Sailor Starlights - 90s & Cosmos Group Transformation
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 7 มิ.ย. 2023
- Fanmade!
Copyright Disclaimer under Section 107 of the
copyright act 1976, allowance is made for fair use for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favour of fair use.
The 90s VAs had a certain power in their voices just like when Sailor Uranus is on screen: World Shaking!!!!
its just a eco
@@mauriciomoura657 The 90s voice actors had mad skills, very professional, theatrical and knew how to properly execute emotions. The new age Japanese voice actors, just like the new English dub actors, don't have the proper training. They sound like kids who were picked up on the street with no real talent.
@@Ralph_Kreutzberger-BlumenfeldThose Americans gave the Japanese that nasty voice acting virus.
Yeh... I want to hear like screaming voice in daily
Naturally the 90’s reflects more on giving them a distinguished and diverse set of personalities. They were more personalized in the Classic series and given more depth as individuals and different when as civilians vs sailors since they physically changed into men. While in Cosmos being more reflective of the manga arc which shows them being more as a set of people that shared the same mission goals and being more mission focused especially since they are officially girls pretending to be boys and actually hold more trust toward Sailor Moon. So Classic definitely tops Cosmos for the voices and music. Favorite voice was Seiya from the 90’s. RIP to Shiho Niiyama the voice of Seiya/Fighter.
90s just feels more…personal - both In Transformation & Battle Cries
It's also because nowadays everything's computer generated. Makes it lack soul and depth.
I was born 1992,90s was amazing world for me I miss it alt
90es Transformation is the best ❤
I like the 90's voice actors more I miss fighters old voice😭😭😭 I miss you Shiho Niiyama😭😭😭
(Edit: eyy 177 likes! Thank you guys!)
The 90s transformation music is also much better. It’s so epic and fits the starlights more. The new one pales in comparison.
Me too 😭😭
She was phenomenal. Seiya's voice could never be mistaken even in a group voice thanks to her. And it fits him so much too. I love the way that she doesn't try too hard, the voice just sounds effortlessly cool and strong just like Seiya.
@@skylar4775 IKR!!
@@harmony137 Well said. Shiho Niiyama was the perfect Seiya. And that scream when Kakyu died? PuuuuurrrriiinnSESSSUUUUUUUU! That pierced my heart.
OMG the 90s voices have so much more charisma and emotion 😯 Each one is distinctive and beautiful. The new version just failed to recapture that magic, they sound generic, almost bored 😥
I agree with ya the 90s voice actor put their soul into the anime now days some you still feel it and some meh no offense but that's my opinion ❤😊
The older version is surprisingly more dynamic than the new Cosmos version.
You can see it especially with Sailor Star Healer in the way each of her gloves and boots are independently animated going up her limbs.
While in the newer version, it's literally just one big wipe then a flash cut to the complete outfit. As a result, it lost a lot of detail in depicting the clothing.
Guys it's not even a competition. The original is a masterpiece visually, musically and even their voices are amazing. Say what you will about them being male in civilian form, but the change in their physique was stunning, it's pure art. Everything looks graceful and fluid, while the new version just looks rigid and soulless.
thats what we call being blinded by nostalgia. 90s star fighter transformations always annoyed me. but for voices you are right
@@blep8336 No. Even from a digital art pov 90s one is better than the other lol. No one is blinded here, the new version looks very awkward, what with how she jumps up by swinging 1 of her leg up 180 degree
@@harmony137 bitch better than doing nothing. 90s is just windows xp effects
Agreed. The original looks way more dynamic and fluid.
To say the 90's were soulless is a bit too much
リアタイで見てたからかも知れないけど、昔の方が好みかな。
カッコイイ😊
旧作の方がオシャレ
La mejor transformación es la de los 90's ❤
They made the Cosmos VA more masculine it seems. Not a judgement, just an observation. I can't wait to watch it!
I'm genuinely curious how you view it as more masculine. The new VA is a lot more subtle and gentle, mysterious voice. Even the way she sang the songs uses more feminine effects/techniques. The 90s VA might use a higher pitch, but the tone of her voice sounds clearer, very straightforward. She uses lots of grits and explosive dynamics, which highlights Seiya's confidence and the "fighter" aspect of his personality.
