'Singing' Recording Sheds Light on Murder in Outback Town of 13 | Paddy Moriarty Case Analysis
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ก.ย. 2024
- This video answers the question: Can I analyze case of Paddy Moriarty?
Support Dr. Grande on Patreon: / drgrande
Subscribe to the Bella Grande Media Podcast: / @bellagrandemedia
Dr. Grande’s book Harm Reduction:
www.amazon.com...
Dr. Grande's book Psychology of Notorious Serial Killers: www.amazon.com...
Check out Dr. Grande’s merchandise at: teespring.com/...
References:
www.abc.net.au...
www.theguardia...
justice.nt.gov...
www.washington...
As an Aussie, I have to say that I love that you pick a lot of cases out of Australia. No one else really does. Also, the way you pronunciate things correctly doesn't go unnoticed either. Love to see it mate ;)
I'm glad that true crime content is branching out a lot more in general from US and Canada. Dire trip is another really good channel that covers cases from all over the world.
Like when he says Melbourne?
I get most of my Australian true crime from Case File.
Seconded
@@robloggiaI was going to mention Case Files for Australian cases myself...complete with a narrator with an Australian accent as well. It's a great listen. I get it through Spotify.
This is a very infamous case in Australia and Netflix have scooped it up. All you need to know is in Australia if you want to get away with Murder do it in the outback. It has a long history of very dodgy Police work and it seems life is pretty cheap in the top end. It's the sort of town Stephen King could layer a story over. Tiny isolated town loaded with misfits who seem to hate each other. It's as if Larrima is a magnet for people who want to fall off the radar. A weird style of alcohol enhanced de-evolution has set up there.
Your description of the outback remind me quite a bit of some of the sketchy, desert towns in the more desolate, isolated areas in the US state of New Mexico. Unfortunately, a lot of the police out there are crooked thugs themselves. Tons of unseemly, murder-y nonsense going down over there.
Yeah there's no mention of police even investigating Owen's car, if that's the case then very sloppy indeed. I haven't watched the documentary yet but it sounds interesting.
Also incredibly easy to dispose of a body and other evidence like the weapon in a way that they'll never be found.
@@h0rriphic I prefeer lazy over crooked(Straight as a dogs hind leg) police.
Much of Australia effected by alcohol, think we would be much better off without drugs n alcohol. Sad . De evolution.
What a sad way to end a life of a dog and a man. Really sad :(
Fran looks like a real dramatic lady too.
She was. There is a documentary about this on TH-cam that has interviews with her.
She looks like Large Marge from Pee Wee's Big Adventure. Poor Paddy
She looks like Large Marge from Pee Wee's Big Adventure. Poor Paddy
She must be a 'Karen'
There's at least one in every town. Some miserable Karen with a big nose.
"The bride was so happy with her wedding gifts she killerrated all her guests." Oh my goodness, I almost sprayed the piece of cake that I was eating all over my computer laughing! Hahahahahahaha! Dr. Grande, you need to do stand up! I would go!
Hillary so loved Vincent Foster, she killerated him. 😆
You could share that cake! 🎂🍰🎂🍰
😂😂
The fifth commandment says "Thou shall not killerate anybody !" So there !
I hate the man was murdered and still awaiting justice, but Kelly’s fate brought tears to my eyes.
Kelly his dog?
I think this is the first time that this sentence has ever been uttered: 'Smacked him on the blanking nostrils'.
OMG 😮 Dr Grande! I’ve just been watching the Netflix series about this strange case and am so glad to hear your perspective on it…I’ve been so torn and confused as to what to believe. The town and its inhabitants are so strange!
What is the name of the Netflix series?
They live in a part of the world where the term, 'going troppo', is a common term.
@@juliewood4340Last Stop Larrimah
@@juliewood4340It's called "Last Stop Larimah." It's an excellent documentary.
The Netflix doc is called "Lost in Larrimah" (according to a comment I read)...looks interesting, I'm going to check it out myself ;) 🍿@@juliewood4340
No one else on can speak about a sad mysterious death and have me chuckling with tears coming out of my eyes.
