Deep gratitude to @jordanbpeterson and his incredible team for hosting me on the podcast. The conversation was thought-provoking, meaningful, and seamlessly executed. Honored to share ideas with someone who inspires such deep thinking across disciplines. Thank you!
Mazel tov on your courses and your conversation with Dr. Peterson, Dr. Keating. I enjoyed every minute. Hope to enroll at Peterson Academy later this year!
@DrBrianKeating This is a long shot but..... is there a way to contact you for an unusual situation?, it's impossible to put into words properly or within the space available? I made a rash decision before Dec last year, single man, 63, out of absolutely nowhere, Depression and anxiety have overwhelmed me and it relates to a house move that went wrong, the circumstances don't fill the normal criterion and I can not find anything remotely akin to it. It isn't relationship related either but I'm absolutely stuck and am very undecided about what to do but cognisant of time as it flies. Kevin.
Someone looks at the world through my eyes; I know it's not me; But I don't know that stranger is more familiar than I am; He knows me more than I know myself; Oh God, have you made a home in my soul?! Or I in your soul;? Neither do you let me live comfortably? ! Nor do you live comfortably; Let's make peace; Come to my heart?! Take comfort in my soul, in my spirit, in my body, Come make a home in my soul; Come end this world war;!? Come end this chaos; I have become a desert; I have become like a parched desert,; I have become thirsty for you; I have become fire, I have become earth, I have become hell and burned; Become the sky for me; Become the rain for me; Become water for me; Become like a surprise for me; Take comfort in my soul; You have driven me to madness and madness; You have brought my soul to my lips; Put your lips on my lips, give your soul into my soul and revive me;!!!! I started wrestling with God, I attacked him so much, I became so intertwined with him, I became so one with him that I did not know whether I was God or he was God; we drank so much from each other's lips, we overflowed with love and passion and longing. I stared into his eyes again and said: Who are you? Are you me or I am you; I am you; He breathed into my soul and breathed into my soul until I was filled with love and desire and madness and lust and seduction. I said to him: Come to me, become a bomb in my soul. Become a world war, become corruption and sedition and lust; He also breathed into my soul with all his power and strength; and in my soul, like a world war, it became an atomic bomb and fire and water. I stared into his eyes again and wrestled with him and intertwined with him and became one with him but I was not satisfied, I became thirstier every moment I said with love I do not know, God, am I you, or are you me?!
I'm 15,and Dr Peterson has helped me a lot.I'm trying to take responsibility,get my life together and aim upward,despite having a fractured family and childhood.This man has given me faith.God bless you,Dr Peterson❤
Pss , I see that you are trying to use grammatics , a couple of suggestion dear young boy : put spaces before and after a comma , also for periods . Last mistake , at the beginning , there's no need for a comma before an "and" , usually writing . I see that you are reading , go on young boy , keep studying , stay strong . Future has hope , like the present .
I'm so glad to hear young people like you are taking advantage of the accessibility you have to knowledge. When I was 15 I wasn't anywhere near the mental ability I have today to enjoy Dr Peterson. If your generation follows same path as you then we are in for a very hopeful future :) Cheers!
Good on you! It is challenging trying to become more than what we’re born into. Never give up or give in, your self awareness at such a young age is incredible. ❤ Best of luck to you in this life.
@@Simon89Jeppesen I think that's a very complicated question definitely not something any of us can answer in one comment, not even Jordan Peterson. i'd probably suggest learning about depression. and thinking about other people more. even just the goal can be enough to see at least a little bit of movement in the beginning. but I'm sure you can find a way to make things better.
thats awsome im excited for you. i see you are trying to do things despite haveing a fractured family and thats i think a very intelligent decision on your part. it's very easy to play the victim and dangerous. so definitely keep moving in that direction anyway you can.
@@DrBrianKeating I love your Channel Dr. Brian! I miss the intense conversations with Eric Weinstein, would be awesome to have someone try and distill his Geometric Unity theory in a more mundane and low IQ (such as mine) way. Joe Rogan didn't seem to be too interested in getting to actually understand it, which was disappointing to me when I listened to the podcast where Eric mentions his theory :/
Yes me too, they touch on some very good points where they are able to entangle philosophy, events and studies of other nature. Very thought provoking and all in all, light for the soul.
I'm envious of Dr Peterson's northern Alberta childhood in which he regularly saw the Aurora Borealis. I've yet to see it myself and it's on the bucket list, along with seeing a total solar eclipse. We do lose something when the background light obscures the beauty of the night sky, just as we lose something when our contact with nature is reduced. Most of us have a secret longing for a cabin in the forest somewhere, but almost none of us will ever end up in one. This was another excellent discussion. No doubt Dr Peterson is delighted with the news coming out of Canada today.
