The dad saying that the wrong twin died shows you right there where the issues started. They were probably compared their whole life and learned to hate each other
@@Lunarj even if it is toxic in that one statement. You can't make assumptions on their childhood and claim you're right when you literally have no idea. Stop acting like you have some magic insight that we don't have. Yes that statement was wrong. Does that mean you automatically know they were treated poorly by their father? No. You can raise kids then not really get along with them when they are adults. It sucks but it's not uncommon.
I 100% agree this this. I also dont think she planned where on the road to do it. I think she just knew she was going to do it and the fight and in that moment decided to do it then. It was just chance there were rocks at the bottom of that bit and not water
So, the fact that she was driving drunk, WELL OVER THE LEGAL LIMIT, doesn’t come into consideration at all? That has to be at least a manslaughter charge.
I hate it when investigators use “she had no reaction” as cause to look into crimes. I’ve had some shocking news relayed to me in my life, and I froze and wasn’t able to process the info until hours later.
@@nina.robbs565 that was my first thought too. Being in a crash like that (and surviving) is enough trauma to send anyone into shock, and witnessing her sister's violent death must have been traumatic as well, even if the crash was intentional. I have to wonder if there was an additional element of surreality and trauma due to the nature of their relationship - because they were identical twins, inseparable to a fault, the surviving twin may have felt as if she witnessed her OWN death ... I can't imagine what it would feel like to see someone who looks exactly like you die in such a brutal way. Dissociation seems like a pretty normal response to any one of those traumatic events.
Even if it wasn't FULLY on purpose, Alexandria was drunk, and driving drunk, caused an accident that killed her sister. How wasnt she found guilty based on that alone???
@@emilyreed8946 Yes! After three separate DWI's you would think that she would have to serve jail time. And that's before you even take into account that she (allegedly) accidentally killed someone while under the influence. Is this just separate states not working together? Something is definitely missing here🤔
There were twins in my sons’ elementary school whose mother always requested they be assigned separate teachers to make it easier for them to develop their own identity. Smart, IMO
Yes I think this is a pretty common practice. In my high school our grades were always split into halves (so blue half and red half), if we ever had any sort of twins they were specifically told one of them would be in red half, and the other in blue half to help them develop friendships and identities independently, I’m almost certain we had 5 sets of twins one year.
Yes, I'm a mom of twin boys and I did the same so that my boys can have their own identities. And it worked, they are close but live their own lives and have their own set of friends, there's no competition between them.
It is. I am a twin and my mother did the same thing. 20 years later I still remember my brother and I crying our eyes out when we realized we were going to different classrooms. It helped us branch off and socialize with other children.
I'm a twin and my mom did that to us too. I remember that we begged her not to. Kindergarten was only 4 hours a day, but even those 4 hours apart were so hard!! After a couple weeks we adjusted and now I'm glad she did it. We ended up developing our own personalities and social circles. We now live on opposite sides of the country without issue. We're best friends, but also are our own people with clear unique identities. Thanks Mom!
True then after school they can elaborate on each other’s day still building that sibling bond☺️❤️ but in this situation I think the relationship between these women sparked somewhere in their childhood the father didn’t even come out to speak about either of the two
So maybe their isn't enough evidence of her intentional killing her sister, but why wasn't she charged with manslaughter by vehicle, since she was so drunk?
Because they could not prove her drunkenness caused the crash. They could easily argue that her sister yanking her hair caused the crash creating reasonable doubt, I think they could've gotten her for DUI but no jury would convict her for manslaughter.
Excuse my Glamm Cosmetics yeah but they did toxicology reports so regardless of whether she was fighting or not she shouldn’t have been behind the wheel drunk
Yea she def should have been charged w/ something considering she was driving drunk & obv recklessly. Yes, the fighting def didn’t help & coulda been 1 of the main causes, but the other 2 still factor in as well.
she was definitely trying to kill both of them, kinda like a “if she’s not with me she won’t be with anyone” situation, since she didn’t want her sister moving away with her bf.
javi I agree! There’s no way she thought running her car off a cliff would kill her sister and not her. If she only wanted her sister dead there’s other ways to go about that without getting hurt as bad as she did
Weirdtuber journalism I’m surprised she didn’t try to say she WAS Anastasia after the car accident, making everybody think Alexandria was dead. I thought that was where the story was going lol
yeah, I'm surprised she didn't get unintentional manslaughter because she was drunk , that's usually what you get, I actually know someone that was driving drunk and didn't mean to hit someone else, a stranger and he died, and although it wasn't on purpose that he killed someone, he still served jail time..
There is a rule of law saying you cannot be judged for the exact same action twice. They prosecuted her for murder and didn't put the intentional manslaughter in the trial so now that she has been acquitted they cannot pursue her again for the exact same thing
My thoughts exactly... How did they not charge her with at the very least involuntary manslaughter!?! I thought it was pretty obvious but apparently not to that court room or judge!🤦🏽
The only thing I can think of is maybe she knew of the statistic that a drunk driver is the most likely to survive in a drunk driving accident. Usually because of slowed reaction time and keeps muscles from tensing as fast in response to injury
Isn’t it possible she was pulling her sisters hair because she threatened to drive them both off the cliff? Like that could’ve been an attempt to stop her from doing it.
At the beginning of this video I was like 'wow, they look so familiar!' and then realized it was because they look like the twins from White Chicks! If I didn't know better, I'd almost think it was them lol
Ugh I wish I didn’t click on your channel Kayleb 🤮 you shouldn’t have a platform on TH-cam for promoting pedophilia - most disturbing 30 seconds of a video I’ve watched
Because prosecutors over-charged her. They do that dumb shit all the time and murderers go free. Look at Casey Anthony. If they had tried to get her for anything other than first degree murder, she would be sitting in jail right now more than likely.
Honestly Kendall's voice is just one that I can listen to for hours without getting bored. Playing these videos in the background helps me be productive lol
I think its because the prosecutor was trying to get her charged with intentional murder, which was their first mistake. If they cannot prove that she was guilty of intentional homicide beyond a reasonable doubt, then she would not be charged with that, and let go. You cannot change the charges (from intentional to manslaughter) during a trial unless a deal is made with the defense team. If they tried charging her with manslaughter initially, I believe she would be in jail now. Basically, the prosecutor risked it all to get her charged with murder, and it backfired. And you can't be charged with the same crime twice.
I think she purposely drove off the cliff, she just didn’t intent to live through the ordeal. It seems like the adrenaline of the fight, mixed with a lot of alcohol, mixed with suicidal thoughts already, she probably made a split decision out of anger and threw them off
I was there with a group of scouts when the accident occurred. One twin was physically attacking the other one when she was driving, and she was trying to protect herself, it was a horrible accident, with even crazier outcome.
It’s so hard to tell if there was intention or just a bad mix of everything going wrong at once. Either way, I’m sure the surviving sister will spend her life wishing she could redo this day. I can’t imagine having to live with that the rest of her life. Terribly sad.
I’ve taught yoga for 8 years and some of the most messed up people I have met, have been other yoga teachers and studio owners. A lot of it is fake and people who hide their mental issues behind a facade.
I met an American woman in Bali who had a 10 year old son, very sweet boy, but she was nuts and shacked up woth the yoga teacher. I actually contacted the police in their home town in the US to see if she had abducted the boy, but there was no missing person report on him and his father had died a few years before of a drug OD.
I know a therapist (therapists are called “doctor” now. She’s an overweight pill popping alcoholic sex addicted slob. Imagine being counseled by somebody like that?
I'm an identical twin, I think being raised to be a full person is one of the most beneficial things a parent can do for multiples, especially identical ones. Like my twin and I were almost always together, but my parents made sure we were in separate classes, so we learned how to be socially independent. My mom would listen to every story twice, even when they were exactly the same, she wanted both of us to feel like we mattered and were individuals. Obviously you can't escape everything, my twin always had a massive issue with us looking the same, we looked increasingly different over the years, but I think childhood is where the meat of the issues begin. Pretty much everyone called us "the twins" or "the girls" but my parents never did. That kind of stuff matters. People say they're freaked out by twins because of infamous twins like these two, and I totally agree, I just know it doesn't apply to all twins. I have some experience. But the twins like that, who still look identical as adults, yeah.. It freaks you out because it oozes dysfunction and hints at some really weird shit. It's abnormal. This reminds me of those silent twins, and the Swedish ones too, like one needed to die so the other could live. You can't treat two virtually identical people with two distinct and competing minds as one entity and expect anything good to come of it. Instant recipe for self destruction.
im an identical twin too!!! me and my twin have different looks now and try to almost prove to everyone that we are two separate people. definitely was called the twins and the girls by everyone even my parents, even still to this day. i love her and she’s almost like my other half but it’s frustrating that others see us as the same person or a group but we see ourselves as 2 very different people. i feel this
I have fraternal twins, so not exactly the same situation but from the beginning, I made sure they are able to explore their own unique interests and not to refer to them as "the twins" very often. They are still small children but it seems to be healthy for them - they get along great 90 percent of the time.
