Simms Top 40 QB Countdown #19-15: Solid options | Chris Simms Unbuttoned (FULL Ep. 621) | NFL on NBC
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 25 มิ.ย. 2024
- Chris (@CSimmsQB) and Ahmed (@ahmedNBC) keep chugging through the Simms Top 40 QB Countdown with an all-emoji tier of solid starters who are missing...something. But first, we debunk Chris' famous sh*t story. #NBCSports #ChrisSimmsUnbuttoned #nflonnbc
(0:00) Ahmed's parents are disappointed in him after Tuesday's "incident"
(10:15) #19 Geno Smith: "For a supposed placeholder, the Seahawks ask him to do A LOT."
(22:55) #18 Tua Tagovailoa: "He is the ultimate NFL point guard at QB."
(37:40) #17 Brock Purdy: "The ultimate Shanahan quarterback. And it’s not just the system.”
(49:00) #16 Kyler Murray: "Incredible talent, but struggles in the pocket."
(1:00:50) #15 Baker Mayfield: "He is a damn good starting QB, but can be too aggressive."
(1:08:55) What's My Grip? The guys discover something unique about Tua's grip.
» Watch Live Sports on Peacock: peacocktv.smart.link/v82e9dl56
» Subscribe to NFL on NBC: th-cam.com/users/NFLonNBC?sub_...
NBC Sports Group serves sports fans 24/7 with premier live events, insightful studio shows, and compelling original programming. NBC Sports is an established leader in the sports media landscape with an unparalleled collection of sports properties that include the Olympics, NFL, Premier League, Big Ten, NASCAR, PGA TOUR, the Kentucky Derby, Tour de France, French Open, IndyCar and many more. Subscribe to our channel for the latest sporting news and highlights!
'Chris Simms Unbuttoned' features in-depth Xs and Os NFL analysis; one-on-one interviews with players, coaches, executives, and draft prospects; game recaps and previews; gambling segments; extensive player analysis leading into the NFL Draft; and much more.
Watch more from NFL on NBC TH-cam: / nflonnbc
Visit NBC Sports: www.nbcsports.com
Find NBC Sports on Facebook: / nbcsports
Follow NBC Sports on Twitter: / nbcsports
Follow NBC Sports on Instagram: / nbcsports
www.nbcsports.com/nfl/sunday-...
nbcsports.com/motors/nascar
nbcsports.com/soccer/premier-...
Simms Top 40 QB Countdown #19-15: Solid options | Chris Simms Unbuttoned (FULL Ep. 621) | NFL on NBC
/ nflonnbc - กีฬา
Posting clips before the full video is absolutely wild
Literally, the spoilers suck
Yeah not a fan of spoilers
That’s on NBC.
Cry us a river boss
This is a trend i noticed from DJ Vlad first. Its basically milking views. Alot of people will watch a clip and then watch the whole thing
Amazing to me how so many "experts" fail to give Purdy the credit he so richly deserves. Okay, he was only okay in the Superbowl, but did he throw a pick like Mahomes did? Did he cause a fumble with a terrible pitch to the running back like Mahomes did? And did Chris bother to notice how many time Chief rushers came in completely unblocked? (It was something like 17 if I remember correctly). And does Chris know that Purdy produced his record-breaking passing stats below a below-average offensive line? The only negative on Purdy that is just is that he has a very time hard in very wet conditions. And even then, when he was having bad games against the Browns and the Packers, he came up big late both times (a missed 38-yard field goal at the buzzer against the Browns cost him the come-back victory). The guy is clutch. He is a terrific runner. He's terrific at feeling the rush. He's a great escape artist. He sees the field as good as anyone. He's gutsy and throws in tight windows. He throwing stats led the league, my goodness! He's a fantastic leader. He's Joe Cool. Simms is Chris Miss. Chris Miss Bigtime. Does he get paid for his nonsense?
To all the geniuses in the comments he's rating the QB physical attributes not stats. Dont get butt hurt about your hometown QB being rated low.
Exactly. He's ranking as if every QB had the same coach and team around them. It's just a list.