@@SpaceMarine113 I grew up in the same climate in Alaska and trust me, you’re not missing a lot. The horrid dark winters are little consolation for the wonder of aurora borealis. I would trade any day, and like Peterson- I have done so and live much further south now.
As someone who lives in central/northern Alberta myself it can be absolutely beautiful but as other comments have said that beauty comes with a price of long dark cold winters.
I live in Alberta. You're not missing much. The Northern lights are actually hard to see with the naked eye. And the flashy colors you see on pictures you can only capture with a camera, not with eyesight. looking at it with your eyes, It kind of vaguely looks like green air/sky, but you can't see it that clearly like the pictures, it is not as bright and the purple hues cannot be seen with your eyes at all.
The few sentences used before the intro are excellent and while he could have used a better example than gravity his point is something that should be remembered by all people, including Christians.
Good evening Jordan and Brian This evening I'm three days into a seven day holiday from my four month very new post as a Mental Health Nurse within elderly end of life care, in short. Currently and very recently winning, however first three months of my post was akin to hell. Explanation for another time, for sure. This evening I opened my window to the universe and cried at the beautiful sight of the moon and stars. Lost my amazing Dad at the same time I started my new nursing post. Super grateful my Dad was my Dad. Anyway this very moment I wish to thank both of you for passing years of sensemaking brain gym. Without you Jordan my Universe may not have made the super sense it has made. I also have to thank a previous patient of mine for mentioning you during an appointment we had many years previous. Truly grateful for you both, indeed. 2025 a year for doing. 💜
Precious Carol, it’s Ruth Anne. I am so happy you are settled into a good job after what you went through and so sorrowful to hear that you lost your Dad. I’m so aware of my parents’ mortality and I text them often just to tell them I love them. Yes, I looked at the moon and stars with my boys tonight, and we all felt how beautiful it is. Hugs from Ruth Anne
My mother went 15 times,2 times becouse his friend was to much ringing on the door bell and insisting to get married. It was nice escape. Believe me they are smart
Hi, I'm very grateful to you for your work, your lectures helped me put my life in order after two escapes from the war and started my life again for the third time, now I'm a Ukrainian from Donetsk who caught the war at 14m and then at 22, now I live in Poland
“We are living in a world in which nobody is free; in which hardly anybody is secure, in which it is almost impossible to be honest and to remain alive.”
Dearest Dr. Peterson, I am certainly looking forward to your thoughts on the news surrounding the Governor of the 51st State, as it were, whenever you can share them. I’m following the news with bated breath. Who knew that real life political scene would be so engaging. I’ve been apolitical all my life and apparently I was missing out on a good deal. Hugs from Ruth Anne
I am so glad you have had Dr. Keating on once again, dearest Dr. Peterson, I so keenly enjoyed the last time. Dr. Keating is such a good communicator and I felt I could understand and enjoy a bit of what he was sharing. Dearest Dr. Peterson, hopefully I will join you all on Peterson Academy next month, the Good Lord willing and the creek don’t rise. A very blessed Feast of Epiphany to you. With Ruth Anne’s love
I’ve listened to this entire exchange, and for most of the conversation I had no idea what these gentlemen were even talking about. I find that certain academics have a particularly frustrating tendency to over complicate any speech, or statements that they make in an effort to come across as the superior intellect.
I so quickly became the third person in this conversation that I tried to interrupt the speakers on two occasions, out loud! Thank goodness I was alone in the room and nobody will ever know. I had a wonderful chat, gentlemen. Thank you both.
I'm through 5 episodes of the gospels series on DW+. It is stuffy, arcane, ivory tower speak and I LOVE IT. It's so fantastic to gain understanding and mental ammunition to fight for Christ.
9:49 Yes! Here in Las Vegas, NV I can literally only see a handful of stars at night. Talk about a place with light pollution! I've been missing out on the night sky since 1980.
Dr. Peterson, based on your statement about arguments for the existence of God (Cardinal Newman's argument) I strongly encourage you and your staff to look into the works of Alvin Plantinga and his argument for the existence of God as "properly basic" that is, belief in God is the necessary prior assumption and basis by which we conceptualize the world around us
Bingo. God is simply a word meaning "the truest condition of Being," and is the starting reference point from which we not only define ourselves, but everything else around us.
@@chillreznov0227 I've actually listened to countless hours of Peterson. I do not recall him engaging with, much less interviewing, Alvin Plantinga. Indeed he seldom to never engages with Theologically conservative Evangelical Protestants....
14:27 Catastrophe doesn't have "astro (star)" in it. It comes from "kata+strephein" meaning overturning. 9:01 Cosmos, cosmology, and cosmetology do share the same root (kosmos) but it means "order" not "beauty".
