*Please consider supporting my work on my new Patreon page and choose your reward!* Find out more: www.patreon.com/TheBestFilmArchives Thank you for your generosity!
nah not no more if ever . lets be honest. you only need to look at history and you get to see the ugly truth. the american ideal is just that,an ideal still waiting to be born. if enough people believe in it then it will happen but theres a ton of bullshit blocking it and theres no point pretending its not there and hoping it will all go away
@@Asemodeous I think the point was the people in power will step on ANYBODY regardless of their affiliation if it means they get ahead. Race, religion etc doesn't matter to tyrants. It wasn't directed at conservatives or anybody it was directed at EVERYBODY.
@@Asemodeous you forget the other side is trying to divide all of us up into our own little categories too. Both sides want total control, and they'll tell you whatever you want to hear to get that control, and they'll tell you it's for your own good. Remember that.
Vera von Weltin True I don't know all that much about Germany but I know enough about their dumb censorship laws. For example they didn't allow Jojo Rabbit to play in their country as if that movie would indoctrinate people into becoming a Nazi
Actually we are. We prefer to be around our own people, and this whole "American experiment" has failed long ago. It's crumbling as we speak, because white people are bludgeoned over the head from birth to have out group preference, while everyone else is told to have in group preference. Yet infants still choose the doll that looks like them.
3:31 "Hey! He's talking about...ME!" "And that makes a difference, doesnt it?" - And that is the moment when it really hit me like a brick wall... This should be shown in every school in America. I have never seen a more powerful retelling of the dangers of division and prejudice as this short film. Bravo to whoever made this and to wheoever posted it here. This is history that needs to be preserved and im grateful its here for the world to see.
Meanwhile anything uncle dolf warned about happened lol. Freemasons taking over usa, non europeans flooding europe, russia invading europe with help from china
As a kid in high school, I'm gonna tell you this now. Sadly, NO ONE is gonna care about this film. I wish more kids would, but they wouldn't even listen to this in class
Not likely to be shown in classrooms too soon. School boards too busy putting hypersexual books in the elementary school library and reporting parents to the FBI as alleged terrorists.
@@EtherealWonders1216 as a history teacher i've given them a test on this video. It had to be done. People need to know what their behaviour could cause.
"I heard the same words that we have heard today, but I was a fool then, I thought the Nazis were crazy people, stupid fanatics. But unfortunately it was not so" I very much relate to that quote today.
It's interesting how human they made Hans. He's shown laughing, smiling, kissing his wife. They don't demonize him in the slightest. He's treated, at worst, as a man who's been conned.
In part, its because it could be you. To portray him as a villain or demonize him would defeat the point, in a "oh its his fault, that guy, that other person" as opposed to the fact that it could be anyone
@@kn9ioutom Let me guess you think getting conned is a scapegoat. Sorry but you blinder than a bat. This video is not meant to justify fascism but to show even we need to stick together and not be divided or what happened to Germany could happen to us. This is really the average man was fed propaganda all the time by the Nazis. You realize that in the context of the time there was no internet or any fast ways of communication besides radios and landlines. So really you had to take them at their word that and mainly because goeballs would overpower other parties.
_"You see, we human beings are not born with prejudices. Always they are made for us, made by someone who wants something. Remember that when you hear this kind of talk. Somebody's going to get something out of it, and it isn't going to be you."_ Hot Damn. Way to call-out 21st century bullshit, 1947.
Guys this is literally government propaganda from the 40s designed to make the public think a certain way and you’re internalizing it. Racial awareness is not taught; it’s learned. Often through experience. Like after the tenth time you’re beaten in the streets by a black or Mexican gang you learn that the 40s propaganda was a lie.
@@peachnehi8683 A person who experienced that should be anti-gang or anti-crime. Instead, that normal hatred of injustice has been twisted in some to becoming anti-black and anti-Mexican even though most blacks and Mexicans are innocent of those crimes, just as most whites are. The race of a perp has become this person’s focus instead of the perp’s character. Instead of “I hate criminals who beat me up” he thinks “I hate blacks, I hate Mexicans”. It’s a gut reaction, a trick of the brain to protect him by putting the biggest wall possible between him and the danger. If, his brain says, “all blacks or all Mexicans are dangerous”, it’s easier to put his walls up to protect himself. He doesn’t have to get close enough to a person to work out their CHARACTER and know if they are dangerous, he can see their colour or race from a distance and take steps. All racism is derived from fear and the brain’s attempt to deal with that fear in the simplest most complete way possible: A black man hurt you? Avoid all black men from now on. Try to reduce their power to hurt you in the future by suppressing them or expelling them. All of them, because you don’t know who the bad ones are. That’s how the racist brain thinks. It’s simple and effective, if you have the power. Which the Nazi’s did.
I wrote a paper in highschool, early 2000s, about how Hitler and Mussolini subverted their governments to take power. I closed the essay out with a paragraph about it makes one think how we could lose our democracy in America. My teacher wrote underneath, "That can never happen in America, we have checks and balances!" with a smiley face. I'm pretty sure she didn't read the paper, I think she just checked to see if we wrote the citations correctly and used at least 3 different books and one newspaper article. Pretty sure she told us everything on the internet is made up too.
I about came to tears when the man started ripping up the pamphlet. Very powerful. We must all stay together as one. We will never be a minority if we remember this..
@@ironfist4457 Saying negative things to strangers on the Internet does not make you look intelligent or superior. Propaganda or not, it’s a good message. You’re one of the people that backed away in the video.
@@dreameater9247 Is it really a good message though or good fantasy? Have you looked at the state of your country? The guy yelling with the pamphlet was right. It’s not even America anymore, it’s not even the west. The idea of America being a “melting pot” was never even introduced until after WWII ended and society has slowly started to fall ever since. And gee I wonder who has been pushing a one world agenda for hundreds of years, it couldn’t have been the poor people we let out of camps who happened to also be in all of the Allies political structure during the war and that currently have more representation in our government and American elites than they did in Russia during Stalins Soviet era. I’m not trying to degrade you or insult you, but seriously wake up. Read more. Think outside of the box about why the Western Hemisphere is in shambles. The fingers all point back to one people. The same people who own Blackrock, Vangard, and everything that you know and love from the media you’ve enjoyed, the products you’ve consumed, and more than likely the people you’ve looked up to. They have always been implementing the ideas of the current downfall into our minds, they’ve just dumbed everyone down enough to do it more openly now and sold it to the people as being “progressive”. Remember Weimar? Or are you unaware of what was being orchestrated in Weimar by the “chosen people”. The world is not sunshine and flowers. Some realities are harsh, and one of those harsh realities is that maybe we have been lied to for a long time and are currently being lied to.
Because they are running the same psychological operation on the people today! They don’t tell you about central banking and unplayable debt that we’re put on German people. The pornography and transgenderism put on the Germans by liberal 🇮🇱. When they burned books ,it was books pushing that typ of propaganda!
