@@mingouczjcz3800 It is possible to be presented a point of view or narrative and simply reject it or take issue with it, no one can force you to believe or accept anything, that is up to you. There is no reason to discard the good documentaries (which are independently produced) because you disagree with some of the viewpoints on their news programs or news articles. For example, I think most Al Jazeera news content is absolute garbage riddled with the most obvious biases in the news industry, however they produce some great documentaries on topics and regions not covered by others and I have no issue watching those documentaries despite finding their news output worthless.
I grew up in a poor family in Cameroon. This reminded me of my childhood and by age 5 I was already doing dishes and mopping the floor and sweeping the compound and making my bed and I even start fire for cooking so my aunt will use. I was forced to grow up fast at age 5 and being raised by relatives. Now age 28 everything I did in childhood to survive came along with me in adulthood and as a mother with my own children I am teaching my kids some of the things I learnt growing up in Africa.
Similar childhood memories/experiences I had growing up in the village and the Town of Bamenda Cameroon! It’s quite fun looking back at the past! The hard life I had as a child growing up has taught me to be mentally healthy in life
there is something envious in the way they are living...i guess it's the peace... simplicity of life, fresh air and loved of family and the community...i hope as they are forced to be incorporated in the modern world they won't lose all those blessings they already have...thanks DW for showing us this story....🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭
They have so much beauty in their faces and souls because of their commitment to each other as a community, nature and spirituality. The deep appreciation and care they have for everything surrounding them and in the work that they do is what allows them to thrive in their own ways. Such a wholesome and beautiful video 🥹
18:15 “we who are born & raised in the Tiger (sic) are guardians of these mountains & this beautiful nature. Reindeer are rare in Mongolia, raising them is the most beautiful thing in the world” Outstanding work DW Documentary, bravo.
@@cocacolalada It is. Yes, there obviously is stress in their day to day life, but it's still not anywhere near how it is in our normal systems, where you get much different mental issues and stress then living in the wild. At the end of the day they will be stress free and happy. We, are not. Even tho we have everything,
All of these kids are just beautiful and I just cannot believe how happy these kids and people are just unbelievable. they don't have a computer sitting in their hand all the time they don't have a TV they're sitting in front of all the day, they're outside in the healthy sunshine, fresh air running and playing I'm jealous. I would love this chance to be like them just for a day
It is really worth watching. Knowing about the cultural diversity that exists across the world and having a chance to become a part of it digitally is a great thing. Thank you DW for making such masterpieces. ❤
Really have to appreciate these documentaries as in the years and decades to come we will be able to look back and show our great grandkids and there kids what life was like 👍 thanks DW
Truly, what a beautiful people! It proves primative is not stupid! I so wish documentaries like this need to be shown in schools! Such a strong people! 😊
High quality documentary. It is calming, peaceful to look at these beautiful landscape, the wilderness - a far cry from noisy, stressful urban life. I also grew in a remote village where there is one mountain river crosses right through the middle of the village and I could always hear the sound of the river from our house. These places remind me of my hometown. I loved going out for walk through the fields and just dream about anything. It is priceless😊 Thank you DW for the excellent work. How you are portraying the lives of these rare people is something amazing to watch.
Thanks a lot for watching, taking the time to comment and sharing your own experience of growing up in remote village. We're glad you found the documentary insightful and it also brought back some fond memories. 🙂 If you're interested in exploring other pockets of the world, then our travel playlist might be of interest: th-cam.com/play/PLovlAKbQVz6BE-32_-Q5ojt-Pgqap-Ye9.html
What wonderful people you are. You are blessed with this nature that God has truly created for you.. Everything that you see around you is the love of God .. God bless the Duca.. greetings from a 75 year old grandma, a retired high school principal from Philippines in southern part of asia..