No, he is a fairy tale. Nowhere to be seen when children are being mutilated, fcuking sick of Bible thumpers making a scapegoat out of tragedy instead of holding one's self responsible. There is no god but sure as shit, there's a Devil.
I don't personally believe or ask why are we here what is our purpose but, we (me) are so lucky to be here, and after this? I don't know just trying to take all this in, there are a lot of ideas around but most seem to be(or want to be) at the cost of this one
Excellent interview but I really really really wish Jordan Peterson would have these same conversations but with Evangelical Protestants! He interviews everyone but them! Dr. Peterson please interview: Hugh Ross on Cosmology and God William Lane Craig on Faith and Reason/Science or questions on Morality and basis there of J.P. Moreland on what is the soul
Dr Peterson, I think Chris Langan would take the conversation deeper in the direction you’re aiming with regard to our perception instantiating reality. David Knowles interviewed him but ran out of curiosity on this thread & changed the subject.
I hope you read this, Dr. Peterson If the world or at least portions of the planet would agree to turn off all light sources at night, we can ponder more on what matters and reflect on ourselves. It changes our disposition instantly.
Based on the title, I thought this was going to be about the relationship between time/space and the miracles in scripture. I hope that aspect can be covered sometime. For example, where the disciples are all in a room frightened, post-resurrection, and Jesus suddenly appears in the midst of them. All we need is one more spatial dimension and you can appear in the midst of a cube without going through any of its sides. I think it was Nachmonides who concluded, from scripture, that there were 10 dimensions.
As a 40-something amateur astronomer who only got to see truly dark skies for the first time last year, we've done ourselves a disservice by blotting out the night. Humanity has been deprived of that feeling of awe at the beauty of the cosmos. The images taken by orbital telescopes don't return that gift to the public. People look up and see nothing
3:50 I've come up with the same understanding, it's isn't facts, figures and evidence that motivates a person - it's narrative and stories. The bible presents this human understanding clearly
18:40 - that’s the weirdest thing I’ve realized about God. He is both things at the same time. I think the Tao symbol is spot on about the reality of things. The opposites are on the same coin with a little bit of the other reflected in them. Everything is white/black, small/big. It’s like how the universe is simultaneously enormous and operates using gravitational forces yet the small is extremely strong and operates using nuclear forces. God and the Universe is everything in every way. It is hard to explain but I see it more everyday.
Dr Peterson, I hope you get Dr Elaine Aron on the podcast because I think you might be an HSP yourself, and with the state of psychology being what it is we are diagnosing people with pathologizing autism who are probably just high in HSP traits.
If you do reach out to her, I bet you’d have a higher chance of getting a response if you told her your score on the self test on her website “hsperson”
@@amyb.6368 I agree! they can look quite similar especially if the clinician doing the diagnosis isn’t familiar with the concept of high sensitivity, especially if the client is in an unsupported environment for their trait.
extremely curious: is Dr. Keating's whispering while Dr. Peterson speaks a part of his rote, or could it be more than that? :) More than an utterance of "that's right" was caught so far and I'm not even halfway through the content. I'm going to assume, towards the audio engineering, that this would actually be something that is gated out of being audible in some similar settings, but in fact this is actually compressed upward in accordance with a priority for allowing softly spoken elements to come through with volume and not necessarily require much effort in post. In any case, my thanks and attention abound to some of the most well spoken and punctual people on the planet, indeed.
Well, I'm happy JP has found something to relieve the stresses of life. Religion has helped a lot of people, but it's also hurt, just as many, if not more. So if a person was to study the main language's of the main religion of the world, what would they find in the difference between them? I am not religious, and I know we're not alone. But I would certainly understand that 3000 years ago, it would certainly appear magical. Great video, boys. Thanks. Peace ✌️ 😎 from Canada, eh.
Chapter 1: Maps of Meaning - A Framework for Understanding At the heart of this work lies the foundational concept introduced by Jordan Peterson in his book Maps of Meaning. This work serves as a guide for those seeking to understand the complexities of meaning, individual purpose, and the overarching forces that shape our lives. Peterson's exploration of meaning centers on the idea that humans strive for meaning, not just as an abstract concept but as a framework that helps guide our actions, thoughts, and relationships. We begin with Peterson’s thesis: that meaning emerges from the confrontation between chaos and order. It is this dynamic interplay that shapes our lives and actions, and the path we choose to navigate this chaos and order is key to our purpose. The human experience, according to Peterson, is fundamentally about the negotiation between these two forces. This is where the importance of maps comes into play-whether these maps are personal, societal, or spiritual, they offer guidance through the chaos that surrounds us.
