This list is really a top individual favorite cover list. This is primarily subjective. The cover was the lure to convince kids to part with their ten coppers. Most are appealing because it is essential for sales. A list of the worst covers would be harder to compile and more interesting.
Great video Sticky 👍🏾. The writer for that article was super “DELUSIONAL” on some of the cover rankings big time 😂. (Some books missed below) •THE CROW 1 •HOUSE OF SECRETS 92 •BATMAN 423 •MANY ZATANNA COVERS PERIOD
Lists are always tough for so many reasons, but there's some great covers here... but when you say greatest, I think historical significance has to come into play, so that imo puts Action Comics at #1(I'll mention my favorite cover as a kid/teen collecting: Uncanny X-Men #268, Cap, Widow and Wolvie by Jim Lee, with the caption together again for the first time)
This has got to be a troll list to drive traffic to their site to complain. Ignoring the crap modern comics listed over classic covers, so many great, iconic covers are ignored completely. Off the top of my head, where is Crime Suspstories #22, Sandman #1, X-Men #251, Love and Rockets #1, Zap #0? I appreciate them including Eightball, but not that issue.
Everyone has their own favorite comic book covers of all time. That list is pretty good, I don't agree with many of those choices, but here's my additions: FF#1, purely for the classic beginnings, Punisher #1 Zeck cover, FF #5 Kirby, Mr miracle #6, Captain America annual #8, legends of the dark knight #23 Bart sears, green lantern#50 parallax. An honorable mention to Dick Tracy for the best comic strips ever, was collected later into a "comic" book, and Modesty Blaise comic strip which was more adults & James bond-ish.
True story about The Walking Dead #19. I had a Robert Kirkman autographed copy I obtained at the Baltimore Comic-Con. Not the comic, the autograph. I took this issue with me because it was the current issue of The Walking Dead. This was back when getting autos was no big deal. You didn't have to pay for a VIP ticket or even pay for the auto. Creators would just sit at a table like a normal person and all you had to do was walk up and ask them for an autograph. There wasn't even a line. Years later I ended up selling this book on eBay. I totally screwed up in how I sent it. I sandwiched it between two pieces of foam board and sent it in a big padded envelope. When the buyer received it, it was bent. I was able to file an insurance claim and I made the buyer whole, but the book was ruined.
Missed too many epic covers from X-men, Black Panther and more. But these are usually just by personal preference. I missed some poison Ivy covers too. Great topic and video, maybe make a video about your personal 100 list!
I thought it was a nice list, but yeah, therre are better (and longer, like 180 covers & more modern takes (80s & after) that belong there. That would make an overly long video though.
My list would annoy most people because I kinda hate most silver and golden age covers. My list would be all modern. It's also why I hate seeing the comic wall of people on TH-cam that's just a bunch of keys. The walls are always the same and a bunch of boring covers. I don't personally understand key collectors and slab collectors for that reason. A lot of first appearances don't even have the character who appears on the cover.
⚠Any sort of 'greatest comic book covers of all time list' without House of Secrets 92 is an immediate red flag. 😁🐀
I love 92! 88 is also amazing :)
Notice they're all "keys".
Batman 1
Batman 171
Batman 189
Batman 227
Swamp thing 37
Infinity gauntlet 1
Asm 3
Af 15
Hulk 340
Those are my favorites
This list is really a top individual favorite cover list. This is primarily subjective. The cover was the lure to convince kids to part with their ten coppers. Most are appealing because it is essential for sales. A list of the worst covers would be harder to compile and more interesting.
Gather some of the biggest covers all time, add some random nothing covers to a randomizer and you have this list.
Great video Sticky 👍🏾. The writer for that article was super “DELUSIONAL” on some of the cover rankings big time 😂. (Some books missed below)
•THE CROW 1
•HOUSE OF SECRETS 92
•BATMAN 423
•MANY ZATANNA COVERS PERIOD
Batman 251, 609
ASM 238
Marvel Spotlight 5
Hulk 340
X-Men 101
@@ScarecrOmega The First Punisher is easily a top 15 🔥🔥🔥
What I'd like to know... are any of these covers iconic? 🤪
Lists are always tough for so many reasons, but there's some great covers here... but when you say greatest, I think historical significance has to come into play, so that imo puts Action Comics at #1(I'll mention my favorite cover as a kid/teen collecting: Uncanny X-Men #268, Cap, Widow and Wolvie by Jim Lee, with the caption together again for the first time)
This has got to be a troll list to drive traffic to their site to complain. Ignoring the crap modern comics listed over classic covers, so many great, iconic covers are ignored completely. Off the top of my head, where is Crime Suspstories #22, Sandman #1, X-Men #251, Love and Rockets #1, Zap #0? I appreciate them including Eightball, but not that issue.
