UPDATE 9/11/2024: The "aftermarket part" I used in this video only lasted about a year. I replaced that with a BMW part purchased from FCP Euro. That last nearly 2 years. Honestly, to look at them, there is no real difference in construction. The only benefit with the FCP Euro part is that is is under warranty. The down side is that it is twice the price. So, I really wont see the return on this unless it breaks one more time. I was really hoping that the OEM part would hold up longer. These parts are just junk.
Man that was a great in depth video , warts and all! This has given me the confidence to tackle mine knowing 'hot tips' and all the important little things that other videos have missed! Cheers.
I want to thank you for all the time you spent to show everyone out there how easy it is or how technical it can be I really appreciate your time and expertise and show on how this is done I'll be watching for your next one
Thank you for posting this. My X5's bracket broke that holds the window onto the track. Your illustrations helped me figure it out with ease and your frustration was as consistent as mine.
Great video, thank you. I think I'll remove the BMW motor and put it in my "box o' BMW stuff" in case the Amazon motor fails, rather than retrofit it now.
It has been holding up fine. However, they seem to give about two years service. I wont know if the white lithium grease worked or not until I have to take it apart again. Good luck with your repair.
@@therankinfiles8956 thank you. My track record with how long these last has been 6 months (front right), 3+ years (rear right, replacing now) and front left (2 years and still ok). There’s a guy on here who figured out how to get the clips not to fail by modifying them with a cheap license plate screw. That fix works. But I find the rollers fail anyway and the pulley gets jammed up.
Why did you leave out how to remove the molding between the two pieces of glass. You can not remove the door panel without removing it first without damaging the panel.
If you are working on an Australian E53 (2001) with rear airbags there is a fourth screw holding the door card. It is behind the SRS Airbag label on the door card. The airbag is screwed into the door. If you decide to remove it do not unplug it or you will set a code. You have to disconnect the battery first to avoid this... Also, I don't think that black clip you damaged stays on the door. If it is in its slot on the door card, the card just pulls straight out to unclip it, no up or down motion needed. If it breaks it is probably due to age making it brittle.
Thank you for your video, the closest OE window regulator I could find is a (VAICO V20-0660 Window Lift), it looks identical to my old OEM I just replaced. BTW Vaico is a huge German manufacturer. Order from Amazon for $121 at this time. I like Pelican as well. Consider not using rock auto because they sent the Vaico window lift item to NJ not my address in NJ in error and want me to pay the $20 for the shipping to and from, when their computers or shipping dept shouldn't of sent that out like that. I had to go thru paypal to get paid back the $20 they charged me for their shipping error. And I would also ask you not use Partzgeek, they have bait and switched me several times frome OE to cheap aftermarket! I know I'm a slower learner sometimes. I have 246k on my 04 e53, I log everything. I got her at 48k in 07 second owner and I'm @ $.20 cost a mile. I used to go to different shops ripping me off until I discovered youtube university. I do most work myself unless I need a lift. I urge you not to put none OE in your cars. So much of the foreign knockoffs are junk! GL!
If they are in good shape, in a pinch, I would reuse. But, these are so cheap and easily available, I would get them and replace. As you can see, they do get crunchy.
Good move on window motor,that bosch should outlast four of those cheaper motors,and that end of regulartor should have roller or rollers on it for easier movement and longer lasting!
Hello from Arizona, complaining about your 90 degrees, shooot that's nothing here. Our norm is about 110 degrees and then some. And you only have thoses "high temps" for a day or two. Heck we have over 160 of 90 degrees or more. 🔥🔥🔥🔥😁
UPDATE 9/11/2024: The "aftermarket part" I used in this video only lasted about a year. I replaced that with a BMW part purchased from FCP Euro. That last nearly 2 years. Honestly, to look at them, there is no real difference in construction. The only benefit with the FCP Euro part is that is is under warranty. The down side is that it is twice the price. So, I really wont see the return on this unless it breaks one more time. I was really hoping that the OEM part would hold up longer. These parts are just junk.
Appreciate your efforts on the walk through !!
As a side note for the next person, the pillar molding does NOT apply to the '03 x5 3.0l
Thanks again
Man that was a great in depth video , warts and all! This has given me the confidence to tackle mine knowing 'hot tips' and all the important little things that other videos have missed! Cheers.
I want to thank you for all the time you spent to show everyone out there how easy it is or how technical it can be I really appreciate your time and expertise and show on how this is done I'll be watching for your next one
Thank you for posting this. My X5's bracket broke that holds the window onto the track. Your illustrations helped me figure it out with ease and your frustration was as consistent as mine.
