This is a re-upload. I apologize for the inconvenience. Note: From 00:48 to 02:30, the video quality might be low, but at least it's better than having no music at all, plus no copyright issue. Thanks for watching!
Here's are the things in the anime that is faithful to the manga, 1. The future teammates of RWBY became friends similarly the same way in the manga though it wasn't in a huge bedroom. 2. Cinder is barely seen like in the manga. 3. Ruby is as afraid to make friends as in the manga. 4. Weiss Schnee isn't the American version of Sakura Haruno. 5 and this is by far my favourite. Weiss has an emotional black and white (tsundere) approach to Ruby, sometimes she's belittling her for acting like a child and other times she's admiring Ruby for being stupidly caring and brave. 6. Blake accidentally reveals herself in the streets in the daytime.
I’m not gonna lie...I kinda like the old version better considering there’s more fighting and it feels like it moves faster. The new one feels a little exposition heavy and like it’s cutting in on the fighting time. Also, the old one’s camera angles were a little more dynamic during the fighting, but more stagnant during the beginning compared to the new one.
There are two types of people, those who only cares about the fight scene and those who are invested in the lore.... Well i understand your point but both 2d and 3d animation have they're own benefits, 3d motion are done by humans/cgi thus have room for movement but lacks/cost more for details while 2d is easier for designing but is bound to 24-30-60 frames
@@aisuhd I love the lore, don’t get me wrong, but I personally prefer “show, don’t tell.” I always feel like I’m getting spoon fed the information otherwise. I also hate when we, (the watchers), are forced to sit through multiple minutes of dialogue for something that we can pick up from simply being observant. I like when shows treat me with a little more intelligence than a kid’s show, (but even as a child I greatly disliked that so maybe I just like picking it up myself). Sure, I like when a show is explaining an interesting concept that couldn’t really be shown, but especially with this scene all they needed to do was be shown breaking into the train, a shot of the dust, (as we soon learn the importance of, maybe they could use a little in their escape so we have a hint to its true capabilities), and maybe have a short conversation showing their opposing feelings on humans and that the rest of the White Fang will be pleased. That’s all. From that we can pick up a good portion of the information for the future, while also being treated as if we’re peering in on an actual conversation and interaction, rather than being overly explained to even though all present parties already understand and know this information, ya know?
@@aisuhd What lore has the anime showned anyway the og had more lore thanks to the history episodes, everything on the first season was world build up and character development we got to know a little about everyone, on the anime we are expected to know who everyone is so they cut everything lore related and skimmed most of the events fast forward to next arc, they only added extra details on weiss overall and the relation of ruby's family but cut everything else. I will still watch the whole series but overall i aint impress in the writing. i have seen amazing 2d fight scenes in the past this wasnt one of the best but it was servisable it was inconsistent overall sometimes you get really high detail and then randomly drops out of nowhere, most of the shots that were highly detail were pv shots to get viewers hooked in. Something that i didnt like is that they made weiss more of a cry baby then a prideful cold mean girl.
Anime: Is better at setting up the plot and story as well as tweaking the character interactions and dialogue in some really nice ways. Original: Is way better at showing off dynamic and interesting fight choreography as well as having a great soundtrack that gets you hyped.
Its 50 50 in anime ruby was more like she was more experienced and forgot that her weapons is a sniper too with high recoil that can be abused but in OG one she rely one her weapon more and show more that she is weapon expert with that genius recoil control of her weapon.... anime: just gonna use my semblance that i mastered it and fcking slash my enemy OG: im a weapon expert so ill show them how my weapon works
It really drives home what a tragedy losing Monty was. Not saying anime fight scenes were bad, but Monty even dealing with the constraints of the medium he used, and the budget was amazing when you compare them side by side when it came to action.
Sadly the anime version doesn't even come close to the original. The most disappointing thing about it is that it could have if they tried as we see with certain fights like against the borbitusk and the Nevermore. At least have Adam do his Moonslice once like come on bruh. On the positive side, I'm really liking Adam's characterization *way* more than the original. Him letting Blake go to learn about the truth of the world is something I wish that was in the original. Edit: I made this comment before I saw the JoJo edit in the end. You a fool for that. 😂
Adam’s fight scenes getting toned down is understandable. It’s hard to Style in Blade Mode. Cutting his ult tho, that’s low. Blake’s ribbon tho? It has no sense of flow, just floats up to enemies like the ghost dog in Nightmare Before Christmas. And instead of cutting them with boomerang spin, it just…shoots them in the head?? The whole point of rope weapons is a sense of pendulum momentum and that’s completely gone here. It’s just a noodly appendage.
I can see why a lot of people like the original better from an action standpoint, but, in terms of series consistency, the anime did a much better job at keeping things grounded, imo. Adam feels like an actual character and Blake's unease throughout is much clearer, rather the wtf moment of her leaving in the original. The biggest thing that the anime got right, though, is the exclusion of the giant mech robot. Sure, it looks cool as hell and Adam gets to show off Moonslice, but we never see this type of weapon again, when Atlas sure could've used something like it during Salem's attacks.
I know many like the fight sequences and will be disappointed with the anime adaptation, but I honestly don't care about the fights. Sure, they're cool and flashy, but that means little in comparison to the story, which is what I want this anime to improve.
@@kant.68 Well, if you watch the original you'll understand, its a Weiss's Company train, in that train has dust which is the most important things for weapon like some gun powders. That's why there are so many robots guarded that train, to make sure nobody can steal it or ran away from there alive Sorry for the grammars, and English mistakes
I'm thinking it's something to show later. Perhaps they thought it'd be more of a surprise for later in the series. If they ever come back to him. Just my thoughts though.
Think of it in a Ice Queendom Standpoint, showing off Moonslice in the First Episode will only show him as some badass OP character, now showing him do that in later Season will make the effect greater because that will show Team RWBY what an Actual Menace he is
Gotta love how people on the internet become a pro fight choreographer from nostalgic anime-like series they used to watch. Granted, the original actually has better fight choreography, but did you all have ever thought of how would you animated alll that crazy shit in hand drawn animation.
I was looking for this comment. And I'd just like to add that there is also a budget to consider and it's this very reason I believe the fandoms of both versions of rwby are criticizing the shows a bit unfairly.
it's because the orignal's fight scenes are what made rwby a good show (or atleast only at season 1) without those great choreography, anime rwby just feels like just a mid anime
2D hand drawn animate can make cool fight too. (example: Cowboy Bebop But Monty's fighting action really hard to remake by hand drawn or they didn't have enough time and money to made. Trust me, being one of INB member drawing these just full of PaiN.
If there's one thing that genuinely fell flat for me with these first few episodes of the anime, it's the way they animated Blake's whip actions. Everything else was on a scale of 'fine' to 'cool', but the way Blake's gun just seemed to float between shots absolutely did not work for me. That said, I definitely still enjoyed the anime thus far, and highly anticipate that it will switch gears from this point forward with original content that - one can hope - will have more flair and effort put into it. The first three episodes are clearly intended as quick 'let's get this part out of the way' setup. I'm interested to see just how AU this gets following the Nightmares.
