I love how you talked about the confusion with the "Rebirth" name. When the Rebirth started in the US I said to my French retailer (I was still reading in French at the time) "I hope they're going to traduce Green Lantern Rebirth at some point" and he said he had it for years already. Even him was confused! Another fun fact: the DC New 52 were branded "DC Renaissance" in France, which means "DC Rebirth"... So when the Rebirth line came out they had to keep it in English to avoid confusion between the two lines and ended up creating even more hahaha Having two different things having the same English name was really confusing for most non-english speaking people here. Even more when you now that they were publishing the Geoff Johns run AND the Rebirth at the same time....
J’imagine la tête des mecs chez Urban quand ils ont vu que la nouvelle ligne éditoriale s’appelait Rebirth 😂 pour le coup il aurait mieux fallu ne pas traduire New52 en Renaissance quand on y repense 😅
@@La-Comics-Cave Encore une décision débile de leur part. Perso j'ai arrêté la VF quand Rebirth a commencé et qu'ils publiaient certains titres en hardcovers avant de les sortir en kiosque.... Et encore je crois qu'il n'y avait plus que 3 titres kiosque? Et peu de temps après si j'ai bien compris le kiosque n'existait plus et c'était du librairie softcover autant chez Urban que chez Panini mais j'avais déjà vendu les 500 bouquins lol
Seeing all these together is so cool. Thanks for making videos like this! A lot of us really appreciate seeing things from the past revisited. Would love to see some omnis for this.
I mostly liked it too. Some of the “Bat?” “Yes, Cat?” conversations were a bit much but overall I thought it was decent. I have the whole run in single issues so I’m waiting for an Omnibus run to double dip.
Appreciate The Retroview Omar,also The Batman Deluxe Editions volumes 1-5 hardcover.also good:the artwork was excellent also I really enjoy the Retroview featuring all 5 Batman Deluxe Edition volumes and Omar thanks for sharing 👌 up the 👍 work stay healthy stay safe much love and have a Happy Thursday.😀😃😊😄😎💪👊
Hey Omar, these Deluxe Editions are nice. I wish I'd known about that format before I started buying the standard thin trades. I have the whole run and I'm content with it. I know I started to read it but maybe got as far as volume 2 as well as the 'Monster Men' trade. An omnibus would likely require 3 volumes perhaps? The use of matte paper began with Batman trade volume 8 which was the first black spine. Annoying. It's a run that I need to make time for, like everything else. Cheers mate.
Thanks for the retroview Omar! I can't wait for the omnis on this run. I think they can do it in three. You have his 85 issue run, plus annuals, specials, one-shots, the Batman/Catwoman series, and I think he's doing another Batman series for Black Label. Don't know if they'll hold out to collect the Black Label series but that is a lot of pages. I got through the Deluxe Edition volume four. I was really mad about the change in paper quality and since they weren't announcing volume five for a long time I just sold them. I want it all in the omnibus treatment too. I want the full crossover stories as well. I think they'll do it as in the Tynion Detective Omni they had all the issues for the Night Of The Monster Men crossover. Take care and peace.
For an Omnibus mapping, you'd need three or four. "Batman" #1-85, Annuals #1-2, and #4, Batman: Secret Files #1, Batman/Catwoman #1-12 and Special; Batman: Killing Time #1-6 (just announced!), Batman/Elmer Fudd, and a CRAP-TON of side stories from a bunch of places like Detective Comics #1000, #1027; Catwoman 80th Special, Robin 80th Special...it'd most likely be a 4 volume set.
Cant believe we're finally getting Vol 6 this year. A gaping hole in my shelf that, frankly, stopped me collecting Batman collected Editions (didn't see the point in moving onto Joker war etc, would be like watching season 2 of a show without watching the season 1 finale)
I just got the first 2 volumes in recently, but book 3,4 and 5 are out of print now, with 6 coming out in a week. I'm so bummed. This is my favorite run on Batman and I wish they were still printing the rest of the books
The books are actually sewn binding, but its like all DC books and omnis, It´s has a big layer of glue. PD: so glad to hear there will be a book 6, being waiting for that like a mad man
I am not as down on the Tom King era as some are. What I AM irate about is that I somehow missed Deluxe Volume 5, which is now challenging to find at a decent price.