I spend 2 weeks in mongolia I ❤ LOVED IT ❤ SO PRIMITIVE ❤ LOVED LIVING IN YURDS ❤ AND THE PEOPLE ARE SO WONDERFUL ❤ MAY BE SOME DAY I WILL GO BACK ❤❤❤😊
Amazing,informative & beautiful documentary❤.Thank you DW for showing this part of the world.Those three Mongolian children were super duper cute especially their cute smile and puffy cheeks❤.
these people living out here like the nora from horizon zero dawn !!!! warms my heart to see that there are humans that are still thriving without technology and are not dependent on fragile modern civilizational frameworks to exist and survive.
A great piece of audio/video work, wonderful editing. Truely a masterpiece about the Dukka and the Taiga. This traditional lifestyle will disappear in the near future. Not because of outside encroachment, but rather progress which all humans want and need.
Many of the chores were things we were made to do as children. I grew up seeing other families living a different way of life that we did. I grew up a Christian and am so happy I did. The Dukkha live in many ways the same. There life of tent living is the way the Native Americans did and they thrived also. It looks like such a peaceful life. I loved the report. Hope to see more about how other cultures choose to live. Helping with the tasks at home is a great way to help kids know the value of work and the rewards as well. Our American lives are improved when everyone sees the value in all things. Its a wonderful way to live and gives pride and honor to those whom are able to do it. Great report. k. f.
your embassy in Stockholm, Sweden does a great job of showcasing your country at all cultural events in the city. i got to try our some nice food and get into a tent
I spent near two years in UB and visited a Tsaatan family on the shores of Lake Khuvsgul. My wife is Mongolian and my daughter, now 18 was born in UB on a -27C day. 🙂
The modern dilemma has even affected this society. The gradual disappearance of this wonderful culture deeply frustrates me. The traditional way of life has almost entirely disappeared from Kazakhstan, where I am from. Which in turn has raised a lot of doubts about who I am.
We bodo community is also from Mongolia, we are migrated from Mongolia to tibet , after tibet we once again migrated to Assam ( NE india) 3000 years ago, currently we have been living in the Assam state of NE india.. Basically we bodo people are very similar to Mongolian🇲🇳 people in terms of looks,culture, character, eating, thinking and so on still today, our grand parents and their both are created from one community, it's very good to see you Mongolian brothers and sisters . Long live to our Mongolian 🇲🇳 diasporas❤ if someone else from Mongolia see my comment please let me know more about our Mongolian diasporas I am very excited to know and learn more about our Mongolian culture ❤❤❤❤❤
The peoples featured in this video are not ethnically Mongolian, despite being Mongolian nationals. While I know you did not mean to offend, in general, people prefer not to be generalized with other ethnic groups. The Tsaatan, also called Dukha, are not a Mongolic or East Asian ethnicity, they are a Turkic people, they descend from ancient steppe dwellers and lived in the area now called Mongolia before the present day Mongols migrated from further east.
@@mat4263nah they are mongolian. They look just like my relatives and other mongolians, and speak the same language. There are other arctic nomads who don’t speak mongolian and are not ethnically mongolian but these are mongolian people and it would be good to not spread misinformation.
@@Aloof_Buddha being of Mongolian descent does not automatically grant you any authority on the subject. Yes, as was pointed out multiple times in the documentary they are forced to attend school and learn the Mongolian language by the national government. The film also mentioned that the young men are encouraged to find wives from outside the community because of their low numbers and fear of inbreeding. The Tssaatan, despite being Mongolian nationals in modern times are not a Mongolic people, irregardless of what you as a Mongolian believe. Good day, “Buddha”
The Dukha, Dukhans or Duhalar (Mongolian: Цаатан, Tsaatan) are a small Turkic community of semi-nomadic reindeer herders living in a sum of Khövsgöl, Mongolia called Tsagaannuur.
This is what the internet and YT is for, thanks DW!
This type of documenreries just serve as DW cover for other misleading propaganda purposes.