Hi, Dr. Grande ☺ 👋
This is Melinda, from Australia again. Just wanted to let you know, that I found this case very interesting. As I watched, the Australian Story Investigative episode of this case, a long time back. Interesting how, with so few people that the Police still haven't cracked this case. I guess, it doesn't help that there is such a vast search area 😆 !!! Thank you for making these Case Studies, for us all. I love the humour, that you add along the way ☺ 👌 I do hope, someone is made accountable for Paddy's death. Just because you don't like someone, doesn't allow you the right to kill them.
I think the police dropped the ball on this case . Perhaps they just didn’t want to solve it . Where did the “ sold “ car go
This car would have been used to transport the body . It has the evidence forensic within . This needs to be impounded and examined . … or it did . Paddy had no family . Had he had one he would have been less easy to forget
@@gabrielleandrew542 not neccesarily Bushies do have mates....and another car who would know
I likerate Dr. Grande's videos.
And now these townsfolk will have the "fun" of suspecting each of the others of being a murderer. This case reminds me so much of the game "Clue".
The gardener was the only one with the motifs and the strength to kill him and make him disappear quickly.
They all know the gardener killed him.
If I understand it correctly, the gardener got cancer and now he is very fragile.
Nobody to be afraid of in that town.
Fran Hodgett with a hammer in the garden!
@@justmeagain7You're wrong there..... ALWAYS fear the Feral Pigs
Aussie also here, Dr Grande. I also find that you pronounce our place names correctly.
However, in the outback, cattle "farms" are known as cattle stations because they are huge properties of many thousands of hectares, not just an average few acres. Thankyou for your programmes which I find most interesting.
Farms are green 😂
@@TheKrispyfort You need to travel more
The Aussie Outback makes the Appalachian looks like high society.
😹🇦🇺
😂😂😂😂too funnee. 😂😂😂😂
Can't breathe for laughing. 😂😂😂😂
Moriarty is just an objectively cool name (especially for a villain) in any setting.
I'm just realizing that a population of 13 people where one of them dies/is murdered and another one is the potential perpetrator, that means they don't have enough remaining residents to form a full jury. That's just interesting.
The Ghost of Paddy makes 12!
Your use of "killerated" (alternate definition) in a sentence had me rolling. However, its use on the title screen had me confused, which meant I had to listen to the video, right? Mission accomplished!
Move over, Beatles! "Bang Bang Maxwell Silver-Hammer" was okay, but Aussie Owen has created a modern masterpiece with "I Killerated Him with my Blankin' Killerator Hammer."
Thanks Dr Grande, you're a top Bloke. (That's Aussie for one held in high regard).
There was a case about a bitter Sherrif's election in Georgia, where the suspect (a sherrif who was later charged and convicted of killing his rival) was heard via wiretap is singing "I shot the sherrif"
😂
But did he shoot the deputy?
@@MJanovicable no. no he did not. lol
Larrimah dental surgery regrets to inform residents that it has gone broke and will be closing down.
The situation and town's eccentric residents are all very "𝘛𝘸𝘪𝘯 𝘗𝘦𝘢𝘬𝘴"-esque; a very unusual case indeed. The fate of Kelly the dog, I must admit, concerns me the most.
A motive a threat and a confession and no charges? Sounds about right for our incompetent police
There's systemic problems in the NT police as they struggle with the bureaucracy and the dysfunctional police management.
Did the NT police did put the brief to the DPP? Was there a coroners inquest, was there a decision not to prosecute?
@@AquaFyrre so many things wrong with that theory..
ye@h. it's not the cop's f@ult. they h@ve to follow the l@w.
@@tatyanamelnikoff9578 well it's their job to find evidence and if someone is killed with a hammer then there's gonna be some evidence. They bugged his house and got a verbal confession. Why bother bugging the house at all if you're not going to use what you get. Australian police are fucking useless in cases like this. Remote police stations in Australia are staffed by rookies , failed pommy immigrants and trainees, not our finest detectives..
Patty, Cookie, and Graham...and Fran sells the Pies.
don’t forget Berry
@@LaciRae ahh and Berry!
The "Fernando" singing in the shower comment was hysterical
If the kangaroo gets run over on your side of the road it gets dumped into your yard. Ranch road rules.
The pub that doubles as a bar, shop and zoo 😂😂 gotta love the ‘outback’ 😂😂
Dr Grande killerated this analysis!
