Incredible patience of the ccp. For 3 months this when on. Meanwhile the US executed 4 students after one week of occupying campuses. And now we see how they arrest pro Palestinian protestors in the UK, USA, Germany.
@@SurBlox Yeah and a lot of the students are communist. You know democracy exists in all government systems right? The west loves to use Chinese protestors but then tries to hide that they're also chanting pro communism slogans or display mao/communist signs 🤣
The media mostly focused on Beijing, and most of the footages taken are from there. However, large protests also happened in other cities, especially in Shanghai, Guangzhou, Changsha, Wuhan, and Chengdu.
@@photosalbum7047 lol, your ignorance surprised me. In that cities, protests were in normal way. No rioter, no weapon robbing, no burning people alive.
@@Qiushishuo Riots were the most violent across all of China in the cities of Changsha and Xi'an on the 22 of April, not in Beijing (Not including fighting response to live munitions used by Chinese soldiers on June 3-4). Stop saying solid lies Commiebot
I had a business and technology trip planned to China at the time to install equipment used for circuit board design and manufacturing; passport ready to go but the Tiananmen massacre changed my mind. Since then I have no interest in ever visiting China.
Gotten worse? In what way? Have you seen what PRC looks like nowadays? They lifted 800 milion people out of poverty and completely eliminated abject poverty. Nearly 80 percent of Chinese millennials are homeowners, what is that in the US?
One of the students during the protests held a sign saying "Absolute power corrupts absolutely'. That sign describes China even more so today than in 1989.
@@adriancarty612 you're not wrong, but chinese government is the one in question here and also the mistakes another doesn't makes china's issues any less worse.
@@fongponto educate yourself and youll find the answer. just because they are the 2nd most powerful economy right now doesnt mean that their people are happy most chinese youth are suffering right now
@@leonlee9223more likely if you distributed this you would be disappeared. They don't like to talk about this. A lot of young Chinese people don't even know about it.
Sad that these students lost their lives. They wanted to have a better life by reforming China into a democracy. But instead, are killed by the orders of old men with old thinking. Also, sad that at the moment both China and Russia are run by two individuals who are wanting to return back to a time when it was rough for the people instead of making their lives better.
@ where is your video link? I’ve been asking for the past 3 months CNN, CNBC, 60 mins, AP, Reuters, BBC, MSNBC have all provided video links. I have not seen your video link that shows Tiananmen Square being peaceful on 1989-06-04
that's a youtube mobile app bug. just close and reopen the app. I've had that a couple of times before. same as the pause button not showing up when I tap on the video.
@@user-drhnkwyrn Yeah I've seen that on the train and bus. They want to be carried on in their poverty expecting the government to do everything for them... that's the 50 cent army.
@@DanH-u3f so where are the video clips from Chinese media showing that on 1989-06-04, Tiananmen Square was a nice summer days with children playing and chocolate milk spilling? All I see are Chinese blood🩸 spilling on 🇨🇳 soil
The tank tries to get around him several times he claims on top of it, gets down and finally some civilian comes and pulls him away. Before western agents tried to hijack the protests for a shot at a color revolution, Communist students were demanding a return to Maoist principles in these protests, literally demanding more orthodox communism. This man was trying to stop the tanks from leaving the square and returning to barracks.
Tank man climbed on top of the tank, then climbed back down, then try to stop the tank again. A moment later, few pedestrians walked toward him pulled him out of that situation. You probably wouldnt know if MSM wouldnt show you the complete story.
China deploy army late into the uprising in 1989, no army at all in the 2019 Hong Kong one. France did straight away in New Caledonia in 2024, and reinforce far from Europe, Australia & New Zealand pledge troop too, all target the very first islanders. The media did not report number of soldier vs protest die in 1989, civilian vs protest die in 2019 Hong Kong. The media did report the number of police & islander die in the New Caledonia event.
The student want to get rid of deng Deng want to bring China into the Modern world The people in the countryside support the government Only some people in the capital support The student
To be honest, most of us, then the street protesters in the Square, now feel really fortunate that China didn't swallow your color revolution pill (as years later on repeated in Ukraine and the Arab Spring), and thus didn't go down the drain like another Soviet Union. That was a true inflexion point in the world's modern history.
And it is sad that in almost every country where college students have risen up in peaceful many always end up dead, again governments sending the military or police against student protestors all over the world many times have resulted with students deaths. Responded before you get flooded with the "whataboutism" people like to play
Mike Wallace is in the room... lol! I miss that reporter... I miss that whole generation of reporters. It was back when there were reporters and when 'The News" was a brag piece that was expected to lose money, but was still worth doing.
Yeah. I was thinking, were blackberries out? But since the report was done in 2001, (and cell phones were still quite new actually), maybe Mike Wallace had a minor brain collapse, and was actually referring to some other technological device I'm not familiar with? Morse code? Telegram?
we all know,there are more than 3000 fake accounts doing fake propaganda for the government,in Chinese,they are called wumao and paid by the government.
