yep. had tears in my eyes seeing naboo and coruscant celebrating as well, realizing how many people the empire actually influenced. for the first time I saw star wars end as it should've been, and I couldn't have asked for more.
I feel the same. I understand people can be critical of the changes, but they gave GL too much shit for it imo. And its not like you cant just get the old version if you want it and prefer it.
Pathetic, some years ago everyone hated the prequels like people like you hate the sequels now and it will always be like this, because you expect the movies to be exactly like you remember your childhood. I grew up with the prequels and I would never say, that they are objectively better movies than the sequels
@@DerEchteBabo No we don't. We just expect them to be good movies(some of us at least). It's just that the sequel trilogy suffered so much because of TLJ. I actually really liked TFA. I even thought TRoS was quite decent, but the movies didn't have the best writing. Rey didn't really work for me as a protagonist because she's a Mary Sue if anything. Finn was great, but he got sidelined after TFA. I didn't find Rose as dislikable as most fans do, but that little stunt she pulled at the end of TLJ saving Finn was completely unnecessary. His arc had literally come full circle. And don't even get me started on Snoke. He was supposed to be the new Palps for this trilogy, but he was so ominous that his death in TLJ didn't feel like comeuppance. It just felt like the catalyst for a fight scene. Anyways, sorry for the essay, but that's my take on this trilogy
The original ending was a proper finale of a beloved trilogy, but the 2011 ending was the finale of an era, tieing together a deeper and more meaningful story
The 2011 ending is really great, save for Anakin looking to his left when he should be looking to his right. Seems he was not well directed in that scene.
When Hayden first appears it's perfect, he's looking straight at Luke, as Sebastian did (minute 2:06 and 5:20). But it is how Christensen looks to somewhere else (minute 5:27) that I still don't like. Do you notice that his eyes are fixed at a different place?
Man, sometimes i wish for sequels but something in me say that would be a horrible mistake with terribly script. Ha, you could imagine it? Something like The Emperor coming back, I'm glad we live in a reality where that never happened
7 วันที่ผ่านมา +2
@@JustGarbo14 Such a return of an old Villain for whom it literally took 6 movies to kill , is just trash .It not only is a dumb, over-used storyline but it even makes no meaning out of OT . Luke , who was so cool to be honest did so good , just gave up and what he did before was revived . Sorry my comment may not match your one but I just wanted to say it
There’s just something so powerful about Luke’s expression while sending off his father. You can tell he’s feeling so many different emotions at once, and the music, coming full circle with the very beginning of episode 4, staring off into the double sun.
Yes, and the almost fierce affection with which he embraces Han is really interesting as well. Their whole relationship gets condensed into that one act. Amazing.
Yeah they missed out on a key character. They should have put him into rogue one with CGI too like they did red leader and gold leader from the battle of Yavin.
@@Ramzi1944 3:55 It is a bit earlier: far in the background when the camera stops panning after the fall of the Statue of the Emperor. Look for the spires on the building.
I love how complete the newer music felt, like this was the definite end of the series. But it was interesting how the original portrayed Anakin, Obi-Wan, and Yoda as a trio of friends before Anakin's fall.
Exactly, this is Anakin’s final send off and after knowing the pain and torment he went through now that we have the prequels it needed a more dramatic ending.
@@bIue_venom The ghosts are the jedis who have an important rol in the Luke's life. Qui gon replacing Yoda has no sense, even if he hadn´t been killed.
2011 version seems to be the favorite. It ties everything from episodes 1 through 6 nicely and serves as a poignant reminder that we never needed an episode 7. This is the Star Wars I want to remember, not what it has become.
The mistake was not to make a new trilogy but to decide that this trilogy should be part of the "Skywalker Saga". Why not just tell a whole new story about the Old Republic or High Republic? All the Sith Wars or Hyperspace War would be a great setting for a new trilogy. But no, they wanted to continue a finished story instead.
Ive never noticed that b4. Also i just realised we never rlly see how ppl in the galaxy feel abt tbe emperor himself, since hes always hidden away from the main conflict most of the time
I never notice that before and went back to watch it. All of the other times I have watched it I was looking at the crowds . Thanks for pointing it out. 👍👍👍👍
My Dad who passed away about two months ago wasn't a big star wars fan, but he loved the music. His favorite one was the Victory Celebration theme. Now I can't help but think of him everytime I listen to it.
This actually made me tear up a bit. I miss how Star Wars used to feel, being reminded that the sequels exist honestly just hurts. The Disney Empire just will just take quantity over quality and all we have now are some dull Disney + shows.
Rebels, andor, the mandalorian, tales of the jedi, the final season of the clone wars, rogue one, the bad batch, altough it is easy to hate on disney they have released some of the best sw content ever.
Yep. A new Star Wars film used to be an event, now the franchise is just too diluted which has killed its lustre. I have to say though, The Phantom Menace is just as good as the original 3 films to me. It was the last great one though.
The only thing that didn’t make sense was the planets celebrating. The Death Star was gone, but the Empire was still large and had a tight grip on the galaxy. Still was more heart felt and felt like a celebration moment, in which they won, and felt right
I love both endings, 1983 ending is a more cultural-esque ceremony for the Ewoks, their celebration, then there is Sebastian Shaw standing there, we get to see how Anakin looked like without his burns and scars, and in his Jedi ceremonial robes, the 2011 version on the other hand, shows the whole Galaxy celebrating the fall of the Empire, the song has more meaning and is more melancholical, a true way to end a trilogy and give us a sense of a happy ending, then there's Hayden Christensen, showing that Anakin truly died when he killed Mace Windu, but then returned (thus being Return of the Jedi) when he, as the Chosen One, killed both Darth Vader and Darth Sidious, i hope he's finally reunited with Padmé in the Force Afterlife and they're both happy with eachother.
When the actors hug on the set you can feel that it's more than just acting. You feel the legitimate love and friendship the actors share for each other.
Yep. For me it ends at the Mandalorian. It does lead up to the sequel trilogy, but they pretty much defeated the whole New Empire (sorry spoilers) so that’s basically the end for me. Return of the Jedi was the end, and the Mandalorian was a double end.
Regardless of the version, what a great ending to the saga. I hope they don't screw it up someday by making some lackluster sequels that undo all of this.
Now while I prefer the 1983 ending, there's just one thing that I think I could do to make this feel like really the ending to Star Wars. We see Sebastian Shaws Anakin and Alec Guinness's Obi-Wan, but as soon as Luke walks away. Both change back to their prequel selves, Hayden Christensen's Anakin and Ewan McGregor's Obi-Wan. That I think, would've brought it full circle.
I see the point. But I disagree. Keeping Alec Guinness as Kenobi’s force ghost I think conjures up an image of a Jedi Master who mentored BOTH father and son
@@jesusfrancoHe actually knows bc between ep 5 and 6 it was revealed that Luke had read Obi Wan's book, and that book contained basically all the information that he needed, as well as Anakin previous physical aspect
@@jesusfrancoAre you saying that Anakin’s force ghost shouldn’t be Hayden Christensen because Luke never knew what he looked like? Because I hope you know how little sense that makes.
