I don't think this is bad at all... The song is pretty cute. The girls did pretty well. I understand their coaches want them to perform like BINI but they have been together for quite a time already. If they want these girls to share that bond and chemistry on stage, give them more time. Good luck girls! Keep doing your best.
Napansin ko din yung moves medyo mukhang matamlay. Kailangan mahasa nila yung dance move nila kahit hard or soft yung step, dapat may dating pa din ang bigay. Medyo galaw baby pa sila e. Pero we are still rooting to these trainees, mapupulido din nila yan dahil sa mga naexperience nila sa show. Just keep na ma-inspired sa mga naging senior nila. Wag nila iisipin na mahina sila dahil walang mahina na di lumalakas.
Yeah, I gotta agree. There's not much parts in their songs where they can do something something with "wow" factor. And they are still a bit lacking in charisma, but they'll get there eventually cuz they train so much and are already very pretty appearance-wise
The girls are actually good. They got nice voices, stage presence and on top of that the song is pleasing to the ears. Don't be sad girls, I know you guys can do it!
They're talented, no question about it. The problem is, they don't have individuality when it comes to vocals, they practically all sound the same, you can't tell them apart when listening to thei voices. Although they're a whole group, its not a bad idea to have their individual voice colors, so the songs don't sound so generic, you know what I mean? Just like ROYGBV colors, when combined becomes a beautiful rainbow 🌈
The girls are talented, they can sing , dance and rap. What they were lacking is a good song that matches their voice color and style and a song with good production. This song is okay... but it lacks the "ooomf" factor. Probably add bass or something to make the song fuller.
الاغنيه رائعة جدا وهذا المقطع ادماني 0:51 الرقصه التي كانت بالبداية رائعه جدا وأعتقد أنهم بذلوا قصار جهدهم اعتقد فقط أنني غير راضيه ابدا عن تصميم المسرح والمكياج والملابس.
I'm not sure what the other commenters are saying here as if they are very good when it comes to music, but what I can say about the song is good, cute and tiktokable chorus. The artists are beautiful too. 🥰 Keep it guys.. Just believe in yourself. You will be successful and famous all over the world. 🔥💪🫰
The girls are so beautiful and talented. Although I don't really listen to this kind of music I really love this since it's chic. Rooting for your debut❤❤❤
Better songs is what they need the most. They just need to improve in not worrying too much about the performance they should let loose and enjoy the stage and the audience
I wouldn't call this a bad song, i find it cute and trendy. Maybe it's just lacking the 'it' factor but it aint bad at all. The dance lacks something that is truly memorable. The feather though...😂
The girls are really good. They just need more time to grow. And be used to more stages. And that hunger for performance. That way they will grow confident. If they will develop g22's stagw presence and and in time the group coordination like Bini. They will grow big. Once they make their own song and sound, they will soar! Go go go girls!!!!
The girls are not the problem. They need songs with better impact. This is a good stage- for like a debut of a neophyte girl group. It just needs an oomph factor. I think, this song could be arranged better. Also, they could have gone full on cute cats concept or full on sexy, or even playful cats would be good. But this stage is none of those. I barely felt the theatre theme or their individual cat themes. If they didnt anounce it at the end, i wouldn't have noticed anything different. I think they should have picked one theme and fully commited to it. It's an okay stage, just lacking that wow factor.
8 หลายเดือนก่อน +2
It's actually a good song that suits their style and voices. They just need more stage presence. That OOMPH factor! Confidence is the key. jiāyóu
From the episodes I've watched, I can see that the girls are really talented. The song is good, but I somehow feel that the girls are not into it, you know what I mean? Maybe they need a song that truly matches their vibe, something they will enjoy performing again and again.
All of you guys is talented and I agree to all comments that your choices of song is the problem. But by the way congrats to all of you guys don’t worry in the future you will be successful singer and dancers😊👌😘
Yes they need better s9ngs! But like Lay said, they dont have a lot of choices because their vocal range are limited as a group but I can alreadysee 2 strong vocalists
I think the song is good overall , the melody is ok, but the beat is something lacking. It must be multiple layer of beats for better impact. Girls performance is really good for me.