The topic is as relevant today as it was in the past. Fascism has been on the rise for several years already, the wish of many conservatives to turn the clock back to the time "when everything was so much better" for "us", but not for all people.The MAGA movement in other words.
@@Yeggman Wow, people still believe that tyranny is started by people who want to limit government power. Unreal. Tyrants always want big government. Idk if it's lack of intelligence or brainwashing
Today we have far-right lunatics who label everyone who disagrees with them conspiracy theorists or nazis or anti-vaxxers. We are ruled by the interests of huge corrupt corporations, pure fascism.
I was coming in expecting something like the "identifying communists" PSAs of the 60s, but not only does this all make sense from a modern lens, it still completely holds up to today's standards. Way to go, 1947!
They were lucid for a few years, but then they wanted to go back to before the war. Strange how people always attempt to slide back into their old ways after a great awakening. Its been documented since the plagues
The post WW2 era was very BASED. There was a lot of sense during that time after so much life lost. People woke up to the reality of war worldwide the cost it has. Not to mention the depression.
Not anymore we believed that lie and it was useful until 2020 now it’s open season on certain people, and we get it. I never deployed but my kids won’t join or be drafted America is done with us so let the ones who benefit from it’s existence fight for Israel.
I like the part when he points out how cowardly and barbaric it was that they went into other countries without first making a formal declaration of wore.
@@jasongorr3975 Something something “I don’t know why we are stopping at Berlin, when we all know the enemy lies further beyond.” - Some history dude circa 1945.
What was most profound for me was how many times they mentioned that the people needed to be separated before the nazis could have power. And it doesn’t take long to think of similarities in our current government.
Relevant. "First they came for the Communists, and I did not speak out- Because I was not a Communist. Then they came for the Socialists, and I did not speak out- Because I was not a Socialist. Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out- Because I was not a trade unionist. Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out- Because I was not a Jew. Then they came for me, and there was no one left to speak out for me." Martin Niemöller
We are clearly regressing into a collective state of mind where this film bounces back from appearing quaint to feeling acutely relevant and effective. /:
it's not an issue relegated to left or right in my opinion, but this polarizing behavior is typical of modern politics now. especially in Eastern Europe, but also present in the West.
@@whitewolf6605 it's wild how clueless both sides are. you are just as much of a pawn as the extreme liberals. the only difference between you and them is that their proposed bills aren't oppressive. have fun with your great replacement you fascist weirdo.
You can really say that about most ststems of Gov. Facism grew out of the great depression when the whole world had been ripped off with the aid of democracy
I could never have imagined America could produce such a sensible and virtuous video so long ago in 1947. Makes me think that past isn't necessarily a more naive perspective.
Sadly the Democrat Party has used the Nazi tactic of Identity Politics to divide America It's frightening that the Democrat Party have brought Nazism back to life
Yup, and did you also notice that the narrator mentioned America's greatest strength, almost in passing... People of all religions and skin colors together as Americans, living free. Three-quarters of a century later, and I think we are the ones with the naive perspective.
It's from the generation that fought and defeated actual Nazis. They had more sense and virtue. People today are more concerned about nothing while the US government is trying to become fascist under the guise of "more inclusive".
Happening again? It's been ongoing since the dawn of the cold war and corporate war profiteering ... Left vs right, whites against minorities, the threat of the "lazy poor", the war on people who want to do drugs to escape it all ... It's just a gigantic "us vs them" circus ... If I was an advanced alien species or an interdimensional/time traveler I would laugh at it all. But seeing as how I can't leave and need to live here, it's just a ridiculous nightmare to have to endure until I die.
As it should. Everything the fascist warned about; happened or is happening. These propaganda pieces brainwashed millions. The West is dying, and globalist imperialism will swallow up and enslave the world.
I think this film needs to be shown over and over again all over the media. People need to be reminded of it's important message. Unfortunately we are seeing history repeat itself.
Even in this film, we see that it only takes 30 seconds for the man to fire up, disillusion, and trick the crowd into racism and false information. Yet it took a whole 16 minutes for the film to provide the truth and better judgement. Truly shows that “A Lie Can Travel Halfway Around the World Before the Truth Puts On its Shoes” -Mark Twain. Fun fact: Mark Twain didn’t say this quote but is often falsely attributed to it.
Great observation, so many misconceptions remain even to this day from lies or errors made ages ago. We all tend to believe things far easier if it fits our preconceived world view or if said by someone we trust.
You can sway a thousand men by appealing to their prejudices quicker than you can convince one man by logic. Robert A. Heinlein, Revolt in 2100/Methuselah's Children
time for some paradigm breaking revelations - the history of eurocentric culture is just different parts of europe doing the same general things. consolidating wealth, enslaving the world, pretending they own the world and feeling entitled to any wealth anyone else might be able to generate. the excuses they give themselves to justify these behaviors are nearly identical too. just replace the name of the country and their past will be filled with little more than copious slaughter and unnecessary suffering. turns out, when you let psychopaths direct society, it turns into a bloodlust murderfest. every single time. because they will go to any length to protect their stolen, undue power.
Astonishing to see an old educational film that doesn't just seem like half-baked claptrap and actually makes a damn good point instead, and one that chillingly still holds up at that.
@@redacted428 How so? I found it interesting, and educational. Well presented, good music, and a good insight into fascist ideology. It was a bit naive about how free America was given they were still in the segregated south era though.
@@edgarwalk5637 an earlier commenter said it best "This was a Warner Brothers film produced by Jack Warner in 1943, a notorious communist sympathizer. This same year, Warner Brothers made the film Mission To Moscow, in which the plot was essentially a US ambassador visits Moscow, realizes that all the negative things he hears about Stalin was untrue, he meets Stalin, and realizes he's a great leader and a kind man, and the film degrades to even showing actual footage of Stalin's late 1930's show trials with a narrator who supports the trials as justice against "fifth columnists", even though these trials were nothing more than made up charges and confessions derived from brutal NKVD torture sessions, and almost always resulted in the execution of one of the thousands of people Stalin perceived as a threat. Seems as though you might be the 'sucker". Either that, or you're a Marxist, which would still leave observers to the same conclusion that you're a "sucker"." Jack Warner interestingly enough was also a polish Jew
_“First they came for the Communists, and I did not speak out-because I was not a Communist._ _“Then they came for the Socialists, and I did not speak out-because I was not a Socialist._ _“Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out-because I was not a trade unionist._ _“Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out-because I was not a Jew._ _“Then they came for me-and there was no one left to speak for me.”_ -Martin Niemöller (1946), Adolf Hitler's “Personal Prisoner” of Dachau.