@Jordan.B.Peterson-p4l Thank you Jordan it means the world to me. I will not stop my yes, and yes, I will stay, yes. I figure about a year. Ava Maria Hail Christ One hallowed God above and in all. God bless you and your family. My our lord Jesus Christ of Nazareth judge us worthy of our great task. Brian Keating is my father's name.
Although the primary domain of science is and should be "the empirical domain".... tools fostered from within the domain-of-Science (reasoning tools, etc.) are applicable via wise employment across the domain-of-Faith. ~ [yet] "It would be absurd to encapsulate the value of a fish by how it climbs a tree."
The opening statement hooked me instantly and I am truly blessed to have this moment in the now to listen to this. Thank you to Dr. Brian Keating and to you as well Dr. Peterson.
@LadieKadie Oh you seem to have been triggered by my statement. If you don't like it then go somewhere else or bring a proper argument. Shoo Fly your a bother.
I see no relation between religion and history. Religion is about how to approach life to make the most out of it. To find meaning even though objectively there is none.
Probably an inappropriate question, but does JP have problems with his throat? In the very intro my whole throat clenched up hearing him speak. Probably from all the talks he gives lol
Deep gratitude to @jordanbpeterson and his incredible team for hosting me on the podcast. The conversation was thought-provoking, meaningful, and seamlessly executed. Honored to share ideas with someone who inspires such deep thinking across disciplines. Thank you!
Amazing to listen.
Mazel tov on your courses and your conversation with Dr. Peterson, Dr. Keating. I enjoyed every minute. Hope to enroll at Peterson Academy later this year!
@ Thanks very much
@DrBrianKeating This is a long shot but..... is there a way to contact you for an unusual situation?, it's impossible to put into words properly or within the space available? I made a rash decision before Dec last year, single man, 63, out of absolutely nowhere, Depression and anxiety have overwhelmed me and it relates to a house move that went wrong, the circumstances don't fill the normal criterion and I can not find anything remotely akin to it. It isn't relationship related either but I'm absolutely stuck and am very undecided about what to do but cognisant of time as it flies.
Kevin.
Someone looks at the world through my eyes; I know it's not me; But I don't know that stranger is more familiar than I am; He knows me more than I know myself; Oh God, have you made a home in my soul?! Or I in your soul;? Neither do you let me live comfortably? ! Nor do you live comfortably; Let's make peace; Come to my heart?! Take comfort in my soul, in my spirit, in my body, Come make a home in my soul; Come end this world war;!? Come end this chaos; I have become a desert; I have become like a parched desert,; I have become thirsty for you; I have become fire, I have become earth, I have become hell and burned; Become the sky for me; Become the rain for me; Become water for me; Become like a surprise for me; Take comfort in my soul; You have driven me to madness and madness; You have brought my soul to my lips; Put your lips on my lips, give your soul into my soul and revive me;!!!! I started wrestling with God, I attacked him so much, I became so intertwined with him, I became so one with him that I did not know whether I was God or he was God; we drank so much from each other's lips, we overflowed with love and passion and longing. I stared into his eyes again and said: Who are you? Are you me or I am you; I am you; He breathed into my soul and breathed into my soul until I was filled with love and desire and madness and lust and seduction. I said to him: Come to me, become a bomb in my soul. Become a world war, become corruption and sedition and lust; He also breathed into my soul with all his power and strength; and in my soul, like a world war, it became an atomic bomb and fire and water. I stared into his eyes again and wrestled with him and intertwined with him and became one with him but I was not satisfied, I became thirstier every moment I said with love I do not know, God, am I you, or are you me?!
I'm 15,and Dr Peterson has helped me a lot.I'm trying to take responsibility,get my life together and aim upward,despite having a fractured family and childhood.This man has given me faith.God bless you,Dr Peterson❤
Pss , I see that you are trying to use grammatics , a couple of suggestion dear young boy : put spaces before and after a comma , also for periods . Last mistake , at the beginning , there's no need for a comma before an "and" , usually writing . I see that you are reading , go on young boy , keep studying , stay strong . Future has hope , like the present .
I'm so glad to hear young people like you are taking advantage of the accessibility you have to knowledge. When I was 15 I wasn't anywhere near the mental ability I have today to enjoy Dr Peterson. If your generation follows same path as you then we are in for a very hopeful future :) Cheers!
Good on you! It is challenging trying to become more than what we’re born into. Never give up or give in, your self awareness at such a young age is incredible. ❤ Best of luck to you in this life.
@@Simon89Jeppesen I think that's a very complicated question definitely not something any of us can answer in one comment, not even Jordan Peterson. i'd probably suggest learning about depression. and thinking about other people more. even just the goal can be enough to see at least a little bit of movement in the beginning. but I'm sure you can find a way to make things better.
thats awsome im excited for you. i see you are trying to do things despite haveing a fractured family and thats i think a very intelligent decision on your part. it's very easy to play the victim and dangerous. so definitely keep moving in that direction anyway you can.
