It's great that Bob still wants to surprise us with a performance as in days of old. Why sit back and sleep his life away when he's still young at heart? Some people are straight out envious that he still has the motivation. The real fans applaud you Bob from the bottom of our hearts!
I like how his aged voice sounds - he's earned that voice. His lyrics are still powerful poetry. I'm seeing him at the Palace in Waterbury next month - very excited!
There he is! Having achieved evrything a singer/songwriter possibly can. Never sold himself neither to the devil, nor the industry (is there any notable difference between). Better than he has been in a long time. Peace and may you stay forever young Mr. Zimmermann.
His mind is sharper than anyone I know at his age ! Bob don't need any teleprompters or in ear monitors it's all up there in his head . Absolutely amazing for a man his age . LOVE YOU MR.DYLAN ty for supporting FARM AID .
And Mike Campbell on lead guitar wow still suffering from the loss of his best friend and band mate Tom Petty teaming up with Dylan . You gotta really know your music to be able to appreciate just how special this is ❤️ 💙
Hey Josh- I've been an unwavering fan of Bob Dylan from the very beginning. There is non more talented! I'm amazed he is still touring. I hope to see him live one more time!
Dylan Dylan Dylan he is allowed himself to play and sing the way he wants to. He has done everything he wanted, others don't, others just hide living wealthy. Dylan is there for the people, stand UP as possible. 🎉❤
That's Dylan for us. Surprises everyone. Plays with a band he hasn't worked with in years. All while he picks up a guitar and plays 3 tunes he hasn't done in years.
Dylan has played farm aid a number of times, this performance was so under rehearsed, the band and Dylan are going through the motions. This was one of the worst performances iv seen of Dylan.
@@rogerd3051 he doesn't even acknowledge the audience ever. I wouldn't waste my money. He will play the opposite of what everybody wants him to play I think he gets off on that.
@@stringlocker Every time I've seen him play, he played exactly what the audience wanted, although the audience might have not been aware of it. These three songs are true Dylan classics.
All this talk about age bewilders me, this sounds better and far more innovative than when they originally played together nearly 40 years ago. I don’t know what we’re gonna do without him.
You are 100% on track! Bob Dylan actually sounds better than he did in the1980's. The whole "age talk" bugs me too! I am Bob's age and still jog and play volleyball. I refurbish houses and maintain my 2 acre lot with 50 trees. Age is just a number!
Bravo dear, you are so adorably cool ! I’ll never tire of watching, listening or loving you! Take care, god bless, Love and respect ! Sincerely , Your next? Kidding….shrugs ,awe❤
Neil Young had just wrapped up a short four song set and left the stage - we were all surprised how short the performance was … next thing you know Bob is seen on stage setting up. What a complete surprise! Glad I was there to see this performance.
Bob Dylan is still the greatest musician. Especially with the Heart breakers live at the farm aid concert. Love from a fan of yours Adam ❤❤❤❤❤😊. I really respect Bob Dylan playing great guitar.
Glad I saw Dylan in 2017 doing all the oldies and standing. It was actually the original first notable time he did so. Jus sayin. His voice has sounded better and he has played guitar for a few years now. I hope I get to see him one more time.
It sounds like this arrangement of Positively 4th Street has a touch of Neil Young's "Powderfinger" woven in. Bob may have been doing it that way for years but as a casually serious fan, it would have escaped me.
Seems to me that when Bob plays with these guys it excites him. He sounds better than he does with his regular band. “Bob Dylan and The Heartbreakers” tour should happen.
@@Piggy-Oink-Oink Yeah.. I saw Woolhalls early this afternoon... I believe I found a even better picture on the channel: MUSIC ENHANCE Please tell me if you think its better.
This would be great. The heartbreakers need someone who will sing actual lyrics, and play electric, and bob dylan needs to decide if he will return from obscurity to actually do something with his skills. Other than these HUGE MASSIVE DIFFERENCES, this may be a good thing. we all want to see the heartbreakers continue
@@jordansmith5978 I mean to whomever was writing the comment that was so critical and used caps, you know. I felt it was too harsh and not too well informed.
@@jordansmith5978 also I don't think I was addressing you. It was to whomever wrote some mean comment. I'm not seeing it here now. Maybe they deleted it. No biggie
@@basilmina8001please explain him to us then. I’ve been a pro musician for 50 years and I don’t understand him in any positive way in terms of his poor etiquette. At one point Mike starts a slow and Dylan just plays right over him.