@@mingouczjcz3800 It is possible to be presented a point of view or narrative and simply reject it or take issue with it, no one can force you to believe or accept anything, that is up to you. There is no reason to discard the good documentaries (which are independently produced) because you disagree with some of the viewpoints on their news programs or news articles. For example, I think most Al Jazeera news content is absolute garbage riddled with the most obvious biases in the news industry, however they produce some great documentaries on topics and regions not covered by others and I have no issue watching those documentaries despite finding their news output worthless.
i don´t see the documentary but i guest, CHINA has the fault rigth DW?
@@mingouczjcz3800 i am pretty sure you don't even know what is the propaganda mf😭
I grew up in a poor family in Cameroon. This reminded me of my childhood and by age 5 I was already doing dishes and mopping the floor and sweeping the compound and making my bed and I even start fire for cooking so my aunt will use. I was forced to grow up fast at age 5 and being raised by relatives. Now age 28 everything I did in childhood to survive came along with me in adulthood and as a mother with my own children I am teaching my kids some of the things I learnt growing up in Africa.
Similar childhood memories/experiences I had growing up in the village and the Town of Bamenda Cameroon! It’s quite fun looking back at the past! The hard life I had as a child growing up has taught me to be mentally healthy in life
OMG! It's amazing how people persevere.
Is your story related in life -40.theres no snow in cameroon 😅
Don't think you are in this world where one place is better or worse than another.
The "schools" prevent the kids from all sorts of issues with education... hooray for these people
DW makes the most picturesque of documentaries. Keep it coming folks.
Thanks for watching and for the feedback!
I was stressed out lately. It makes me calm. Thank you DW documentary.
Thanks for watching! We’re glad you found the documentary helpful. 😊
@@DWDocumentary ❤
I hope you found the peace you needed :)
Ditto
Those three children are absolutely perfect ❤
you sound sus
They have a healthy childhood
@@MrSalbego no, you
1:59 Oh my god, tell me that isn't one of the most adorable kids ever! Cuteness overload
i don´t see the documentary but i guest, CHINA has the fault rigth DW?
I agree !
@@marvinschumacher8549 I gest china 🇨🇳 do it right?
@@aye3678 china
@@aye3678 g
there is something envious in the way they are living...i guess it's the peace... simplicity of life, fresh air and loved of family and the community...i hope as they are forced to be incorporated in the modern world they won't lose all those blessings they already have...thanks DW for showing us this story....🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭
What dw covers is outstanding picturesque sites!!! Really appreciable
You should check out SLICE documentaries too about mongolia nomads. They are best like this.
This type of documenreries just serve as DW cover for other misleading propaganda purposes.
i don´t see the documentary but i guest, CHINA has the fault rigth DW?
@@mingouczjcz3800you just need to ignore the propaganda otherwise you will miss out on masterpieces like this
@@NyanyiCI do the same. I really like DW documentaries but I avoid propaganda ones
I so enjoy videos about places I'll never see in person. Thank you DW!
Thank you Brian for watching and leaving us your comment!
Great work. Thank you DW. What a lovely family. Kids are wonderful 300% more helpful than me at their ages.
They have so much beauty in their faces and souls because of their commitment to each other as a community, nature and spirituality. The deep appreciation and care they have for everything surrounding them and in the work that they do is what allows them to thrive in their own ways. Such a wholesome and beautiful video 🥹
18:15 “we who are born & raised in the Tiger (sic) are guardians of these mountains & this beautiful nature. Reindeer are rare in Mongolia, raising them is the most beautiful thing in the world”
Outstanding work DW Documentary, bravo.
I know it sounds like Tiger but it is pronounced TAIGA.
@@EmmaGanaaPronounced and written as TAIGA.
When you have a family that works together and prays together that is the kind of family that stays together ❤.
I want to be stress free as the kids on this documentary. Love from Kenya 🇰🇪
Thanks for watching and taking the time to comment! Kudos from Germany. :)
These documentaries bring me joy!😊 well done DW channel! Absolute quality content!