The government did the right thing in 1989. Ask yourself this: if the anti-government protests were not put down, would the average Chinese's living standards be better or worse today? Political stability is the foundation of China's miraculous economic development.
I was about the age of those students. When I saw the footage back then i was furious like many of the Hong Kong people. I went to June 4 memorial gathering year after year as much as I could to show my support to the poor students. Then suddenly I saw the event repeat itself, only in Hong Kong in 2019. The difference is that I saw the truth with my real eyes but heard deeply biased reports from those same media. I started to doubt what I was shown before. I soon found out that signature scene where the guy stood in front of the tank to make you think he would be crushed next turned out he was pulled aside, and the Chinese army, who were also as young as those students, many of them were beaten, tortured, burnt and thrown from overpass. If that so called democracy movement had its way back then and the government was overthrown, China would not be as prosperous and strong as it is today.
When Americans care about a country and continue to focus on topics, it is definitely unfortunate for that country. Fortunately, the Chinese people are wise and powerful enough not to become a vassal state of the United States. China is not the European Union or Japan, and we will not let the United States control exploitation casually.
35 years before, these students risked their lives to require democracy for their people, when CCP had bad record like cultural revolution. Comparing US campus now to 1989 Tiananmen?
They risked their lives, but who was killed? The US police captured these students who were demanding justice, so is there no difference between the US and Chinese governments? The Chinese government admitted their fault regarding the Cultural Revolution and included it in history textbooks. Now, let's talk about the massacre of Native Americans in the US. How do their descendants feel knowing their ancestors were subjected to such brutality?
They only allow certain members of their ¢.50 army to know and comment about it in comments sections of news media outlets. When an independent creator does a video, short ,online essay etc. on it the subject the ¢.50 army attacks saying it did not happen. Now in CCP China this "never" happened and if you bring it up, let's just say good luck to ya mate.
Here is a list* of the countries bombed and/or invaded by the United States from the end of the Second World War to 2020: Afghanistan 1998, 2001- Bosnia 1994, 1995 Cambodia 1969-70 China 1945-46 Congo 1964 Cuba 1959-1961 El Salvador 1980s Korea 1950-53 Guatemala 1954, 1960, 1967-69 Indonesia 1958 Laos 1964-73 Grenada 1983 Iraq 1991-2000s, 2015- Iran 1987 Korea 1950-53 Kuwait 1991 Lebanon 1983, 1984 Libya 1986, 2011- Nicaragua 1980s Pakistan 2003, 2006- Palestine 2010 Panama 1989 Peru 1965 Somalia 1993, 2007-08, 2010- Sudan 1998 Syria 2014- Vietnam 1961-73 Yemen 2002, 2009- Yugoslavia 1999 Note that these countries represent roughly one-third of the people on earth.
The amount of what-about-ism in the comments form tankies and the 10c army is insane. Like it's impossible for them to see china criticism without lashing out like a child.
I think its funny how they mentioned they would alter his voice to maintain anonymity but then proceeded to just put a translation narrator over his voice ..............................
I came to Hunan, China as a farmer. I am very grateful to these powerful, democratic, free and civilized countries and the righteous people of all countries for speaking out for the Chinese people! As a Chinese, I can't do anything at all. I can only tell my friends and relatives what happened on June 4th. I am very sad to live in such a ruling system! Many Chinese people can't see the truth at all. Chinese people have been brainwashed since childhood. The news information that Chinese people see is all fed by the government! They don't understand the real situation at all. They are powerless in the face of such an environment and there is no way to change it!
@@karinaroyuki7065 it was the students that tripped and fell in front of the moving tanks. They now regret spending a months pay on Nike Shoes, which are American crap products
7:09 on the screen "May Fourth Youth Ssociation" You can tell this is from decades ago, that would have the red jagged line under it highlighting the typo
@kaowang-xs1vb Democracy is a heavy dose of medicine with potent side effects. Only countries that are strong in terms of economy, social stability, and cultural quality can take it, so the best way to keep a developing country weak and unstable is to give it democracy. Deng knew China was not ready for democracy yet, and he knew exactly why certain governments in the west were so eager to force feed democracy to China (just like what they did again a few years ago to Hong Kong), so he made a choice that was most beneficial to the country.
Born & raised in China until 22. Heard of this cruel story from my teacher in high school, who participated in the movement. Part of the reason im outta there now lol
I was 10 when did happened and the image of tank guy always stuck with me, whenever I would se a protest I would always expect to see a tank rolling in. Funny how as a kid I associated tanks with protest not war.
@@josephling8455 42,000 Chinese citizens in Australia at that time were granted political asylum and subsequent Australian Citizenship not long after. My neighbour is one of them and forever thanked the late Bob Hawke for saving his life and more importantly the life of his family
Back in the early 2000’ there were discussions at the CCP’s politburo about disclosing the truth. It’s incredible to see how the political climate has fallen.