I feel like ufotable the only studio that could’ve translated the camera movements and choreography into 2d with the way they animate, for lots of crazy stuff they have their in house cg team pretty much make the cg area or whatever and have these like cg dummy’s fighting each other in that space then hand it off to the animators who pretty much animate over it and like like like it’s kinda like rotoscope animation in a way idk I’m bad at explaining but hopefully you get the point lmao
How did the anime completely miss the point of the original scenes? Like the end of seeing the train stopping and his response was nice it added without diminishing what was there already. Give me scenes like that. As for the fights itself, we LITERALLY see Blake standing still just shooting inanimate object that may as well be the wall without it feeling like there is a sense of speed. The original felt fast and powerful, anime felt clunky. Also HOW THE FUCK DO YOU GET RID OF ADAMS MOMENT VS SPIDER TANK. The small one line back and forth as the train speeds away was ok, doesn't feel too bad though I would have preferred having Adam being more cold in that delivery.
Monty's choreography would be hard to adapt into 2d while still keeping the fast-paced energy the originals had that made them spectacles to watch, IQ also crammed the character trailers and volume 1 into 3 episodes which meant plenty of moments had to be skipped over for the new stuff
@@boyscodon909 Studio Shaft doesn't really focus on the fighting sequences with a lot of their animes since they focus on the slice-of-life aspects, which is why I was hoping that Ufotable would animate RWBY cuz they use 3D and offers a LOT of their budget to the fighting scenes
Understandable that they couldnt go Full Sakuga for all the fights Like they've done with Ruby's, Weiss's and The Nevermore fight- (2d takes hell of a lot more time to get done than 3d especially high quality Sakuga scenes) especially since i assume ep. 1-3 were all basically a recap + more character building to what we already know- before the new Plot Starts up BUT Yeah that part with Blake throwing the her gun and shooting the robots was - Painfully Bad -
Man, people need to understand. 3D, with average budget and a good animator, will produce a good 3d animation with a good flow. 2D with average budget and a good animator, will still not produce the same standard as 3D in terms of flow It is useless to compare both because 2D is being restricted by the frames they have to make. 2D doesn't have 3D freedom for making continuous animation flow. You can't demand a animation flow like a 3D into a 2D without giving a high budget which means more frames to make. The detailed 2D animation you have seen either have high budget to make from frames or they mix 3D and blend it into 2D.
My biggest issue and complaint is that this completely ruins/gets rid of the build up and surprise of Blake being a Faunus. Like in the OG you can figure it out, but it never straight up says that they are Faunus, or that that was White Fang operations, So in the later scene when she says "We" It can really hit you with a surprise. But in the anime it makes it very clear that she is a Faunus and that they are White Fang.
Adam was always treated like trash, but this is just setting the man's grave on fire at this point. His voice is rather deep, and maybe it's because I'm too used to his original voice (it was kinda...rough, to begin with) but this just makes him sound like a old wise guy.
I gotta be honest with you guys, the new anime is good. However, the fighting some of them are missing and it feels slow unlike the original. I could wait for more episodes to see where the anime going but my expectations didn't exceed it purpose
they noticeably relying on cool aesthetic but unclear with the choreography, the opposite of the original. The anime is only good with its story and its aesthetic but it's even mid at best compared to new animes in general
@@zaidanhakim4974 "only good with it's story and aesthetic" Isn't that what makes anime... Well.. Anime? Animating 1 minute fight scene take a lot of time with 2D animation Not that i'm putting down monty's work He's absolutely amazing but it's a lil bit unfair to compare it like that Eventho the anime has a studio and a lot of people to animate it,it still has limited budget, deadline, etc meanwhile monty is doing it for fun
I think people should stop comparing the original to the new series. Because this whole new RWBY series is going on different path. That's why they cut some scenes from the original
ok if we do that then does it stand on its own, if you watched this show without prior knowlegde of the og do you think it was good overall, forget everything you knew from the og even the characters that you knew, come with a fresh mind, then watch it again.(do not fill in the gaps with the prior knowlegde that you knew the characters) The show expected you to watch the og to know the characters beforehand so its inevitable for the comparison. Any new viewer would be confused and lost as this whole pacing feels rushed and mashed together with no cohesive story.
@@rationaldemon195 not really, it explains about as much of the world as the original did, they just cut out a lot of jokes and some scenes that don’t add much to the plot, like Jaune getting bullied.
@@ethanmaloney3438 grim, dust aplication, dust usage, dust marketing, semblance, aura, faunas in general, the black market, teachers, principal, the school to name a few that was skipped so far we get a say that exist but not much detail on how it worked or where it was obtained or how it was discovered or how they interacted with it, i mean we get some exposition on john about semblance activation but that was practicly skipped and said activation on the end, they can skipped jaune if they liked to but because there was not really any build up for juane, the power of friendship felt unimpactfull with the reveal of the nightmare grim. Also they are keeping the fact that descrimation on faunas exist but no history about why it happened in the first place or any events of that happening yet so far or how it even started, i know people can claim they can reedeem this part but they didn't had to rush this much content in the first place they can deviate as far as they like but the things that they remove and add don't add any context without the og knowledge. I mean its easy for you to fill in the gaps but you should asked why did the conflict happened in the first place when watching this in a fresh mind.
I’m not gonna lie I don’t like the new anime I will admit the art looks very clean very crisp but I don’t like how they’re cutting out a lot of the scenes from the original especially for this specific episode how they almost completely removed the majority of Adams fight in the trailer especially his signature move moon slice, though I will admit I do prefer the ending of this where it actually shows Adam saying let Blake figure out her own path and to see how cruel the world truly is and so that she will know in the end that the white fang was correct with the path they chose
Facts, this new version COMPLETELY butchered alot of the scenes from the original. Not to mention the pacing is not there at all and we never got to the school
@@mastertjt56 reminder that we this part is only a clip of an entire episode instead of its own stand alone trailer and 2d animation it's way harder to work with in comparison to 3d so ofcorse the original black trailer will have more fighting Not to mention they also had to animate weiss's fight in the anime version at the same time it's like Making the white trailer and the black trailer in one episode
@@pokeymaster9415 I love how the lot of you go for the "it's harder to animate" excuse. Both 3D and 2D are hard to animate and master. They have their own strengths and weaknesses, you guys need to stop with the excuses. If they wanted it to be done right then they should've taken a slower pace instead of trying to rush to the new content
@@mastertjt56 Its not an excuse when that’s how it works? 2D animation is much harder and more expensive, both monetarily and time-wise. The studio has to pick and choose what to adapt, what to change, and what scenes get the most focus within a set schedule. They were paid to do a 12 episode tv anime with an original story that diverges away from the original RoosterTeeth production. If you’ve seen how 99% of anime is animated, you’ll see that Ice Queendom is doing nothing out of the ordinary. If it was Studio Orange, the new anime would’ve been in made with 3D animation in mind, but I’m sure they were too busy with the new Trigun anime. All in all, if you want RWBY with a focus on fights and character moments, the original is way better in terms of that up until the end of Vol 3 and then it goes downhill. Seeing as this is written by Gen Urobuchi, fights and those same character moments won’t be the focus, but the narrative will. I have full faith in him seeing as he’s written Madoka Magica, Psycho-Pass and Saya no Uta, all of which have a masterful narrative. Just keep an eye on it and give it a try once it’s all said and done.