Ballad of a Trumping Man (2020) [Verse 1] You walk into the Oval Office With your smartphone in your hand You see David Duke smile And you say, “Who is that man?” You try so hard But you don’t understand You tell the Survivor staff “This joint’s a real dump!” [Refrain] ‘Cause something is happening here But you don’t know what it is Do you, Mr. Trump? [Verse 2] You hit your golf ball Then you ask, “Is this where it is?” And Lindsey Graham points to you and says “It is” And you say, “That’s mine?” And Don Jr. says, “Where what is?” And you say, “Oh my God I just beat Forrest Gump!” [Refrain] But something is happening And you don’t care what it is Do you, Mister Trump? [Verse 3] You pardon Sheriff Joe Your face on yuge TVs The base bows down to you Ah, those precious Greenville memories And you ask, “How does it feel To be white like me?” You think they’re terrific So you give them fist-pumps [Refrain] And something is alt-right here But you don’t see what it is Do you, Mister Trump? [Verse 4] You have many contacts Among the paid hacks To get you facts When the press attacks your imagination But nobody has any respect Anyway they already expect you To just give applause To climate denier pollutin’ organizations [Verse 5] You’ve been with your accountants Fox & Friends hate your looks With great lawyers you have Discussed Russians and crooks You’ve been through all of Barron’s Grade 8 textbooks You’re very well read You’re no chump [Refrain] But something is happening here And you don’t smell what it is Do you, Mister Trump? [Verse 6] Well, the Bible preacher, he comes up to you And then he kneels He crosses himself And he thinks you make great deals And without further notice He asks you how it feels And he says, “I want my soul back. I’m in a slump” [Refrain] And you know something is happening But you don’t like what it is Do you, Mister Trump? [Verse 7] Now you see this man in white Saying the word “Seek” And you ask, “For what reason?” And he says, “Be meek” And you ask, “What does this mean?” And he says, “Your life’s bleak. Give the poor all your wealth Or follow the man Trump.” [Refrain] And you know something’s happening But you don’t know who he is Do you, Mister Trump? [Verse 8] Well, you fly to Mar-a-Lago Watch CNN and then you frown You keep Bill Barr in your pocket And your hair in a mound There ought to be a law Against you lyin’ around You should be made To wear speed bumps [Refrain] ‘Cause the joke is on you now And you don’t get what it is Do you, Mister Trump?
Yeah, wish I had a grandfather who could still perform in his 80's. I didn't even have a gramps! Bob isn't going to sit back in his rocking chair and sleep 24/7 like alot his age.
Either my ear is shot or one of the guitarists is playing in a different key than everyone else. Im a huge Dylan fan, a huge Mike Campbell fan, but this sounds AWFUL.
Bob does this on purpose.. mike had some rough moments during solo of ballad of a thin man but thats ok. He has not played these for a longtime and Everyone gets nervous playing with Bob.
@@STRAT1974 I hear you. Guess it depends on the individual. A devoted fan wouldn't care how Bob performed, they'd be like me and go just to see him. Stay home and listen to the records in future!
It's great that Bob still wants to surprise us with a performance as in days of old. Why sit back and sleep his life away when he's still young at heart? Some people are straight out envious that he still has the motivation. The real fans applaud you Bob from the bottom of our hearts!
I am blown away. Hope to see you live again in 2024.
This made my day, week and month ... 😎
Love it! Dylan whipping out licks! He has never lost his fervor for his old songs.🎸
Thanks for sharing. I wish I was there, but I'm glad I can watch it from the other side of the world too.
I like how his aged voice sounds - he's earned that voice. His lyrics are still powerful poetry. I'm seeing him at the Palace in Waterbury next month - very excited!
What did you think of his performance
This was just exactly perfect
Many thanks
thanks for posting this show so people who weren't there can see it. thanks much.
Bob Dylan right there in 2023 ! WOW !!!
A last LIVING LEGEND.
a big SUPRISE 4 those attendees!
Wow! him back on guitar on stage! great!! thanks a lot for sharing this marvellous document!!!
ballad of a thin man, that was the best live ive seen was very nice
There he is! Having achieved evrything a singer/songwriter possibly can. Never sold himself neither to the devil, nor the industry (is there any notable difference between). Better than he has been in a long time. Peace and may you stay forever young Mr. Zimmermann.
He told the world he sold his soul to the devil very plainly on 60 Minutes. He wasn't joking about it.
His mind is sharper than anyone I know at his age ! Bob don't need any teleprompters or in ear monitors it's all up there in his head . Absolutely amazing for a man his age . LOVE YOU MR.DYLAN ty for supporting FARM AID .
And Mike Campbell on lead guitar wow still suffering from the loss of his best friend and band mate Tom Petty teaming up with Dylan . You gotta really know your music to be able to appreciate just how special this is ❤️ 💙
Thank you thank you thank you
Back on the guitar...! Essential Dylan...! And...Positively 4th Street...we are blessed.
