BAND MAID (LIVE) - PLAY - DRUMMER REACTS
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 ต.ค. 2024
- Good morning Drum Nerds, hopefully you're well. Please enjoy BAND MAID (LIVE) - PLAY - DRUMMER REACTS
Always a treat to watch them throw down some fun and vibe creating groves.
Original video - • BAND-MAID / Play (Offi...
SUPPORT THE 10k SUB JAPAN SPECIAL HERE - www.buymeacoff...
JOIN THE DRUM NERD ELITE FOR EXTRA PERKY GOODNESS!
/ @drumnerd
Be well and keep your stick on the ice,
Colin
#drummerreacts #bandmaid @BANDMAID
If you're able to please consider SUPPORTING THE 10k SUB JAPAN SPECIAL HERE - www.buymeacoffee.com/DrumNerd THANK YOU ALL.
Hard pass.
We are all here to enjoy the music and your constructive technical breakdown of the song is much appreciated. I think we all want the best for this band too. Take care.
There are drum only videos for many of their songs to be found online ;)
After a few years, Akane changed the way she held her drumsticks, which can be seen in this video from 2016, when she held them "properly". It was probably related to her health problems with the spine. So this is not a "technical error", but her conscious decision.
th-cam.com/video/844bAPjKWNU/w-d-xo.html
THE PROPER GRIP IS WHATEVER WORKS. WE ALL HAVE DIFFERENT SHAPED HANDS AND TENDENCIES
I always play Play when I’m turning someone on to Band-Maid because Play shows how good the Maids play when they’re playing Play. 😜🤘 Thx, Cloin!
It's a solid choice for sure to get people digging what they do! You're a smart man and great taste maker that's for sure :) Happy Saturday and have a great weekend. Be well.
@@DRUMNERD 🙏
MISA (bass) grew up with a mom who heard a lot of old school rock - including The Who!
The heart of this song is an instrumental that Kanami wrote. Story goes that Saiki really liked the song and saw another future for it. She asked Miku to write lyrics to it and Play was born. Interesting how these song evolve into what we hear. This song blew me away the first time I heard it. Awesome arrangement. Great analysis.
The BEST Japanese female drummers HARUNA(LOVEBITES), AKANE(BAND-MAID), JUNNA/NAGISA(TRIDENT-JAPAN), TAMU(NEMOPHILA), HANA/YURI(GACHARIC SPIN), SAE/CHIKA(HANABIE), SAO-CHAN(MAXIMUM THE HORMON)
Nao is the drummer for MTH.
The psychology of fandom is so interesting. I’d be willing to bet if you talked to Akane and asked her why she held the sticks that way she’d either say it was just for that song for whatever reason, or that she had fallen into bad habits which she has since corrected (since this isn’t something you’ve seen in other videos). Either way I’m sure she wouldn’t be offended and you’d likely have a great time together talking about drumming.
I couldn't agree with you more, and honestly - if she showed me what benefits it could have - I'd walk a way having learned something new and being thankful for it. The issue these oddly emotional and defensive odd balls seem to have is they think that me asking basic, factual questions or making clear statements about drumming efficacy is in some way hating her or being a dick. I don't think anyone of the drummers thought that when Gus Moller went around and interviewed them all regarding their technique. I would cherish the day she and I could just have a nerdy drum chat. Have a great weekend mate, be well.
@@DRUMNERDI'm sure that you and Akane could spend hours laughing yourselves silly over incredibly technical percussive minutiae in addition to the role of thermodynamics in the fishes eternal struggle to ride a bicycle ! Your stream of consciousness explanations are always informative and never dull to my uninformed, non-drummer self . Have a great week and count yer chicklets after a cranial cross-check ! 🤕🏒
Akane is the best 🤘🤘🤘🥁🥁🥁 I saw them live in Detroit and dang her drums were so freaking amazing live best band in the world 🌎 Band-Maid!!! 🤘🤘🤘🎸🎸🎸🎤🇯🇵🇯🇵🥁🥁
That performance will forever be in my heart and head (cuz my ears rang for 3 days, from sitting in front of Kanami's stack of speakers !) 🤯🎸
I was taught to hold drumsticks so that they balanced on the index finger (rather than holding them down at the butt end) to achieve greater control.
