Hard shell vs softshell carry on: What is the best luggage to travel with and buy?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 5 มิ.ย. 2024
- Get your FREE editable packing lists here!
lp.constantcontactpages.com/s...
Our LinkTree, with all of our Socials and Discount codes:
linktr.ee/itsthekellys
Shop our Amazon Influencer storefront for Amazon Travel essentials: www.amazon.com/shop/itsthekellys
In Today's video, Lauren is going to show you hardshell vs softshell luggage, and what is the best luggage to travel with and buy. This isn't really a luggage review, more of a luggage guide.
The choice is ultimately up to you, but we are going to show you a few factors that can help you decide. Let us know in the comments what you decide!
5 types of luggage: • Which type of luggage ...
Checked bag vs carry-on: • Checked bag VS Carry-o...
The best backpack for travel: www.ebags.vayb.net/e45yjX
The best packing cubes for travel: www.ebags.vayb.net/qnL5oj
Subscribe for more travel vlogs and tips and tricks so that you can travel too!
Follow us on Instagram:
/ its.the.kellys
Like us on Facebook:
/ itsthekellys
Travel often, Pack well. We're here to help.
#bestluggage #bestsuitcase #travelluggage
*This video helps you choose hard shell luggage or soft shell luggage. Which is the best luggage for travel? Depending on your choice this video may help you decide which type of luggage is the best to buy for you. watch and find out.
![ตัวอย่างภาพยนตร์ Venom: The Last Dance [Official - Sub Thai]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/DHPjvAwmnRE/mqdefault.jpg)
Which style of luggage do you prefer? comment below!
My heart likes both.
I like the hard side for its durability, organization and sleek, modern look.
But, I like soft side for the outside pockets, and multitude of pattern choices. I prefer to have luggage that is unique to my personality and that I and others can recognize easily. I say others, because having a unique color or pattern minimizes the chances of someone else mistakenly taking your bag. I don't travel often (relatively), once a yr or so. This year it will be 2 times so durability is on the bottom of my priority list, although I still want quality luggage . Ive never experienced damage on either type. So, for my lifestyle, for now, I'm TEAM SOFT SIDE.
@@tigre9271 sounds like you found the luggage that works best for you! The outside pockets on the soft shell case can be quite nice. Thanks for watching!
I love hard side and soft side depending on quality of the suitcases I like three too four pockets
@@ItsTheKellys Also, forgot to mention. I bought two pieces of luggage when I was in Molokai, soft side, with white and yellow hibiscus flowers on a black background. All of my family on my mother's side are all from Hawaii and since my mom and grandma have both passed, this luggage has sentimental value. I always feel like they are with me when I travel.
That’s beautiful. It’s always good to have some guardian angles. Thank you for sharing that.
On check vis a vis carry-on, do bear in mind that the ergonomics of hoisting a bag into an overhead bin are tough as one ages. As a 75 year old -- tho fit & in good health, I've coverted from being carry-on only to resigning myself to checking in recent years. SO, for us older fans, your assessment of checked luggage is also much appreciated. Your videos are terrific! Jan P, Washington DC
For sure, Jan! Thank you. Would you just take the same size bag and check it instead? I find that most people, when checking, end up packing more, and then they are hauling 50 pounds vs 20. Although, less lifting is needed :)
I was just wondering this and just knew you would have posted about it. Thx!
Hardshell luggage looks nice, but is frankly, less practical. It is vastly harder to pack with two shallow halves than a single opening, they require a giant area to lay the thing out on when packing and unpacking and they hold less. Super inconvenient in small European hotel rooms. They have no pockets on the outside--and your suggestion that hardshell luggage are the only ones that come with good quality spinning wheels is just a misstatement--cheap softshell luggage like the one you showed comes with cheap wheels. Same for cheap hardshells. Many veteran travellers (like flight attendants and pilots) prefer two wheeled luggage BTW because silly weekenders take up two persons worth of space in crowded airports holding their luggage off the the side versus pulling behind them. Hardshell luggage is much more likely to be dented, damaged, scuffed and cracked and your suggestion of "don't check it in" isn't always an option--and it gives the hardshell luggage a pass for its inferior durability. I own lots of cases and my older hardshell stuff looks like crap after a few year on the road. The only real advantage to hardshell I can think of is slightly lighter empty weight (for the modern plastic varieties) and the contents are less likely to get wet in the rain if it is checked and left on a tarmac.
Everyone got "carried Away" with these in the last few years because of their sleek looks, not their practicality--and I think hardshell looks as great as the next person--but if I'm being honest about it, a more practical suitcase for most people is softshell. A Briggs and Riley Basline piece if you can afford it, in fact--top luggage rated by the NY Times.
