"" Arpeggione". son interprétation , c'est une autre chose, mais l'oeuvre est écrite o Par Schubert ‼️ dommage pour Mme Argerich,‼️😱
Pas en forme ce jour là, Monsieur Maisky, Trop d'erreurs et d'imprécisions , notamment au niveau de la justesse. Mais comme toujours une belle sensibilité.
Normal il avait 68 ans, on peut tous espérer oser l'arpeggione a cet âge:) Ces petits accros font partie de la condition humaine, plus jeune il était un immense virtuose mais la il ne peut plus, il cherche quand même et fait de très belles choses je trouve cela touchant et suis capable de passer outre les imperfections techniques
Toujours jouer le même répertoire pourquoi. ? Il y a tant de chef-d’œuvres méconnus qui méritent d’être présentés, pourquoi toujours vouloir jouer les mêmes choses ? C’est désolant!
Careful! I was once listening to a "Bach Busker" in Leicester Square. He bravely had a go at the Bach Chaconne but half-way through his memory failed. I hummed him the next phrase and he foolishly offered me his violin. I carried on through to the end and then collected over £100 for him!@@montesmarcelo5749
@@montesmarcelo5749Die Kritik von Paul Jones ist durchaus nachvollziehbar, wenn nicht sogar naheliegend. Ein Werk für die individuelle Subjektivität zu instrumentalisieren ohne alles Streben in das Erforschen der Intention des Komponisten investiert zu haben entspricht nicht meinem ethischen Verständnis. Dass MM nicht alles probiert hat, um im Sinne das Komponisten zu spielen, ist natürlich eine Unterstellung meinerseits, aber mein Eindruck von dieser Interpretation hat ja auch seine Ursachen. Und übrigens: Kritik setzt nicht voraus, dass der Kritiker es "besser" kann! MM hat die extremen technischen Herausforderungen dieses Werkes, welches nicht für Cello geschrieben ist, einigermaßen gut gemeistert, obwohl er sicher selbst weiß, dass da, vor allem für ihn, der doch in vielen Interpretationen bewiesen hat, wie gut er spielen kann, noch ein bisschen Luft nach oben ist.
I am a cellist and I can appreciate every single second of this!
Mischa Maisky seems so engaged with each note and silence, each musical moment.
Quienes no lo somos, ¿no podemos apreciar?
Tutti possono apprezzare,ed anch'io sono un violoncellista
Chello dense et puissant.... Délicat et confortable au piano.... Ce sont les contrastes élevés qui créent cette atmosphère qui frise tous les cheveux de ma crinière.... ❤😂
La pianista Martha Argerich è eccezionale bravissima!
Bravissimi e Bellissima questa Sonata un CAPOLAVORO del Grande Schubert il Maestro delle melodie malinconiche... Schubert uno dei miei compositori preferiti del romanticismo!!!
Edge of my seat playing and I was only listening. Thanks for the posting.
Я иду по темной ноябрьской улице… Рабочий район большого города… Музыка в наушниках, а руки танцуют, в душе светит солнце, все во мне улыбается, какая радость!!!
Благодарю!!!❤
What a delight to listen to and watch these masters so well attuned in their performance of a great work
einfach furios, grandios, gefühlvoll, voller geheimnis, jugendlicher verspieltheit, und eine schier grenzenlose, vorausahnende altersweißheit. das geht nur bei schubert. ich liebe dich so sehr!!! spielmann!
Ce n'est peut-être pas la meilleure prestation sur cet Arpaggione de Schubert qu'ils aient réalisée ensemble.
Mais on ne boudera pas le plaisir d'ecouter ces deux artistes exceptionnels .Martha à 83 ans passés est tout juste incroyable et continue sa carriere genereuse et fantasque comme si de rien n'etait ! Elle a donné tant de joie au public depuis les annees cinquante ! Et Maisky reste un incomparable artiste sensible et inventif. On lui pardonnera quelques imprecisions ici ou là. L'essentiel est une ecoute sans préjugé, apte à admettre les pas de côté et les recherches improvisées. D'ailleurs Argerich adore ces participations impromptues avec ses amis comme elle le fait au Japon ou le fit à Lugano... On est loin d'une carriere convenue , programmée et ennuyeuse ! Tout cela renouvelle avec bonheur le contact avec la musique . On a entendu tant de fois l'Arpaggione qu'il est rafraîchissant d'en decouvrir encore et encore l'inepuisable richesse... La musique apporte tout simplement le bonheur !
