*Timestamps:* 0:00 - Introduction 0:18 - Background of Dr. Naoki 0:47 - Topics to be covered 2:45 - The Forgotten Islamic History of East Asia 5:52 - Islam in China 6:45 - Studying about Chinese Islam as a Japanese 9:07 - Islam in Japan 11:26 - Revert Story of Dr. Naoki 16:55 - Reasons for accepting Islam 18:14 - The Journey of being a Muslim 20:44 - Islamic History of China 23:36 - Muslims in China 25:35 - Muslim regions in China 27:20 - 4 Schools, 4 Tariqa 30:37 - Qīngzhēnsi Masjids in China 33:12 - History of Chinese Islam 35:32 - Ming Dynasty and the Muslims 37:12 - Hongwu Emperor's Eulogy for Muhammad ﷺ 39:50 - Was Hongwu Emperor of China a Muslim? 43:39 - Intellectual Tradition of Chinese Islam 46:34 - Emergence of Chinese Islamic Literature 48:22 - Use of the word "Kitab" in Islamic Civilisations 49:49 - The Han-Kitab 52:19 - Recommended Books on the Han-Kitab 53:11 - The Chinese Islamic Scholarship: Explaining Islam in Chinese Vocabulary 55:49 - The Legacy of the Chinese Islamic Scholar: Liu Zhi 57:54 - Islamic Philosophy: Hellenistic & Confucianistic Tradition 1:00:34 - Islam and Confucianism 1:06:54 - Kung Fu and Islam 1:10:47 - Actual Context of the Japanese Tea Ceremony 1:13:13 - Chinese Muslims as a Minority 1:14:06 - Loneliness as a Minority 1:15:41 - Jin Tianzhu: Eliminating Doubts against Islam 1:20:49 - Muslims being to closer to the teachings of Confucius & Jesus 1:23:02 - Jin Tianzhu's criticism of Buddhist Monks 1:24:28 - Jin Tianzhu being a Proud Chinese Muslim 1:25:15 - Lessons from the Chinese Muslims 1:30:05 - Role of Muslims in Modern Europe 1:32:26 - Using Local Vocabulary & Cultural Traditions to propagate Islam 1:34:50 - "Islam in China" by James Frankel 1:36:06 - Academic Aspirations of Dr. Naoki 1:39:33 - The Issue of Nation-State Mindset 1:41:56 - Reconstructing the Islamic Kitab Civilisation 1:43:19 - Brother Paul praises Dr. Naoki 1:44:10 - Need of Recognition of the Kitab Tradition of China 1:44:57 - East vs West Islamic Civilisations 1:47:04 - Closing Remarks SubhanAllah ❤️🤍💖 Amazing Presentation & Discussion 👍🏻👌🏻 _May Allah ﷻ bless you both and reward you for your efforts._ 🤲🏻
The beauty of ISLAM ...the interviewer is an Englishman and the gentleman giving the interview is Japanese. Still, they greeted each other in a standard greeting. ASALAMO ALEKUM
An Englishman and a Japanese discussing Islam is really overwhelming. In this month of Zulhijjah, Muslims gather to perform the Hajj regardless of race and social status. This is the beauty of Islam in uniting humankind. May Allah bless us all and make us the best Muslims. Aamiin.
As another convert (Mexican background), it is refreshing to see people from some different backgrounds discuss Islam. It is also very true, a lot of people don't have a specific reason or dramatic story for becoming Muslim. This isn't surprising as this is the religion of human nature دين الفطرة Also I used to live in China. The Muslims there are very nice and the culture is very interesting. They have halal restaurants everywhere that serve Lanzhou cuisine (Hui Chinese food)
Indeed our sisters and brothers in China are giving a good picture of Islam to the people who come in contact with them. I lived in Japan some 20 years ago and I remember very vividly meeting a young Japanese man in the city of Sendai. He came to the city's small prayer hall because there was no mosque in the city of Fokushima in the neighbouring prefecture. He was so happy to show the certificate of conversion from the islamic centre in Tokyo. That young man was fascinated by chinese muslims when he visited the country and ended up becoming Muslim..MashAllah.
Admiral Cheng Ho is the most well-known chinese muslim. We are a family of Yamamoto, my Japan's name is Hisato Yamamoto and my Indonesia's name is Muhammad Hendriyawan, greet from me from Indonesia my brother Prof Naoki Yamamoto.
Malaysian here. My great grandmother from maternal side was a Chinese convert to Islam. Long story short a lot of my rakyat(people) and friends thought i was a chinese even today. Little did they know i'm actually a Malay-Chinese Muslim and i can't even speak chinese lol
This channel has never been ordinary, it has always maintained its quality and is on the rise among other similar ones. Paul, we are proud of you. Thank you!
Both gentlemen reverted few years back. I am born muslim in a generations back Muslims family and I am here to learn about Islam and I actually learnt . May Allah almighty bless you with more knowledge and reward you for your hard work.
@@TheWatchmanWebsite COULD YOU STOP SPREADING YOUR LIES IN THIS MUSLIM CHANNEL? YOU CAN GIVE YOUR ADVICE IN THE CHURCH TO CHRISTIANS ONLY, BUT TO US MUSLIMS, WE KNOW OUR QURAN, THE MUSLIM HISTORY, ISLAMIC STUDIES ETC. SINCE YOUNG IN SCHOOL. THOSE WHO HAVE REVERTED TO ISLAM, THEY SEE BEAUTY IN ISLAM. AND YOU ONLY CREATE YOUR OWN TALES ABOUT ISLAM... STOP BEING LIKE KKK OR THE CRUSADERS OR THE COLONIZERS, WHO TRIED TO PERSUADE, EVEN FORCED OTHER PEOPLE TO WORSHIP THE CREATION, NOT THE TRUE CREATOR!!! PLEASE DON'T BE IGNORANT & STUDY MORE ESPECIALLY THE COMPARISON IN RELIGIONS. LEARN WITH AN OPEN HEART & BE OPEN-MINDED TO FIND THE TRUTH😊
Dr. Naoki Yamamoto does a good job of pointing out how much our identities are embedded in ethno-centrism and nationalities. He thinks ahead in the future when there would be a thriving Muslim community in Japan too. May God help him in his endeavors.