My dream ending would be 2011 with Sebastian Shaw in it. His benevolent fatherly look on his twins always gives me chills. A thing I desired so much since my father died before I saw RotJ.
1983: the rebels celebrating they destroyed an imperial station 1997/2011: the whole galaxy celebrating the fall of the Empire that oppressed them for over 20 years and celebrating that they're finally free, bringing a brand new positive era to the galaxy
2011 ending gets me everytime. I can't just help but drop some tears. Really. The tender music, these little bear-like creatudes dancing with all their innocence, soldiers dancing and Luke, victorious, watching his masters and his redeemed father looking at him proudly. Just beautiful.
The celebration music change as well as adding Bespin, Tattooine & Coruscant were added in the 1997 Special Edition while adding Naboo & replacing Sebastian Shaw with Hayden Christensen as Anakin's Force Ghost were added into the 2004 DVD.
@@waltuh2.3bviews3secondsago3 Coruscant was added into the 1997 Star Wars Trilogy Special Edition & has been in every upgrade since. Naboo on the other hand was added into the 2004 DVD set. Episode I was in development at the time in 1997 while Episode III was being worked on when the middle/original trilogy was being released to DVD. It's been a hot minute, but I think Coruscant was also a setting (or at least mentioned) in the book, Star Wars: Shadows of the Empire (1996), which is only in Legends canon & not Disney canon.
The addition of more sound in the 2011 version does a subtle job but adds so much camaraderie, you can practically feel it. Instead of just silence and music, you can hear Han and Lando laughing as they embrace; Chewie's roars are louder and crisper, even a few of the extra hugs can have their slaps and pats heard, and during almost all of it, you can hear the whole cast's laughter and chatter in the background. You can hear the happiness of the people and characters we've come to know and love, and that makes the scene feel so much better.
This is an interesting side note but I absolutely love that Wedge was included in the celebration montage of both endings. Wedge is by far one of the most underrated Star Wars heroes, he was arguably just as important to blowing up the second Death Star as Lando Calrissian and Nien Numb were.
@@drlca6601ok, if so tell me one thing. Is Wedge Antiless or Antilles is the same person as captain Antilles (or Antiless). The R2D2's and C3PO's new master? From RotS's ending?
lol at how all the zoomers trying to make the prequels seem good all of a sudden. Can't wait for the next generation to praise 1-9 when the next trilogy happens.
@@The_RedVIII Haha, nobody who really likes Starwars actually had a fulfilling emotional experience watching 7-9. 1-6 is best, always…great story arc overall. Sequels story was a total mess
When I was a kid we had the special editions on VHS and for the longest time I thought that was the original ending music in ROTJ. I finally saw the original version on tv when I was like 15 and thought I was crazy for remembering it differently.
@@mysteriousdude6296 because actually anakin brought balance to the force by killing the jedis and the siths, If a new Jedi order was created again the effort of anakin would have been for nothing.
I get goosebumps during the 2011 ending when i see the jedi temple in the background and than I see Anakin's force ghost. It really sends a message that people can be redeemed and deserve a second chance whether it is in life or death.
Honestly, the thing that makes the original the best to me is the pure happiness, pride, and joy on older Anikans face for his son when we see him in his glowing form. So much more impactful and beautiful!
I haven’t seen the original in years!! I’m old enough to remember watching Star Wars in ‘77 as a schoolboy. The ending, although kinda low key always felt satisfying to me. I think people of my age actually thought this was the end!!
Who cared ? Anakin Skywalker's seduction, into the Darkside of The Force, never tasted appealing. However, Ben 'Obi-Wan" Kenobi was of greater interest to me. What made him "The Only One"?⁷
The 2011 version showing prequel locations like Naboo and Coruscant really ties up both trilogies as a whole. Thank you George Lucas for creating such an amazing story.
Same! I really do think that was an intentional nod to the famous Reichstag photo when the Soviets brought an end to the war. Lucas also had lots of respect for Soviet cinema.
@@revolutionariesoffreedom2374 That's true, this is also one main reason why the Russian revolution and communists world wide have adapted that symbol later. In any case, it represented freedom and liberation.
Righto Righto you prefer creepy young Anakin? Lol look, for someone watching Star Wars in episodic order, Hayden makes more sense. Hell, use CGI Yoda and Ewan McGregor as Obi-Wan lol. Release order? Use Sebastian Shaw.
I just like the 2011 one better. Within a few seconds, Hayden made sure we felt the love Anakin had for the children he never come to know as a father. It's beautiful and heartbreaking at the same time.
I cannot get past all the quick cuts in the 2011 version when leia and Han reunite with Luke and everyone is hugging each other. They keep cutting over to c3po and r2, nothing is allowed a moment to build the emotions and resonate with the characters feelings between one another; it feels like a choppy compilation. No shot lasts more than a few seconds. It completely ruins the pacing up to that point. I’m not all the old version is better in every way, but all the editing they did right there in the new one feels so bizarre.
2011 was the perfect ending to the empire, Deathstar 2 gone, Palpatine and Vader gone, whole galaxy celebrating and then they just ruined it by bringing back the empire in the form of the First Order w/ another Death Star . Why couldn't they just have a new threat?
HFYYN like I said, First Order is basically the Empire (stormtroopers, starkiller base etc.) not necessarily what I would consider a new threat. We've seen it all before.
I love the 2011 version more cuz the music is more touching for an ending, the scenes of all the galaxy celebrating the fall of emperor Palpatine's tyrany are perfect, they help to conect with everything that we've seen till this point and having Episode III Anakin as a force ghost goes better with it since this was the way he look right before he got tainted by the dark side.
Two things about 1983 that I like better: The Song and the fact that Vader is the face that Luke knew (nothing against Hayden Christensen). I do like the added celebration scenes from 2011.
Julian Shipp Jr He’s probably about to be executed which might explain the fact that there is someone willhem screaming at 3:55 because he was a stormtrooper and he was thrown down Coruscant
2011 is definitely better. The music is beautiful, and I also think it makes more sense to have Hayden appear as he is the Anakin we all know, and have followed throughout the movies
Darth Batman but he didnt look like a normal shaw. He had high degree burns and a huge scar on his head, thats how he died, so it makes no sense to put him as the normal unscared shaw either.
I always liked the 2011 version better. Seeing the celebrations on the other planets and then going back to Endor was a great touch. Also, I found the music to be a huge improvement. I never liked the music in the original. I feel like the music in the new version is more fitting.
I agree. Yub Nub was too whimsical a song for the conclusion of the trilogy. 2011's version still retains some of the Ewok influence, but its made more universal through toning the fun side down. It makes seeing the galaxy celebrating more appropriate, with just a tinge of melancholy
The main change was in 1997 for the 20th anniversary. This was the version I grew up with and is my favourite because it has the new John Williams music which I love and feel so much more epic than the Yub Nub. But it also has Sebastian Shaw as Anakin Skywalker which, in my opinion, is how Anakin's force ghost should look like
There's a lot more interaction between Luke and Leia in the 1983 version, more beautiful, stronger and emotional. The way they look to each other and hold each other 😍
I grew up on the special editions, so those will always be nostalgic to me. I do like how they don’t cut away in the original, but the music is so much better to me in the remastered
SE is a bit different as Sebastian Shaw is in the final scene and Ian McDiarmid isn't retconned into Ep. V like he was in 2004, but other than that they are pretty much the same. Theatrical and '97 versions deserve Blurays IMO.
