You Want to Put My Son's Heart into a Monkey? | Heartbeat | MD TV
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 5 ต.ค. 2024
- Doctors attempt the first ever human-to-animal organ transplant when the only viable receiver of an HIV positive heart is a chimpanzee.
From Heartbeat Season 1 Episode 9 'Sanctuary' - Dr. Alex Panttiere makes her best effort to bring the dying wish of a young heart patient to fruition.
Heartbeat (2016) Prominent heart transplant surgeon Dr Alexandra (Melissa George) tackles several challenging cases in the hospital. At the same time, she struggles to maintain a balance between her personal and professional life.
Watch full episodes of Heartbeat here: www.justwatch....
Welcome to MD TV! A channel dedicated to your favourite medical dramas! Featuring iconic moments from House M.D., Chicago Med and more. Follow the professional and personal lives of the hospital staff, as you go a journey right from the very first doctor's call to the E.R and beyond. MD TV is packed full of drama, intrigue, and plenty of medical emergencies!
#MDTV #medicaldrama #medicaltvshow - บันเทิง
That little boy’s dying wish was for his heart to go to someone that could use it..he never said it had to be a human…That chimp needed a heart and she got one…end of story
👍🥺😞🥰
agreed
Wait I thought shows were acted but is this for real? Was this actually real like an actual human heart go to a chimp I would put of my mind if this was not acted
@@Silver_Diamond_The_Angel_Wolf There has been attempts of human-to-animal transplant iirc, but whether they actually succeeded or not i dont know
He was still a kid. Imagine how excited he would feel to live in a monkey and be the first of hopefully many future interspecies operations
Honestly, if I was 6 and they told me my heart couldn’t go to another human, I would’ve given it to a baby elephant if it could be helped.
Bro same, even now, if I was dying and an animal could use my lungs, I'd agree to it
Absolutely, yes I would. When I die I do not want to be cremated, I would absolutely hate that. Instead I want my body to help as many people/ beings as possible and only after that be put into the ground for the bugs and creatures. I don't even want a casket, just wrap me in a sheet and leave me as nutrient.
Me too.
Just make sure it is donated individually, rather than donating your whole body. If you donate your whole body it could be sold to the military to test weapons.
You sound like me. I will agree with you on cremation I already did but it has a tenant connotations to it don’t forget God buried Moses.
Felt this on another level
There's something I think it's called a tree pod, they put your body in it and it uses your nutrients to grow a tree
The hardest thing I ever did was to was sign a DNR for my mom watching her take her last breath I wouldn't wish that pain on no one taking someone off life support is the hardest thing you will ever do.
@@vanessav65
1 your opinion doesn’t matter when you’re speculating
2 it’s not letting them go or watching them suffer. It’s usually both
3 could you remove the duplicates. Once is enough
Hey Joel, I think I might understand where your coming from. My mom had to put my grandma on hospice, had to sign a DNR and everything like that. She had heart disease and she was diabetic. I don't fully know how she passed away they never really told me to this day. I'm only 13, she died in 2020 which would've made me only 11. It was the hardest thing ever for me. Me and my grandma were so close and whenever she got sent to the hospital the first time we found her in her assisted living facility she wasn't breathing good and she just didn't look good. She was also deaf so she couldn't just go call someone she would have to text them and do all that. But it was so hard to watch her sit there and just wait for her to pass away, I don't think about her that much anymore but this video reminded me of her and I'm thankful for that and your comment helped me remember her even more so thank you, I hope you feel better soon Joel.
@@damienbarger6149 you seem like a kind, empathetic, and intelligent person. Please don’t ever lose that. We need need more people like you. If you grow up and hold on to those qualities you’ll do amazing things! Good luck to you and God Bless!
We dont deserve children. Theyr to kind and innocent and all we do is ruin it.
If I was in a position where I (dying) could give away my heart to a chimp, I wouldn't even give it a second thought:
- Sir, we found a recipient for your heart!
- Oh good. What kind of person are they?
- Well... There's this monkey-
- Yes.
It’s not about that. It’s illegal. There are other ways
-so there’s this monkey, we stole it and giving it your heart will put hundreds of people out of work and patients with nowhere to turn because it can get this hospital shut down. Every single person in the operating room during the procedure will lose their medical license and be barred from ever performing surgery again.