@@Cheeky_Sheikhy america or europe arent called inclusive despite what they do to traitors, dont suddenly use a different measurement when it suits you.
I am a born Muslim from a majority Muslim country living in a Dutch city with a LARGE Islamic presence. I am having lunch in a Turkish restaurant while listening to this. And I can relate because the reason I am listening to this while eating is because I am sitting at a table for one. So don't be sad if you're the only Muslim in your community. Born Muslim or living in a Muslim community doesn't automatically translate into a Muslim family. So just be proud and grateful that Allah choose you and your religion isn't just your culture Alhamdulillah wa Allahou Akbar
You cannot be a Muslim unless you have knowledge to understand the reality of the Truth about ISLAM and it's legislated platforms according to the Sunnah of Muhammad salalahu alaihi wasalaam and the Companions... So what is ISLAM by definition? In one WORD...
Ps I can't even go back to that restaurant. The owner shamed me in front of all the other customers for ordering TWO lahmacuns for myself. I thought I would do the smart thing and not engage, but she was like a dog with a bone. I was news in the kitchen too because when I got up to leave the cook asked me if I finished them both. I was already in doubt because of the coffee, but to shame my food choices that I paid for, wow! -Are they both for you?! - I thought someone would join you? -Where you THAT hungry?! Me :🤨 - I guess you needed the energy
_"I want to contribute for the next generation"_ - Professor Naoki Yamamoto _"This nation-state mindset is so firmly embedded in our brain! So, every Muslim think that their version of Islamic culture is the best!"_ - *Professor Naoki Yamamoto* _"We muslims we are so haunted by this 'National identity'... So, we should reconstruct our identity as a member of 'United Ummah'... We should learn a lesson not only from our own heritage, but also the heritage of the other culture as well"_ - *Professor Naoki Yamamoto* _"We muslims should know Islamic civilization is a diverse!"_ - *Professor Naoki Yamamoto* Those were among the crucial take-aways I personally got from this beautiful academic discussion! Thank you brother Paul and Professor Naoki Yamamoto for such great productive content.
I love this channel. Paul is truly an amazing guy with much knowledge to share with us muslims & non muslims. His guests are fantastic , those you cant help but admire & respect . So inspiring. Salute to Paul.
Hello!! I want to thank you from the bottom of my heart. I am a Cantonese convert muslim living in montreal. Feel so lonely :/ but now knowing that islam and chinese traidition goes along makes me happy.
welcome brother, Canton was one of the first region in China that has a huge Muslim community since 1000 years ago and if i'm not mistaken one of the oldest mosque in China was in Canton. SO cantonese Muslim is our earliest brothers! But during the Song dynasty there was a conflict with the emperor and the Muslim community there because the chinese nobles are jealous of the prosperity of the Muslim merchants over there so 800 000 Muslim were killed and a lot of them fled to South East Asia and married locals here. Im not sure the Mosque is still there or not. But Arabs used to call Canton as Zaitun.
@@wewenang5167 Now the conditions are reversed, Chinese people who are prosperous in other countries are exposed to a lot of discrimination, maybe in Hinduism it is called karma
As a Chinese Muslim, it's good to see a Japanese Muslim mentioned our shared history bounds from a Islamic perspective, which I currently am incapable to share out of many reasons, and what always wonders me is that why Chinese Islam didn't reach to Korea and Japan like Chinese Buddhism did during Tang dynasty and later. And why Korea and Japan didn't really have that much Islamic history like China have.
Maybe because of politics....from my understanding Chinese Muslims never become a part of ruling division...Every ruler in Chinese dynasties is non muslim (please correct me if im wrong)
@@ezzwizz5219 Chinese rulers are not so interested in religions, though some of them are Buddhists or Taoists, they are unlikely to send a group of Buddhist missionaries to Japan and Korea to preach. And even if we Chinese Muslims were never really the ruling classes of the whole nation, we did helped preaching Islam to Malaysia and Indonesia during 14---15 century, I just don't know why it didn't take place in Korea and Japan
@@ezzwizz5219 during Yuan dynasty there were few governors who are Muslim, and a Muslim governor did great contribution for the growth of Islam in Yunnan province.
@@renleihuman4551 maybe at that time Japan and Korea didn't open to outsider, im from Malaysia and the main reason islam spread in Malaysia and Indonesia is through trade....
@@ezzwizz5219 I don't quite familiar with early history of Islam in Malaysia but I do know that trades is the key element, and Muslim citizens in Hokkien province of China helped spreading Islam in Malaysia and Indonesia with other Muslims, I was surprised when I first knowing it.
I believe the name of the Professor that he contacted was Prof Hasan Ko Nakata. I met him and became his interpreter when he gave a lecture in our university.
May Allah bless you ustadh Paul for using your platform to teach Muslims about topics we desperately need exposure especially the history of our ummah in this duniya, i wish you can bring ustadh naoki again for more indepth about Chinese Muslims intellectual dialogue and contribution to the history of China. Also i would like you to ask ustadh adnan rashid for an indepth episode on islam in india.