I don't know why DC not giving King some fun characters to write about. I think he is very good at comedy. His super friends and the gift stories are hilarious as well as issue in the deluxe 5 that was drawn by Amanda Conner.
Hey Omar great video except issues 64&65 of Batman are in volume 5 of the deluxe editions. DC didn’t collect chapters 2&4 which are the Flash parts of the crossover.
OMG im trying to get that batman Rebirth deluxe edition HC they don't have anymore in the store or online it been sold out for long time and it was hard to find it and i dont order on ebay and i will keep looking again online or the store too im trying to do the best and i hop i can find some help. thank you for your help when i get the spider--man miles omnibus
Some REALLY good stuff in the King issues. I wasn't blown away by everything, but what was good was SOOOOOO good. Annual 2 was one of my single favorite Batman issues of all time. Seems like any time he teams with Lee Weeks is printed gold, though. When these hit omnibus format, I may have to buy them.
I started the run in single issues but then stopped cold turkey with single issues around #10, so I'm waiting a few more years for that omni I guess :P
Okay I’m late to the game. Playing catch up…..I can’t get these at all. No where. Unless you have a place that sells all (6) editions. I can buy 1,2,5 (5 is a maybe) and 6. 3-4 I can’t get anywhere. Will there be reprinting? An omnibus?
I could be wrong but I think Jason's last name is pronounced "Fay-bock". Concerning the run I only hear positive or negative things, really a 50/50 split. When it comes out in 2 omni's then I'll pick it up. Thanks for the video.
At first I thought Tom King’s Batman run was just meh but I kept going because I always read Batman’s main book. Looking back at the run as a whole now though I’ve really grown to appreciate it and the long story that Tom King was trying to tell. Tom King might honestly be my favorite writer working right now
Started collecting these a while back, but when I saw they started fucking with the spines and discontinuing lines I dropped off and decided to wait for the inevitable Omnibus. Easy to reprint the same oversized pages in bigger books when half the work is already done!
I stopped collecting Batman TPBs in the middle of New 52 and I want to be more selective so I'm wondering if I need to get everything in DC You and Rebirth or if some can be skipped.
King's run on Batman is my personal favorite. I hope DC releases it as an omnibus somewhat soon considering this deluxe line ended before the run was finished.
While King’s run was not my favorite, I felt like it achieved higher peaks than Snyder’s run did in many ways, even if the lows were also lower. The decompressed, padded nature of the run made it feel a bit bloated, and it was painful reading this monthly. All that said, I appreciated King trying some new ideas with the character, even if I have some objections to some of the twists and characterizations contained therein. Also, if they did do omnis, I hope they include Batman and Elmer Fudd, a surprisingly great crossover.
I agree. I love the way this run flipped the script on Bruce and his trauma, emphatically stating that it is love and reaching out to others that heals you.
While I wasn’t a fan of Knightfall because it felt like a money grab just to increase sales, it did give us a villain that was as smart as Batman. It also grounded Batman showing all the damage that he was taking mentally and physically over the years fighting crime. I mean bats had been beaten, stabbed, and shot over the years. That has to take a toll on someone. The human body and mind can only endure so much.
It’s ridiculous how hard to find these are. I payed 60€ for book 3 and 80€ for book 5, been looking for a whole year. Book 4 nowhere to be found, only found one on ebay for 122$…I just don’t understand why they would print so few of them when Batman it’s a character famous all around the world
Although I don’t love the run, this reads so much better in collected format vs trying to read it in singles. Excited for book 6 to happen and hopefully people can enjoy it. :) Another great vid, my friend!
Hello Omar, I have a doubt , when are Dark Knights Metal and Death Metal taking place with the Rebirth Batman Issues? As I understand, Batman #52 ended giving birth to Dark Knights Metal… right? But then after Metal is the Batman Rebirth Era of King and then after that Death Metal and then Future State?
Year One (Frank Miller) Long Halloween, Dark Victory, Catwoman When in Rome, Killing Joke, A death in the family, Hush. That would get you started on all the highlights.