The tank tries to get around him several times he claims on top of it, gets down and finally some civilian comes and pulls him away. Before western agents tried to hijack the protests for a shot at a color revolution, Communist students were demanding a return to Maoist principles in these protests, literally demanding more orthodox communism. This man was trying to stop the tanks fr
@@tritium1998 im not saying no democratic country uses force on its own citizens, either. But china is in turmoil and needs free spech to create stability. The wishes of the few projected on the many always creates discontent.
Worse in morale. And things like China facilitating fentanyl precursors over here is truly ruining a portion of the country. Thanks China! We will overcome this, though. Because we ARE a great nation, built upon democracy and equality. Which can be aspirational at times. But we will go from there. ✊
You are saying this because you ate up the bulshit that winnie the Poh was banned or whatever. Google Shanghai Disneyland Winie the Pooh experienc. God, you guys are so god damn gulible.
35 years ago today.
Just realized it's the same day as killdozer
It's terrifying that within one generation, history was able to be erased and the young Chinese can't even fathom this actually happened.
@@ATT503 Wow, missed that entirely!
lol, your reaction makes me laugh. You are brainwashed by western media.
@@ChristineBlack-so7og Actually, you just know what western media told you. Pity for you.
The fact that these young people stood up against the establishment during the 1980s were amazing and outstanding.
They are sort of jokers from Chinese perspective.
To my point of view, they were too young, too simple, sometimes naive.
Incredible patience of the ccp. For 3 months this when on. Meanwhile the US executed 4 students after one week of occupying campuses.
And now we see how they arrest pro Palestinian protestors in the UK, USA, Germany.
学生的初心是好的，当时正值改革开放初期，西方思潮和社会主义思潮激烈碰撞，社会矛盾激化，确实需要改革。但后期，一些社会无业人士和流氓也加入了运动，背后还有美国cia的影子，这群学生逐渐被外部势力裹挟了，提出和诉求越来越激进，企图直接颠覆中国的政权，背离了原来的改革目的。
@@stephinealice 中華民國萬歲
Wow. That student didn't hesitate to say it was was worth his life. And then immediately doubled down. That's courage.
Noticed the yank never harmed him
Now tell us about Kent state
South Korea stood up to their leaders in the 80’s.
Respect to these Chinese protesters.
Tell me … over and over and over again !
Warms my heart to see Americans supporting communist student protestors 🥰
@@Devilishlybenevolent pro democracy
@@SurBlox Yeah and a lot of the students are communist. You know democracy exists in all government systems right?
The west loves to use Chinese protestors but then tries to hide that they're also chanting pro communism slogans or display mao/communist signs 🤣
@@SurBlox It is a joke. You know nothing about this.
The media mostly focused on Beijing, and most of the footages taken are from there. However, large protests also happened in other cities, especially in Shanghai, Guangzhou, Changsha, Wuhan, and Chengdu.
There was no CIA in other cities.
@@Qiushishuolots of communists instead😮 of
@@photosalbum7047 lol, your ignorance surprised me. In that cities, protests were in normal way. No rioter, no weapon robbing, no burning people alive.
@@Qiushishuo Riots were the most violent across all of China in the cities of Changsha and Xi'an on the 22 of April, not in Beijing (Not including fighting response to live munitions used by Chinese soldiers on June 3-4). Stop saying solid lies Commiebot
@Qiushishuo How much does the CCP pay you per comment?
-9000 social credit score
😂😂😂😂😂 they are as independent as Taiwan. Flucc the CCP-PLA, and the 50 cent army.
is that where above 9000 comes from?!
@@preshisify Dragon Ball Z. Vegeta says it when he and Nappa scan Goku.
victim of cia propaganda
@@levelazn Chinese shill working extra hard today 🤣🤣
The tank man survives, even climbing atop the tank 😂
@@AlphaCookies his life ended 24 hours later
I had a business and technology trip planned to China at the time to install equipment used for circuit board design and manufacturing; passport ready to go but the Tiananmen massacre changed my mind. Since then I have no interest in ever visiting China.
You should. The food is just awesome!
Roast duck $3.5 ❤
Hand pulled noodle beef soup $1.50
Very safe and clean too.
@@StrongOakTree China is clean as long as you don’t breathe Oxygen.
Don’t go. I am Hong Kong American and I will never step foot in that country and support a ruthless dictator
Might as well go Malaysia vietnam or Bangladesh for the same logic. @@StrongOakTree
@@helloworld9996 Yes you can but it will never be China. 😊
Kind of like there is only one God. ♥️
at the end NOTHING changed infact gotten worse
Gotten worse? In what way? Have you seen what PRC looks like nowadays? They lifted 800 milion people out of poverty and completely eliminated abject poverty. Nearly 80 percent of Chinese millennials are homeowners, what is that in the US?
Yes, a memorial day should also be established for the self-immolations in the United States.
