Is homosexuality conflicting with cultural values of India?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 18 ก.ย. 2024
- After the Supreme Court recently ruled that homosexuality is illegal, we debate on Prime Time whether the judgement is right and whether gay lifestyles are opposed to our culture. Panelists debate whether the issue of homosexuality and gay rights gained significance simply because the West has become increasingly liberal on the subject. (Audio in Hindi)
Watch full show: khabar.ndtv.com...
So, you know what's unnatural? Marrying someone who you have no interest in sexually and ruining their life, but doing so anyway, just to please society and family.
Touché
What a bunch of non sense
Exactly true
@@yungman7053 get lost homophobe
U mean if u attracted to dog then their is another gender discovered
Who is here After section 377 is decriminalized!!!
One step to development
Me!
@@surinderpalkaur4282 true!
@KERALA TIGER it is
Watching this debate at a time high court debating to recognize gay marriage
Homosexuality was as natural as heterosexuality in India and it was never a Taboo nor was condemned by the Indian society or religion. It's only during the British rule, homosexuality was declared illegal by the British Govt. Indian religion, culture & tradition was too pagan for Britishers and therefore enforced their christian beliefs. The history of gays in India are as old as Ramayan & Mahabharata. In Ramayan, Rama never condemn gays but he blessed them, so also in Mahabharat, the great Hero Arjun had to be a Transvestite/ transgender for a year. Similarly Ambika intentionally was reborn as Hermaphrodite(Shikhandi) to exact her revenge on Bheeshma. Krishna and five great heroes of Mahabharat, Pandavas didn't reject Shikhandi's help based on her sexual identity or orientation but willingly accepted her help to defeat Bheeshma. Even the supreme gods Vishnu (Mohini incarnation) & Shiv (Ardhanarishvara) are Androgyne gods.
Ironically, the Britishers who declared homosexuality as illegal in India, made it legal in their own country. Before the advent of Britishers, homosexuality was never an issue in India. Today, when most of the western countries has gay rights, don't know why it is such a problem in India to accept gays despite the history of gay tolerance in Indian religion & tradition.
Fuck u
bill tyson The hatred you expressed on Jesus is similar to the hatred of Heterosexual Indians towards Homosexual Indians. Democracy means liberty & freedom which entails religion & sexual orientation.
who are u dude?
karmappa hi
Manu smriti opposes homosexuality
If it is a crime in religions...then obviously religons are flawed...
It is the humans who are flawed..
Ikr like they don't have anything to do with it 🙂
None religion say it's bad
It's just people of great following like religious leaders
That's why every one say
F*ck Religion
No matter which
All religions are based on old orthodox culture .
And the major reason for riots and terrorism
Our country is ran by the constitution not any religion!
it's amazing how Indian media is playing a fantastic role in informing people about the rights of the people... this gives me a lot of hope.. !
U gay?
Rahul Bhaskar Does that matter?
So by that standard, a white man who fights against racial discrimination againts the blacks, IS black? You clearly, have no sense of logic or understanding regarding the matter. Next time, comment only if you know what you're talking about.
Also, it seems you are rather proud of the fact that you're related to Freddy Mercury. It's a shame you don't know he was bisexual.
Imad Rais
There's a big difference between a black man and a homosexual and frankly it
s highly offensive when u say that. Freddie wasn't bisexual. He was gay and he dies of aids.
Wish there were more like Ravish. India needs more progressive voices in order to be a actual democracy. India and its constitution does not offer equal fundamental rights to all.
The woman deserves a high five. Even the man deserves a high five. In the face.
Yeah, right..
🤮🤮🤮
Old Noob 🤮🤮🤮 on you
That lady is very clear on her views
***** if its a choice when did you choose to be straight
Anupam Shrivastava
Yes everyone knows that they are stereotyped...But u see most of these flamboyant come from the gay community. Shameless! Not all..but most.