One of the best talks you've had in a while with a guest. I love the mingling of the scientific with the religious
@@VictorMatsunaga 🙏
It's the pathway
@@DrBrianKeating I love your Channel Dr. Brian!
I miss the intense conversations with Eric Weinstein, would be awesome to have someone try and distill his Geometric Unity theory in a more mundane and low IQ (such as mine) way.
Joe Rogan didn't seem to be too interested in getting to actually understand it, which was disappointing to me when I listened to the podcast where Eric mentions his theory :/
Fiction mixing with facts can be insightful.
Yes me too, they touch on some very good points where they are able to entangle philosophy, events and studies of other nature. Very thought provoking and all in all, light for the soul.
I'm envious of Dr Peterson's northern Alberta childhood in which he regularly saw the Aurora Borealis. I've yet to see it myself and it's on the bucket list, along with seeing a total solar eclipse. We do lose something when the background light obscures the beauty of the night sky, just as we lose something when our contact with nature is reduced. Most of us have a secret longing for a cabin in the forest somewhere, but almost none of us will ever end up in one. This was another excellent discussion. No doubt Dr Peterson is delighted with the news coming out of Canada today.
i think he talked about his childhood in alberta and it was pretty shit. This is why he no longer lives there.
@@SpaceMarine113 I grew up in the same climate in Alaska and trust me, you’re not missing a lot. The horrid dark winters are little consolation for the wonder of aurora borealis. I would trade any day, and like Peterson- I have done so and live much further south now.
As someone who lives in central/northern Alberta myself it can be absolutely beautiful but as other comments have said that beauty comes with a price of long dark cold winters.
That's well worth your time....
I live in Alberta. You're not missing much. The Northern lights are actually hard to see with the naked eye. And the flashy colors you see on pictures you can only capture with a camera, not with eyesight. looking at it with your eyes, It kind of vaguely looks like green air/sky, but you can't see it that clearly like the pictures, it is not as bright and the purple hues cannot be seen with your eyes at all.
The few sentences used before the intro are excellent and while he could have used a better example than gravity his point is something that should be remembered by all people, including Christians.
This is why podcasting is the greatest gift the Internet gave us! 🙌🏻
Well it might be if JP allowed the guest to speak.
@@rossco12 Thank you,
Good evening Jordan and Brian
This evening I'm three days into a seven day holiday from my four month very new post as a Mental Health Nurse within elderly end of life care, in short.
Currently and very recently winning, however first three months of my post was akin to hell. Explanation for another time, for sure.
This evening I opened my window to the universe and cried at the beautiful sight of the moon and stars.
Lost my amazing Dad at the same time I started my new nursing post. Super grateful my Dad was my Dad.
Anyway this very moment I wish to thank both of you for passing years of sensemaking brain gym.
Without you Jordan my Universe may not have made the super sense it has made.
I also have to thank a previous patient of mine for mentioning you during an appointment we had many years previous.
Truly grateful for you both, indeed.
2025 a year for doing.
💜
Precious Carol, it’s Ruth Anne. I am so happy you are settled into a good job after what you went through and so sorrowful to hear that you lost your Dad. I’m so aware of my parents’ mortality and I text them often just to tell them I love them. Yes, I looked at the moon and stars with my boys tonight, and we all felt how beautiful it is.
Hugs from Ruth Anne
@AFringedGentianToEnnien I'm crying with joy again. Thank you Ruth Anne.
Thanks
God bless you carol!
My mother went 15 times,2 times becouse his friend was to much ringing on the door bell and insisting to get married.
It was nice escape.
Believe me they are smart
Best conversation I've heard in 4 years. Finally someone that can out tangent Peterson. What a great Combination. Thank you Brian!
Unsure whether I have thanked you both for this interesting conversation, but all the best Mr Keating love that one can't deny science :)
the enthusiasm and eagerness from both parties are off the roof! it's my third time watching this episode, and it still gets me smiling to brim!
make sure you rest enough , we need you to continue your teaching and book referrals ❤
Hi, I'm very grateful to you for your work, your lectures helped me put my life in order after two escapes from the war and started my life again for the third time, now I'm a Ukrainian from Donetsk who caught the war at 14m and then at 22, now I live in Poland
May God blesses you and keep you from harm. From a Vietnam War refugee at 11 years old
“We are living in a world in which nobody is free; in which hardly anybody is secure, in which it is almost impossible to be honest and to remain alive.”
