I invest considerable time in researching, compiling, and editing these videos, but unfortunately they become ineligible for monetization. If you wish to extend your support or make REQUESTS FOR NEW VIDEO content, your assistance would be greatly valued via the link in my bio. ❤
@@markkroner9800 let me correct you. He stopped hitting them because he used poor technique, almost ruining his voice. He had to train very hard to get it back in shape and he did. Now he dodges as many high notes as he can and still does them. Very impressive.
@@xanderguldie Just to clarify as I don't know how it works and I haven't heard him sing the high notes anymore: Is his ability to sing them gone? Did he lose that voice up there over the years or is he just saving it?
@@lorenzmuller3542 definitely saving it, if you listen to lion or english eyes from their 40 tours around the sun live album he hits high notes with ease but only when necessary
Was listening Joe in1998 wizh some cover band. "Tried to catch a shooting star, what seems so close can't be that far I'm living in a dream that's never ending." This end of verse - He killed it better than original. In my opinion, his best singing era was in time when he released great solo albums "I'm Alive" and "3".....
This comparison is quite unfair : First video, we all know he had lost his voice. 2nd video, he had not sing since a very long time and was starting his come back. It's obvious to me he has always been really good at singing, even if yes, he is even better today.
I think he's become a much better singer over the years. He used to be pretty pitchy. He is much better now, and also seems to phrase things better to accentuate the positive qualities of his voice.
In 1988 he was in bad shape with partying too much and that led to his dismissal from the band. Fortunately he cleaned up and was rehired some years later, after the "Autotune Tour" with Bobby 2007 or 2008 if I recall
I wish Joe had been able to look after his voice better back in the 80s. I seen them last year in Hamburg and he just sounds so fantastic these days though.
Learn something new every day. Never knew of the connection between the film industry's finest living composer and one of the best band in the country's lead singer. Damn.
Joseph has continually improved IMO. He has more power now in his 60's, than in his 30's. He does vocal exercises daily, and it shows. Did you know that he is the son of the most famous composer of all time, John Williams ?
Los amo, gracias al Universo por obsequiarme verlos y escucharlos este 2024, mi sueño desde que era una niña ….. mi regalo de cumpleaños de mi para mi. Gracias gracias gracias ❤
That's because Bobby is much older than Joe. Joe will be 64 in September. Bobby who had hearing loss and has Dementia will be 77 years old March 29, 2024. 😮😮😮😮😮😮
Not only does Joseph sound so consistent and powerful over the years, how's the tempo?! I was expecting the tempo to slightly fluctuate from the different clips but it's all pretty bang on the same!
I wish Toto hadn't changed, a pity Paich, Kimball (of course not to mention the late Porcaros) are not there any more but that's life. Probably the greatest band in the world, especially considering professionalism. Good Lukather and Williams still don't let us forget about Toto.
I miss him so much from 1986-1988.....charming voice and nice handsome guy.... The golden boy of the Hollywood movie and music industry....Now he's a fat old man in his 60s, but his voice is still there.
I'm a massive Toto fan so I'm not discrediting anything.. but the 2013 (Anniversary Tour) and the 2021 ('Toto with a little help from friends' during lockdown) video has a lot of post-production going on. Those are from official live releases.. theres not a single wrong note or anything even slightly off note.. not possible in a live environment. However, the recent performance (2024, the final video) at "Night Of The Proms" in Belgium, I believe is the real deal. Man sounds phenomenal
@@michaelshepherd885 Yessss I see this a lot!! 😂. Not just with that DVD/TOTO fans.. but any "live performance" here on TH-cam.. autotuned/pitch corrected into oblivion and people in the comments will be like "Omg they're so good!! Love your voice. Better than the original artist". Yes because its fake 🤣
Yup 100%. I never get the Toto fans who hate on Joseph who do pretty much always talk about the Live in Amsterdam DVD as the reason why. A recording from the desk is literally on youtube to show them what Bobby DID sound like that night @@kieranniemand2939
I’m born with perfect pitch and have heard the band every time they visited the North of Europe since 2010. Joe sings in pitch. You can hear him go to a lower note at times when the backing vocals saves his voice but the pitch is flawless. And he’s so consistent other vocalists needs to take note.
Last week, Joseph Williams came to the Billboard Live in Osaka, Japan with former Chicago member Bill Champlin and shook hands with Joseph Williams after the show. His hands seemed to be very thick. I was very impressed!!!