@@jpbefree Fun fact: 75% of American adults possess the literacy level of 6th-graders (11-year-olds) or less - 21% of Americans are functionally illiterate. Thank you for providing proof of that statistic. _“I love the poorly educated.”_ -Donald J Trump (2016) Welcome to the _stupidest party_ in America: the _Repuglican_ Party-the *Stupid Peoples’ Party.*
Sad thing is, this still holds true today. If a struggle of people doesn't affect me, then I don't care and don't concern myself with it. Only when they come for me, I start to speak out. People then get a sense of, well, if you don't help to fix the problem, then you must be by default part of the problem. It's easy then to look at others as the "enemy". It's a sad thing to witness.
I loved how the film pointed out that fascism is a derivative of georges sorel's socialism, and national socialism is a branch of socialism, and communism is a branch of socialism also I liked how the film differentiated between people illegally invading another country, and legal citizens who actually belong to that country and I loooooooooooove how it pointed out that nazi germany had some of the first hate speech legislation in history (polish people aren't allowed to talk bad about germans) really makes you think
I can repeat the same things as other commenters (i.e. “We should show this in schools!” “We need this film now more than ever” “We haven’t learned”) but I think you’ve already read enough of them if you’ve found my comment. I’m tired. I’m not even an adult and I’m tired. I feel like despite all my hard work and effort, this world just wants to see me burn. I don’t understand how people can be so mean. I genuinely don’t get where people get off by villainizing minorities and other groups, and then say “well I’m a [insert political party here] and I think it’s the [opposite political party]’s fault that the world is broken and we’re all suffering from their greed and evil.” I don’t give a flying F about what political ideology you follow. I think we can all agree that politicians and politics in general are evil. What I’m tired of is having my right to be a (living) person debated by a bunch of people I don’t know and didn’t vote for. I’m way too young to be worrying about my life. And before you go on a triad of “oh boo hoo you little snowflake. Quit crying about it and get to work!” I am working. I’m focused on staying ALIVE. I’m trying not to get jumped in the street by a bunch of people who would rather I go away because I’m of a certain minority. I just want to live.
I know you're tired. You're not alone. I'm tired too. I've been fighting for human rights and equality for 50 years. I feel like Sisyphus, everyday pushing that boulder up a hill and everyday having it roll back down. But remember, toiling to push the rock is only torture if you don't find meaning in the work. I've been doing this for a long time and every day I am able to help someone. However small a token of aid, it helps. Telling someone they're not alone helps. Connecting someone with a community that supports them helps. Changing one heart about one issue helps. And that's where I find meaning. There are millions of us who still dream of an America that isn't controlled by Nazis. Today we mourn, tomorrow we organize. We build our communities, we give support to each other, we stay resistant and resilient, we plant our feet and we push back. We are only 18 months from the midterms and if we can show that the future is better when we aren't subservient to a steaming pile of narcissistic feces then we can take back Congress and cut this fascist movement off at the knees. Yes, things suck now. Things always suck, but it's what we do about it that matters. So do something about it.
@ that means a whole lot to me. Truly. I can’t imagine just how much you’ve seen in 50 years-that has to be A LOT! I know I should find meaning in the little things, keep myself going as long as possible. I’ve been trying. I don’t plan on letting the fascists outlive me. (Imagine how funny the internet will be when that happens?) Thank you again for your kind words. I hope that wherever you are, you have a pleasant day and find happiness in every moment!
@@youruniquehandle2you have no idea how much I needed to hear that. You've proven your words with your actions, and the message is clear. Thank you very much!
Indeed, you got Far Left Progressives causing the Culture War and trying to basically fight racism with more racism and some of them trying to make things so "safe" and non offensensive it's restricting,and rarely trying to find the middle ground, and some essentially causing mindless violance and chaos as seen by the horrific 2020 riots and just going into ideas that are so disturbing and morally wrong, and you got some on the Right trying to counter that chaos, but sometimes they go a little too strict on laws. One side causes chaos and occasionally censors thing, one tries to bring too much order, we got the parties going for the most extremes rather then trying to find something that works for most people. Thus both sides implement some elements of Fascism.
Imagine how disappointed people in the 40's would be if they realized that there were people dumb enough in 2023 to watch this schlocky and banal 1943 war propaganda film made by Warner Brothers, which was written by an actual communist (who 10 years later was brought up on charges by House un-American committee's), and think that it was "needed". You know what other propaganda film Warmer Brothers made that same year in 1943? Mission To Moscow. I'll save you the time of laying out the plot (you can watch it since you're so enamored with pro-Marxist, anti-Christian propaganda), but its main points were pointing out what a great man and leader Josef Stalin was, and how happy people were in the Soviet Union under communism. Meanwhile, also in 1943, the Germans found the mass graves of over 20,000 Poles who were executed in mass graves, killed by the barbaric Soviet NKVD. Your own government knew the truth, and still lied to you and blamed the deaths on the Germans, all while producing pro Soviet films from Warner Brothers. It took 50 years for the US govt to admit the truth that it wasn't the Germans, which is still less time than it took to learn the lies about illegally arming the civilian passenger ship Lusitania.
I watched these films in basic training in the Army. I tell you it really strikes a nerve. Watch as many of these PSA films as you can. Because the message never changes.
Damn this anti-racist film from 1947 is better than 99% of anti-racist ads in 2023 Edit: how the hell did this comment I made 2 months ago blow up?????
You didn't, I did. I didn't just learn I lived it , you should be terrified if somebody work money can target you and try and make you suffer, that's also a monopoly a dictator, I didn't do dictator s I can govern myself
@masterofmycoc I'd be more worried about my family dying when the Axis invaded and preventing that, do you think our ancestors were cowards or something? that they'd cower in fear because of a change you can't accept? The world is an evolving changing place, old men like you are what kill armies because they can't adapt and think the world is always going to move at their pace. Grow or get run over.
@masterofmycoc Your arguments here contradict themselves, you claim to argue for the founders, but look down on the founder's ideals. The founders were anti-authoritarian, you argue that songs and videos should be consored by authorities. You only decry autorotarianism when its a power figure you disagree with. When the first executive order enacting gun control, banning bump stocks, was signed by Trump you said nothing. You don't care about freedom or decency, just control.
The ending monologue at 15:27 is *chef's kiss* Perfect way to end this knowledgable video. People talk about 'minorities' as if they're not a part of one, but literally _EVERYONE_ is a minority in one way or another-it doesn't have to be in race, sex, origin or religion. A threat to any minority spreads as a threat to _all_ of them. Just like MLK said: _"Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere."_
The problem is that some minorities are persecuted more than others. White Americans have been threatening and oppressing the freedom of Black Americans for centuries despite whatever "minority" group they come from.
@@pepelepew1227 isolated incidents aren't representative. the british and french ended the slave trade. look up the true story of 'the woman king' its a good lesson on reality and on how the media lies to u. and u can't trust mainstream anything. do some research on who actually controlled the slave trade. it was mostly joos.
@blakethomas5637 the difference is at 4:20 when the Hungarian immigrant said that he is now an American and a U.S. Citizen. He assimilated into American society.
@@austinwilkerson84I love how this myth of “there are good ones, and there are bad ones.” That seems to persist. So easy to see through the ruse, but there are a lot of very impressionable people out there that fall for it. Truly sad to see.