Omg! You just convinced me to get a soft shell. My inner voice was telling me everything you just stated, but I was blinded by the beautiful, shiny hard shells. Thank you!
And I disagree with most of the things that person said honestly. It’s way easier to pack with two sides, they totally fit on luggage racks, and 2 wheels are a nightmare. I get quality hard shell luggage that doesn’t scuff or scratch. I’ve tested all of them that I have reviewed. (I have about 20 of them now) But that’s just my opinion, to each their own.
I agree with you completely. 100%
I agree love the hardshell luggage it protects you're belongings so much better also when checking bags because there handled so rough by airline staff.
We're flying from Australia to Italy for the first time in June this year and was hoping to do carry on only but we're flying Emirates and their carry on allowances are smaller than any suitcase I can find, and they don't allow a personal item in addition. It's essentially a "handbag OR laptop bag" for each economy traveller. I wish we could do carry on but I don't think it's feasible on all airlines so while I know you prefer carry on (and I don't disagree!) thank you for touching on the checked baggage. Hopefully ours survives the trip and it's there when we arrive 😅
Carryon I’d great unless you are on a full flight and have to check your bag at the gate ( occurred more than once) or the airline has a weight limit on your carryon bag and you have to check it. Both have happened to me but I would still carryon with a hard shell. Happy Trails!
I've always struggled with my packing issues, but I found an L.L. Bean carry on, wheeled soft side, the Carryall Spinner Pullman, that's a perfect carry on size, and a Delsey Paris Expandable Spinner, ( hard side ) that was perfect for my recent trip to India. The Delsey came through the trip; with no damage; which surprised me. I was expecting some damage, to be honest.
I’m glad you found something that works well for you, and I’m glad it didn’t get damaged! 💜
Thanks, I never had a hard shell bag so was considering getting one but was unsure. The problem nowadays with carry on luggage, too many people are bringing them on can bring on and there is not enough room for all of them in the overhead bins. I sometimes have a hard time finding room to put a computer backpack up there.
Yeah unfortunately people are putting their backpacks and jackets and smaller items up there and not leaving room for luggage. I always like to board as soon as possible, and if I’m sitting in the back, I will put my suitcase in any in bin in front of my seat, even if it’s nowhere near me.
One edge to soft is it can be squeezed a bit to fit if space is tight in the overhead.
For sure!
Older people may prefer to check bags. I have a hard time lifting the carry on up to the overhead bin.
I am under 5 ft tall and always have to ask for help. If you want to try a carry on, most people are very kind and will help when asked
When I’m travelling carry on only I prefer a 2 wheeled bag because you gain more interior packing space because the wheels don’t take up as much of the exterior dimensions of the bag. If needing a checked and carry on bag, 4 wheel spinners so you can put the cases back to back and hold both handles.
Interesting with the wheels. I use packing cubes so it doesn’t take up any space on my end. Spinners are usually under the suitcase vs the two wheels are usually half in the suitcase.
@@ItsTheKellys but that’s what I mean. You have to fit the exterior dimensions of the suitcase into the sizer. So you lose 1.5-2” of height that could be suitcase to the spinner wheels.
@@BrynneC ah I get what you mean now :) I just still fit so much more in my hard one! I packed for this trip with soft and then switched at the last minute when I realized how much more it could fit and it weighed less!
I prefer hard sided luggage for sure, but on a recent flight, I questioned that choice. I had to push and shove my carry on to get it into the overhead bin, and had to accept help from a guy at the end of the flight to get it back out. And I had a 20 inch! It made me wonder if a soft-sided would have squooshed better. If you haven't yet done a video on safety while traveling, would you do one on that subject? When we travel in the US, it's not to crowded, big cities, so we aren't that concerned about pick-pockets and such. On our upcoming European trip, I'm needing some tips! What have you learned to do or not do? What to carry or not carry? Thanks!
Susan, on my last flight I had a similar situation with my eBags backpack. I was on one of those tiny Delta planes and I had to take stuff out of the front pocket to fit in the overhead bin! My hard Beis would have never fit!
And yes, I’d love to help you with safety! It’s been on my list for a while. One tip I’ll give you now… I love a decoy wallet! An old wallet with a few bills and maybe old cards so it looks legit. If someone tries to mug you, throw that and run! Thankfully I’ve never had to use it, but it’s my favorite tip!
@@ItsTheKellys Oh, that's a great tip! Thanks!
can you do a video packing your Beis carry-on (not using the extendable feature, and then using the extendable feature, for comparison!). and if you have the beis mini weekender, i'd love to see if the detachable portion at the bottom can fit into othe carry on suitcase when you're using the extendable feature! im hoping to buy my beis luggage because of you soon, and would love to see that!!
My mini weekender just came in the mail today! Definitely doing a full review asap, and can put the bottom in the carry on for sure!