@@drlca6601Absolutely agree! I was lucky enough to get the box set with the original theatrical versions on DVD but I would love to have the Special Editions also as I only have them on VHS. So much better than when they went back and started changing bits unnecessarily.
This ending makes me hate 7 and 8. In 6, Anakin coming backing to the light, the Fall of the empire, RETURE OF THE JEDI!! Just to find out were back were we started😧
@@dramos8847 In the next Star Wars movie the Emperor isn't dead, Anakin's role to balance the Force basically didn't happen. Palpatine still lived and Anakin's sacrifice was all in vain...
I think anikan throwing Palpatine like 1000 feet down then a massive explosion should have killed him dont ya think. But noo disney says lets bring him back to life
No handshake between Luke and Han. Straight to a hug. Also I know people get upset that the Hayden anakin is used at the end. But people who watch 1-6 for the first time in that order love it. My wife literally cried seeing younger Anakin redeemed and returned to his former self. Beautiful stuff. 2011 ending is way better.
I'm gonna say it, I liked that they added young Anakin (Hayden Christensen). Feels good to see him in these Jedi Robes, realizing he's free and was forgiven. A lot more emotional than seeing Sebastian Shaw imo.
Also, no disrespect to Shaw but he looked too old as well. It's like they made him look he was the same age as Obi Wan or something. When Anakin died, he was like 45 year old. I wouldn't even be surprised if he still looked Young considering Qui Gone was 60 in TPM yet he looked 30.
If Vader hadn't died, just imagine the reactions of all the rebels on Endor because he has in some way shape or form fucked them over. Even though Luke redeemed him, Vader still killed his aunt and uncle, his mentor, and cut off his right hand. Then you have Leia, who Vader tortured for information and then destroyed her home planet. Then all of a sudden, she finds out he's her father. And then you've got Han, who Vader tortured and put in carbonite before letting Boba Fett take him to Jabba the Hutt for three years. Then Lando, who was just trying to protect the citizens of Bespin, then Vader just kept screwing him over and made him look like a huge, sell-out dickhead. Even fucking Chewbacca, who Vader put into a chamber with loud, screeching noises and since Wookiees are based around dogs, we can imagine he has extremely sensitive hearing. In all honesty, the only person who would have a positive reaction to seeing Anakin would be either R2 or 3PO, who just kind of knew Vader before he became a clunky robot servant with his dick burned off. All around, the party on Endor would have been more awkward than when Travis Bickle took his girlfriend to a porn theater.
Never thought that way. Obi-Wan let him kill himself. Darth Vader isn't technically Anakin. Everything bad he did was as "Darth Vader", controlled by Sidious. At the end of the movie, Anakin was stronger than Darth Vader, and he took his body back.
In one of the comics it actually shows Vader ( or should I say Anakin) returning as a force ghost to Leía. She wanted nothing to do with him after all, he was partially responsible for the destruction of Alderaan and hated him for also torturing Han back on Bespin. It took awhile for her to forgive and wasn’t until he found young Anakin’s journals and found out that he had a lot of good within him. That’s when she decided to forgive him.
I can't say i like the 1983 version better. I think its more meaningful to see Hayden Christensen be anakin's ghost to sort of say: "only the light siders can live forever as a ghost." Also I think it's great to see the galaxy celebrating the death of Palpatine.
@Phantom 26 Well while it explains where First Order suddenly appeared/got its military power, its still stupid as shit.... Honestly Emperor/Palpatine should have remained dead after this, it made Vader's/Anakins death bit meaningless.... Even more so it officially made sequel trilogy just "Empire vs Rebels 2.0" except with much weaker set of characters. I had no problem with old cast returning, but I would have wanted some entirely new kind of story than just recycled plot elements from original trilogy
I was borned 1992 and music from ending 2011 was already that time in film at 1997 when I saw original star wars trilogy for the first time... I think, it is for the first time I hear this music from 1986 and for me... d Definitely the ending from 2011 with music is the real and beatiful ending of star wars saga... Brings me beatiful memories from the childhood and cruel fact that every great story comes To its end and so same young years of happiness of every people here, and that fact that the things will never be the same again... This ending of movie brings me always happy emotions of memories in past, same time always brings a little bit of sorrow too... 😊
The OT was never about wizards, laser swords, spaceships, robots or democracy. Star Wars was about Han, Luke and Leia. That’s it. That’s why it worked and that why we (Gen X) loved it. The original ending of Return of the Jedi drives that point home perfectly. It was a little story about those characters and their journey, not some huge, Dune-esque saga of politics and faith. But George just had to pry that complete and satisfying story back open to “expand” it so that he could continue to squeeze it dry. And once the carcass became empty, he sold its remains to a mouse that continues to perform God-knows-what selfish evils upon its legacy. Long live The Trilogy.
So triumphant, the empire has been defeated, the Jedi have returned, and the republic shall be restored. Our heroes will be there to ensure the path to peace, Han has changed from a smuggler to a hero of the Rebellion, Leia will be active in the new government, Luke will begin a new Jedi order that has learned from the past. THEN EVERYTHING WENT TO HELL.... In the end none of this mattered, the reset button is essentially hit and everything our heroes fought for, every sacrifice was all for nothing.
The new trilogy feels like as if the Empire had won, or if they'd remained almost just as powerful as they already were, despite the loss. Like an alternative universe.
If you see the stories from the old expanded Universe then you have another storys with weird situations. You have a new generation of jedi yes but you have a Luke on the dark site for a short Time. The Emperror come back. There is the yuuzhan vong. The Sequels have mistakes yes but I like there.
Obviously the 2011 there’s a lot more incredible “art” going on but what I really like is how Hayden appears cause after what we’ve seen (now) in 1-3, he’s the Anakin we’ve all grown to love… or hate. But love the fact that Luke can look upon his bad ass “good” father finally.
![[LIVE] ย้อนวันวานกับนางเอกยุค 90's #คุยให้เด็กมันฟัง EP.42 (8/6/67)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/MslQDdFwULE/mqdefault.jpg)
The 1983 version feels more like the ending of the OT while the 2011 version feels more like the ending to the saga as a whole.
M'aiq the Liar Well it was back in 2011...
yep. had tears in my eyes seeing naboo and coruscant celebrating as well, realizing how many people the empire actually influenced. for the first time I saw star wars end as it should've been, and I couldn't have asked for more.
Spot on!
M'aiq the Liar I agree
I feel the same. I understand people can be critical of the changes, but they gave GL too much shit for it imo. And its not like you cant just get the old version if you want it and prefer it.
Its cool to see how Prequel and Original fans are coming together because we all hate the sequels
Ratchet 0401 lol
I know right? It's beautiful...