Since the day my sister-in-law found out she was pregnant with twin girls she did not allow anyone to call them "the twins". We actually refer to them as "the girls" or by their names. They are very different personality and looks wise. They have different goals and dreams and are rarely even together and have different circle of friends. They are 20 years old now.
Anyone else notice how when they were both being interviewed on the news the headline was “former local business owner charged with killing sister” foreshadowing or what😳
Kristina Abraham My aunts are twins and I know they said as little girls, it was fun. They even once pranked their boyfriends as teens. But one thing that they shared with me was that it was at their teenage years, they wanted to feel separate. They felt half of a person, always “the twins”. It was in their teens that they started to self identify. They say it was cute as children to dress the same but when they were old enough to choose, they did.
Did she get no time?? She literally was arrested multiple times for drunk driving which alone should give jail time. Also, I’m not sure how it works but if she was intoxicated whilst driving off the cliff could she not still be done for manslaughter?
She did! I live in Maui and we are all well aware of this case. My uncle is a Corrections Officer she was detained for her PreTrial before she made bail. She was very cocky though, like very snooty. She knew what had happened, but while incarcerated, my uncle claimed it seemed she had no remorse
Kayzia-Ashley Washington that’s really interesting. I watched her on Dr Phil, and everyone in the comments section (plus Dr Phil) seems to think she was innocent, but I’m seeing a lot different on here.
No, according to the law you cant be charged twice for the same crime. They already charged her for the cliff incident with 2nd degree murder so they can't charge her again.
There's literally no way she tried to solely kill her sister- there was absolutely no guarantee of her surviving that crash and only killing her twin... Plus I don't find it strange at all that she had no emotion, didn't ask about the sister, and started wearing her clothes. With the mental connection they had, she probably knew immediately that the twin was gone and she was numb to it, like being in shock. How does she cope with the guilt of knowing she killed her other half whom she had a rocky relationship with? She tries to fill the void by trying to feel the sister nearby, by wearing her clothes. Idk it all adds up as either A. an accident or B. she wanted to take both their lives and didn't plan to live
Agreed! They were both dysfunctional and violent. It's likely they both had suicidal ideations but there is no evidence either had a plan. The witness driving behind them is critical. You have to be out of your damn tree to pull someone's hair while they are driving anywhere ever but especially on that road!
This case reminds me of the Silent Twins. They refused to speak to anyone but each other, and did literally everything the same and together. But they also fought like dogs. One twin strangled the other with a radio cord during one of their brawls. In the end one twin died while napping on her sister’s shoulder, and it was written in her journal one of us must die, so the other can live. The similarities are so eerie. It’s something about identical twins.
It sounds like both of these women have been able to scam and avoid any type of consequences their whole life. Massive amounts of debt, DUIs, fighting, and scamming people out their money. No accountability anywhere!
Its dui resulting in substantial bodily harm/death (in NV) and it often carries a 3-15, or a 4-10, meaning after 3 or years they are elligible for parol. And with good behavior, and work detail, the back #s (the 15 or the 10) are nearly cut in half. . . And DUI inmates are considered minimum security inmates and go to the work camps. So 3-15, turns into 3 yrs in minimum security, then parole for 4 years. Of course that's for a first offense and obv on certain circumstances. That's in Nevada, at least
@@sunshinek5827 it's all good, but yes I just ment my personal feelings. Was hit by a drunk driver 2 months ago and luckily walked away with only bruises.
That’s exactly what I thought. It could be why she wasn’t phased by her sisters death🤷🏽♀️ They were 1 soul in 2 bodies, then were 1 soul in 1 body so it just felt right.
The idea of twins harming each other always seems weird to me. I am a twin I have a sister. We never truly thought of being a twin as special other than some people would tell us we were closer than most siblings. We tend to think similar and often have the same ideas. I have anxiety and depression while my sister is rather self confident and doesn't have problems with her mental health. In some ways I truly do think she is my other half because she has traits that I truly wished I had. We moved into an apartment together and just adopted a dog together. I really enjoy my life with her right now. She is my best friend.
My younger brothers are twins. The fought viciously in their youth. We're talking: hitting each other with shovels & baseball bats, cutting each other with scissors, one pushed the other into a chimney & cracked his head open, the list goes on. Our father abandoned the family & my mom was an abusive alcoholic. I've wondered if a crappy upbringing contributed to their hatred of each other. Anyhow...they ended up becoming friends in their adult lives & even live next door to each other.
@@butterfly8514 I did with my sister awhile back. We both thought these girls relationship with each other was really creepy and toxic. Same with this case.
@@kevinmalone3210 True but I wonder if she could have faked it or just made up a lie about grieving her sister and the crash "changing" her. The father seems very sketchy with that the other daughter should have died line.
There’s no way she would have known that would have only killed Anastasia. So I think she was trying to kill both of them. They definitely had a very toxic relationship. And their Dad saying that shows they probably had a pretty hard home life when they were younger.
Some people mistake smooth ground for a path and don't known heading toward a cliff until to late. Don't drive off road if you don't know what is up ahead.
There is no way she could have planned to kill her sister in this manner. How did she know how the car was going to land and that she was not going to get killed or paralysed too. Then on top of that she was drinking. I would never ever believe she could have planned that.
I was thinking a murder-suicide too. Or at the very least she didn't care if they both died. They were fighting, were known to have a toxic relationship. I don't buy for a second that this was an accident.
Francesca Raso I agree BUT I feel like there’s enough reasonable doubt. I mean she WAS being attacked while driving!! Idk so hard to make a decision for me
Right?! Even me and my sister who’s 2 years older were kinda messed up by being raised like twins. It caused a lot of resentment and issues so deep we’re still working things out decades later.
I think the rock part is a coincidence, I think she was just intoxicated and out of her mind with the fighting and saw there was no rail and lost it. I don't think it was specifically planned but I think she had it in her mind for a while. I think she expected to kill them both but mainly wanted to kill her sister. Definitely not an accident!
i never like when they say “oh she was so calm and didn’t care” because a lot of people forget shock can make you so numb and disconnected from everything that’s happening
are we just gonna ignore the fact that not only did she show no emotion when they told her that her sister died BUT then she started wearing her clothes and TOOK A SHOWER WITH HER DEAD SISTERS BOYFRIEND?! Like , if it was just a tragic accident why were they comfortable enough to be bathing together
That can sometimes be a trauma response. I've had no reaction in severely traumatizing situations because I didn't have the capacity to process what happened. Wearing someone's clothes after they grieve can also be a way to feel closer to them. Human beings are nuanced. I think she may have tried a murder suicide and survived and then regretted it deeply.
@@deli.rat. Agreed... I had no response when my dad was killed. I was blank. I didn't have any emotions until i saw his body in the casket. Crazy, ppl think everyone should react in the exact same manner. Twin or not.
As an identical twin, I feel like magnet thing. I currently live in another country and I literally feel the “pull” from being away and feeling lightness and wholeness being with my twin. We even still finish each other sentences, have the same song stuck in our heads, and even make the same dinners the same night without saying anything to each other. Nothing can compare the twin relationship ❤️
I live on Maui and I remember when she was acquitted a lot of folks here felt she should have been found guilty. To this day ppl refer to them as the “Crazy twins.”
I live on Maui - she did it on purpose, and you can’t change my mind 😬 it’s an eerie and powerful side of the island, and it still feels weird to drive by there. So many cases on Maui worth covering and getting out there. Mo Monsalve, Charli Scott, and the more recent, still missing Ikaika Gamponia ♥️ I miss my friends - they deserve to be remembered
I was vacationing on Maui last summer where we did the road to Hana tour. I remember seeing a wrecked car like theirs at the bottom of a drop. Do you know if they ever recovered the vehicle? I’m wondering if the car I saw is the one Kendall shows in this video.
I was thinking something like that as well. Like, she didn't ask how her sister was because she was in the car while this all occured and already knew her sister had been killed.
That whole relationship sounds like a trainwreck from the start. I feel like it could've only ended in tragedy. The mom's death, the dad being the way he seems to be...this is one of those stories that are more intense and dramatic than fiction. Crazy, and I'm really sad for them both in a perverse way.
or possibly it was one of those situations where she had the mindset of “if i can’t have you no one can?” (not necessarily romantic ofc) but maybe she wasn’t unsatisfied with the fact that she herself didn’t die? it makes sense considering she didn’t have much of a reaction. my other theory is that she really did want to kill her sister, but didn’t mind risking her own life in the process.
It's possible there's more to the story, like maybe their father or mother was sexually abusive and they feel safer in the shower together. Just a thought, I don't know. They both seem pretty psychologically disturbed.