Im telling you, these girls can slay! They got so much potential, but they gotta have better songs. This song they is okay, its just that somehow Im not feeling it with them.
the other 2 performers has a wow impact .. this one is quite mediocre compared to the other two groups performance.. they should've choose a better song to match with their skills and rivals.. g22 goes hardcore, bini is refreshing and this one is cute .. my POV only, I'm quite a veteran home audience/streamer wen it comes to survival shows haha
Song is CRINGE 😬 but the girls can sing ang dance. They're just need a better song and FEEL it, improve their vocals, and a LOAD of stage presence like they MEAN IT. Go girls! I'm rooting for you.🎉🎉🎉
if you want to go global do something that both chinese and global market would like. looks like a kid performance to me from song to dance steps all bad.
Is this from Taiwan? I'm afraid I'm watching Chinese from mainland! I want to watch Taiwanese drama or movie and their Girl Group as well, the problem is, I can't distinguish if they are Taiwanese or Chinese! I don't want to watch Chinese!
I watched 3 groups but this group is really a tendency of a girl group in the future. They have same appearance, voice and moves. They have cute English and Chinese in song. Please practice more about dance, arrangement of standing positions, outfits, hair styles, makeup, the ways of filming and connection. Good! Nothing is easy. Please send my "Thank you!" to your trainers. They are strict, right? But it's good for you. You did a good performance, to me. Hope everything lucky to you. 💖👏💐
YeAh! I agree with you!This girls are so talented they need a song that will matches to their character.I mean We want a “WOW or IT factor😭😭 And why are their voice are the same? If I am not mistaken, and I want to see the real them!
Considering they are fighting with 2 groups with strong vocal and great stage presence.... This stage is very mediocre. Not because the girls did not do a great job..they did its just that its not meant to be for these stage.... Its way too tame and cute ...I don't know the sequence but if they perform this in between or after the 2 groups. Its no wonder audience would like the other two because its like eating a very delicious spicy malatang and suddenly your giving me these seafood porridge after. 😅
They're lack of energy, more energy it would be best for them to dance well, or maybe they are energetic while in practice, hoping theres no over practice for this girls, coz when it comes to the live perf they don't have energy already, they look exhausted, even tho their faces are pretty, but its shows to their moves and their eyes that they're really tired 🥺
Honest opinion about the girls beside vocals is that they're too bland on the stage. There are no cohesion between them. They are not enjoying the stage or maybe because i cant feel the emotions of the song that's why i think they are bland.
I'm sorry but i had to skip watching their whole performance... Everything was how i expected it to be, it was predictable, i dont mean to be rude but i wish they could have given something different, something that would give the audience something new and unexpected to look forward to... The wow! Factor is missing... This is just my opinion... 😊😊😊 they have potential - they just need to explore and experiment more on the kind of music or song that would showcase their talent and skills in music...😊😊😊
They must focus on there original culture. Bini is carring philiipines culture like a typical tropical country vibe. Same of alamat and SB19 there all using pure ppop style dont imatate kpop. Its better to use our own MPOP
I don't think this is bad at all... The song is pretty cute. The girls did pretty well. I understand their coaches want them to perform like BINI but they have been together for quite a time already. If they want these girls to share that bond and chemistry on stage, give them more time.
Good luck girls! Keep doing your best.
They are not the problem, its the songs...
Yes
Napansin ko din yung moves medyo mukhang matamlay. Kailangan mahasa nila yung dance move nila kahit hard or soft yung step, dapat may dating pa din ang bigay. Medyo galaw baby pa sila e. Pero we are still rooting to these trainees, mapupulido din nila yan dahil sa mga naexperience nila sa show. Just keep na ma-inspired sa mga naging senior nila. Wag nila iisipin na mahina sila dahil walang mahina na di lumalakas.
This 💯
Yeah, I gotta agree. There's not much parts in their songs where they can do something something with "wow" factor. And they are still a bit lacking in charisma, but they'll get there eventually cuz they train so much and are already very pretty appearance-wise
Somehow i agree that song choices are a must to match in their voice.
You go girls!!! Rooting for you here from🇵🇭
The girls are actually good. They got nice voices, stage presence and on top of that the song is pleasing to the ears. Don't be sad girls, I know you guys can do it!