Seriously? I love animals as much as the next person, but this was moronic. That heart could've gone to another dying child that needed it more. It's difficult as it is giving innocent people organ donors. The monkey could've easily gotten a heart from another dying animal.
@@trevie7589 the heart could not have been given to another child the child would have never been put on the donor list due to his medical history thus they gave it to the chimp since the medical history would not affect the chimp, but could very severely affect another child, this child’s heart would have gone to vain and never been used if it had not gone to the chimp
@@valerieguerrero6699 If the heart was that bad, they were better off putting that monkey to sleep. 🙄 Still utterly ridiculous.
Aww poor baby this had me in tears!❤🥺
I got to admit that monkey is very cute
and dangerous
It’s a chimpanzee, monkeys have tails and chimps don’t. Just letting you know 😊
@@sonicspyrofan5237 👍
@@G1Fenzo at one time I noticed that the chimpanzee saw a child in the monkey closer who fell down into the monkey closer and that chimpanzee had to investigate and got the child to safety by waiting for the rescue team at the door of the monkey closer and that chimpanzee was not dangerous he just wanted to give a helping hand to a child and okay the child falling down the monkey closer was dangerous in fact that child was pushed into the monkey closer by his own family
@@matthewpattison8611 Chimpanzees are extremely amazing but extremely dangerous. That is why the poor chimpanzee used in this tv show is likely stuck in a cage somewhere, because they become unmanageable at about the age of five. Sanctuaries do not even allow direct physical contact between humans and chimpanzees. A chimpanzee can kill a human with ease, even without meaning to. Chimpanzees have been known to rip off faces, genitalia, fingers, hands and feet. It is nothing against them, just that no matter how sweet they are normally, eventually they snap. They are just so strong, and when they snap, it is almost impossible to stop an attack. A human is very weak in comparison to a chimpanzee, even a young or out of shape one. If one knows anything about chimpanzees, they know never to be within reaching distance of them. I love chimpanzees, but they are not what they are portrayed as on tv shows. A wild chimpanzee does not normally bother humans, although they are dangerous to infants and young children. However, a captive chimpanzee is always psychologically damaged to some degree.
One of my favorite clips of this show; wanna see the full episode. To be so young that kid is pretty smart
I wanna give the guy a hug right now
The way some of them act as though the chimp isn't worthy of a human heart makes my blood boil.
They weren’t… who???? N In this case. It wasn’t.
👍😥
If I was a doctor devoted to saving lives, I would be focused on saving lives and not what a bunch of millionaires with zero medical credentials want. Nima, the chimpanzee, was stolen from a lab that was testing on her which is incredibly cruel. If I were in their position? I'd do the exact same thing, even if I lost my license. I could live with myself knowing I tried, and succeeded, to use a heart that would've been discarded because it wasn't good enough on a beautiful, intelligent animal that deserves a second chance at a better life.
I would also gladly donate my organs to animals, if they would have them and could use them.
Is it also worth the hospital getting sued and having to lay off thousands of workers as well as endanger people who no longer have that hospital to go to
not only could you lose yourvlicense you could go to prison and the hospital could be closed
So y’all can live with y’all selves by putting others out. When it comes to stuff like this procedure That’s why doctors should think logically. Not emotionally. The manager was right. You’re not just putting yourself under the chopping block. You’re throwing others under the bus as well. You may be able to live with yourself but what about your colleagues n other patients. You won’t be the only person sued. That manager was right.
👍🥰💖
If you did that, you’d be fired pretty quickly.
Wish this show had lasted longer than one season.
Me toooo. I have no idea why they stopped filming this.. maybe too close to the good dr, house MD, or others
@@ServiceDogRosie Abysmal ratings. Hardly anyone watched it, and the ratings were getting worse with each episode.
@@youpeoplearecrazy374 it looks horrible tbh
@@ServiceDogRosie
I watched it when it was on. The clips are good but watching the full show made it feel like they were trying to make every episode more over the top than the last. It didn't seem like the show wanted to be it's own but to be bigger than Grey's and House were before it.
I watched this until the monkey then wondered where house was then realized I don't know what show this is.
I kinda agree with the manager-lady... I just don't think what they did, while admittedly beautiful, was worth potentially an entire hospital...