@@rahulbhaskar6790 what is shameless about it? And you are going around every comment spreading your hate filled message...seriously LOSER! Go get a job mahn, and a brain to go with it
And now we’re free! Love is always wins. Thank you to our govt
not the govt, the Supreme Court, the lawyers and the judges
Government was silent as its prominent leaders are homophobic.
The dude is wearing a SUIT saying we should not copy western countries🤣🤣🤣
😂😂
Ok to show his professionalism , he should come in Dhoti Kurta.
1) India is a diverse country supporting many religions.
2) India is intolerant to Homosexuality.
3) It wasn't always like that.
4) India was originally dominated by Hindus.
5) Hindu religion is based on many vedic sacred texts.
6) Those sacred texts embraced homosexual relationships. Such love tales are embraced as sacred and beautiful.
7) Those texts are GREATLY diverse on how different things work in this greatly non-uniformed universe.
8) Different forms of love, sexuality, bodies, forms, feelings, relationships, beliefs, views are portrait with equal purity and respect.
9) According to the texts, nothing in this universe is unnatural. Everything is natural. Any form of any feeling, birth is possible and entitled to be embraced.
10) Originally, Hindus and Hindu religion had the view of any form of love to be natural and tolerable.
11) Known to history is that- the influence of Islam and Christianity in India has changed the views and beliefs to quite great of an extant.
12) Those who had unusual forms in their perspective were punished throughout that era.
13) This still has managed to change the views of the current Indian population and continues to have the influence.
I can't comment on other religious beliefs but being a Hindu, I have my piece of view of it originally embracing any form of any product.
Now add that in Social Science books.
Homosexuality might be an offence in Hindu Society, but it sure ain't in Hindu religion.
God doesn't judge own's creation.
If everything is natural, is pedophilia, necrophilia and incest also natural and permitted?
rkp mizzed lol nice one.
BULLSHITTING story.
Bharata maata culture is full with stories about war against corruption and decadence.
Each time decadence and corruption raised, power abuse, rape and sexual abuse become normal, Vedic priest become powerless and good people were put under pressure to obey EVIL.
When this happened special people suddenly appear and challenge whole Society.
People like Chanakya stand up and destroy via spiritual way countries enemies while linking all kind of powers and re-educating society what dharma is.
@@mynameisritarar1 yes
No way! Got any proof mate?
Yes I will support and always LGBT community Because they also human have a right to live in this society The combination of all religions is that India does not worry about such trivial things, India will be with us 🙏🙏🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🙏🙏🙏
Humanity is a parasitic species, I want ki** 7 billion people to save MY MOTHER NATURE 🌚🖤
Shocked on these so called 'politicians' reactions!!
it's shameful our leader not agree to talk on these serious issue .
Respect for Ravish
Nice debate.. Waiting for the next part of this debate
lol, the MPs in the beginning. Do they think it's a joke?
Ravees kumar you are the Best
jab tak dharm is desh me hawi rahenge... tark, insaniyat or vikas ka to sochna bhi bebakufi hai
If we take Hindu Dharma into consideration, homosexuality is nothing unnatural and is portrait as sacred.
Iska dharm se kuch lena dena nahi hai. Jo log homosexuality ko pasand nahi karte wo dharam ka jhootha sahara lekar iska protest kar rahe hain jabki hindi dharm me isko offence nahi kaha gaya hai. Or ek baat pyaar se bada or koi dharm nahi hota nahi hindu nahi sikh nahi muslim or nahi Isaiah. Love is the greatest of all religion and you cannot say that loving someone is offence!!
@@saumil6679 Right
Deepak sir, desh sanvidhan par chalta hai, jab Manvi Adhikar ki baat hoti hai, koi mazzab maine nahi rakhta!
@@malhar__8932 sir samajh nahi aaya.. Kripya apne sentence ko rearrange kr lein, phir post karein..