@@BlackGrailKiara Okay, I'll admit this. Production of 2D animation with the budget for a 12 episode length tv anime series with the limitations of having to closely follow the original storyline of Rooster Teeth's productions with it's own original narrative and moreso is quite difficult, especially having to adapt a 3d model animation into a 2d, hand-drawn product. Following this? Awesome. The circumstances are far from similar. Monty Oum- Bless him- Had not only to create an entirely original story, but build the foundations for it all and actually make sense of it while steering the narrative into the direction he wants it to take. Icequeedom is moreso a recreation- Meant to evoke what makes RWBY what it is while also trying to flesh out the narrative. The issue with 3d- Here's an example to one of RWBY's VOL 1 faults- modeling. It was the impotence of the world itself. Populated, designated areas brimming with life was anything but, the city of Vale and the students at beacon themselves were there but not given anything at all to make their inclusion have substance. Characters were usually literal shadow model depictions with no identifying feature's to the extent calling them nobodies were a kind mercy, large crowds of characters usually occupy the backgrounds even using the models of pre-existing characters like when Ozpin made his speech or in Beacon's locker room. They did nothing to expand the world. They were included to make it not feel lifeless but the difficulties and folly's of 3d animations reared its head. In other words, this: Icequeedom fixes this issue. Ruby has explained during her trip to the City of Vale the nature of Remnants' technological advancement by showcasing it. People(Who at least looked basic) crowded the streets of Vale, stop lights were in the form of a somewhat interactive, digital screen. Ruby explored shops, a cafe and even shown advanced technology and architecture and shown exactly what they were capable of. Students of Beacon acknowledged Pyhrra's existence with unveiled awe and respect in the locker rooms as homage to her status as Mistral's annual tournament winner and fame. The interactions between Ruby, Yang and their family they're leaving behind and even showcasing Ruby speaking to Summer's grave to explain her character motivations at the start are also other great examples of their differences. Now. Sorry for derailing the argument, but in conclusion: The difference between the animation styles is staggering. They take a long time to improve upon and master like any form of art. One may seem "easier" than the other but remember the differences and variables in production's budget, staff, styles, writing and the work itself. The original showcased the conception of everything they wanted to include in order to flesh out their world but needed a spinoff to attempt to convey it properly. Icequeedom's development is no easier or harder than OG RWBY'S. IQD needed to create new things and expand upon the foundations of concepts the original couldn't. Hell, the original needed to create the world in question and how everything worked anyways, something IQD doesn't. IQD needed exposition to explain some parts of the world the OG show left behind for fight scenes or because they feeded the viewers all we needed to know, not what we wanted. The chorography and framework is more solid I the original but animating some of their fast paced action sequences two for two or even comedy bits wasn't possible so they improvised. The dialogue, the interactions and progression- let alone the things I'm not mentioning are all different. It's unjust to compare two drastically different things. One only has an abridged version of like what, 12 episodes+ two trailers. Man.
It's sad the amount of people that just walk in with predijuce, some are so biased it's obvious they have never seen any anime, or heard of SHAFT. The simplistic artstyle coupled with the stellar motion of the animation, with consistent designs is why SHAFT is actually a perfect choice for this. IS anyone stupid enough to compare ANYONE to Monty? It's actually an insult. Monty was a prodigy, a one in million. Comparing people with passion to his standards just to please your greedy eyes is selfish. I think SHAFT did justice to the fights that NEEDED it in context of the anime. One's that were watered down or not included hardly served any purpose other than being cool.
3d is made in 3d space and 2d in 2d space, if fans would understand a little bit of this, they'll know how hard it is to do dynamic camera angles for every fight scene. Background is not the problem, it can be done in 3d, but matching 2d characters with it require immense work and more frames. The main budget went into Ruby vs White Fang fight, and it looks gorgeous. But moving forward, fans would have less to complain about because anime story would take original path, so no more fights scenes to compare to.
How is it predijuce when they watched it, also the standard of 2d fights wasnt amazing even on 2d standard, there are plenty of works that done 2d fights that were amazing, the budget was wasted on pv trailer shots which increased the expectation that the anime was going to looked like the pv but was unable to deliver. I mean even a newcomer who came in and didn't watch rwby og wouldn't be invested on this, the story was non-existant and everything was rushed you are expected to watch the og to enjoy the show in the first place. Either your standards are super low or haven't watched enough shows to see others works.
@@rationaldemon195 I don't know what else you're expecting. The fights were good. If you're comparing it best selling manga adaptations, then it makes no sense since those have higher budget. Also don't forget it's not only the animation that makes it a masterpiece. Take Madoka Magica for example, one of the best works of Studio Shaft. The animation quality was meme worthy at the time of airing, but after it got praise, not only it got sequel, but also remake as 2 movies with higher budget. And it's only been 3 episodes, and there are atleast 3 animation sequences which I already love. Maybe it's not upto your taste, but it doesn't make the fight scenes bad.
@@SahilKumar-zp8fx I had no expectations when watching the show, i was more curious to see where it was going and overall it was a underwhelming project maybe you have lower standards but i didn't enjoyed it so far, im being reasonable here by treating it as a independent work but even then, it managed to screw that up, if you were to show anyone who hasn't watched rwby before do you honestly think they would enjoy these 3 episodes so far, be honest with me. I only hear fanboism on shaft which is pretty biased imho. Maybe you should watch other works too and question yourself why was this anime good so far. Shit is shit may have nice colors but its still shit.
monty is not a deity. it is totally possible for other people to make good, or even better fight scenes. its not "unfair" to compare the anime to the original just because monty didn't make it. expecting a good fuckin fight scene isn't being "prejudiced"
It feels like old action scenes in movies where it's *supposed* to look like the person is moving super fast and alot is happening but in reality, it's just one person moving while everyone else stands there looking dumbfounded. Best example of this would be the Sarlac pit scene from star wars with the big flip into catching the saber. Like it comes off as this clunky motion
Please do understand that dynamic fight scenes like Monty's might as well be impossible for a 2D anime. They can be done, but not on the budgeted time and money given to a show's production.