I think you’d be really interested in doing a story on a childhood friend of my name Josh Iwasiuk... he died in Mexico. Family believes he was beaten/tortured and thrown over a balcony. The autopsy done in Mexico does not add up to all of the damage done to his body. He was from Sellkirk Manitoba Canada
What's this weirdness about picking up a woman on the side of the road who also happened to be an identical twin? It's so odd and almost a comical detail to the sequence of horrific events. Wonder, didshe ever have anything to say as a witness?
its so weird that every single case has people thinking about others' reaction to awful things happening. people can easily dissociate due to trauma, panic attacks can be quiet sometimes, some people show signs of catatonia, everyone processes grief in their own ways like..... im pretty sure if something awful happened in my life i would just stare blankly and feel numb and break down later
It’s so frustrating to me when I hear people say it’s “weird” when someone’s face just goes blank and they show no emotion as a reaction. These girls obviously did not have a healthy grasp on their emotions and it is VERY common for people to shut down as a response. It is also very common for someone to wear the clothing of a loved one, who has passed. It allows them to feel closer. It is also common to seek intimate affection from the partner of the person who has passed.
Its common to seek affection from the partner of someone whos passed? Wow. Thats the upmost disrespectful was to "honor" your loved one who passed. Super fucked up man.
Lindsay Turner it’s super disrespectful to judge the actions of someone who has gone through loss. I have never done this but it is a very common occurrence.
yeah I agree. some of these comments are weird. for one, it doesn't surprise me at all that a twin would wear the others clothes. plus, these chicks were weird before this happened. seems to fit to me
@@BrittanyZane my husband and mom both killed themselves and I have been in some relationships where I was emotional and psychically beat up. I still don't understand. And i know trauma!
Here's the thing: I think she was probably responsible. The way she was acting afterwards definitely makes that the most likely scenario, at least in my mind. But I think there's enough reasonable doubt that it would have been unfair to convict her in a court of law. This is why it worked in her favor to select a bench trial, rather than a jury trial. I also think this is especially true considering almost all of the evidence was circumstantial. If anything hopefully she was convicted for some of her drunk driving, DWIs and DUIs are no joke and multiple offenses carry really strict sentences. I find it really strange how their father brought up that he wished Anastasia had lived rather than Alexandria - wish he had given more clarification on that!!!
Thank you! I scrolled till I found this comment. I don’t even know what this is about because I haven’t heard anything since, “they even showered together”. 😳 I don’t know what mental health crisis drives you to shower with ANY sibling as adults.
I’m not gonna lie to you when she made that statement and a few seconds later said “faught like crazy” idk if it’s the way she said it or the way I heard it but I thought she said “fucked like crazy” I was like whoa she did not just say that on her channel 😭 I lost it
They absolutely overcharged her. If they had gone for a lower charge along the lines of her being drunk and not sufficiently preventing the accident they would’ve gotten a guilty verdict.
So are we, like, absolutely sure they didn’t ever switch places for any reason? Like that the surviving twin isn’t actually the one we think is dead? I don’t know the showering with her boyfriend and wearing her clothes makes me feel like that’s definitely a possibility. I know they checked ID but... they were identical.
And the boyfriend said “when she had on her sister’s dress, it was hard to distinguish them or tell them apart” which is lowkey scary af.... is Anastasia still alive?!
They were identical twins but they were not indistinguishable. People who knew them would be able to tell them apart its not a Olsen twins movie. Anyway why would she claim to be the other?
My guess is that one of the twins was abusive to her sister who found it harder and harder to cope. The father sounds abusive too so I think the twin he related best to was the abusive one. Based on that I think the victim is the one who survived??? I bet Daddy knows who the abusive one was...she took after him.
if she and her sister showered together like was said, maybe she guilted him into it by saying she didn't want to shower alone for the first time. Fits in with her trying to be the other sister after, try on clothes, try on the boyfriend
I can understand her wearing her twins clothes. I’ve heard many occurrences of family members wearing their loved ones jacket, or keeping their most recently worn clothes or slept in items, etc, so that they can still “smell” the departed loved one’s scent for comfort. Grief is a strange beast, man.
so she told the boyfriend she wanted to kill her sister, her dad said "the wrong one died" and they had been fighting for years. And she had been charged with multiple DUI's?? Whether or not she drove off the cliff on purpose or not, she should still be in prison for her multiple DUI's, especially considering she essentially commited manslaughter in that crash by driving drunk.
I think they were just toxic. I had a friend that died and her mom wore her clothes after she died just to feel closer to her. People deal with death in many different ways ...and the trauma that comes with it.
I have an identical twin and our relationship is normal, healthy, and supportive. I have however known two sets of identical twins that violently fought, stole each other’s partners and played really cruel tricks on people. It has always freaked me out because I love my sister so much, I could never ever imagine hurting her. This story is so heart breaking.
Twin relationships are interesting. I think it is probably hard not to compare yourself to your twin especially if youre identical and plus it seems like a lot of ppl do that intentionally and unintentionally (like "oh thats the cool one" for ex). Im glad to hear you and your twin have a good bond. My mom is a (fraternal) twin and unfortunately her twin's constant comparison and trying to be "better" than my mom has led to their falling out. It's for the best tho; her twin isnt a very good person. Anyway much love to you and your sis :)
Some helicopters do have them. They're not required to have one but most modern helicopters do have one, but the older ones more than likely don't have one unless they've been updated.
Their dysfunctional twin relationship reminds me so much of Darcy and her sister from 90 Day Fiancé. Joint at the hip just to fight and compete all day.
It doesn’t make sense that she would drive off to kill the other sister. They’re BOTH in the car lol. So that theory makes no sense and I find that line of thinking really illogical. Why would someone have a motive to kill the other and plan to do it in a car crash where both are in the car? If you’re gonna murder someone intentionally you’re not gonna risk your own life. So it was either an accident (unlikely) or she intended to kill both of them.
Morgan Cunningham - agreed! If the car “accident” was actually a car “on purpose,” then the plan was to kill them both, together. Based on the way she was reportedly acting & responding to everything, she didn’t seem overtly happy to have survived.
I think it was supposed to kill them both, it’d explain her reaction and her going to new york and drunk driving again like it was a second attempt and just a clear disregard for her own safety
This is just another case of really very toxic relationship between identical twins, reminds me of The Silent Twins and Eriksson Twins. 😣 Pure madness.
Anna's randomness WhoCares I think it was sort of a Silent Twins situation, where in order to be happy, one would die. There’s very disturbing similarities between June and Jennifer Gibbons (Silent Twins) and these two. I just wished people got them help sooner, the surviving Silent Twin seems to be living a good life.
I live on Maui, this story was trending around the island for a while. I was actually in jail when she came in, and she was crying. When asked what was wrong she replied that its because shes in jail a couldnt get bail. She didnt mention anything about her sister which we found strange.
I thought you were going to say she stole her sister's identity. I think being in the car with her dead sister until she was rescued from it, she probably already knew her sister was dead considering she was a "bag of bones", hence why she didn't ask about her. I imagine that was pretty traumatic and I'm not surprised that she was blank in the hospital. Sounds like shock to me. Wearing her clothes, I think that's pretty common when you lose someone. That person's clothes smell like them and feel like them. I think she probably wanted to kill them both and had to live with the horrifying reality that she didn't die.
Not be rude, but it's really weird to me that usually when someone is super mentally unstable, they always LOOK a little odd. It's not even necessarily because they're high or drunk, like their facial structure looks unsettling.
I saw her Dr Phil episode and she even denied that her and her sister were fighting in the car. She denied EVERYTHING, including actual police reports.
there has to be some level of culpability. her reckless behaviour in assaulting her sister under such severe and dangerous conditions (heavy intoxication, a treacherous road, with a spare tire no less) is at the very least reckless endangerment. then coming back to New York and driving drunk and recklessly AGAIN? this woman is a danger to society.
They showered together?? That’s seriously flippin weird. Even if they lived in a mansion with 2 shower heads in the bathroom. It’s just so unnecessary! Showering is like your private, alone time. I just can’t...
The fact that she was accelerating at 100% does lead me to believe she did this on purpose, including the fact that if she was being pulled to the passenger's side, the wheel would've been pulled to the right as well, not to the left. I can't believe this woman got away with killing her sister and everyone around her knew that she would do eventually do it, including the boyfriend and potentially the father. Her reckless driving after the accident also shows that she was trying to harm herself again, and got away with that too. Sad and unjust.
There is no way she could have planned to kill her sister in this manner. How did she know how the car was going to land and that she was not going to get killed or paralysed too. Then on top of that she was drinking. I would never ever believe she could have planned that.
Hey! How are you? I just started a YT channel and I was wondering if you could check it out pls and maybe subscribe if you enjoyed. I make true crime videos :)
This is insane. I was born and raised on Maui and I’ve never heard of this before. The road to Hāna is no joke and people need to be so careful driving ESPECIALLY if they’re not from Maui.