Thank you for your time making this wonderful video. Appreciate your efforts, showcasing this man's extraordinary voice over 40 years and this band's dynamic evolution. There are no words for how this band has impacted me musically and more importantly emotionally for my entire adult life. Thanks again for your efforts!
Joseph is a fine fine singer and entertainer. Bobby is/was a fine singer….but when he was bad….he was HORRIBLY bad. Bobby has always had this…it was something about him that put me off about him.
i really like some songs, BUT ...i ve never heard a live tune/video etc. that even comes close to the album recordings....sorry to say. especially the vocals in general really suck. last summer i heard a toto cover band and they sounded better than the original. It was great fun to listen to them. i mean....come on , Toto...
![Toto - Africa / Hold The Line / Stop Loving You (live) [2024]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5tppmuRLNkc/mqdefault.jpg)
![Toto - Africa / Hold The Line / Stop Loving You (live) [2024]](/img/tr.png)
I invest considerable time in researching, compiling, and editing these videos, but unfortunately they become ineligible for monetization.
If you wish to extend your support or make REQUESTS FOR NEW VIDEO content, your assistance would be greatly valued via the link in my bio. ❤
He's still singing in the original key. That's impressive.
He long ago stopped singing the high notes. Warren Ham or the girl singer hit the hard stuff . Just sayin
@@markkroner9800 let me correct you. He stopped hitting them because he used poor technique, almost ruining his voice. He had to train very hard to get it back in shape and he did. Now he dodges as many high notes as he can and still does them. Very impressive.
@@xanderguldie Just to clarify as I don't know how it works and I haven't heard him sing the high notes anymore: Is his ability to sing them gone? Did he lose that voice up there over the years or is he just saving it?
@@lorenzmuller3542 definitely saving it, if you listen to lion or english eyes from their 40 tours around the sun live album he hits high notes with ease but only when necessary
Keeps getting better!
Joseph is a amazing singer. A amazing voice aways.
Love toto. Joe had one the best rock voices. Even now
His live voice definitely got better through the years. Nowadays it is much like the young Joe Williams, back in 1988, curiously.
Was listening Joe in1998 wizh some cover band. "Tried to catch a shooting star, what seems so close can't be that far
I'm living in a dream that's never ending." This end of verse - He killed it better than original. In my opinion, his best singing era was in time when he released great solo albums "I'm Alive" and "3".....
steve is one of the few remaining members to still be in the band since Toto formed in 1977, thats over 40 years,
This comparison is quite unfair : First video, we all know he had lost his voice. 2nd video, he had not sing since a very long time and was starting his come back. It's obvious to me he has always been really good at singing, even if yes, he is even better today.
AMAY-ZING!
Justru vokal di tahun 2021 sampai 2024 better than early years when lived performing .. menurut saya hen can reach hight note..thats cool❤
Love Williams ❤
But Kinball was something different... Although I can't say who I love most 🤷🏻♂️
I think he's become a much better singer over the years. He used to be pretty pitchy. He is much better now, and also seems to phrase things better to accentuate the positive qualities of his voice.
He sounds phenomenal. But it’s irritating when he doesn’t sing the chorus.
I love Toto! But the man is out of shape. Background sings half of the lyrics.
Umm wow… he sounds better as he’s aged! IMO
In 1988 he was in bad shape with partying too much and that led to his dismissal from the band. Fortunately he cleaned up and was rehired some years later, after the "Autotune Tour" with Bobby 2007 or 2008 if I recall
What makes you so sure Joe isn't using AUTOTUNE ?? Oh, because it isn't Bobby Kimball, eh?
@@waltersimmons946Because he is not deaf 😂
@@piotrh3881 Yeah , sure 👽
Joseph's technique has definitely improved over the years.
Exactly what I was thinking. He sounds better as he’s aged I think! Amazing
In one of his interviews he stated he left the band and had vocal lessons in LA for a few years! Definitely shows
Did anyone see him on star search from approx 83? He was amazing
Yeah he almost ruined his voice until he began training with a new coach. It has improved a lot since then
4 decades on the original tone, WOW Joseph, WOW 😮😮😮
The 2013 concert is just so good.
His voice remains unchanged whatever how old he is. We love you, Joe!
Unchanged? His voice is even better today in my opinion😍
I really miss Tony Spinner. The extra guitar and his vocal range really filled out the sound
girl whatever
His vocals really suits the song
I wish Joe had been able to look after his voice better back in the 80s. I seen them last year in Hamburg and he just sounds so fantastic these days though.