This life isn’t stress free.
@@cocacolalada It is. Yes, there obviously is stress in their day to day life, but it's still not anywhere near how it is in our normal systems, where you get much different mental issues and stress then living in the wild. At the end of the day they will be stress free and happy. We, are not. Even tho we have everything,
What a blessing and Inspiration that most of the reindeer nomads especially the young ones want to preserve their culture.
Thank you DW for showing this part of the world and these beautiful people ! so rare and pure! Mongolia is beautiful!
Thank you for watching and taking the time to comment! Be sure to check out our channel for more content. :)
This is what a meaningful life looks like
I hope these people don’t lose their culture.
Amazing indigenous people of Mongolia. Thank you DW for the educational film.
Thanks for watching!
This's one of the documentaries you can't get tired of watching....Thanks DW for your effort to bring this to us. Watching from Kenya
The fact the mongolian government forces these families to separate so the kids go to school is absolutely rediculous...
The world is not such bad place after all. Thanks for sharing this, it relaxed me.
I really thoroughly enjoyed this video and learned alot. The people work so hard and everybody helps with the chores. The children are so adorable.
Thank you for watching and for your positive feedback!
What a beautiful and fulfilling life.
Thank you for your effort in showing us the other side of the world, thank you so much DW🙂
Thank you for watching!
I started to appreciate myself, my people and my environment more and more after watching this masterpiece. Thank you DW
Great documentary, DW. Thank you
DW offers best documentary experience
Thanks a lot for watching and for your positive feedback!
the children are so capable at such a young age!!!
All of these kids are just beautiful and I just cannot believe how happy these kids and people are just unbelievable. they don't have a computer sitting in their hand all the time they don't have a TV they're sitting in front of all the day, they're outside in the healthy sunshine, fresh air running and playing I'm jealous. I would love this chance to be like them just for a day
What a beautiful documentary! DW is the best in documentary filmmaking. I learn so much. Thank you!
Thanks a lot for watching and for your positive feedback. We appreciate you taking the time to comment and
are glad you like our content!
Great documenteries..appreciate the effort and money DW is spending on genuine journalism
Thanks a lot for watching and for your positive feedback!
It is really worth watching. Knowing about the cultural diversity that exists across the world and having a chance to become a part of it digitally is a great thing. Thank you DW for making such masterpieces. ❤
Thanks a lot for watching and for your positive feedback.
One year of work for documenting this is so worth it. Thank you for your efforts.
Thank you for watching and for your positive feedback!
Really have to appreciate these documentaries as in the years and decades to come we will be able to look back and show our great grandkids and there kids what life was like 👍 thanks DW
Thank you for your comment!
Truly, what a beautiful people! It proves primative is not stupid! I so wish documentaries like this need to be shown in schools! Such a strong people! 😊
Their sowing machine is AWESOME. Plus the cool noise it made when cranking it!! I'd love to have one. ❤
Thanks to DW we're getting to know ways of living which i never thought still existed and it's lovely to watch
Thank you for showing us this far corner of the world
High quality documentary. It is calming, peaceful to look at these beautiful landscape, the wilderness - a far cry from noisy, stressful urban life. I also grew in a remote village where there is one mountain river crosses right through the middle of the village and I could always hear the sound of the river from our house. These places remind me of my hometown. I loved going out for walk through the fields and just dream about anything. It is priceless😊
Thank you DW for the excellent work. How you are portraying the lives of these rare people is something amazing to watch.
Thanks a lot for watching, taking the time to comment and sharing your own experience of growing up in remote village. We're glad you found the documentary insightful and it also brought back some fond memories. 🙂 If you're interested in exploring other pockets of the world, then our travel playlist might be of interest: th-cam.com/play/PLovlAKbQVz6BE-32_-Q5ojt-Pgqap-Ye9.html
What wonderful people you are. You are blessed with this nature that God has truly created for you.. Everything that you see around you is the love of God .. God bless the Duca.. greetings from a 75 year old grandma, a retired high school principal from Philippines in southern part of asia..