@@KnightOfZero00 yes I do understand that you can't translate 1:1 choreography from a 3d animation to a 2d anime but just bc it is very difficult to do doesn't change the fact that it's objectively bad. If you are willing to compromise as much as they did in terms of fluidity of movement they might as well try a completely different approach. What they ended up doing is just bad
Reminder that one of these are it's own exclusive trailer while the other is just 1/5 of an entire episode the animators had to work on so OFCORSE the standalone 3d trailer will have more fighting
Anyone else a little annoyed this just up and spoils that Blake is Faunus? “MAYBE WE WERE JUST TIRED OF BEING PUSHED AROUND!” is supposed to come way out of left field and be a big surprise
Another thing you have to do RWBY: IQ HAVE GOOD FIGHT CHOREOGRAPHY AND GREAT CAMERA ANGLES AND IT WOULDN'T HURT TO SLOW DOWN A LITTLE DURING A FIGHT WHEN A LOT OF COOL THINGS HAPPEN( it depends if they could come up with cool things to do like CRWBY did. Even when Monty died RIP they still had amazing stuff to do in fights) I loved the old one before around Volume 6 after that my love for the series practically dropped low. I want this RWBY to survive and I want to love it so Japanese people GIVE IT YOUR ALL WHERE EVER YOU ARE
You guys talking about how the OG RWBY's fights are better, but ignoring that said OG fights were during the time Monty was alive and made those fights. Those were essentially the best parts of RWBY that we don't get anymore. Of course, those will be better.
I don’t exactly like that the anime version reveals Blake’s Faunus heritage so soon. I haven’t watched it yet, but a huge part of the story telling us that you’re supposed to learn she’s a Faunus alongside the other characters. I’m all for more plot but I just can’t get over that detail. Also, the action in the anime can’t even be compared to the original. A big thing about the scene was the combination of the action and the music, not the plot. It was so mysterious. Idk, I guess I’m just disappointed.
God that's cliche, like everything, and the fights have no punch at all, look at 1:55 when Blake throw her gun, in anime it look like a magic pistol that move however you want and shoot, in RT it look SO much better, it isn't used to shoot closer but to trip and stab at a distance, being an effective support to Adam, the only moment the anime is looking nice is for a miserable second or two when Blake is killing robots at the begenning and it ends when she use her uzi
Well, the anime version is getting more and more disappointing. Shame too. It does have some nice scenes but it’s missing the point of the original that long time fans loved so much. And it’s a simple rule; “Less talky, more smashy!”
People complaining that the anime cut out Adam vs the spider Tank and didn't do some of the action justice. Boy am i glad i ripped my heart out and crushed it ages again so that i couldn’t give less of a shit about this kind of stuff. Yes i will agree the action scene isn’ t as good as in the Black Trailer, but from a writing standpoint, this blows the Black trailer out of the water in every way possible. Not only does Adam feel way more consistent here than in the series, letting his obsession for Blake be much more subtle than it coming right the fuck out of nowhere in the original, But Blake’s heal turn also feels allot more earned this time around. Feels allot more in character than last time.
They cut out the meat and potatoes of the whole scene that got people hooked on the first place. The material is there to use, not much issues to solve other than the minor ones. The personal trailers were made to show off the characters and their abilities. Which they fell short of this anime. I've notice they even cut corners for basic fight encounters. Like oh there's an explosion over there then they cut to elsewhere then cut back to the scene of engagement when it's all over. It feels cheap. It's like they build up to expect something then don't deliver. It kinda half hearted. After so long the series is pretty much dead not many care much for it anymore. It wasn't the show it was the people who ran the show after Monty died...
Huh, well it's easily the best of the trailer remakes since for half the runtime time it's better(getting to the fight area and after the fight) and half the runtime time it's worse(all the fights) than the original. I'm not really taking into account the ears/bow reveal being spoiled since the implications matter to the long term story not the trailer itself, also ignoring the dialogue quality since on the one hand voice acting in the original was awful, but on the other hand the writing for the train scene in the remake felt really unnecessary and forced, making it feel like she's trying to figure out whether he's an idiot and doesn't realize people could get hurt or if he doesn't care(both reasons to bail, so like she's just trying to find an excuse to leave), instead of like she's gauging whether he sounds like he could be dissuaded from doing it
So far, the anime version fight scene feels generic. everyone fights like they are the same person with different weapons, unlike in the original where everyone has their unique fighting style. Every movement has more momentum and every hit feels impactful. The anime version is just run and slash or shoot.
Ugh, I've said it once, I'll said it a thousand times. I HATE ANIME DIALOGUE! IT IS SO FUCKING... LACKING IN SUBTLETY! I'm completely sticking with the original because it showed off things by being little in dialogue that still gets to the point with just Show and Not Tell. I'm probably a little annoyed but still.
shit the anime looks so much better it's choreography is WAAAYYY better and the attacks dont look like they are weak and looking at the original is hard on my eyes after seeing the anime version
since when ppl come to rwby for plots ? i came to rwby 'cause of dead fantasy lol ppl keep crying about budget this budget that if u can't adapt an og series with respect then don't fuking touch it for ppl keep saying 2d cant make fight scene good, try to watch Fog Hill of Five Elements first 3 chapters of IQ is boring and plain af, nothing can deny that
This is a re-upload. I apologize for the inconvenience.
Note: From 00:48 to 02:30, the video quality might be low, but at least it's better than having no music at all, plus no copyright issue. Thanks for watching!
Here's are the things in the anime that is faithful to the manga,
1. The future teammates of RWBY became friends similarly the same way in the manga though it wasn't in a huge bedroom.
2. Cinder is barely seen like in the manga.
3. Ruby is as afraid to make friends as in the manga.
4. Weiss Schnee isn't the American version of Sakura Haruno.
5 and this is by far my favourite. Weiss has an emotional black and white (tsundere) approach to Ruby, sometimes she's belittling her for acting like a child and other times she's admiring Ruby for being stupidly caring and brave.
6. Blake accidentally reveals herself in the streets in the daytime.
I’m not gonna lie...I kinda like the old version better considering there’s more fighting and it feels like it moves faster. The new one feels a little exposition heavy and like it’s cutting in on the fighting time. Also, the old one’s camera angles were a little more dynamic during the fighting, but more stagnant during the beginning compared to the new one.
Agreed if only there's a way to mix both of them together
No one can beat monty’s fight animation
There are two types of people, those who only cares about the fight scene and those who are invested in the lore....
Well i understand your point but both 2d and 3d animation have they're own benefits, 3d motion are done by humans/cgi thus have room for movement but lacks/cost more for details while 2d is easier for designing but is bound to 24-30-60 frames
@@aisuhd
I love the lore, don’t get me wrong, but I personally prefer “show, don’t tell.” I always feel like I’m getting spoon fed the information otherwise. I also hate when we, (the watchers), are forced to sit through multiple minutes of dialogue for something that we can pick up from simply being observant. I like when shows treat me with a little more intelligence than a kid’s show, (but even as a child I greatly disliked that so maybe I just like picking it up myself). Sure, I like when a show is explaining an interesting concept that couldn’t really be shown, but especially with this scene all they needed to do was be shown breaking into the train, a shot of the dust, (as we soon learn the importance of, maybe they could use a little in their escape so we have a hint to its true capabilities), and maybe have a short conversation showing their opposing feelings on humans and that the rest of the White Fang will be pleased. That’s all. From that we can pick up a good portion of the information for the future, while also being treated as if we’re peering in on an actual conversation and interaction, rather than being overly explained to even though all present parties already understand and know this information, ya know?