Pathetic, some years ago everyone hated the prequels like people like you hate the sequels now and it will always be like this, because you expect the movies to be exactly like you remember your childhood. I grew up with the prequels and I would never say, that they are objectively better movies than the sequels
@@DerEchteBabo No we don't. We just expect them to be good movies(some of us at least). It's just that the sequel trilogy suffered so much because of TLJ. I actually really liked TFA. I even thought TRoS was quite decent, but the movies didn't have the best writing. Rey didn't really work for me as a protagonist because she's a Mary Sue if anything. Finn was great, but he got sidelined after TFA. I didn't find Rose as dislikable as most fans do, but that little stunt she pulled at the end of TLJ saving Finn was completely unnecessary. His arc had literally come full circle. And don't even get me started on Snoke. He was supposed to be the new Palps for this trilogy, but he was so ominous that his death in TLJ didn't feel like comeuppance. It just felt like the catalyst for a fight scene. Anyways, sorry for the essay, but that's my take on this trilogy
@@DerEchteBabo shut up thats it
3:53 the random stormtrooper "crowd surfing" made my day.
Complete with the Wilhelm Scream!
Bro getting killed😭
I just realized that
That detail gave more life to the scene
lmao I just noticed it
The original ending was a proper finale of a beloved trilogy, but the 2011 ending was the finale of an era, tieing together a deeper and more meaningful story
Prequel sux dick
Am I the only one who likes the 2011 ending more than the 1983 ending?
Gugel Acaont you're not the only one man
Lucio Padilla Rojas Glad to hear that :)
The 2011 ending is really great, save for Anakin looking to his left when he should be looking to his right. Seems he was not well directed in that scene.
+Rockwars10 What are you talking about? He is looking straight at his son.
When Hayden first appears it's perfect, he's looking straight at Luke, as Sebastian did (minute 2:06 and 5:20). But it is how Christensen looks to somewhere else (minute 5:27) that I still don't like. Do you notice that his eyes are fixed at a different place?
3:37 You can hear Jar-Jar saying: "Messa free!"
Weesa Free bro not Messa
You could also see him
Lol so awesome
@Arashasgul is a sith general well shit
@ChickenTablet96 is a sith general could have been another Gungan
It‘s crazy how it all tied up so well, never for us to see these characters ever again.
Man, sometimes i wish for sequels but something in me say that would be a horrible mistake with terribly script. Ha, you could imagine it? Something like The Emperor coming back, I'm glad we live in a reality where that never happened
@@JustGarbo14 Such a return of an old Villain for whom it literally took 6 movies to kill , is just trash .It not only is a dumb, over-used storyline but it even makes no meaning out of OT . Luke , who was so cool to be honest did so good , just gave up and what he did before was revived . Sorry my comment may not match your one but I just wanted to say it
That is until Disney got their greedy hands on them.
There’s just something so powerful about Luke’s expression while sending off his father. You can tell he’s feeling so many different emotions at once, and the music, coming full circle with the very beginning of episode 4, staring off into the double sun.
Mark Hamill was amazing playing Luke Skywalker and making him come to life. Superb.
Yes, and the almost fierce affection with which he embraces Han is really interesting as well. Their whole relationship gets condensed into that one act. Amazing.
For some reason it makes me especially happy that Wedge is there and is getting hugs too.
Indeed, Wedge deserves a good retirement, he survived all death star attacks and is awesome in the non-canon comics (which was canon then).
Just noticed in the 1983 version Wedge didn't had a hug from Luke, so the 2011 version corrected it too
Shame he wasn't in the newer films :(
Its because of the X-wing books isnt it?
Yeah they missed out on a key character. They should have put him into rogue one with CGI too like they did red leader and gold leader from the battle of Yavin.
The part of Couruscant got to me, where it all began.... you can even see the jedi temple in the distance
Epsolio and a stromtrooler being taken with a wilhelm scream and statues being knocked down.
Davros Darlek I actually never noticed those before
Me too, but I've got a question:
I though the temple has been destroyed by the empire, hasn't it?
@@niklasmalcharczyk apparently not.
The Clarinet Guy Palpatine uses it as his Imperial Palace with a throne room during the Empire era.
I always love the short focus on the Jedi Temple at 4:05. It’s short and poignant, and it gives the message that the Jedi had finally been avenged.
Im surprised they didnt destroy it
@@billross9132 Palpatine actually used it as his imperial palace.
I don't see the temple
@@Ramzi1944 3:55 It is a bit earlier: far in the background when the camera stops panning after the fall of the Statue of the Emperor. Look for the spires on the building.
@@maxulic Thank you
I love how complete the newer music felt, like this was the definite end of the series.
But it was interesting how the original portrayed Anakin, Obi-Wan, and Yoda as a trio of friends before Anakin's fall.
Exactly, this is Anakin’s final send off and after knowing the pain and torment he went through now that we have the prequels it needed a more dramatic ending.
You know what would've been beautiful? Qui gon, obi wan and anakin, the better trio, the trio we would've gotten had qui gon not been killed
@@bIue_venom The ghosts are the jedis who have an important rol in the Luke's life. Qui gon replacing Yoda has no sense, even if he hadn´t been killed.
2011 version seems to be the favorite. It ties everything from episodes 1 through 6 nicely and serves as a poignant reminder that we never needed an episode 7. This is the Star Wars I want to remember, not what it has become.
True canonical ending?
Mandalorian is pretty good.
The mistake was not to make a new trilogy but to decide that this trilogy should be part of the "Skywalker Saga". Why not just tell a whole new story about the Old Republic or High Republic? All the Sith Wars or Hyperspace War would be a great setting for a new trilogy. But no, they wanted to continue a finished story instead.
@@immermitderruhe especially palpatines return was a mistake that's the whole reason of anakins/vaders death.
This is the true ending to Star Wars
When palpy statue fell in coruscant, the music start. Love that part
I never noticed that before. Thanks man.
3:55 i think
Ive never noticed that b4. Also i just realised we never rlly see how ppl in the galaxy feel abt tbe emperor himself, since hes always hidden away from the main conflict most of the time
I never notice that before and went back to watch it. All of the other times I have watched it I was looking at the crowds . Thanks for pointing it out. 👍👍👍👍
Dur to a firework. The Wilhelm scream also happened there.
I love the detail that Palpatines Statue got mantled down in the coruscant one.
What time point does that occur? I keep overlooking it
@@Tylanjamison96 you start seeing it at 3:55
My Dad who passed away about two months ago wasn't a big star wars fan, but he loved the music. His favorite one was the Victory Celebration theme. Now I can't help but think of him everytime I listen to it.
I’m very sorry for your loss, it’s not easy losing a loved one. At least you’ll have this song to remember him by. Stay strong 🫶
So sorry for your loss 🙏😞
Let this song remind you of your loved one. Peace in heaven to your father and health to you🕊.
Love it! Did he like the old one or the new version?
Hugs, love, and prayers from across the internet.
I love Han's reaction when he sees Luke and realizes he's not dead
Well if u remember Leia told Han that Luke wasn't on the Death Star when It blew
I think he's just relieved he no longer needs to see him as a rival...
me to
That transition from Coruscant to Endor was flawless. It really made the ending feel more organic with the newer changes
And Palpatines statue subtly falling on Coruscant was visual chefs kiss...😎
I'd be so kind as to mark the minute when that happens
Off ftopic, but super cute fursuit!