Wow. My ex got manslaughter for driving intoxicated, and him and his girlfriend at the time were fighting, and she punched him in the head and he swerved into the other lane and killed someone. And even though evidence showed he was hit and thats why he swerved, since he was intoxicated, they charged him with vehicular manslaughter and he got 4 years in prison. *EDIT* For some reason, people are assuming im saying my ex shouldn't have got prison time, when im literally telling this story BECAUSE the twin also was driving intoxicated & killed someone and didn't get time just because they got hit and thats why they crashed, when my ex went through the same thing but since he was intoxicated to begin with, he still got time (as he should). Im not sure why people think I'm saying my poor ex shouldn't have been in jail🤣🤣🤣 so i thought I'd clear that shit up real quick, thats the last thing im doing
wow... even if he did purposely hit someone on purpose 4 years is definitely not enough however I’m pretty sure he got 4 year because of driving intoxicated
@@amelie3135 he never hit someone on purpose. HE was punched, swerved because of it, and hit a car and killed the person inside. He didn't purposely kill anyone
I read about this case. I can relate. I’m an identical twin with a VERY love hate relationship with my sister. I think it’s quite common for identical twins. Regarding the charge...I think she should have been charged with DUI manslaughter.
The dad saying that the wrong twin died shows you right there where the issues started. They were probably compared their whole life and learned to hate each other
One sentence and you can draw conclusions about how their childhood probably was like. Wow... you got some pretty outstanding abilities there.
@@sharatainx3990 The father's statement is pretty heavy so yes it easy to draw conclusions.
@@sharatainx3990 are you dense? A father to even mention ‘the wrong twin’ is toxic in its own form. Wake tf up dude.
@@Lunarj even if it is toxic in that one statement. You can't make assumptions on their childhood and claim you're right when you literally have no idea. Stop acting like you have some magic insight that we don't have. Yes that statement was wrong. Does that mean you automatically know they were treated poorly by their father? No. You can raise kids then not really get along with them when they are adults. It sucks but it's not uncommon.
@@naomimills7215 yea nah. Toxic.
I think she did it on purpose, but probably was expecting to die herself.
I 100% agree this this. I also dont think she planned where on the road to do it. I think she just knew she was going to do it and the fight and in that moment decided to do it then. It was just chance there were rocks at the bottom of that bit and not water
Agreed!
I think the same!
Yes! Maybe that’s why she had a blank face with no emotion?
Ditto
So, the fact that she was driving drunk, WELL OVER THE LEGAL LIMIT, doesn’t come into consideration at all? That has to be at least a manslaughter charge.
Yup and the fact they were fighting with *each other*, her sister wasn't just sitting there attacking her it was both of them
I agree! Especially since they also had previous charges for drunk driving!
Nicholas Prantil thank you!!! I was about to say the same thing!!!!
th-cam.com/video/XRoEa9LmH14/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/XRoEa9LmH14/w-d-xo.html
I hate it when investigators use “she had no reaction” as cause to look into crimes. I’ve had some shocking news relayed to me in my life, and I froze and wasn’t able to process the info until hours later.
yep, and she could have been in shock or disassociating to protect herself from the trauma.
@@nina.robbs565 that was my first thought too. Being in a crash like that (and surviving) is enough trauma to send anyone into shock, and witnessing her sister's violent death must have been traumatic as well, even if the crash was intentional. I have to wonder if there was an additional element of surreality and trauma due to the nature of their relationship - because they were identical twins, inseparable to a fault, the surviving twin may have felt as if she witnessed her OWN death ... I can't imagine what it would feel like to see someone who looks exactly like you die in such a brutal way. Dissociation seems like a pretty normal response to any one of those traumatic events.
I had this thought as well.
Yes, let's not forget that it's fight, flight, and freeze.
Everyone deals with grief differently.
Even if it wasn't FULLY on purpose, Alexandria was drunk, and driving drunk, caused an accident that killed her sister. How wasnt she found guilty based on that alone???
It should be accidental manslaughter at a minimum for driving under the influence.
Laura Eliza exactly
i know!!
Right? And she was drunk driving after the fact too. How does she keep getting off the hook for this?
@@emilyreed8946 Yes! After three separate DWI's you would think that she would have to serve jail time. And that's before you even take into account that she (allegedly) accidentally killed someone while under the influence. Is this just separate states not working together? Something is definitely missing here🤔
There were twins in my sons’ elementary school whose mother always requested they be assigned separate teachers to make it easier for them to develop their own identity. Smart, IMO
Yes I think this is a pretty common practice. In my high school our grades were always split into halves (so blue half and red half), if we ever had any sort of twins they were specifically told one of them would be in red half, and the other in blue half to help them develop friendships and identities independently, I’m almost certain we had 5 sets of twins one year.
Yes, I'm a mom of twin boys and I did the same so that my boys can have their own identities. And it worked, they are close but live their own lives and have their own set of friends, there's no competition between them.
It is. I am a twin and my mother did the same thing. 20 years later I still remember my brother and I crying our eyes out when we realized we were going to different classrooms. It helped us branch off and socialize with other children.
I'm a twin and my mom did that to us too. I remember that we begged her not to. Kindergarten was only 4 hours a day, but even those 4 hours apart were so hard!! After a couple weeks we adjusted and now I'm glad she did it. We ended up developing our own personalities and social circles. We now live on opposite sides of the country without issue. We're best friends, but also are our own people with clear unique identities. Thanks Mom!
True then after school they can elaborate on each other’s day still building that sibling bond☺️❤️ but in this situation I think the relationship between these women sparked somewhere in their childhood the father didn’t even come out to speak about either of the two
So maybe their isn't enough evidence of her intentional killing her sister, but why wasn't she charged with manslaughter by vehicle, since she was so drunk?
Because they could not prove her drunkenness caused the crash. They could easily argue that her sister yanking her hair caused the crash creating reasonable doubt, I think they could've gotten her for DUI but no jury would convict her for manslaughter.
kady k but they still didn’t charge her for a DUI
They ruled that out because the witness said that the accident was caused by her sister pulling her hair which made her swerve off the road
Excuse my Glamm Cosmetics yeah but they did toxicology reports so regardless of whether she was fighting or not she shouldn’t have been behind the wheel drunk
Yea she def should have been charged w/ something considering she was driving drunk & obv recklessly. Yes, the fighting def didn’t help & coulda been 1 of the main causes, but the other 2 still factor in as well.
“They did everything together”
Me: okay, thats not weird
“They even showered together”
Excuse me💀
You are so funny 😆
🤣🤣 I had the same reaction!!
I used to show with my sister WHEN I WAS LITTLE their grow ups that's weird😂
That's not that weird
@@giselegodoy7139 yes, yes it is or at least it is in American culture
“we have no money and are basically broke, let’s move to one of the most expensive states in the U.S” nice
Park City, UT is also the most expensive city here 🤯
🤦🏿♀️
i just wanna know how they afforded it lmao
My friends dad lived in Hawaii for a few years just selling pineapples and surfing. 🤷🏼♀️
@@erin.19 probably the boyfriends
she was definitely trying to kill both of them, kinda like a “if she’s not with me she won’t be with anyone” situation, since she didn’t want her sister moving away with her bf.
I want to take it further,she didn't just want to get rid of her she wanted to be her!
I totally agree with you,she wanted her sister just for herself.
Fr
javi I agree! There’s no way she thought running her car off a cliff would kill her sister and not her. If she only wanted her sister dead there’s other ways to go about that without getting hurt as bad as she did
Weirdtuber journalism I’m surprised she didn’t try to say she WAS Anastasia after the car accident, making everybody think Alexandria was dead. I thought that was where the story was going lol
I CANNOT believe she got away with no charges. She literally drove her sister off a cliff while drunk driving and killed her.
Absolutely. Regardless of intent, that is a serious crime.
yeah, I'm surprised she didn't get unintentional manslaughter because she was drunk , that's usually what you get, I actually know someone that was driving drunk and didn't mean to hit someone else, a stranger and he died, and although it wasn't on purpose that he killed someone, he still served jail time..
There is a rule of law saying you cannot be judged for the exact same action twice. They prosecuted her for murder and didn't put the intentional manslaughter in the trial so now that she has been acquitted they cannot pursue her again for the exact same thing
My thoughts exactly... How did they not charge her with at the very least involuntary manslaughter!?! I thought it was pretty obvious but apparently not to that court room or judge!🤦🏽
so let me get this straight. they were both in the car. they both had equal chances to die. and she planned NOT to die?
There's no way she could've known in advance that she'd survive and her sister wouldn't. Must've been suicidal or accident.
The only thing I can think of is maybe she knew of the statistic that a drunk driver is the most likely to survive in a drunk driving accident. Usually because of slowed reaction time and keeps muscles from tensing as fast in response to injury
A drunk brain/body will take the path of least resistance in a crash and not brace for impact like a sober brain would
Olivia Parker i never knew that. interesting
@@olive_99 - I can't really imagine this woman being so calculated. They both seemed kind of dumb.
@@dream4starz this is not a real fact ps. also they were both drunk
Hmm personal opinion that she was trying to kill the both of them..
Ain't no rocket science right
I agree totally
🙏🙏
Really sad tho
Totally
Am I the only one who thinks these twins look like the Wayne's brothers dressed as Brittany and Tiffany in white chicks......