After being released from YT incarceration (god knows why i was put there) It's nice to hear something that is SO science based and not dwelling in the land of Unicorn Tears and fluffy bunny-shaped clouds . Thank you , Colin , for taking the invisible slashing penalties , sitting in the box , and coming back out swinging Probert style ! 😁🏒
Honestly mate, this has made my night! I just showed the clip to my girlfriend of Probert taking out Maguire to defend Yzerman...to show her who Probert was and the reference you made. Genuinely, you're a beaut man, really appreciate the support and kindness you bring to the channel. I will always come out swinging if I'm targeted first. Also, hope to one day be put into the comment hall of fame 😎 Have a fabulous weekend and wonderful week buddy. Be well.
Also, welcome back from the YT sin bin; for whatever ridiculous snowflake reason they put you there.
Your comment about Akane's left hand made me wonder if this was a personal choice for the song or her drumming style in general. I looked back at your reactions to Sense, Domination & Onset and saw that her stick is farther back for those songs. So I believe that was a song choice, not necessarily a style choice.
That is a very valid point of view. It is likely that this grip choice was done out of need for the specific song choice and to that I absolutely yield. The issue I have with the trolls on here who say I'm jealous or a hater simply because I said - the fulcrum point of the stick is legitimately located somewhere and she might get more rebound and power by holding it there; somehow means I'm an asshole or an idiot who's jealous - that really confuses me. I love her playing, love the band and am a big fan of what she does. Happy Saturday and hopefully you have a great weekend. I genuinely do see your point and it does hold water. Be well.
Akane does a self-cover of this song on Band-Maid Prime. I think her hand position in this live video was a preference for a certain feel, sound or other reason. Please SUBSCRIBE and enjoy all their self-covers.
@@gku8744 Already subscribed to Band-Maid prime !
This is an older video and I believe I read somewhere Akane had to change her drumming style due to fatigue/health issues with shoulder and back pain. Something along those lines.
Band Maid are horrible with super jumpy videos. You'd have to subscribe to Prime to see them but they have several videos of just one member playing so you can full focus on Akane. Problem is its behind a paywell and would get struck. She shifts her grip a lot even during this song if you watch closely. If you look at old videos like Thrill she played a lot with her shoulders. After a hiatus due to a back injury, she modified her style a lot.
If you take the time there are a couple of videos exclusively showing Akane. The view is from above
Achi spent much of covid lockdown videoing herself performing. Just to iron out what she saw as a ton of little issues. It shows with her recent work.
You want to get your face melted by a Japanese band?
Asterism-Rising Moon.
Geezuz bloke! You cannot debate that Akane does amazing with things with "the wrong grip point". Look at how Senri Kawaguchi grips her sticks. Gawd, you can be a really annoying twit. Akane is my drum goddess!!!
Alright mate, I normally don’t go this hard but you sir can seriously get on your bike and fuck off. Just because you have an incel boner for her doesn’t validate your lack of drumming knowledge. There is correct grip technique and there is incorrect grip technique in terms of efficiency with the stick. You not liking science isn’t a factor in its outcome. So again, go fuck your self. Be well.
@@DRUMNERDIf I could subscribe to you twice or more , I would. 🤣👍
@@FullTexanEffect love it mate! I appreciate the support and am happy to have you on the channel. Hope you have a great Saturday and weekend. Be well.
@@DRUMNERD I only will say that Akane does shift her grip from song to song. I've seen her play holding the sticks at the base, then 1/3rd of the way up like she did here, and I think it was in her solo in Freedom she played with her grip half way up on the left hand and below on the right, but both hands grip changed by the end of the solo.
During their Lollapalooza performance of Hate? she lost a stick. At first several of us thought she had broken one and tossed it, but thinking about how she changes her grip, she ma have lost her grip while changing during the song, so she tossed it and grabbed a new stick.
@@greylocke100 Dude's a hater, who loses the music in the theory.
"It's so hard so see what's going on with live tracks"
Be careful what you wish for...
AntMusic has released some videos where Akane does the drums for BandMaid tracks (sans tracks):
No God -- th-cam.com/video/OJKlby7pZTM/w-d-xo.html
Giovanni -- th-cam.com/video/J-EB5TWhqnc/w-d-xo.html
Sense -- th-cam.com/video/rvj7Kwt7Be8/w-d-xo.html
There are others. Perhaps you could do these followed by the live videos?
edit: There's plenty more there, I almost missed Without Holding Back --th-cam.com/video/ER1fRh-mw9U/w-d-xo.html
watch the white room sessions- instrumentals'
Live? I hope?