美国的华尔街事件，坦克碾压老兵，应该也这样每年纪念一下。
Their cities look much better now, lots of people, nice huge buildings and pretty lights, lots of people.
@@Allfaxnocapsthats great but do their citizens have human rights tho
One of the students during the protests held a sign saying "Absolute power corrupts absolutely'. That sign describes China even more so today than in 1989.
What about America?
@@adriancarty612 you're not wrong, but chinese government is the one in question here and also the mistakes another doesn't makes china's issues any less worse.
@@platinumdm7099 You double standard doesn't surprise me.
Just because it is more harder for foreigner control.
@@adriancarty612 It's funny that you guys live in a free world but longing totalitarianism life
a reminder that the chinese people once fought for democracy but their own people failed them
And look how the country is doing now
@@fongponto not well.
Free market? Yes. Sort of.
Free people? No.
@@fongponto educate yourself and youll find the answer. just because they are the 2nd most powerful economy right now doesnt mean that their people are happy most chinese youth are suffering right now
你们那套民主本来就是垃圾 我们不要😅
I wonder what playing this video in China does to your credit score
It doesn’t exist in China. If someone got caught with this they would definitely be imprisoned and probably become a forced organ donor
Dude will likely be cancelled
@@leonlee9223more likely if you distributed this you would be disappeared. They don't like to talk about this. A lot of young Chinese people don't even know about it.
Dude will likely be what we Chinese say "was invited to drink tea" at the police station.
now its called '大记忆恢复术' in cn😂@@xiphoid2011
This is an amazing report from the perspective of today, 2024!!
Sad that these students lost their lives. They wanted to have a better life by reforming China into a democracy. But instead, are killed by the orders of old men with old thinking.
Also, sad that at the moment both China and Russia are run by two individuals who are wanting to return back to a time when it was rough for the people instead of making their lives better.
June 4th 35 years ago is a day that all Chinese people will never forget.
Not me. Don’t try to speak for us.
99.99% who re born after 1989 havent even heard of it.
@@evelynn_teoh Which poll? Don't lie, OK?
@@CerroZimm Important enough you seem to care Wu Mao. If it's so insignificant, then why do you bother to comment?
@@CrimeBoss777 Hey, come on. Just let him be, every man longs for freedom.
Sic semper tyrannis, friend.
Thank you for the repost. Keep this alive.
And 0 proof . Unlike Iraq
@@zacksmith5963 still couldn’t provide any proof that Tiananmen Square was a peaceful place on 1989-06-04? I’ve been waiting for months
@yslee1401 still waiting for proof of tianamem. U are really bad at this 😆
@ where is your video link? I’ve been asking for the past 3 months
CNN, CNBC, 60 mins, AP, Reuters, BBC, MSNBC have all provided video links.
I have not seen your video link that shows Tiananmen Square being peaceful on 1989-06-04
@yslee1401 I never made a claim. U did . Checked all of them . Not 1 showed any massacre
Try again
Excellent beautiful Explanation good service to Humanity thanks for sharing 🙏
Let’s not forget
This blank screen for 12 minutes with white noise really helps me study.
I really wonder why do you have to study while watching this?
Never Forget
Weird. I've been staring at a black screen for 12 minutes.
It works today, June 8, 2024….
Are you behind the great firewall?
Did you graduate from kent state university
that's a youtube mobile app bug. just close and reopen the app.
I've had that a couple of times before. same as the pause button not showing up when I tap on the video.
@@geoffhoutman1557I’m behind the great firewall and I see it clearly.
Wow thanks for sharing ☺️🙏🏿
People’s army surrounded by people. Growing up I heard this slogan many times, now I know what it really meant
Surprised China isn’t suing over this
Devastating to see what China has become today after these heroic individuals attempted to defend their rights.
We Chinese don't think so.
@@Qiushishuo good boy 50+ social credits
@@rufuslh It shows you know nothing about China. Just brainwashed by wester media. Keep going.
@@Qiushishuo🤓
@@rufuslh Good boy. 2+ fentanyl
As Chinese people, we warmly celebrate the 35th anniversary of the defeat of the Western color revolution.
Not many countries succeeded
Thanks little pink piggy
@@yushengdeng4741小青蛙很失望😂😂
@@yushengdeng4741 你们永远是食物链底层 🤣
@@jkc3738 thank you high level CCP members. China was,is yours but not will be forever.
As a Chinese I will never forget, that was a riot. It was worse than Jan 6 in USA and 2019 riot in HongKong.
Now, this is a wonderful documentary for the 50 cent army to watch.
Brainwashed again and again by western media? Oh, no.
@@user-drhnkwyrn Yeah I've seen that on the train and bus. They want to be carried on in their poverty expecting the government to do everything for them... that's the 50 cent army.
They still deny everything? It's bizarre
@@Michael9-23-15 lol, deny your propaganda is deny everything? BS.
@@Qiushishuo Eric, why don't you say anything to the other person on this thread? You're picking on me? I thought we were gonna be friends? 😞
China's media was actually allowed to cover Tiananmen in 1989. Now their media wouldn't dare, so China's media is actually more censored today.