They look like men, narrow hips, very unusual, will have to look up the guys
OMG yes!!!
also funny because the boyfriend kinda looks like marlon wayans one of the brothers that played the girls 😭😭
I was looking for this comment! It’s all I can see
TTTKA!
"She seemed disconnected/she showed no emotion"
That sounds like shock...
Yup
Isn’t it possible she was pulling her sisters hair because she threatened to drive them both off the cliff? Like that could’ve been an attempt to stop her from doing it.
That's what I was thinking!
I was thinking this too
If that was the case, then why did she never state that or use it for her defense?
@@samanthakhandaker464 because she's dead
this is exactly what i thought to a T.
I remember being in Maui when this happened! They look like the twins from white chicks
OMG! YES!!!!!!!
Looked 😔
At the beginning of this video I was like 'wow, they look so familiar!' and then realized it was because they look like the twins from White Chicks! If I didn't know better, I'd almost think it was them lol
Ugh I wish I didn’t click on your channel Kayleb 🤮 you shouldn’t have a platform on TH-cam for promoting pedophilia - most disturbing 30 seconds of a video I’ve watched
@@wackyunicorn11 are defending pedophilia because it's not directly hurting the person who commented? You deserve to be in prison along side him.
She was drunk. How was she not convicted of that alone?
Omg true? Didn’t even realize
right like intoxication causing death???
Because prosecutors over-charged her. They do that dumb shit all the time and murderers go free. Look at Casey Anthony. If they had tried to get her for anything other than first degree murder, she would be sitting in jail right now more than likely.
Honestly Kendall's voice is just one that I can listen to for hours without getting bored. Playing these videos in the background helps me be productive lol
I keep her on at night
honestly the only true crime TH-camr I can tolerate
True. This is 3rd story in a row I'm listening to.
She’s honestly the only reason I watch TH-cam at this point!
Yeah same! I love this type of American accent, the accent where not every end of a word sounds like a question haha
How is she not charged with at least manslaughter? She’s at fault for killing another human being under the influence of alcohol.
That’s what i don’t understand! She still was drunk driving so that did kill her sister regardles
Ya vehicular manslaughter...makes no sense
I think its because the prosecutor was trying to get her charged with intentional murder, which was their first mistake. If they cannot prove that she was guilty of intentional homicide beyond a reasonable doubt, then she would not be charged with that, and let go. You cannot change the charges (from intentional to manslaughter) during a trial unless a deal is made with the defense team. If they tried charging her with manslaughter initially, I believe she would be in jail now. Basically, the prosecutor risked it all to get her charged with murder, and it backfired.
And you can't be charged with the same crime twice.
@@graceyoung4205 like in the casey Antony case
@@reginapauffley2577 Exactly.
If their dad said the wrong sister died it’s most likely she did it on purpose
Not necessarily, but he'd probably know them best.
It is very telling of who the mean onecwas. Also that Alex bf reacted how he did.
Or the dad was a Jerk
It's very common for parents to have a favourite twin, not normally to this extreme but favourites is definitely a thing.
nolinaGirlasia.link
I think she purposely drove off the cliff, she just didn’t intent to live through the ordeal. It seems like the adrenaline of the fight, mixed with a lot of alcohol, mixed with suicidal thoughts already, she probably made a split decision out of anger and threw them off
I was there with a group of scouts when the accident occurred. One twin was physically attacking the other one when she was driving, and she was trying to protect herself, it was a horrible accident, with even crazier outcome.
It’s so hard to tell if there was intention or just a bad mix of everything going wrong at once. Either way, I’m sure the surviving sister will spend her life wishing she could redo this day. I can’t imagine having to live with that the rest of her life. Terribly sad.
I’ve taught yoga for 8 years and some of the most messed up people I have met, have been other yoga teachers and studio owners. A lot of it is fake and people who hide their mental issues behind a facade.
I met an American woman in Bali who had a 10 year old son, very sweet boy, but she was nuts and shacked up woth the yoga teacher. I actually contacted the police in their home town in the US to see if she had abducted the boy, but there was no missing person report on him and his father had died a few years before of a drug OD.
Yoga teachers or life coaches. Every one I know is psychologically messed up.
@@charlisays a lot of psychiatrists are crazy as loons too.
Oh that's also very true! 😬
I know a therapist (therapists are called “doctor” now. She’s an overweight pill popping alcoholic sex addicted slob. Imagine being counseled by somebody like that?
It sounds like a murder suicide to me.
Murder attempted suicide. But yeah. I agree
Mother Hen of Damnifiknow Farms you know what I meant.
I think it is murder suicide accident for the twins
I'm an identical twin, I think being raised to be a full person is one of the most beneficial things a parent can do for multiples, especially identical ones.
Like my twin and I were almost always together, but my parents made sure we were in separate classes, so we learned how to be socially independent. My mom would listen to every story twice, even when they were exactly the same, she wanted both of us to feel like we mattered and were individuals.
Obviously you can't escape everything, my twin always had a massive issue with us looking the same, we looked increasingly different over the years, but I think childhood is where the meat of the issues begin. Pretty much everyone called us "the twins" or "the girls" but my parents never did. That kind of stuff matters.
People say they're freaked out by twins because of infamous twins like these two, and I totally agree, I just know it doesn't apply to all twins. I have some experience. But the twins like that, who still look identical as adults, yeah.. It freaks you out because it oozes dysfunction and hints at some really weird shit. It's abnormal.
This reminds me of those silent twins, and the Swedish ones too, like one needed to die so the other could live. You can't treat two virtually identical people with two distinct and competing minds as one entity and expect anything good to come of it. Instant recipe for self destruction.
im an identical twin too!!! me and my twin have different looks now and try to almost prove to everyone that we are two separate people. definitely was called the twins and the girls by everyone even my parents, even still to this day. i love her and she’s almost like my other half but it’s frustrating that others see us as the same person or a group but we see ourselves as 2 very different people. i feel this
@@nothingpersonal222 almost like your other half? Lol
Um she kinda is haha
I'm only playing. Made me laugh. :)
Exactly!! Your parents were very wise! Encouraging individual thinking and self worth is key with multiples!
I have fraternal twins, so not exactly the same situation but from the beginning, I made sure they are able to explore their own unique interests and not to refer to them as "the twins" very often. They are still small children but it seems to be healthy for them - they get along great 90 percent of the time.
Since the day my sister-in-law found out she was pregnant with twin girls she did not allow anyone to call them "the twins". We actually refer to them as "the girls" or by their names. They are very different personality and looks wise. They have different goals and dreams and are rarely even together and have different circle of friends. They are 20 years old now.
I’m only at the 1:00 mark and when you said “They even showered together” I knew this was going to be a ride.
th-cam.com/video/XRoEa9LmH14/w-d-xo.html
Anyone else notice how when they were both being interviewed on the news the headline was “former local business owner charged with killing sister” foreshadowing or what😳
WHAT. That's creepy as hell.
@@starqueen3270 Right
I didn’t even notice
@@raixbd Exactly, no foreshadowing whatsoever 😒
Use your brain! The interview with the twins is an old footage that they showed after the accident and the murder charge… duh 🙄
Idk who needs to hear this but....... STOP PUSHING YOUR TWINS TO DRESS THE SAME!! Just because they look alike doesn’t mean they are same person!!!
❗️
My girls are twins and they dress the same 🤣🤷🏻♀️
Jess Xo just ask both of your girls if they actually like dressing the same...
Kristina Abraham My aunts are twins and I know they said as little girls, it was fun. They even once pranked their boyfriends as teens. But one thing that they shared with me was that it was at their teenage years, they wanted to feel separate. They felt half of a person, always “the twins”. It was in their teens that they started to self identify. They say it was cute as children to dress the same but when they were old enough to choose, they did.
Kristina Abraham they have no choice 😏
Did she get no time?? She literally was arrested multiple times for drunk driving which alone should give jail time. Also, I’m not sure how it works but if she was intoxicated whilst driving off the cliff could she not still be done for manslaughter?
She did! I live in Maui and we are all well aware of this case. My uncle is a Corrections Officer she was detained for her PreTrial before she made bail. She was very cocky though, like very snooty. She knew what had happened, but while incarcerated, my uncle claimed it seemed she had no remorse
Kayzia-Ashley Washington that’s really interesting. I watched her on Dr Phil, and everyone in the comments section (plus Dr Phil) seems to think she was innocent, but I’m seeing a lot different on here.
She should’ve yes
No, according to the law you cant be charged twice for the same crime. They already charged her for the cliff incident with 2nd degree murder so they can't charge her again.
Crocheting Canuck Double Jeopardy
There's literally no way she tried to solely kill her sister- there was absolutely no guarantee of her surviving that crash and only killing her twin...
Plus I don't find it strange at all that she had no emotion, didn't ask about the sister, and started wearing her clothes. With the mental connection they had, she probably knew immediately that the twin was gone and she was numb to it, like being in shock. How does she cope with the guilt of knowing she killed her other half whom she had a rocky relationship with? She tries to fill the void by trying to feel the sister nearby, by wearing her clothes. Idk it all adds up as either A. an accident or B. she wanted to take both their lives and didn't plan to live
Spot on what I was thinking... her twin passed away so her herself maybe felt dead or dying also. Plus shock. I 100% believe this theory!