Thank you for the note. I am glad to hear that the information was helpful. Good luck with your X5.
Thanks for the excellent info mate, very helpful.
Thanks. I’m glad it helped.
Definitely not too much info!!! I'm in the process of doing this exact thing!!! Thank you for the informative video!
Thanks. I am glad it helped.
This helped me a lot! Thank you for taking the time to make it and share it!
Thank you for the video expelen it took me couple of hours but because your video I did a good job thanks
Cool! Glad it helped.
Perfect walkthrough! Thank you!!!
Glad it helped.
Buen Video muy explicito me ayudó mucho con mi X5 BMW
Good job...
Great video, thank you. I think I'll remove the BMW motor and put it in my "box o' BMW stuff" in case the Amazon motor fails, rather than retrofit it now.
Going to do mine tomorrow. How's yours holding up after 6 months? Thoughts on whether the WD-40 grease was a good idea?
It has been holding up fine. However, they seem to give about two years service. I wont know if the white lithium grease worked or not until I have to take it apart again. Good luck with your repair.
@@therankinfiles8956 thank you. My track record with how long these last has been 6 months (front right), 3+ years (rear right, replacing now) and front left (2 years and still ok). There’s a guy on here who figured out how to get the clips not to fail by modifying them with a cheap license plate screw. That fix works. But I find the rollers fail anyway and the pulley gets jammed up.
What part number did you get? I have a 2001 X5 and I’ve bought a Dorman from Amazon and now an A premium and neither one fits?
I bought the right rear one from Amazon. It was a "A-Premium" brand. The part number was WR0138. This model includes the motor which I did not use.
I had my boyfriend watch your video and I think he may have it figured out now. I suspected he was missing something.
VAICO V20-0660 Window Lift, identical to ours!
Great video, the first one with the sun protection system! Now I know 😉😃 .... Thanks for sharing. Cheers from NRW, Germoney
Aftermarket regulators do not last. Who cares about a warranty when you have to keep doing it. Also make sure you lube all the window tracks/slides.
VAICO V20-0660 Window Lift, is my answer!
Why did you leave out how to remove the molding between the two pieces of glass. You can not remove the door panel without removing it first without damaging the panel.
Pretty sure I cover that around the 12:10 mark in the video???
If you are working on an Australian E53 (2001) with rear airbags there is a fourth screw holding the door card. It is behind the SRS Airbag label on the door card. The airbag is screwed into the door. If you decide to remove it do not unplug it or you will set a code. You have to disconnect the battery first to avoid this... Also, I don't think that black clip you damaged stays on the door. If it is in its slot on the door card, the card just pulls straight out to unclip it, no up or down motion needed. If it breaks it is probably due to age making it brittle.
Thank you for your video, the closest OE window regulator I could find is a (VAICO V20-0660 Window Lift), it looks identical to my old OEM I just replaced. BTW Vaico is a huge German manufacturer. Order from Amazon for $121 at this time. I like Pelican as well. Consider not using rock auto because they sent the Vaico window lift item to NJ not my address in NJ in error and want me to pay the $20 for the shipping to and from, when their computers or shipping dept shouldn't of sent that out like that. I had to go thru paypal to get paid back the $20 they charged me for their shipping error. And I would also ask you not use Partzgeek, they have bait and switched me several times frome OE to cheap aftermarket! I know I'm a slower learner sometimes. I have 246k on my 04 e53, I log everything. I got her at 48k in 07 second owner and I'm @ $.20 cost a mile. I used to go to different shops ripping me off until I discovered youtube university. I do most work myself unless I need a lift. I urge you not to put none OE in your cars. So much of the foreign knockoffs are junk! GL!
Thanks for your video
Do you have a link to what window regular you bought?
Bonjour, merci pour votre vidéo 👍
Wait… you’ve replaced these WR before and didn’t replace the clips the first time? 🙄
If they are in good shape, in a pinch, I would reuse. But, these are so cheap and easily available, I would get them and replace. As you can see, they do get crunchy.
Good move on window motor,that bosch should outlast four of those cheaper motors,and that end of regulartor should have roller or rollers on it for easier movement and longer lasting!
Yes. For sure. You get what you pay for. I think next time, if I have time, I will take my own advice and buy the better parts!
@@therankinfiles8956 Thats what I will do when mine goes out!
Fantastic video mate amazing
Thank you so much 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Thank you
Thank you for watching!
So much bla bla bla 😔
I agree.
Hello from Arizona, complaining about your 90 degrees, shooot that's nothing here. Our norm is about 110 degrees and then some. And you only have thoses "high temps" for a day or two. Heck we have over 160 of 90 degrees or more. 🔥🔥🔥🔥😁