Is that a joke? The documentary from China is not shown in western media. Western media repeats one side story again and again.
just like tiktok 😅
@@DanH-u3f yeah, 100% censorship rules apples
@@DanH-u3f so where are the video clips from Chinese media showing that on 1989-06-04, Tiananmen Square was a nice summer days with children playing and chocolate milk spilling? All I see are Chinese blood🩸 spilling on 🇨🇳 soil
the bots are going wild on this one
🥱 cia bot spotted
Usa bill hr1157 cia employs bots to spread anti china propaganda
Every Chinese should watch this video
I watched and I agree with Deng Xiao Ping
我看了，但是我支持邓小平的处理方式，中国需要稳定，幸运的是中国抵抗住了美西方国家的颜色革命。要是这场颜色革命成功，就不可能有现在这般强大的中国了。
I watched. Chinese is lucky to stop these color revolution.
The none Chinese should watch the other side of the story, no? It is only fair.
我看了 又如何？
Now show Rachel Corrie...radio silence
Free Palestine, hypocrites.
Then please comment to a related video.
@@veralicious. This is why it's related, this channel never talk about Palestine genocide
@@einroboter1301 they did talk about Palestine, whether it's or not related to genocide, I am not so sure because I ain't interested.
@@veralicious. Yes, you cares more about China history which lack of evidence than 14 thousands civilians death in Palestine.
When American journalism had at least a semblance of integrity and gravitas.
When Chinese media can't even criticize ccp, not even one sentence even if it is a fact.
A good example of time travel alterations. Many people remember the Tank Man being ran over. Others only remember the tank stopping.
Transcripts were found in a trash in Beijing !🤣 no whereabouts ,no reports
The tank tries to get around him several times he claims on top of it, gets down and finally some civilian comes and pulls him away. Before western agents tried to hijack the protests for a shot at a color revolution, Communist students were demanding a return to Maoist principles in these protests, literally demanding more orthodox communism. This man was trying to stop the tanks from leaving the square and returning to barracks.
Tank man climbed on top of the tank, then climbed back down, then try to stop the tank again. A moment later, few pedestrians walked toward him pulled him out of that situation. You probably wouldnt know if MSM wouldnt show you the complete story.
坦克压人的视频和照片在哪里？军人被杀和烧死的视频你又知道？
China deploy army late into the uprising in 1989, no army at all in the 2019 Hong Kong one. France did straight away in New Caledonia in 2024, and reinforce far from Europe, Australia & New Zealand pledge troop too, all target the very first islanders. The media did not report number of soldier vs protest die in 1989, civilian vs protest die in 2019 Hong Kong. The media did report the number of police & islander die in the New Caledonia event.
I miss the pre-9/11 era. Seeing the date on this segment, we had no clue about the chaos that awaited us.
Tiananmen Square took place roughly a week and a half before my parents got married.
亲眼所见，89、64当天，中央电视台新闻
播报的主持人是薛飞与杜宪，二人还流着泪！此事难忘。当晚12点，我与妻怀抱不满周岁儿子去重庆大礼堂市府大门口，声援在市府门前静坐示威的“重庆建工学院”的学生们……
虽做不了什么，但此生难忘
不为别的，只为宽阔的草原……
0:51 young man
+1000 points respect
-1000 points social credit
This should have been on every channel across the globe on the anniversary.
Brainwashed again and again by western media? Oh, no.
The student want to get rid of deng
Deng want to bring China into the Modern world
The people in the countryside support the government
Only some people in the capital support The student
This was the most important program in history of CBS 60 minutes. Thank you for your report! ❤❤❤
😂😂😂 ok prove it
To be honest, most of us, then the street protesters in the Square, now feel really fortunate that China didn't swallow your color revolution pill (as years later on repeated in Ukraine and the Arab Spring), and thus didn't go down the drain like another Soviet Union. That was a true inflexion point in the world's modern history.
This is the most based comment here
@@ThriftyCHNRthis person was not in the square lmao 😂
@@1001yngwie you mean not funded by the CIA?
Did you use a translator app to type that, the wording hints that you did
@@Allfaxnocaps As a matter of fact, I did not. Pls point out where are those wording "hints".
I wonder what all those protesters back in 89' think about china current state in 2024. Im sure many of them are still alive.
미국 LA 폭동 때 당신들은 어떤 방식으로 처리했나? 폭도들은 한국인 지역으로 몰아 넣어 약소국 이민자들에게 화풀이를 하도록 유도했다. 그리고 탱크맨 영상은 왜 편집해서 보여주는 거야.
Students seeking freedom and justice should always be respected. No matter it happens in which country or in which university.