It is indeed mate. Be well.
You stop in the worst places. You should at least back up. And whatever you say about her grip, you're the TH-cam critic, and she's The Rock Star, thermodynamics be damned. And, speaking of physics, and the "genetically built in world we live in", whatever that means, maybe, being a smallish woman, she has to hold it that way to get the power she does. Maybe that's more important than than bounce balance. She and MISA studied at the Tokyo School Of Music together. I'm sure she's been taught every stick grip under the sun and uses what works for her. When you go on a world tour and make LMVs I'd actually want to watch I'll critique your grip. You may be the Drum Nerd, but she's The Beast. You asked, but I think you're just fishing for comments.
Your comment only let's me know that you want me to roast you and give you attention; which I just won't do. And if you want to know who taught me - educate yourself and look up Pete Reilly, Bob Armstrong and Dom Famularo; enjoy. By the way, regardless of being a small girl or a large man, the fulcrum point of a drum stick will largely be the same, you know as it's a rather standardized length (although I should express that some sticks are slightly longer or shorter than others) to avoid you from trying to throw that in the mix. Facts don't care about your feelings and science is based in the real world; not one of your wishes and misinformed ideologies. Hey look, you also got some attention in this after all, well done cupcake. Be well.
@@DRUMNERD If one wants the full power of a hammer as a lever to drive a spike, one holds it near the end of the shaft, not at its point of balance or fulcrum point which would be near the hammer's head. If I want to drive a small finishing nail, I hold the shaft near the head to give light taps. I'm not a drummer but I've driven tons of nails. Drum tutor Rob Brown with 300K followers says the hand position on the sticks can vary greatly according to what one wants to accomplish on the drums. Makes sense to me and I assume a great drummer like Akane knows what she is doing. I'm not a troll but blanket statements can sometimes be perceived as being limited and unfair. Just saying.
@DRUMNERD This video was from 2020. I know during COVID she spent a lot of time working on her fundamentals so I'm curious if she holds it different now? Anyway enjoyed the reaction.
@@DRUMNERD Don't pay attention to me. Pay attention to her. Go watch the Documentary on Akane with specific attention to the other drummers commenting on her drumming. And BTW, you asked to be roasted in the comments. You're welcome!
Also, being a drum nerd, I'm sure you've seen the Great drummers talking about Ringo's playing. Akane is on that level. And though I'm sure you're a much better drummer than I am a musician, I have played with great drummers and I admire anyone who can do it at that level, and by extension you as well, but even the best critique is a fart in the wind to even the most meager performance. So now go and change the world with you music and I will do my best as well. But be careful what you ask for. If you wanted to be roasted in the comments, don't get your panties in a twist when you are. Okay? Much respect. Now GFY! @@DRUMNERD
I think you really missed the main point......this is a total jam !!!!!! and Akane's playing fits the song so well without going overboard. After
reading some of the comments, you seem to need to really impress upon everyone how knowledgeable you about drumming. The
problem is the video should be about the drummer and not you and your idiotic explanations.
Your grammar is appalling. “How knowledgeable you about drumming.” Please fix this before insulting me again. Be well.
Some constructive criticism of your reaction habit:-----Swigging your drink---whether ciffee or water or whatever---adds NOTHING to the efficacy of your act.-------------------NO,it it is NOT cool.
It is a bit boring. It is a bit repulsive.
Please try to correct your bad habit before offering criticism to others.
Swigging is tolerable in babies with a bottle.......not in any other circumstance.
Some positive response, I don't drink my coffee in any way to be cool and I don't drink it on the channel to be cool. I film in the morning and thus, right around the time I have my coffee. You're on a different planet if you think I'd forgo having my coffee, least of which because someone dislikes me drinking it. Finally, nothing on my channel is an act; I turn on my computer, hit record and just go. P.S - I only drink coffee, not ciffee. Are you also suggesting that if someone isn't perfect, they can't offer criticism? As for that logic, your inability to spell '''coffee'' would render your criticism irrelevant (using your logic). Be well.