So you want me to pack the carryon extended and not extended? :)
@@ItsTheKellys omg that’s perfect!! I literally can’t wait to order and use my carry on + mini weekender, you totally convinced me on Beis haha! Yes I’d love to see you pack the carry on normally (without the extension), and then pack it using the extension. It would also be so cool to see if the detachable portion of the mini weekender is able to fit into the carry on when using the extension feature as well! Hope that makes sense :)
Do you know if the Beis hard shell carry-on bag nests inside the 26" hard shell check-in bag?
I believe so! :)
Have you ever considered or tried one of those cooler backpacks for travel? They are kind of like a hard shell version of a backpack and seem deeper which is where I feel like I a, always giving up space, not height or width. I want to optimize every inch of opportunity!
I haven’t. I actually gave up on backpack life! My back can’t handle it anymore 😂👵🏼
nice video ... do you have any recommendations for luggage brands that offer a lifetime warranty ?
Thank you :) and Yes I’ve done several reviews on this channel. Right now my favorite is LEVEL8 luggage because it’s small enough for international trips, but seems amazing to travel with. Beis was always my favorite but is a little too big for international.
Here is a link to the playlist! th-cam.com/play/PLiTcxyDSiK9UGUYn_IbVvuynzn9WFRitV.html
Hello, I had asked about you opinion on Biaggi pieces and you mentioned not being sure of the hardside piece. I'm really curious about the biaggi runway hardside hybrid carryon (wow, that's a long name, lol). I'm not able to find any real video reviews, other than the company videos. Is there a possibility that you would be doing a video review of this product? Thank you.
Unfortunately once I reach out to a company and they don’t respond, I don’t have any ability to get it without them sending one, as I can’t pay $400 for every bag I want to review :)
But I’ll keep trying, I promise!
I found an Eastpak carry on that is softside but packs like a hardside
Would be very interesting to hear opinions from an airline baggage employee. 👍🏼
Great suggestion!
You haven't mentioned the inconvenience of living out of your bag with the hard shell The hard shell luggage takes up twice the space when you are unpacking it - or trying to live out of it for a day or two - than the softshell. Also, durability is much less of a factor with a carry on when you, not the luggage handlers, are going to be keeping your bag with you. As for weight, my Travelpro spinner weighs almost a pound less than my sister-in-law's hard shell - both carryons.
I’ve never ever felt inconvenienced living out of my hard shell, whether it’s 3 days or 3 weeks. I pack packing cubes no matter what bag I pack, and my luggage is always put away and unpacked in my hotel.
But just trying to lay out a clam shell hard side on a rack is extremely difficult. Unless you find a hotel with over sized racks (practically non-existent) it’s impossible to unpack unless you place your suitcase on the bed (gross) or the floor (also gross). After an episode of wet clothes in Europe, I’m interested in a hard side, but looking for one that opens like a soft side, and then using packing cubes for my organization where needed.
I’ve never used a luggage rack in my life, to be honest. Hotel room floor, overhead bin, under the plane, on the luggage carousel, through the TSA bins and belts… it’s all germy. At least the hard shells can be wiped down and cleaned better.
I'm going 2 Egypt from Florida my 1st time on a plane I do have both I don't know what be best tho
Whichever you already have could be fine! It’s all a personal preference :)
I'm new at this I dont know what be best 2 take because the airport will have so many people around and I don't want 2 be in any 1 way lol and it's like a maze in the line also
I personally like to use hard luggage and have a small backpack with me. I think it’s nice to protect the things in your suitcase with the hard shell, and it’s best for all weather. They also have 4 wheels and roll nicely.
Thx so much for your help it's going 2 be a check bag because I have things can't be a carry on bag because it's my 1st time meeting my man in person in Egypt and getting married next month so I have gifts for him
Congratulations 🎊
My husband used a soft sided suitcase with an outside pocket on our Dominican Trip and the zipper must have caught and was ripped off.
Oh no!
Sounds to me that soft vs hard shell luggage is a no contest
I always find i pack more in a soft shell suitcase. You can always really put your knee into to make that last thing fit and zip it up 😂. Hard shell you can’t do that.
You can with good compression and a knee ☺️ with hard luggage, you can pack on each side and I can always pack just about double!
@@ItsTheKellys oh really? So you think hard shell is better for more space? I’m in the market for one at the moment and I’m undecided
@joeldelaney0 yes, my whole channel is luggage reviews and packing examples :) I love monos, July, and heys the best.
@@ItsTheKellys nice, thanks! I’ll check some of your vids out 😃
Oh yea,it’s gotta look good. 😂
😂 I don’t know why it matters BUT it does!
the music is tooo distracting
Thanks for the feedback :)
@@ItsTheKellys Thanks for info. I barely heard it. Especially compared to other content creators.