Except, the students were demanding a return to Maoist principles, more orthodox communism instead of the reforms of Deng Xiaoping
And it is sad that in almost every country where college students have risen up in peaceful many always end up dead, again governments sending the military or police against student protestors all over the world many times have resulted with students deaths. Responded before you get flooded with the "whataboutism" people like to play
Mike Wallace is in the room... lol! I miss that reporter... I miss that whole generation of reporters. It was back when there were reporters and when 'The News" was a brag piece that was expected to lose money, but was still worth doing.
向在1989反革命暴乱中牺牲的15名人民解放军战士致敬!
🎉
I wonder where the whistleblowers are now ? I hope they are safe.
Did anyone catch at around 4 min mark that he said the reporter recorded video on his "cell phone" in 1991??
Yeah. I was thinking, were blackberries out? But since the report was done in 2001, (and cell phones were still quite new actually), maybe Mike Wallace had a minor brain collapse, and was actually referring to some other technological device I'm not familiar with? Morse code? Telegram?
we all know,there are more than 3000 fake accounts doing fake propaganda for the government,in Chinese,they are called wumao and paid by the government.
For clarity...He said he "Reported from the square on his cell phone" not Recorded from the square.
Cell phones were new to the world, however 5 million were sold in the u.s. throughout 1991, some of which were essential in journalism.
he didn't say that
cover shows: in china
, a man can stop tanks and no problem.
The government did the right thing in 1989. Ask yourself this: if the anti-government protests were not put down, would the average Chinese's living standards be better or worse today? Political stability is the foundation of China's miraculous economic development.
Another 50¢ propagandist.
@@uriituw Feel free to point out where I'm wrong
@@dengist8172 You advocate for a totalitarian dictatorship. The CCP.
I think that’s all that needs to be said.
CCP did not allow Chinese people to speak for themselves or joint the political decisions, that is what’s wrong about CCP government. Wumao.
@@uriituwPoor little guy, you have been brainwashed! CCP serves the people, not as what you say "totalitarian dictatorship"!
I was about the age of those students. When I saw the footage back then i was furious like many of the Hong Kong people. I went to June 4 memorial gathering year after year as much as I could to show my support to the poor students. Then suddenly I saw the event repeat itself, only in Hong Kong in 2019. The difference is that I saw the truth with my real eyes but heard deeply biased reports from those same media. I started to doubt what I was shown before. I soon found out that signature scene where the guy stood in front of the tank to make you think he would be crushed next turned out he was pulled aside, and the Chinese army, who were also as young as those students, many of them were beaten, tortured, burnt and thrown from overpass.
If that so called democracy movement had its way back then and the government was overthrown, China would not be as prosperous and strong as it is today.
@@virginia_wong so sad CCP ruined Hong Kong after 20 years. 50 年不變 promise was a blatant lie
When Americans care about a country and continue to focus on topics, it is definitely unfortunate for that country. Fortunately, the Chinese people are wise and powerful enough not to become a vassal state of the United States. China is not the European Union or Japan, and we will not let the United States control exploitation casually.
From the free African-Americans, keep your head up and keep on pushing. Change is going to come 💯
What happened in Hong Kong means everything.
Yes, rioters are gone.
*Ah yes another tactical error that will come to bite us all back globally*
35 years later, same thing is happening in the US campus😅
Lol, not even close
35 years before, these students risked their lives to require democracy for their people, when CCP had bad record like cultural revolution. Comparing US campus now to 1989 Tiananmen?
They risked their lives, but who was killed? The US police captured these students who were demanding justice, so is there no difference between the US and Chinese governments? The Chinese government admitted their fault regarding the Cultural Revolution and included it in history textbooks. Now, let's talk about the massacre of Native Americans in the US. How do their descendants feel knowing their ancestors were subjected to such brutality?
@@musicwithimagine American students are even more pitiful, just simply supporting Palestine will be suppressed!
Spot on.
But, wait a minute, China swears this didn’t happen.
They only allow certain members of their ¢.50 army to know and comment about it in comments sections of news media outlets. When an independent creator does a video, short ,online essay etc. on it the subject the ¢.50 army attacks saying it did not happen. Now in CCP China this "never" happened and if you bring it up, let's just say good luck to ya mate.
And u have proof it did?
Hey Mike… I heard that the guy who walked up to the column of tanks most likely “did not” survive.
You heard from whom? You always have no solid proof.
He was pulled away by his friends. This part was deliberately deleted by western media.
Another fake tally for your written history and crocodile tears of course.
There was hope but it was destroyed by the selfishness of a small group of people
I wonder if Winnie Xitler is watching this....