@@SonnyD223Basically, Modi is doing this whole Indian nationalism thing and has been supporting Muslim hate groups as India has lots of Muslims and they are often target by Hindus. And many of these hate groups are similar to the Nazis due to their nationalistic spirit and hateful ideas towards Muslims. And unfortunately, many people fall into them and hate towards Muslims is increasing in India and like in the film, Modi is simply dividing people up into groups so he can gain political support
This is why Nazism was dispised by the majority of people back then. Cause they just lived through it. This is the best anti Nazi film I've seen. It sucks how history is trying to repeat itself. It's easier to point the finger at someone else for your problems then to take responsibility for them yourself.
@@davenewsom5985there is a video where hitlers speeches were translated by AI and the amount of “he’s actually right though” makes me depressed to be a history nerd.
_"you see, we human beings are not born with prejudices. Always they are made for us, made by someone who wants something. Remember that when you hear this kind of talk. somebody is going to get something out of it, and it isn't going to be you."_ true.
False. We still be simpler beings without complex socialpsychological processes (e.g., prejudices). I know this is a harsh reality, but true regardless. Read into evolutionary and social psychology.
@@ThomasMueller999 human beings are born with prejudices, you are afraid of the dark, you are afraid of heights. things you don't understand can harm you, so it's built in to protect you as a defense mechanism safety until you can comprehend, and move away from prejudice with experience and knowledge
It's pretty obvious that the US is not striving to educate its citizens. Little to no curriculum discussing journalistic integrity, propaganda, or critical thinking.
Usually they’re people who tout about wanting socialism and equality when they have no actual solution or realistic way of approaching that kind of an outcome
@@mannyverse6158 notice how they didn't overtly say "hey maybe negros should be allowed to sit in front!" Back in a time where expressing that view does need to be spelled out.
"You see - we human beings are not born with prejudices. Always, they are made for us. Made by someone who wants something. Remember that when you hear this kind of talk. Somebody is going to get something out of it; and it isn't going to be you." Damn.
Pretty much. I mean as a kid, I treated each new kid like a new friend. It's hard to keep that through adulthood. Or harder still to revive it. I try. Some days I'm better than others. I think we should celebrate our differences, but that doesn't mean we should do so based on heuristics like the color of our skin or our gender. So what if you're a woman, can you pass the physical? Then you're in. Who cares if you're black, do you have the education? You're in. White? Male? Do you have the qualifications? In. Otherwise come back when you've got yourself sorted. I'm of the political party that says trans/gays shouldn't be picked on... but I personally don't recognize more than two genders. The republicans kind of left me to do some weird fight against drag queens. Drag queens aren't a problem. Nut jobs shooting up schools might be a problem. I disagree with Dems on abortion and boys changing in girls locker rooms. I disagree with Reps on... well Jan 6th-style thinking and ignoring Covid. I just don't know what happened to my America. Everyone went extra crazy after Covid. Just accept each other's strengths instead of picking at each other's weaknesses.
@@mugsofmirth8101 ? how is this propaganda ? whos making money from you ? or do you mean knowledge is propaganda ? which sounds kind of backwards .. are you backwards ? or just a putin boy ?🥃
I also want to remind you that the Americans didn't join because of the holocaust. They didn't join to fight the Nazis. They joined because they were attacked. Not because of some ideal. Most people had no idea what was going on anyway. So do not tell me they went to war to end the holocaust. They didn't.
@@chiggins4399 So? You are saying they went to war to stop it. They didn't. That was a lie. That they found out that the issue was much more serious does not actually make what you said true. The "greatest generations" witnessed evil for sure. But they did not go to war to end it. So do not lie about them.
Funny how it was generally uncontroversial to hate Nazis when "The Blues Brothers" was released. Now, the right wing would complain about the "Dems" curtailing the freedum of the Illinois Nazis.
@@HeathWatts you seem to want to lump "the right" as a group with no derivation in ideals and lable them all fascist and/or fascist apologizers. That seems close to Mccarthyism, just using fascism as the blame instead of communism. And the government coming down to imprison people for there beliefs (which Mccarthyism did) is fascist. So don't be a sucker and fall for that.
@@maxfinazzo2443 Not all right wingers are fascist, but all fascists are right wingers. It's the definition. That said, capitalism, the rich, and the right wing benefit from fascism.
@@HeathWatts I don't see how capitalism benefits from fascism. The only corporations that benefit are the ones that the government nationalizes in the name of the country/ethnicity/race. Any seemingly successful business is run out/given to a member of the fascist regime. In Nazi Germany, any successful business run by a jewish person would either be shut down or run into the ground by a german who has no idea how to run that business. I can see how some of the right benefit from fascism, being that fascism is right wing, but it wouldn't benefit any right winger who isn't fascist. Any libertarian capitalist who doesn't want the government to run his business is screwed. And, of course, any rich people who aren't part of the regime will have their wealth taken away. So only certain rich people benefit. To clarify, I hate fascism. I am not defending it. But I am a right winger, in the sense that I am a libertarian capitalist type. My argument is that fascism only benefits fascists, and the vast majority of right wingers have more in common with democrats than fascists. I'm sure the left, with stalinism is in the same boat, but I'm not a leftist, so I don't know.
That's exactly what I thought first when the video started. The narrator's voice is incredibly well trained and professional. Just like in the old movies. Today you can't hear such voices anymore, sad to say.
Relevant today because this propaganda needs constant reinforcement because unlike the left would have you believe in group preference isn't learned it's deeply engrained in our biology. If they ever take their foot off the gas the 5% of the world that's not racist will immediately revert....and they can't have that while there is still wealth to exploit and infrastructure to process the third world through.
This film was literally made at a time when the USA was subject to strict racial segregation, racism was no less than in the Nazi Germany, people were discriminated against on the basis of their faith or origin, and the dominant and most influential group were white, Anglo-Saxon Protestants, while Catholics, Negroes and other groups were subjected to harassment. Freedom of speech and personal freedoms existed only in theory, in practice prejudice was common. This film is just a propaganda bullshit commissioned by the US War Department, which was supposed to encourage Americans to fight against Germany.
@@michaoborodo931 I think they are more saying that America has so much freedom to run home the point that fascism has no freedom. This film is post world war II. They aren't fighting Germany they are fighting fascism. Even if some things are wrong or outdated, They did a pretty damn good job with the things they got right.
@@FreshGreenMoss And that is why we are repeating the same scenario over and over again. Enslavement of the mind and spirit through dictatorial forms of governmental and social control keep us in an endless loop of repeating this same play. The communist and fascist totalitarian gamebook divides the WE into "us and them", makes the past evil, and promises a better tomorrow if we just walk down the primrose trail. Isn't that what we see today, divisions between races, religions and genders. There are horrendous events in every nations past. There is not one nation that doesn't have innocent blood on their hands. We SHOULD learn from the past. We SHOULD be a WE. Listening to the rhetoric of those who are claiming to be "woke" are essentially, the same characters portraited in this film creating division. The prophet nailed it when he said "Come now, and let us reason together,' says the Lord."