Yeah but coaches can do things vastly different, so not everything is as simple as that. This list is arbitrary 😅
not only physical attributes but big time throws - power throws and plays beyond the system - off the script plays. thats why tua, purdy, hurts probably will never be a top 5 qbs in his book. the only qb that simms ranked so high even tho his arm is not elite is joe burrow. he went to the sb with the worst oline ever in his ... 2nd or 3rd year? burrow is so elite in all aspects so he overcame a terrible oline. tua, purdy, hurts could not overcome this. ...but i still cant believe he has dak prescott again flirting with the top 10!!!!!
To the genius who commented this, Chris is not just rating on physical skills. He just doesn’t know how to evaluate QBs. Just like why he thought Kellen Mond was great
@@soko2678no one bats .1000
Chris really needs to put the bowl down 🤣 he's just Mr. Contradiction with this list 💀
You really need to chill out… it’s impossible not to be somewhat contradictory ranking 40 nfl QBs… 🙄
Explain
Purdy has to be top 12 like the purdy disrespect is insanity
Purdy definitenly not better than the top 15 guys
Simms all in his mind. Erase all stats. Useless stats. Use Simms mind.
Did Brock Purdy not have two comeback wins in the playoffs. I don't really care where they rank Purdy, I just wish they were honest. Here are two people, one never played QB and the other never played QB well.. When they played the Cowboys, if you had changed QBs (Purdy on Dallas and Dak on SF) Dallas would have won. Dak is the single most reason the Packers beat Dallas. Every year Dak fails, yet he will always be put ahead of Purdy. As a 49er fan I think of what life would be like if they hadn't drafted him. I would rather have Purdy than Mayfield, Dak, Lawrence, Cousins. Goff, Kyler Murray, Gino Smith. Jury is still out on Love and Hurts. The really funny part of all this is Brock Purdy reminds me of Phil Simms. Chris's dad. Possibly the single worst thing that has happened to society is giving every loser his own podcast.
That's a pretty solid take :)
I've always held the ball 1-3-under-6. Having two fingers on the seams feels the easiest way to throw with power. But I noticed that I'm not a professional QB.
Tua could lead in every significant passer category on the year and they'd rank him like 12th in the offseason.
Turndaballova is mid. Cannot beat playoff teams and Hill and Waddle stat padding for him
Lol, bro...the whole store high in transit 😂. Hey Simms, you ever been snipe hunting?
Still catching up on the QB countdown!! Love you guys ❤
PURDY 17TH??? 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I know right , should be way lower
It’s based on physical stats and shit. Purdy isn’t special physically
I think Purdy is overrated, and even I was surprised at 17. I was thinking somewhere around 10-12
He’s adopting the PFF model of make the dumbest takes possible so people will talk on all your posts.
watch the qb school breakdown of purdys superbowl performance and you undrrstand why..
I'm not ready.
If you only look at stats, you end up with Russel Wilson as your starting quarterback
…or Tua. Hard pass for me (no pun intended)
@@josephbell7648 Or Purdy
@@TheLivedeath I’d rather have Purdy. In a shorter amount of time in the league, Purdy has demonstrated that he can read what defenses are doing and make in-game adjustments. Yes. He AUDIBLES…IN THE MIDST OF HAVING GUYS IN MOTION. So all that crap Tua said about it being difficult to audible bc of the motions, it was just that. Crap.
Tua is a robot. He goes into the huddle with a play and he AINT RUNNING NOTHING ELSE. The computer tells McDaniel what play to run and Tua sticks to the script. When there’s glitches in the system, you get the Titans, BUFF (twice), Eagles, KC (twice), BAL…2023: BUFF, SF, Chargers, and GB. This is not a $55-$60 mill QB. The market doesn’t tell you to pay Aston Martin prices for a Hyundai.
Strongest Man in Football, early 1980s. My dad had the great idea to make this a TV show. I don't remember which network ran it. Unfortunately, it eventually got bought up and transformed into something less pure than my father's vision. As a young girl, I had a front row seat to some great competition but I wasn't very interested. A lot of guys like the Young brothers would truck through at my dad's powerlifting gym in Austin. I would do anything to go back and be part of those times now that I appreciate how special it was. Really enjoyed the episode.
43:00 FALSE. Purdy did have a 4th quarter comeback and 2 GWDs vs Packers and the Lions!