I have all these plus the King /Weeks book (which is matt paper) plus Night of the monster men, and the Button, and even 'The Wedding Album' If the do reprint volumes 4+5 I hope they do it on Glossy paper and with the white spines (although they probably won't) I didn't know about the heroes' in crisis books, But have literally just bought them on Amazon, so thanks for the info Omar, and if they do print Omni's with all this in then please could they include the crossovers, or I shan't bother to double dip, I get so p'd off when they are more concerned with whether a particular writer wrote it all, I buy 'em for Batman, not who writes it. Same kinda thing happened with the Grant Morrison Omni's, half way through a story there would be issues missing 'cos Morrison didn't write them(eyeroll)
Really regret not picking up Book 5 early on just for completing my collection. Going on Amazon they're asking for more than the listed price and the annoying part is Book 5 contains the Knightmare's storyline which is arguable the worst part of King's run. Overall though King's time on Batman will definitely not be forgotten and even some of his storylines such as Cold Days will be considered some of the greatest Batman stories ever.
I personally prefer deluxe editions to omnis because they are more comfortable to read and tend to have matching spines (except green arrow, yeah DC, just make the spine blue.. wtf) but since collecting DC has become a pain in the ass and they just discontinued the whole line, I sold most of my Rebirth Deluxe Editions except Detective Comics and Actions Comics, because they at least finished a whole run. So now I have a couple of rebirth deluxe which at least have great looking spines, right next to my rebirth trades, who just look horrible.. 3 different spines during the Tom King Batman run.. 🤦🏻♂️
I absolutely loved this run. Not only was it, in my opinion, an intricate deep dive into Batman's psyche, but it was also just a good time. I blazed through Deluxes Vol. 1 and 2 and sold my set in anticipation of an Omnibus. The "I Am Gotham/I Am Suicide/I Am Bane" trilogy was solid and "War of Jokes and Riddles" was great ("Night of the Monster Men" was alright). "Rooftop" is one of my favorite Batman stories of all time. It's where "Rules of Engagement" and "The Gift" came out that I started to think, "Okay..." And of course..."The Wedding" was an unnecessary misdirect.. That said, I thoroughly enjoyed everything I've read from it. King is so creative with how he tells the story, the art is gorgeous, and the way the story builds to a, admittedly, okay conclusion was great. I will definitely purchase this run in an Omnibus!!
I enjoyed volumes 1-3 even though the great tragedy that Batman feels guilty for is creating Kiteman. Batman could easily blame himself which would have been great. Then he ruined Booster Gold as if he never read any recent run of the character. Then comes the wedding. Tom King has to Tom King. He is the antonym to Geoff Johns when it comes to DC lore. A writer makes a deal with the reader. Tom King thinks breaking the deal over and over is a good thing which was why it fell flat.
It was a good run for real. I loved it. How Batman was not only "Ehi dude. I'm Batman. I can do anything, also beat the c**p out of anyone because..I'm Batman". Here, "'I'm Batman" is not a meme at least. It's something more personal. It shows how a character in comics can change. Reading this after the Snyder's lame run was very refreshing.
While I personally think Snyder's run is great (just re-read it last week), I think King's is definitely better. King added a human element to Batman. He wasn't the guy who always won or had a plan for everything. There are some bumps in the run, but King's will always be special to me
Good: Art is great throughout and in the first issue Batman is absolute bad ass riding airplane. Bad: If you thought Batbunny was terrible ending to Snyder's New 52 run, King says hold my beer and gives us Nightmares and City of Bane. Batman was just so uncharacteristic and he was made to look so weak against Bane in the final battle. Worst thing I have ever read. Tom King simply doesn't get Batman at all.
This was the worst run of Batman I've ever read. If you want a soy-boy, mommy-wife having, overly emotional, ineffective and whipped Batman, enjoy. Those who want good comics stay away.
I love how you talked about the confusion with the "Rebirth" name. When the Rebirth started in the US I said to my French retailer (I was still reading in French at the time) "I hope they're going to traduce Green Lantern Rebirth at some point" and he said he had it for years already. Even him was confused! Another fun fact: the DC New 52 were branded "DC Renaissance" in France, which means "DC Rebirth"... So when the Rebirth line came out they had to keep it in English to avoid confusion between the two lines and ended up creating even more hahaha Having two different things having the same English name was really confusing for most non-english speaking people here. Even more when you now that they were publishing the Geoff Johns run AND the Rebirth at the same time....