@@aisuhd What lore has the anime showned anyway the og had more lore thanks to the history episodes, everything on the first season was world build up and character development we got to know a little about everyone, on the anime we are expected to know who everyone is so they cut everything lore related and skimmed most of the events fast forward to next arc, they only added extra details on weiss overall and the relation of ruby's family but cut everything else. I will still watch the whole series but overall i aint impress in the writing.
i have seen amazing 2d fight scenes in the past this wasnt one of the best but it was servisable it was inconsistent overall sometimes you get really high detail and then randomly drops out of nowhere, most of the shots that were highly detail were pv shots to get viewers hooked in.
Something that i didnt like is that they made weiss more of a cry baby then a prideful cold mean girl.
Anime: Is better at setting up the plot and story as well as tweaking the character interactions and dialogue in some really nice ways.
Original: Is way better at showing off dynamic and interesting fight choreography as well as having a great soundtrack that gets you hyped.
Well said
Its 50 50 in anime ruby was more like she was more experienced and forgot that her weapons is a sniper too with high recoil that can be abused but in OG one she rely one her weapon more and show more that she is weapon expert with that genius recoil control of her weapon.... anime: just gonna use my semblance that i mastered it and fcking slash my enemy
OG: im a weapon expert so ill show them how my weapon works
@crystalblade13 only in that part tho, it fell pretty quickly. They can't match monty's fighting scenes
I would add "anime: so exposition heavy you sometimes feel as if beeing beaten by the book"
It really drives home what a tragedy losing Monty was. Not saying anime fight scenes were bad, but Monty even dealing with the constraints of the medium he used, and the budget was amazing when you compare them side by side when it came to action.
Sadly the anime version doesn't even come close to the original. The most disappointing thing about it is that it could have if they tried as we see with certain fights like against the borbitusk and the Nevermore.
At least have Adam do his Moonslice once like come on bruh.
On the positive side, I'm really liking Adam's characterization *way* more than the original. Him letting Blake go to learn about the truth of the world is something I wish that was in the original.
Edit: I made this comment before I saw the JoJo edit in the end. You a fool for that. 😂
I totally agree.
(But they didn't made Moonslice I kinda disappointed too.
Hope they will make him better not a toxic ex bf
Adam’s fight scenes getting toned down is understandable. It’s hard to Style in Blade Mode. Cutting his ult tho, that’s low.
Blake’s ribbon tho? It has no sense of flow, just floats up to enemies like the ghost dog in Nightmare Before Christmas. And instead of cutting them with boomerang spin, it just…shoots them in the head?? The whole point of rope weapons is a sense of pendulum momentum and that’s completely gone here. It’s just a noodly appendage.
I can see why a lot of people like the original better from an action standpoint, but, in terms of series consistency, the anime did a much better job at keeping things grounded, imo. Adam feels like an actual character and Blake's unease throughout is much clearer, rather the wtf moment of her leaving in the original.
The biggest thing that the anime got right, though, is the exclusion of the giant mech robot. Sure, it looks cool as hell and Adam gets to show off Moonslice, but we never see this type of weapon again, when Atlas sure could've used something like it during Salem's attacks.
I know many like the fight sequences and will be disappointed with the anime adaptation, but I honestly don't care about the fights. Sure, they're cool and flashy, but that means little in comparison to the story, which is what I want this anime to improve.
@@shirayukix2155 Action is a part of narrative.
We don’t even know why tf all those robots are there in the first place
@@kant.68 Well, if you watch the original you'll understand, its a Weiss's Company train, in that train has dust which is the most important things for weapon like some gun powders.
That's why there are so many robots guarded that train, to make sure nobody can steal it or ran away from there alive
Sorry for the grammars, and English mistakes
@@kant.68 Actually we do lol
They really did him dirty, did they really hate Adam that much that they cut out the most awesome semblance show off in all of Rwby.
I'm thinking it's something to show later. Perhaps they thought it'd be more of a surprise for later in the series. If they ever come back to him. Just my thoughts though.
We didn't even expect Adam here
Not as much as Rooster Teeth hates him lol
At least they let he have better lines.
In Blake's nightmare he really looks like a cool bad ass villain.
Think of it in a Ice Queendom Standpoint, showing off Moonslice in the First Episode will only show him as some badass OP character, now showing him do that in later Season will make the effect greater because that will show Team RWBY what an Actual Menace he is
Like they made a few alterations to the dialogue that Adam's main motivation is ego and spite to those who he sees to have wronged him.
Gotta love how people on the internet become a pro fight choreographer from nostalgic anime-like series they used to watch. Granted, the original actually has better fight choreography, but did you all have ever thought of how would you animated alll that crazy shit in hand drawn animation.
I was looking for this comment. And I'd just like to add that there is also a budget to consider and it's this very reason I believe the fandoms of both versions of rwby are criticizing the shows a bit unfairly.
it's because the orignal's fight scenes are what made rwby a good show (or atleast only at season 1) without those great choreography, anime rwby just feels like just a mid anime
2D hand drawn animate can make cool fight too.
(example: Cowboy Bebop
But Monty's fighting action really hard to remake by hand drawn or they didn't have enough time and money to made.
Trust me, being one of INB member drawing these just full of PaiN.
If there's one thing that genuinely fell flat for me with these first few episodes of the anime, it's the way they animated Blake's whip actions. Everything else was on a scale of 'fine' to 'cool', but the way Blake's gun just seemed to float between shots absolutely did not work for me.
That said, I definitely still enjoyed the anime thus far, and highly anticipate that it will switch gears from this point forward with original content that - one can hope - will have more flair and effort put into it. The first three episodes are clearly intended as quick 'let's get this part out of the way' setup. I'm interested to see just how AU this gets following the Nightmares.
Do they release 3 episodes every week or.. I haven't watch the OG so I kinda liked the anime
I feel like ufotable the only studio that could’ve translated the camera movements and choreography into 2d with the way they animate, for lots of crazy stuff they have their in house cg team pretty much make the cg area or whatever and have these like cg dummy’s fighting each other in that space then hand it off to the animators who pretty much animate over it and like like like it’s kinda like rotoscope animation in a way idk I’m bad at explaining but hopefully you get the point lmao
did they also skip showing blake's semblance?
How did the anime completely miss the point of the original scenes? Like the end of seeing the train stopping and his response was nice it added without diminishing what was there already. Give me scenes like that.
As for the fights itself, we LITERALLY see Blake standing still just shooting inanimate object that may as well be the wall without it feeling like there is a sense of speed.
The original felt fast and powerful, anime felt clunky.
Also HOW THE FUCK DO YOU GET RID OF ADAMS MOMENT VS SPIDER TANK.
The small one line back and forth as the train speeds away was ok, doesn't feel too bad though I would have preferred having Adam being more cold in that delivery.