Also plays with 4 middle schoolers on his OL. Take purdy off the niners and put in Kirk cousins and the niners win 3-5 games last year. Purdy really did make people never realize just how bad that OL is.
I'd trade Shanahan immediately for an OL as good as the Lions. Overrated playoff choker who's lucky his QB went rogue, ran the ball and carried him with his legs to the SB. Builds his offense for the RB. How's blocking and YAC the best traits of all your receivers? The OL always put the ass in pass blocking just because Shanahan wants these weak but nimble track star OLs.
Kyler Murray above Tua and Brock Purdy???? Yeah I'm out.
Hi Chris and Ahmed, very nice show! one of the best :) .. where do you rank Jimmy G? Thanks
Bake above Brock?
Of course, Baker is a superior QB. Brock has a superior coach and cast
Baker has won playoff games on two different teams.
@@HockeyDudeJames2 Baker had a great supporting cast in Cleveland and didn't accomplish anything after the one year he won one playoff game. Baker is not currently better than Brock.
@@citizenx8710he absolutely is and he just won a playoff game with Tampa. Best QB Cleveland has had since Bernie
Now it makes sense why you are crying. Wah wah wah
So.. Jalen Hurts in front of Purdy ? El Oh El.
Purdy wishes he could consistently sit in a pocket for 5+ seconds.
How is Caleb Williams in the top twenty and hasn’t played a nfl game lol.
Obviously projection. This list scenario is "Given the exact same team each time, which QB would you take right now" Caleb just happens to be #20
@@TheLivedeath I get the scenario just don’t get him being in the top twenty. As a football fan hope I’m wrong.
Tua: It's about follow through! He's got to win the big games. Its about mentality
Why is this always posted on youtube before Peacock? its at least 3 hours later and nbc still doesn't have this up... your own employer
Baker Mayfield 15 and Purdy 17😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Put baker on that team and they win the Super Bowl last year
I think both should be a little higher. Baker 12 Purdy 13.
@@BratatoChipYou are hilarious
@@citizenx8710Baker is a far better thrower of the football and reads through his progressions better than Purdy. The only physical attribute Purdy has over him is his running ability, which isn’t even top 10 in the league. Purdy has dealt with the best case scenario in terms of coaching stability and scheme, Mayfield has dealt with the most coaching instability out of any starter in the league.
Back up your emojis my friend … what’s your analysis that has Purdy way better than baker..?
I just purchased a new gaming PC, I love it
Chris Simms is so ignorant.
Sam Howell WAS brought in for competition.
My biggest issue with Kyler is that when you catch him he tries to trick you out of your three wishes
🤦🏽♂️🤦🏽♂️
32:07 LOL the delusion
simms says it himself, but either completely forgets or underrates the mental aspect of qb processing. Otherwise, i cant fathom how guys like purdy are this far down the list. It's like the list is completely populated by physical traits, but i wouldnt trust trevor lawrence, baker mayfield, jordan love or kyler murray to make the same reads that brock purdy does
Swear words are Saxon terms for things... they were considered vulgar as opposed to the French Norman words which were considered proper
🤓
I didn't even know who Chris Simms was until I checked his wikipedia. A quarterback who got many shots but just couldn't last or succeed anywhere. Why would anybody listen to the guy?
I think Geno was more hurt in the Giants game than reported. He threw 6 of his 9 interceptions over the next month and in that Giants game he was 9 for 11 before he was hurt and 2 for 9 after
And I'd have Geno more like #12
I have watched this channel for years now and like a lot of content. But having Purdy at 17th is just ridiculous. He is way better than Geno Smith and Kyler. And Baker has played much longer and been less productive than Brock. He either led or was top 3 in nearly every QB stat in his first season as a starter and was top 5 MVP. There really is no solid argument for him to be anywhere outside the top 10. What more do you want the guy to do?
Baker has been on pretty bad teams. With proper WRs last year, he won a playoff game, even though TB is still flawed. Won a playoff game with the Browns too. 49ers the last 2 years has had the best roster by far(including coaching) of any other team minus QB.