@@BloggingTheology .Truly interesting,I just enjoy the intellectual discourse at every occasion ,for it was inthat sense what is found in CHEIKH HAMZAH YUSSEF, ABDAL HAKIM MURAD .YET that is what the Quran teach ,as an advice and a challenge as in this AAYAH " FA' LAM ANNAHU LAA ELAAHA ELLAA HU."SO with that ponderous mind for one to admit the EXISTENCE of a Super powerful beyond anything about the realm of Our environment and even more.Sir Paul this is a refreshing site.Glad I found your channel.
This channel is becoming beyond a youtube channel and a podcast. It's going to be University and real life course. Hats off brother Paul for all the work that you put in.
Japanese from Turkey 🇹🇷 speaks English talks about Chinese 🇨🇳 along with British in American platform, respect from San Francisco ❤ alhamdulila Islam is the only solution for all the problems in the world 🌎
I am so glad to see Yamamoto San on your channel. Thank you brother Paul for leading such brilliant conversations. This channel provides opportunities for real Dawah that crosses international boundaries and cultures.
I have many Chinese friends in Australia and lived with them for a couple of years. I completely agree with Dr. Naoki that somehow any non-East Asian way of dawah and articulation of Islam somehow doesn't penetrate. Most of them agree logically with everything Islam offers. However, there is still an invisible barrier, which as a non-Chinese, I don't think I'll ever be able to overcome. We need to sow the seed to cultivate indigenous East Asian scholars speaking to their community in their own language within their context. May Allah reward you brother Paul for bringing such intriguing guests. I love your work and the way you conduct these sessions.
Allah bless you both. I’ve always had a deep seated belief that the importance of honor, cleanliness, and excellence would make the Japanese naturally attracted to Islam if it was presented appropriately. Islam is indeed the quality control that removes what is harmful and promotes what is good in every culture, while allowing the uniqueness and beauty to thrive. When I read the Tao Te Ching, I see Islam in almost every line.
Thank you Mr. Williams for your continuous informative videos about Islam as a non-national subject, but a global one. Also thanks to Prof. Yamamoto for his unique study about Chinese Islam; and for him reminding us that Islam -as it is-is the "best" Islam, not necessarily the Islam of the Arabs, or the Persians, or the Turks, with all due respect to all. Very well appreciated.
It was quite an interesting lecture. If I were to summarize it I'd say islam surpass the boundaries of national identities since every muslim is a part of this united ummah. Btw paul it would be really good if u drop another episode about etiquette from Al Adab Al Mufrad
Thank you Paul and thank you Prof. Yamamoto. I’ve learned so much about Islam in Eastern Asia. May Allah reward you both and may Allah alleviate the hardship of our brethren in the Uyghur Region and around the world
What a wonderful guess. He so unique in his perscpective. His point about Nationalism dividing the Ummah is valid and it is also true that there is a problem in communication with those out side a certain fath tradition and how the local language and culture can misinterpret words and rituals causing push back undeccessarily. People in general assume things in error to the facts. Thanks for the discussion it was truly fascinating and illuminating.
This was absolutely fascinating, to say the least. Such an informative discussion. Especially enjoyed hearing the professor's perspective on mainstream Islam in contemporary times and how it relates back to the Orient (China, Japan etc.). Jazakallah khair for another wonderful interview, brother Paul 🌷
SubhanAllah, I wish Islam reaches the hearts of more Japanese people InshaAllah. Really impressed by the intellect of this professor and how he has chosen to lead his life, MashaAllah.
Just coming across this video and very happy i did. This speaks to my experience of my journey to Islam. Dr. Yamaoto's commentary is very important for Muslims from other geographic locations to understand that Islam melds into the people/culture it joins, not that an "Arabized" culture should represent Islam as a faith or culture alone. I became Muslim in China through Hui Muslims, his family had been Muslim for more than 1350 years, while a language student at Beijing University over 40 years ago. When I spent time as a language student and expat in the Middle East a decade later, I am so glad I was introduced to Islam outside of the Middle East...an understanding of Islam that was more kind, inclusive, and inculcating a softness toward others from Far Eastern philosophies--and not flagellation from an "Islam is superior-ity" complex that is not obvious to many Muslims bound to traditional thinking. Just take a look at the knee-jerk reactions of most Muslims in traditional Muslim states...form over substance.
Nice lecturing..i hope to be made a video about islam in southeast asia soon,since we are the the region that has the biggest muslim population in the world.. I hope with such video will help understanding our brothers and sisters in the west that being muslim does not mean being an arab or pakistani or middle eastern, we can still be muslim regardless of our own ethnicities..jazaakallah khairan brother Paul
@@mariyabiswas3391 yeah sorry,i mean the most predominant muslim in a country is actually Indonesia. India has much larger muslim population than indonesia, but they are just minority in the country of India.
There are great japanese scholars on Islam and myself enjoyed islamic books written by japanese scholars, unlike those written by orientalists. I pray that Allah swt give hidayah of Islam to the Japanese, koreans, taiwanese, latin Americans and Europe.
My guess was correct, he's a Japanese man because of his name ,the topic was confusing I thought he's a Chinese man. I'm glad and happy for him that he's a Muslim
There is another expert who writes in English about Chinese Islam who is Japanese: it is Murata Sachiko. She has severla books that are really interesting. Really recommend to read her work.
This session was so rich of excellent information! Thank you both for your research and bringing this to us. Dr Naoki is so correct that we need to come out of the nationalistic mindset and work together and learn from all the experts in the Ummah. Thank you for all your hard work in breaking barriers.
Thank you for interviewing Dr. Naoki Yamamoto! It is interesting to learn about Muslims from other people and their cultures. Unfortunately, I don't know much about Chinese Muslims. Thank you Dr. Naoki for sharing some history of Islam and Muslims in China.