Wonderful people, very simple. An excellent documentary by DW . Thanks ❤❤❤❤
Glad to see a people connected to their roots❤
Great movie, the stories you tell through this video inspire me so much! An amazing tribe, an amazing tribe! Thank you DW!
Thank you for watching and taking the time to comment!
Really enjoyed watching this. Thanks DW team for going to such a remote place and making it. ❤❤from Canada 🇨🇦 🇨🇦
I love watching how different people and culture at then other end of the world live, however i dont think i can even imagine living like that.
I spend 2 weeks in mongolia I ❤ LOVED IT ❤ SO PRIMITIVE ❤ LOVED LIVING IN YURDS ❤ AND THE PEOPLE ARE SO WONDERFUL ❤ MAY BE SOME DAY I WILL GO BACK ❤❤❤😊
Those children doing their chores..❤
oh my... those lovely children
this is beautiful. thank you DW
Thank you for your comment!
Mongolian nice Landscape in winter, such a beautiful country, watching from Thailand.
Wonderful documentary, thank you for posting it 🥰!
Amazing,informative & beautiful documentary❤.Thank you DW for showing this part of the world.Those three Mongolian children were super duper cute especially their cute smile and puffy cheeks❤.
Thanks for watching and your comment!
DW is the real one thank you for this
Thanks for watching!
thank you! Really interesting! I would watch if you did another documentary on them :)
these people living out here like the nora from horizon zero dawn !!!! warms my heart to see that there are humans that are still thriving without technology and are not dependent on fragile modern civilizational frameworks to exist and survive.
Extremely wonderful documentary shared by an amazing (DW)documentary channel
I really enjoyed this!Thank u! Amazing people ❤️watched from Florida USA
Watching these kind of documentaries is better then watching influencers
A great piece of audio/video work, wonderful editing.
Truely a masterpiece about the Dukka and the Taiga.
This traditional lifestyle will disappear in the near future.
Not because of outside encroachment, but rather progress which all humans want and need.
I love watching these, people living different to the rest.. So interesting. Kinda makes me want to live like them
Wow beautiful documentary..great effort guys well done
fantastic doc! I'm in love with these beautiful people
Thanks for watching! Be sure to check out our channel for more content. 😊
Those vans are so fierce.
Many of the chores were things we were made to do as children. I grew up seeing other families living a different way of life that we did. I grew up a Christian and am so happy I did. The Dukkha live in many ways the same. There life of tent living is the way the Native Americans did and they thrived also. It looks like such a peaceful life. I loved the report.
Hope to see more about how other cultures choose to live. Helping with the tasks at home is a great way to help kids know the value of work and the rewards as well. Our American lives are improved when everyone sees the value in all things. Its a wonderful way to live and gives pride and honor to those whom are able to do it. Great report. k. f.
wow.. this place is what i needed in my my life
So beautiful documentary. Thank you for your hard work and afford.
This is a beautiful documentary. Love from India
Thank you for watching and taking the time to comment!
The scenery; The remainder; The trees, and Snow.😲😍🙏🙏🙏🥹🥹🥹
Absolutely beautiful documentary
This was 🤗glorious, and I always appreciate this💙❤️🍃🌹 topic, thank 🤙 you.
I really enjoyed learning about this family. They are happy and focused on family and nature, that’s beautiful!
Great documentary👏
Thank you for watching!
Im too poor to travel but thanks for taking me on the journey
Wonderful documentary. Thank you for sharing.
Thank you for watching!
Beautiful and hardworking wife. He is a lucky man.