@@TheLivedeath flawed logic. Baker had OBJ, Jarvis Landry, Chubb/Hunt and Njoku and played below average. That’s pretty good weapons to have
Not sure what they want Purdy to do. He runs that offense perfectly. He wasn't the reason they lost the SB. If you give those same stats Purdy had last year to the guy in KC, he's the MVP not Jackson. He does remind you a little of Brady. Run the offense and take what it gives you. Why Talking Heads now seem to hate QBs who do that I don't know. Give me a guy who can run the offense over an Allen type QB any day. If Purdy was a top 5 pick QB they'd be singing his praises. He not so he can't be good. He's been nothing but good practically every game he's played. I'm not a SF fan. But I'm a Purdy fan after watching how he just runs the offense and takes what the defense gives him. You win more game doing that than playing hero ball that a Josh Allen plays. Does he have a great team around him? Sure. But you can't mark him down for that.
He wasn’t the reason they won the Super Bowl either & that deserves attention.
That said, I think you make a great point & I was surprised Purdy wasn’t in the top 12
Chris Sims…love your work, but please stop saying “right?” after every other sentence. Please!
Chris saying I gushed all over him makes me so mad that I’m leaving this video
I'm struggling with all the contradictions, even when talking about one QB. But hey, it's your list, Simms, so you make your own criteria for your opinions.
I think he’s being nice. For example, he says “Tua can do everything”. Clearly that’s not the case! It’s like a compliment sandwich. He says something nice, then takes it away, only that he never added the nice thing back. So it’s more like a sandwich with only one piece of bread. 🤷🏽♂️ he was trying not to straight dog Tua but he was spot on about his limitations.
I’m proud of Simms for being courageous enough to rank Purdy and Tua outside the top 15
You're "proud" ?
Are you his mom ?
Courageous? Or just ignorant. How is one of the best rated QBs in every metric last year ranked in the bottom half of the league. It’s the only way Chris gets people to watch.
@@soko2678 He's treating them all like they have the same coaching and talent around them. This is a list that ignores their situation to get his ranking of where he'd pick them all for an average team.
He put purdy ahead of Tua
He’s also correct 👍
Purdy at 17? Harsh. I wonder why “football guys” hate him so much…
They don't. Warner, Young, Steve Smith, Montana, and many others talk about how well he plays and proves others wrong. It's just Simms judging people on athleticism and arm talent and discounting immeasurables.
Didn't purdy bring them back against the lions ,
Purdy won those games
Daniel Jones was not good two years ago. The offense was set up to minimize him being bad/putting the game too much in his hands.
Purdy led the league in almost every passing category. Chris is much too critical of him.His two year record is tremendous.
Hes on the best roster in the nfl. Literally 15 qbs could do what he does
yk stats aren’t a way to determine which qb is better than another
Its not fantasy football. Not all about stats. The actually player isnt a top 15 qb in the league
He's talking about the player physical attributes not stats genius. From arm talent to decision making. 🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡
@@raniasaad8772 The 49ers have great skill players but except for Williams a lousy offensive line..
i just need to say about Tua, he'll probably get paid, he should be franchise tagged, which granted i would sit out if i was him which would get him paid still, i guess congrats on getting paid, There's no excuses for the dolphins to not be in a super bowl like, the division shouldn't even be remotely close as well talent wise. and i doubt he's good enough to get there in the AFC in this era. Just based on even peak projection of his traits, not even passing but with pocket presence limitations. his body literally alone limits him situationally, he literally doesn't have the talent to problem solve effectively post snap and this really bothers me because it just makes everything harder for everyone. When it should be easy for this roster and its frustrating to watch teams like the dolphins cap themselves at the QB spot. ik everyones not Mahomes or burrow or lamar, i just think you should be constantly revolving the starter spot till you nail on a dude, that's that level. i don't get the desperation to give Tua money besides front office ego/hubris.
Really enjoyed your breakdown on Geno. I think he's a really good QB. Live the way he throws the ball and can thread the needle. But you answered several questions for me as to why that talent doesn't translate to more success. I know it's something that can be fixed....to what degree, I guess that depends on Geno. But I also wonder how much of the problem was a result of the scheme. I know that the Hawks didn't utilize the middle of the field. The question is, was that because of Geno or the lack of other positional players. With JSN I expected more slot plays but it never happened.
Geno literally carries the hawks. 2nd worst oline in the league 30th ranked run game 31st ranked defense. Geno on any of the teams listed is better than the guys listed before him.