I may be the odd one here, but I don't mind their new transformations. I was super taken aback when they were first teased (I even stopped the video to laugh lol), but I think after watching it so many times now it's grown on me :} I still enjoy the 90s transformations and music, but I don't think there is anything wrong in enjoying the new one as well :} Thanks so much for this upload comparison!
The new transformation is creative, but the music is definitely not as good.
animation is entirely fine, the music is awful, I am so upset all they did was copy-paste the manga with no soul or passion, on top of missing any panel that was more serious/violent
@@SM-ce1uy except tap dancing, that animation is outright awful.
Old animation was not perfect everywhere, but it looks much cleaner in this case.
Same, it was so unexpected! 😂 The frickin' tap dancing and all. Still going to enjoy the rest of the movie(s), haha.
@@EveRosell That tap dancing looks ridiculous. It just doesn't flow well with the transformation.
Me quedo con la sensualidad que destilan las de los 90s puro fuego 😅
旧作はBGMも見せ方もうまい
90s was much better but I like the revamped character animation and that they brought on the original art director!!
I think the biggest mistake modern sailor moon remakes make is trying to modernize the artstyle. The artstyle that was so iconic it became almost synonymous with 80-90s shojo. The artstyle people study and emulate when they want to do nostalgic anime fanart.
The new sailor moon (and a lot of other modern anime) feels very bleak to me having almost Family Guy color scheme with mute beiges for everything thats not bright ass primary color.
90's anime is just better period
I have always loved these characters so much. The older I got and the more I came
To understand about my own queer journey, the more sense it continues to make
新しい方はプリキュア感が強すぎて…微妙…
90s transformation had better composition and choreography (in that it made SENSE and flowed with PURPOSE instead of just flexing on a higher number of frames in modern animation)
I actually love them both versions but the original will always be a classic transformation
Nostalgia is a hard thing to beat. So I will just love both.
昔の方が好き
The 90’s one’s give you the sense of difference and individuality. While the Cosmos ones sound like they are announcing their character when you land on them on the character selection screen of a fighting game. 😂
Сейлормун 90-х годов намного лучше в плане эмоций и передачи индивидуальности героев... И анимация немного мягче, приятнее воспринимается...
la mejor version sin duda alguna es la de los 90s, nadie hara la voz y las canciones tan perfectas como lo hacia Shiho Niiyama. Lo mejor de lo mejor es Sailor Moon Stars 90s
Seeing this comparsion, I loved how strong 90's voice is compare to the remake version. But both are good in their own ways. I still loved seiya voice from the 90s'!
I like the taller slender look, plus the close up transformation gives it more of a dimention. The new one looks flat.
Tbh I love the both. When I discovered our dear fighter va died I was so heartbroken but I’m sure the new fighter will make an amazing job. Even tho the transformations have changed I think is a good element.
I can’t not love the new ones lol but animation wise, 90s was better
The voice from the 90s have more charisma and emotion than the new version. In terms of animation, I give props to the new version for its fluidity and clean animation. The only thing that ticks me off is the stupid tap dancing sequence when transforming. They look stupid and retarded doing it. I really wish they animated the old transformation. They look more badass.
90's better
the 90s song for this transformation murders the new song
For me it's right up there with the Outer Senshi theme.
90s is WAY better! Remake is just AWKWARD!
Did they really make Cosmos Starlights tap dance to get battle ready?
its a horrible mess
I don't know. It worked wonders for Kyoryuger when they did the samba dance during transformation.
th-cam.com/video/U1Y1OvpQ9Tg/w-d-xo.html
I was taken aback at first, like why tap dancing? The first time I watched it, I was like ”well that was random…” xD But it has grown on me now and I kinda like it, especially Yaten’s dance!
I wish they had given them each a different dance style. Just one of them tap dancing (probably Yaten lol) would have been enough.
Technically only Healer is actually tap dancing, the other two are just dancing, which is honestly funny to me like is she Irish now? What, because of the green?