È una bellissima sonata e questi interpreti sono favolosi. Singolare è il fatto che questa è una delle pochissime sonate scritte per Arpeggione, un strumento a 6 corde tastato che assomiglia a un po' al Violoncello, un po' alla Viola da Gamba ed un po' alla Chitarra che condivide l'accordarura ma, come il violoncello, si suona con l'archetto; ebbe una vita molto breve.
esattamente 🙂
Amanecer con esta bellísima obra de Schubert es regalo para el corazón. Mil gracias
Фантастично.Незабравимо!
What a joy to listen to, thank for uploading !
This artistry is masters to whom one never grows as the soul flies with stars glowing.
Bravo, Martha Angerich & Misha Maisky.
🙏❤️🌏🌎🌍🌿🕊🎵🎶🎵💫✨️💫
Wunderbares Stück, wunderbare Aufführung
World's best musical duo.
Heard them playing it in Lugano in 2016. What a fantastic memory!
Normal, pour une oeuvre de ce niveau -‼️.
il y a pas mal de " comas" faussés ds cette version, aucun chant sublime ds ce jeu là, quel dommage, très déçue.
c très sec,, peu sensîble, pour Schubert, c'est peu croyable.‼️😮
Нравится Миша Майский и нравится Марта Аргерих. Не хочется думать о звуках, а думать о мыслях и чувствах, которые передают нам музыканты. Их отношение к Шуберту. Прекрасно
Cómo pudo Shubert crear tanta belleza! El fue realmente un gran gênio. Si hubiese vivido más seria el mejor de todos!
¡ Vaya DOS ! ...SIEMPRE JÓVENES ... y cada vez MEJORES .
Li trovo incantevoli. Grande musicalità degli artisti e grande musica di Schubert, del rubato..... non mi curo
Recensione perfetta.
Maisky was a student of Rostropovitch. And it is so evident here. My favourite cellist, one of the greatest.
I totally agree! ❤
Merci pour ce partage magnifique ! Quel bonheur !!! Merci !!!
The musicality of these masters is incredible. They are perfectly synchronized, every tempo change is perfect. It is such a privilege to witness and enjoy this performance!
Ooo - ee - two classic performers - I look forward to this - once I have finished listening to Evgeni playing the Goldberg Variations
Потрясающий ансамбль❤
Adorable playing -I love it ❤🌹🌹🌹 !
Ohh....magnificent piece and performance...❤
This is absolutely amazing
Grazie mille per la condivisione, moltoooo gradito 💕
I love this piece. I play the euphonium, and we have a wonderful transcription of this magnificent work done for us. So very glad for this wonderful performance and its availability. Thank you for posting it.
Duo parfait ❤❤❤ merci beaucoup
Can we talk about the production quality? It keeps getting better!
A better seat than the front row!
A magnificent duo! Here is a master-class in solo/accompaniment, so well coordinated! This goes in "Favorites." Very best greetings from Canada.
Beautiful sweet & mellow of these two virtuosoes .
..no se de música :
..pero..pero...Al ver a estos DRAGONES de la GRAN MÚSICA. donde sin tanta parafernalia, hacen lo que saben hacer bien...........
No solo nos enseñan ARTE...también como debemos ser las personas cuando dominamos con tanta dedicación un oficio.
Lo cual me hace....que sea un mejor lustrazapatos en mi barrio.!
Simplesmente, Magistral... A simplicidade de caráter é o resultado natural da profundez de pensamento. Obrigado!
0
Wonderful
=Schubert Cello Sonata Arpeggione=
•Allegro Moderato• (0:30)
•Adagio• (13:00)
•Allegretto• (17:24)
Do grande mestre Mischa Maisky.
Absolutely gorgeous
Brilliant !
素晴らしい組み合わせです!😊❤
Вы правы,Миша Майский уже не тот. Это возраст,и ничего тут не поделаешь,я сама скрипачка,и знаю это .мне 70 и я уже не могу играть как играла.но от этого Миша не становится менее велик,он гениальный был ,есть и будет.
Too much attachments on standard versions, by some critical comments... Just opening spirit, and listening as a new story, and beauty and deep joy will enter in full range into your heart...