Today we have far-right lunatics who label everyone who disagrees with them conspiracy theorists or nazis or anti-vaxxers. We are ruled by the interests of huge corrupt corporations, pure fascism.
"Your right to belong to a minority is a precious thing" Never forget that, people. Celebrate the things that makes us differ, defend the rights of every minority. In the end, we're all minorities in one way or another.
Lessons? This is a cheesy war propaganda film made by Warner Brothers in 1943 (reissued in 1947 with a few minor edits). Warner Bros. made another war propaganda film in 1943 called Mission To Moscow, a longer form fictional film where Josef Stalin is portrayed as a great leader, and the people in the Soviet Union are portrayed as living happily under communism. Sadly, you're so far gone, you'd probably really think that was full of "lessons" also.
@@jackprecip5389 So because Stalinist communism was bad, you think Nazis were good? At the time, without communist Russia, we would not have defeated Hitler.
The people who made the propaganda for Reagan, ie Lee Atwater, saw these sorts of films as they grew up. They took those lessons and began with paring the Tree of Party Politics in the 1980s. Lee Atwater , before he died, apologized to the American people for undermining the system. Thank folks who saw these films then ran riot with their "messages" for the antediluvian policies created from them.
THIS is the America I support: one that supports freedom for all, whether black or white or religious or not, one that doesn't ban books, one that preserves rights for every minority, and one that accepts that we're all minorities in the bigger, singular majority: American.
@@BazzBrother True! You're exactly right! We were banning things, and that was totally wrong! But the ideal was what I said earlier, the ideal! What we were striving for, what we believed to be, etc. Were we perfect? No, not at all. But we WERE getting better. That's the America I want to see continue.
Too bad that america is only a fantasy. As a little child I thought US was actually a nice place but after decades of learning about it i know its shithole with a nice coat of paint on it.
@@BazzBrother The U.S. was improving, heading in the right direction, expanding rights, until the Reagan administration. Just because we hadn't arrived there yet, don't bash a time when people still wanted to. Now we're racing in the wrong direction. edit: Our foreign policy was as awful then as it is now though.
Who have we become? Have we learned nothing in the last 76 years. I cried watching this because my father was the son of a poor Italian immigrant and he fought in the Normandy invasion. A war so horrible that it was said those atrocities could never again happen. But here we are. We have become those deluded people we fought against in the name of freedom and liberty. We must find it in our hearts to love one another and have compassion for those who struggle to simply be recognized and heard as equal and not less. And who are trapped in poverty by an unfair and divisive system. Our great country too can fall if we choose to avoid speaking out against inequity and hatred and place blame rather than take responsibility for being part of a more important whole than ourselves. Our future and our children's future literally depend on us finding love in our hearts for each other, our neighbors, and our beautiful planet. Peace, Love and Blessings to all.
You lost me at equity. America doesn't need socialism BLM bullshit etc.. equity brings everyone down to the same level, doesn't boost anyone up. My grandfather was also a poor immigrant. He got blown off a ship in the Pacific when a Zero crashed right next to him. He would agree with everything I'm saying 100%. Equity, just like socialism, is trash. 👍
@motleylou609 I said inequity. Very different. I hope that you can find love in your heart. Fear, hatred, and resentment just feed more. Once you put yourself in someone else's shoes, it's easier to see from their perspective. We all have challenges in our lives. They might be different, but we're all human on this rock together. The world is too small for hatred now. We're seeing that vividly.
It got lost in the red scare. And yes Stalin was a monster,no doubt. Just as murderous and repressive. Trump is the epitome of pitting one against other.
@@mjh5437 A slight correction; we are more... Republicans then all of us! Most all of the Democrats I know are very pleasant calm people; most of the republicans as we. saw under dmfp; are angry, loud and detrimental to the over all health of our country!
Conservatives are two steps away from goose-stepping down the street heiling for Trump as they vote to keep themselves in poverty. Meanwhile liberals don't want to engage in reality and refuse to see the warning signs. We need to elect more scientists and fewer high school bullies.
Not just the USA. There is a palpable rise in right wing action in many places. Eastern Europe for one, which is a rare grain of truth in Putin's several 'reasons' to invade Ukraine (by sneak attack, same as Hitler). Meanwhile, the republican party in the USA (Trump) embraced the right wing/Neo-Nazi groups in order to grow their party and infect as many simple American sucker brains as possible - that's how Trump won in 2016. Simple fact is this is cyclic. Right wingers had their time in the sun back in the 50s. Then the liberals rose up, delivering more women's rights, legal abortion which rambled on a while as we wrestled with our war in Vietnam and the aftermath leading to a softer right wing reaction with Ronald Reagan Make America Great Again. First black President was a shot across the bow for the right wingers and worse, Obama basically tossed the keys to the kingdom to the gays, fruits and nuts his last 2 years in office and that was too much. And that's how we got Trump, who's an even dumber right wing reaction than GW Bush was. I never cared much for Joe Biden at any point, but I'll take him any day of the week over Trump, and twice on Sunday.
For real because none of them looked like the Perfect “Master” race they yapped about. Thats why it is important for people like teachers speak up against what is wrong and teach their students the truth.
@@politicsiswack8925 you do realize there wasn t really a master race. uncle h himself wasn t blond with blue eyes nor did he ever say that was the master race. the aryan race meant the european race, nordics, medditeraneans,slavs,etc. Loving your race doesn t mean you have to hate other races. Lear more real facts about the enemy before making stupid arguments.
Legit appreciate that this film also takes the time to show how terrible it feels to be other Ed by the fascists. The way it shows the black and foreign people in the crowd looking genuinely afraid for their lives. I had heard of this film before, but I didn’t realize just how raw and effective it is at showing the poison that underpins fascism.
Immigrants are never victims, they make the conscious choice to go to a place and demand equality to the people who have lived there their whole lives. It's disturbing
"you see, they knew that they were not strong enough to conquer a unified country" Today in America, we have been split into feuding groups... This shit is happening right now, everywhere around you. The media is not your friend, there's something awful happening right now in America.
Wow, a lot of familiar stars from that era. Well produced. The credit says 1947, but was actually made in 1943 during the war, then re-released in theaters again after the war. Paul Lukas played the Hungarian professor -- such a great actor. It contains a message as true today as it was back then!
@@Liam-uq7rb the 1943 date comes from IMDB, who are generally correct about these things. According to the IMDB page, the film was re-released in 1947 with a shorter runtime and updated to mention later events.
I'm 44 and I used to catch these kind of old films during daytime television at home on the weekend as a kid. The central character, that young man who says "I'm a mason!" I'm sure I recognise him too - was he pretty famous?
