Looking Back at Pakistan's History | Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed | Full Episode | TWT | Ep 22 | WTI
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 22 มี.ค. 2023
- Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed by the guests in this video are solely their own and do not necessarily reflect the views of the creators or publishers of this content. We do not endorse or promote any specific views, ideologies, or beliefs presented by the guests, and encourage viewers to form their own opinions based on a diverse range of perspectives.
In this episode we invited a very special guest, Dr Ishtiaq Ahmed, to revisit our independence and its struggles, our relationship with India, our role in the region and prospects of Pakistan in future.
A Must Watch!
Ishtiaq Sb,
Please continue speaking the truth as long as possible.
May you live long with good health & high spirits to spread the message of peace & harmony in South Asia !!!
Aameen, Elaahi Aameen
I am a Panjabi.
Kicked out in 1947. Lost my land. Why? Quran says I am a Kafir.
Fortunately I m not a woman. Otherwise I would be one of the six wifes of the PM.
Sahir Ludhainve was kicked out, for playing music. (Not allowed in Quran)
All smart Muslims migrated to India. Even Jinnah's daughter.
Lucky. in heaven they get more women. See what is going on in IRAN.
Stoning, Lashes, Jail or Chain saw.
COMFORT WOMEN? I love to listen o all this nonsense.
The Parsees came as refugees. Contribute heavily.
I am 90. Saw this coming and left India in 1958
Book written by Dr ishtiyaq ji contains 750 pages, 22 chapters, and around 1500 notes/references..every other podcasters will have to call him, and they will have to listen to him.. No contradiction.. Great sir👍👍🙏
Such a gem of person. ! But I wonder was his same voices not heard in Pakistan during its continuous political , social , constitutional failures? Kudos to Host Mr osman .
Such a gem, he talks the truth and does not care to please anyone.
Please lower the introductory music and others. They are deafening
I agree !!!
Yes you're right. It hurts
Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmad is an erudite person and Pakistanis need to learn a lot from such personalities.His last words are so precious and should be written with golden words that "Give peace a chance."❤❤❤❤Mera pegham mohabbat hai jahan tk pohanchay💐
HE IS THE MAN TO READ. ISHTIAQ SIR YOU BEAUTY
Delightful discussion
Thank you for discussing this important topic
'Riots' which started against Muslims at partition are still going on in 'India'. 'Riots' in Gujrat and later in Delhi last year are just carbon copies of that lol. And who forgets what happened when Pathaan movie was about to release hehe.
Dr istiaq ahmed sir is very unbiased in his approach ..... Respect from india
A person from Godi media country is talking about unbiased 😂😂😂😂 indian even blame amritpal is a Pakistani 😂😂😂
@@bojpuri423 amritpal is taking funds from Pakistan
Please reduce some more eco/reverb, its disturbing.
An exceptional analysis.
Peace can only be between India and Pakistan if they give back POK and stop terirosm
Sir Usama you are the best podcaster and MASHA ALLAH asks very important questions ❤
Dont take it otherwise.......What's the ancient history of Pakistan or prior to 732 A.D. and then what havoc followed it????
When we even not teach "Half-truth" or recognize our existence things cannot settle!!!
Their are very few pakistanis like Dr Ishtiyaq Ahmad , Syed Muzammil Shah, Hassan Nissar , Abbas Haider , jinko thumbnail me dekhkar Indian apni attendance lagane aa jate hain 🙂
OMG, what a wise man he is.
Love You Usama ❤
Love You world times css
Neutral judgement
Neutral talk show 😊
Informative 🎉
Wallah ...... Mn sehri bana rahi thi sath handsfree lgaey hoay thy ....or aik dm start hoa music_ Meri Jan nikl kr pir wapis aai ....😂...
Ishtiak sir is looking very dashing. 😍
ڈاکٹر اشتیاق صاحب اتنا بتا دیں کہ پاکستان جب بنا تو اس وقت پاکستان کی کتنی آبادی تھی ( مشرقی اور مغربی پاکستان)
Dr Ahmed is not accepting that Jinnah asked for separation. Not by any Hindu leader.