J’imagine la tête des mecs chez Urban quand ils ont vu que la nouvelle ligne éditoriale s’appelait Rebirth 😂 pour le coup il aurait mieux fallu ne pas traduire New52 en Renaissance quand on y repense 😅
@@La-Comics-Cave Encore une décision débile de leur part. Perso j'ai arrêté la VF quand Rebirth a commencé et qu'ils publiaient certains titres en hardcovers avant de les sortir en kiosque.... Et encore je crois qu'il n'y avait plus que 3 titres kiosque? Et peu de temps après si j'ai bien compris le kiosque n'existait plus et c'était du librairie softcover autant chez Urban que chez Panini mais j'avais déjà vendu les 500 bouquins lol
Appreciate the retroview, Omar. There's either so much hype or negativity surrounding King's Batman run that it's nice to have a balanced perspective.
Seeing all these together is so cool. Thanks for making videos like this! A lot of us really appreciate seeing things from the past revisited. Would love to see some omnis for this.
We need a retroview of all the Batman ABSOLUTE editions
I have been waiting for the next vol for what feels like forever.
Love this series so much. Can’t wait for the omnibuses. I hope they’ll include the Batman/Catwoman 12 issue follow up.
I just heard book 6 is coming out this year so excited. I might be the one guy that liked this Tom King run
You’re not alone. I already quadruple dipped his run. Waiting for an omnibus release.
We...are the only guys lol
I’ll be double dipping as well mates
I mostly liked it too. Some of the “Bat?” “Yes, Cat?” conversations were a bit much but overall I thought it was decent. I have the whole run in single issues so I’m waiting for an Omnibus run to double dip.
Heck no, you're definitely not alone! Loved this run!
Appreciate The Retroview Omar,also The Batman Deluxe Editions volumes 1-5 hardcover.also good:the artwork was excellent also I really enjoy the Retroview featuring all 5 Batman Deluxe Edition volumes and Omar thanks for sharing 👌 up the 👍 work stay healthy stay safe much love and have a Happy Thursday.😀😃😊😄😎💪👊
Hey Omar, these Deluxe Editions are nice. I wish I'd known about that format before I started buying the standard thin trades. I have the whole run and I'm content with it. I know I started to read it but maybe got as far as volume 2 as well as the 'Monster Men' trade. An omnibus would likely require 3 volumes perhaps? The use of matte paper began with Batman trade volume 8 which was the first black spine. Annoying. It's a run that I need to make time for, like everything else. Cheers mate.
Omar, I’ve been waiting for your Batman No Mans Land Omnibus review. Can’t wait!
Thanks for the retroview Omar! I can't wait for the omnis on this run. I think they can do it in three. You have his 85 issue run, plus annuals, specials, one-shots, the Batman/Catwoman series, and I think he's doing another Batman series for Black Label. Don't know if they'll hold out to collect the Black Label series but that is a lot of pages. I got through the Deluxe Edition volume four. I was really mad about the change in paper quality and since they weren't announcing volume five for a long time I just sold them. I want it all in the omnibus treatment too. I want the full crossover stories as well. I think they'll do it as in the Tynion Detective Omni they had all the issues for the Night Of The Monster Men crossover. Take care and peace.
For an Omnibus mapping, you'd need three or four. "Batman" #1-85, Annuals #1-2, and #4, Batman: Secret Files #1, Batman/Catwoman #1-12 and Special; Batman: Killing Time #1-6 (just announced!), Batman/Elmer Fudd, and a CRAP-TON of side stories from a bunch of places like Detective Comics #1000, #1027; Catwoman 80th Special, Robin 80th Special...it'd most likely be a 4 volume set.
Cant believe we're finally getting Vol 6 this year. A gaping hole in my shelf that, frankly, stopped me collecting Batman collected Editions (didn't see the point in moving onto Joker war etc, would be like watching season 2 of a show without watching the season 1 finale)
I just got the first 2 volumes in recently, but book 3,4 and 5 are out of print now, with 6 coming out in a week. I'm so bummed. This is my favorite run on Batman and I wish they were still printing the rest of the books
Yes, I am missing volume 3 and 5. My collection... it hurts 😅 I need a reprint, please Dc.
Yes!! I can't wait for book 6. I'm in the small group that liked Kings run so I'm very happy.
Are we ever going to get an original run Nightwing omnibus?
The books are actually sewn binding, but its like all DC books and omnis, It´s has a big layer of glue.
PD: so glad to hear there will be a book 6, being waiting for that like a mad man
I am not as down on the Tom King era as some are.