I agree with you
Agreed! They were both dysfunctional and violent. It's likely they both had suicidal ideations but there is no evidence either had a plan. The witness driving behind them is critical. You have to be out of your damn tree to pull someone's hair while they are driving anywhere ever but especially on that road!
My thoughts too.
Agreed
This case reminds me of the Silent Twins. They refused to speak to anyone but each other,
and did literally everything the same and together. But they also fought like dogs. One twin strangled the other with a radio cord during one of their brawls. In the end one twin died while napping on her sister’s shoulder, and it was written in her journal one of us must die, so the other can live. The similarities are so eerie. It’s something about identical twins.
It’s not normal behavior to shower with your sibling as an adult. Some dysfunction going on behind closed doors...
RIGHT?!?!
It’s not weird at all 🙄
They shared men in the past ,indeed very strange
Kyla Lambalot not
Nazira it’s not
Why arent they taking away this womens drivers license?!
bc of white privilege
Cause they're dumb
Exactly, she's done more than enough to get her licence taken away
Brîndușa D. Actually it is...
It sounds like both of these women have been able to scam and avoid any type of consequences their whole life. Massive amounts of debt, DUIs, fighting, and scamming people out their money. No accountability anywhere!
I think she was trying to kill both of them. There's no way she knew that just her sister would be the one to pass.
Same, that’s how I feel.
Plus one of the boyfriends mentioned the girls planning to take their lives. It's possible it was meant to be a murder-suicide.
Yeah I agree. Cause they said it was a miracle Alexandria survived
I reckon Anastacia was pulling Alexandria's hair bc she was threatening to drive off the cliff
Their faces give me chills, on the mugshot I was so creeped out. They just look non human ?!
Plastic surgery?
Same
Anyone drunk driving is guilty of murder in my opinion.
not how the law works. its manslaughter
Its dui resulting in substantial bodily harm/death (in NV) and it often carries a 3-15, or a 4-10, meaning after 3 or years they are elligible for parol. And with good behavior, and work detail, the back #s (the 15 or the 10) are nearly cut in half. . . And DUI inmates are considered minimum security inmates and go to the work camps. So 3-15, turns into 3 yrs in minimum security, then parole for 4 years. Of course that's for a first offense and obv on certain circumstances. That's in Nevada, at least
Sunshine K that’s why they said it’s their opinion
thats true. sorry. guilty in their opinion and not necessarily legally guilty. sorry
@@sunshinek5827 it's all good, but yes I just ment my personal feelings. Was hit by a drunk driver 2 months ago and luckily walked away with only bruises.
They kind of remind me of the “silent twins” June & Jennifer Gibbons. Only one could live. 😳
Thats what I was thinking the whole time!!!!!
ME TOOOOOOOO
my thoughts exactly, and didn't kendall cover them too? there has to be some kind of diagnosis or cause for this behavior. it's so odd.
That’s exactly what I thought. It could be why she wasn’t phased by her sisters death🤷🏽♀️ They were 1 soul in 2 bodies, then were 1 soul in 1 body so it just felt right.
IKR that’s what I was thinking
The idea of twins harming each other always seems weird to me. I am a twin I have a sister. We never truly thought of being a twin as special other than some people would tell us we were closer than most siblings. We tend to think similar and often have the same ideas. I have anxiety and depression while my sister is rather self confident and doesn't have problems with her mental health. In some ways I truly do think she is my other half because she has traits that I truly wished I had. We moved into an apartment together and just adopted a dog together. I really enjoy my life with her right now. She is my best friend.
Watch her case on the silent twins. Crazy! They hurt each other aswell
th-cam.com/video/stOemEQRc3w/w-d-xo.html
My younger brothers are twins. The fought viciously in their youth. We're talking: hitting each other with shovels & baseball bats, cutting each other with scissors, one pushed the other into a chimney & cracked his head open, the list goes on. Our father abandoned the family & my mom was an abusive alcoholic. I've wondered if a crappy upbringing contributed to their hatred of each other. Anyhow...they ended up becoming friends in their adult lives & even live next door to each other.
This comment is so wholesome
@@butterfly8514 I did with my sister awhile back. We both thought these girls relationship with each other was really creepy and toxic. Same with this case.
Apparently, you aren't twinning properly.
What if the twin who died was actually Alexandria?! That would explain the clothes and the shower scene..
Thank you! I was looking for this. Are we the only ones thinking this? Plus the boyfriend in court kept calling her the wrong name. I am convinced!
STOP
One of them had a more outgoing personality. The dad would be able to identify who was whom.
a parent should be able to tell their twins apart
@@kevinmalone3210 True but I wonder if she could have faked it or just made up a lie about grieving her sister and the crash "changing" her. The father seems very sketchy with that the other daughter should have died line.
There’s no way she would have known that would have only killed Anastasia. So I think she was trying to kill both of them.
They definitely had a very toxic relationship. And their Dad saying that shows they probably had a pretty hard home life when they were younger.
Agreed. Had to be a murder-suicide attempt. There’s no way she would have known she’d make it out alive. Drunkenness sure didn’t help.
Some people mistake smooth ground for a path and don't known heading toward a cliff until to late. Don't drive off road if you don't know what is up ahead.
There is no way she could have planned to kill her sister in this manner. How did she know how the car was going to land and that she was not going to get killed or paralysed too. Then on top of that she was drinking. I would never ever believe she could have planned that.
I was thinking a murder-suicide too. Or at the very least she didn't care if they both died. They were fighting, were known to have a toxic relationship. I don't buy for a second that this was an accident.
JUST BECAUSE THE SUICIDE PART OF HER MURDER-SUICIDE PLAN DIDN'T SUCCEED DOESN'T MEAN SHE'S NOT A MURDERER.
She was drunk driving and took a life.
Yeah exactly
Francesca Raso I agree BUT I feel like there’s enough reasonable doubt. I mean she WAS being attacked while driving!! Idk so hard to make a decision for me
This is why twins need to be raised with their own identities
Yep so true
Definitely agree but they should also be raised together because sometimes a twin is part of you, mentally. Sometimes physically too tho
Right?! Even me and my sister who’s 2 years older were kinda messed up by being raised like twins. It caused a lot of resentment and issues so deep we’re still working things out decades later.
I'm pretty sure I read that Twins should be raised as different people and not the same as it has some bad mental effects
Totally agree. The mom thought them habits like taking showers together and stuff. It's just unhealthy
I think the rock part is a coincidence, I think she was just intoxicated and out of her mind with the fighting and saw there was no rail and lost it. I don't think it was specifically planned but I think she had it in her mind for a while. I think she expected to kill them both but mainly wanted to kill her sister. Definitely not an accident!
As a twin this whole thing makes me so uncomfortable
Be your own people
i never like when they say “oh she was so calm and didn’t care” because a lot of people forget shock can make you so numb and disconnected from everything that’s happening
This and also not everyone is a crier, screamer and fainter. I'm not.
She could have dissociated imo
i agree
Dude fr. My grandpa died and I was in so much shock and some girl at school yelled at me and To this day I remember how hurtful she was.
are we just gonna ignore the fact that not only did she show no emotion when they told her that her sister died BUT then she started wearing her clothes and TOOK A SHOWER WITH HER DEAD SISTERS BOYFRIEND?!
Like , if it was just a tragic accident why were they comfortable enough to be bathing together
That can sometimes be a trauma response. I've had no reaction in severely traumatizing situations because I didn't have the capacity to process what happened. Wearing someone's clothes after they grieve can also be a way to feel closer to them. Human beings are nuanced. I think she may have tried a murder suicide and survived and then regretted it deeply.
elliot thurber yea I totally get the clothes thing. I wear my dead parents clothes all the time.
@@deli.rat. Agreed... I had no response when my dad was killed. I was blank. I didn't have any emotions until i saw his body in the casket. Crazy, ppl think everyone should react in the exact same manner. Twin or not.
As an identical twin, I feel like magnet thing. I currently live in another country and I literally feel the “pull” from being away and feeling lightness and wholeness being with my twin. We even still finish each other sentences, have the same song stuck in our heads, and even make the same dinners the same night without saying anything to each other. Nothing can compare the twin relationship ❤️
My mom is a twin and almost every birthday they give each other the SAME birthday card.
This comment made me smile♥️God bless your relationship with your sister always ♥️
I live on Maui and I remember when she was acquitted a lot of folks here felt she should have been found guilty. To this day ppl refer to them as the “Crazy twins.”
I live on Maui - she did it on purpose, and you can’t change my mind 😬 it’s an eerie and powerful side of the island, and it still feels weird to drive by there.
So many cases on Maui worth covering and getting out there. Mo Monsalve, Charli Scott, and the more recent, still missing Ikaika Gamponia ♥️ I miss my friends - they deserve to be remembered
I was vacationing on Maui last summer where we did the road to Hana tour. I remember seeing a wrecked car like theirs at the bottom of a drop. Do you know if they ever recovered the vehicle? I’m wondering if the car I saw is the one Kendall shows in this video.