The comparisons are a thing made of nonsense, they are beautiful in its own way. It's not easy to be an animator these days, and in Japan is also that doesn't gets paid well so lets cheer them and just recognize the hard work, and be grateful of them giving us at least a revival of SM.
Agreed
The 90s one is superior, hands down.
90 voice better than 2023😅
Faces look better in the original. I mean, just look at the preview of this video. Shading in new one feels too flat, while original shading makes face more defined.
Original simply looks sharper. And... actual black colors on their outfits! XD
Why modern artists are so much afraid of pure black color in art?
Nothing beats the original
セーラースターヒラ〜ところツボになる
Анімація 90-х набагато краща ніж Кришталь. Мені зображення персонажів з оновленої Сейлор Мун взагалі не подобається, хоча до сюжету претензій немає. Якби творці аніме малювали у стилі тої Сейлор Мун яку ми всі знаємо, то було б набагато краще. Це моя думка.
Is it just me or does the new voice sound like they have gum in their mouth
Yes
やっぱりスターライツは旧だなぁ
映画は良かったけど正直タップダンスはちょっと未だに受け入れられない
Holy Crap! As much as I'm not interested in Sailor Moon Cosmos, the song in the background is good!!
Back then when i was younger (9) i was confused on what they are, and till this day i am still confused 😐 (20)
Well, let me explain :
In the both the manga and 90s anime the sailor starlights are sailor shenshi from a planet destroyed by Galaxia (the big bad of the season ) .
Incase you're confused ab the starlights gender I will explain it to you :3 :
In the manga the sailor starlights are only female but the 90s anime crew ( besides Naoko ) were wanting the sailor starlights to be only male but Naoko was against that beacose only girls can be sailor shenshi so the other crew bitter as fuck for that made this change : the sailor starlights are shenshi that come to earth to escape from Galaxia attack and while on earth the sailors "choose" an male form to be on earth but changed back to female when they were transforming into sailors a change to the story that wasn't that much acknowledged within the story besides one time by Kakyu
Sound of all starlights in cosmos is totaly flavourless and pretty much the same in their speech, why :c
The 90-x one is the best, cosmos could try to do better, even if this characters are not main
I don't even talk about graphics and music
旧アニメの方は、男から女に変わるから、声も若干性格も変わるんだよね。
でも映画版は原作と同じで男装していて、多分体は女の子。
変身で服が変わるだけだから、声も話し方もボーイッシュな感じのままなんだよね。
旧アニメで育ってきた身としては、声優さんは豪華✨って思ったけど、もう少し活躍の場を作ってほしかったな…って思った
구버전은 남자에서 여자가 된다는 느낌이 강한데 신버전은 변신해도 남자같다.. 목소리도 구버전이 더 중성적
Curioso por la creadora de sialor moon no le gustó ese aspecto de los 90 pero en esta versión de crystal no ha dicho nada al respecto
I’ve always liked the start of their transformations in the 90s version, but was rather meh about the rest when compared to the transformation of the others. I think the new had some fairly interesting ideas but oh god does the tap dancing just take me out-feel like it was so unnecessary 🤦♀️. I do like the spins and the stage setup though, but ultimately the intro from the 90s leaves a more lasting impression
Оссобенно Ятен
I hate being that person. But gosh the music was way better in the 90's version. I'm sure the new voices will be easy to get used to - I'll probably watch the english version anyway. But gosh dang the music.
yes, they got the animation right but the music is so bland, it's giving nothing
Cosmosは音楽も演出もカッコいい。
🌌美少女戦士セーラームーン セーラースターズ🌌
The little dance they do before transforming was an odd choice.
90年
人物を回転させながらカメラワークの大胆な寄り引き
これを手書きでやってるのがすごい
新作
0:01とか、人物の動きが全然ない
いくら背景の効果つけても疾走感がまったくない
Las del 90 son más finas y sexys, las actuales aunque son las heroínas que amamos, parecen niñas 😅
新しいセーラームーン所々見てるけれども、やっぱり旧作の方が刺さるんだよなぁ
タップダンス取り入れなくても良かったのになぁ。
スターズがアイドルだからそれを出す為にステップ踏んでってやったんだろうけれども、前の方がアイドル感出てたと思うけどなぁ
i honestly cannot make a comparison. the transformations are great but I like the latter more because they are not yelling when introducing themselves
I LOVE 90S BETTER!!