They didn't utilize the middle of the field because of Pete Carroll. His philosophy was not to use middle field because it leads to more INTs.
In the playoffs when he plays the ENTIRE game, he has stepped off the field with for the last time of each game he either has the win or the lead. Who else can say that presently besides Mahomes?
I love how most teams shining moment was "out playing the chiefs" "should have beat the chiefs." Browns were getting stomped in that 2020 divisional game until mahomes was yanked for a concussion that he didnt actually have. Hurts "outplayed" mahomes in the superbowl even though they loss and mahomes was playing on a high ankle sprain. The nfl does not like the same teams being good every year contrary to all the fans that think kc gets all the calls because discussion around who the best is gets stale.
Wish yall would post the full pod before the clips! I hate they get spoiled for me before getting to watch the entire thing!
How many playoff wins does Purdy has? The only reason he's ranked above 5 is because he was picked last. How's Goff better?
Love the pod, but Geno is way to low.
Keep up the good work.
The Titans game plan that "stumped" Miami that Simms is talking about was literally watching Miami's starters suffer injury after injury.
Williams done for the year
Tyreek severely banged up
Eichenberg banged up
Howard banged up
Mostert banged up
Waddle banged up
All in addition to the starters already injured before the game:
Armstead
Baker
Holland
Hunt
Phillips
Wynn
Generally speaking when literally all 3 of your best O-Linemen are out, offensive production suffers.
mahomes, allen, burrow, stroud, love, jackson, herbert, cousins, stafford, lawrence, rodgers, goff, hurts, dak
Bad guesses my guy
Wow! Aiden O Connell top 15!
😂😂😂
19-15 QR the 👍🙁Tier. Geno: It's about reads. He needs to go through his reads
I hope the whiners give Purdy 50 mil + 😂🤣
Tua's decisive split second decision making and accuracy means nothing.........,,,a? Hmm Christopher can never admit when he's wrong!
Tua isn't nuanced, he's Tuauanced
Terrible joke
Purdy at 17 is insane.
Dude was the most efficient QB in the league last year. Absolute stud for where he was drafted. No way is he bottom half of the league. Even Chris can't escape draft bias. What a joke
The thing is; this is ranking QBs without all the weapons and OC. There are a lot of QBs that would have flourished with SF's weapons and shanahan as playcaller. Don't get me wrong, Purdy was a stud last year, but let's not overreact here.
@hoek-ni8fl , flourished and near MVP are two different things. Other QBs could win but only a handful of other QBs could put up his numbers.
Their are so many QB’s that would thrive in Shannahan’s system with Deebo, Aiyuk, Kittle, Jennings, and obviously McCaffrey. He has exceeded his expectations as a 7th round pick but he’s not a top 5 or even top 10 QB talent.
Purdy is too low I agree with that
Your dad stuck with the grip change for the rest of that season, and then switched back, because he couldn't be consistent with it after.
Dam I was looking at Tuas numbers from last year and was comparing it to Burrows 2021 campaign Tua has 4624 yards, 29 TD’s, 8.3 YPA and a 69.3 completion percentage. Burrows 1st full year of football 2021 Burrow and ALL starters did not play the last game because they didn’t have to. Tuas numbers above are for 17 games. Here is Burrows 2021 numbers for 16 games is 4611 yards 34 TD’s, 8.9 YPA, 70.4% completion percentage. He led the league that year in completion percentage and YPA and he would have this year as well. He would have been second in yards about 17 yards behind Tua and would have been 2nd or third in TDs. Dak led the league with 36. And despite that brilliant performance with a 108.3 passer rating he did. It make the god damned Pro Bowl. He made it in 2022 though and should have made 2nd team All Pro in 2022 and not Jalen Hurts. Burrow had 40 total TDs in 2023. 35 tds a franchise record and 4500 yards. And again in 2021 the Bengals starters all
Rested in the last game. They didn’t even dress out. And in 2022 the Bills game was canceled because a guy literally died on the field and they had to resuscitate him. And last year we were headed right back the AFC championship. This year things will come fulll circle and Burrow will win MVP and Super Bowl MVP. They will beat the 49ers in New Orleans at the super dome for the Super Bowl and it will be poetic because 5 years prior there is where LSU Burrow and the boys from Baton Rouge dismantled the Clemson Tigers in the 2020 national championship game. And we will finally exorcise the demons of
The past and we will vanquish the 49ers who beat us in the Super Bowl in 1981 and 1988. So that’s a little sneak peak on what is going to happen. Place your bets early while you have good odds.