Crazy, you commented 7 years after the video and still got >700 likes in a week
Wtf Furry 💀
3:55
Many people might not have noticed but if you see in the corner you will see earth sidious statue falling
This actually made me tear up a bit. I miss how Star Wars used to feel, being reminded that the sequels exist honestly just hurts. The Disney Empire just will just take quantity over quality and all we have now are some dull Disney + shows.
Rebels, andor, the mandalorian, tales of the jedi, the final season of the clone wars, rogue one, the bad batch, altough it is easy to hate on disney they have released some of the best sw content ever.
Yep. A new Star Wars film used to be an event, now the franchise is just too diluted which has killed its lustre.
I have to say though, The Phantom Menace is just as good as the original 3 films to me. It was the last great one though.
You can ignore These trashy films. Star Wars ended on The Return of Jedi
As if it wasn't George's fault
@@miadatenshi9903 Sure, ultimately he did decide to sell it, but most people wouldn’t have guessed how bad newer projects were going to turn out.
3:39 Are those gungans on the rooftop? THIS IS GETTING OUT OF HAND. NOW THEY HAVE THE HIGH GROUND.
Wesa Free
Jar jar is a sith lord
@@davids1854
The worst of all
Jush push them off bruh
Eesa over. Weesa have high ground.
The 2011 felt some much more right and heart felt
The Conquistador I agree
The Conquistador true
Except for Hayden
The only thing that didn’t make sense was the planets celebrating. The Death Star was gone, but the Empire was still large and had a tight grip on the galaxy. Still was more heart felt and felt like a celebration moment, in which they won, and felt right
The Conquistador I guess because anikan force ghost in that looks the same as him in the other films
My childhood consisted of both seeing the original ending on vhs and the new ending on dvd and I think that was the best way to grow up.
The 2011 version brought a tear to my eye, the music, the finality of it. I didn’t realize that this was truly the end of Star Wars!
RIP CARRIE FISHER.
Not to be insensitive but can you guys just get over it already?
Broken Warhead Studios unfortunatly she wasn't a jedi
She ain't dead she's in the last jedi
Nvm
RIP
I love both endings, 1983 ending is a more cultural-esque ceremony for the Ewoks, their celebration, then there is Sebastian Shaw standing there, we get to see how Anakin looked like without his burns and scars, and in his Jedi ceremonial robes, the 2011 version on the other hand, shows the whole Galaxy celebrating the fall of the Empire, the song has more meaning and is more melancholical, a true way to end a trilogy and give us a sense of a happy ending, then there's Hayden Christensen, showing that Anakin truly died when he killed Mace Windu, but then returned (thus being Return of the Jedi) when he, as the Chosen One, killed both Darth Vader and Darth Sidious, i hope he's finally reunited with Padmé in the Force Afterlife and they're both happy with eachother.
I figure the Force afterlife is only
Force adepts.
Padmee was not force sensitive so that’s not gonna happen sadly
This man just said cristian Haydenson besides that great comment
@@deesnuts1 Two years later and i've never noticed, and in these two years i've always have been confused by how his name is actually spelled lmao.
When you die you just become part of the force. The only way to avoid this is by becoming a five ghost, and I’m pretty sure that’s temporary.
Lucas made a perfect ending saga with 2011 version. Thanks George for your brillant vision and good job.
When the actors hug on the set you can feel that it's more than just acting. You feel the legitimate love and friendship the actors share for each other.
I love the statue of the emperor being toppled at 3:55 on coruscant
Just like in the 50s in Russia
@@thebigflop3118 and 90's!
And the random Wilhelm Scream
The people who overturned the statue were attacked by the stormtroopers. The planet plunged into civil war and was only liberated much later
Just like Iraq
Fuck Disney Star Wars ends here.
Yep. For me it ends at the Mandalorian. It does lead up to the sequel trilogy, but they pretty much defeated the whole New Empire (sorry spoilers) so that’s basically the end for me. Return of the Jedi was the end, and the Mandalorian was a double end.
I'm not sorry the sequels will never be the ending for me
I like to put them in the part of my mind where I keep the memory of Jar Jar Binks
@michael cooper agreed
@michael cooper true. Disney owes us three apologies, one for each hideous movie.
Regardless of the version, what a great ending to the saga. I hope they don't screw it up someday by making some lackluster sequels that undo all of this.
Now while I prefer the 1983 ending, there's just one thing that I think I could do to make this feel like really the ending to Star Wars. We see Sebastian Shaws Anakin and Alec Guinness's Obi-Wan, but as soon as Luke walks away. Both change back to their prequel selves, Hayden Christensen's Anakin and Ewan McGregor's Obi-Wan. That I think, would've brought it full circle.
I love your idea of actor transitions
I see the point. But I disagree. Keeping Alec Guinness as Kenobi’s force ghost I think conjures up an image of a Jedi Master who mentored BOTH father and son
The 2011 version really felt like it tied into the saga as a whole. It was so beautiful I legit started crying.
Whaaaat? Luke doesn't even know who the fuck is the third spirit at 5:17. Doesn't make any sense to see Hayden Christensen there!
2011 was the sh*ts. What were you crying about? How he butchered his masterpieces with all this crap additions that his kids came up with.
@@jesusfrancoHe actually knows bc between ep 5 and 6 it was revealed that Luke had read Obi Wan's book, and that book contained basically all the information that he needed, as well as Anakin previous physical aspect
@@jesusfrancoAre you saying that Anakin’s force ghost shouldn’t be Hayden Christensen because Luke never knew what he looked like? Because I hope you know how little sense that makes.
How come he's the only force ghost not to resemble his age and appearance at death?
The 2011 version has of touch of salsa music in it. I enjoyed it very much.
Myrna Laboy What are you smoking?
Cringe
Also enjoyed it
Myrna Laboy thanks!
George Lucas lol
My dream ending would be 2011 with Sebastian Shaw in it.
His benevolent fatherly look on his twins always gives me chills.
A thing I desired so much since my father died before I saw RotJ.
Great comment
1983: the rebels celebrating they destroyed an imperial station
1997/2011: the whole galaxy celebrating the fall of the Empire that oppressed them for over 20 years and celebrating that they're finally free, bringing a brand new positive era to the galaxy
And then a new empire attacked so badly and destroyed everything....the Disney empire.
@@ivanroa5988we can just say it’s not canon in our minds
The fact that the jedi temple is still standing in the 2011 version is amazing.
in canon, it was turned into the imperial palace, tho it was left in ruins in legends
2011 ending gets me everytime. I can't just help but drop some tears. Really. The tender music, these little bear-like creatudes dancing with all their innocence, soldiers dancing and Luke, victorious, watching his masters and his redeemed father looking at him proudly. Just beautiful.
innocence.. ewoks and innocence do not go together 😂
@@DarthJarJarTheWiseMoney opportunities are innocent
2011 ending is objectively better.
@ARandomInternetUser08 It's the only alteration to the OT that I liked.
@@zacmumblethunder7466 I can't really argue with that. The CGI changes in ANH especially were a little strange.
I love the confidence of the quartermaster who made sure to bring fireworks to the the attack on the deathstar.