I live on Maui too 🙃
Christy J I think it was another car you're thinking of
Even if it was an accident, she was still driving drunk like????? she should still have been held responsible.
White privilege
The surviving twin seemed shocked... like in shock. She probably seen her sister dead already and just felt hopeless and numb
I was thinking something like that as well. Like, she didn't ask how her sister was because she was in the car while this all occured and already knew her sister had been killed.
I felt this too like she's in denial that she let this happen.
*saw
I agree. I think she did it on purpose to kill them both but was in shock that she survived and that her sister was dead.
Agree.
That whole relationship sounds like a trainwreck from the start. I feel like it could've only ended in tragedy. The mom's death, the dad being the way he seems to be...this is one of those stories that are more intense and dramatic than fiction. Crazy, and I'm really sad for them both in a perverse way.
The acceleration is what really has me convinced this was an attempted murder suicide..
or possibly it was one of those situations where she had the mindset of “if i can’t have you no one can?” (not necessarily romantic ofc) but maybe she wasn’t unsatisfied with the fact that she herself didn’t die? it makes sense considering she didn’t have much of a reaction. my other theory is that she really did want to kill her sister, but didn’t mind risking her own life in the process.
Your foot can slip when you're in a fight.
Maybe. But she was drunk and fighting. Her responses and reflexes would have been impaired.
Um ok but showering together? No offence but kinda gross ._.
Puff Puff Pig it’s very common in other cultures but I feel you 💀
I'm a twin, an identical twin, and I think that's absolutely disgusting. Like you do you, but like...that's ain't for me.
I mean I guess if you got the exact same body anyway?? 😂 still weird imo
@@austinm8334 yeah, my sister and I have the same body, but it'd just be strange tbh. Like....it'd just be weird LOL
It's possible there's more to the story, like maybe their father or mother was sexually abusive and they feel safer in the shower together. Just a thought, I don't know. They both seem pretty psychologically disturbed.
‘They even showered together’ Lmao wtf 🤨😅
Yea im good off that😂 its unacceptable with a sibling after like 5
Okay but like ew
This was me when she said that 👁👄👁
@@jessicacathrine1 you don't have a nose?
All these comments have me dying 😂😂😂😭
Imagine a live action version of this story both twins played by nicole kidman
Yes!!
I love this idea.
Agree
Creeeeeepy! (But I'd def tune in lol!)
I think you’d be really interested in doing a story on a childhood friend of my name Josh Iwasiuk... he died in Mexico. Family believes he was beaten/tortured and thrown over a balcony. The autopsy done in Mexico does not add up to all of the damage done to his body. He was from Sellkirk Manitoba Canada
This is just is crazy overall. But I'm mostly wondering why they looked late 30s to early 40s in high school.
I made this exact comment hahah, so glad it’s not just me
makenna shuter white people age quickly
Hahaha I was thinking that exact same thing lol
There's always a few white girls that have looked like 40yr old moms since highschool
Frosty theHoeman yeah, we call them “feminists” today 🤣😉
What's this weirdness about picking up a woman on the side of the road who also happened to be an identical twin? It's so odd and almost a comical detail to the sequence of horrific events. Wonder, didshe ever have anything to say as a witness?
maybe it never happened. If it did, she's probably thanking her lucky stars!
Maybe the hitch hiker lied 🤔 to seem more appealing to them in some way?
In Hawaii, it's kind of a thing. Some believe it's Pele testing your good will, and helping her will bring good fortune to you.
its so weird that every single case has people thinking about others' reaction to awful things happening. people can easily dissociate due to trauma, panic attacks can be quiet sometimes, some people show signs of catatonia, everyone processes grief in their own ways like..... im pretty sure if something awful happened in my life i would just stare blankly and feel numb and break down later
It’s so frustrating to me when I hear people say it’s “weird” when someone’s face just goes blank and they show no emotion as a reaction. These girls obviously did not have a healthy grasp on their emotions and it is VERY common for people to shut down as a response. It is also very common for someone to wear the clothing of a loved one, who has passed. It allows them to feel closer. It is also common to seek intimate affection from the partner of the person who has passed.
Its common to seek affection from the partner of someone whos passed? Wow. Thats the upmost disrespectful was to "honor" your loved one who passed. Super fucked up man.
Lindsay Turner it’s super disrespectful to judge the actions of someone who has gone through loss. I have never done this but it is a very common occurrence.
yeah I agree. some of these comments are weird. for one, it doesn't surprise me at all that a twin would wear the others clothes. plus, these chicks were weird before this happened. seems to fit to me
@@lindsayturner84 Oh, you’d be surprised. Trauma does wonders.
@@BrittanyZane my husband and mom both killed themselves and I have been in some relationships where I was emotional and psychically beat up. I still don't understand. And i know trauma!
Here's the thing: I think she was probably responsible. The way she was acting afterwards definitely makes that the most likely scenario, at least in my mind. But I think there's enough reasonable doubt that it would have been unfair to convict her in a court of law. This is why it worked in her favor to select a bench trial, rather than a jury trial. I also think this is especially true considering almost all of the evidence was circumstantial. If anything hopefully she was convicted for some of her drunk driving, DWIs and DUIs are no joke and multiple offenses carry really strict sentences.
I find it really strange how their father brought up that he wished Anastasia had lived rather than Alexandria - wish he had given more clarification on that!!!
Glad to see you here my guy
@NillyC I know. What an awful thing for a father to say.
Omg skjdhwb it's Kalvin Garrah 😍
@@TH-kp5vi ikr!
but then man witnessed her slam on her breaks, turn the wheel and floor it off the cliff... thats a murder suicide
Nobody gonna talk about how they showered together 💀💀💀💀💀
😭🤣🤣
That along with the father’s statement along with the alcoholism makes me believe that there was some type of abuse that they grew up in
Thank you! I scrolled till I found this comment. I don’t even know what this is about because I haven’t heard anything since, “they even showered together”. 😳 I don’t know what mental health crisis drives you to shower with ANY sibling as adults.
I’m not gonna lie to you when she made that statement and a few seconds later said “faught like crazy” idk if it’s the way she said it or the way I heard it but I thought she said “fucked like crazy” I was like whoa she did not just say that on her channel 😭 I lost it
That's weird for any siblings, twins means nothing. But this world is cuckoo.
They absolutely overcharged her. If they had gone for a lower charge along the lines of her being drunk and not sufficiently preventing the accident they would’ve gotten a guilty verdict.
So are we, like, absolutely sure they didn’t ever switch places for any reason? Like that the surviving twin isn’t actually the one we think is dead? I don’t know the showering with her boyfriend and wearing her clothes makes me feel like that’s definitely a possibility. I know they checked ID but... they were identical.
And she refused fingerprints... I like this idea
Their father would recognise which twin is which
Saphire Wallis what if hes in on it👀
And the boyfriend said “when she had on her sister’s dress, it was hard to distinguish them or tell them apart” which is lowkey scary af.... is Anastasia still alive?!
They were identical twins but they were not indistinguishable. People who knew them would be able to tell them apart its not a Olsen twins movie. Anyway why would she claim to be the other?
No one is talking about the fathers' weird reaction????
indeed like wtf??!!
My guess is that one of the twins was abusive to her sister who found it harder and harder to cope. The father sounds abusive too so I think the twin he related best to was the abusive one. Based on that I think the victim is the one who survived???
I bet Daddy knows who the abusive one was...she took after him.
She seems like an abusive person
super. but also,,,,says a lot about her
@@frankboff1260 I agree. No normal parent would respond that way.
Also WHY was her sister's boyfriend showering with her right after......?
Yeah that was weird as hell. He was strange too
if she and her sister showered together like was said, maybe she guilted him into it by saying she didn't want to shower alone for the first time. Fits in with her trying to be the other sister after, try on clothes, try on the boyfriend
@@msleighfawnduh it does but why would he agree to it! I do see what you're saying about her manipulating him but still...
@@laceyelizabeth816 agreed... At least he seemed to care but maybe not
@@evelambrick True, all I can hope is that is was a super fucked up coping mechanism
Kendall: “lets just dive right in”
Me: 👀 the play on words lmao
I can understand her wearing her twins clothes. I’ve heard many occurrences of family members wearing their loved ones jacket, or keeping their most recently worn clothes or slept in items, etc, so that they can still “smell” the departed loved one’s scent for comfort. Grief is a strange beast, man.
My fiancé passed away in February, I'm wearing his T-shirt right now.
so she told the boyfriend she wanted to kill her sister, her dad said "the wrong one died" and they had been fighting for years. And she had been charged with multiple DUI's?? Whether or not she drove off the cliff on purpose or not, she should still be in prison for her multiple DUI's, especially considering she essentially commited manslaughter in that crash by driving drunk.
How you gonna drop, "They even showered together," on us and not even pause to let us process 😂
Oh, I'm sure the males paused and " processed " that detail with a visualization for a moment.