I am from padang, Indonesia, at the 80s when I was at elementary school, we studied read quran at surau (madrasah), we wear peci (malay traditional hat) and baju koko or baju gunting cina (Chinese cut clothes). That how Chinese culture influence and mix with our malay (minangkabau) tradition.
One of the most thought provoking conversations surrounding the topic. The dialouge really highlights the fact that in some way, every single pre-islamic human civilisation had divine elements found in its roots. Evidently, it's understood that there has been hundreds of thousands of prophets before nabi Muhammed (pbuh) sent to these different cultures. Theories around Plato and other prominent historical figures that played a role in formulating a societal practice potentialy are interesting examples of this. Islam's arrival truly revolved around brining all of these accumulated diviations of faith back to its initial core beliefs. Really something grand and amazing to think about.
59:55 the Professor stated it very well that Islam was able to accommodate both Hellenistic and Confucius philosophies and it did so without there being any theological fractures within the Islamic civilization. This truly shows Islam’s universality.
@@BloggingTheology Thank you Ustadh Paul for replying to my comment. Please make dua for me and my mother. I m personally stuck and my mom is terminally ill
Paul I'm sure your conversion story isn't boring, any experience of embracing Islam is a special thing :) I personally would be interested in learning how you converted.
Great, great video even by just listening to this epic discussion, thank you so much both of you, you guys are doing a great job and may Allah always guide us all to His open arm,Salam for all
Wow what an interesting video today Paul :) I’ve wondered a lot about Islam in China from someone who’s studied it’s history in depth especially with the current oppression against the Uighur people. Great video once again Paul:)
I don't know if Br. Paul did this on purpose, but having the guy tell his story first makes it a lot better than start with the history of Islam in China. If it was done on purpose, kudos Paul.
Brother Paul is a great interviewer and knows how to ask the right questions at the right time….I really wished he had his own TV program….May Allahﷻ reward brother Paul…Ameen
Allah knowing everyone of us n preserving Islam ☪️ by creating us to be a Muslims .. possibly to leading Islam for everyone n giving to those that are able to …. May we among the chosen one , always….Ameen 🤲🤲
*Timestamps:*
0:00 - Introduction
0:18 - Background of Dr. Naoki
0:47 - Topics to be covered
2:45 - The Forgotten Islamic History of East Asia
5:52 - Islam in China
6:45 - Studying about Chinese Islam as a Japanese
9:07 - Islam in Japan
11:26 - Revert Story of Dr. Naoki
16:55 - Reasons for accepting Islam
18:14 - The Journey of being a Muslim
20:44 - Islamic History of China
23:36 - Muslims in China
25:35 - Muslim regions in China
27:20 - 4 Schools, 4 Tariqa
30:37 - Qīngzhēnsi Masjids in China
33:12 - History of Chinese Islam
35:32 - Ming Dynasty and the Muslims
37:12 - Hongwu Emperor's Eulogy for Muhammad ﷺ
39:50 - Was Hongwu Emperor of China a Muslim?
43:39 - Intellectual Tradition of Chinese Islam
46:34 - Emergence of Chinese Islamic Literature
48:22 - Use of the word "Kitab" in Islamic Civilisations
49:49 - The Han-Kitab
52:19 - Recommended Books on the Han-Kitab
53:11 - The Chinese Islamic Scholarship: Explaining Islam in Chinese Vocabulary
55:49 - The Legacy of the Chinese Islamic Scholar: Liu Zhi
57:54 - Islamic Philosophy: Hellenistic & Confucianistic Tradition
1:00:34 - Islam and Confucianism
1:06:54 - Kung Fu and Islam
1:10:47 - Actual Context of the Japanese Tea Ceremony
1:13:13 - Chinese Muslims as a Minority
1:14:06 - Loneliness as a Minority
1:15:41 - Jin Tianzhu: Eliminating Doubts against Islam
1:20:49 - Muslims being to closer to the teachings of Confucius & Jesus
1:23:02 - Jin Tianzhu's criticism of Buddhist Monks
1:24:28 - Jin Tianzhu being a Proud Chinese Muslim
1:25:15 - Lessons from the Chinese Muslims
1:30:05 - Role of Muslims in Modern Europe
1:32:26 - Using Local Vocabulary & Cultural Traditions to propagate Islam
1:34:50 - "Islam in China" by James Frankel
1:36:06 - Academic Aspirations of Dr. Naoki
1:39:33 - The Issue of Nation-State Mindset
1:41:56 - Reconstructing the Islamic Kitab Civilisation
1:43:19 - Brother Paul praises Dr. Naoki
1:44:10 - Need of Recognition of the Kitab Tradition of China
1:44:57 - East vs West Islamic Civilisations
1:47:04 - Closing Remarks
SubhanAllah ❤️🤍💖
Amazing Presentation & Discussion 👍🏻👌🏻
_May Allah ﷻ bless you both and reward you for your efforts._ 🤲🏻
Jazakallah Khair 😄
@Asadullah SAAiD Many thanks!
@@BloggingTheology You're Most Welcome Sir 😄
@@asadullahsaaid3794 _Thanks for taking the time and do a very productive deed. May Allah multiply your reward on these ten days of Dhul Hijjh_
@@seekfactsnotfiction9056 بارك اللٰه فيك أخي ❤️
The beauty of ISLAM ...the interviewer is an Englishman and the gentleman giving the interview is Japanese. Still, they greeted each other in a standard greeting. ASALAMO ALEKUM
The only, and I mean ONLY, belief system that can and has successfully united men and women of all races and skin colours on such an enormous scale.