The newer music is so much more uplifting. Makes me well up almost every time 😊
The celebration music change as well as adding Bespin, Tattooine & Coruscant were added in the 1997 Special Edition while adding Naboo & replacing Sebastian Shaw with Hayden Christensen as Anakin's Force Ghost were added into the 2004 DVD.
I appreciate the info, I was confused because I had seen the added scenes before 2011 but you gave me a resolution, thank you.
@@Ramzi1944yeah that’s why I was confused on the title saying “2011” when I’ve seen Hayden before that year in this special edition
@@Ramzi19442011 was the blu-ray, it was probably put because it was more well known in general.
Wait Coruscant was a thing before the prequels? Where was it?
@@waltuh2.3bviews3secondsago3 Coruscant was added into the 1997 Star Wars Trilogy Special Edition & has been in every upgrade since.
Naboo on the other hand was added into the 2004 DVD set.
Episode I was in development at the time in 1997 while Episode III was being worked on when the middle/original trilogy was being released to DVD.
It's been a hot minute, but I think Coruscant was also a setting (or at least mentioned) in the book, Star Wars: Shadows of the Empire (1996), which is only in Legends canon & not Disney canon.
3:39 "WESA FREE!" was confirmed to be Jar Jar Binks.
Really? That's cool. Do you have a source?
Michael Myers what a stupid fucking decision
Michael Myers It’s cool that Jar Jar got to see the end of his biggest mistake ever, because of the the fact that it was fixed
Michael Myers how is he still alive
@@wickedshadesproductions5254 He is 60 years old at the moment.
I love so much the original version!!! 🧡
This is the Star Wars I fell in love with
The addition of more sound in the 2011 version does a subtle job but adds so much camaraderie, you can practically feel it. Instead of just silence and music, you can hear Han and Lando laughing as they embrace; Chewie's roars are louder and crisper, even a few of the extra hugs can have their slaps and pats heard, and during almost all of it, you can hear the whole cast's laughter and chatter in the background. You can hear the happiness of the people and characters we've come to know and love, and that makes the scene feel so much better.
The music was already there in 1997
This is an interesting side note but I absolutely love that Wedge was included in the celebration montage of both endings. Wedge is by far one of the most underrated Star Wars heroes, he was arguably just as important to blowing up the second Death Star as Lando Calrissian and Nien Numb were.
Wedge is a G in movies and EU. I love Wedge!
@@drlca6601ok, if so tell me one thing. Is Wedge Antiless or Antilles is the same person as captain Antilles (or Antiless). The R2D2's and C3PO's new master? From RotS's ending?
@@MC-ly4pm I believe the two have no relation in EU, though I don't know if the new Disney canon changed that
@@MC-ly4pmThey are different characters
I have fond memories of 'Yub Yub' because when I was in elementary school, our music teacher choreographed a dance to go along with 'Yub Yub'.
It doesn't matter which version. The fact is that Star Wars ends exactly at this point.
How about the return of admiral trawn?
@ndaru7412 this is great and a shame that it's not "official".
@@leonardoborges_oficial what did you mean not official bro??
@@ndaru7412 I mean it's not in the movie sequels.
@@leonardoborges_oficial i see, i thought you meant not official its not canon. well, if that's what you said, then it's definitely true hahaha
Just goes to show 1-6 can’t be beaten. Thank you George, Disney never could carry the mantle of your great story
Dave Filoni & Jon Favreau can though.
But Rogue One and Mandalorian are great.
Man 1-3 suck mando and rogue one is way better than them
lol at how all the zoomers trying to make the prequels seem good all of a sudden. Can't wait for the next generation to praise 1-9 when the next trilogy happens.
@@The_RedVIII Haha, nobody who really likes Starwars actually had a fulfilling emotional experience watching 7-9. 1-6 is best, always…great story arc overall. Sequels story was a total mess
This is how it really ENDED! (No Disney)
Disney never happened.
@@godzillakaijuboy it did happen
@@E4or16 (we pretend it didn't)
NinjaSteven YTッ Yeah, in alternate reality that really should have never existed.
@@dacstudios1168 don't you mean in another reality the squeals never existed?
I like the meme that shows the younglings killed by Anakin reacting to him showing up in Jedi Heaven. LOL
When I was a kid we had the special editions on VHS and for the longest time I thought that was the original ending music in ROTJ. I finally saw the original version on tv when I was like 15 and thought I was crazy for remembering it differently.
3:56 Jedi Temple in the background
Why didn’t they start a new Jedi order there
*Imperial Palace.
@@mysteriousdude6296 because actually anakin brought balance to the force by killing the jedis and the siths, If a new Jedi order was created again the effort of anakin would have been for nothing.
@@theleader7032 never thought of it like that. I guess it was truly his destiny to kill those younglings.
@@DarrellKeith_ watch this video it will explain it more in detail: th-cam.com/video/RxGoHS0f_DY/w-d-xo.html
I get goosebumps during the 2011 ending when i see the jedi temple in the background and than I see Anakin's force ghost. It really sends a message that people can be redeemed and deserve a second chance whether it is in life or death.
People who murder hundreds of children and blow up planets with millions of people and torture people relentlessly for 20+ years deserve redemption?
@@ajd7772Yes.
@@ajd7772yes
@@ajd7772 yes, they do.
@@ajd7772Redemption, forgiveness aren’t given because people deserve it but because they need it. It’s an act of mercy.
Honestly, the thing that makes the original the best to me is the pure happiness, pride, and joy on older Anikans face for his son when we see him in his glowing form. So much more impactful and beautiful!
I haven’t seen the original in years!! I’m old enough to remember watching Star Wars in ‘77 as a schoolboy. The ending, although kinda low key always felt satisfying to me. I think people of my age actually thought this was the end!!
Who cared ? Anakin Skywalker's seduction, into the Darkside of The Force, never tasted appealing. However, Ben 'Obi-Wan" Kenobi was of greater interest to me. What made him "The Only One"?⁷
"low key" 💀
They’re both fuckin awesome I love Star Wars
WHATWHENWHERE what about the last jedi?
We don't mention that abomination. Not anywhere near the holy presence of the Original Trilogy.
Even the prequels?
Im Stupid well the prequels had so really good parts and come questionable dialogue but I’d take them over that Disney shit
@@_im_stupid_ You mean, even the sequels?
To see the Jedi Temple in Coruscant just broke me down. It’s just all the series, that became part of my life.
Thank u George
The 2011 version showing prequel locations like Naboo and Coruscant really ties up both trilogies as a whole. Thank you George Lucas for creating such an amazing story.
I love the detail of the red communist style banner on Naboo at 3:40 for the liberation from a brutal fascist dictator.
Same! I really do think that was an intentional nod to the famous Reichstag photo when the Soviets brought an end to the war. Lucas also had lots of respect for Soviet cinema.
Weesa freee
The French revolutionaries also waved red flags, specially during the July revolution, as well as tricolor flags.
@@revolutionariesoffreedom2374 That's true, this is also one main reason why the Russian revolution and communists world wide have adapted that symbol later. In any case, it represented freedom and liberation.
2011 all the way.
fundhund62 not all the way...remove Hayden Christensen and put back Sebastian Shaw
+Joe V But why tho
Righto Righto you prefer creepy young Anakin? Lol look, for someone watching Star Wars in episodic order, Hayden makes more sense. Hell, use CGI Yoda and Ewan McGregor as Obi-Wan lol. Release order? Use Sebastian Shaw.