Why do you write like that?
I'm disappointed they changed the camera angle away from the 'blue jean girl' at 23:45.
make mine the "tight white pants girl" btwn 4:18 - 4:28
I’m just wondering one thing next week: If Goff can make Simms’s top 10 QB
He did
all these guys above Geno is insane , guy does as much as any of them with the 2nd worst protection in the NFC
The line isn't as bad as the sack numbers suggest. While I agree they lack interior talent, the tackles are good. The scheme that he played in was awful and he held the ball too long at times.
@@brandonwilson4740the tackles were hurt all year and when finally health the last 5 games Geno had the number one QBR in the league. The oline and run game were horrendous.
Im actually surprised im agreeing with this list as much as i am
I get that you want to exonerate your bestie Kyle Shanahan for folding at the end of yet another Super Bowl by rating Purdy so low (oh, if only Kyle had a better QB, maybe he would have known the overtime rules...) but c'mon dude - Baker Mayfield is in your eyes better than Purdy!? Baker? I don't even know what to do with Kyler. He's obviously better that Baker as well, but currently he is not better than Purdy. BTW, where are Zach Wilson and Kellen Mond? In the top 10? Go pound sand man, you're a walking contradiction
Find my grip was kinda easy and y’all know y
Kind of puzzled at this segment and how they’re treating it. I just look at skin tone and then accessories (if you’ve watched NFL for a few years you know who likes to wear wrist tape/bands). If they wanted to make it harder they should have done this after every 10-20 QBs that Chris ranked instead of 5-6.
I’m not saying Tua is a top five QB but there is a 100% a false narrative that he underthrows balls more or worse than other QB’s. He doesn’t have a strong an arm as Josh Allen or Mahomes or Lamar but he can make the throws he needs to make. You know who underthrows receivers as well. Mahomes , Allen and Lamar. It just happens sometimes and it’s not about arm strength, it’s usually about timing
With Tua you can see some balls he throwing it with everything he's got and Tyreek has to literally stop and come back to it. And he can't make the tight window throws off schedule, everything with Tua has to be pre-planned and scripted. Or else everything breaks down, just like in all their tough games.
Purdy is waaaaaaaay to low
I just can't listen to anyone who buttons all the way up .. damn bro u gotta be choking yourself!
Some of us dont have triple chins and globs of fat on our necks
How good was Chris Simms on a top 40 scale in his prime?
Last year during his ratings ,he was asked and said about 23.
@@jasonbrazier2864 Ok thats not bad. Thanks!
I was about to say 20. Only starting 1 year in jon grudens overly complex offense.
Chris is super biased
Sorry there aren't 12 QBs better than Brock Purdy.
I know Chris leans on arm strength and some of those elite tools....BUT....Purdy is elite in accuracy, processing, pocket escapability, and anticipation.
12 he has Brock at 16 but dak and hurts with just as much talent aren't even in same tier and dak dosnt get punished for choking in big games but purdy gets punished for having coach some say chokes in big games, also they said he's never had 4 th quarter comeback or game winning drive yet they forgetting Packers game.
Simms’ ranking of Purdy is spot on.
The challenge for Purdy now is to prove that this isn't his ceiling. Can he progress to make some of those throws that he can't (or hasn't yet)? If he doesn't then he will be doomed because the team around him won't always be as incredible as it is and when he gets paid like he's top 5 in the league he HAS to.
@@davet2459 why would anybody ever think purdy is at his ceiling? This is where Brock criticism is unfair I don't remember anyone ever suggesting a quarterback that has never had a full off season to improve is at there ceiling why is it Jordan love is expected to improve and be great but Brock can't yet he's been in NFL less time it's such disingenuous way to rank guys how can Jordan love he ahead of purdy love has had maybe 6 good games and why with some qbs does Simms down play there bad play but with Brock who did throw 2 balls that should been picked but Simms says at least 5 v packers no it's all nonsense to justify his preference for big arms because there's nobody can tell me the tape says love is better.
