I am Pashtun from Paktia, my hometown is not far from Durand line, usually Pashtuns from the other side of Durand line like to come here if there is a wedding and we also love to go accross the Durand line too if there is a wedding. Pashtun tribal relation is very strong, we are same religion, same people, same norm. We are unlike Punjabi who hate their own people accross the Indian border because of religious difference. All Pashtuns are one religion, similar dialects, one people. Why would we hate each other and block each other?
Well articulated Sir, But I think your content should be better in urdu with English subtitles because majority of the audience can’t understand English properly. If not, Then at least the subtitles should be in urdu so everyone could understand this intricate conflict 👍🏻
Its not called "international border with Pakistan" It is and will be British colonial imposed artificial durandline seperating Afghan tribes! And we afghans will never recognize any foreign imposed borders.
@@peschannel9815 you are not Pakistani your identity is Afghan if you are pashtun! Your kings are afghan your history is Afghan your language pashto is afghan! Pakistan is irrelevant!
Afghan talk about family getting divided by this border ! Well, Tajik, Uzbek, turkmen ethnic groups of Afghanistan also are divided by 3 border walls because of Afghanistan. There are countries of Tajikistan, Uzbekistan, Turkmenistan right on the Western/northern border of Afghanistan. Why letting those families divide like that? Why not hand those regions which is 70% of Afghanistan to Tajikistan, Uzbekistan, Turkmenistan ? Please Afghanistan don't divided those brothers and sisters like that. You need to remove those 3 Durand lines first.
This Durand line dispute is just an excuse. Afghans consider Pakistan soft and perhaps stupid compared to Iran, Uzbek, Tajikistan and Turkmenistan. It's time Pakistan take hard stand as it has done more than enough for Afghans yet they show no respect towards us.
@@UnstoppableEmpire well Pakistan (read Pakistani establishment) was doing everything coz of it's insecurities. But that doesn't mean one should target Pakistani public who openly helped, supported and most of the times tolerated over 4 million refugees for more than 4 decades. So much so, they hate Pakistan more than Russia or US. Whatever we did was far less than what he'll Russia and US brought on them yet they only blame Pakistan is the real problem for me.
@@UnstoppableEmpire I better not use the term "pests" but our govt and establishment was just looking for its own interests selfishly is how I would describe the situation.
@@globalcitizen1856 true, and that's why we still fight til this day to re-unify the entirety of Kashmir back with Bharat. But the current line is drawn by British/UN.
@@---GOD--- Kashmiri do not want with India actually, they deserve their own country. Kashmiri, Nuristani, Chitrali, Kohistani, Gilgit-Baltistani, Pashayi deserve their own country together. They are unique people, as Pashtun, we love them. We should redrawn the line to divide the country truly based on nation
@@Ghost0fPakistan it's already being done , it had already started in early 2008's had the PPP government paid attention to it we might have curbed a lot of terrorist attacks
British represented British India and not Pakistan! That is because British India got divided into 3 countries in 1947. British established boundaries for political & administrative convenience. Those borders were not cultural demarcations. Pashtuns are Afghans and have no connection with Pakistanis who are offsprings of Mughals. Why should the world respect Pakistan's false claims? Pakistan did not even exist before 1947. Why should Afghans be willing to be part of Pak?
@@Dankseid-o1u Did any muslim belonging to South asia claim that? Pakistanis look middle-eastern. Though they might carry a small percentage of native genes because of the native women who were originally abused, Pakistanis are primarily middle-eastern or central asian - look at their habits, the way they look, their culture, practices & rituals, life values, their history, political systems, food habits etc. Pakistanis are offsprings of mughals & other foreign tribal marauders who occupied local land & resources. What was the 2-nation theory about? Why did native societies fight wars of independence against muslims & other foreigners like Tipu sultan & Akbar etc? Why did founders of Pak & other muslims fight for an Islamic state in 1947 while native citizens fought for independence from muslims & British? Recently a lot of fiction is being created to legalize false claim of Pakistanis & to mainstream Pakistanis as being natives of the south-asia.
@@globalcitizen1856 pakistanis are but Hindus, Buddhists and Jains of those areas who were forcefully converted. Now they pretend to be arab and central asian.
@@globalcitizen1856 only Pashtun and Baloch are Middle-Eastern, Pashtun are close to ancient Bactrian, Baloch are closer to Kurds and Omani. The rest like Punjabi and Sindhi are just Indian
@@naim_sulaimankhel Nobody becomes Punjabi or Sindhi by living on the land that once belonged to native Punjabis & Sindhis. Culturally native Sindhis & Punjabis are very contrastingly different from Pakistanis. Pakistanis are descendants of Central Asians. That is why they look very different
Durand line was a pact with the British to agree ob a sphere of influence. When British empire collapsed, this agreement should have been nullified. Btw, we afghans don't accept any British made lines anyways. Unless Pakistan sees Itself as part of Britain. Then that's a different story.
"Its sanctity has to remain" No. No it does not. The Durand Line never made any sense because it divided the Pashtun people, giving a good sizeable amount of their land and people to Pakistan. The line must be redrawn. Either Pakistan gives up KP and tribal regions willingly, or the Taliban take it by force. One thing for sure is that this line is not remaining as it once was.
The comical and sad part about this is that Pakistan understands the divisive nature of this artificial line that split an entire ethnic group within their own land. Tragic legacy of imperial slavery mindsets.
Hmmm we are waiting for this kind of action by some thugs and then teach them some lessons if today the Pashtuns are in power in Afghanistan it's all because of Pakistan otherwise Tajiks and uzbeks were crushing them and show them their real place
It doesn't divide pashtuns, what the hell are you on about, only three tribes, wazir, shinwari and mohmand, the majority of them are in Pakistan anyway. By that token we should remove all borders around the world. Whether it be West Bengal and Bangladesh, Switzerland should have no borders with Italy,Germany,France etc too. I am pashtun and have no links or ties with Afghanistan. 50 million pashtuns call Pakistan their home, they have been part of the Indus and Gandhara Civilisation. This topi drama has lead to the common Pakistani Pakhtoon hating all Afghans, we want the 4 million refugees returned and you want us to have no borders.