Monty's choreography would be hard to adapt into 2d while still keeping the fast-paced energy the originals had that made them spectacles to watch, IQ also crammed the character trailers and volume 1 into 3 episodes which meant plenty of moments had to be skipped over for the new stuff
@@Delta21OnYT lol try to watch fog hill of five element
maybe they can't be done like Monty, but they didn't even try to make it good
@@boyscodon909 Studio Shaft doesn't really focus on the fighting sequences with a lot of their animes since they focus on the slice-of-life aspects, which is why I was hoping that Ufotable would animate RWBY cuz they use 3D and offers a LOT of their budget to the fighting scenes
Understandable that they couldnt go Full Sakuga for all the fights Like they've done with Ruby's, Weiss's and The Nevermore fight- (2d takes hell of a lot more time to get done than 3d especially high quality Sakuga scenes)
especially since i assume ep. 1-3 were all basically a recap + more character building to what we already know- before the new Plot Starts up
BUT Yeah that part with Blake throwing the her gun and shooting the robots was - Painfully Bad -
Yea the anime can't make justice to the trailer, but at least it was good
Man, people need to understand.
3D, with average budget and a good animator, will produce a good 3d animation with a good flow.
2D with average budget and a good animator, will still not produce the same standard as 3D in terms of flow
It is useless to compare both because 2D is being restricted by the frames they have to make. 2D doesn't have 3D freedom for making continuous animation flow.
You can't demand a animation flow like a 3D into a 2D without giving a high budget which means more frames to make.
The detailed 2D animation you have seen either have high budget to make from frames or they mix 3D and blend it into 2D.
My biggest issue and complaint is that this completely ruins/gets rid of the build up and surprise of Blake being a Faunus. Like in the OG you can figure it out, but it never straight up says that they are Faunus, or that that was White Fang operations, So in the later scene when she says "We" It can really hit you with a surprise. But in the anime it makes it very clear that she is a Faunus and that they are White Fang.
After a few seconds i thought Adam sounds quite familiar…
ah yes, Adam Bucciarati
Adam was always treated like trash, but this is just setting the man's grave on fire at this point.
His voice is rather deep, and maybe it's because I'm too used to his original voice (it was kinda...rough, to begin with) but this just makes him sound like a old wise guy.
I gotta be honest with you guys, the new anime is good. However, the fighting some of them are missing and it feels slow unlike the original. I could wait for more episodes to see where the anime going but my expectations didn't exceed it purpose
they noticeably relying on cool aesthetic but unclear with the choreography, the opposite of the original. The anime is only good with its story and its aesthetic but it's even mid at best compared to new animes in general
@@zaidanhakim4974 "only good with it's story and aesthetic"
Isn't that what makes anime... Well.. Anime?
Animating 1 minute fight scene take a lot of time with 2D animation
Not that i'm putting down monty's work
He's absolutely amazing but it's a lil bit unfair to compare it like that
Eventho the anime has a studio and a lot of people to animate it,it still has limited budget, deadline, etc meanwhile monty is doing it for fun
@@varrel434 Was*
In both instances, Adam can still make the jump...
Honestly, you don't need to choose just one. Let's watch both of them. It will give compliment.
I think people should stop comparing the original to the new series. Because this whole new RWBY series is going on different path. That's why they cut some scenes from the original
ok if we do that then does it stand on its own, if you watched this show without prior knowlegde of the og do you think it was good overall, forget everything you knew from the og even the characters that you knew, come with a fresh mind, then watch it again.(do not fill in the gaps with the prior knowlegde that you knew the characters)
The show expected you to watch the og to know the characters beforehand so its inevitable for the comparison. Any new viewer would be confused and lost as this whole pacing feels rushed and mashed together with no cohesive story.
@@rationaldemon195 not really, it explains about as much of the world as the original did, they just cut out a lot of jokes and some scenes that don’t add much to the plot, like Jaune getting bullied.
@@ethanmaloney3438 grim, dust aplication, dust usage, dust marketing, semblance, aura, faunas in general, the black market, teachers, principal, the school to name a few that was skipped so far we get a say that exist but not much detail on how it worked or where it was obtained or how it was discovered or how they interacted with it, i mean we get some exposition on john about semblance activation but that was practicly skipped and said activation on the end, they can skipped jaune if they liked to but because there was not really any build up for juane, the power of friendship felt unimpactfull with the reveal of the nightmare grim.
Also they are keeping the fact that descrimation on faunas exist but no history about why it happened in the first place or any events of that happening yet so far or how it even started, i know people can claim they can reedeem this part but they didn't had to rush this much content in the first place they can deviate as far as they like but the things that they remove and add don't add any context without the og knowledge. I mean its easy for you to fill in the gaps but you should asked why did the conflict happened in the first place when watching this in a fresh mind.
@@ethanmaloney3438
Jaime getting bullied literally is the whole arc of the character, tf you saying?
And RWBY is an action-fantasy show with comedy
Don't tell me they skipped the spider droid part
Well that’s a shame that u had to reupload
It’s still cool that u made comparisons
I’m not gonna lie I don’t like the new anime I will admit the art looks very clean very crisp but I don’t like how they’re cutting out a lot of the scenes from the original especially for this specific episode how they almost completely removed the majority of Adams fight in the trailer especially his signature move moon slice, though I will admit I do prefer the ending of this where it actually shows Adam saying let Blake figure out her own path and to see how cruel the world truly is and so that she will know in the end that the white fang was correct with the path they chose
Facts, this new version COMPLETELY butchered alot of the scenes from the original. Not to mention the pacing is not there at all and we never got to the school
@@mastertjt56 reminder that we this part is only a clip of an entire episode instead of its own stand alone trailer and 2d animation it's way harder to work with in comparison to 3d so ofcorse the original black trailer will have more fighting
Not to mention they also had to animate weiss's fight in the anime version at the same time it's like Making the white trailer and the black trailer in one episode
@@pokeymaster9415 I love how the lot of you go for the "it's harder to animate" excuse.
Both 3D and 2D are hard to animate and master. They have their own strengths and weaknesses, you guys need to stop with the excuses.
If they wanted it to be done right then they should've taken a slower pace instead of trying to rush to the new content
@@mastertjt56 Its not an excuse when that’s how it works? 2D animation is much harder and more expensive, both monetarily and time-wise. The studio has to pick and choose what to adapt, what to change, and what scenes get the most focus within a set schedule. They were paid to do a 12 episode tv anime with an original story that diverges away from the original RoosterTeeth production.
If you’ve seen how 99% of anime is animated, you’ll see that Ice Queendom is doing nothing out of the ordinary. If it was Studio Orange, the new anime would’ve been in made with 3D animation in mind, but I’m sure they were too busy with the new Trigun anime.
All in all, if you want RWBY with a focus on fights and character moments, the original is way better in terms of that up until the end of Vol 3 and then it goes downhill. Seeing as this is written by Gen Urobuchi, fights and those same character moments won’t be the focus, but the narrative will. I have full faith in him seeing as he’s written Madoka Magica, Psycho-Pass and Saya no Uta, all of which have a masterful narrative. Just keep an eye on it and give it a try once it’s all said and done.
@@BlackGrailKiara Okay, I'll admit this. Production of 2D animation with the budget for a 12 episode length tv anime series with the limitations of having to closely follow the original storyline of Rooster Teeth's productions with it's own original narrative and moreso is quite difficult, especially having to adapt a 3d model animation into a 2d, hand-drawn product. Following this? Awesome.