I have encountered little towns throughout the American West with a vibe like Larrimah. One my wife and I drove through on our honeymoon in western Colorado. According to some travel site, it had a spa run by a guy named Magic Mike. I imagined that he greets people by saying "My friends call me Mike the Murderer, but you can call me Magic Mike!"
When I'm old i want to end up in a podunk town in the desert. Sounds peaceful.
Why did he killerate Patty when he could have just sued him for some dollaridoos?
Channel surfed and found a documentary on this town/case and was hooked. At first I thought it may have been a _mockumentary_ . It's almost Shakespearean or soap opera-like. I'm sure a DARK comedy could be made of it. Maybe even a DARK musical comedy. It's got everything.
every other word fr@n s@ys h@s to be bleeped out. m@ybe, the musici@ns c@n m@ke @ song out of th@t--@ line of bleeps for @ c@tchy tune.
Makes W Virginia look more civilized than I thought was possible.
Reminds me of The Sandstone Killer.As I worked there for 7 years you cant help wonder how safe you really are anywhere.
this town & the “characters” are like the set up to a Rob Zombie horror movie.
I worked way out west in NSW years ago. People out there said people got "disappeared" real easy because of how sparsely populated it is. I said what happens in (the next state west) South Australia?
They said, "Nothing, no-one lives there!"
South Aus is murder central! More murders than any other state in the country!
Haha They were wrong I live here in my little place of paradise I call home :)
@@kerrylawson3522 I'll drop by for a coffee then
I only watched most of the first episode. The gards reactions were brilliant.
I always think murder is never the way to go. Now if they made him sick with poison. Joking. But no I didn't like how Paddy bullied the woman. It was unfair. I'm from Ireland and I don't mind a bit of irish banter. But if it leads to hurting someone. Stop apologise at once. If you hurt them so much they want to kill you, you went to far. I see this as a bullied victim being so hurt by an idiot, and that person ranted. A person who saw the pain took revenge. Not right. But why the doc?
He was old. Maybe he was going crazy already. Or maybe he was a bully who couldn't care less about hurting others.
Paddy was known for his sarcasm and was an habitual piss pot.
th@nk you for pointing th@t out. it's true too. i couldn't believe @ll the messed-up @busive shyte he did to fr@n!!! & wh@t for? i do think p@ddy is @ tot@l @rse----. & he's such @n @rse---- th@t her only option to get him to stop, w@s go hire @ bushy to get rid of him. billyboy didn't defend her; he's @ wuss. momm@'s boy. ye@h, it re@lly looks like th@t p@ddy guy w@s @ tot@l complete @busive @-hole! even b@rry s@id--it w@s funny, we would @ll l@ugh, the w@y p@ddy picked on her, but we didn't t@ke it seriously. m@ybe we should h@ve t@ken it more seriously.
i me@n, everybody knows, fr@n's behind it. she didn't do it directly, but she definitely stopped th@t s.o.b. from @busing her @ny more. i think he h@d it coming to him. bottom line--p@ddy w@s @ huge @-hole!!!! fr@n h@d @ right to defend herself.
looks like, p@ddy w@s doing @ll the @buse. then, when she hired owen, only then did p@ddy st@rt sending his dog over to her property. the dog w@s @n innocent byst@nder, but p@ddy must've done something to the dog to @nt@gonize & instig@te it going over to her property so much.
Poison? Like someone had ten-80 on them which is to trap dingos
This story could make a cool movie!
Whoever killed Paddy and I assume the poor dog also could have fed them to the crocodile at the zoo thus no bodies.
This Moriarty, clearly a case for Sherlock Holmes...
Where is Kelly his dog though?
it’s Owens now.
The rumour is that she made them both into meat pies 😢
@@heidithesausage EWWWWW
Cops: we heard exactly what we wanted. Our work here is done.
Aussie: you'll arrest him and search for the car and physical evidence?
Cops: Nah
How sneaky are those NT police; did they have a warrant to record those conversations? He must have been the main POI for them to go that far.
You think they have rights in Australia? 😂😂😂
@MrNexor-cj8gs Ignorant comment, makes you sound like a conspiracy theorist.
Very informative, well presented
You killerated that analysis, Dr. Grande!
The car. The car he sold the day after.
Forensic it to bits.
When you get to Larrima,
drive on through,
someone's waiting there,
just for you.