I agree but he should stick to chords and let Mike Campbell play the leads. Plus his guitar is WAY to loud in the mix. Still a fun listen.
@@imanalien2222yep, he’s not really got the hang of playing lead.
This is awesome! I just got into Dylan last year and I love him now. I hope I get the chance to see him live just once!
You will find he’s done some good stuff.
Hey Josh- I've been an unwavering fan of Bob Dylan from the very beginning. There is non more talented! I'm amazed he is still touring. I hope to see him live one more time!
Fantastic Thank youu Bob Dylan🌹🌺❣️
Dylan Dylan Dylan he is allowed himself to play and sing the way he wants to. He has done everything he wanted, others don't, others just hide living wealthy. Dylan is there for the people, stand UP as possible. 🎉❤
That's Dylan for us. Surprises everyone. Plays with a band he hasn't worked with in years. All while he picks up a guitar and plays 3 tunes he hasn't done in years.
Sounds like you are making excuses for him. He has sounded like this for the past 40 years😂 or longer
Dylan has played farm aid a number of times, this performance was so under rehearsed, the band and Dylan are going through the motions. This was one of the worst performances iv seen of Dylan.
@@rogerd3051 he doesn't even acknowledge the audience ever. I wouldn't waste my money. He will play the opposite of what everybody wants him to play I think he gets off on that.
@@rogerd3051 The last time Dylan played Farm Aid was.....wait for it....1986. He's played 3 times in 38 years.
@@stringlocker Every time I've seen him play, he played exactly what the audience wanted, although the audience might have not been aware of it. These three songs are true Dylan classics.
Bob is on fire!!!!!
fantastic short set. band tight as always.
00:01 Maggie's Farm
4:55 Positively 4th Street
9:06 Ballad of a Thin Man
After all that’s gone on and all the musician’s deaths in this country, this was much needed.
Man! I hope he comes to Minnesota again! Ever phenomenal, and his band too! Thanks Mark!
All this talk about age bewilders me, this sounds better and far more innovative than when they originally played together nearly 40 years ago. I don’t know what we’re gonna do without him.
You are 100% on track! Bob Dylan actually sounds better than he did in the1980's. The whole "age talk" bugs me too! I am Bob's age and still jog and play volleyball.
I refurbish houses and maintain my 2 acre lot with 50 trees. Age is just a number!
Bravo dear, you are so adorably cool ! I’ll never tire of watching, listening or loving you! Take care, god bless, Love and respect ! Sincerely , Your next? Kidding….shrugs ,awe❤
I don't think Dylan has played this much guitar in concert since the early 2000s. Also, his voice hasn't sounded this good in 20 years.
Superb 💫🎼
With flowers 🌺 in our hair
Thank you Bob or making my day 😻❤
So cool...with Benmont Tench around, why not grab a guitar?
That was a treat after all this time. Ho Ho, still peeved at someone with a lot of nerve but checking for a realisation.
Amazing really. It’s the Endless Tour with endless brilliance
Beyond all us . But not beyond God . Bob is only a human being we all are enthralled by .
Love Bob Dylan…….. I’ll hope he’s soul and mind stays in sync………forever 😇🇸🇪🤗❤️🔥🫵
Neil Young had just wrapped up a short four song set and left the stage - we were all surprised how short the performance was … next thing you know Bob is seen on stage setting up. What a complete surprise! Glad I was there to see this performance.
Great band. Great crowd (it’s a gathering of the faithful). Come back to Aus please 🙏🇦🇺❤️
Love Bobby…but it can be a TOUGH gig playing with him. Props to the band.
The look on Ferrone’s face at the chaotic end to Maggie’s Farm is priceless.
Dylan is the greatest.
Fabulous still so cool ❤
Bob Dylan is still the greatest musician. Especially with the Heart breakers live at the farm aid concert. Love from a fan of yours Adam ❤❤❤❤❤😊. I really respect Bob Dylan playing great guitar.
Cada vez melhor grande Bob Dylan
O maior músico de todos os tempos um grande genio
Such a relevant song, so perfectly delivered by the best of the best. Do you really think the heart breakers come out for anyone else? No.
Dylan is the best
Bob ❤
This proves he can still play pretty good live. WIsh I got this when I seen him at the Outlaw Festival with Willie and Robert Plant.
Glad I saw Dylan in 2017 doing all the oldies and standing. It was actually the original first notable time he did so. Jus sayin. His voice has sounded better and he has played guitar for a few years now. I hope I get to see him one more time.