Hahaha...Pakistan always supported terrorism and Mujahideen in Afghanistan..Pakistani army is responsible for causing instability... Pashtuns will never forget.. Better give back NWFP areas to real Afghans.
For your kind information, Pakistan never got independence. India was split/divided into TWO parts. The other part became Pakistan. Ambassador Durrani needs to be educated on this issue.
Sir Pakistan got independence or India got parition.which is correct.Is Pakistan is a partition part of India .If this is true then no question of independence.It was partioned.
We Afghans will never accept the Durand line cuz this line was between Afghanistan and British India not Pakistan and there is nothing in common between the Pashtuns and Punjabi people also if Pakistan believe in Islam than they shouldn’t divide brothers which the British did if Pakistan don’t agree than there is no difference between Pakistan and British this means Pakistan is also a colonizer like British which opens the page that we must declare Jihad against Pakistan.
Ignore this video. Im from the durrand lone area what this person hasnt mention wad that the durrand lines divides us Pashtuns into 2 country. Afghanisfan anf pakistan dividing families and tribes. To this day no Pashtun from both side even see the durrand line. Many ignore it He nentioned that "afghans call it durrand line and Pakistan call its an international border". This isnt true us Pakistani Pashtuns dont see it as "international" My pashtun tribe: the shinwaris are literally divided by it
I am punjabi but first we are Pakistani. If afghanistan wants to be part of a greater Pakistan the border can be removed otherwise if the afghans want to be a separate country then the fence should stay. Also the 2 million refugees can go back to afghanistan too. what do afghans want?
@@mrexpress8002 Your a punjabi. Yiu shouldnt be imvolved in Pashtun issues worry about your own india Pak punjab border Although yours id diffrent since punjabis have a diffrent religions Pashtun border aka durrand line is diffrent as we come from the same tribe. Have the same religon language and culture and no we rather have independance than become part of another nation..We KPK pashtun did not want to be a part of pak or india or afg
@@omarshinwari7823 you are living in dreamland dude. I am punjabi and i get involved in everyones issues but first of all i am a Pakistani. Pakistani Punjabis are muslim you idiot! the problem with you is that you live in the past and are stuck in backward thinking. My grandfathers fought for independence and my uncles fought against the soviet union when they invaded afghanistan. Let me tell you something son we will never surrender on the sovereignty of Pakistan. Also many many pashtuns have married punjabis. you are an afghan go back to afghanistan dude.
@@mrexpress8002 Your a nationalists alsp who said punjabis are not muslums. thefe muslim. hindus and sikh punjanis Punjabis have no rights getting involved in Pashtun affairs. thats like an english man getting involved in arab affairs go worry about your own pak india punjab border Im a pashtun from Landi kotal shinwari tribe in KPK Also we pashtuns dont marry outside our tribes so idk what your talking about
@@mrexpress8002 Whos an afghan here. 😂😂😂 im from Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and native for us pashtuns beinf muslims and pashtun is first. and nationality (pakistani) is second also no pak or afghan pashtun accepts durrand line like i said worrt about your own border in India/pak punjab instead of gettinf involeved in ours 😂😂
Strange issue, so the King of Afghanistan gave away a massive portion of Afghanistan without consulting Afghans. Who agreed on this shabby deal? And where is the original agreement. Was it in Farsi or Pashto or English?
He is lying, Durand Line has never ever been accepted as an international border and the 1921 treaty of Rawalpindi has cancelled all the previous treaties including the Durand treaty, and the 1921 treaty is a temporary arrangement which could not be cancelled for the first three years and after three years both party can at any time unilaterally cancel the treaty with 12 months binding periode, and the agreement of 1930 is a reconfirmation of the treaty of 1921 and nothing new addition. in 1949 Afghanistan has cancelled the treaty and it has no legal basis whatsoever. this is the text of the as per article below of the treaty of 1921. Article XIV The provisions of this treaty shall come into force from the date of its signature, and shall remain in force for three years from that date. In case neither of the High Contracting Parties should have notified, twelve months before the expiration of the said three years, the intention to terminate it, it shall remain binding until the expiration of one year from the day on which either of the High Contracting Parties shall have denounced it. This treaty shall come into force after the signatures of the Missions of the two Parties, and the two ratified copies of this shall be exchanged in Kabul within 2⅟2 months after the signatures.
Its kind of absurd. First of All ,what they have,they can't manage it. People migrated to different countries like Pakistan UAE Australia and Europe. They want to acquire more dude first be a nation. Always scattered ,polarized community and divided among war lords with certain ethnicity.
Please dont lie, Durand Line has never ever been accepted as an international border and the 1921 treaty of Rawalpindi has cancelled all the previous treaties including the Durand treaty, and the 1921 treaty is a temporary arrangement which could not be cancelled for the first three years and after three years both party can at any time unilaterally cancel the treaty with 12 months binding periode, and the agreement of 1930 is a reconfirmation of the treaty of 1921 and nothing new addition. in 1949 Afghanistan has cancelled the treaty and it has no legal basis whatsoever. this is the text of the as per article below of the treaty of 1921. Article XIV The provisions of this treaty shall come into force from the date of its signature, and shall remain in force for three years from that date. In case neither of the High Contracting Parties should have notified, twelve months before the expiration of the said three years, the intention to terminate it, it shall remain binding until the expiration of one year from the day on which either of the High Contracting Parties shall have denounced it. This treaty shall come into force after the signatures of the Missions of the two Parties, and the two ratified copies of this shall be exchanged in Kabul within 2⅟2 months after the signatures.
