Let's not forget that Deng was a protégé of Mao who later took his own path, just like Mao also earlier deviated from his own mentors as regards to how to liberate China
What wud china be today, if those students managed to change the government.. Deng Xiaopeng has the same thought of economic reform. But he waited for the perfect moment when those idea is feasible..
There is video and photo evidence of dead SOLDIERS around Tiananmen but none for dead students or protesters. That's because soldiers never performed a massacre. If anything, the massacre was against soldiers and that the incident at Tiananmen square was an attempted coup.
@@pix3m130 there were dead people only not on the square. indeed students murdered soldiers too and there was a response. dont deny that, doesnt help china nor the truth. indeed western narratives about the incident are false.
How come there are only pictures of Donald Trump mugging for the camera but not the 1 million dead Americans who perished under his disastrous COVID policy?
I recommend for anyone interested in modern China's economic philiosophy, pick up a book titled "China's Socialist Economy" by Xue Muqiao and find that Deng's economic policies were actually in line with the economic principles laid out in Stalin's book "Economic Problems of Socialisn in the USSR". The main principle being that the relations of production needs to match the social character of the productive forces. If Ezra Vogel wants to say they're a "China expert", he should be able to go into detail how China synthesized Marxism-Leninism-MaoZedong thought to lead to their market reforms but he fumbled his first question from the audience. The modern PRC are committed marxists up to this day and will continue to do so.
In fact, China and the United States have similar systems, but the progress bar of the United States is ahead of China. The path China is taking now is basically the same as the trajectory of every dynasty in its history.
Bro, I doubt that China is anywhere close to socialism, especially considering the fact that China's economy is mostly privately owned (about two thirds).
@@wenxuyao5934 Xi is looking at the caricature where the Western countries are slicing China like it was a big pizza pie.. While Japan got the "Gunboat Diplomacy of Com Perry"... Xi is looking at the "century of humiliation by the West"...
Thank you so much for sharing this amazing story about Deng Xiaoping of China after long centuries of experience in Chinese economic development.
Thank you for opening up our minds on part of the Chinese history. Your stories are very interesting and helpful for us in the west.
Deng is amazing! He changed China!!! He will be missed.
Yes. Exactly!
Yes, We miss him!
当然，在我眼里，他是一个great man🎉
A great scholar on a great statesman.
Ten years late but am here
一个伟大的人物 !
Thank you very much for sharing !
RIP Professor Vogel.
Can you tell me the Russian that is mentioned at the 15th minute mark?
He was a japan expert before. I enjoyed very much reading his book - Japan as No 1.
A great man with enormous charisma
Deng is a true hero
Hopefully not the last generation of people who seek truth in the world instead of working to divide us
Thx Dr. vogel, forever humble..rip
science and education are nothing if they don't teach humbleness
RIP Mr Vogel
China without Deng would be just another....bigger North Korea: Poor, pitiful and miserable. His pragmatism was really amazing indeed
Preeeet preeet. Preeet. 👈
very insightful
Can you tell me the Russian that is mentioned at the 15th minute mark?
LOL If you turn on the auto-generated subtitles, you get "Joe and I" instead of Chou Enlai
Mr. Deng, you are dearly missed in China. We need another Deng-like statesman to steer China through today's tough times.
deng prefers people call him comrade xiaoping
Doesn't Xi continue within Deng's framework?
if only xi jinping was president
Let's not forget that Deng was a protégé of Mao who later took his own path, just like Mao also earlier deviated from his own mentors as regards to how to liberate China
How come there's only footage of the guy confronting the tank but not of the hundreds of dead?
What wud china be today, if those students managed to change the government.. Deng Xiaopeng has the same thought of economic reform. But he waited for the perfect moment when those idea is feasible..
There is video and photo evidence of dead SOLDIERS around Tiananmen but none for dead students or protesters. That's because soldiers never performed a massacre. If anything, the massacre was against soldiers and that the incident at Tiananmen square was an attempted coup.
@@pix3m130 there were dead people only not on the square. indeed students murdered soldiers too and there was a response. dont deny that, doesnt help china nor the truth. indeed western narratives about the incident are false.
How come there are only pictures of Donald Trump mugging for the camera but not the 1 million dead Americans who perished under his disastrous COVID policy?
You were a great president Deng, you shall be sorely missed
he didn't be a president even one day bro
Paramount leaders to be exact
RIP
good speech. bad audio.
Yeah I want to donate Emory University a pop filter
1:05:19 Meiji Japan and what's the other one?
Comparison between meiji japan and deng reformist era
I recommend for anyone interested in modern China's economic philiosophy, pick up a book titled "China's Socialist Economy" by Xue Muqiao and find that Deng's economic policies were actually in line with the economic principles laid out in Stalin's book "Economic Problems of Socialisn in the USSR". The main principle being that the relations of production needs to match the social character of the productive forces. If Ezra Vogel wants to say they're a "China expert", he should be able to go into detail how China synthesized Marxism-Leninism-MaoZedong thought to lead to their market reforms but he fumbled his first question from the audience. The modern PRC are committed marxists up to this day and will continue to do so.
In fact, China and the United States have similar systems, but the progress bar of the United States is ahead of China. The path China is taking now is basically the same as the trajectory of every dynasty in its history.
Bro, I doubt that China is anywhere close to socialism, especially considering the fact that China's economy is mostly privately owned (about two thirds).
👏👏👏👏👏👍
As a Chinese citizen, it is heartbroken to watch what the current leaders of China is doing ...😭😭
Can I ask you why?
icecool1616 Mao made China, Deng made China great, Xi made China great again but your phone is made in China
@@wenxuyao5934 Ha ha well said!.
@@wenxuyao5934 Xi is looking at the caricature where the Western countries are slicing China like it was a big pizza pie..
While Japan got the "Gunboat Diplomacy of Com Perry"... Xi is looking at the "century of humiliation by the West"...
Wow You are troll BS CIA /Ned 🤣🤣🤣☝️☝️
0:40 come on that was a good joke
居然没有评论，消灭零回复
+Andy S 这本书看过很多遍
Lot of "pop" in the audio
0
I wish you study prophet Muhammad story instead. Thank you
Yes everyone should just study Muhammad and forget everything else. What a world that would be.
of course... what cud go wrong studying the prophet...
Am Muslim and studying secular sciences there is nothing wrong with that, stop this kind of attitudes as it makes Muslims look stupid.
Delicious cringe.
Stop making Muslim look so stupid