Very talented ang mga girls. Kaya naniniwala ako na mas lalo silang hahasa go lang laban! Konting kembot pa.
They're talented, no question about it. The problem is, they don't have individuality when it comes to vocals, they practically all sound the same, you can't tell them apart when listening to thei voices. Although they're a whole group, its not a bad idea to have their individual voice colors, so the songs don't sound so generic, you know what I mean? Just like ROYGBV colors, when combined becomes a beautiful rainbow 🌈
true that
後聽好聽的歌曲和音樂感覺很舒服，謝謝 ❤❤❤
They’re charismatic I must say! ❤
Ang cute nila dito🥰😻💖💖
這歌很棒 一直在變化旋律跟風格
They need a good catchy song and individuality character they need also stage presence
The girls are talented, they can sing , dance and rap. What they were lacking is a good song that matches their voice color and style and a song with good production. This song is okay... but it lacks the "ooomf" factor. Probably add bass or something to make the song fuller.
Omg i like this song
Good luck girls. Laban lang.
Yes. I love this song
they are so good and so pretty...
Beautiful performance girlsss! You did great❤
Fighting!
الاغنيه رائعة جدا وهذا المقطع ادماني 0:51
الرقصه التي كانت بالبداية رائعه جدا وأعتقد أنهم بذلوا قصار جهدهم اعتقد فقط أنني غير راضيه ابدا عن تصميم المسرح والمكياج والملابس.
❤RED女孩們加油吧！👍別讓張PD老闆Boss失望唷！👍💜LAY💜非常想看 🦄張藝興💜百分百出品💜的染色體四聖獸的男團小花盆們，真的又帥又有禮貌唱調又棒👍👍一個60歲母親及全家人都想看的男聖獸小花盆💜💜🍀
น่าดูมากๆสาว❤❤❤❤❤❤
I'm not sure what the other commenters are saying here as if they are very good when it comes to music, but what I can say about the song is good, cute and tiktokable chorus. The artists are beautiful too. 🥰 Keep it guys.. Just believe in yourself. You will be successful and famous all over the world. 🔥💪🫰
Hala Ang galing😊
Ang cute
i love there rapper so beautiful girl ♥️♥️♥️
amazing group 🎉
Jiayou girlies! Especially my bias Zhou Luoxi🥰 but Hu Jingyi is really so cute.😄
Mr.. Lay Zhang asks a help from Ppop coaches how to modernize their musical styles which is a big help to improve their overall performances.
These girls have a potential though real talk they just be more confident to be themselves just enjoy every performance.
Ask ppop?they should ask kpop bcuz they r more advance and lay have more connection with the kpop 8ndustries
@@rhannightowl173Kpop is good in visual presentation only while Ppop is advanced in vocal dynamics, unique styles and live performance.
is there any video about this?
Its based of my suggestion
amazing the trainees confidence is different on stage than in practice. they shine! 🇵🇭🇨🇳❤
Ivy! 😍😍😍👏👏👏👏👏👏
Magnetic type vibe by ILLIT I think is the best fit song for them
Very cute
The girls are so beautiful and talented. Although I don't really listen to this kind of music I really love this since it's chic. Rooting for your debut❤❤❤
Better songs is what they need the most. They just need to improve in not worrying too much about the performance they should let loose and enjoy the stage and the audience
Ur all pretty, nice performance😍😍
😍 pretty , beautiful voice
They're pretty good👍❤
The production 📈
I wouldn't call this a bad song, i find it cute and trendy. Maybe it's just lacking the 'it' factor but it aint bad at all. The dance lacks something that is truly memorable. The feather though...😂
Jingyi, Luoxi/Alice, Xiangrui, Yulin, Tingxiu, and Qianyu! love you alllllll
Goodluck! It’s cute!
❤❤❤❤gogogogo little Flower Pot❤❤❤❤
هذا رائع وجميل جدا
The girls are really good. They just need more time to grow. And be used to more stages. And that hunger for performance. That way they will grow confident. If they will develop g22's stagw presence and and in time the group coordination like Bini. They will grow big. Once they make their own song and sound, they will soar! Go go go girls!!!!