I m from Swat and I don’t recognize Duran line.. Your Masters are gone so all the agreements.. end of story Although Pak still in the delusion of being Brown Angrez., time is up
The great lie starts at 3:20 -- there is no formal legality of which he speaks, and he fails to mention what the actual disagreement is and why there is disagreement to begin with. This is how they avoid speaking openly and honestly. If Pakistan was truly a nation of muslims with good intentions, the dialogue wouldn't continue in this manner -- everyone knows the fence has nothing to do with narcotics or terrorists (they literally trained the Taliban in Pakistan to then go back to Afghanistan after the US pulled out). This type of two-faced rhetoric simply adds to the same issues of character & credibility of Pakistan on the global stage.
rhetoric cries and always blame Pakistan we r here till doomsday do whatever you can as durrani the ones who founded afghanistan he is proud to be a Pakistani .
The lie starts when he says it is demarcated inch by inch😂😂😂, first of all Kaalia poomjabakai slave, the Durrand line runs through such a rough difficult terrain that, it was never formally demarcated, as early as 2018 was when the US paid $400 million to Pakistan to demarcate the line based on alliance of Pakistan in the invasion of Afghanistan by US and Pakistan. The agreement was signed in English and later it was marked based on valley and mountains not by inches as this hypocrite Asad fake Durrani claims. To this day Pakistan hasn't provided the agreement nor the documentation of demarcation, it is purely taken away by force just like Israel has taken over Palestine 🇵🇸. There was no agreement with Pakistan and nor was there any self determination rights given to the people of Pakhtunkhwa.
Pakistan got independence lol as if it existed before, the correct line would have been pakistan got created, wonder how many other biased word plays are in this video
@@zyT175 by your logic there was no country ever existed all were regions ... grow out of this mindset ... do something productive instead of word plays
@@zyT175 the problem with you is you are blind in monsoon all you see is green ... Keyboard warrior history expert . Go do some productive work with you cloudy region textbook
Let me correct some facts which is missing in this video. it was not only one aggrement but four. e.g 1879,1893, 1901, and 1919. Afghanistan has no offical claim on KP anywhere. the bitish given subsidy far before the durand line. the subsidy started in 1879 during the Gandamak treaty.
Please dont lie, Durand Line has never ever been accepted as an international border and the 1921 treaty of Rawalpindi has cancelled all the previous treaties including the Durand treaty, and the 1921 treaty is a temporary arrangement which could not be cancelled for the first three years and after three years both party can at any time unilaterally cancel the treaty with 12 months binding periode, and the agreement of 1930 is a reconfirmation of the treaty of 1921 and nothing new addition. in 1949 Afghanistan has cancelled the treaty and it has no legal basis whatsoever. this is the text of the as per article below of the treaty of 1921. Article XIV The provisions of this treaty shall come into force from the date of its signature, and shall remain in force for three years from that date. In case neither of the High Contracting Parties should have notified, twelve months before the expiration of the said three years, the intention to terminate it, it shall remain binding until the expiration of one year from the day on which either of the High Contracting Parties shall have denounced it. This treaty shall come into force after the signatures of the Missions of the two Parties, and the two ratified copies of this shall be exchanged in Kabul within 2⅟2 months after the signatures.
@@EsmatLaarawai-mo8oy 1921 agreement is the not the Durand line agreement but the extension of 1919 Rawalpindi agreement. Afghanistan has never denounced the 1921 agreement till 1947.
Durand line is a dead horse. it's an international border but more interestingly Afghanistan has no official claim on KPK. KPK is part of Pakistan and Pashtuns are proud Pakistani
@@riffatwaniofficial9810 The treaty of Kabul in 1921 is signed because both sides could not come to an agreement on the Durand line and is therefore made an temporary arrangement, which gives both sides the right to cancel the treaty unilaterally at any time, and Afghanistan has used that right to cancel the treaty in 1947, before the establishment of a new neocolonial state named Pakistan for the loyal servants of the British empire as a extra buffer as part of the broader security politics of the leaving British empire against the Communist USSR.
@@riffatwaniofficial9810 It is up to people of both sides of Durand line and Afghanistan to decide thier future, and Afghanistan has never ever recognized the line of Hatred drawn by colonial power, so that is the most important thing is, the opinion of colonial powers around the world and the opinion of Punjabi Establishment in GHQ and the opinion of states that has no affinity with the issue doesnt matter at all.
British have no business in drawing lines and thereby creating everlasting disputes outside its own geographical borders and by that I mean the British Isle. Chinese has as much claim to reject McMahon line and reclaim Laddakh, Sikkim and Arunachal Pradesh. Same way Afghans have no need to accept Durand Line, that seperates it from it's rightful brother province of KPK. Pakistani pashtuns must realize that it is in their best interest to join fellow Pashtuns than remain second class citizens to Punjabi who reep all the benefits. Bengalis proved it by setting themselves free from oppressive Mullah and Martial Law, establishing their own nation and results speak for themselves. Long live valiant Pashtuns who once ruled over these Punjabis.
Ladakh, Sikkim, Arunachal Pradesh wants to be with India. British did had business dividing border as they were the rulers. It's upto you to negotiate.
@@amolkhobaragade the territories of dispute will be taken back by China and India will do nothing, just as they watched with utter humiliation China taking back Pangong Tso, where they are building bridges, as well as villages in Arunachal Pradesh.
But there is a difference. Forget about Indian territories, even Tibet was never part of China till 1950! Neither Tibetans nor Indians ever call themselves Chinese. Whereas Pashtuns never accepted they are Pakistanis. Like China occupied Tibet and other surrounding areas, Pakistanis occupied KP, Balochistan, and Kashmir. Both of these countries are rouge countries always looking to create trouble for others
Durand Line Forced Agreement, one part of Afghanistan was leased for 100 years, the lease has been expired long ago 30 years, the Afghan Government has fully right to take his land and take the lease for 30 years with full penalty form the successor government of Pakistan.