Murray > Purdy? 🤢🤮🤯
I disagree with Geno, yes he does get a lot thrown on him but he holds the ball wayyyy too long so he doesn’t throw into coverage. I want him to step up and throw more lasers with JSN, DK & Lockett out there
had an actual top 5 quickest release in the nfl last year so the stats disagree with you. he was the 5th highest pressured Qb so what you should want is an OL that is NFL caliber, thats all he needs
@@divinecomedy7311Exactly. Geno critics don't want to acknowledge how poor the offensive line has been.
Baker is a good ol' boy... who belongs on the bench of the front porch.
Why is Tua a below average starter? .... "Can he make the big-time throws?" ... Really? ... Let's see your Josh win a big-time game. Lamar. Cousins. ... a lame excuse for criticism.
Purdy>Tua is about that top button and haircut.
TrashField at 15 lmao on Chris don’t get caught In the Hype of last year
1 of 14 qbs in nfl history to win a playoff game for multiple teams.
@@anthonypa8045 wanna cookie 🍪 lmao he was the fucking number 1 overall pick ahah
@@markey1808 yea and he is playing like it. He's only played 6 years and has had 3 top 10 seasons in yards and tds. And led two teams to playoff wins. There is only one tom brady bro.
@@markey1808 yea and he is playing like it. He's only played 6 years and has had 3 top 10 seasons in yards and tds. And led two teams to playoff wins. There is only one tom brady bro.
@@anthonypa8045 yeaa 6 years later lmao 🤣
Purdy ranks seventh among starting quarterbacks with a 2.53-second release rate
17 ranked quarterbacks don't take teams to the superbowl.
Wtf are we talking about Brock purdy didn't have 4th quarter comeback or game winning drive so he didn't do it against green bay in playoffs? He didn't have biggest comeback in championship game history? I have no issue with anyone who wants to see it from purdy for longer or anyone who thinks he's not elite but having him below baker n as low as this it's just nonsence especially when you don't even have him in same tier as guys like hurts and dak who have just as much talent played longer in NFL, Brock has never even had a full off season to improve he's been to championship game and left feild 3 times in superbowl with the lead in fourth quarter it's just strange to me that choking in big games like dak dosnt penalise him but having Kyle a guy everyone says chokes in big games punishes purdy I mean what we talking about here.
Purdy was trash against GB. CMC long run, tipped TD pass led to comeback.
@@glow4417 I agree purdy had a bad game with wet ball no doubt but that's not my point is it there saying he's never had come from behind win or game winning drive but that's not true, they also punish Brock for talent on his team yet dak as plenty of talent and chokes in big games yet he's in whole other teir above Brock I don't understand the criteria is winning in pressure situations not one of the biggest qualities qbs can have?
@@glow4417, Jordan Love was worse. Lamar Jackson was worse against KC. Like all of these criticisms apply even more so to other QBs.
@@judshuttie70they were talking about the regular season. That is where that stat comes from
@@POWPOW-rn5uqjordan love played well outside of the last interception. He tried making a play when they needed it and ended up turning it over. Brock Purdy was terrible until the last drive when he started running. For 90% of the game Love outplayed him but purdy had the better team. Specifically defense
Simms is amazing but his opinions on Purdy are so bad.
Jordan love ACTUALLY threw 2 interceptions and cost his team the game. Your bias is showing. You don’t wanna put him in the top 10 after being 1st in every statistical category fine. But 17 just means this list is nothing more than toilet paper.
Kyle Shanahan would secretly take Love over Purdy if given the chance.
@@TheLivedeath Kyle would be looking to replace him if he ended our season like ended the packers season. Especially if that game was basically handed to him on a silver plate to win and he couldn’t close it.
OMG, Baker and Murray above Tua?. My God they are never as accurate.... Hater!
Murray isn’t an incredible talent. If you can’t stand in the pocket and take a hit while throwing the ball, you’re screwed. He is just too small for the NFL period.
He clearly is an incredible talent hence why he's in the NFL despite the height etc.
Whatever you think of Brock Purdy right now, that was Tom Brady until 2014 when he changed his throwing velocity. Belichick deserves much more credit than he’s received.
Get mad that your little QB isn’t ranked higher. These are Simms’ best QBs in terms of who can win a championship today, right now. Not next year, not the year after that, but THIS year.