The circumstances are far from similar. Monty Oum- Bless him- Had not only to create an entirely original story, but build the foundations for it all and actually make sense of it while steering the narrative into the direction he wants it to take. Icequeedom is moreso a recreation- Meant to evoke what makes RWBY what it is while also trying to flesh out the narrative. The issue with 3d- Here's an example to one of RWBY's VOL 1 faults- modeling. It was the impotence of the world itself. Populated, designated areas brimming with life was anything but, the city of Vale and the students at beacon themselves were there but not given anything at all to make their inclusion have substance. Characters were usually literal shadow model depictions with no identifying feature's to the extent calling them nobodies were a kind mercy, large crowds of characters usually occupy the backgrounds even using the models of pre-existing characters like when Ozpin made his speech or in Beacon's locker room. They did nothing to expand the world. They were included to make it not feel lifeless but the difficulties and folly's of 3d animations reared its head. In other words, this:
Icequeedom fixes this issue. Ruby has explained during her trip to the City of Vale the nature of Remnants' technological advancement by showcasing it. People(Who at least looked basic) crowded the streets of Vale, stop lights were in the form of a somewhat interactive, digital screen. Ruby explored shops, a cafe and even shown advanced technology and architecture and shown exactly what they were capable of. Students of Beacon acknowledged Pyhrra's existence with unveiled awe and respect in the locker rooms as homage to her status as Mistral's annual tournament winner and fame. The interactions between Ruby, Yang and their family they're leaving behind and even showcasing Ruby speaking to Summer's grave to explain her character motivations at the start are also other great examples of their differences.
Now. Sorry for derailing the argument, but in conclusion: The difference between the animation styles is staggering. They take a long time to improve upon and master like any form of art. One may seem "easier" than the other but remember the differences and variables in production's budget, staff, styles, writing and the work itself. The original showcased the conception of everything they wanted to include in order to flesh out their world but needed a spinoff to attempt to convey it properly. Icequeedom's development is no easier or harder than OG RWBY'S. IQD needed to create new things and expand upon the foundations of concepts the original couldn't. Hell, the original needed to create the world in question and how everything worked anyways, something IQD doesn't. IQD needed exposition to explain some parts of the world the OG show left behind for fight scenes or because they feeded the viewers all we needed to know, not what we wanted. The chorography and framework is more solid I the original but animating some of their fast paced action sequences two for two or even comedy bits wasn't possible so they improvised. The dialogue, the interactions and progression- let alone the things I'm not mentioning are all different. It's unjust to compare two drastically different things. One only has an abridged version of like what, 12 episodes+ two trailers. Man.
i can't believe the left out the coolest scene of the trailer
It's sad the amount of people that just walk in with predijuce, some are so biased it's obvious they have never seen any anime, or heard of SHAFT. The simplistic artstyle coupled with the stellar motion of the animation, with consistent designs is why SHAFT is actually a perfect choice for this. IS anyone stupid enough to compare ANYONE to Monty? It's actually an insult. Monty was a prodigy, a one in million. Comparing people with passion to his standards just to please your greedy eyes is selfish. I think SHAFT did justice to the fights that NEEDED it in context of the anime. One's that were watered down or not included hardly served any purpose other than being cool.
3d is made in 3d space and 2d in 2d space, if fans would understand a little bit of this, they'll know how hard it is to do dynamic camera angles for every fight scene. Background is not the problem, it can be done in 3d, but matching 2d characters with it require immense work and more frames. The main budget went into Ruby vs White Fang fight, and it looks gorgeous. But moving forward, fans would have less to complain about because anime story would take original path, so no more fights scenes to compare to.
How is it predijuce when they watched it, also the standard of 2d fights wasnt amazing even on 2d standard, there are plenty of works that done 2d fights that were amazing, the budget was wasted on pv trailer shots which increased the expectation that the anime was going to looked like the pv but was unable to deliver. I mean even a newcomer who came in and didn't watch rwby og wouldn't be invested on this, the story was non-existant and everything was rushed you are expected to watch the og to enjoy the show in the first place. Either your standards are super low or haven't watched enough shows to see others works.
@@rationaldemon195 I don't know what else you're expecting. The fights were good. If you're comparing it best selling manga adaptations, then it makes no sense since those have higher budget. Also don't forget it's not only the animation that makes it a masterpiece. Take Madoka Magica for example, one of the best works of Studio Shaft. The animation quality was meme worthy at the time of airing, but after it got praise, not only it got sequel, but also remake as 2 movies with higher budget.
And it's only been 3 episodes, and there are atleast 3 animation sequences which I already love. Maybe it's not upto your taste, but it doesn't make the fight scenes bad.
@@SahilKumar-zp8fx I had no expectations when watching the show, i was more curious to see where it was going and overall it was a underwhelming project maybe you have lower standards but i didn't enjoyed it so far,
im being reasonable here by treating it as a independent work but even then, it managed to screw that up, if you were to show anyone who hasn't watched rwby before do you honestly think they would enjoy these 3 episodes so far, be honest with me. I only hear fanboism on shaft which is pretty biased imho. Maybe you should watch other works too and question yourself why was this anime good so far.
Shit is shit may have nice colors but its still shit.
monty is not a deity. it is totally possible for other people to make good, or even better fight scenes. its not "unfair" to compare the anime to the original just because monty didn't make it. expecting a good fuckin fight scene isn't being "prejudiced"
the new animation feels extremely slowed down and clunky. whoever did this did not understand genius of Montys Choreographies
It feels like old action scenes in movies where it's *supposed* to look like the person is moving super fast and alot is happening but in reality, it's just one person moving while everyone else stands there looking dumbfounded. Best example of this would be the Sarlac pit scene from star wars with the big flip into catching the saber. Like it comes off as this clunky motion
Please do understand that dynamic fight scenes like Monty's might as well be impossible for a 2D anime.
They can be done, but not on the budgeted time and money given to a show's production.
@@KnightOfZero00 yes I do understand that you can't translate 1:1 choreography from a 3d animation to a 2d anime but just bc it is very difficult to do doesn't change the fact that it's objectively bad. If you are willing to compromise as much as they did in terms of fluidity of movement they might as well try a completely different approach. What they ended up doing is just bad
Please do remember that if they did do that, it might as well be called plagiarism. They’ve respected Monty’s style and substituted their own.
@@ReRoute25 that explains why it's hella clunky
Reminder that one of these are it's own exclusive trailer while the other is just 1/5 of an entire episode the animators had to work on so OFCORSE the standalone 3d trailer will have more fighting
Anyone else a little annoyed this just up and spoils that Blake is Faunus?