Everyone has their own favorite comic book covers of all time. That list is pretty good, I don't agree with many of those choices, but here's my additions: FF#1, purely for the classic beginnings, Punisher #1 Zeck cover, FF #5 Kirby, Mr miracle #6, Captain America annual #8, legends of the dark knight #23 Bart sears, green lantern#50 parallax. An honorable mention to Dick Tracy for the best comic strips ever, was collected later into a "comic" book, and Modesty Blaise comic strip which was more adults & James bond-ish.
True story about The Walking Dead #19. I had a Robert Kirkman autographed copy I obtained at the Baltimore Comic-Con. Not the comic, the autograph. I took this issue with me because it was the current issue of The Walking Dead. This was back when getting autos was no big deal. You didn't have to pay for a VIP ticket or even pay for the auto. Creators would just sit at a table like a normal person and all you had to do was walk up and ask them for an autograph. There wasn't even a line.
Years later I ended up selling this book on eBay. I totally screwed up in how I sent it. I sandwiched it between two pieces of foam board and sent it in a big padded envelope. When the buyer received it, it was bent. I was able to file an insurance claim and I made the buyer whole, but the book was ruined.
Looks like just one persons opinion. Any info on how this list was derived? I guess I would have to say Nooooooooooooo!
you should do your own top 20 covers that u own in your collection I think that would be a fun one
Supreme Power run is based on the Squadron Supreme its better then then the Boys run in my opinion!
Oh god that was a terrible list. Even Superman 1 didnt make it huh? No Cap Schomberg? No Baker? No Wrightson? wow
i agree with the strange suspense 19 such a rad cover!
I mean no offense to the creator of that list, but it's awful. Also, strange suspense stories 19 isn't an EC book, it's charlton
Missed too many epic covers from X-men, Black Panther and more.
But these are usually just by personal preference. I missed some poison Ivy covers too.
Great topic and video, maybe make a video about your personal 100 list!
Have you guys went over exactly what is a Sticky Goose???
I got Giant size x-men #1 the reprint one. 😀👍
No Spiderman 7 Spiderboy variant!? 😜
That list is fucked. They don't even have the right pictures or issues listed.. lmfao.
chamber of chills 19 has to be my favoirite cover
This list isn't "horrible" it's garbage
Whoever created this was drunk.
And as to that number one choice?!
Do me a favour.
I got X-men #1 the reprint one. 😀👍
I got Spawn #1 the reprint one. 😀👍
I got Acton Comics #1 the facsimile edition. 😀👍
I got Superman #75.😀👍
I thought it was a nice list, but yeah, therre are better (and longer, like 180 covers & more modern takes (80s & after) that belong there. That would make an overly long video though.
I got the uncanny x-men #141 the facsimile edition. 😀👍
Are you from the DUB ???????? Wv?
I got Tales of Suspense #39 the facsimile edition. 😀👍
I got Detective Comic #38 the facsimile edition. 😀👍
This list is terrible I know it’s opinion based but man this list sucks!
FF 48 is overrated and overvalued. Captain America 🇺🇸 1 and Batman # 1 are top 10. Justice League fighting a Starfish is absurd.
That list is a joke!
I got X-men 1991 #1.😀👍
My list would annoy most people because I kinda hate most silver and golden age covers. My list would be all modern. It's also why I hate seeing the comic wall of people on TH-cam that's just a bunch of keys. The walls are always the same and a bunch of boring covers. I don't personally understand key collectors and slab collectors for that reason. A lot of first appearances don't even have the character who appears on the cover.
I got Captain America #1 the reprint one. 😀👍
I got Green Lantern #85 the facsimile edition. 😀👍
I got Flash #123 the facsimile edition. 😀👍
I got Superman #1 the facsimile edition. 😀👍
I got Batman #428.😀👍
I got Batman #1 the facsimile edition. 😀👍
I got the uncanny x-men #232.😀👍
I got the incredible hulk #181 the facsimile edition. 😀👍
ASM 1 is one of the worst covers of all time. I'm already done with this list, it's garbage.
I got The Avengers #1 the facsimile edition. 😀👍
I got The Amazing Spider-man #1 the facsimile edition. 😀👍
I got the incredible hulk #1 the facsimile edition. 😀👍
Definitely wasn't intended to be in order or someone is out of there mind.. sorry man I stopped watching after the 1rst couple minutes 👎
Insane to see a grown man so into comic book covers.
Weird to see a grown man attempting to bully people in TH-cam comments.
I got Batman #497.😀👍
I got Daredevil #181 the facsimile edition. 😀👍