Always interesting.
Thank you
I’m cracking up that there was a hotel in a town of 13. 😂😂😂
The outback here is a great place for a 'killeration' - I suppose that is the noun - a place of haunting beauty amid occasional (well, rare) events like this
$40 for 8 cans of beer is insane.
It was the butler!
This Fran said in an interview :"I don't now what happened to him, I don't know who'd done it, I don't know where he is...." One can still see all the signs, posters and location on Google Earth!
"Killerated"😂
Reminds me of a book I read once, the killer nicknamed "Poke" would refer to his murderous actions as being "pokerized"
What a depressing life. Walk to the dump for fresh air...gosh.
I swear, at first I thought you were saying cow 'farts'.
Had to rewind a couple times.
Not guilty beyond a reasonable rap lyric
Raggedy Andy called....he wants his shirt back🤨🤬🌝
Your video thumbnail says “confesson” instead of “confession” just so you know.
The error is pequeña, not grande.
I can, having had the experience, assure you that Fran's pies were certainly not worth the drive ! Never stopped there again on subsequent drive-by's.
This could be another Coens Brothers movie lol.
Intriguing case for sure.
The multi-part documentary is quite entertaining.
I can understand why he got off singing about killing someone, doesn't mean he did it, he could have fantasized about doing it just talking rubbish and singing it.
As an Aussie I have been fascinated with this case since it happened. I watched the original Australian Story documentary about it a couple of years back and that left me suspecting Fran. But after seeing the Netflix doco with the new info about the police recordings, I have little doubt it was Owen. I think there's a good chance he did it completely off his own back without Fran's involvement. I really hope the police get him for it but unfortunately there's some chance they won't.
William will haunt my nightmares forever.. ..
If i remember rightly the pub's called "the pink panther" hotel?
Dear Dr Grande I hope you're not taking this the wrong way. I don't particularly like your content mostly right from the very dumb beginning "Can I analyse ....." Nobody asks that of you!!!
You have a soothing voice and a very sonore tone without emphasis for anything what makes this recordings perfect for what I'm using it for, that is I put on my earphones when I want to sleep and one minute later I'm fast asleep. I wonder how long your wife can withstand this urge.
You're humor on the other hand is spot on combined with the emotionless tone it sometimes hits very hard bc it comes so unprepared. I think you should be selling "My funniest joke tales to put you to sleep" tapes for people with insomnia. That's not an analysis, just my view of how things can develop in this situations.
Wonder what happened to Paddy's dog?
It has taken me watching a few of your videos to really appreciate your expertise.. Being Australian, Paddy's case really interests me, especially as I have experienced that great expanse called the Australian outback. Very easy for someone to just go missing,. Thank you and I look forward to watching many more. Best..
I’ve said from day one it was the Gardner guy. Mind boggling the police haven’t done anything about it.
If talking to the 👮♀️ is idiocy, what makes one talking to self?
I have the impression that the police in Australia are not functioning well
looking at that gardener guy he reminds me of the guy accused of killing peter falconio
going by the bug recordings i'd say he did ol paddy in and the dump area of the garden area would be areas to look for paddys body
Cluedo, outback edition.
Worse than Deliverance.
Fran made Paddy pies .
Owen has an uncanny resemblance to Chopper.
Good on ya mate
Welp, this answers the age-old question:
If a mate falls in the outback and no one is there to see it, will the killer be found ??
Informative
Or speculation
You Can't have both
As much as Owen is the prime suspect. I think his confession, which was mainly made up of ramblings over some average blues guitar playing could just be an odd man play acting out a scenario in his head. It's not conclusive by any means.
Owen and Murdoch look very similar. Many say Murdoch has been framed for the missing British bloke and his girlfriend survived. Owen is simple. Like so many due to many variables...
Did Fran hear Paddy's quad bike come home that night?
Did you forget to mention the 'home made pies' rumour to explain the lack of a body... or am I thinking of another case? 🤔
Oh dear lord, 'Sweeney Todd the Barber'...my grandfather used to tell that story!
No its this case
Owen could have been the next Eminem spitting those bars.
Dr Grande: you "killerated" this analysis. Thanks for sharing 👍
This situation sounds like a board game or an Agatha Christie novel.
Or Harper Lee or Cormac McCarthy!