"Of course he is...............with the help of our sponsor... Nord VPN"
@@mosando 😅😅
Here is a list* of the countries bombed and/or invaded by the United States from the end of the Second World War to 2020:
Afghanistan 1998, 2001-
Bosnia 1994, 1995
Cambodia 1969-70
China 1945-46
Congo 1964
Cuba 1959-1961
El Salvador 1980s
Korea 1950-53
Guatemala 1954, 1960, 1967-69
Indonesia 1958 Laos 1964-73
Grenada 1983
Iraq 1991-2000s, 2015-
Iran 1987
Korea 1950-53
Kuwait 1991
Lebanon 1983, 1984
Libya 1986, 2011-
Nicaragua 1980s
Pakistan 2003, 2006- Palestine 2010
Panama 1989
Peru 1965
Somalia 1993, 2007-08, 2010-
Sudan 1998
Syria 2014-
Vietnam 1961-73
Yemen 2002, 2009-
Yugoslavia 1999
Note that these countries represent roughly one-third of the people on earth.
Relevancy to Tianamen Square?
@@keiththomas1180 None, They're a Tankie
Now name the country china falsely claims as theirs and i ain't talking bout taiwan
The list of countries russia attacked is longer but would be equally irrelevant to the video at hand
The amount of what-about-ism in the comments form tankies and the 10c army is insane.
Like it's impossible for them to see china criticism without lashing out like a child.
I bet more people in the west remember this better than China. It was a huge propaganda win for the US.
We have our own Red Guards in the U.S. now.
Instead of the red flag and pix of Chairman Mao, our Red Guards fly rainbow flags and pix of 🤡⚧
I think its funny how they mentioned they would alter his voice to maintain anonymity
but then proceeded to just put a translation narrator over his voice ..............................
I have never seen an american who dare to try to stop a tank.
because no tanks used in America,so no man stop a tank 😅
I came to Hunan, China as a farmer. I am very grateful to these powerful, democratic, free and civilized countries and the righteous people of all countries for speaking out for the Chinese people! As a Chinese, I can't do anything at all. I can only tell my friends and relatives what happened on June 4th. I am very sad to live in such a ruling system! Many Chinese people can't see the truth at all. Chinese people have been brainwashed since childhood. The news information that Chinese people see is all fed by the government! They don't understand the real situation at all. They are powerless in the face of such an environment and there is no way to change it!
这下不得不撅醒了🤣
如果真的想了解，就看所有和这个有关的视频的资讯，而不是看一家之言。这个坦克人的视频，一直有完整版，完整版，这个小伙子一直当在坦克前面，坦克一直在避让，这个年轻人甚至爬上了坦克，最后被其他人拉开离开了广场，但很多西方反华媒体有意只剪辑前半部分在坦克面前的画面，意图营造一种被碾压的迹象。
@@stephinealice 人和坦克车队，西方媒体强调的是人的勇气，却完全不提坦克的克制。如果当年真的发生了大屠杀，为什么完全没有军人向民众开枪的视频？不是军人拿着枪，不是民众在奔跑，而是军人开枪的视频。为什么西方媒体连几秒钟的这样的视频也拿不出来？
@@Baiyoubai 这场运动持续了长达几个月，早期游行还是相对和平的，诉求也主要是希望改革，改革开放初期，中西方思维碰撞很厉害，当时社会矛盾激化，确实需要改革。但学生运动到后面，社会上的闲散人士和无业游民甚至社会流氓也加入了进来浑水摸鱼。运动的形式越来越暴力，诉求越来越极端，背离原来的改革初心，其目的不再是改革，而是想要颠覆中国的政权。暴力打杂抢，焚毁交通工具，破坏公共设施，有不少人甚至有燃烧弹等管制武器，把执法人员打死，吊死，烧死军人，这个学生运动就已经变味了。特别是学生运动带头人还与美国cia人员接头，这个就变成一场赤裸裸的颜色革命了。
后来去那里了，扔进精神病还是被人抓起来做牢了呢！
Why did the CCP block Tiananmen Square nowadays? It's as if the protester students never left. They are just there.
天安门永远在那里，如果你想去看，可以随时去。。记得预约哦
Have the bulletholes been filled in in the meantime?
@@jennysue601
Nah. CCP is busy building tofu skyscrappers. ;3
You're literally crying because you don't own the square or the rest of the country.
@@karinaroyuki7065 it was the students that tripped and fell in front of the moving tanks. They now regret spending a months pay on Nike Shoes, which are American crap products
7:09 on the screen "May Fourth Youth Ssociation" You can tell this is from decades ago, that would have the red jagged line under it highlighting the typo
It’s a shame that Chinese people nowadays have forgotten what happened in 1989.
Only the government but not the people.
笑死，美国发起的颜色革命成功的国家，基本上都陷入停滞、分裂、内战，在国家治理方面基本都是失败。阿拉伯之春让多个阿拉伯国家陷入动荡不安，冲突不断，造成的损失最起码得是好几万亿美元，死亡几十万人，千万级别的难民。十多年前的阿拉伯之春造成的冲突依旧在持续，颜色革命的可怕后果是当地人在承受，美国的占领国会山被定义为叛国，为啥在别国发声同样的事在美国看来却是美丽的风景线？美国的大学生支持巴勒斯坦被经常打，被学校取消毕业证，还搞了违法美国宪法的反犹太意识法案。
China is lucky to stop this color revolution.