Such a beautiful comment, Allhumdlillah
Subhanah Allah 💕
@@noorjahan1333 which verses bruh?
We cannot change anything from Quran and never will.
Mashaa'Allah Quran is always the best.
@@noorjahan1333 you're a hindu masquerading as a muslim.
An Englishman and a Japanese discussing Islam is really overwhelming. In this month of Zulhijjah, Muslims gather to perform the Hajj regardless of race and social status. This is the beauty of Islam in uniting humankind. May Allah bless us all and make us the best Muslims. Aamiin.
Further testimony to the universal brotherhood and sisterhood preached in Islam. ALLAHU AKBAR
Why it's overwalming?
İslam is international Religion.
Muslim muslim karke pura beda garg kar diya pure kom ka... Mubarak ho
The west will embrace Islam perhaps not our lifetime, but it’s matter of time.
I agree my brother, this is definitely the beauty of Islam....it's amazing! Alhumdullilah
As another convert (Mexican background), it is refreshing to see people from some different backgrounds discuss Islam. It is also very true, a lot of people don't have a specific reason or dramatic story for becoming Muslim. This isn't surprising as this is the religion of human nature دين الفطرة
Also I used to live in China. The Muslims there are very nice and the culture is very interesting. They have halal restaurants everywhere that serve Lanzhou cuisine (Hui Chinese food)
Indeed our sisters and brothers in China are giving a good picture of Islam to the people who come in contact with them.
I lived in Japan some 20 years ago and I remember very vividly meeting a young Japanese man in the city of Sendai. He came to the city's small prayer hall because there was no mosque in the city of Fokushima in the neighbouring prefecture. He was so happy to show the certificate of conversion from the islamic centre in Tokyo. That young man was fascinated by chinese muslims when he visited the country and ended up becoming Muslim..MashAllah.
Admiral Cheng Ho is the most well-known chinese muslim. We are a family of Yamamoto, my Japan's name is Hisato Yamamoto and my Indonesia's name is Muhammad Hendriyawan, greet from me from Indonesia my brother Prof Naoki Yamamoto.
May Islam unite the Japanese and Chinese
I think he's probably well-known in Malaysia too!
@@faatihahnizam3582 Yes brother, not only in Malaysia but also in Indonesia too.
Zheng He is a Persian muslim. As we known he was taken as slave during Ming Dynasty era.
Malaysian here. My great grandmother from maternal side was a Chinese convert to Islam. Long story short a lot of my rakyat(people) and friends thought i was a chinese even today. Little did they know i'm actually a Malay-Chinese Muslim and i can't even speak chinese lol
This channel has never been ordinary, it has always maintained its quality and is on the rise among other similar ones. Paul, we are proud of you. Thank you!
Alhamdulillah
@@BloggingTheology Absolutely! Alhamdulillah...
Both gentlemen reverted few years back. I am born muslim in a generations back Muslims family and I am here to learn about Islam and I actually learnt .
May Allah almighty bless you with more knowledge and reward you for your hard work.
@@TheWatchmanWebsite COULD YOU STOP SPREADING YOUR LIES IN THIS MUSLIM CHANNEL?
YOU CAN GIVE YOUR ADVICE IN THE CHURCH TO CHRISTIANS ONLY, BUT TO US MUSLIMS, WE KNOW OUR QURAN, THE MUSLIM HISTORY, ISLAMIC STUDIES ETC. SINCE YOUNG IN SCHOOL. THOSE WHO HAVE REVERTED TO ISLAM, THEY SEE BEAUTY IN ISLAM. AND YOU ONLY CREATE YOUR OWN TALES ABOUT ISLAM... STOP BEING LIKE KKK OR THE CRUSADERS OR THE COLONIZERS, WHO TRIED TO PERSUADE, EVEN FORCED OTHER PEOPLE TO WORSHIP THE CREATION, NOT THE TRUE CREATOR!!! PLEASE DON'T BE IGNORANT & STUDY MORE ESPECIALLY THE COMPARISON IN RELIGIONS. LEARN WITH AN OPEN HEART & BE OPEN-MINDED TO FIND THE TRUTH😊
Same to me
Dr. Naoki Yamamoto does a good job of pointing out how much our identities are embedded in ethno-centrism and nationalities. He thinks ahead in the future when there would be a thriving Muslim community in Japan too. May God help him in his endeavors.
A Japanese and a British muslims conversing, not in my wildest dreams, mashallah, love this
AND talking about Islam in China
Talk about inclusivity. Subhanallah for Islam, its truly the most unifying force in this life.
@@yade5979 inclusivity? What if one of them apostatised?
@@Cheeky_Sheikhy america or europe arent called inclusive despite what they do to traitors, dont suddenly use a different measurement when it suits you.
What makes you a Muslim???
Do you really know Islam???
How is it that all of you Muslim have to bow down to a black stone Kaaba???
I am a born Muslim from a majority Muslim country living in a Dutch city with a LARGE Islamic presence. I am having lunch in a Turkish restaurant while listening to this.
And I can relate because the reason I am listening to this while eating is because I am sitting at a table for one.
So don't be sad if you're the only Muslim in your community.
Born Muslim or living in a Muslim community doesn't automatically translate into a Muslim family.
So just be proud and grateful that Allah choose you and your religion isn't just your culture
Alhamdulillah wa Allahou Akbar
You cannot be a Muslim unless you have knowledge to understand the reality of the Truth about ISLAM and it's legislated platforms according to the Sunnah of Muhammad salalahu alaihi wasalaam and the Companions...
So what is ISLAM by definition? In one WORD...