Sir great and honest analysis and suggestions , being a default country we need such kind of reforms and policies to rescue our futur and next generation.
We always Sir.. 🙏
Osama sir ap hamey bateay pms or css Mai difference
We always Sir🙏
That's we trying for gives peace 🕊️ fighting in business scores in case win don't look down helping Each others rewards win who knows
26:00, but sir it is on the behalf of those Muslim campaigns we are saying Allah-o-Akbar اللّٰہ اکبر instead of ram ram رام رام. Humans are robots without ideology. If we aren't going to follow our ideology, we will be subjected to following other's ideologies.
If not this one, then that one is a must.
You are subject of Arab ideology mean mental slave
Wars have been gentlemanly, specially if we bring ongoing Ukraine war into the perspective, but terrorist attacks by non state actors have rather been dastardly and enjoy tacit support of pakistani masses. Reading the situation wrong to suit one's narrative is an art pakistani have mastered with great felicity.
Sound recording is bad, inspite of having all those gadgets...
Who would play Kafr Tax, Zizya Tax if Mughal converted all the Hindus.
Yes the main reason. India was no 1 in agricultural revenue . That was the reason it attracted lots of foreign invaders starting with Greek to English.
There is a lot of eco in your podcast and voice is not at all clear please make some thing about it
Very good 👍
My question is that mentors urge students to write patriotic answers in the exam, anything controversial is discouraged. Keeping this in view, is it wise to write the arguments which ishtiyaq sahb is presenting? To write against jinnah? however accurate it may be. Please answer this query
Assalam O Alaikum
Osama Sir you are so talented economist so why you always take other person's podcast not share your acquired knowledge with us?
جزاک اللّٰہ
Nice
In an ironic way, Jinnah greatly helped India by keeping the majority of the separatist Muslim population out of India. Without the partition, Muslim population of undivided India would have been 40% of the population by now. Being ideological and group thinking, radical Muslims would have pushed jihadi religious politics, which would have greatly hindered India's growth. Therefore, Indians should be greatly thankful to Jinnah for the partition of India.
🙏🏽🇮🇳🙏🏽
In my opinion all those leaders who favored partition of India in 1947 were not patriotic to the soil they were born . They didn’t care for the killing and sufferings of people. If they did not know the results of this idea then they can’t be called visionary leaders.
Can I take 2 subjects for 200 marks one physics and one political science?
Living together has been a norm; fighting over religion is aberration.
Hello 🤗 Osama sir koi education for women's key liyeay b videos banyeay islyeay Pakistan ke population half illletrate h
Fear's loss's overthinking and start fight and setup losing straight humanity in case shear's good and seriously positive honest fear's will not places and positive working
Very informative interview. We need more people like Prof Ishtiaq in our Sub continent to make some impact on our people, who are easily misguided by the power elites.
🇮🇳 Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam 🇮🇳
no matter what happend in past, all pakistanis are still our brothers and sisters, its just some misguided people create hate. love from india🇮🇳
😂😂😂 ok begairat behaya ghasti mughaliya ki kaafir kataria se hue halala ki paidash ganduudin 😂😂😂
Love you brother
You are welcome to go and stay with your "brothers and sisters".
Sorry. The Pakistanis have been indocrinated to hate India since the first day in primary schools. In Pakistan, INDIA is spelled H I N D U. The children are taught that Hindus are devious, dishonest and dirty. The Pakistani school text books are full of chapters filled with pathological hatred of Hindus. Pakistanis hate Hindus more than they love their own children - their hate for India is much more powerful than love for their children. I believe, Pakistan will not be friendly with India for several hundred years - may be after 500 years.
गौरव जी! जब 100 मेँ 99 गुमराह होँ तो वो गुमराह नहीँ गुमराह आप हैँ।
आप उन्हे भाइ समझते रहेँ लेकिन वो आपको मल मुत्र से भी बदतर और कत्ल करने लायक समझते हैँ। आप उनकी किताबेँ पढ़लेँ, उनके धर्म गुरुओँ को सुनलेँ। आपकी समझ ठीक हो जायेगी। उनको बोलेँ यदि वोभी आपको भाइ समझते हैँ तो कहेँ की उनकी किताबोँ मेँ गलत लिखा है, उनके उपदेशक गलत कहते हैँ।
In my opinion Muslims would have peace and more progress,than they have in Pakistan, in united India-indian federation- and less political and economic woes,if they had struggled to live mutually.