+Joe V Good point
2011 except Anakin
I just like the 2011 one better. Within a few seconds, Hayden made sure we felt the love Anakin had for the children he never come to know as a father. It's beautiful and heartbreaking at the same time.
I like it too because Anakin truly died when he became Darth Vader just like Kenobi said to Luke on Dagoba
I cannot get past all the quick cuts in the 2011 version when leia and Han reunite with Luke and everyone is hugging each other. They keep cutting over to c3po and r2, nothing is allowed a moment to build the emotions and resonate with the characters feelings between one another; it feels like a choppy compilation. No shot lasts more than a few seconds. It completely ruins the pacing up to that point. I’m not all the old version is better in every way, but all the editing they did right there in the new one feels so bizarre.
@@patricksnoring4739 just cram as much stuff in as possible
Yeah he wasn't a good father left like my old guy
And also makes sense: Anakin is trying to give Luke closure.
This is why i like Episode 6 is my favorite a happy ending to everyone Luke becomes the chosen one and He sees his dad reunited with Obi-wan and Yoda
I literally can't go one Star Wars video without the sequels being brought up. Give it a rest, damn.
And congratulations for being one of the one's to bring it up. :/
Yeah, constant whining. Jfc star wars fans are awful lmao. I like being able to watch and enjoy things without throwing a tantrum.
People keep whining about the sequels as if it they were released yesterday, it's almost been a decade 💀
@Sapocalipsis11 because all the new content is leaning into the sequels
2011 was the perfect ending to the empire, Deathstar 2 gone, Palpatine and Vader gone, whole galaxy celebrating and then they just ruined it by bringing back the empire in the form of the First Order w/ another Death Star . Why couldn't they just have a new threat?
The First Order is the new threat.
HFYYN like I said, First Order is basically the Empire (stormtroopers, starkiller base etc.) not necessarily what I would consider a new threat. We've seen it all before.
*at least until Thrawn returns, Palpatine Clones himself, Yzongvong, Krayt..*
“Bad men need nothing more to compass their ends, than that good men should look on and do nothing.”
Thrawn was the new threat, the 1st order doesn't hold a candle to that series.
I love the 2011 version more cuz the music is more touching for an ending, the scenes of all the galaxy celebrating the fall of emperor Palpatine's tyrany are perfect, they help to conect with everything that we've seen till this point and having Episode III Anakin as a force ghost goes better with it since this was the way he look right before he got tainted by the dark side.
Two things about 1983 that I like better: The Song and the fact that Vader is the face that Luke knew (nothing against Hayden Christensen). I do like the added celebration scenes from 2011.
Showing a young Anikn Skywalker, actually makes a hell of a lot more sense. I love it.
3:54 look at the crowd and you will see a stormtrooper being carried he even screams
Julian Shipp Jr He’s probably about to be executed which might explain the fact that there is someone willhem screaming at 3:55 because he was a stormtrooper and he was thrown down Coruscant
(If you do pick this up): Let's admit that-that stormtrooper was crowd surfing.
Poor guys were just following orders😢😢
I NEVER NOTICED THAT WOW
@@Highly-groundedso were the nazis
2011 is definitely better. The music is beautiful, and I also think it makes more sense to have Hayden appear as he is the Anakin we all know, and have followed throughout the movies
but he died as old anakin. just like yoda and obi-wan appeared as the last time we saw not some younger version. so it doesnt make sense
The 2011 doesn't have yub nub 😭
Anakin died a Jedi in episode 3. That’s how he looked.
yes but that knight anakin was more pure than old anakin
Darth Batman but he didnt look like a normal shaw. He had high degree burns and a huge scar on his head, thats how he died, so it makes no sense to put him as the normal unscared shaw either.
I always liked the 2011 version better. Seeing the celebrations on the other planets and then going back to Endor was a great touch. Also, I found the music to be a huge improvement. I never liked the music in the original. I feel like the music in the new version is more fitting.
I agree. Yub Nub was too whimsical a song for the conclusion of the trilogy. 2011's version still retains some of the Ewok influence, but its made more universal through toning the fun side down. It makes seeing the galaxy celebrating more appropriate, with just a tinge of melancholy
The main change was in 1997 for the 20th anniversary. This was the version I grew up with and is my favourite because it has the new John Williams music which I love and feel so much more epic than the Yub Nub. But it also has Sebastian Shaw as Anakin Skywalker which, in my opinion, is how Anakin's force ghost should look like
For me this is where Star Wars ended for the greater good.
The greater good.
@@JPwendi STOP SAYING THAT!
"the greater good."
@@mikes6457 gue'la mad
No lies detected
3:53 Poor Stormie's corpse/armor got held by the crowd 💀
I think they kill him in that scene you can here the willhelm scream
No i think he got harangued and as a punishment, got an surfboard through the crowd for free. @@Epicgirl3680
@Epicgirl3680, that wasn't him. It was another one at the start of that bit
@@1eyepaul oh shoot kk
There's a lot more interaction between Luke and Leia in the 1983 version, more beautiful, stronger and emotional. The way they look to each other and hold each other 😍
Anakin being young is so beautiful.. thats the man who luke was willing to die for.. the jedi Knight how he was 😢
I grew up on the special editions, so those will always be nostalgic to me. I do like how they don’t cut away in the original, but the music is so much better to me in the remastered
SE is a bit different as Sebastian Shaw is in the final scene and Ian McDiarmid isn't retconned into Ep. V like he was in 2004, but other than that they are pretty much the same. Theatrical and '97 versions deserve Blurays IMO.
@@drlca6601Absolutely agree! I was lucky enough to get the box set with the original theatrical versions on DVD but I would love to have the Special Editions also as I only have them on VHS. So much better than when they went back and started changing bits unnecessarily.
This is exactly how I feel.
This ending makes me hate 7 and 8. In 6, Anakin coming backing to the light, the Fall of the empire, RETURE OF THE JEDI!! Just to find out were back were we started😧
Ep. 6 was the REAL Star Wars ending.
True but you can argue anakins real purpose was to balance the force and bring an end to the sith which he did.
@@dramos8847 In the next Star Wars movie the Emperor isn't dead, Anakin's role to balance the Force basically didn't happen. Palpatine still lived and Anakin's sacrifice was all in vain...
doesnt make sense how first order rises and get so may resources to create a bigger army and deathstar.
I think anikan throwing Palpatine like 1000 feet down then a massive explosion should have killed him dont ya think. But noo disney says lets bring him back to life
No handshake between Luke and Han. Straight to a hug.
Also I know people get upset that the Hayden anakin is used at the end. But people who watch 1-6 for the first time in that order love it. My wife literally cried seeing younger Anakin redeemed and returned to his former self. Beautiful stuff. 2011 ending is way better.
This is one of the few places where I think they really did better with the changes, it does tie in with the other movies much better
I'm gonna say it, I liked that they added young Anakin (Hayden Christensen). Feels good to see him in these Jedi Robes, realizing he's free and was forgiven. A lot more emotional than seeing Sebastian Shaw imo.