It sounds like this arrangement of Positively 4th Street has a touch of Neil Young's "Powderfinger" woven in. Bob may have been doing it that way for years but as a casually serious fan, it would have escaped me.
Yes, even Maggie's Farm sounded like Crazy Horse! Dylan solo's have Jerry Garcia scope. It's going to be "Grateful Horse" or "Crazy Dead"!
Same Dylan. No body signs Dylan as Dylan. Nobel prize. Thank you Boby.0
Good as i been to you .
Love the bit at 6:42 where he adjusts the mic stand so he can see his left hand while singing.
💔s🎸🎹🥁 Mike, Benmont, Steve!
the heartbreakers had a good time im sure, RIP TP
A textbook example, by the whole crew, of rockin' true classics with "dignity".
He is a punk and i love him
it's hard rain baby
Seems to me that when Bob plays with these guys it excites him. He sounds better than he does with his regular band. “Bob Dylan and The Heartbreakers” tour should happen.
Why is the volume so criminally low? This performance sounds epic, but it would be ecstatic to hear it at the level it merits.
♥♥♥
UNBELIEVEABLE. on guitar too !!!
Is he playing rhythm? wow that’s unbelievable, fancy that!.
His electric playing is indeed unbelievable. I can honestly say I’ve never heard playing quite like it: marvellous isn’t the word for it!
I think that’s Tom Pettys band for the biggest part
Thank God the spirit of Kurt Cobain is still alive and that Dylan carries the torch that is red hot! Maggie’s Farm indeed!
Miss you ❤❤❤
It sounds like no one knows what to do. They’re all looking at each other.
Like the pros they are they’re trying to avoid being made to sound like complete amateurs.
@@JayStapley true but they’re also watching him because he changes keys apparently, in the middle of songs
i dont think they did rehearsals or anything, still a fun listen but Dylan and touring band are a lot more tight
soundman did him no favors with his sloppy guitar so hot in the mix, but dang his voice is great!
Where was this show???who else was on the bill
Good point. Would be good to know who other musicians are...
your mom was on my bill last night
Farm Aid concert three days ago
Heartbreakers sound good
wow they got that dude standing by him like he might fall over or something
He's wearing the hat. Someone's got to.
♥❤❤❤❤❤❤ 😇 ✌ 💋 💋 💋
Too bad the sound is so low.
Any one know the names of the band members haven’t seen him in a while
RIP RNR
RE- UP can hardly hear it with volume at 100
He wont even respond..
It's ridiculously low
@@AMEER-114- It's been posted in full by WOOLHALL check his upload. He always comes through.
@@Piggy-Oink-Oink
Yeah..
I saw Woolhalls early this afternoon...
I believe I found a even better picture on the channel:
MUSIC ENHANCE
Please tell me if you think its better.
@@AMEER-114- You are right. It;s a bit better. Wonder what the story is..he wasnt booked for Farm Aid..must have had a free day and came to help out
@@Piggy-Oink-Oink
Umm..
Even more curious...
How did Mike Cambell, Tench, Ferrone and Larry Cambell ? end up rejoining him for the event...
I think he's playing in a different key than the band.
Bob jamming with Tom Petty's old band
I like Dylan and all, but...
I don't get it....
Real Quiet!!! Is this legal?
I'm 68 ... and i say I'm 24 😂
This would be great. The heartbreakers need someone who will sing actual lyrics, and play electric, and bob dylan needs to decide if he will return from obscurity to actually do something with his skills. Other than these HUGE MASSIVE DIFFERENCES, this may be a good thing. we all want to see the heartbreakers continue
What do you mean Dylan doesn’t do anything? He made an amazing album in 2020 and tours constantly
Who's writing your comment, Donald J?
@@davidrobinson9507lol what?
@@jordansmith5978 I mean to whomever was writing the comment that was so critical and used caps, you know. I felt it was too harsh and not too well informed.
@@jordansmith5978 also I don't think I was addressing you. It was to whomever wrote some mean comment. I'm not seeing it here now.
Maybe they deleted it. No biggie
low volume
My ears are bleeding from this
Bob is ripping on the guitar better now at 83 than he was back in his hay day in the 60s, go figure.
What was the age of the kids from school of rock who arranged this? UHHH
Not sure you actually understand him.
@@basilmina8001please explain him to us then. I’ve been a pro musician for 50 years and I don’t understand him in any positive way in terms of his poor etiquette. At one point Mike starts a slow and Dylan just plays right over him.
sound?
Better sharpen your pencil Mr. Jones.
Oof
You worked on Netanyahu's farm, Mr. Frost. Sold out long ago. Antique's road show. pfft. Stick to your "Heaven's Gate" swill.