Exactly what I thought! Such intrigue!
I thought the same thing!
Add to that lot's of Alcohol and Bed Hopping, Fran's famous for her Pie's
😂 I loved this Netflix documentary. It’s like a mini-series of Neighbours, the poor relations edition. I mostly feel sad for his dog, Kelly, who either ran away never to be seen again, or was killerated.
The killer actor prolly dumped the dog with the body in the outback only to die of exposure. If I lived there, there’d be another mystery t9 solve.
I'm glad to see someone else wondered what happened to Kelly.
I like to think she was given to someone & is sleeping safely tonight.
@@DamePigletSadly I think Kel's is no longer with us
Poor Kelly. I hate to think that something bad happened to her.
Neighbours 🤣
I guess the word “killerated” is a combination of kill and eradicated and sounds less sinister when a murderer decides to sing about his crime.
I wish Dr. Grande had sung the jingle in the way it was meant to be. Just reciting the words with bleeps didn't do justice to it!
I think excavator which is used to dig graves. Owen was a gardener was he not?
@@manichairdo9265 did @nyone go out there with @ met@l detector? looks like old p@ddy h@d @t le@st two dozen fillings.
I thought it was a play on the 2 words, kill and incinerated 🤷♂️
"Killerate" is actually kind of a common term used amongst older generation australians; don't ask!
As a born and bred Territorian I do remember meeting Paddy in the late 90’s before the big floods in Katherine N.T. He was a friendly, pleasant sort of bloke when sober but turned into an obnoxious individual once he started drinking. No surprise how he could piss people off especially in a small community like Larrimah. His body might turn up one day but the N.T. is a big, mostly uninhabited place with lots of unsolved mysteries.
I worked in Boorroolloola and stoped there a few times. I remember my Paul’s Ice Coffees in the fridge always covered in dust lol. Shabby joint
That is true Rusty but we are all still waiting on a clue to where Peter Falconio is buried. Yet no body and they successfully got a conviction for him.
I often fantasize about living quietly in a small town with a menial job that pays the bills and people in the town who are trustworthy and also quiet, but would give you the shirt off their backs in an emergency. Then I think, what a stupid fantasy.
people tend to go crazy in small towns
Definitely do not move to The New England area.
Barnaby Joyce.
Need I say more?
@@TheKrispyfort The New England area of NSW is hardly remote. For a NSW example I would say Goodooga - it was voted the most boring town in Australia two years in a row. I was there in 1985 for a few months. Now that made one 'stir crazy'
@@IB-1963my family used to own a farm there years ago called Bre Gardens I think bye the river . It reminded me of Papua New Guinea with everything at the local shop stored behind bars
@@TrumpAndKamila I did not know the area well enough to recall "Bre Gardens" - I was there in Goodooga for a few months as a young Constable to replace the two local Police Officers who were removed "overnight" because they had a monumental falling out. The head station was then Walgett (140 kms to the South) and I was directed to go up until full time replacements were recruited. I would hazard a guess that "Bre Gardens" was likely named after the area - the next nearest town to the West is "Brewarrina" seems a bit coincidental. Lots of things were named "Bre" even the local football team. I have never been to Papua but I understand what you say about "behind bars" - Walgett in fact was the worst example of this feature - not a single pane of glass in the whole commercial main street did not have steel mesh covering the glass. I do remember that I went shooting on a property just over the border in Queensland - the township of Hebel - I was invited there by a man named "Army" - I am six foot two and he made me look like a midget. I was glad to make his acquaintance just in case I needed to call upon him for help in the township of Goodgooga given that I was one out. There was in fact a riot there during my time when a funeral was delayed for a Shillingsworth when the funeral hearse was turned back on the Brewarrina to Goodooga unsealed black dirt road because it rained. Ask your family members about how easily it was to get bogged on wet black dirt roads. Anyway, the funeral was delayed 3 days and those who had come from all over NSW and QLD got on the drink and rioted when the publican went to close the Hotel early because it was all getting out of hand. Geez that has triggered a few memories for me. I survived all that and more and recently turned 60. My thoughts now turn to those unlucky Queensland Police Officers who were murdered by ironically the former Principal of Walgett Highschool - its all sliding doors stuff - I disarmed an armed offender on my own on Weilmoringle Station after he shot at two people escaping a Domestic Violence offence. Back in those days there were no telephones apart from some "party lines" and the single side band police radios did not work unless it was night time - just too remote and hot - geez look at me rambling on - maybe I should write a book someday LOL
I’m Australian. This one has fascinated me. What astounds me --(and seems like something from another era ) - is that the cops did not get a warrant and go and scour Owen’s house, property and car for blood, after hearing exactly what they’d been hoping to hear in those tapes from the bugs at Owen’s house. I mean, why bother bugging the place, if, one you get the right kind of evidence, you take no notice of it. This is a shocker. Thanks for having a delve into the Aussie stuff mate
It's not that astounding. The vastness off Australia means that if you choose to live outside of civilised areas, you can do so. Comes with certain benefits, risks, and sometimes unforeseen costs.