“MAYBE WE WERE JUST TIRED OF BEING PUSHED AROUND!” is supposed to come way out of left field and be a big surprise
Just when you thought RWBY couldn't get more anime, they added mid-fight exposition
Tacos or burritos
Another thing you have to do RWBY: IQ
HAVE GOOD FIGHT CHOREOGRAPHY AND GREAT CAMERA ANGLES AND IT WOULDN'T HURT TO SLOW DOWN A LITTLE DURING A FIGHT WHEN A LOT OF COOL THINGS HAPPEN( it depends if they could come up with cool things to do like CRWBY did. Even when Monty died RIP they still had amazing stuff to do in fights)
I loved the old one before around Volume 6 after that my love for the series practically dropped low. I want this RWBY to survive and I want to love it so
Japanese people GIVE IT YOUR ALL WHERE EVER YOU ARE
why they gota change the part at 2:00. that was one of her weapons most powerful feature
I couldn't help but imagining Blake using this weapon feature against Adam xD
Comparing fights is nice and all
But the real question is, what's the difference between a semblance and magic
Please please please let Adam be done good this time around heres to hoping 🙏 no chopping of arms or going insane lets hope Adam is done good pleaseee
The zipper part caught me off guard lol-
so disappointed that they cut Adam's shotgun introduction
You guys talking about how the OG RWBY's fights are better, but ignoring that said OG fights were during the time Monty was alive and made those fights. Those were essentially the best parts of RWBY that we don't get anymore. Of course, those will be better.
rwbyのvolume.1がアップロードされて10年近く経つが、最新のアニメ版の戦闘シーンはそれに劣っている。
アニメ版の戦闘シーンは空手の組手が何かでしょうか？ 予算をかけてでもrwbyの戦闘シーンはきっちり表現するべき
I don’t exactly like that the anime version reveals Blake’s Faunus heritage so soon. I haven’t watched it yet, but a huge part of the story telling us that you’re supposed to learn she’s a Faunus alongside the other characters. I’m all for more plot but I just can’t get over that detail. Also, the action in the anime can’t even be compared to the original. A big thing about the scene was the combination of the action and the music, not the plot. It was so mysterious. Idk, I guess I’m just disappointed.
God that's cliche, like everything, and the fights have no punch at all, look at 1:55 when Blake throw her gun, in anime it look like a magic pistol that move however you want and shoot, in RT it look SO much better, it isn't used to shoot closer but to trip and stab at a distance, being an effective support to Adam, the only moment the anime is looking nice is for a miserable second or two when Blake is killing robots at the begenning and it ends when she use her uzi
Adam is being voiced by Yuichi Nakamura?
The original Is *better*
wait...does blake has purple color on her hair in the original??? i never noticed it until i saw the anime
No it’s unique to the anime design, possibly to help it stand out more from all of the black in her clothes
@@jaragi it's in promo art aswell sometimes
@@jaragi Yep, and it can make panting easier.
I kinda prefer the 3D in-terms of fight scenes, it feels more impactful compared to 2D but the 2D visuals are great
The anime is not bad at all, in fact it is damn good.
Still Monty was that genius to out perfomr that man. Can't praise him enough for that.
Love the meme at the end!
the lesser action scenes and lack of casey williams singing is real apparent
A pity Yellow got skipped
Well, the anime version is getting more and more disappointing. Shame too. It does have some nice scenes but it’s missing the point of the original that long time fans loved so much. And it’s a simple rule;
“Less talky, more smashy!”
lol the anime doesnt even put dust in the box XD thats not dust thats some weird serum, dust is either in dust form or crystal
People complaining that the anime cut out Adam vs the spider Tank and didn't do some of the action justice. Boy am i glad i ripped my heart out and crushed it ages again so that i couldn’t give less of a shit about this kind of stuff. Yes i will agree the action scene isn’ t as good as in the Black Trailer, but from a writing standpoint, this blows the Black trailer out of the water in every way possible. Not only does Adam feel way more consistent here than in the series, letting his obsession for Blake be much more subtle than it coming right the fuck out of nowhere in the original, But Blake’s heal turn also feels allot more earned this time around. Feels allot more in character than last time.
The anime's animation is good, but it just can't hold a candle to the original
Good old times when Blake was not absolute depressed trash and hold herself together despite discrimination.
The old version has better fighting scene but lack details unlike the anime
Do they know their Naruto running? Lol
They cut out the meat and potatoes of the whole scene that got people hooked on the first place. The material is there to use, not much issues to solve other than the minor ones. The personal trailers were made to show off the characters and their abilities. Which they fell short of this anime. I've notice they even cut corners for basic fight encounters. Like oh there's an explosion over there then they cut to elsewhere then cut back to the scene of engagement when it's all over. It feels cheap. It's like they build up to expect something then don't deliver. It kinda half hearted. After so long the series is pretty much dead not many care much for it anymore. It wasn't the show it was the people who ran the show after Monty died...
Dialogue is definitely better in the second one, but the first one has better fight scenes by far
Huh, well it's easily the best of the trailer remakes since for half the runtime time it's better(getting to the fight area and after the fight) and half the runtime time it's worse(all the fights) than the original.
I'm not really taking into account the ears/bow reveal being spoiled since the implications matter to the long term story not the trailer itself, also ignoring the dialogue quality since on the one hand voice acting in the original was awful, but on the other hand the writing for the train scene in the remake felt really unnecessary and forced, making it feel like she's trying to figure out whether he's an idiot and doesn't realize people could get hurt or if he doesn't care(both reasons to bail, so like she's just trying to find an excuse to leave), instead of like she's gauging whether he sounds like he could be dissuaded from doing it
God I miss From Shadows...
Three for three for me, the original wins hands down. What is it with this studio cutting out the cool parts? Sheesh.
So far, the anime version fight scene feels generic. everyone fights like they are the same person with different weapons, unlike in the original where everyone has their unique fighting style. Every movement has more momentum and every hit feels impactful. The anime version is just run and slash or shoot.
the original is just game cutscene like that
the anime is summary
lol
This is more proof that the original is better.
original is definitely obviously apparently better
The old one had a lot more impact and story. This new version COMPLETELY butchered Blake's backstory.
Ugh, I've said it once, I'll said it a thousand times. I HATE ANIME DIALOGUE! IT IS SO FUCKING... LACKING IN SUBTLETY! I'm completely sticking with the original because it showed off things by being little in dialogue that still gets to the point with just Show and Not Tell. I'm probably a little annoyed but still.
Original best
戦闘アクションは、オリジナルの方が凄過ぎて、アニメではあそこまで描ききれないね。
最後のおまけは、微妙な感じw
shit the anime looks so much better it's choreography is WAAAYYY better and the attacks dont look like they are weak and looking at the original is hard on my eyes after seeing the anime version
Nice bait
@@frostb7ackmyotisco7d93 wdym
briyng Otaku: aah but cgi is trash blabla
since when ppl come to rwby for plots ?
i came to rwby 'cause of dead fantasy lol
ppl keep crying about budget this budget that
if u can't adapt an og series with respect then don't fuking touch it
for ppl keep saying 2d cant make fight scene good, try to watch Fog Hill of Five Elements
first 3 chapters of IQ is boring and plain af, nothing can deny that
For this one it's definitely a downgrade no matter how you look at it
if ya'll don't like it then don't watch it lol
I don't like this
it is not my rwby
it is fake rwby
the anime's fighting scenes are god awful