Благородная вдохновения пара,достойная высокого искуства
Bellísima!!!❤❤❤🎉🎉
Due Giganti
Thank you
Maravillosos ambos interpretes
As a cellist, it's hard for me to say anything negative about Maisky (even less about Martha). I grew up with his recording of Arpeggione from the 80's (or 90's, I don't remember). Already in that recording, the tempo fluctuations were notorious.
Perhaps this is not the best performance of Maisky and Argerich, the rubati and tempo changes are even more exaggerated and Maisky's intonation is not the best, however, things have to be put in context. Considering how difficult the Arpeggione sonata is, that Maisky goes out to play it from memory and at his age, it is truly remarkable.
Having said that, I think this performance is brilliant. 👍👍
Thank you for your observations. Only someone that plays the cello can notice this tempo variations. It's always good to get comments that contribute something from someone that know what she/he is talking about. Once more thank you for bringing thus up.
I noticed the tempo fluctuations (not a cellist). I found them funny and thought - isn't this a bit too much? But then the quality of their play and their listening goes beyond those irritations and it's just wonderful.
Almost all interpretations have the WEIRDEST idea of "Allegro Moderato" and I too find the tempo fluctuations far too excessive, sometimes by as much as half or double speed.
I discovered this sonata in the version of Rostropovich/Britten th-cam.com/video/8CW6S4gRahY/w-d-xo.html that remains my reference - with more "stable" tempo and, useless to say, a superb cello playing
I’m a cellist and also play the piano, and I have great admiration for both musicians. However, this is not a version I resonate with. I prefer a more whimsical interpretation
Incredible!
La madurez musical de cuerpo entero,bravo
Браво..
The music is one of those miracles of art that makes me feel reconciled to mortality. The playing is magical -- somehow these two did a mind-meld before they started the performance so that every rubato, every dynamic gesture, every phrase was as if one mind were performing. Maisky is not technically flawless, but, seriously, is that bothering you?
I am glad you mentioned that, because I was wondering if my ear was playing tricks on me. That said, yes he hits some notes that are a bit off, but the emotional engagement of his playing far outweighs that.
Great 🎉🎉🎉🎉
Ascoltando Schubert suonato da questi si deve credere che esiste un Dio che ci ha Regulator questo per poter vivere
Autstanding
Due mostri di bravura
Tof cello concert, mooie uitvoering
Hermoso, muchas gracias.
ΥΠΕΡΟΧΟΙ!!!
Σας ευχαριστώ πολύ
❤❤❤
Какие внешне эффектные люди
Is this recording perhaps a few years old and from a concerthall in hamburg? Because I had the privilege do witness them perform this piece a few years back and it was stunning!
Milano, 18 march 2016
I witnessed them performing in Lugano 2016.
Благодарю! Восхитительно!
Povo vai num concerto desse só pra tossir! Ave Maria!
Merci infiniment
I noticed Mischa’s endpin flexing; do you prefer one type of flooring over another?
참 좋습니다(very good)!
🙌🏻🙌🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻❤️
I thought Misha was Cosplaying as Schubert
😊❤🎉😊
♥️♥️
❤
Correct me if I am wrong. I just feel Mischa Maisky doesn't play as well as he was when he was younger. I just felt nervous when I am listening to his playing, feeling afraid that he may make some unwanted sound. How do you feel about his performance?
Perhaps he want to improvise a little bit from the origin piece. Mischa Maisky love to bring lots variation to his piece that he played. In my opinion. As for me to say iam not much care for the difference. Sometimes other variation and interpretation can still be beautiful.
@@classicalmusicreplay got you.
je ne ressens pas la plénitude du son de ce violoncelle, qui me semble parfois faux( qqs Commas) et pas en possession de tous ses moyens.
il y manque de l'espace, de la rondeur, de l'ampleur.En bref, je suis déçue, d'autant plus triste que cette sonate ET Matha Argerich sont magnifiques ✨😭🌟
@@griottembf2405 Je suppose qu'il veut le rendre un peu différent de l'original et l'a improvisé. mais de mon point de vue c'est quand même beau. mais bien sûr nous avons tous des avis différents. et oui il y a peu d'erreurs mais nous sommes humains. et nous faisons toujours des erreurs. juste mon humble avis.
@@griottembf2405 That's what I mean. Thank you.