Agreed, yes there is a good cause behind it but the monkey was the property of a lab testing facility. It doesn't matter how they were treating the monkey, they owned it. It was stolen and hence the hospital could get sued, which would put the hospital under. And because of this they aren't just risking their own jobs, they are risking the jobs of hundreds if not thousands of people. They are risking thousands of lives from people who won't have that hospital to go to, and they need to go to one further away, or the other hospitals around the area are too full.
Saving 1 chimp isn't worth putting hundreds at risk from the hospital no longer being operational.
@@alexanderelderhorst2107 Exactly!
This is a very grey arguement
On one hand the procedure would save a monkey and give the boy his wish
On the other hand the procedure could go completely lopsided causing the very potential death of the chimp which could leas to a zoo v hospital sue case that would give bad attention and put the hospital under and the heart would eventually die and would leave the boys wish unfulfilled and the procedure alone is experimental therefore there is no way to say it will work and if it goes lopsided then the attempt alone will do the same that the zoo v hospital thing that i mentioned only that this time it would majorly affect the reputation (not saying the zoo v hospital wouldn’t but this would hit harder) and they would also get in major trouble from the board of health which would put the hospital at an even lower stand because people would see the lower standing with the board the hospital would have
I agree, there are both pros and cons and each are valid, but the impact of the cons would far outweigh the impact of the pros therefore making the procedure both highly risky and high chance of affecting their reputation in a severe manner
@@st33lsh0tz you listed two pros and numerous cons. Sacrificing an entire hospital is not worth one foolish promise and a stolen chimp. It’s heart touching, but ultimately the wrong decision.
@@acemosis lets be honest, EVERYTHING is a bias in this world
Wow what a brilliant boy
My body is old, broken, and failing. I would donate my frikking fingernails if I thought someone needed them.
ah the nagging voice of admininstrative bureaucracy
I couldn't be a Doctor because I care to much.
Why does the music feel so inappropriate for the mood??
Ikr!
it's just like what they did in the game "the quarry" but on streamer mode. where all the songs are vastly inappropriate for every single scene... every scene... and yes they put campy happy tunes to depressing and sad scenarios.
@@mychatpalace yeah! That reminded me of life is strange, but with Life is strange I felt the music fitted better for some reason lol. I wonder what in our minds makes us so annoyed and disjointed with bad music scores…
Why tf does it matter if it's going to animal people have a bad habit of thinking animals are beneath us if the heart is going to be going discarded if not used why does it matter
They should do what the little boy asked the lady to do
Can the dad adopt Nima?! Please!!!!
That’s probably a bad idea. Despite how cute they look, chimps can be very dangerous when provoked. And a lot of things provoke them.
@@Wolf-xy7xp but they can also be very affectionate💕
If taken proper care of, he can always take a class on how to care for primates.
@@Timelordderpy who just gives out classes for that?
@@TheDreamCrosser I don’t know? This was honestly just a joke!😆
@@TheDreamCrosser lots of people give out tips and training advice for monkeys
I really crying right now 😢 😭
I wonder how many perfectly good organs have been wasted because of some dumb protocol somewhere that didn’t matter in that situation.
Shame on whoever wrote this video title.
FATHER IN THE STORY: "You want to put my boy's heart into a chimp."
Script writers, thank you for not helping to perpetuate the common ignorant conflation of monkeys and apes.
TITLE OF THIS VIDEO: "You Want to Put My Son's Heart into a Monkey?"
Why? Why would you misquote in a way that helps to perpetuate common ignorance?
A CHIMPANZEE IS NOT A MONKEY.
I cried so hard at this 😭😭😭
Ape, actually. Monkeys have tails (among other physiological differences with the great apes).
Heartbeat (formerly Heartbreaker during production)[1] is an American medical comedy-drama television series based on the real life of Dr. Kathy Magliato, as described in her book Heart Matters.
Chimpanzees are not monkeys big difference.
Chimp. It’s a great Ape. Cal it a god damn ape. You’ve seen more chimps than you have actual monkeys. Call them what they are, they are our closet relative.
If any of my organs can save any life, even a lowly cockroach, I would be happy. I am dead, what use it is for me. If my organs can't be used at least compost me somehow and produce fertilizer for plants. Body is just a box.
Alaris pump has been alarming since the start of the scene 😅
Glad I’m not the only one who went “when the red light is flashing,something’s not working right and it’s beeping!”