What I AM irate about is that I somehow missed Deluxe Volume 5, which is now challenging to find at a decent price.
Also, no: I had the Lee Weeks Deluxe; it had the same paper as the Deluxes Vols. 4 and 5
I don't know why DC not giving King some fun characters to write about. I think he is very good at comedy. His super friends and the gift stories are hilarious as well as issue in the deluxe 5 that was drawn by Amanda Conner.
For some reason I can’t find book 4 or 5 anywhere in the uk so I had to go to trade paperbacks 💀 😭
Wish they reprinted 4 and 5 got 1-3 and don’t want to start tbp for the last volumes
Hey Omar great video except issues 64&65 of Batman are in volume 5 of the deluxe editions. DC didn’t collect chapters 2&4 which are the Flash parts of the crossover.
Do the Retroview of avengers by Johnathan Hickman
I love that matte paper, colors look way better on it imo. Pretty sure it’s actually more expensive than the typical glossy too?
I am waiting for the omnibus editions. I stopped buying the deluxe editions after volume 2 and volume's 3, 4 and 5 are hard to find in Canada.
Thank god vol 6 is coming and have all omnibus/ hardcover from new 52 to James run completed
OMG im trying to get that batman Rebirth deluxe edition HC they don't have anymore in the store or online it been sold out for long time and it was hard to find it and i dont order on ebay and i will keep looking again online or the store too im trying to do the best and i hop i can find some help. thank you for your help when i get the spider--man miles omnibus
Wow what a great and informative video Omar
Some REALLY good stuff in the King issues. I wasn't blown away by everything, but what was good was SOOOOOO good. Annual 2 was one of my single favorite Batman issues of all time. Seems like any time he teams with Lee Weeks is printed gold, though. When these hit omnibus format, I may have to buy them.
I read Annual 2 with my wife and it was a beautiful love story. She loved it. King does some seriously incredible stuff with this run.
I started the run in single issues but then stopped cold turkey with single issues around #10, so I'm waiting a few more years for that omni I guess :P
Keep reading if you can. His run is all interconnected. It makes only sense if you read it all.
I would bind them together!!! I'm think of doing it with the Flash Rebirth Deluxes
I've done it lol
@@Sooner4ever1994 Dope!
Okay I’m late to the game. Playing catch up…..I can’t get these at all. No where. Unless you have a place that sells all (6) editions. I can buy 1,2,5 (5 is a maybe) and 6. 3-4 I can’t get anywhere. Will there be reprinting? An omnibus?
They are all available at Amazon.
Great choice of Retroview :)
Cannot Wait for Vol 6 💪💪
I could be wrong but I think Jason's last name is pronounced "Fay-bock". Concerning the run I only hear positive or negative things, really a 50/50 split. When it comes out in 2 omni's then I'll pick it up. Thanks for the video.
Would you need to read the heroes in crisis Batman tie in issues?
Batman issues of the price crossover ARE collected in the deluxe number 5. You literally flipped through them
At first I thought Tom King’s Batman run was just meh but I kept going because I always read Batman’s main book. Looking back at the run as a whole now though I’ve really grown to appreciate it and the long story that Tom King was trying to tell. Tom King might honestly be my favorite writer working right now
Will these be reprinted? I need 3 4 5 and they are going for 5x cover price insane!
So are all 5 of these books the whole collection, at least to this point? Looking to try them as my first batman comic series.
Started collecting these a while back, but when I saw they started fucking with the spines and discontinuing lines I dropped off and decided to wait for the inevitable Omnibus. Easy to reprint the same oversized pages in bigger books when half the work is already done!
I stopped collecting Batman TPBs in the middle of New 52 and I want to be more selective so I'm wondering if I need to get everything in DC You and Rebirth or if some can be skipped.
im waiting for the omnibus
Im trying to back track and purchase volume 3,4 &5. They are out of print. Any idea if DC will reprint them?
No word yet
Just bought the Batman Rise and Fall omni. Wish Dc had released this in omnis too. 😂
Omg I ran to preorder just to replace the last two books so I can have this era all the same size
Hermano… I missed out on this and I’m not sure if I should pick up Vols 1-2 with 3-5 unavailable.
You think they’ll reprint them?
That Batman looks like BVS knightmare scene
King's run on Batman is my personal favorite. I hope DC releases it as an omnibus somewhat soon considering this deluxe line ended before the run was finished.