One of my favorite singers of all time. And for the last 10 years, he's been never better!
Simply one of the most versatile supergroups ever!!
Toto is not just a living legend, Toto is The Wonder Band❤
I love both singers and feel no need to pit one against the other
just aged like fine wine, his vocals imrpoved over time
Exactly!!!
If anything his voice sounds richer, more refined 😊
My thoughts exactly!
Learn something new every day. Never knew of the connection between the film industry's finest living composer and one of the best band in the country's lead singer. Damn.
Yeah, I've just learned about this as well about 2 weeks ago. Had no idea, but it kind of makes sense, doesn't it ? :D
I've just learned about this about 2 weeks ago too. What DNA! Who's joseph son's?
the best singer of Toto
50/50 Joseph bobby
@@leostereodj NEVER
One of the band's best songs!
After 36 years and still sounds good.
Probably one of the best singers from that time that still has a wonderful voice
i really respect him. amazing singer amazing man. Love you Joseph 🎉🎉
in ear monitoring allows for a much better pitch control onstage nowadays, before that it was a pain in the ass for singers live.
Amo a TOTO❤..Joseph hermoso como siempre 😍😍y esa voz espectacular, increíble..!! Talento extraordinario ..Saludos🇦🇷🇦🇷
Joseph need to loose some weight again than he sings much better . See poland 2013
Yup. That was his best shape of the last years. :)
if you haven’t seen it, go look up Joseph’s performance on tv show Star Search from before he was in Toto….really good
Fabulous singer sounds better every time
Sorry. As much as he gained weight he lost his ability to hit the high notes
Yep.
Vocal improvement. Agreed!!!! Intonation, pitch, style. Keep it up Joe!!!!
Excellent my friend show the voice evolution of Joseph Williams.
Great video seamless edits....much appreciated, well done
C'est l'une de mes chansons préférés 💖💋 chanter par le beau et sa belle voix
Joseph Williams 😍💖💋
Pareil 😊
I have never seen someone own the stage like he does absolute superstar
Singing smootherr as the years go on. Love Joseph at the mic.
Joseph has continually improved IMO. He has more power now in his 60's, than in his 30's. He does vocal exercises daily, and it shows. Did you know that he is the son of the most famous composer of all time, John Williams ?
Los amo, gracias al Universo por obsequiarme verlos y escucharlos este 2024, mi sueño desde que era una niña ….. mi regalo de cumpleaños de mi para mi. Gracias gracias gracias ❤
Joe's not hitting the high notes on the clip like he used to. 😮😮😮😮
Son of composer John Williams..himself and Steve a great combination.
Bobby kimball it was & still the best vocalist of Toto EVER !
What a band.
Joseph's voice held up much better than Bobby's over the years.
😑
That's because Bobby is much older than Joe. Joe will be 64 in September. Bobby who had hearing loss and has Dementia will be 77 years old March 29, 2024. 😮😮😮😮😮😮
that may be true, but its nothing near as iconic as kimball in hold the line and rosanna - the hits that MADE toto a legendary band
Nothing can beat bobby voice for legendary songs AFRICA and ROSANNA❤
@@kchmyy EXACTLY 💯 👏
O melhor vocalista da banda Toto.
Cada um com suas particularidades, mas eu prefiro o Kimball
Not only does Joseph sound so consistent and powerful over the years, how's the tempo?! I was expecting the tempo to slightly fluctuate from the different clips but it's all pretty bang on the same!
They may have a click track.
Super😊. Merci pour cette rétrospective, moi qui est une fan de Joseph des la première heure.
No doubt. The older he gets, the better he sings. God bless Joseph and Toto.
Am I hallucinating, or is that both Bobby Kimball AND Joe Williams sharing the same stage in 1998 and 2008? Help! Somebody!
Yes.
@@cristianepereiraandrade7197 Muito obrigado!
1988 wasn't great due to ruining his voice, 1998 improvement and 2008 almost sounds like the studio version but i honestly think he can't get any now
Very nice editing!!
Que impresionante..! Que calidad..!! me parece estar en la disco en los 80’..!! Mis respetos a un grande de la música..!🎵 🙏🏼🇨🇱👏🏼👏🏼
I fucking love this guy
Miss the days when Joseph and Bobby shared lead duties
2013 was his best year
🍀🍀🍀
❤❤❤
Parece vinho, só melhorou o uso da voz e a técnica... Adoro "Stop Loving You". Musicão!