@@orlandogivens4779 I rest my case
Ps I can't even go back to that restaurant. The owner shamed me in front of all the other customers for ordering TWO lahmacuns for myself.
I thought I would do the smart thing and not engage, but she was like a dog with a bone. I was news in the kitchen too because when I got up to leave the cook asked me if I finished them both.
I was already in doubt because of the coffee, but to shame my food choices that I paid for, wow!
-Are they both for you?!
- I thought someone would join you?
-Where you THAT hungry?!
Me :🤨
- I guess you needed the energy
_"I want to contribute for the next generation"_ - Professor Naoki Yamamoto
_"This nation-state mindset is so firmly embedded in our brain! So, every Muslim think that their version of Islamic culture is the best!"_ - *Professor Naoki Yamamoto*
_"We muslims we are so haunted by this 'National identity'... So, we should reconstruct our identity as a member of 'United Ummah'... We should learn a lesson not only from our own heritage, but also the heritage of the other culture as well"_ - *Professor Naoki Yamamoto*
_"We muslims should know Islamic civilization is a diverse!"_ - *Professor Naoki Yamamoto*
Those were among the crucial take-aways I personally got from this beautiful academic discussion! Thank you brother Paul and Professor Naoki Yamamoto for such great productive content.
I love this channel. Paul is truly an amazing guy with much knowledge to share with us muslims & non muslims. His guests are fantastic , those you cant help but admire & respect . So inspiring.
Salute to Paul.
Alhamdulillah
Hello!! I want to thank you from the bottom of my heart. I am a Cantonese convert muslim living in montreal. Feel so lonely :/ but now knowing that islam and chinese traidition goes along makes me happy.
welcome brother, Canton was one of the first region in China that has a huge Muslim community since 1000 years ago and if i'm not mistaken one of the oldest mosque in China was in Canton. SO cantonese Muslim is our earliest brothers! But during the Song dynasty there was a conflict with the emperor and the Muslim community there because the chinese nobles are jealous of the prosperity of the Muslim merchants over there so 800 000 Muslim were killed and a lot of them fled to South East Asia and married locals here. Im not sure the Mosque is still there or not. But Arabs used to call Canton as Zaitun.
@@wewenang5167 Interesting, You got a resource where I can read about it?
@@wewenang5167 Now the conditions are reversed, Chinese people who are prosperous in other countries are exposed to a lot of discrimination, maybe in Hinduism it is called karma
As a Chinese Muslim, it's good to see a Japanese Muslim mentioned our shared history bounds from a Islamic perspective, which I currently am incapable to share out of many reasons, and what always wonders me is that why Chinese Islam didn't reach to Korea and Japan like Chinese Buddhism did during Tang dynasty and later. And why Korea and Japan didn't really have that much Islamic history like China have.
Maybe because of politics....from my understanding Chinese Muslims never become a part of ruling division...Every ruler in Chinese dynasties is non muslim (please correct me if im wrong)
@@ezzwizz5219 Chinese rulers are not so interested in religions, though some of them are Buddhists or Taoists, they are unlikely to send a group of Buddhist missionaries to Japan and Korea to preach. And even if we Chinese Muslims were never really the ruling classes of the whole nation, we did helped preaching Islam to Malaysia and Indonesia during 14---15 century, I just don't know why it didn't take place in Korea and Japan
@@ezzwizz5219 during Yuan dynasty there were few governors who are Muslim, and a Muslim governor did great contribution for the growth of Islam in Yunnan province.
@@renleihuman4551 maybe at that time Japan and Korea didn't open to outsider, im from Malaysia and the main reason islam spread in Malaysia and Indonesia is through trade....
@@ezzwizz5219 I don't quite familiar with early history of Islam in Malaysia but I do know that trades is the key element, and Muslim citizens in Hokkien province of China helped spreading Islam in Malaysia and Indonesia with other Muslims, I was surprised when I first knowing it.
I believe the name of the Professor that he contacted was Prof Hasan Ko Nakata. I met him and became his interpreter when he gave a lecture in our university.
I love that brother Naoki said we are a kitab civilization. Very nice definition
May Allah bless you ustadh Paul for using your platform to teach Muslims about topics we desperately need exposure especially the history of our ummah in this duniya, i wish you can bring ustadh naoki again for more indepth about Chinese Muslims intellectual dialogue and contribution to the history of China. Also i would like you to ask ustadh adnan rashid for an indepth episode on islam in india.
Mashallah Absolutley amazed by these intellectual dialogues almost on daily basis, something I longed for. Thanks for making this happen.
Glad you enjoyed it!
The Islamic/Interfaith/Theological discourse on YT unfortunately was very blah until Paul came around.
@@BloggingTheology .Truly interesting,I just enjoy the intellectual discourse at every occasion ,for it was inthat sense what is found in CHEIKH HAMZAH YUSSEF, ABDAL HAKIM MURAD .YET that is what the Quran teach ,as an advice and a challenge as in this AAYAH " FA' LAM ANNAHU LAA ELAAHA ELLAA HU."SO with that ponderous mind for one to admit the EXISTENCE of a Super powerful beyond anything about the realm of Our environment and even more.Sir Paul this is a refreshing site.Glad I found your channel.
This channel is pure intelligence and excellence. I came here to increase my intellect. Love this channel ❤️
Glad you enjoy it!
I also am hoping to "increase my intellect" through Blogging Theology. Peace of God to you
So true. As a born Muslim I learn a tremendous amount from this channel
This channel just keeps on giving, amazing work.
This channel is becoming beyond a youtube channel and a podcast. It's going to be University and real life course. Hats off brother Paul for all the work that you put in.