@@SOWProgramming thanks to Angrez. Yaha hamlogo ko divide karke khud socha tha ki duniya mein hukumat karega lekin aaj hamlog hi unke sar ke upar baithe huye hai
The durand line was for lease for 100 years and and pakistan was supposed to pay 20 million afghani yearly like rent and a package such as weapons horses and etc and they never paid that. The lease ended long time ago and the land is supposed to be given back to Afghanistan. If pakistan wants the land they have to pay trillions of dollar to Afghanistan for the land which they never did.
Well its a blatant lie that agreement is for 100 years If you read original agreement there’s no such thing written in it So stop the sale pitch because no one’s gonna buy it
Fencing durand line means dividing afghani and pakistani pakhtuns i am from Orakzai tribe and i am against durand fence bcoz actually every pakhun is afghan زه دا حيران يم چي پاكستان دشمني إنڈیا سرہ دی خو ليكن بند كوي دي افغانستان بورڈر۔ دا ولی ؟ زندہ باد یو پختون
Do you give guarantee that there will be no terrorists coming to PAK from AFG? Would you take responsibility if illegal Afghans do criminal stuff in our cities?
@@muhammadusama6040 why don’t they fence indian side border. coz they claim india is their worst enemy but with them they are sharing sweets on a good days here on afghan side they are fencing borders that’s really sad and disappointing. coz they don’t have any right to do it. bcoz they didn’t conquered our pakhtun tribal areas they didn’t conquered us. so we will decide for this land. what we want should happen not what they want
@@muhammadusama6040 don’t worry too much about our side. coz when their was drone strikes on our areas at that time where was these people to take stance. when we was being killed by us drone strikes where was our savior napak army. where was our government. where was our just name brother punjab. we don’t have any threat from afghan side don’t worry son too much about us.
Pakistan got independence lol as if it existed before, the correct line would have been pakistan got created, wonder how many other biased word plays are in this video
Im pashtun from kpk and we dont recognize it as a border .. its just a line and this kpk belong to Afghanistan..this is their land
Get out of Pakistan if you like Afghanistan that much 🤬🤬🤬
Durrand line is Pakistan and no-one can take it from us 💪🇵🇰
@@tajdarkazmi21 they will take it .india will help them
@@tajdarkazmi21 if you support imaginary lines created by the British to cause division between muslims around the world then sure.
I am Pashtun from Paktia, my hometown is not far from Durand line, usually Pashtuns from the other side of Durand line like to come here if there is a wedding and we also love to go accross the Durand line too if there is a wedding. Pashtun tribal relation is very strong, we are same religion, same people, same norm. We are unlike Punjabi who hate their own people accross the Indian border because of religious difference. All Pashtuns are one religion, similar dialects, one people. Why would we hate each other and block each other?
Excellant Bhai that's why we like afghanis
We don't hate our indian punjabi brothers and sisters don't spread false news
You are more than welcome to go there permanently
@@talhahussain3132 yes we do
Well said brother. Love from India
His English skill is more interesting than Durand line issue to me....
No Afghan alive or dead will accept the Durand line NEVER 🇦🇫
Well articulated Sir, But I think your content should be better in urdu with English subtitles because majority of the audience can’t understand English properly. If not, Then at least the subtitles should be in urdu so everyone could understand this intricate conflict 👍🏻
The agreement was for 99 years which already passed 129 years, which is now Afghanistan’s land up to atak bridge.
Show me where it is written that the agreement was for 99 years? It's not shitty pata khazana, it's international agreement.
@@muhammadusama6040 all of Pakistan is historic Afghan land before the Europeans stole it from us. All Pakistanis (Punjabis and sindhis) must leave
@@amazingamx1255 Punjab and Sindh are historical Indian lands whereas KPK & Baluchistan are historical Afghan lands
@@aAverageFan you mean Pakistan is an illegal land of Afghanistan and India
@@muhammadusama6040 makh Dey ruksha, kpal khalko sara ular osa.
Pakistan has every right to defend itself.
Its not called "international border with Pakistan"
It is and will be British colonial imposed artificial durandline seperating Afghan tribes! And we afghans will never recognize any foreign imposed borders.
Why not?
We Pathans are Pakistanis
@@peschannel9815 you are not Pakistani your identity is Afghan if you are pashtun! Your kings are afghan your history is Afghan your language pashto is afghan! Pakistan is irrelevant!
@@pakistanzucks But I live in Pakistan and born in Pakistan
Family in Pakistan
Work in Pakistan
🙂
Afghans lost war and gave all this area and its people to British in exchange for money. Shameless afghans should have some gharat
@@muhammadusama6040 They have always been fighters and have survived 40 years of war, calling them shameless is akin to spitting in the sky.
Lying is very bad Mr Pakistani 😢
We’re Pakhtuns and we will have it back it doesn’t matter if it takes 100 years. 😢
Stop crying lundian bot
@@Markhor579 m a dar-ch-od idhar bhi tereko India hi dikh raha hai. Lagta hai teri am-mi ko India walo ne ch-oda tha
Afghan talk about family getting divided by this border !
Well, Tajik, Uzbek, turkmen ethnic groups of Afghanistan also are divided by 3 border walls because of Afghanistan. There are countries of Tajikistan, Uzbekistan, Turkmenistan right on the Western/northern border of Afghanistan.
Why letting those families divide like that? Why not hand those regions which is 70% of Afghanistan to Tajikistan, Uzbekistan, Turkmenistan ? Please Afghanistan don't divided those brothers and sisters like that. You need to remove those 3 Durand lines first.
This Durand line dispute is just an excuse. Afghans consider Pakistan soft and perhaps stupid compared to Iran, Uzbek, Tajikistan and Turkmenistan. It's time Pakistan take hard stand as it has done more than enough for Afghans yet they show no respect towards us.
@@AAdab77 the only good we ever did in Afghanistan was from 1979-1988. After that we were pests that should not have ruined the country.
@@UnstoppableEmpire well Pakistan (read Pakistani establishment) was doing everything coz of it's insecurities. But that doesn't mean one should target Pakistani public who openly helped, supported and most of the times tolerated over 4 million refugees for more than 4 decades. So much so, they hate Pakistan more than Russia or US. Whatever we did was far less than what he'll Russia and US brought on them yet they only blame Pakistan is the real problem for me.