Exactly, also I can't think of a less biased analyst than Simms. I think he truly wishes success for every qb and player but he has to give his honest opinion on everything he sees. That's exactly why I watch his shows.
@@scottrowlandrowland1098 What has Herbert done or Lawrence?
@@citizenx8710 This is a QB evaluation given the same team around each guy. Herbert has had a horrible situation around him. Bottom 5 defense, worst coach in the league, bad Oline and aging to bum WRs/TEs and RBs that can't stay healthy.
Russell Wilson is better than all these QBs.... IMHO
No he is not.
Simms is a clown! The Niners are the top social media team in the league. The dude does the dirty on Purdy for the views. Shame! Simms sucked as a QB and now as a football analyst🤣
Good 😊 God
Purdy is miles better than Mayfield wtf. Guess this pod is just engagement bait now
Kyler at 15 lmao
Def should be higher, top 4 minimally.
HAH!! he the 2nd coming of RG3... he'll be outta the NFL in 2 seasons...
@@winebuyah 🤡
Already know there’s gonna be butthurt tua fanboys in here 😂😂😂😂
Just imagine how much better this show would be if Simms actually had someone to debate with that actually knew about football and X’s and O’s. Cuz we all know that Ahmed isn’t that. Not even close. Ahmed is the worst
Geno Smith... come on now
what about
I wonder where chris simms would rank lol. The Tua hate is old chris come on man
There’s no hate. Hell, I think he should be lower. We could both name 20 other QBs that would succeed way more than Tua in that offense. Weak arm, relies on anticipatory throws, injury prone, weak mindset, etc. Tua is so damn overrated
@@tylerbarclay629 delusional
The problem is that I genuinely think you can’t win a superbowl with Tua
@jrmiami4035 how? Explain Tua's stats vs good teams.. I'll wait
I just think it's funny a career back up who did absolutely nothing has the gall to rate anything. Chris has has an issue with Tua from jump street. How about Chris compare himself to Tua. Yes I'm a dolphins fan so I support Tua. He gets better every year so I'm looking forward to this year. Yo 🐬
Chris is right about Brock! It hurts. Brock needs to work on his throwing mechanics. He needs to go through his reads better. He needs to read defenses better! With a complete off season Brock will be Better!
This is his first one. Will be interesting to see if he makes small improvements or leaps and bounds of improvements
This countdown is proving so much how mediocre the QB position is at the QB position at the moment and being so top heavy....
Why can’t we get the unedited audio so I can hear all of Ahmed’s swearing unfiltered 🧐🤔
chris simms will always talk neg about purdy to elevate his bf kyle shanahan
You hate Tua... just admit it
Tua is trash
How is that hate? Show it
What did he say about Tua that you disagreed with? I’m a dolphins fan but I felt the critiques were spot on
@@trehendrix8588 it’s not just this video… dude had Taysom Hill ranked ahead of tua two years ago lol
@@jrmiami4035 what has Tua accomplished without Tyreek?
Chris Simms you dont know shit about football putting Purdy that far down i lost all respect for your opinion
Second !
Did you not watch the game where he came off the bench, as a rookie, and crushed the Dolphins?
whose he
@@buddysteele7624 Sorry, Purdy
He led their offense to 23 points, with only the 2 TD drives going for 40+ yards (one FG came starting from Miami's 25, then went 3-and-out) . 210 yards on 37 pass attempts, roughly 1/3 of his completions were behind the line of scrimmage and overall for the game he averaged 3.7 air yards per completion. This was against a defense missing 2 of its top 3 cornerbacks and starting safety. QBR was slightly above average (58.6).
The talent that crushed Miami was the 49ers' defensive line. Miami missing 3 starters on the O-Line resulted in them keeping in extra guys for pass protection on all but 3 plays, and SF's line still kept nearly constant pressure.
Purdy for sure is a good QB but stating his first start as a crushing performance is overstating things
@@smudgeous4068 As a rookie off the bench
@@johnf6198 Yes, and that's part of the reason why I said he was a good quarterback. All I did was refute your labeling of that performance as "crushing".
His first start against Tampa was a substantially more impressive game, as was his first playoff game/6th overall start against the Seahawks.