Selam from China
Wa alaykumu s-salam
Japanese from Turkey 🇹🇷 speaks English talks about Chinese 🇨🇳 along with British in American platform, respect from San Francisco ❤ alhamdulila Islam is the only solution for all the problems in the world 🌎
I am so glad to see Yamamoto San on your channel. Thank you brother Paul for leading such brilliant conversations. This channel provides opportunities for real Dawah that crosses international boundaries and cultures.
I have many Chinese friends in Australia and lived with them for a couple of years. I completely agree with Dr. Naoki that somehow any non-East Asian way of dawah and articulation of Islam somehow doesn't penetrate. Most of them agree logically with everything Islam offers. However, there is still an invisible barrier, which as a non-Chinese, I don't think I'll ever be able to overcome. We need to sow the seed to cultivate indigenous East Asian scholars speaking to their community in their own language within their context.
May Allah reward you brother Paul for bringing such intriguing guests. I love your work and the way you conduct these sessions.
Very appreciate to introduce Chinese Islami
your reversion story Professor Yamamoto is actually one of the most fascinating and touching ones I've heard, mashAllah
Is it in this video or somewhere else?
@@ermins.newyork7434this one at 11:26
Made me cry!
Allah bless you both. I’ve always had a deep seated belief that the importance of honor, cleanliness, and excellence would make the Japanese naturally attracted to Islam if it was presented appropriately. Islam is indeed the quality control that removes what is harmful and promotes what is good in every culture, while allowing the uniqueness and beauty to thrive. When I read the Tao Te Ching, I see Islam in almost every line.
Thank you Mr. Williams for your continuous informative videos about Islam as a non-national subject, but a global one. Also thanks to Prof. Yamamoto for his unique study about Chinese Islam; and for him reminding us that Islam -as it is-is the "best" Islam, not necessarily the Islam of the Arabs, or the Persians, or the Turks, with all due respect to all. Very well appreciated.
Yes, love the internationality of this channel and how broad the topics are.
I also started crying when I heard the story when he said the story at 14:05, beautiful
It was quite an interesting lecture. If I were to summarize it I'd say islam surpass the boundaries of national identities since every muslim is a part of this united ummah.
Btw paul it would be really good if u drop another episode about etiquette from Al Adab Al Mufrad
Alhamdulilah. Very interesting subject. Bravo.
Thank you Paul and thank you Prof. Yamamoto. I’ve learned so much about Islam in Eastern Asia. May Allah reward you both and may Allah alleviate the hardship of our brethren in the Uyghur Region and around the world
I'm so happy to see Ummah in every diffrent nation around the world , and making Islam more beautiful to humanity .. 🌺
So enlightening Professor Yamamoto.
Thanks for contributing to our growth.
Thanks also to you, Paul.
👍🏽😘
What a wonderful guess. He so unique in his perscpective. His point about Nationalism dividing the Ummah is valid and it is also true that there is a problem in communication with those out side a certain fath tradition and how the local language and culture can misinterpret words and rituals causing push back undeccessarily. People in general assume things in error to the facts. Thanks for the discussion it was truly fascinating and illuminating.
This was absolutely fascinating, to say the least. Such an informative discussion. Especially enjoyed hearing the professor's perspective on mainstream Islam in contemporary times and how it relates back to the Orient (China, Japan etc.). Jazakallah khair for another wonderful interview, brother Paul 🌷
Wow Dr Naoki Yamamoto is a marvel I love this guy what an extraordinary and fresh perspective.
Amazing contents .... Love from 🇲🇾
This is beautiful 🙏🏾❤
May Allah grant both of you Jannah In Shaa Allah.
Really love your program and all the guests you bring on for the debate or discussion….May Allahﷻ reward you immensely brother.
SubhanAllah, I wish Islam reaches the hearts of more Japanese people InshaAllah. Really impressed by the intellect of this professor and how he has chosen to lead his life, MashaAllah.
Inspiring, may Allah bless this brother and his mission.
Dear Paul Allah bless you you are doing great work on this planet and we love you
Just coming across this video and very happy i did. This speaks to my experience of my journey to Islam. Dr. Yamaoto's commentary is very important for Muslims from other geographic locations to understand that Islam melds into the people/culture it joins, not that an "Arabized" culture should represent Islam as a faith or culture alone. I became Muslim in China through Hui Muslims, his family had been Muslim for more than 1350 years, while a language student at Beijing University over 40 years ago. When I spent time as a language student and expat in the Middle East a decade later, I am so glad I was introduced to Islam outside of the Middle East...an understanding of Islam that was more kind, inclusive, and inculcating a softness toward others from Far Eastern philosophies--and not flagellation from an "Islam is superior-ity" complex that is not obvious to many Muslims bound to traditional thinking. Just take a look at the knee-jerk reactions of most Muslims in traditional Muslim states...form over substance.
Nice lecturing..i hope to be made a video about islam in southeast asia soon,since we are the the region that has the biggest muslim population in the world..
I hope with such video will help understanding our brothers and sisters in the west that being muslim does not mean being an arab or pakistani or middle eastern, we can still be muslim regardless of our own ethnicities..jazaakallah khairan brother Paul
@@mariyabiswas3391 yeah sorry,i mean the most predominant muslim in a country is actually Indonesia. India has much larger muslim population than indonesia, but they are just minority in the country of India.
As always Jazakallah Khairun Paul. You continue to spoil us.
There are great japanese scholars on Islam and myself enjoyed islamic books written by japanese scholars, unlike those written by orientalists. I pray that Allah swt give hidayah of Islam to the Japanese, koreans, taiwanese, latin Americans and Europe.
Thank you very much Mr Paul for bringing up this topic
My guess was correct, he's a Japanese man because of his name ,the topic was confusing I thought he's a Chinese man.