‘Out of civilised areas’. Yeah, i guess you’re right
@@Alice-ui9oyThat doesn't explain why the cops didn't bother to get a warrant to properly search the guy's property at the very least. They were clearly interested enough to bug the guy's house, but I guess not interested enough to convert that evidence to search the guy's property for evidence like blood left on clothes or shoes. It appears they didn't track down the vehicles he sold either. Also, the OP is Australian, I think they're aware of the vastness and remoteness of many regions in the country.
@@zlm001 I suspect 'the cops' in this case consisted of 1 guy who was stationed 200km from that town who didn't want to chase anything up, given that he woukdnt be paid for the extra time spent out there, and he would certainly not be home in time for dinner.
Owen is well known for talking to the Wall's.....Paddy was fed to the Pig's
Fascinating case and analysis. Love the humor. The only problem is now Fernando is going to be stuck in my head all day 😂
@nhlpens583 ABBA!! Oh how I adored them❤❤❤❤❤❤❤😊
I know they are real people, but what a cast of characters! They look like real ‘bushies’ as we sometimes refer to folks in the outback (the bush).
Your description of the town residents sounds like the setup for a Coen brothers movie.
I want to hear Frances McDormand trying out an Australian accent…
@@markiangooley Haha I've yet to hear any non australian use it correctly
Sounds as if Owen is living his own personal “crime and punishment” saga.
Bit tenuous.
Owen sounds pretty blanking happy with this heinous act of killing Paddy. So, no punishment there for him it seems. He has zero sense of guilt.
@@AncoraImparoPiper he h@s no money, but employs @ l@wyer??? he's the only one who won't t@lk? GUILTY.
fr@n h@d to keep telling him--don't do @nything stupid. why's th@t? b/c they t@lked @bout it, @ lot, how to do in p@ddy.
@@AncoraImparoPiper Yes no remorse
“…the dump was not really distinguishable from the rest of the town…” that just killed me
I've been through Larrima, the place stinks a bit
I just heard him say that when I arrived at this comment.
A very accurate description of Larrimah and basically the N.T. as a whole!
700 animals in their zoo? How did they afford to feed them?
In the comments every aspect is dissected! Even the local zoo!
Hey maybe that's where Paddy ended up!
@@AquaFyrreI hope you are kidding about crocs being kept in cages?...If not, how sad for those crocs!
And how can anyone drag a kangeroo anywhere. Their claws are terrifying and they sure can kick ass. 😂
@@manichairdo9265 So true!
I think that the last time something positive was achieved under the influence of alcohol was probably when Hemingway wrote his last novel.
There is a saying in Australia, to call someone "as mad as a cut snake". Imagine the level of tension in that remoter than remote small outback town.
A highway goes right through it, so it's not that remote.
This case has facinated me as an Aussie. It's just bizarre
I have always thought the story was that she made them into meat pies 😩 or they were fed to the croc 😢
I person says on the docuseries that he really hated Fran. Her X husband. Too funny. 😂
I think Feral Pigs munged Ol' Paddy, it's the deep North
i don't believe the old bloke went into her pies, of couirse not, but it is very fitting, since @ll he did w@s m@ke up lies & gossip @bout her pies, you know, th@t the l@st rumor is th@t he's in the pies. he truly @dded to the rumors.
Well when I worked there and ate at the pub regularly the choice was special burger #1 or special burger #2. When I left there on the last day the owner told me the burgers were horse. 🤔
@@crackerjacksailing of course, of course