Giving an infected heart to another patient regardless of if it’s animal or human is poor practice.
@Gi Gi so is dog lab animals depending on who you talk to. Things are only a grey area when there allowed to be. There are chimps that die of natural causes. There are peoples hearts with seemingly no issues but due to the people’s history there refused
Not if it’s an animal, they don’t develop symptoms of AIDs
I would have agreed with the transplant. It should not be a surprise that most human treatments were first tested on animals. I believe that some human drugs can be used on animals too.
How is that even possible?
It’s a TV show
Putting a human heart in a chimp? Biologically speaking it's completely possible. Humans and chimps have roughly 98% of the same Dna. That's why they are used to test drugs on. It's the closest you'll get to doing human trials without tripping over human rights issues. Legally speaking? Yeah, that manager lady was 100% right. That team would be fired at the very least.
Humans are genetically compatible with all sorts of mammals, which is why animal testing is a thing, though I've heard that when performing these kinds of procedures, the tissue needs to be specially treated to avoid the risk of rejection.
@0:08
Isn't this Sadie from Grey's Anatomy?
He was breathing pretty good for heart probem
Yea you can breathe with heart issues?
heart issues don't always mean lung issues plus a lot of lung damage due to heart conditions is done over time and he was only like 8 so
He really wasn’t breathing a machine was breathing for him because he couldn’t. Plus he was brain dead but not fully dead. Zero chance of recovery.
@@leabee8101 heart issues don’t always mean lung issues.. but with heart issues you will develop difficulty breathing even speaking (check out NYHA classification). Kid’s only 8 and I don’t know his story but I’m guessing he was terminal?
you mean on the ventilator because yeah...thats how that works
As long as this isn't the beginnings of research into creating the animals like in a certain series of movies.they were a warning of what not to let happen.
Just stumbled on this show while watching house and Chicago med clips. Gotta say it's a little weird, the doctors are so headstrong and the COO lady loses in all 3 episodes I've watched. Not surprised to see a comment that the show only lasted one season
Hello guys how are you doing today?
Good 😊 how are you today
@@ronaciaifill5372 I’m very good thanks
Bro the chimpanzee is so cute
They've probably stole this idea from some Ancient Egyptian papyrus or something...
Am I the only one who started to cry when we saw the monkeys face?
This is surely the goofiest tv series that tries to act serious
What happened afterwards?
i went and watched the full episode cause i also wanted to know. they proceed with the surgery and the woman who wanted to stop them (millicent i think her name is), located which lab the chimp was stolen from and two representatives come from there to the hospital to collect the chimp after the surgery ends, alex and jesse do not want to return the chimp as she will go through cruel experiments, so they fake the chimp's death on the surgery table. after the reps and millicent leave the viewing room, the reps threaten legal action since the chimp was stolen, the surgeons continue the surgery and it's a success. they move the chimp back to the sanctuary and colin's father comes to see her and gives her colin's book. alex and jesse did get in huge trouble after millicent tells them the lab wants nima's body, but they obviously cant produce it, so millicent finds out they lied about her dying on the table. we dont see what happens afterwards though with the legal trouble and the lab.
i genuinly am sad..
not for the boy, but for the monkey that got forced into doing this and the duty officer, I love her for trying to stop it
You'd rather the chimpanzee die? I agree that it's unethical to experiment on animals but not only was this not for experimentation purposes, what you're saying is also dangerously close to PETA's "We gave them the gift of euthanasia and it was the best gift they ever recieved" levels of f**ked up.
What now? That monkey wants to live.
yet, scientist have recently discovered how to transplant a pig's heart into a human
Not really, it was a failure.
So the father of the kid refused and they still did the transplant?
Chippanzins are so cute
What a terrible show, the writers are literally incompetent fools that let Google/Facebook searches finish sentences for plots and lines.
This people most be crazy look the men who need a liver and he got a pig but the men passway now a little boy heart for the monkey I don't think it will work at all
"human healthcare business" - that's why america failed
From an outsider looking in, yes. Not enough people realize what a dystopian scenario is playing out today. Everything is for profit, and it’s normalized, people use arguments like ‘what, you expect them to work for free’, not seeing the logical, ethical alternative.
hi first love the clips
Is there nobody in the region on the list?
well monkey have a human dna so yeah
''No one should have the right to call life property''.