Dearest Dr. Peterson, I am certainly looking forward to your thoughts on the news surrounding the Governor of the 51st State, as it were, whenever you can share them. I’m following the news with bated breath. Who knew that real life political scene would be so engaging. I’ve been apolitical all my life and apparently I was missing out on a good deal.
Hugs from Ruth Anne
This was an excellent discussion. You both have deep insights on these subjects. I always learn invaluable perspective from dr. Peterson.
I am so glad you have had Dr. Keating on once again, dearest Dr. Peterson, I so keenly enjoyed the last time. Dr. Keating is such a good communicator and I felt I could understand and enjoy a bit of what he was sharing.
Dearest Dr. Peterson, hopefully I will join you all on Peterson Academy next month, the Good Lord willing and the creek don’t rise.
A very blessed Feast of Epiphany to you.
With Ruth Anne’s love
Thank you, so much
Hello. What a wonderful conversation thank you very much for everyone involved.👍🙏
@@jeffbilyard7848 so great to hear that
This was an absolutely beautiful conversation, thank you both.
Agreed!
I’ve listened to this entire exchange, and for most of the conversation I had no idea what these gentlemen were even talking about. I find that certain academics have a particularly frustrating tendency to over complicate any speech, or statements that they make in an effort to come across as the superior intellect.
I so quickly became the third person in this conversation that I tried to interrupt the speakers on two occasions, out loud! Thank goodness I was alone in the room and nobody will ever know. I had a wonderful chat, gentlemen. Thank you both.
So e 1:32:26 njoyed this ...will now follow Dr. Brian Keating ..thanks JP
So excited to view this with Dr. Peterson!!!
@@normaorlando3538 🙌
Jordan is getting better guests all the time!
@@TonyMountjoy Thank you, I
I'm through 5 episodes of the gospels series on DW+. It is stuffy, arcane, ivory tower speak and I LOVE IT. It's so fantastic to gain understanding and mental ammunition to fight for Christ.
Yes! Now onto apolgetics and get on out there! Biola U.
Awesome exchange of ideas what a great conversation 🎉
Wonderful interview!
9:49 Yes! Here in Las Vegas, NV I can literally only see a handful of stars at night. Talk about a place with light pollution! I've been missing out on the night sky since 1980.
Dr. Peterson, based on your statement about arguments for the existence of God (Cardinal Newman's argument) I strongly encourage you and your staff to look into the works of Alvin Plantinga and his argument for the existence of God as "properly basic" that is, belief in God is the necessary prior assumption and basis by which we conceptualize the world around us
Bingo. God is simply a word meaning "the truest condition of Being," and is the starting reference point from which we not only define ourselves, but everything else around us.
@sullivan1858 There IS no such thing as "a god" energy wise, we are collectively god and part of the universe.
Sounds like you haven't listened to a lot of Jordan's content if you felt the need to say that lol
@@chillreznov0227 I've actually listened to countless hours of Peterson. I do not recall him engaging with, much less interviewing, Alvin Plantinga. Indeed he seldom to never engages with Theologically conservative Evangelical Protestants....
14:27 Catastrophe doesn't have "astro (star)" in it. It comes from "kata+strephein" meaning overturning.
9:01 Cosmos, cosmology, and cosmetology do share the same root (kosmos) but it means "order" not "beauty".
The beginning of the discussion reminds me of this...
“Wisdom is the recovery of innocence at the far end of experience.”
- David Bentley Hart
Two of my favorite thinkers! 🎉
Bless you all here watching this. Christ is King, yea or nay?
Oh a very big ol Yea!!! 🙌🙌🙌
💯
No, he is a fairy tale. Nowhere to be seen when children are being mutilated, fcuking sick of Bible thumpers making a scapegoat out of tragedy instead of holding one's self responsible. There is no god but sure as shit, there's a Devil.
A definite yay praise God
So cringe what is wrong with you seals?....hello from a believer smh
Love this; impossible to separate science from ethics
Outstanding interaction!!!!
You are a huge inspiration for me and have helped alot thank you ❤D33
I don't personally believe or ask why are we here what is our purpose but, we (me) are so lucky to be here, and after this? I don't know just trying to take all this in, there are a lot of ideas around but most seem to be(or want to be) at the cost of this one
Great discussion. And yes, I'm aware I'm full of it many times, lol.
Excellent interview but I really really really wish Jordan Peterson would have these same conversations but with Evangelical Protestants! He interviews everyone but them! Dr. Peterson please interview:
Hugh Ross on Cosmology and God
William Lane Craig on Faith and Reason/Science or questions on Morality and basis there of
J.P. Moreland on what is the soul
Dr.Keating asked the question, what was the most important day on the calendar ? My answer TODAY !!! Without it, there would be no days.