Yea, the people trying to make people look shitty in history are the ones this video is warning about. They are trying to spin a narrative that divides people into sub categories and then pits them against each other. That's how republics are taken down, slowly over many years of repetitive and exhaustive effort.
It’s not the people of the past I blame, it’s the people of the present I see as dumb and racist. Back then you had the excuse of lacking information and only reading propaganda. Nowadays we have infinite access to information yet people still choose the prejudice that was made for us by those who will profit from our hatred.
The part I loved the most is when they said that they were American and not a group to be seperated from minor differences. That is was ok to have physical differences or different Religions. Why can’t we have that now? Why can’t we unite as a people to solve our problems for the good of everyone. Why does everything have to result in a pointless debate with something that may not even matter in the end. I may sound Nationalistic but I just want for the better for everyone Edit: 112 and counting replies, that went well with others lmao. Entertaining though.
@@tjones6277 Is recognizing a truth hand-waving? Unfortunately, segregation tends to happen across cultures. How many black people to you see in China, Japan, Pakistan, etc. Look at borders of countries most countries are home to one primary race, and if there are others they are often segregated into Jewish communities, Kurdish communities, Sunni, Shai, Gypsy etc communities. Humans tend to organize by cultural groups, New York had jewish, black, german, italian, hungarian, chinese, etc communities. Hispanic restaurants employ mainly hispanic people. Chinese, sudanese, japanese, and african american restaurants often employ members of their familial/cultural groups. African Americans evolved humanity forward. Segregation was the norm everywhere and still is. Most countries are not diverse. America is the 1st and only country to allow a diversity of so many different races, religions, ethnicities, and cultures. In the past, when cultures clashed, evil occurred, different people were often viewed as something to be feared. Yes, the 1950's were bad, but videos like this, and writings from the past show that they were on their way to being more inclusive. Its sad people ignore tribalism across humanity. The ability to see past it, is a very new, and unique gift. Thank MLK.
At Dodger Stadium, you'll find a statue of Jackie Robinson (the first black person to play in major league baseball). Underneath the statute is a quote saying, "There's not an American in this country free until every one of us is free."
I teach 7th grade language arts. One of my students said “the US national film archives has less followers than many TH-cam gamers.” I’m still haunted by that.
Because nobody cares about past History. It doesn't mean anything to them. Because they don't care about anything. But what's in front of them. And that's the truth.
Frank D The EU says the Visegrad countries have one month to "normalize" their policy on immigration. Sounds like Prag in -68. Leftists calling on history to aid their stupid causes... Twats...
Hate breads hate. Nationalism, ignorance, fear, and hate leads to violence. Nazi Germany wasn't created in a vacuum. Mussolini and Hitler capitalized on the same types of nationalism, ignorance, and fear that we are experiencing right now. Who will take their place? Duterte? Trump? Jong-un?
@Medovukha What the hell are you babbling on about? Those white supremacist, nazi scum buckets arrived ready for battle. They were dressed in military gear, carrying weapons, ready to fight! They came from all around the country, threatening to take over Charlottesville. They chanted nazi slogans! They rammed a line of riot cops, pushing against them in an effort to breach the barricades! They drove a car into a crowd, a terrorist act to be sure. These white supremacist nazi scumbags are terrorists! Enough with the false equivalency bullshit!
Frank D Reagan cut taxes. The result was a 15 year surge in our economy which went through the Clinton Presidency. The Clintons had nothing to do with it. Yet being the politicians that they are, they took credit for it. When taxes are cut Americans are free to invest invest and buy. It creates more jobs. More people are working so more people pay taxes. The economy surges in a positive way. That is the truth. High taxes stifle the economy.
Yes the Democrat Party has used the Nazi tactic of Identity Politics to divide America It's frightening that the Democrat Party have brought Nazism back to life
They use you until they come for you. Fascism always has to have a domestic enemy in order for it to work, some group, or groups, to divide and conquer. If they take from the initial target groups and run them off, kill them, imprison them, then they must have someone else to 'deal with' to turn the suckers against until it is their turn. The only way it is ever able to work in the first place is for there to be enough people willing to sacrifice someone else in their desire to have more for themselves, right along with enough people it doesn't matter to. You are left with people who are willing to do that to you either through greed or fear, depending upon where they fit in the scheme of things.
The fact that so many in the comments are trying to say that this is a propaganda film and therefore has no value is insane. The message itself is a great one that it doesn't matter what way it was told, but being technically propaganda just so happens to be how it's told.
@Kristopher Prime oh american values? You mean real americans right? Like the pawnee, Mohicans and the great tribes and civilizations that were wiped out?
@@Nodnarbero tell me a country and i’ll tell you a war crime they committed you do know that the indians were from russia right? there was no human from america
Replace jew and catholic with white and Christian... and you have the modern progressive movement, sounding again like the 1920s "progressive" movement.
They literally need to put this in a primetime tv slot to show serious every American alive should watch this in today's political society it would open some of there minds
Yes the Democrat Party has used the Nazi tactic of Identity Politics to divide America It's frightening that the Democrat Party have brought Nazism back to life
@@onlyjuanhope ah yes, that one guy America who makes all the decisions. America is just a singular sentient entity that thinks for itself and controls all the people beneath it and forces them to segregate. No, America doesn’t do these things. America is founded on individuality and entirely free expression. If these rules are violated, it’s not American. America isn’t some omnipotent entity in Washington that forces the people beneath it to go by its bidding. America is a bunch of people, some are the government, some are the public. The government and the public work symbiotically, not one way or the other. You’re talking about when nasty people make the big decisions. This isn’t America. This is nasty people who exploit the American system.
@@dogol284 You have been duped into think freedom is a virtue that people choose but its not, you are told what is freedom and have it served to you over a mountain of corpses and debt.
@@StrangeScaryNewEngland Yes and its always been the position of the ignorant to assume they are individuals with sovereignty. We always have masters and with the overthrow of the monarchs now we have no idea who they are or what they want.
1:39 One thing I didn't expect from a PSA from 1947 was appreciation of America's diversity and acknowledgement of racism, xenophohia, etc. as a scapegoat, a very pleasant surprise
What!? That's exactly the kind of smearing dirt in your eyes when things aren't much better in your own country than in other racist societies. Here oneself is presented better than reality. And the co-responsibility for the emergence of the Nazi movement, through a deeply unjust peace treaty of Versailles, is completely ignored. The failure of American politics in 1919 and the years that followed could hardly be better concealed than with a poor propaganda ham like the one we see before us. What happened when Germany laid down its arms in November 1918? The bulk of the German fleet was interned in England. The Imperial Air Force had been disbanded and the latest aircraft were in French hands. Allied troops had been in the Rhineland since December 1918 and had established large bridgeheads across the Rhine. Germany was no longer able to continue fighting. Despite this, the illegal long-distance blockade of the Allied fleet was not lifted. Not even for the urgently needed food. As a result, 850,000 Germans starved to death in the winter of 1918/19. The blockade was not lifted until the end of June. Then 1 million Germans fled from the separated parts of the country to escape the repression of the new masters. And at the end of the day, everyone in Germany lost their money due to a hyperinflation that is unique in the world untill today. And now please tell me again what kind of message the film has and how true these statements are...