242
Ballad of a Trumping Man (2020)
[Verse 1]
You walk into the Oval Office
With your smartphone in your hand
You see David Duke smile
And you say, “Who is that man?”
You try so hard
But you don’t understand
You tell the Survivor staff
“This joint’s a real dump!”
[Refrain]
‘Cause something is happening here
But you don’t know what it is
Do you, Mr. Trump?
[Verse 2]
You hit your golf ball
Then you ask, “Is this where it is?”
And Lindsey Graham points to you and says
“It is”
And you say, “That’s mine?”
And Don Jr. says, “Where what is?”
And you say, “Oh my God
I just beat Forrest Gump!”
[Refrain]
But something is happening
And you don’t care what it is
Do you, Mister Trump?
[Verse 3]
You pardon Sheriff Joe
Your face on yuge TVs
The base bows down to you
Ah, those precious Greenville memories
And you ask, “How does it feel
To be white like me?”
You think they’re terrific
So you give them fist-pumps
[Refrain]
And something is alt-right here
But you don’t see what it is
Do you, Mister Trump?
[Verse 4]
You have many contacts
Among the paid hacks
To get you facts
When the press attacks your imagination
But nobody has any respect
Anyway they already expect you
To just give applause
To climate denier pollutin’ organizations
[Verse 5]
You’ve been with your accountants
Fox & Friends hate your looks
With great lawyers you have
Discussed Russians and crooks
You’ve been through all of
Barron’s Grade 8 textbooks
You’re very well read
You’re no chump
[Refrain]
But something is happening here
And you don’t smell what it is
Do you, Mister Trump?
[Verse 6]
Well, the Bible preacher, he comes up to you
And then he kneels
He crosses himself
And he thinks you make great deals
And without further notice
He asks you how it feels
And he says, “I want my soul back.
I’m in a slump”
[Refrain]
And you know something is happening
But you don’t like what it is
Do you, Mister Trump?
[Verse 7]
Now you see this man in white
Saying the word “Seek”
And you ask, “For what reason?”
And he says, “Be meek”
And you ask, “What does this mean?”
And he says, “Your life’s bleak.
Give the poor all your wealth
Or follow the man Trump.”
[Refrain]
And you know something’s happening
But you don’t know who he is
Do you, Mister Trump?
[Verse 8]
Well, you fly to Mar-a-Lago
Watch CNN and then you frown
You keep Bill Barr in your pocket
And your hair in a mound
There ought to be a law
Against you lyin’ around
You should be made
To wear speed bumps
[Refrain]
‘Cause the joke is on you now
And you don’t get what it is
Do you, Mister Trump?
Bravo!
Terrible
Love it.
Very appropriate.
Trump 2024 MAGA!
I think Trump n Dylan both get it. You I'm not so sure. 😊
The crazy visiting uncle on the couch. What is he babbling about ? Could someone bring him some seltzer water to clear his throat. Love ya Zimmy !
82 years old!!!
Yeah, wish I had a grandfather who could still perform in his 80's. I didn't even have a gramps! Bob isn't going to sit back in his rocking chair and sleep 24/7 like alot his age.
At 8:30 the band take matters into their own hands and impose an ending on the dreadful soloing going on.
Actually you can notice Bob giving Mike the nod and they finish the song together.
Either my ear is shot or one of the guitarists is playing in a different key than everyone else. Im a huge Dylan fan, a huge Mike Campbell fan, but this sounds AWFUL.
It’s Dylan’s guitar that’s out
Bob does this on purpose.. mike had some rough moments during solo of ballad of a thin man but thats ok. He has not played these for a longtime and Everyone gets nervous playing with Bob.
@@cumhurtimucin6985 that’s why I’ve walked out of his portion of a double bill at least twice
Great writer
Not a great performer
@@STRAT1974 I hear you. Guess it depends on the individual. A devoted fan wouldn't care how Bob performed, they'd be like me and go just to see him. Stay home and listen to the records in future!
Na ja .
Wow, something seems so out of tune
his guitar is out of tune........
They’re embarrassingly dazed 😅I like Dylan and Hearthbreakers. It seems they doesn’t follow the beat and somebody plays out of key. They can do better
Bob throws curveballs onstage, you really gotta be on your toes if you play with him.
Great band, but someone take that guitar away from Bob!
@@Theodre_Verany 🤣
He should be playing nursing homes for free
You had to be there, it was awesome
Very bad recording 🤨
Horrible. Did the band even rehearse?
lousy sound
I absolutely love this performance of ballad of a thin man Bob is the goat!!!!