@@UnstoppableEmpire I better not use the term "pests" but our govt and establishment was just looking for its own interests selfishly is how I would describe the situation.
Khurasan WILL come back. This is a promise. And then Israel is finished
You believe the line drawn by the British Empire should remain in tact forever? Do you say the same about Israel? What about Kashmir?
The people who divided Kashmir are Pak army!
@@globalcitizen1856 true, and that's why we still fight til this day to re-unify the entirety of Kashmir back with Bharat. But the current line is drawn by British/UN.
@@---GOD--- haha you said in another comment that you were Pashtun and called out your bull shit... Now you yourself said you are from India
@@abdulahadkhan557 I've never said that. You're drinking too much 🐪🐫 p
@@---GOD--- Kashmiri do not want with India actually, they deserve their own country. Kashmiri, Nuristani, Chitrali, Kohistani, Gilgit-Baltistani, Pashayi deserve their own country together. They are unique people, as Pashtun, we love them. We should redrawn the line to divide the country truly based on nation
This guy has explained nothing.
Another excellent well informed video. Well done TCM, keep up the good work. Do you have a patreon I can donate to?
Hi Shuaib. Kindly find the Patreon link here: www.patreon.com/thecentrummedia
I'm Pashtun I don't recognize this line, This lines divided Pashtuns.
Well explained... border should be secure as secure with india.....
@@Ghost0fPakistan it's already being done , it had already started in early 2008's had the PPP government paid attention to it we might have curbed a lot of terrorist attacks
Exactly bro. Thanks to Pakistan that we don’t have to deal with these Talibans. They’re more dangerous
Thanks for covering
British represented British India and not Pakistan! That is because British India got divided into 3 countries in 1947. British established boundaries for political & administrative convenience. Those borders were not cultural demarcations. Pashtuns are Afghans and have no connection with Pakistanis who are offsprings of Mughals. Why should the world respect Pakistan's false claims? Pakistan did not even exist before 1947. Why should Afghans be willing to be part of Pak?
pakistanis have no connection with mughals who were uzbeks, mughals were exiled to Burma after 1857.
@@Dankseid-o1u Did any muslim belonging to South asia claim that? Pakistanis look middle-eastern. Though they might carry a small percentage of native genes because of the native women who were originally abused, Pakistanis are primarily middle-eastern or central asian - look at their habits, the way they look, their culture, practices & rituals, life values, their history, political systems, food habits etc. Pakistanis are offsprings of mughals & other foreign tribal marauders who occupied local land & resources. What was the 2-nation theory about? Why did native societies fight wars of independence against muslims & other foreigners like Tipu sultan & Akbar etc? Why did founders of Pak & other muslims fight for an Islamic state in 1947 while native citizens fought for independence from muslims & British? Recently a lot of fiction is being created to legalize false claim of Pakistanis & to mainstream Pakistanis as being natives of the south-asia.
@@globalcitizen1856 pakistanis are but Hindus, Buddhists and Jains of those areas who were forcefully converted. Now they pretend to be arab and central asian.
@@globalcitizen1856 only Pashtun and Baloch are Middle-Eastern, Pashtun are close to ancient Bactrian, Baloch are closer to Kurds and Omani. The rest like Punjabi and Sindhi are just Indian
@@naim_sulaimankhel Nobody becomes Punjabi or Sindhi by living on the land that once belonged to native Punjabis & Sindhis. Culturally native Sindhis & Punjabis are very contrastingly different from Pakistanis. Pakistanis are descendants of Central Asians. That is why they look very different
Durand line was a pact with the British to agree ob a sphere of influence. When British empire collapsed, this agreement should have been nullified. Btw, we afghans don't accept any British made lines anyways. Unless Pakistan sees Itself as part of Britain. Then that's a different story.
We never accept the bloody Durand line 🇦🇫❤️🌹
We do
Can you work for me I will sand you good salary just delete pakr army
very good journalism. keep up the good work
"Its sanctity has to remain"
No. No it does not. The Durand Line never made any sense because it divided the Pashtun people, giving a good sizeable amount of their land and people to Pakistan.
The line must be redrawn. Either Pakistan gives up KP and tribal regions willingly, or the Taliban take it by force. One thing for sure is that this line is not remaining as it once was.
The comical and sad part about this is that Pakistan understands the divisive nature of this artificial line that split an entire ethnic group within their own land. Tragic legacy of imperial slavery mindsets.
@@SR-te2db of course they do. Just like they split Punjabis, Kashmiris, and Bengalis. Hope those lines vanish in the future.
@@---GOD--- you really think Taliban can take it by force?... No way in hell
Hmmm we are waiting for this kind of action by some thugs and then teach them some lessons if today the Pashtuns are in power in Afghanistan it's all because of Pakistan otherwise Tajiks and uzbeks were crushing them and show them their real place
It doesn't divide pashtuns, what the hell are you on about, only three tribes, wazir, shinwari and mohmand, the majority of them are in Pakistan anyway. By that token we should remove all borders around the world. Whether it be West Bengal and Bangladesh, Switzerland should have no borders with Italy,Germany,France etc too. I am pashtun and have no links or ties with Afghanistan. 50 million pashtuns call Pakistan their home, they have been part of the Indus and Gandhara Civilisation. This topi drama has lead to the common Pakistani Pakhtoon hating all Afghans, we want the 4 million refugees returned and you want us to have no borders.
Britishers draw this line
Duran line was never accepted or will b accepted by Afghanistan either by a democratic government or by taliban.........
Hahaha...Pakistan always supported terrorism and Mujahideen in Afghanistan..Pakistani army is responsible for causing
instability... Pashtuns will never forget.. Better give back NWFP areas to real Afghans.
oh just shut up ,pashtuns dont need u to talk about them
For your kind information, Pakistan never got independence. India was split/divided into TWO parts. The other part became Pakistan. Ambassador Durrani needs to be educated on this issue.
if i were you i might get my brain cells checked.