Why
Yes! Absolutely my favorite Batman series. It’s so good.
It hasn’t ended, volume 6 is coming out in July which will hopefully collect the rest of it
@TheWokenado your name perfectly explains why you love this run
@TheWokenado I guess this guy thinks the run is “woke.” Not sure where he’s getting that from, though
While King’s run was not my favorite, I felt like it achieved higher peaks than Snyder’s run did in many ways, even if the lows were also lower. The decompressed, padded nature of the run made it feel a bit bloated, and it was painful reading this monthly.
All that said, I appreciated King trying some new ideas with the character, even if I have some objections to some of the twists and characterizations contained therein.
Also, if they did do omnis, I hope they include Batman and Elmer Fudd, a surprisingly great crossover.
I agree. I love the way this run flipped the script on Bruce and his trauma, emphatically stating that it is love and reaching out to others that heals you.
While I wasn’t a fan of Knightfall because it felt like a money grab just to increase sales, it did give us a villain that was as smart as Batman. It also grounded Batman showing all the damage that he was taking mentally and physically over the years fighting crime. I mean bats had been beaten, stabbed, and shot over the years. That has to take a toll on someone. The human body and mind can only endure so much.
It’s ridiculous how hard to find these are. I payed 60€ for book 3 and 80€ for book 5, been looking for a whole year. Book 4 nowhere to be found, only found one on ebay for 122$…I just don’t understand why they would print so few of them when Batman it’s a character famous all around the world
Although I don’t love the run, this reads so much better in collected format vs trying to read it in singles. Excited for book 6 to happen and hopefully people can enjoy it. :) Another great vid, my friend!
Tom king run is excellent up until the wedding that’s where the drop off
Hello Omar, I have a doubt , when are Dark Knights Metal and Death Metal taking place with the Rebirth Batman Issues? As I understand, Batman #52 ended giving birth to Dark Knights Metal… right? But then after Metal is the Batman Rebirth Era of King and then after that Death Metal and then Future State?
@TheWokenado thanks man! Yeah was trying to figure out the continuity there
I thought this was going to be an overview of all the Batman Deluxes.
Maybe should add Rebirth into the title
Definitely want to start buying some Batman stuff. Recommendations would be great!
Stay far away from this run
Snyder's run. One word epic!!!!!
Knightfall is a good one but not for new readers as such.....
You can't go wrong with starting at Long Halloween and then Dark Victory
Year One (Frank Miller) Long Halloween, Dark Victory, Catwoman When in Rome, Killing Joke, A death in the family, Hush. That would get you started on all the highlights.
I have all these plus the King /Weeks book (which is matt paper) plus Night of the monster men, and the Button, and even 'The Wedding Album' If the do reprint volumes 4+5 I hope they do it on Glossy paper and with the white spines (although they probably won't) I didn't know about the heroes' in crisis books, But have literally just bought them on Amazon, so thanks for the info Omar, and if they do print Omni's with all this in then please could they include the crossovers, or I shan't bother to double dip, I get so p'd off when they are more concerned with whether a particular writer wrote it all, I buy 'em for Batman, not who writes it. Same kinda thing happened with the Grant Morrison Omni's, half way through a story there would be issues missing 'cos Morrison didn't write them(eyeroll)
Really regret not picking up Book 5 early on just for completing my collection. Going on Amazon they're asking for more than the listed price and the annoying part is Book 5 contains the Knightmare's storyline which is arguable the worst part of King's run. Overall though King's time on Batman will definitely not be forgotten and even some of his storylines such as Cold Days will be considered some of the greatest Batman stories ever.
Why is the hardcover of Book 3 so much more expensive than the others?
It’s out of print.
Anyone know where I can get book 4 and 5 at a reasonable price? Been having some difficulty
Same here..can’t find 3-4-5 😢
I personally prefer deluxe editions to omnis because they are more comfortable to read and tend to have matching spines (except green arrow, yeah DC, just make the spine blue.. wtf) but since collecting DC has become a pain in the ass and they just discontinued the whole line, I sold most of my Rebirth Deluxe Editions except Detective Comics and Actions Comics, because they at least finished a whole run.