Aik hee time may dono kesy kry
Salam sir... mein aj tk is philosphy ko nhi smj paya ky aik urdu speaking country mein khud ko prha likha sabit krny ky liay english bolni prti hai ..ya tu english ko qoomi zaban bna diya jaya ta kay lower middle class ka bhi faida ho jiay
Urdu speaking country bhi zabardasti bnayi hai....partition k time pe majority log Bengali the...2nd majority punjabi thi...Urdu musallat ki zabardasti
As per the information partition of united India is the costs 10 lakhs people s mascare and 160 lakhs people s Displacement from their mother land
It is just hegemony of some people, who claims that we are above all ,by god grace we were bound to rule the all others ,ultimately partition was taking place Most of the valuable money,time energy is being used and loss of human life Today lot of interpersonal discussion were started in highly educational leval
Welcome for it thanks for theirs contributions
Sir
As far as business and trade is concerned why India Pakistan and Bangladesh can become a confederation.
Hinduism ko bhi agar survive karna hai toh converting religion banna padega
Hindus atleast need to be welcoming anyone who follows Hindu philosophy or Mary's Hindu!
Hello sir
Sir jee Indian government declaring non Hindu are not Indian nationals...kia discuss ker rehay hain asp
Please make a program on exmuslim momentum activits such as SACHWALAJI SAMEER JI SAMEERJI ADAMJI AND SAHILJI BECAUSE these are the only hope to save Pakistan from becoming another Afghanistan
Pakistan need to start geo- economics relation with its neighbour at least this time they have to keep their egos aside
Exchange of population should be implemented in the first step. All Muslims of India should leave India and go to Pakistan and Bangladesh, and in exchange all non-Muslims of Pakistan and Bangladesh should come to India. After that, line of control in Kashmir should be converted to the International Border. This is the only solution for the Kashmir problem and everyother problem.
India's problem was created by Nehru and Ambedkar who wanted to forget the basic fact that the country was partitioned on the basis of religion and after the partition, no Muslims should stay in India.
Dr Ahmed seems to be a liberal democrat influenced by Nehru.He has leftist background and is highly respected for his scholarship.
Muslim rulers by and large tolerated big Hindu population and didn't convert them. Main reason was jijia paid by kaffirs. Muslims were exempted . Hindustan was unique in that sense! Other ME lands even Iran was not as rich as agriculturist India.
Rest of all, i don't agree with his view about partation. Partition was necessary...
Yes but it should have been complete. Nothing wrong if Hindus feel cheated at the deal they got
Yes , then why 200 million are living in india? open you door for them too 🙂.
As a Sindhi Hindu born in Pakistan, I thank Jnnah for creating Pakistan. Otherwise India would have been an Islamic hell. However, I am sorry that Nehru didn't push Muslims out of India. Jinnah was a Shia Muslims but ironically Shias are hated in Pakistan. I have seen videos of Sunnis chanting, "Shia Kafir, Shia Kafir". Ahmadi Muslims were biggest supporter of Jinnah's vision of Pakistan - now Ahmadis are declared Kufir - irony of irnies!
alag mulk banane ke faide hi faide.............APNE HI sadiq ur amin amirul momineens ne gira diye nasheman par bijliyan............now maqbooza Pakistan.........wahid islami mulk
Fun fact is the daughter of Quaid e azam 🤣🤣🤣 of Pakistan is an Indian 😂😂
I just dont afree with Ishtiaq ji on muslims rulers, I think he need more reading on that also u cant be that binary that how only 20% got converted, bcz they were in half of india and most of the time fighting either with Marathas or with Brits.
TRUTH IS INVINCIBLE , UNSINKABLE AND IMMORTAL .... JHUT AUR GADDARI NEVER PAYS > LEARN IT FROM WORLD HISTORY !