흐앙 예뻐~~~~~
This the first time I actually prefer the new transformation sequence vs the old. And, yes, I saw the fansubs back in the day. It's all a matter of personal opinion.
The 90's was better 😢
Only 90s 🙌🏼
They took out the fun of the gradual transformation to add...tap dancing? Is this a talent show?
90s version is way more stylish and cool, as usual. I like Fighter's final pose more in Cosmos and that's about it. Even the voice direction isn't anywhere near as powerful.
🌌劇場版 美少女戦士セーラームーン Cosmos🌌
The dance is going to get getting used to.
90s al tje way
出た‼︎（笑）
伝説の性転換変身‼︎（笑）
WHY ARE THEY TAP DANCING 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
90s dominated .. additionally the new ones lack black in their costume
Me quedo con la de los 90s.
90's is better, change my mind
Me molestó mucho 1:22 ese bailecito, x eso me quedo con el de los 90's
Ese baile se justifica porque son literal artistas xd.
@@ladyalice1274en sí no, porque el tre light solo se enfoca a cantar no a bailar, tuviera sentido si hiciera un tipo de canto
@@sutki_111 pero si ellos también bailan XD así que tiene sentido.
the 90s anime sure wasnt perfect but SMC falls just very short when compared to the 90s version. the fact that both versions are from the same studio is just....how..??!! why??!
Studio Pierrot has the same problem, unfortunately... I started to see that this is common problem with anime now and it's sad
In new version, they must dance before they can henshin
I... don't know what to think of the Cosmos version..
Amazing🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩
the voice actors in cosmos sound flat as a wet weekend
90’s is way better…but the new version is growing me. At first I hated it. 😅
ugh once again the 90s Moonies make a BS excuse to like 90s more just to BS the remake and trash them as much as they like. first of all the transformation in the 90s and music is great but cosmos did the best as it can with animation and music and even that was actually good it's actually new and different and it's well crafted and made.
both of them are great in their own way and it's not fair to compare them in a hostile way.😑🙄
The voice of sailor healer its the same one of Andromeda Shun in Hades Inferno???
I just want to know what Naokos thought process that landed on leather biker dominatrix for their theme
th-cam.com/video/qHuh__87ZIo/w-d-xo.htmlsi=zQ9jyISa-0OZguQr
Is this movie already out?
Part 1 is out! June 9th
I like the 90’s original better.
Новое мне больше нравится
90's 100%
圧倒的に90年代！
タップダンスは草w
I don’t really like both anime’s but tbh I would like the 90’s better even tho I hate the new one and the 90’s one
旧作のスターライツの変身シーン見たとき、他のキャラよりイマイチかっこよく見えなかったけど、新作のと比較したら前の方がまだよく見える😅
新作本編見たらタップダンスの理由分かるのかな？
name song
Tap dancing is a choice…. Also all their new voices sounds too similar.
I know I grew up with the original, so I'm biased. Gosh, I just don't feel the energy with the new one. It's well animated, sure, but it's very... clumsy. Yes, that's the word. Perfer the original voice actors.
I don't like anything about the Cosmos versions of the Starlights. Their voices are very boring and the henshin sequence is a huge let down in how bland it is.
The Starlights always had a very noticeable "punch" to them in the 90s version, it set them apart from the other senshi and made then feel powerful in a different way that the other girls. Now, they just feel so flat...like a trio of NPCs.
they do sound like NPCs now that you mention it.
@@SM-ce1uy Healer especially. Her original voice was SO powerful, now it sounds so fake and bad.
Don’t waste your time with this movie, what you see is what you get. The pacing is the worst I’ve ever seen in a film they can say 1:1 manga all they want it doesn’t excuse an emotionless adaption.
탭댄스 진짜 때쳐치워라
I love the new ones!
全然声も顔違うじゃん。。泣プリキュア化しないでほしい
90 better
I’m also like a fan of the new song “tsuki no hana”. It isn’t bad, but it’s vibe just doesn’t match the series imo.