@@MEGALecture He is right. India got independence and Pakistan was created in August 1947.
Pakistan never existed before that.
@@amolkhobaragade How come Pakistan came into being a day before India ?
Actually, India got divided into 3 parts
@@AJ-I Pakistan came into being a day before India became a Republic, India always existed before pakistan.
Sir Pakistan got independence or India got parition.which is correct.Is Pakistan is a partition part of India .If this is true then no question of independence.It was partioned.
So you are telling me that India existed before 47.
We Afghans will never accept the Durand line cuz this line was between Afghanistan and British India not Pakistan and there is nothing in common between the Pashtuns and Punjabi people also if Pakistan believe in Islam than they shouldn’t divide brothers which the British did if Pakistan don’t agree than there is no difference between Pakistan and British this means Pakistan is also a colonizer like British which opens the page that we must declare Jihad against Pakistan.
Pakistan was created as a hat-red tool against India. They never wanted India to prosper that’s why they created Pakistan
Perfectly put forward
He missed a lot of issue.
perfectly ignorant that this border is not real for the Pashtuns
Ignore this video. Im from the durrand lone area
what this person hasnt mention wad that the durrand lines divides us Pashtuns into 2 country. Afghanisfan anf pakistan
dividing families and tribes. To this day no Pashtun from both side even see the durrand line. Many ignore it
He nentioned that "afghans call it durrand line and Pakistan call its an international border". This isnt true us Pakistani Pashtuns dont see it as "international"
My pashtun tribe: the shinwaris are literally divided by it
I am punjabi but first we are Pakistani. If afghanistan wants to be part of a greater Pakistan the border can be removed otherwise if the afghans want to be a separate country then the fence should stay. Also the 2 million refugees can go back to afghanistan too. what do afghans want?
@@mrexpress8002 Your a punjabi. Yiu shouldnt be imvolved in Pashtun issues
worry about your own india Pak punjab border Although yours id diffrent since punjabis have a diffrent religions
Pashtun border aka durrand line is diffrent as we come from the same tribe. Have the same religon language and culture and no we rather have independance than become part of another nation..We KPK pashtun did not want to be a part of pak or india or afg
@@omarshinwari7823 you are living in dreamland dude. I am punjabi and i get involved in everyones issues but first of all i am a Pakistani. Pakistani Punjabis are muslim you idiot! the problem with you is that you live in the past and are stuck in backward thinking. My grandfathers fought for independence and my uncles fought against the soviet union when they invaded afghanistan. Let me tell you something son we will never surrender on the sovereignty of Pakistan. Also many many pashtuns have married punjabis. you are an afghan go back to afghanistan dude.
@@mrexpress8002 Your a nationalists
alsp who said punjabis are not muslums. thefe muslim. hindus and sikh punjanis
Punjabis have no rights getting involved in Pashtun affairs. thats like an english man getting involved in arab affairs
go worry about your own pak india punjab border
Im a pashtun from Landi kotal shinwari tribe in KPK
Also we pashtuns dont marry outside our tribes so idk what your talking about
@@mrexpress8002 Whos an afghan here. 😂😂😂
im from Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and native
for us pashtuns beinf muslims and pashtun is first. and nationality (pakistani) is second
also no pak or afghan pashtun accepts durrand line
like i said worrt about your own border in India/pak punjab instead of gettinf involeved in ours 😂😂
A nice recap of all the things we learned in class one
Imaginary line to keep one nation apart
Good Job TCM!!
Well explained
Peace fence should be completed at any cost
What peace fence? its a bloody fence
Strange issue, so the King of Afghanistan gave away a massive portion of Afghanistan without consulting Afghans. Who agreed on this shabby deal? And where is the original agreement. Was it in Farsi or Pashto or English?
It would be nice to know if it was an actual border or buffer zone.
@@shuaybx1811 Bhai buffer zone tou Karachi mai hai kia hogga
He is lying, Durand Line has never ever been accepted as an international border and the 1921 treaty of Rawalpindi has cancelled all the previous treaties including the Durand treaty, and the 1921 treaty is a temporary arrangement which could not be cancelled for the first three years and after three years both party can at any time unilaterally cancel the treaty with 12 months binding periode, and the agreement of 1930 is a reconfirmation of the treaty of 1921 and nothing new addition. in 1949 Afghanistan has cancelled the treaty and it has no legal basis whatsoever. this is the text of the as per article below of the treaty of 1921.
Article XIV
The provisions of this treaty shall come into force from the date of its signature, and
shall remain in force for three years from that date. In case neither of the High
Contracting Parties should have notified, twelve months before the expiration of the
said three years, the intention to terminate it, it shall remain binding until the
expiration of one year from the day on which either of the High Contracting Parties
shall have denounced it. This treaty shall come into force after the signatures of the
Missions of the two Parties, and the two ratified copies of this shall be exchanged in
Kabul within 2⅟2 months after the signatures.
Set playback speed to 1.25x.
Thank me later.
I did it, still it was slow, then I set it 1.75 x mager phir bhi isnay boht time zaya kia, boht footage Khai isnay
I think it's much difficulties for people to meet their tribes.
Its kind of absurd. First of All ,what they have,they can't manage it. People migrated to different countries like Pakistan UAE Australia and Europe. They want to acquire more dude first be a nation. Always scattered ,polarized community and divided among war lords with certain ethnicity.
This so-called border shouldn't have been drawn in the first place. Expect more conflicts in the future.
Well I did understand in English but it should be in URDU dubbing so everyone could exactly know in this video
Plz don't add those awful disturbing background music
in the agrement the word Subsidy is written
Great Durrani sahib 👍
Poor knowledge: Zahir shah + daud tried their best destroyed peace, and on several occasions, attacked 😢pakistan
Durand line was signed in 1893 unpto wehn??