Jo Harvelle same
The force ghost of Young Anakin Skywalker is way better than that other dude next to Yoda on the left in 1983
I think also in the 1983 version when Vader dies, it shows his eyebrows
Jo Harvelle anakin had time to change clothes? If you remember in RotS he had black robes but in the 2011 release anakin had beige and brown robes.
Also, no disrespect to Shaw but he looked too old as well. It's like they made him look he was the same age as Obi Wan or something. When Anakin died, he was like 45 year old. I wouldn't even be surprised if he still looked Young considering Qui Gone was 60 in TPM yet he looked 30.
Honestly both version are good but the 2011 version really has the "it's over" feeling
I think that sums it up perfectly
Good to see that people aren't saying 1 is ultimately better than the other because they both have their merits
the 2011 ending brought back memories when bin Laden died.
The 2011 version is actually the third version. I like the second version best. It is the same as the third but without Hayden Christensen.
Bringing back that old shit Palpatine back was really a slap in the face to the entire realm of Star Wars.
Really defeated the purpose of this film, but makes you wonder how he did return I guess
He somehow came back in legends too. Didn't see anyone complaining.
Thank you for that. I've missed seeing the versions that I grew up with.
If Vader hadn't died, just imagine the reactions of all the rebels on Endor because he has in some way shape or form fucked them over.
Even though Luke redeemed him, Vader still killed his aunt and uncle, his mentor, and cut off his right hand.
Then you have Leia, who Vader tortured for information and then destroyed her home planet. Then all of a sudden, she finds out he's her father.
And then you've got Han, who Vader tortured and put in carbonite before letting Boba Fett take him to Jabba the Hutt for three years.
Then Lando, who was just trying to protect the citizens of Bespin, then Vader just kept screwing him over and made him look like a huge, sell-out dickhead.
Even fucking Chewbacca, who Vader put into a chamber with loud, screeching noises and since Wookiees are based around dogs, we can imagine he has extremely sensitive hearing.
In all honesty, the only person who would have a positive reaction to seeing Anakin would be either R2 or 3PO, who just kind of knew Vader before he became a clunky robot servant with his dick burned off.
All around, the party on Endor would have been more awkward than when Travis Bickle took his girlfriend to a porn theater.
Max Isola 3PO didnt know after Episode III anymore
Never thought that way.
Obi-Wan let him kill himself.
Darth Vader isn't technically Anakin. Everything bad he did was as "Darth Vader", controlled by Sidious. At the end of the movie, Anakin was stronger than Darth Vader, and he took his body back.
Diogo David That's right, but many people won't core.
Diogo David Leia didn't forgive him until like 20 years later
In one of the comics it actually shows Vader ( or should I say Anakin) returning as a force ghost to Leía. She wanted nothing to do with him after all, he was partially responsible for the destruction of Alderaan and hated him for also torturing Han back on Bespin. It took awhile for her to forgive and wasn’t until he found young Anakin’s journals and found out that he had a lot of good within him. That’s when she decided to forgive him.
I love how Lando is just clapping at the end 😂
The originals and prequels will always be my favorite Star wars trilogys😊😊😊😊
I like the gungans dancing on the roof yelling we are free
2011 was cool because it connected it back to the prequels.
5:20-5:27 yep.
There's just one problem. You can't watch in release order anymore.
@@ECSOrder66why not?
@@ECSOrder66you can, I watched it in release order and it was fine
@@ECSOrder66 Who does that?
I love how the jedi Temple looks unchanged and how they brought light to the temple. Putting Return, in Return of the Jedi.
I can't say i like the 1983 version better. I think its more meaningful to see Hayden Christensen be anakin's ghost to sort of say: "only the light siders can live forever as a ghost." Also I think it's great to see the galaxy celebrating the death of Palpatine.
3:53 "F" for that stormtrooper lol
Watching Vader’s Jedi funeral makes me tear up a little every time. Knowing anakin was redeemed but tugs are heart strings
And then The First Order came out of nowhere....🤷♂️
George Lucas didn't create The First Order. Disney made up that thing
Watch Rise of Skywalker
@@solarpower26 I don't consider Disney star wars Canon the mandalorian is an exception because it's actually good
@Phantom 26 Well while it explains where First Order suddenly appeared/got its military power, its still stupid as shit....
Honestly Emperor/Palpatine should have remained dead after this, it made Vader's/Anakins death bit meaningless....
Even more so it officially made sequel trilogy just "Empire vs Rebels 2.0" except with much weaker set of characters. I had no problem with old cast returning, but I would have wanted some entirely new kind of story than just recycled plot elements from original trilogy
George Lucas created Star Wars. Anything made by other people, isn't real. It's just fanfiction..
I was borned 1992 and music from ending 2011 was already that time in film at 1997 when I saw original star wars trilogy for the first time... I think, it is for the first time I hear this music from 1986 and for me... d
Definitely the ending from 2011 with music is the real and beatiful ending of star wars saga... Brings me beatiful memories from the childhood and cruel fact that every great story comes To its end and so same young years of happiness of every people here, and that fact that the things will never be the same again... This ending of movie brings me always happy emotions of memories in past, same time always brings a little bit of sorrow too... 😊
The OT was never about wizards, laser swords, spaceships, robots or democracy. Star Wars was about Han, Luke and Leia. That’s it. That’s why it worked and that why we (Gen X) loved it. The original ending of Return of the Jedi drives that point home perfectly. It was a little story about those characters and their journey, not some huge, Dune-esque saga of politics and faith. But George just had to pry that complete and satisfying story back open to “expand” it so that he could continue to squeeze it dry. And once the carcass became empty, he sold its remains to a mouse that continues to perform God-knows-what selfish evils upon its legacy. Long live The Trilogy.
2011 ending has a much somber and bitter-sweet feeling to it. It actually makes me sad; just in a good way.
So triumphant, the empire has been defeated, the Jedi have returned, and the republic shall be restored. Our heroes will be there to ensure the path to peace, Han has changed from a smuggler to a hero of the Rebellion, Leia will be active in the new government, Luke will begin a new Jedi order that has learned from the past. THEN EVERYTHING WENT TO HELL.... In the end none of this mattered, the reset button is essentially hit and everything our heroes fought for, every sacrifice was all for nothing.
The new trilogy feels like as if the Empire had won, or if they'd remained almost just as powerful as they already were, despite the loss. Like an alternative universe.
Alternate universe would make them slightly more bearable.
If you see the stories from the old expanded Universe then you have another storys with weird situations. You have a new generation of jedi yes but you have a Luke on the dark site for a short Time. The Emperror come back. There is the yuuzhan vong. The Sequels have mistakes yes but I like there.
Luke on the dark side for a moment still cool. Maybe the Return of the Emperor as a clone was a bit much. And the Yuuzhan Vong were cool as well
I just don’t consider the sequels cannon and try to ignore them completely
I unironically love Yub Nub, I’m so sad It was cut out.
Obviously the 2011 there’s a lot more incredible “art” going on but what I really like is how Hayden appears cause after what we’ve seen (now) in 1-3, he’s the Anakin we’ve all grown to love… or hate. But love the fact that Luke can look upon his bad ass “good” father finally.