My 75 years of experience:
- Mussalman cannot live with other religions in peace, will always try to convert and rule.
- Indian subcontinent will never find peace till Pis’stan exists.
Why?
Because the Indian Mussalman (Islamists, seeking superiority) will always seek another Pis’stan.
- Once Pis’stan is dismembered, no Integration with India, into its constituent pieces, Indian Mussalman (Islamists, seeking superiority) ki
hekdi utar jayegi.
All this bunkum, saath main trade etc, Sheikh Chilli ke sapne hain!
@Football-Pundit sure.
The Mussalman lives in peace all over the world, especially in Pis’stan and neighbouring India where he goes about in mobs chanting “… sar ran se juda” and doing it too!
'Riots' which started against Muslims at partition are still going on in 'India'. 'Riots' in Gujrat and later in Delhi last year are just carbon copies of that lol. And who forgets what happened when Pathaan movie was about to release. lol
Great thought about contemporary context but his veiw on partition and about Mr Jinnah is controversial
We are fed half truth bro
@@harisghumman8397 i think he exaggerate some facts, *the creation of Pakistan was miracle of 20th century* it wasn't said by a Pakistani
Justifying your leader ego is eternal truth for pakistani otherwise how can they justify there country
Deeply disappointed with sugar coating of muslim leaders by professor. Khilji, Aurangzeb, Timur et al. Breaking temples, killing orgy of Timur, Aurangzeb; Direct action day? What happened to 17% of minority population in Pak at partition. Sorry, I have lost my respect.
Ishtiaq Ahmed is another type of Jihadi mentality. He is denying the jihad when the atrocities, mass conversion, holocaust and destruction of temples were accounted and written by muslims own historian from Bildauri , Abul Fazal.
Hindus reminded hindus because Jats , Maratthas , Rajputs and Sikhs were faught many wars against them.
The Punjabi , Sindhi , Baloch write in Arabic script because they were defeated by muslims .
Please get lost and watch communal Hindu videos.
'Riots' which started against Muslims at partition are still going on in 'India'. 'Riots' in Gujrat and later in Delhi last year are just carbon copies of that lol. And who forgets what happened when Pathaan movie was about to release hehe.
Misrepresentation of facts regarding the wars...Totally a bookish chat.
Pms kry ya css
Both!
@@osamarizvi7083 thanks for guidelines
@@osamarizvi7083 ap ney css kyun nhi kia ap ko itna knowledge h
Aoa sir ap sy ek request hn mj css pak affair key very important questions Jo hn wo bataa dy
Radical people and mullah brigade are main responsible for Pakistan social and economic crises. It's very sad to say that political party and elite class shamelessly support these to survive their political durability, which is clearly visible. And superiority complex is extraordinary where has nothing logical deepness. These are the basic reasons why Pakistan going deep to deepest toward blackhole. Deradicalizatio, educational reform, economic reform, degradation of religious education and controlling mullah brigade is whoud be the perfect solution for Pakistan burning issues. I'm not Pakistan specialist it's personal feeling. By the way it's meaningful discussion.
He is citizen of pakistan but representing more ideology of Gandhi..
The truth has to be told
Citizen of Sweeden.
When You read more about nehru Gandhi and indian freedom struggle , and gandhi sacrifices for muslims , he will take your words back , rss has pledged to kill all indian muslims in 1947 but nehru and gandhi didn't let that now indian muslim has grown from 10 percent to 15 percent.
भाइ मुश्लिम तो है? इस्लाम मेँ नेशन स्टेट नहीँ होता। मुशलमान केवल अपने दीन और खुदा को मानता है। यदि कोइ कहे की मैँ पहले देश का नागरिक हुँ फिर मुश्लिम तो वो गया समझो।
Ideology of Gandhi is of truth you mean
Pakistani history exists?😂
If Muslim were so stable in India so why they migrated to Pakistan leaving their properties and close relations in India?
Urdu speaking educated people leave for better jobs in 1947. But those educated people have looted. Rss and sikh literally butchered muslims in East punjab but up still has 20 percent of muslim population . I am from up.