Real information
Please dont lie, Durand Line has never ever been accepted as an international border and the 1921 treaty of Rawalpindi has cancelled all the previous treaties including the Durand treaty, and the 1921 treaty is a temporary arrangement which could not be cancelled for the first three years and after three years both party can at any time unilaterally cancel the treaty with 12 months binding periode, and the agreement of 1930 is a reconfirmation of the treaty of 1921 and nothing new addition. in 1949 Afghanistan has cancelled the treaty and it has no legal basis whatsoever. this is the text of the as per article below of the treaty of 1921.
Article XIV
The provisions of this treaty shall come into force from the date of its signature, and
shall remain in force for three years from that date. In case neither of the High
Contracting Parties should have notified, twelve months before the expiration of the
said three years, the intention to terminate it, it shall remain binding until the
expiration of one year from the day on which either of the High Contracting Parties
shall have denounced it. This treaty shall come into force after the signatures of the
Missions of the two Parties, and the two ratified copies of this shall be exchanged in
Kabul within 2⅟2 months after the signatures.
I m from Swat and I don’t recognize Duran line..
Your Masters are gone so all the agreements.. end of story
Although Pak still in the delusion of being Brown Angrez., time is up
The great lie starts at 3:20 -- there is no formal legality of which he speaks, and he fails to mention what the actual disagreement is and why there is disagreement to begin with. This is how they avoid speaking openly and honestly. If Pakistan was truly a nation of muslims with good intentions, the dialogue wouldn't continue in this manner -- everyone knows the fence has nothing to do with narcotics or terrorists (they literally trained the Taliban in Pakistan to then go back to Afghanistan after the US pulled out). This type of two-faced rhetoric simply adds to the same issues of character & credibility of Pakistan on the global stage.
rhetoric cries and always blame Pakistan we r here till doomsday do whatever you can as durrani the ones who founded afghanistan he is proud to be a Pakistani .
Do you care to highlight what the actual disagreement is?
@@baghi536 afghanis being afghani is the actual issue the assholeness is just too much to bear .
You hindoo?
The lie starts when he says it is demarcated inch by inch😂😂😂, first of all Kaalia poomjabakai slave, the Durrand line runs through such a rough difficult terrain that, it was never formally demarcated, as early as 2018 was when the US paid $400 million to Pakistan to demarcate the line based on alliance of Pakistan in the invasion of Afghanistan by US and Pakistan.
The agreement was signed in English and later it was marked based on valley and mountains not by inches as this hypocrite Asad fake Durrani claims.
To this day Pakistan hasn't provided the agreement nor the documentation of demarcation, it is purely taken away by force just like Israel has taken over Palestine 🇵🇸.
There was no agreement with Pakistan and nor was there any self determination rights given to the people of Pakhtunkhwa.
Best Vedio Sir.In English it seems to be more intresting n Understandable..
OH PUnjABEEE
Pakistan got independence lol as if it existed before, the correct line would have been pakistan got created, wonder how many other biased word plays are in this video
This is true actually. It was formation, not independence. In fact, Pakistan has high ethnic tension between each other because of this
@@aurangzeb1618 orange pocket is Sheikh Chilli and Bro even Pakistan name did not existed before british let alone civilization.
@@zyT175 India was already there from centuries , only benstoke pakistan got born ... even the Columbus found US looking for India .
@@zyT175 by your logic there was no country ever existed all were regions ... grow out of this mindset ... do something productive instead of word plays
@@zyT175 the problem with you is you are blind in monsoon all you see is green ... Keyboard warrior history expert . Go do some productive work with you cloudy region textbook
very biased
dukhtar farosh and bachabaz afghani.
TCM abrevation of ?? U an army Senior Sir?
Ended the video After one minute. Dont want to have this topic explained by a Pajeet with pajeet accent lol
This was so boring that I fell asleep after 2
Minutes. Just speak in Urdu please, there are English subtitles. Ap se English boli nahin ja rahi Janab.
Let me correct some facts which is missing in this video. it was not only one aggrement but four. e.g 1879,1893, 1901, and 1919. Afghanistan has no offical claim on KP anywhere. the bitish given subsidy far before the durand line. the subsidy started in 1879 during the Gandamak treaty.
Please dont lie, Durand Line has never ever been accepted as an international border and the 1921 treaty of Rawalpindi has cancelled all the previous treaties including the Durand treaty, and the 1921 treaty is a temporary arrangement which could not be cancelled for the first three years and after three years both party can at any time unilaterally cancel the treaty with 12 months binding periode, and the agreement of 1930 is a reconfirmation of the treaty of 1921 and nothing new addition. in 1949 Afghanistan has cancelled the treaty and it has no legal basis whatsoever. this is the text of the as per article below of the treaty of 1921.
Article XIV
The provisions of this treaty shall come into force from the date of its signature, and
shall remain in force for three years from that date. In case neither of the High
Contracting Parties should have notified, twelve months before the expiration of the
said three years, the intention to terminate it, it shall remain binding until the
expiration of one year from the day on which either of the High Contracting Parties
shall have denounced it. This treaty shall come into force after the signatures of the
Missions of the two Parties, and the two ratified copies of this shall be exchanged in
Kabul within 2⅟2 months after the signatures.
@@EsmatLaarawai-mo8oy 1921 agreement is the not the Durand line agreement but the extension of 1919 Rawalpindi agreement. Afghanistan has never denounced the 1921 agreement till 1947.
Durand line is a dead horse. it's an international border but more interestingly Afghanistan has no official claim on KPK. KPK is part of Pakistan and Pashtuns are proud Pakistani
@@riffatwaniofficial9810 The treaty of Kabul in 1921 is signed because both sides could not come to an agreement on the Durand line and is therefore made an temporary arrangement, which gives both sides the right to cancel the treaty unilaterally at any time, and Afghanistan has used that right to cancel the treaty in 1947, before the establishment of a new neocolonial state named Pakistan for the loyal servants of the British empire as a extra buffer as part of the broader security politics of the leaving British empire against the Communist USSR.