Song choice matters! They need one that captures their spirit as a group.
rooting for them !!
Guys keep it up girls more practice guys go go go🎉
The song is nice tho its just that maybe its not the same as what we filos mostly like. They're already so talented but look exhausted somehow?
Their voice quality is like kpop
The girls are not the problem. They need songs with better impact. This is a good stage- for like a debut of a neophyte girl group. It just needs an oomph factor. I think, this song could be arranged better. Also, they could have gone full on cute cats concept or full on sexy, or even playful cats would be good. But this stage is none of those. I barely felt the theatre theme or their individual cat themes. If they didnt anounce it at the end, i wouldn't have noticed anything different. I think they should have picked one theme and fully commited to it. It's an okay stage, just lacking that wow factor.
It's actually a good song that suits their style and voices. They just need more stage presence. That OOMPH factor! Confidence is the key. jiāyóu
❤🎉
ilove BINI specially Colet,Joanna,Aiah,Maloi,Sheena, Gwen,Stacey,Mikah 😂❤❤❤
Idk but for me, BINI really set the standards high ❤🌸
靜怡高音超級讚
From the episodes I've watched, I can see that the girls are really talented. The song is good, but I somehow feel that the girls are not into it, you know what I mean? Maybe they need a song that truly matches their vibe, something they will enjoy performing again and again.
All of you guys is talented and I agree to all comments that your choices of song is the problem. But by the way congrats to all of you guys don’t worry in the future you will be successful singer and dancers😊👌😘
This is giving b-side energy. And should've given more enegetic dance break if you wanna give concert vibe
Hi, like the song. Can anyone link me to the original song? Thank you 🫶🏻
comments are bs i feel you can definitely tell between their voices and the song is good too...
LABAN🔥🔥
Yes they need better s9ngs! But like Lay said, they dont have a lot of choices because their vocal range are limited as a group but I can alreadysee 2 strong vocalists
❤❤❤❤❤
I think the song is good overall , the melody is ok, but the beat is something lacking. It must be multiple layer of beats for better impact. Girls performance is really good for me.
I don't get the vibes but the girls did so amazing ❤
Im telling you, these girls can slay! They got so much potential, but they gotta have better songs. This song they is okay, its just that somehow Im not feeling it with them.
Are they lip syncing? The voice and lips and breathing don't coincide. They also lack facial expressions and emotions but they're cute.
same thought lip syncing...its impossible that their voice is so style😂
the other 2 performers has a wow impact .. this one is quite mediocre compared to the other two groups performance.. they should've choose a better song to match with their skills and rivals.. g22 goes hardcore, bini is refreshing and this one is cute .. my POV only, I'm quite a veteran home audience/streamer wen it comes to survival shows haha
The girl at 00:45 looks like Rose' of Blackpink
please get them a new producer
Song is CRINGE 😬 but the girls can sing ang dance. They're just need a better song and FEEL it, improve their vocals, and a LOAD of stage presence like they MEAN IT. Go girls! I'm rooting for you.🎉🎉🎉
I love this girls, but please give them a better song that will suit to them😭
It’s not the girls or the song. The performance is just dry, don’t know for what reason. Individually pleasant to the eyes and ears.
I don't think its the girls, it's the song
Did they meet the threshold?
it's not hard to identify if it is Lypsinc or live..
Kailan nila gagamitin ung hand mic ?
did they win?
歌曲是问题，女孩儿们可以
They are all pretty and song is very catchy but i think i heard too much auto tune.
❤ but not live i think
if you want to go global do something that both chinese and global market would like. looks like a kid performance to me from song to dance steps all bad.
看成四腳獸😂
name of the group?
There is no official name.
R.E.D for now.
表现不错，但是歌有够烂😅
Yeah!They need a song that matches to them😭😭😭😭
Is this from Taiwan? I'm afraid I'm watching Chinese from mainland! I want to watch Taiwanese drama or movie and their Girl Group as well, the problem is, I can't distinguish if they are Taiwanese or Chinese! I don't want to watch Chinese!