1988 & 2010 has very poor sound quality.
You can't really judge that.
you should have used the version from munich 1988. Joes best performance on the song ever without a doubt (even tough it wrecked his voice for a bit)
I wish Toto hadn't changed, a pity Paich, Kimball (of course not to mention the late Porcaros) are not there any more but that's life. Probably the greatest band in the world, especially considering professionalism. Good Lukather and Williams still don't let us forget about Toto.
I miss him so much from 1986-1988.....charming voice and nice handsome guy....
The golden boy of the Hollywood movie and music industry....Now he's a fat old man in his 60s, but his voice is still there.
I'm a massive Toto fan so I'm not discrediting anything.. but the 2013 (Anniversary Tour) and the 2021 ('Toto with a little help from friends' during lockdown) video has a lot of post-production going on. Those are from official live releases.. theres not a single wrong note or anything even slightly off note.. not possible in a live environment. However, the recent performance (2024, the final video) at "Night Of The Proms" in Belgium, I believe is the real deal. Man sounds phenomenal
I was there in antwerp belgium, it was great
Weirdly loads of toto fans who prefer Bobby site the 2008 live dvd as proof of why they love him. That is the most autotuned show in history 😅
@@michaelshepherd885 Yessss I see this a lot!! 😂. Not just with that DVD/TOTO fans.. but any "live performance" here on TH-cam.. autotuned/pitch corrected into oblivion and people in the comments will be like "Omg they're so good!! Love your voice. Better than the original artist". Yes because its fake 🤣
Yup 100%. I never get the Toto fans who hate on Joseph who do pretty much always talk about the Live in Amsterdam DVD as the reason why. A recording from the desk is literally on youtube to show them what Bobby DID sound like that night @@kieranniemand2939
I’m born with perfect pitch and have heard the band every time they visited the North of Europe since 2010. Joe sings in pitch. You can hear him go to a lower note at times when the backing vocals saves his voice but the pitch is flawless. And he’s so consistent other vocalists needs to take note.
Last week, Joseph Williams came to the Billboard Live in Osaka, Japan with former Chicago member Bill Champlin and shook hands with Joseph Williams after the show. His hands seemed to be very thick. I was very impressed!!!
Thank you for your time making this wonderful video. Appreciate your efforts, showcasing this man's extraordinary voice over 40 years and this band's dynamic evolution. There are no words for how this band has impacted me musically and more importantly emotionally for my entire adult life. Thanks again for your efforts!
Это эволюция не голоса а аппаратуры в которую сейчас работают музыканты
His voice didn't change. Technology changed. Better vocal processing. Autotune, digital delays, etc.
I've always been hesitant to his intonation from most of what I've heard him performing live.. he's a great studio singer, but live, meh..
Love you Toto!!Forever my favorite band.Love luke and Joe
It's rare that is better as they get older, Joseph's voice really took a huge leap when he rejoined Toto. Way better control.
Maybe the quality of the recordings add up. But Joaeph is fantastic
Bobby had the better voice, but Joseph has the reliable voice.
Joseph is a fine fine singer and entertainer. Bobby is/was a fine singer….but when he was bad….he was HORRIBLY bad. Bobby has always had this…it was something about him that put me off about him.
Getting better over the years. Amazing
Effortless as a young buck.... has to work so much harder, but still sounds very good.
th-cam.com/video/bYr3OJOXk60/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=TotoVEVO
th-cam.com/video/bYr3OJOXk60/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=TotoVEVO
Que no se te apague nunca tu voz Joseph....ÚNICO y por muchos años la voz de TOTO....❤ GRANDE TOTO!!!
i really like some songs, BUT ...i ve never heard a live tune/video etc. that even comes close to the album recordings....sorry to say.
especially the vocals in general really suck.
last summer i heard a toto cover band and they sounded better than the original. It was great fun to listen to them. i mean....come on , Toto...
God I love this guy
0:47 That year is when I was born On August 15
I think its just gone better tbh😂 I know he took a break and stuff so that has something to do with it, and also the drugs and alcohol from the 80's
Durimg the 7th one tour he wrecked his vocal chords... so the live clip sounds much worse than he actually sounded.
2018 ok. Wcześniej to było słabe.
I just wish Fergie would have made at least one more record with Toto.
Joe Williams, great voice!
Love JSW 🥰
I didnt realize his dad was john williams the famous composer
Toto will never be the same without Bobby Kimball
Beautiful.. the older the better..
Glad that thin 2010 mustache left 😁