@@LauncherSpiderMk7 Wow, that's not very patriotic of you. You're not a true American, go wave your Confederate flag with the other losers, like the n*zis and Indians!
@@Movedaccountlol U mean if we completly ignore the fact the whole continent was simply stolen from the "real american Americans" by europeans (mainly germans) who founded this, our joungest Nation by far. Wich is and was in war, ever since. Still the only one cold blooded enough to nuke a completely unprepared City. Additional polluting one of the most beatutyful places on earth with tons of radiation and bla and bla and bla... Founded on lies, financial system corrupted to the core... China own`s more physical Dollar than there is physical America....
People of America We need to make this go viral!!!! We ALL need to hear this over and over . Please please send it to everyone you know! Specially those who are on the fence .
Men should be allowed to dress up like woman and go into woman's bathrooms/dressing rooms/woman's sports. All this 💩 with gender is crazy. They claim they are being oppressed. I bet they started this BS because they wanted to take attention away from men's rights activist. But what do I know. I just thought of that after watching this video.
I know. If fascists will get rid of communists like AOC then Im starting to warm up to fascism. I'd rather vote F than allow the continued mutilation of kids, abortion of innocent unborn, and mass invasion at the south border. If fascism will protect our people, then I'd vote for it. I'd vote for any other group that wasnt fascist but would turn off the migrant spigot, would end womb based murder, and would sto pthe trans communist ideology. But failing to have an alternative to fascism, I'll take fascism.
@@fishjohn014 The Nazis are an existential threat to everyone, including themselves. Countries have a right and duty to warn their populations against them
Yes the Democrat Party uses the Nazi tactic of Identity Politics to divide America It's frightening that the Democrat Party have brought Nazism back to life
@@gregbors8364 I meant your current incumbent. It was his handling of Ukraine I was thinking of specifically. But enlighten me. How did Trump abolish truth exactly?
Rook Valentine wtf are you talking about it was all over the news they were fighting for that statue to be taken down because it represents slavery and because those people protesting were "slaves" yes they are saying that they were born in the time African Americans were slaves
why ? so they can misunderstand it and apply it to whatever politician they personally dont agree with ? the dems are gonna say this is how trump is and the republicans are gonna say this is how the left wing deep state is accept its now reversed prejudice against white christians and conservatives .
@@itsallgoodman4108same with a lot of radical left ideologies too since at the end of the day though the ideologies may be different the outcome still the same
short and sweet? It's literally against the only system that vehemently was against communism, and all the perversion that is rampant today. Sorry to break it to you, but the good guys lost. And the evil communists won, just look at society; that proves (between good and evil) which side won the war. Germany NEW if they lost, the world was lost; that's why they faught so hard. 1 nation, versus the most perverse, corrupt, and evil people on earth. When you go up against the greatest liars in history, great lies will be told about you. "You are of your father the devil, and your will is to do your father's desires. He was a murderer from the beginning, and does not stand in the truth, because there is no truth in him. When he lies, he speaks out of his own character, for he is a liar and the father of lies."
@@moondancer6488 People have been falsely told that Putin is the new Hitler. This film might be about anti fascism but it's true purpose at this time is to feed the two minutes of hate.
This short is even more valuable today than when it was released 70 years ago. Then, most of the vets who smashed the nazi war machine were still around and could tell us what they had seen. Now, most of them have passed on, and the country has come into the hands of those who sit up nights trying to take what we have ... and they've been very successful. But they're nowhere near finished!
@@kaylahills3760 He means the recent rise of things like antisemitism, restrictions of voting rights, more anti union sentiment, increase of extremist political movements, etc. Similar to what was happening in the early 20th century and what led to WW2, the Holocaust, etc.
This really needs to be shown in India where the current ruling party has leaders and supporters who target religious minorities, promote pseudoscience and use religious sentiment as a tool to seize power.
I find it interesting how three of the four comments on this thread have been hidden due to ??? Any questioning of India's nationalistic government on US social media is immediately ridiculed by M0di supporters. I saw the turn among H1B visa holders in 2014 when M0di won the election. It's a bit spooky that even Ghandi is now considered "too woke" or even a traitor among Hindu Nationalists who now venerate his killer, Nathuram Godse, as a misunderstood patriot.
*Please consider supporting my work on my new Patreon page and choose your reward!* Find out more: www.patreon.com/TheBestFilmArchives
Thank you for your generosity!
Sounds like the Democrat party of today’s 🇺🇸
The Romanian born Professor was very wise
This propaganda is hilarious since Catholic Church were known supporters of Nazis.
Your work? Ha! This isn't your work; this is someone else's work (and terrible work at that) which you uploaded to your channel.
@@kenfox5442 He was played by Paul Lukas, the actor.
"Hey, that fella is talking about...ME"
"And that makes a difference, doesn't it" - Truer words have hardly been spoken.
@Captain Gregg Bot account is less than a month old.
@Captain Gregg Random capitalization is a sure sign that you're a reasonable person worthy of my attention.
@Captain Gregg Your content is dumb too.
@@johnschwartz1641 And he got our attention, which is the whole purpose.
@Captain Gregg keep demonizing communism, fascist loser
“History never repeats itself, but it does often rhyme.” - Mark Twain
It rhymes with "new".
I've also heard, "History doesn't repeat itself, Man does."
_"I don't drink water, cause fish fornicate in it"_
W.C. Fields
@@maxi-me I don't breathe air, because humans fuck in it
"i shat everywhere in my house last night it was absolutely fucking violent disgusting" - Socrates
“Here we have liberty, personal freedom. These are not just fancy words, they are a practical and priceless way of living“
Amen
Yeah, until the Hart Celler act 🤣
nah not no more if ever . lets be honest. you only need to look at history and you get to see the ugly truth. the american ideal is just that,an ideal still waiting to be born. if enough people believe in it then it will happen but theres a ton of bullshit blocking it and theres no point pretending its not there and hoping it will all go away
WORD.@@arwaldc9056
They are practical when properly maintained and they seem priceless but it’s paid through sacrifice
"He is talking about me.."
"Then that is making the difference?"
What a powerful moment which can happen to everyone.
That is the juicy part, as far too many people cannot see past their immediate concerns and notice how conservatives are attacking them from afar.
@@Asemodeous I think the point was the people in power will step on ANYBODY regardless of their affiliation if it means they get ahead. Race, religion etc doesn't matter to tyrants. It wasn't directed at conservatives or anybody it was directed at EVERYBODY.
@@JesusChrist2000BC Which is bothsiderism that conservatives use to justify their evil.
@@JesusChrist2000BC It was directed at fascists.