Not important to the story but Alcoholics, going on a camping trip is one of the worst places to try and stay sober IMO.
When you said the paramedics went down to see if any of them made it, I though you were going to say: and they found them fighting lol
SAME!
Lol this comment was funny
Lol
The way the boyfriend gave her a bath and smiled when he said they were indistinguishable...? I wonder how he feels about it?
That part was so weird and gross. She,accident or not, killed your girlfriend and you give her a bath?! Wtf?!
I friggin love your profile pic haha 🙂
Pretty sure it wasn't just a bath
@@BlueblueN exactly :/
@@sbradley1308 yup
I think they were just toxic. I had a friend that died and her mom wore her clothes after she died just to feel closer to her. People deal with death in many different ways ...and the trauma that comes with it.
I have an identical twin and our relationship is normal, healthy, and supportive. I have however known two sets of identical twins that violently fought, stole each other’s partners and played really cruel tricks on people. It has always freaked me out because I love my sister so much, I could never ever imagine hurting her. This story is so heart breaking.
Hard to say, we always did everything together but we were never obliged to dress the same ect. None of the usual tropes. 😊
Twin relationships are interesting. I think it is probably hard not to compare yourself to your twin especially if youre identical and plus it seems like a lot of ppl do that intentionally and unintentionally (like "oh thats the cool one" for ex). Im glad to hear you and your twin have a good bond. My mom is a (fraternal) twin and unfortunately her twin's constant comparison and trying to be "better" than my mom has led to their falling out. It's for the best tho; her twin isnt a very good person. Anyway much love to you and your sis :)
So you're telling me, newer cars come with black boxes but helicopters don't? WTF
Some helicopters do have them. They're not required to have one but most modern helicopters do have one, but the older ones more than likely don't have one unless they've been updated.
I don’t know why but my mind instantly went to White Chicks when I saw them..
They have big masculine faces so I see that
Same here🤣. and Federico was Terry Crews😆!
@@vickyfaul3160 :D
Same! I keep thinking this is them, even tho that was just a movie lmaoo
Pretty sure it's because they have male bone structure
Their dysfunctional twin relationship reminds me so much of Darcy and her sister from 90 Day Fiancé. Joint at the hip just to fight and compete all day.
Haven’t watched the whole thing but there’s a Netflix movie about this !!
what’s it called
carley lynn twinsanity
Oh wow I saw that movie, I didn't realize it was a true story. Crazy!
Exactly what I was thinking
About to watch it tonight that for that comment!!!
It doesn’t make sense that she would drive off to kill the other sister. They’re BOTH in the car lol. So that theory makes no sense and I find that line of thinking really illogical. Why would someone have a motive to kill the other and plan to do it in a car crash where both are in the car? If you’re gonna murder someone intentionally you’re not gonna risk your own life. So it was either an accident (unlikely) or she intended to kill both of them.
Stephen Bailey exactly. I think she was trying to kill both of them.
Morgan Cunningham - agreed! If the car “accident” was actually a car “on purpose,” then the plan was to kill them both, together. Based on the way she was reportedly acting & responding to everything, she didn’t seem overtly happy to have survived.
I think it was supposed to kill them both, it’d explain her reaction and her going to new york and drunk driving again like it was a second attempt and just a clear disregard for her own safety
I think it was supposed to be a murder suicide gone wrong
Agree except I think it was an accident
This is just another case of really very toxic relationship between identical twins, reminds me of The Silent Twins and Eriksson Twins. 😣 Pure madness.
Anna's randomness WhoCares I think it was sort of a Silent Twins situation, where in order to be happy, one would die. There’s very disturbing similarities between June and Jennifer Gibbons (Silent Twins) and these two. I just wished people got them help sooner, the surviving Silent Twin seems to be living a good life.
I live on Maui, this story was trending around the island for a while. I was actually in jail when she came in, and she was crying. When asked what was wrong she replied that its because shes in jail a couldnt get bail. She didnt mention anything about her sister which we found strange.
7:07 Hawaii? All that debt and they move to Hawaii?!! It’s crazy expensive there 😫🤣
I thought you were going to say she stole her sister's identity. I think being in the car with her dead sister until she was rescued from it, she probably already knew her sister was dead considering she was a "bag of bones", hence why she didn't ask about her. I imagine that was pretty traumatic and I'm not surprised that she was blank in the hospital. Sounds like shock to me. Wearing her clothes, I think that's pretty common when you lose someone. That person's clothes smell like them and feel like them. I think she probably wanted to kill them both and had to live with the horrifying reality that she didn't die.
Not be rude, but it's really weird to me that usually when someone is super mentally unstable, they always LOOK a little odd. It's not even necessarily because they're high or drunk, like their facial structure looks unsettling.
Yeah I feel the same way. It’s odd but really interesting
Like your profile pic🤔🧐
Right? I thought I was seeing things
@@Heseesyou 💀
@@Heseesyou ouch
I saw her Dr Phil episode and she even denied that her and her sister were fighting in the car. She denied EVERYTHING, including actual police reports.
kendall: here’s how the murder went down
me: what a good cat
I went to their yoga studio and was taught by them. Can’t believe your covering this story!!!
there has to be some level of culpability. her reckless behaviour in assaulting her sister under such severe and dangerous conditions (heavy intoxication, a treacherous road, with a spare tire no less) is at the very least reckless endangerment. then coming back to New York and driving drunk and recklessly AGAIN? this woman is a danger to society.
How do they completely disregard the fact that her BA was 3 times the legal limit?! She’s responsible for the accident no matter how you look at it.
They showered together?? That’s seriously flippin weird. Even if they lived in a mansion with 2 shower heads in the bathroom. It’s just so unnecessary! Showering is like your private, alone time. I just can’t...
The fact that she was accelerating at 100% does lead me to believe she did this on purpose, including the fact that if she was being pulled to the passenger's side, the wheel would've been pulled to the right as well, not to the left. I can't believe this woman got away with killing her sister and everyone around her knew that she would do eventually do it, including the boyfriend and potentially the father. Her reckless driving after the accident also shows that she was trying to harm herself again, and got away with that too. Sad and unjust.
There is no way she could have planned to kill her sister in this manner. How did she know how the car was going to land and that she was not going to get killed or paralysed too. Then on top of that she was drinking. I would never ever believe she could have planned that.
There's a Netflix movie based on these two: "Twinsanity". I KNEW it was about them as soon as I saw this title!
thanks
I knew I had heard a version of this somewhere
@@mindpathmusings6284 Yup! It's actually very much like a Lifetime movie (might be a Lifetime movie) but it's pretty good
I was insane. And after watching it I believe that she did it on purpose
Praying for the gentleman who witnessed the accident...it had to be traumatic to witness
always drop everything i’m doing for her videos❣️🦋
Samee lol
Did you even watch the video?
Hey! How are you? I just started a YT channel and I was wondering if you could check it out pls and maybe subscribe if you enjoyed. I make true crime videos :)
Same!!!!
Same here lol
This is insane. I was born and raised on Maui and I’ve never heard of this before. The road to Hāna is no joke and people need to be so careful driving ESPECIALLY if they’re not from Maui.
Hana roadways are crazy
You can even get a t-shirt in Maui that's says "I survived the road to Hana".
Really?? It was like al over the news girl! I even ran into them too! I too born and raised Maui!
I was just thinking about how rough that road is.
Kayzia-Ashley Washington maybe I missed it on the news! It’s crazy!
Wow. My ex got manslaughter for driving intoxicated, and him and his girlfriend at the time were fighting, and she punched him in the head and he swerved into the other lane and killed someone. And even though evidence showed he was hit and thats why he swerved, since he was intoxicated, they charged him with vehicular manslaughter and he got 4 years in prison.
*EDIT* For some reason, people are assuming im saying my ex shouldn't have got prison time, when im literally telling this story BECAUSE the twin also was driving intoxicated & killed someone and didn't get time just because they got hit and thats why they crashed, when my ex went through the same thing but since he was intoxicated to begin with, he still got time (as he should).
Im not sure why people think I'm saying my poor ex shouldn't have been in jail🤣🤣🤣 so i thought I'd clear that shit up real quick, thats the last thing im doing
Holy shit that’s girlfriend must feel like crap
That ex girlfriend should have been charged as well. What a sad horrible situation ☹️
wow... even if he did purposely hit someone on purpose 4 years is definitely not enough however I’m pretty sure he got 4 year because of driving intoxicated
@@leximari she was also charged. She got more time because while she was out on bail, she did a bunch of really fucked up stuff.
@@amelie3135 he never hit someone on purpose. HE was punched, swerved because of it, and hit a car and killed the person inside. He didn't purposely kill anyone
I read about this case. I can relate. I’m an identical twin with a VERY love hate relationship with my sister. I think it’s quite common for identical twins. Regarding the charge...I think she should have been charged with DUI manslaughter.
I know this is off-topic, but I love how there's always an animal chillin on the bed whenever Kendall does a video.