이게 최고다
Warum ist der Deckel des Flügels voll offen...halb oder ein Drittel geöffnet hätte einen ausgewogeneren Balance gegebenenfalls,? Zumal die Pianistin nicht ganz aus ihrer Rolle als Solistin herausgefunden hat.
The balance is beautiful!
Für zwei Solisten
Her er Mischa Maisky i dag
It;s a matter of taste but I like more the version by Perenyi and Andreas Schiff.
totally agreed.
Diesen Eindruck könnte man haben. Misha ist als Schubert verkleidet, nur, der könnte beileibe nicht so gut Cello, sorry, Arpeggione spielen.
Tolle Interpretation der beiden. Bravooooo 🙏😀
Personally, I think they are not strict enough with the tempo. sure , Schubert was a romantic fellow, but his music is in a style of his time, which feels right when it’s played as they played at that time, which was fairly orthodox; this is not Chopin or Rachmaninov!
Show us your interpretation, kid
Майский производит -весьма провинциальное впечатление......
😮What an unnecessary comment...🤔
Someone is already for bed. Nice PJs.
3 FERAS
@ a Paul jones
Mais si, il s'agit bien de la sonate " piano/ violoncelle de Schubert"" Arpeggione".
son interprétation , c'est une autre chose, mais l'oeuvre est écrite o
Par Schubert ‼️
dommage pour Mme Argerich,‼️😱
It looks like Mischa and Martha both use the same hair stylist.
this is almost the godfather theme
J'ai déjà acheté de la truite fumée plus bandante 😅🥱
ㆍ
viola is good match for this sonata !!! pinchas zukerman eg
😂a inveja mata!!!!
В исполнении Ростроповича эта соната звучит безупречно, а это мне не нравится.
Pas en forme ce jour là, Monsieur Maisky, Trop d'erreurs et d'imprécisions , notamment au niveau de la justesse. Mais comme toujours une belle sensibilité.
You may have to check your hearing. 😁
Normal il avait 68 ans, on peut tous espérer oser l'arpeggione a cet âge:) Ces petits accros font partie de la condition humaine, plus jeune il était un immense virtuose mais la il ne peut plus, il cherche quand même et fait de très belles choses je trouve cela touchant et suis capable de passer outre les imperfections techniques
シューベルト先生も草葉の陰でお喜びでしょう
Toujours jouer le même répertoire pourquoi. ?
Il y a tant de chef-d’œuvres méconnus qui méritent d’être présentés, pourquoi toujours vouloir jouer les mêmes choses ?
C’est désolant!
Lots of rubatooooooo
I agree with it
But it is quite beautiful.
So sad it's not arpeggione here
Secondo me, il duo Perenyi-Schiff, può parere impossibile, è ancora meglio, malinconico sì ma anche dolcemente gaio,,,
Too much impulse. Not my style at all!!
what is THIS? this is Schubert? I don;t think so. Maisky is more erratic than Argerich. Extravagant,,,,, compare with Rostropovitch/Britten.
I would love to hear your version! Apparently you have a very specific, precise and exquisite way to play Schubert as Schubert should be played! 💪🏼
@@montesmarcelo5749 I agree with you, let him play his version for us! 💓
Careful! I was once listening to a "Bach Busker" in Leicester Square. He bravely had a go at the Bach Chaconne but half-way through his memory failed. I hummed him the next phrase and he foolishly offered me his violin. I carried on through to the end and then collected over £100 for him!@@montesmarcelo5749
@@montesmarcelo5749Die Kritik von Paul Jones ist durchaus nachvollziehbar, wenn nicht sogar naheliegend. Ein Werk für die individuelle Subjektivität zu instrumentalisieren ohne alles Streben in das Erforschen der Intention des Komponisten investiert zu haben entspricht nicht meinem ethischen Verständnis.
Dass MM nicht alles probiert hat, um im Sinne das Komponisten zu spielen, ist natürlich eine Unterstellung meinerseits, aber mein Eindruck von dieser Interpretation hat ja auch seine Ursachen. Und übrigens: Kritik setzt nicht voraus, dass der Kritiker es "besser" kann! MM hat die extremen technischen Herausforderungen dieses Werkes, welches nicht für Cello geschrieben ist, einigermaßen gut gemeistert, obwohl er sicher selbst weiß, dass da, vor allem für ihn, der doch in vielen Interpretationen bewiesen hat, wie gut er spielen kann, noch ein bisschen Luft nach oben ist.
❤