Direct action day by Muslim league, started riots which resulted in massacre of innocent Sikhs and Hindus. Subsequently Muslims were massacred in Bihar and elsewhere in India. Forcing them to run for their lives. Quaid e Azam so desperately wanted partition, just to prove he is a bigger leader than Gandhi. But his actions resulted in millions of innocent lives being lost. He never visited a refugee camp, but once he did, the people(Muslims) in those camps started lamenting to him that your politics resulted in us loosing everything, our loved ones, mothers, father, sister, homes etc.
Muslim league targeted Sikhs and hindus in 1947 pre partition....so Sikhs and Hindus targeted them at partition...so they had to migrate
Then why majority of muslims didn't go to pakistan why they are still living in India
The rest were reluctant to leave India. They didn't agree with Jinnah. And we're more inclined towards the nationalist politics of Jamait Islami hind, Muslim congress leaders like Abu ul Kalam Azad, jamat e ihrar etc. Jinnah was not the only Muslim representative.
Dr. Shaheb! root cause of enmity between Bharat & Pakistan is Islam which you always forget to mention or don't have the courage to speak about & it only can change when Pakistani Muslims denounce & defy the hateful teachings from their holy Book.
You know the issue of war in Europe was political & not religious & Though the teachings of Christians are full of hate towards non-Christians but Christians have learned to ignore it.
Bhai sar tan sy juda ky order lag jaengy Dr sahab par 😂usky saath blasphemy bhi lag jaegi
@@taraprasadbehera6516 You are right Behera Babu, and I want to point & highlite it.
You are very blinded with wrong knowledge of Islam
@@abdullahtayyab3344
Okay then what is right knowledge?
You mean to say what is written in books is wrong?
foolish arguments by ishtaque all ruler was protectours nonsense india mey muslims poorey india per kabhee hukumat nahee kar payey mahartha rajput sikh inoney hamesha mughlo ko tuff time diya jaha per muslim rule tha vaha to population convert kiya gaya aaj ka pakistan partition key time 76 % muslim bengal mejority muslim kashmir mey muslims converssion ka kaam to sab ney kiya kisee ney thoda kiya kisiney aurangzeb ney jyada kiya suna hai kisee hindu ruler ney musalmano per jijiyalagaya or extra tax lagaya kisee ko converssion kiya india mey converssion totally na ho paya uskey alag reason hai lekeen afganistan kee baat ley iran kee baat ley makka madina kee baat ley sab jagah to forcefully converssion hua hai muslims rules kee khudkee jo books hai unmeybhee saree histoury bharee padee hai muslims rulers key julm kee porey dastayey moujood hai
AR Rehman aur Sarooj Khan ko bhi convert Aurangzeb ney hee kiya tha? lol. 'Nasha' chorr ur utha jaa beta ab lol.
makka madina per kabja kaisey hua conversion kaisey hua iran sey parsi kyo bhagey afganistan key budhist kaha gayey ar rehman ko 2 nd marege karnee thee isliye usney islam ka sahara liya kyonkee india mey musalmanoko alag law and hinduoko alag law hai jara histoury padh samaj ayenga @@aarifboy
@@pradeepkumarkamble4017 Tum 'Hindus' history mein ronay ke siwa aur kuch nahin ker sakey, Tum woh 'hijre' ho, jinko sirf apni Auraton ko 'aag' mein 'jala' ker 'satti' kerna hee aata tha hehe. Hairat hai ke Aurangzeb ye sab dekhta raha, aur uss ne tum logon ki 'band' nahin bajjayi lol.
His views related partition is disgusting
Baji he spoke truth
That's why you are in this state of bankruptcy .
hahha......yeah someone is in denial despite the do qaumi nazariat BILKUL NAAKAAM sabit hua........alag mulk banane ke faide hi faide.............APNE HI sadiq ur amin amirul momineens ne gira diye nasheman par bijliyan............now maqbooza Pakistan.........wahid islami mulk
Truth is hard to digest.
Because your books teach you lies