This is Chinese. They are R.E.D from Lay Zhang's agency
I watched 3 groups but this group is really a tendency of a girl group in the future. They have same appearance, voice and moves. They have cute English and Chinese in song. Please practice more about dance, arrangement of standing positions, outfits, hair styles, makeup, the ways of filming and connection. Good! Nothing is easy. Please send my "Thank you!" to your trainers. They are strict, right? But it's good for you. You did a good performance, to me. Hope everything lucky to you. 💖👏💐
这歌他们无法消化，造型，舞蹈，演绎上就是平平无奇，看的我一直走神。连续几期看下来，越来越差。而国际团就越来越强。。。这真的。问题出在哪呢？没有强烈胜负欲带出来的野心是无法做好一个舞台的。同时一个优秀的团一定有个强势的队长。这几个妹子，除了周洛兮每场都让人眼前一亮，但这个优势只有几秒，之后就被其他组员拉平了。最弱的就是刘婷秀，这个把面瘫当·冷酷的塑造真的很不讨喜。胡静怡每次都让我一把子期待又一把子失望。这队伍真的很需要大VOCAL。冲着对张艺兴的期待，希望染色体在危机意识上能够给孩子们加强又加强。
YeAh! I agree with you!This girls are so talented they need a song that will matches to their character.I mean We want a “WOW or IT factor😭😭
And why are their voice are the same? If I am not mistaken, and I want to see the real them!
而且她们一直唱的都是rap风格 很无趣啊啊 国际女团每个种族都比她们好多
哇！好嚴苛丫😂
皮肤死白、瘦的皮包骨、装可爱、每个人毫无特色，长的也是（怎么看起来都一样）跳舞无力，一味模仿韩团！还谈什么竞争力，某些高中大学的舞蹈队可能都比她们强！
我希望加两个人，两个vocal, 两个不同且有辨识度的声音。或者 1个vocal + 1个 rapper。
不喜欢这首歌，舞台没记忆点。服装和造型不搭这首歌。这一集这个舞台弱爆了。女团的声线太一致了，就只有Alyce 和 Jenni 的声音在她们之中比较有辨识度。如果一个团有6个人但是听起来像3个人，真的好吗？真的得加人。可以加两个吗? 其实6人团很理想，2 vocals, 2 dancers, 2 rappers。 但是如果声线即没有辨识度也无法产生互补的效果，真的会把整体感觉拉下。也白费心机。😢 这女团真的要累死张艺兴了。
Traines Chromosome ent fighting❤
Mas ok cguro kung ung song mismo ng mentors ung pineperform nila.
Considering they are fighting with 2 groups with strong vocal and great stage presence.... This stage is very mediocre. Not because the girls did not do a great job..they did its just that its not meant to be for these stage.... Its way too tame and cute ...I don't know the sequence but if they perform this in between or after the 2 groups. Its no wonder audience would like the other two because its like eating a very delicious spicy malatang and suddenly your giving me these seafood porridge after. 😅
I think the performance is good but the problem is the vocals of some members are not stable and should I say energy?
They're lack of energy, more energy it would be best for them to dance well, or maybe they are energetic while in practice, hoping theres no over practice for this girls, coz when it comes to the live perf they don't have energy already, they look exhausted, even tho their faces are pretty, but its shows to their moves and their eyes that they're really tired 🥺
Honest opinion about the girls beside vocals is that they're too bland on the stage. There are no cohesion between them. They are not enjoying the stage or maybe because i cant feel the emotions of the song that's why i think they are bland.
TBH, The song was bland
This song....arghhh... Not good, doesn't suit the girls. They are much better than the song! 🥺
I'm sorry but i had to skip watching their whole performance... Everything was how i expected it to be, it was predictable, i dont mean to be rude but i wish they could have given something different, something that would give the audience something new and unexpected to look forward to... The wow! Factor is missing... This is just my opinion... 😊😊😊 they have potential - they just need to explore and experiment more on the kind of music or song that would showcase their talent and skills in music...😊😊😊
You can see afterlife red or game over red, i think because theme song
They must focus on there original culture. Bini is carring philiipines culture like a typical tropical country vibe. Same of alamat and SB19 there all using pure ppop style dont imatate kpop. Its better to use our own MPOP
This girls good singing but just need good song for them.. They dance also good but some of them still luck