I'm glad and happy for him that he's a Muslim
There is another expert who writes in English about Chinese Islam who is Japanese: it is Murata Sachiko. She has severla books that are really interesting. Really recommend to read her work.
@@AlIskanderZhao sure I will check it out
@@Dark-gd7ob I just realised she is mentioned in the video as well, so never mind haha
@@AlIskanderZhao any TH-cam videos links about her work please?
This session was so rich of excellent information! Thank you both for your research and bringing this to us. Dr Naoki is so correct that we need to come out of the nationalistic mindset and work together and learn from all the experts in the Ummah. Thank you for all your hard work in breaking barriers.
Great interview as usual , Jazakom Allah khairan
Thankyou for this conversation sir...
Well done 兄弟们 jazakallah khair! 👆
@白某某 没有好兄弟，我是巴基斯坦人
Thank you for interviewing Dr. Naoki Yamamoto!
It is interesting to learn about Muslims from other people and their cultures. Unfortunately, I don't know much about Chinese Muslims. Thank you Dr. Naoki for sharing some history of Islam and Muslims in China.
I am from padang, Indonesia, at the 80s when I was at elementary school, we studied read quran at surau (madrasah), we wear peci (malay traditional hat) and baju koko or baju gunting cina (Chinese cut clothes). That how Chinese culture influence and mix with our malay (minangkabau) tradition.
Masha Allah brother Paul you are on the right path 🙏
*_Masha'Allah, BT is a wealth of information to a discerning student of knowledge._*
One of the most thought provoking conversations surrounding the topic.
The dialouge really highlights the fact that in some way, every single pre-islamic human civilisation had divine elements found in its roots.
Evidently, it's understood that there has been hundreds of thousands of prophets before nabi Muhammed (pbuh) sent to these different cultures.
Theories around Plato and other prominent historical figures that played a role in formulating a societal practice potentialy are interesting examples of this.
Islam's arrival truly revolved around brining all of these accumulated diviations of faith back to its initial core beliefs.
Really something grand and amazing to think about.
You guy will never run out of profoud insights.
I like it !
JazakAllah khairun. Absolutely beautifully presented, very informative and much needed. Thankyou again.
Masha Allah beautiful, I have learned a lot today
An absolutely fascinating lecture/conversation.
59:55 the Professor stated it very well that Islam was able to accommodate both Hellenistic and Confucius philosophies and it did so without there being any theological fractures within the Islamic civilization. This truly shows Islam’s universality.
Not of the east, not of the west as it says in ayat al nur
ありがとうございました、山本先生。勉強になりました！
On a similar note, I'd like to see a video like this for the Cham/Vietnamese Islam
Yes
This was very informative! Thanks for teaching us the history of Islam in China.
The salam of brother at the begining ❤️❤️
Thank you! This podcast was so insightful and mind provoking! Just amazing! JazakAllahuHayran!
Alhamdulillahi Rabbil Alameen
brilliant video shiek
Thanks paul
thanks for inviting interesting guests br. paul, i feel a bit more knowledeable about Islam
Alhamdulillah learned a lot ! Thank you Prof Naoki Yamamoto and brother Paul.
Assalamu alaikum, Brother Paul and Brother Yamamoto
Wa alaykumu s-salam
@@BloggingTheology Thank you Ustadh Paul for replying to my comment. Please make dua for me and my mother. I m personally stuck and my mom is terminally ill
Amazing discussion, learnt a lot from this lecture. Love from Qatar
So so proud of you Mr Paul ❤️🤲
Wow amazing stream jazak Allah khair dears
Thank you so much 😊
Another fantastic talk!
Masha Allaah. watching from Philippines
May Allah SWT guide, bless n protect you both.. ive been following your soc-med lately.. May Allah SWT bless every muslim in the world..
Amazing interview 🌷
Very pleased to hear from both of You.
😍😍😍
Brother Paul, proud of you. May Allah bless you
Paul I'm sure your conversion story isn't boring, any experience of embracing Islam is a special thing :) I personally would be interested in learning how you converted.
Great, great video even by just listening to this epic discussion, thank you so much both of you, you guys are doing a great job and may Allah always guide us all to His open arm,Salam for all
Wow what an interesting video today Paul :) I’ve wondered a lot about Islam in China from someone who’s studied it’s history in depth especially with the current oppression against the Uighur people. Great video once again Paul:)
I don't know if Br. Paul did this on purpose, but having the guy tell his story first makes it a lot better than start with the history of Islam in China. If it was done on purpose, kudos Paul.
Brother Paul is a great interviewer and knows how to ask the right questions at the right time….I really wished he had his own TV program….May Allahﷻ reward brother Paul…Ameen
I think his revert story is one of the most amazing I've ever heard, I'm in tears
The more I listen the more I get amazed by the way professor Naoki explains to make us understand the cross cultural understanding. Amazing!
Masha Allah pure knowledge...Thank you for this Video!!!
Brother Paul, May Allah swt reward you for all that you do. I watch all your uploads religiously.
It's really amazing to know how close is between islamic teachings with the traditional spiritual and old rites of Chinese people.
Thank you for this extra ordinary history. So nice new information. Greatings from belgium. Selamlar.
Very informative. Appreciate both.
This was beautiful Mashallah
Ahumdallilah. I show my gratitude to your efforts to bring us valuable knowledge.
MashaAllah thank you, Eid Mubarak
Allah knowing everyone of us n preserving Islam ☪️ by creating us to be a Muslims .. possibly to leading Islam for everyone n giving to those that are able to …. May we among the chosen one , always….Ameen 🤲🤲
Intriguing discussion! Thank you Paul 😊