Is she vegan?
No, just humane! ^^
This iss ccrazy giving your heart to aa chimp
I think it was a last wish by the little boy
he had aids so no human could of taken it anyway
What's the name of this show
Heartbeat
Cancelled due to horrible ratings
Woa, two Aussie docs, what's this show?
Um, is this even possible?
I guess so 😂😹
Well it is a tv show so it might not be true
@@itssophia35 fair point
mhm it probably is, also, there has been a successful transplant of someone getting a pigs organ (might hv been liver or smt but could very possibly been the pigs heart) so that happened
@@niaharmes9256 I'd be impressed if it was lol
The only thing that matters to you right away are your hair color choices so if you’re going with something.
If I was asked to give up my kids organs for a chimp I would say no. I love animals but no save humans first
I think that’s fraught with danger. We’re different species 1 million things can go wrong.
豚なら食肉用へ転用できようが、お猿さんは流石に可愛そうすぎる。中国はわかりませんね。
何の話をしているの?
That blonde Doctor looks familiar
As a animals rescues i would do it.
What is this series called?
Uh ... Yeah, really..... Believable, I'm sure he understood enough to say all that.
❤
I can tell after a few scenes this show was doomed. Too hokey and ridiculous 😅
Wow that was a really dumb call. Risk the entire hospital, hundreds of people jobs and access to care, because you want to write a little article for surgeons digest and get your name on the front? It’s a stolen monkey. Give the heart to another HUMAN child that needs it, there are hundreds of the waiting list that would be happy with even a damaged heart if it gave them more time.
They legals cannot give the boys heart to another human
Tv shows are getting more ridiculous I love animals but are you telling me there wasn't a human out there who needed it more am supposed to believe that they couldnt find someone oh brother
His heart had too many problems, no one in good conscience could possibly give such a “broken” heart to another person recovering from a heart transplant, it would cause too many problems for the new person and might even kill them or just make them sicker 😅😞
@@kawansiesquad6659 ok that's fair enough
I know the hospital is loaded but i can't help thinking about the resources and time used on a surgery when there are so many people lacking adequate healthcare. Besides if the heart is defective and just failed on the little boy, how long will it last on the chimpanzee?
Paging dr Frakentein and Mengele to IR
To each his own but I don’t agree with you.
Present
A.) No actual monkey was shown in the video
B.) Suggest my kid's heart ends up in a damn chimp and you'd be looking for a complete dental transplant
C.) So glad this series was cancelled
Geez,calm
@@zoneofendless6501 No.
Alright lok
Definitely agree with you. My child's heart would not end inside a chimpanzee
Jesus. Cheesy *and* heavy handed
I pracires god and for child of god
This is a dumb series 😆
I'm sorry I know this is mean but I would not give my heart or the heart of a family member to a ape. Sorry but no thank u give it to another human or if not ill k3ep it I'll take my self off the transplant list for hearts
So humans are better than animals REALLY?
@@Boxofcare666 I don't think humans are better than animals it just is my choice if I want my heart or my family members ♥️ to be transferred to a ape or human being. If I say no then it's a no
Well that’s your choice.
They did try to give it to another human, the board refused
he had aids, they couldnt give the heart to a human and he was dying anyway
this is the stupidest thing I have ever seen. All the doctors acting like they are saving a life that's so important. It's a chimp, I love animals but you're not going to tell me that there was no human out there that didn't need it more. It's already an insult when the doctor give up and ask about organ donation but to ask you for you dying sons heart to save and animal is ridiculous.
I think you kinda lost the point of it. They gave it to the chimp because it couldn't be used in any other way. They would have had to throw it away.
Yeah there would have been humans that could’ve taken the heart, it’s just the kid was infected with AIDs and medical workers don’t like purposely infecting people with a debilitating virus.
Disgusting smh
Errr…….
Well that’s the point isn’t it I’ve heard that there’s less than 1% divergence of DNA in champs versus humans but there still animals they don’t have souls when they die they are gone..
Some countries they eat monkeys. Here in America we do surgery on monkeys and give them the utmost care with organ transplants. Also do surgeons honestly fist bump with bloody gloves? That really gives psychopath vibes.
Plus the heart had a history of heart disease. The whole show is a little bizarre. The hospital must be overfunded