@@riffatwaniofficial9810 It is up to people of both sides of Durand line and Afghanistan to decide thier future, and Afghanistan has never ever recognized the line of Hatred drawn by colonial power, so that is the most important thing is, the opinion of colonial powers around the world and the opinion of Punjabi Establishment in GHQ and the opinion of states that has no affinity with the issue doesnt matter at all.
British have no business in drawing lines and thereby creating everlasting disputes outside its own geographical borders and by that I mean the British Isle.
Chinese has as much claim to reject McMahon line and reclaim Laddakh, Sikkim and Arunachal Pradesh. Same way Afghans have no need to accept Durand Line, that seperates it from it's rightful brother province of KPK. Pakistani pashtuns must realize that it is in their best interest to join fellow Pashtuns than remain second class citizens to Punjabi who reep all the benefits. Bengalis proved it by setting themselves free from oppressive Mullah and Martial Law, establishing their own nation and results speak for themselves. Long live valiant Pashtuns who once ruled over these Punjabis.
Ladakh, Sikkim, Arunachal Pradesh wants to be with India.
British did had business dividing border as they were the rulers. It's upto you to negotiate.
@unknown soldiier You can leave for Afghanistan anyday.
@unknown soldiier Soon brother, these lands will go to where they belong and nations will be reunited.
@@amolkhobaragade the territories of dispute will be taken back by China and India will do nothing, just as they watched with utter humiliation China taking back Pangong Tso, where they are building bridges, as well as villages in Arunachal Pradesh.
But there is a difference. Forget about Indian territories, even Tibet was never part of China till 1950! Neither Tibetans nor Indians ever call themselves Chinese. Whereas Pashtuns never accepted they are Pakistanis. Like China occupied Tibet and other surrounding areas, Pakistanis occupied KP, Balochistan, and Kashmir. Both of these countries are rouge countries always looking to create trouble for others
Me durand line me rshta hon hamary adh se zith reshta dar khost me hain zakheil
افعانستان نے ڈیورنڈ لائن معاہدہ 1893 میں میر عبدالرحمن کی بادشاہت کے دوران طے کیا تھا۔۔۔کیا یہ معلومات درست ہیں؟؟؟
For 100 years
@@freeminder347 Where is it written that agreement was for 100 years ? Please show
دالخور لنگمار کی نسل اپنے کام سے کام
Awful explainer
Divide and Rule is the new colonial policy.
Durand Line Forced Agreement, one part of Afghanistan was leased for 100 years, the lease has been expired long ago 30 years, the Afghan Government has fully right to take his land and take the lease for 30 years with full penalty form the successor government of Pakistan.
But first they have to take govt from talibans
Hahahah wake-up from day dreaming
@Zamary shaker if afghans accept a greater Pakistan then Kabul can be the 5 biggest city in Pakistan.
@@mrexpress8002 you should take permission from your Chinese masters then we will talk.
abayy Qomii zoban urdu ha or tuu to english ma . chalo khairr agli bar urdu ma koshish karo
Pakistan ka koi border b natural nh h.
Punjab ki b to division ki gai thi so hzm kren.
Same with India. Sirf Punjab hi nahi balki Bengal ko bhi divide kiya gaya tha
@@dipanjanmahapatra5258
Dono desh e ajeeb hain.
Insaano ki tarah rhen to kya hi bat h.
Pta nh kb peace prevail hoga
@@SOWProgramming thanks to Angrez. Yaha hamlogo ko divide karke khud socha tha ki duniya mein hukumat karega lekin aaj hamlog hi unke sar ke upar baithe huye hai
@@dipanjanmahapatra5258 no doubt
@@SOWProgramming seriously I wanted to say to my Indian subcontinent brothers and sisters. Do jihad against these goras
The durand line was for lease for 100 years and and pakistan was supposed to pay 20 million afghani yearly like rent and a package such as weapons horses and etc and they never paid that. The lease ended long time ago and the land is supposed to be given back to Afghanistan. If pakistan wants the land they have to pay trillions of dollar to Afghanistan for the land which they never did.
Well its a blatant lie that agreement is for 100 years
If you read original agreement there’s no such thing written in it
So stop the sale pitch because no one’s gonna buy it
@IMD GAMER I AM AFRAID UNLESSS YOU ACCEPT A GREATER PAKISTAN THEN THE BORDER REMAINS. KABUL CAN BE THE 5TH BIGGEST CITY IN PAKISTAN.
Pork
Fencing durand line means dividing afghani and pakistani pakhtuns i am from Orakzai tribe and i am against durand fence bcoz actually every pakhun is afghan
زه دا حيران يم چي پاكستان دشمني إنڈیا سرہ دی خو ليكن بند كوي دي افغانستان بورڈر۔ دا ولی ؟
زندہ باد یو پختون
Do you give guarantee that there will be no terrorists coming to PAK from AFG? Would you take responsibility if illegal Afghans do criminal stuff in our cities?
@@muhammadusama6040 why don’t they fence indian side border. coz they claim india is their worst enemy but with them they are sharing sweets on a good days here on afghan side they are fencing borders that’s really sad and disappointing. coz they don’t have any right to do it. bcoz they didn’t conquered our pakhtun tribal areas they didn’t conquered us. so we will decide for this land. what we want should happen not what they want
@@muhammadusama6040 don’t worry too much about our side. coz when their was drone strikes on our areas at that time where was these people to take stance. when we was being killed by us drone strikes where was our savior napak army. where was our government. where was our just name brother punjab. we don’t have any threat from afghan side don’t worry son too much about us.
@@Randomfunny_47 dude, each and every inch of indian border along with LOC is fenced and guarded. Please verify your knowledge
@@muhammadusama6040 what about kartar pur
DURAND LINE kuf r
PAKISTAN ZINDABAD!
@@mrexpress8002
Pakistan Murdabad
Pakistan got independence lol as if it existed before, the correct line would have been pakistan got created, wonder how many other biased word plays are in this video