Dr Peterson, I think Chris Langan would take the conversation deeper in the direction you’re aiming with regard to our perception instantiating reality. David Knowles interviewed him but ran out of curiosity on this thread & changed the subject.
I would be interested to hear Dr. Peterson interview Dr. Scott Masson. Hopefully that will happen soon.
Second smartest Keating. RHK* God Bless
I hope you read this, Dr. Peterson
If the world or at least portions of the planet would agree to turn off all light sources at night, we can ponder more on what matters and reflect on ourselves. It changes our disposition instantly.
❤❤❤ though the discussion was cut right where it got very interesting for me and my own area of work :)
Based on the title, I thought this was going to be about the relationship between time/space and the miracles in scripture. I hope that aspect can be covered sometime. For example, where the disciples are all in a room frightened, post-resurrection, and Jesus suddenly appears in the midst of them. All we need is one more spatial dimension and you can appear in the midst of a cube without going through any of its sides. I think it was Nachmonides who concluded, from scripture, that there were 10 dimensions.
As a 40-something amateur astronomer who only got to see truly dark skies for the first time last year, we've done ourselves a disservice by blotting out the night. Humanity has been deprived of that feeling of awe at the beauty of the cosmos. The images taken by orbital telescopes don't return that gift to the public. People look up and see nothing
Thanks for sharing, shared.
3:50 I've come up with the same understanding, it's isn't facts, figures and evidence that motivates a person - it's narrative and stories. The bible presents this human understanding clearly
18:40 - that’s the weirdest thing I’ve realized about God. He is both things at the same time. I think the Tao symbol is spot on about the reality of things. The opposites are on the same coin with a little bit of the other reflected in them. Everything is white/black, small/big. It’s like how the universe is simultaneously enormous and operates using gravitational forces yet the small is extremely strong and operates using nuclear forces. God and the Universe is everything in every way. It is hard to explain but I see it more everyday.
The divine in intervention creates awe. 🙂
I enjoyed the discourse with Brian much more with Jordan than him on his own channel.
Dr Peterson, I hope you get Dr Elaine Aron on the podcast because I think you might be an HSP yourself, and with the state of psychology being what it is we are diagnosing people with pathologizing autism who are probably just high in HSP traits.
If you do reach out to her, I bet you’d have a higher chance of getting a response if you told her your score on the self test on her website “hsperson”
Autism is quite different from HSP, and it's possible to have both. But I agree that would be a great guest!
@@amyb.6368 I agree! they can look quite similar especially if the clinician doing the diagnosis isn’t familiar with the concept of high sensitivity, especially if the client is in an unsupported environment for their trait.
Congratulations!!
Canadian citizens have to be thrilled to hear that Justin Trudeau has finally decided to resign! God Bless Canada!
Thank you 🇨🇦
He's only one of many.
We’ll be happy when he is in jail.
Does Peterson Academy have a dark mode?
extremely curious: is Dr. Keating's whispering while Dr. Peterson speaks a part of his rote, or could it be more than that? :) More than an utterance of "that's right" was caught so far and I'm not even halfway through the content.
I'm going to assume, towards the audio engineering, that this would actually be something that is gated out of being audible in some similar settings, but in fact this is actually compressed upward in accordance with a priority for allowing softly spoken elements to come through with volume and not necessarily require much effort in post.
In any case, my thanks and attention abound to some of the most well spoken and punctual people on the planet, indeed.
👍 this comment if you want JBP interview Stephen meyer!
Well, I'm happy JP has found something to relieve the stresses of life. Religion has helped a lot of people, but it's also hurt, just as many, if not more. So if a person was to study the main language's of the main religion of the world, what would they find in the difference between them? I am not religious, and I know we're not alone. But I would certainly understand that 3000 years ago, it would certainly appear magical. Great video, boys. Thanks. Peace ✌️ 😎 from Canada, eh.
"Embedded-ness" is not a word.
Gracias Jordan
Cosmetology is my favorite subject. Does hairspray have anti gravity properties?😂
@@annjames1837 indeed
Chapter 1: Maps of Meaning - A Framework for Understanding
At the heart of this work lies the foundational concept introduced by Jordan Peterson in his book Maps of Meaning. This work serves as a guide for those seeking to understand the complexities of meaning, individual purpose, and the overarching forces that shape our lives. Peterson's exploration of meaning centers on the idea that humans strive for meaning, not just as an abstract concept but as a framework that helps guide our actions, thoughts, and relationships.
We begin with Peterson’s thesis: that meaning emerges from the confrontation between chaos and order. It is this dynamic interplay that shapes our lives and actions, and the path we choose to navigate this chaos and order is key to our purpose. The human experience, according to Peterson, is fundamentally about the negotiation between these two forces. This is where the importance of maps comes into play-whether these maps are personal, societal, or spiritual, they offer guidance through the chaos that surrounds us.