Wow atleast India working on progress 😊 . Support LGBTQ . 🌈
india will be doomed then if they allow such evil activities
We need more debate 👍🏻.. ravish sir well done 🙏👍🏻
can't believe he said khamosh
In jaise Gadho ( Shotgun) ko aaj bhi shayad akal na aa payi ho😂
2022- ........377 is not here
.....jeet hmesa sch ki hoti
.......jeet hmesa pyar ki hoti h .....🤩🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🌈🏳️🌈🏳️🌈🏳️🌈🏳️🌈🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🏳️🌈🏳️🌈🇮🇳🇮🇳🏳️🌈🏳️🌈🏳️🌈
the topic needs fresh debate
Ravish Kumar is awesome😍😍
Every religion which discriminate lgbt is a flaw. Religion is the biggest reason behind the lack of development india. India will remain conservative and conservative will remain undeveloped and will go back in age. Who said that Indian culture is great??? Does discriminating lgbt, religions, women and immaturity depict indian culture. Shame on discriminatory conservative BJP politicians. Victory of BJP reflect the educated illiteracy of Indian citizens.
Short answer to the title: NO
Ravish sir, you are the best.
Please help homosexual people that they are facing two problems in their such as harassment violence bulling and depression and if some one facing this problem in their please share you are experience
love has no gender........ love is love.....
2 adults mai aanewale konsebhi relations unki sahamati hote huye crime kaise ho sakte Hai??? privacy part of life.....
True!
I think India is not secular country! Cuz when you fill any form then u will be asked about your religion! I am an Atheist and still I have to fill with HINDU! There is no freedom in India when it comes to Religion,Love,personal liberty!
Same here. It's just annoying and when I tell someone I'm atheist then they just look at me like they've seen a uncivilized Neanderthal. Must it be so?
@Shreya Sanjay 223 that's is a very foolish argument.
Why were religious people even called on debate? There is no role of religions to decide how a free society can and should behave. I think it is problem with Ravish Kumar who legitimized these people to even ask their opinions. They should have no say on such matters.
Because India is all religion, it is built about it
Listening music , watching tv , photography , etc are as sin in islam but they follow coz they are enjoying so ignore .....it's not about muslim or hindu ....we always accept those thing in which we feel enjoy and comfort ...then doesn't matter they are against of religion or in favour
Well said
@w There's a difference you r talking about crime when Homosexuality is simply love
One and only truthful news chanal NDTV lov it
Ravish kumar is lit 🔥…. I am proud that such journalists are there… always loved the way he never let pass any wrong comment!!!
Great Debate
homosexual hona natural haiii......
Kya y 100%truth h?
@@jaisingh-yl5hn then how do you know that being straight is 100% natural
Sir. bohot bohot dhanyawad iske liye
Thik bolecho,bro
Their love does not harm anyone, but your homophobia harms them.
I'm agree with you ravish kumar sir
Spot on Vrinda Ji.
Why music is running behind ravish kumar show????
Cultural values of India , lol what a joke 😂😂😂😂
SC advocate is saying prostitution is illegal in india??? Omg .... its legal.... only brotheling is a crime ...God help our judicial system...
yeh log to tatti me bhi culture dhoondte ,kya log hai
Wish it had english subtitles
He is a best and honest journalist of India 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳 and he is my favourite only.
all i have to say to all the haters who hate ANYthing different be it who you love be it how you look or dress up
WE are building a country of bullies
politicians, people everyone now thinks the louder voice is the right voice to them id like to quote
We cant fall any further
if we cant feel ordinary love
we cant reach any higher
if we cant deal with ordinary love
nd mind it love is love no matter what the sex of the person is
as long as you are human its ok
and Seriously our hate-country could use some lovin :)
Wonderful journalist!
Yes,bro,app kaha rehete ho
Good job Rawishji.
Common sense > religion
If u talk abt culture then just take a simple example.....hum sabhi english bol rahe h bilki english to hindu culture may h hi bhi nhi to hum konsa sanskrit may bate krte h?
Hindu mein aisa crime nahi hai idiot?!
This is the ravish which i admired the most
People need to decide the source of basis of morality. And then act upon it
I was not a supporter of Ravish Kumar but now I support his style of debate.🙏
All are God created people... i will accept and respect every human irrespective of their sexual preferences...
yrr ravish kumar tm ek sache reporter ho yrr ...