Mongolia is always my favorite destination so far , I will try to get there one day
wow much appreciation for such a great documentary
Yet again a lovely documentary!!! All blessings to the team!!!...❤for years dw never disappointed ❤
Wow 🤩 wonderful children ❤❤ they knows how to taking care of themselves so well and help their families and knows what they are doing ❤❤❤
Thank you very much for showcasting my country. I will definitely share this video with my international friends!
your embassy in Stockholm, Sweden does a great job of showcasing your country at all cultural events in the city. i got to try our some nice food and get into a tent
Watching this documentary is super calming ❤❤❤
Thank you DW
Loved to watch it. Love From the Northeast States of India , Arunachal Pradesh. We are tribal indigenous lives as well out here. 🫶🏼
Thank you
I spent near two years in UB and visited a Tsaatan family on the shores of Lake Khuvsgul. My wife is Mongolian and my daughter, now 18 was born in UB on a -27C day. 🙂
The modern dilemma has even affected this society. The gradual disappearance of this wonderful culture deeply frustrates me. The traditional way of life has almost entirely disappeared from Kazakhstan, where I am from. Which in turn has raised a lot of doubts about who I am.
Welcome to the club. "State mandated" is how we forgot who we are too. Welcome to Babylon, the land of confusion.
We bodo community is also from Mongolia, we are migrated from Mongolia to tibet , after tibet we once again migrated to Assam ( NE india) 3000 years ago, currently we have been living in the Assam state of NE india.. Basically we bodo people are very similar to Mongolian🇲🇳 people in terms of looks,culture, character, eating, thinking and so on still today, our grand parents and their both are created from one community, it's very good to see you Mongolian brothers and sisters . Long live to our Mongolian 🇲🇳 diasporas❤ if someone else from Mongolia see my comment please let me know more about our Mongolian diasporas I am very excited to know and learn more about our Mongolian culture ❤❤❤❤❤
Such a beautiful place to live, pure nature.❤❤❤
The Mongolians are also excellent horsemen. Many tribes have large herds of them. They drink horse milk and occasionally eat horse meat.
Horseback archery should be in the olympics
The peoples featured in this video are not ethnically Mongolian, despite being Mongolian nationals. While I know you did not mean to offend, in general, people prefer not to be generalized with other ethnic groups. The Tsaatan, also called Dukha, are not a Mongolic or East Asian ethnicity, they are a Turkic people, they descend from ancient steppe dwellers and lived in the area now called Mongolia before the present day Mongols migrated from further east.
@@mat4263 I learned something, thank you
@@mat4263nah they are mongolian. They look just like my relatives and other mongolians, and speak the same language. There are other arctic nomads who don’t speak mongolian and are not ethnically mongolian but these are mongolian people and it would be good to not spread misinformation.
@@Aloof_Buddha being of Mongolian descent does not automatically grant you any authority on the subject. Yes, as was pointed out multiple times in the documentary they are forced to attend school and learn the Mongolian language by the national government. The film also mentioned that the young men are encouraged to find wives from outside the community because of their low numbers and fear of inbreeding. The Tssaatan, despite being Mongolian nationals in modern times are not a Mongolic people, irregardless of what you as a Mongolian believe. Good day, “Buddha”
I like it life in the wild looks amazing
Very interesting video. Watching from Jamaica 🇯🇲.
Gives me hope knowing there are curious people like me all over the world. Watching from Vietnam. Bless you.
Love you all from India 🇮🇳
Really beautiful place
They are like those Elves in fiction books, riding Reindeer and live with the nature. Amazing
Happiness has very less correlation to amount of money you have ..it definitely has relation to the work that you do every day....
DW, Kindly include official English subtitles.
The Dukha, Dukhans or Duhalar (Mongolian: Цаатан, Tsaatan) are a small Turkic community of semi-nomadic reindeer herders living in a sum of Khövsgöl, Mongolia called Tsagaannuur.
Türklüğün doğuş yeri.
There is no Turkic community. Stop dreaming.
wow.Appreiated the works by DW
Beautiful Documentary by DW i love this..... best of the best.....
Thanks for watching!
Nice documentary ! Love from India,will visit magnolia as a tourist,very soon ❤