So now I have a couple of rebirth deluxe which at least have great looking spines, right next to my rebirth trades, who just look horrible.. 3 different spines during the Tom King Batman run.. 🤦🏻♂️
I like that Tom King was fearless with Batman. There were peaks and valleys but it’s easily one of the best runs on the character in a long long time.
Really hoping these get the omnibus treatment. The omission of issues from story arcs is why I don’t like the Deluxe format.
The best HQ
17:44 Omar, noooooooooooooo
This Tom King run was bad overall,but it had a few decent moments. The art was strong.
I absolutely loved this run. Not only was it, in my opinion, an intricate deep dive into Batman's psyche, but it was also just a good time. I blazed through Deluxes Vol. 1 and 2 and sold my set in anticipation of an Omnibus. The "I Am Gotham/I Am Suicide/I Am Bane" trilogy was solid and "War of Jokes and Riddles" was great ("Night of the Monster Men" was alright). "Rooftop" is one of my favorite Batman stories of all time. It's where "Rules of Engagement" and "The Gift" came out that I started to think, "Okay..." And of course..."The Wedding" was an unnecessary misdirect.. That said, I thoroughly enjoyed everything I've read from it. King is so creative with how he tells the story, the art is gorgeous, and the way the story builds to a, admittedly, okay conclusion was great. I will definitely purchase this run in an Omnibus!!
Could you do a retroview of all Batman deluxe editions you have? (non rebirth)
Having King’s run in omni format is a waste of paper.
King's run for better or worse is a lot of things but back to basics is not one of them.
I know you are probably tired of me commenting this, BUT, where the heck is the Superman reading order?
I thought I had replied?
Loved the artists in this run particularly Janin and Mann. The stories are a lot of hits and probably two hits.
King's run was, at best, just OK.
I've liked some of his other stuff but his Batman was pretty underwhelming.
I though most people hated Tom King's Batman
Where is batman no mans land omnibus overview
Out in the wild. I explained in the video.
They lost me in rebirth loved new 52
It’s not just you Omar this run was not good and the whole bat cat thing is super weird
I enjoyed volumes 1-3 even though the great tragedy that Batman feels guilty for is creating Kiteman. Batman could easily blame himself which would have been great. Then he ruined Booster Gold as if he never read any recent run of the character. Then comes the wedding. Tom King has to Tom King. He is the antonym to Geoff Johns when it comes to DC lore. A writer makes a deal with the reader. Tom King thinks breaking the deal over and over is a good thing which was why it fell flat.
@TheWokenado Heroes in Crises is Tom King's Baby not Didio. Your love affair with Tom King is noted. Any argument is pointless with you.
It was a good run for real. I loved it. How Batman was not only "Ehi dude. I'm Batman. I can do anything, also beat the c**p out of anyone because..I'm Batman". Here, "'I'm Batman" is not a meme at least. It's something more personal. It shows how a character in comics can change. Reading this after the Snyder's lame run was very refreshing.
While I personally think Snyder's run is great (just re-read it last week), I think King's is definitely better. King added a human element to Batman. He wasn't the guy who always won or had a plan for everything. There are some bumps in the run, but King's will always be special to me
Good: Art is great throughout and in the first issue Batman is absolute bad ass riding airplane.
Bad: If you thought Batbunny was terrible ending to Snyder's New 52 run, King says hold my beer and gives us Nightmares and City of Bane. Batman was just so uncharacteristic and he was made to look so weak against Bane in the final battle. Worst thing I have ever read.
Tom King simply doesn't get Batman at all.
OK that is so dang dumb you only get the batman issues for the button that would not read well AT ALL what the flip that's dumb, rant over lol
great artwork, garbage writing.
The best Batman run ever. Sorry, Morrison.
Morrison is not even close. I can think of like 5 off the top of my head that are better then Morrisons jumbled mess.
This was the worst run of Batman I've ever read. If you want a soy-boy, mommy-wife having, overly emotional, ineffective and whipped Batman, enjoy.
Those who want good comics stay away.
Agreed,the run was really bad but the art was great.
@@mannyc19 Sometimes it was. Too bad it had like 10 different artists.
@TheWokenado Sorry, your gana have to explain your insult (if it was one). Genuinely did not get it.
The story and characters of Gotham girl and gotham guy was the Dumbest thing ever! Even i was what garbage am i reading
@@robd1329 I dont get it. Are you agreeing/disagreeing with me or what?