Kudos to ravish....Kya anchoring hai....maar li fuddu ki
I feel pained to watch this video.
then go to the hospital. homophobia is a disease xox
Wow this is the first time I am watching a news debate where reporter does not want to make it into a fight
kripya poora vadvivad prakashit karein. mujhe intezar rahega.
khabar.ndtv.com/video/show/prime-time/301010
I hate congress leaders as well , cuz when they were authorised they did nothing
Love you ravish sir ❤️😂
Vrinda Marwah is looking very cute and beautiful.. Pls marry mr
IJAZ VS RAVISH 🤣🤣😂😂
Fan of ravish 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
Hi reshma I am also gay my self my name is chetan from England 🏴
Hinduism main sab kuch allow hain
India had expected but Indian people not expecting 😔😔😔😔😔😔😔
Help us need more support
My opinion :
Like relise lgbt love movies by india and serial so other people know clear mean of lbgt😔😔
azaaz ahmad sahab homework kar ke aana chahiye tha aapko,har kuch me dharm ka vaasta mat dijiye
Vrinda is so lit
Ravish Sir👌👌👌👌
Vedic culture was never against homosexuality. It doesn't even differentiate between animal and human, living or non-living, energy or matter. Stupid NDTV will get the most ignorant fools for debates.
IPC 377 ka ansar Indian Constitution mai haiii
Look at those freaking representatives of nation in Parliament they are laughing
I'm so ashamed 🙂
Full Video kidhar hai
Damn, Shatrughan Sinha, wth.
mokbul is nonsense.
yes its time to scrap section 377 now
Jiyo or jine bhi do
Ravish Kumar 😌🙌🙌
IPC 377 mai badal jaruri hai......
And this guy was human resource minister
Wow ravish ji
o my god / is India still thinking in this way ... thats way we outdoors don,t believe in people that call there self yogi orr anything like this kind off ....Ramdew
THEY Start with Good things and than EGO starts ..if they get the change they ll became the min of india , ( they have no experience aboth wath they say ) and insult others ( he sad pagel kabhi nehi kehegi hem pagel he )
he says that homosexualty is a dissorder .
( he talks abouth islam , cristian , hindu ) .... what is love , respect , they don,t no
Bhagwaan aur Dharm ka theka politics mei jab tak band nahi hoga tab tak iss desh ka kuch nahi ho sakta
"Shiv shiv shiv"
Well Lord Shiva was homosexual,, bisexual actually.
16:26
RIP Saleem Kidwai
This is not pop state I asked one a questen whice is frist mind, religen and sosalist?
Hello every one , I really don't understand how the supreme court of India is leaving this deceasing on political leaders ,they are not educated enough not at least in the field of health science or psychology. SC should take the help of IMA or any relevant team who can give the proper clarification on this issue. actually these politicians are real criminals , how many scandals these people are doing , n see who is making decision n about what loving some body. chahe o BJP ho yaa congress koi bhi issues ko resolve nahi karna chahata ... bus un subka mudda banake ek doosre ke khilaf use karke election ladna chahate hai ...Hna mai maantha hun BJP ne is baar achaa kaam kiya hai.. par iseke bareme q nahi bolna chahte MODIJI. Q ki ek religious issue hai isliye ? kya tripla talak riligious issue nahi tha ? LGBT walonse kitna vote milega ... muslim mahilavonse jaada vote milenge isliye usipe concentrate kiya..
Supreme court was right at that time but later some nonsense judge change that
You are muslim?
law sabko saamaan haiii
Why am I watching this is in 2021? It's beautiful from my closet
It'll be even more once u come out....Best of Luck for that...😊
Tough question - chorh dete h😂
Economic coercion is a thing !
Ravish you Bampanthi-Bhrashtpanthi
Hey Ravish- just listen to this Islamic man. Why don’t you allow to say something to someone?? Why do u keep on saying your own??? Just listen him.
इश्लाम में तो बच्चाबाजी भी माना होगा,
अफगानिस्तान