@Jordan.B.Peterson-p4l Thank you Jordan it means the world to me. I will not stop my yes, and yes, I will stay, yes. I figure about a year. Ava Maria Hail Christ One hallowed God above and in all. God bless you and your family. My our lord Jesus Christ of Nazareth judge us worthy of our great task. Brian Keating is my father's name.
Donna Mary is my mother's name.
Although the primary domain of science is and should be "the empirical domain".... tools fostered from within the domain-of-Science (reasoning tools, etc.) are applicable via wise employment across the domain-of-Faith. ~ [yet] "It would be absurd to encapsulate the value of a fish by how it climbs a tree."
If you like Dr. Petersons content you might appreciate the 20+ videos I've made covering his academy.
Facts over faith 🙏
You don’t get many facts without faith…
You mean both.
That’s not how you enter a marriage.
That’s not how you enter a marriage.
6:41 I swear he says pastromany. The study of pastromi
@Jordan.B.Peterson-p4l absolutely amazing number
Great conversation, thank you. I would highly recommend having author and pastor John Burke, who has studied near death experiences for years.
Love John Burke. Imagine Heaven and Imagine the God of Heaven are both wonderful books! God is using him!
Omg best episode ever
Seeing the Milky Way in its entirety must be amazing to behold. Especially as a young man. I'm jealous🙂
What is the word Petterson used a few times in this? Reprosmov or Reprosmoff, not sure what it is
1:14 Hey Jordan, Please read the Upanishads.
6:40 Cosmology is science? What’s a hypothesis from the field of cosmology?
The opening statement hooked me instantly and I am truly blessed to have this moment in the now to listen to this. Thank you to Dr. Brian Keating and to you as well Dr. Peterson.
@LadieKadie Oh you seem to have been triggered by my statement. If you don't like it then go somewhere else or bring a proper argument. Shoo Fly your a bother.
@LadieKadie 😂🤣😂🤣😂 Triggered much. Coward!
@@LadieKadie So triggered! 😂🤣😂🤣 did I hurt your little feelings. Coward
I hope you could interview Dr Stephen Meyer
You should have Bart E. Do the lectures on Bilical Textual Criticism. Perhaps with Kipp D.
Would be fascinating with the production value.
Richard Feynman quote - "Science is the philosophy of ignorance"
I enjoyed this episode.
Brian always got interesting stuff to say.
Religion is a record of what happened in history and Science explains how and why it happened
I see no relation between religion and history.
Religion is about how to approach life to make the most out of it. To find meaning even though objectively there is none.
@ Good for you. Then you shouldn’t celebrate Christmas or Easter. Which are the birth and death of Jesus.
@@alexadam8819 You are quite good at finding non-existent connections🤣
@@gzoechiBe gone you Atheist.
came for jp's hand gestures. I'll learn how I can get it
Jordan, much love from Toronto. Please make sure to be taking care of yourself. Your voice is sounding pretty rough these days. 🫶🏼
Thought is free.
The night sky is only free to those with the ability to witness it.
Thought is free, if you keep it inside your head....
@ when it comes out of your head it’s called speech.
@ta1260 The consequences of that may be deadly.....
@@wheel-man5319 which is why you keep it in your head. What the fuck are we doing here?
What is in his left sleeve?
Great conversation. also, congratulations on Trudeao resignation my dear Dr Peterson 😂🎉
Best guest yet
Thanks
Cool thumbnail
Thanks
Aren’t we going into a timeline shift. Bright time ahead is inevitable.
내가 존경하는 조던피터슨 🙏😊💛
any cosmology that overlook the central role of plasma and electricity accross the universe is incomplete
If I hear "a. Pryori ethical framework " one more time......
Congratulations on Bye Felicia 👋🏾😎
To teach is to learn.
Only by teaching can you truly understand a subject.
Probably an inappropriate question, but does JP have problems with his throat? In the very intro my whole throat clenched up hearing him speak. Probably from all the talks he gives lol
brilliant x2
You don’t get to look at the night sky if you’re in prison ☹️
Who's this guy
..very smart
It me
@DrBrianKeating subscribed 💯💯🙏 thank you Sir
@ wonderful
Jordan Peterson accidentally giving the best advertising for his lectures 🤣
Josh Groban - Galileo (lyrics)😊
Billy Joel - Lullabye (Goodnight, My Angel) (Official Video)
Jonathan Livingston Seagull - grade 7 - Samson Junior High School - cold room in the addition built on, second floor
Jordan, do you have a cold in the ad in the beginning?
He sounds awful, like it hurts to talk
1:15:22 this is my point
I need someone to share their DW login 😆🤣