@kaowang-xs1vb Democracy is a heavy dose of medicine with potent side effects. Only countries that are strong in terms of economy, social stability, and cultural quality can take it, so the best way to keep a developing country weak and unstable is to give it democracy. Deng knew China was not ready for democracy yet, and he knew exactly why certain governments in the west were so eager to force feed democracy to China (just like what they did again a few years ago to Hong Kong), so he made a choice that was most beneficial to the country.
I never forgot the Jan 6.
Why don't you report on the American student movement?
Whataboutism.
They do, unlike China.
Spot on.
Mixing up Apple's and Oranges my comrade
We need this kind of change again.
Another color revolution from US? Hell no.
Irritated wumao incoming
Irritated CIA bot incoming
Heyyy it's pajeed . 😂😂😂
Always impressing America!
No, America is impressing China when they really did that before.
Born & raised in China until 22. Heard of this cruel story from my teacher in high school, who participated in the movement. Part of the reason im outta there now lol
I'm happy you're safe now. And happy that someone told you what happened.
I was 10 when did happened and the image of tank guy always stuck with me, whenever I would se a protest I would always expect to see a tank rolling in. Funny how as a kid I associated tanks with protest not war.
@@josephling8455 42,000 Chinese citizens in Australia at that time were granted political asylum and subsequent Australian Citizenship not long after. My neighbour is one of them and forever thanked the late Bob Hawke for saving his life and more importantly the life of his family
@@yslee1401 Same here in the US. Many ppl were granted asylum after that so that type of green card was called “type blood” in the Chinese community.
So sad 😢
Why rerun it now? Why not tell us the real truth? Why not tell nus about CIA's actual involvement?
This is CIA propaganda that’s why.
Where is Chinese rerun of this massacre now?
@@maggie198333 Would you show something that you will have to explain through your teeth?
he (the youngman in front of the tanks) could not fit his BIG pair even in the plastic bags.
The sound of him walking could be heard from miles away on a quiet night
Every CCP official just went blind.
they can't see those drone struck middle eastern children
Selective activism from the gun barrel of democracy
@@zachcouch8654 Li Ke Qiang made noise and he was executed
挡在坦克前的人，他一定咆哮的是，那都是孩子，和你们一样年轻的兄弟姐妹，他们只希望中国更好，这是中国人的中国，这是所有爱国人的希望
35 years since Tiananmen
Disgusting govt.
Winnie the Pooh and his voters dislikes this video
Back in the early 2000’ there were discussions at the CCP’s politburo about disclosing the truth. It’s incredible to see how the political climate has fallen.
Why did CBS not show the whole clip of the tank man?
Didn't fit the narrative?
Nope still does
If you listen the narrator said he stood up to them and survived the encounter.
@@andrewweaver2517 yes, but how. This is interesting
Chyna Han you spread corona
The tank tries to get around him several times he claims on top of it, gets down and finally some civilian comes and pulls him away. Before western agents tried to hijack the protests for a shot at a color revolution, Communist students were demanding a return to Maoist principles in these protests, literally demanding more orthodox communism. This man was trying to stop the tanks fr
Respect to the protesters, they have helped to make the current gov to be more competent and more advanced caring to its people
Oh really? I don't respect them, since their desire had no limit at the later phase.
funny if this vid gets played at every ads screen in china
Brainwashed again and again by western media? Oh, no.
we now know who won
-9999 social credit score
+9999 fentanyl
Back in the day when they still had to debate on weather or not to use force.
And it was seen as weakness by defectors and foreigners. Even their ongoing peace with no war is seen as such.
@@tritium1998 im not saying no democratic country uses force on its own citizens, either. But china is in turmoil and needs free spech to create stability. The wishes of the few projected on the many always creates discontent.
This is old news. China is changing to the better while american lives today compare to 1960 ???
Worse in morale. And things like China facilitating fentanyl precursors over here is truly ruining a portion of the country. Thanks China!
We will overcome this, though. Because we ARE a great nation, built upon democracy and equality. Which can be aspirational at times. But we will go from there.
✊
Never had a scene shown someone was killed, can anyone give the explanations
because it is lie
Today I got 175 on social studies as Chinese.
oh no, the POOH's GONNA GET YA!
You are saying this because you ate up the bulshit that winnie the Poh was banned or whatever. Google Shanghai Disneyland Winie the Pooh experienc. God, you guys are so god damn gulible.
@@LetsLynchTheLandlords Man, the little pinks are in full force today, huh?
@@novaboy1174 Don't worry, we Pink can't win, because this is the home of your fentanyl army
@@novaboy1174 Winnie the Poop?
😂Americans, you don 't care about Palestine now, but you care about the failed color revolutions in the past, it's very funny!
Save your own country poor men !
Using a VPN this trash human
This is Us Priopaganda.
xi jinping makes it way more worse than before. way more worse
习近平让中国越来越强大 对你们来说确实更糟
It's fortunate for China that mess did not come to China.