@@Asemodeous you forget the other side is trying to divide all of us up into our own little categories too. Both sides want total control, and they'll tell you whatever you want to hear to get that control, and they'll tell you it's for your own good. Remember that.
The only thing we learned from history is we learned nothing from history
Tell that to your country's president
Most Germans have learned their lesson, and the AfD stays at around 10 %
Vera von Weltin The Germans learned nothing they continue to censor
@@staraptorflock3661 It is obvious that you know nothing about Germans.
Vera von Weltin True I don't know all that much about Germany but I know enough about their dumb censorship laws. For example they didn't allow Jojo Rabbit to play in their country as if that movie would indoctrinate people into becoming a Nazi
"We human beings are not born with prejudices. They are made for us. Made by someone who wants something."
He literally outted himself in 3 sentences, lol.
Actually we are. We prefer to be around our own people, and this whole "American experiment" has failed long ago. It's crumbling as we speak, because white people are bludgeoned over the head from birth to have out group preference, while everyone else is told to have in group preference. Yet infants still choose the doll that looks like them.
@@l337pwnage god weeps at the lack of media literacy you're displaying
@@percussionfellow6168 Dunning Kruger
@@l337pwnage Coming from a propagandized fascist cuck who can't spell 'outed' 💀
3:31
"Hey! He's talking about...ME!"
"And that makes a difference, doesnt it?" - And that is the moment when it really hit me like a brick wall...
This should be shown in every school in America. I have never seen a more powerful retelling of the dangers of division and prejudice as this short film.
Bravo to whoever made this and to wheoever posted it here. This is history that needs to be preserved and im grateful its here for the world to see.
Meanwhile anything uncle dolf warned about happened lol. Freemasons taking over usa, non europeans flooding europe, russia invading europe with help from china
As a kid in high school, I'm gonna tell you this now. Sadly, NO ONE is gonna care about this film. I wish more kids would, but they wouldn't even listen to this in class
OK capitalist, keep feeding the companies your favourite people own
Not likely to be shown in classrooms too soon. School boards too busy putting hypersexual books in the elementary school library and reporting parents to the FBI as alleged terrorists.
@@EtherealWonders1216 as a history teacher i've given them a test on this video. It had to be done. People need to know what their behaviour could cause.
"I heard the same words that we have heard today, but I was a fool then, I thought the Nazis were crazy people, stupid fanatics. But unfortunately it was not so"
I very much relate to that quote today.
It's interesting how human they made Hans. He's shown laughing, smiling, kissing his wife. They don't demonize him in the slightest. He's treated, at worst, as a man who's been conned.
In part, its because it could be you. To portray him as a villain or demonize him would defeat the point, in a "oh its his fault, that guy, that other person" as opposed to the fact that it could be anyone
@@jacknelson7477 Thats right. It creates a them and us mentality and all of a sudden people dont think it can happen to them.
it would defeat the purpose of the video its a education video to make you aware if he was so alienating it could not relate to you or me.
FASCISM NEEDS SCAPEGOATS !!!
@@kn9ioutom Let me guess you think getting conned is a scapegoat. Sorry but you blinder than a bat. This video is not meant to justify fascism but to show even we need to stick together and not be divided or what happened to Germany could happen to us. This is really the average man was fed propaganda all the time by the Nazis. You realize that in the context of the time there was no internet or any fast ways of communication besides radios and landlines. So really you had to take them at their word that and mainly because goeballs would overpower other parties.
_"You see, we human beings are not born with prejudices. Always they are made for us, made by someone who wants something. Remember that when you hear this kind of talk. Somebody's going to get something out of it, and it isn't going to be you."_
Hot Damn. Way to call-out 21st century bullshit, 1947.
"Racism isn't born, it's taught. My son's 2 years old, you know what he hates? Naps. End of list." - Dennis Leary.
I'm showing my 11 year old this video today,to show her that history will repeat itself.. looking in the mirror of the past to today.
Be Safe...
Guys this is literally government propaganda from the 40s designed to make the public think a certain way and you’re internalizing it. Racial awareness is not taught; it’s learned. Often through experience. Like after the tenth time you’re beaten in the streets by a black or Mexican gang you learn that the 40s propaganda was a lie.
@@peachnehi8683 A person who experienced that should be anti-gang or anti-crime. Instead, that normal hatred of injustice has been twisted in some to becoming anti-black and anti-Mexican even though most blacks and Mexicans are innocent of those crimes, just as most whites are. The race of a perp has become this person’s focus instead of the perp’s character. Instead of “I hate criminals who beat me up” he thinks “I hate blacks, I hate Mexicans”. It’s a gut reaction, a trick of the brain to protect him by putting the biggest wall possible between him and the danger. If, his brain says, “all blacks or all Mexicans are dangerous”, it’s easier to put his walls up to protect himself. He doesn’t have to get close enough to a person to work out their CHARACTER and know if they are dangerous, he can see their colour or race from a distance and take steps. All racism is derived from fear and the brain’s attempt to deal with that fear in the simplest most complete way possible: A black man hurt you? Avoid all black men from now on. Try to reduce their power to hurt you in the future by suppressing them or expelling them. All of them, because you don’t know who the bad ones are. That’s how the racist brain thinks. It’s simple and effective, if you have the power. Which the Nazi’s did.
Biology disagrees with you but ok
I wrote a paper in highschool, early 2000s, about how Hitler and Mussolini subverted their governments to take power. I closed the essay out with a paragraph about it makes one think how we could lose our democracy in America. My teacher wrote underneath, "That can never happen in America, we have checks and balances!" with a smiley face. I'm pretty sure she didn't read the paper, I think she just checked to see if we wrote the citations correctly and used at least 3 different books and one newspaper article. Pretty sure she told us everything on the internet is made up too.
It would’ve been ironic if one of the books you used was it can’t happen here by Sinclair Lewis.
Americans don't have democracy, their elected representatives have democracy. Don't be a sucker
The student surpasses the teacher.
Did everybody clap?
@@shroomer8294 Lol you beat me to it.
I about came to tears when the man started ripping up the pamphlet. Very powerful. We must all stay together as one. We will never be a minority if we remember this..
That’s because you are easily manipulated and some how felt emotion watching American propaganda lmao
@@ironfist4457 Saying negative things to strangers on the Internet does not make you look intelligent or superior. Propaganda or not, it’s a good message. You’re one of the people that backed away in the video.
@@dreameater9247 Is it really a good message though or good fantasy? Have you looked at the state of your country? The guy yelling with the pamphlet was right. It’s not even America anymore, it’s not even the west. The idea of America being a “melting pot” was never even introduced until after WWII ended and society has slowly started to fall ever since. And gee I wonder who has been pushing a one world agenda for hundreds of years, it couldn’t have been the poor people we let out of camps who happened to also be in all of the Allies political structure during the war and that currently have more representation in our government and American elites than they did in Russia during Stalins Soviet era. I’m not trying to degrade you or insult you, but seriously wake up. Read more. Think outside of the box about why the Western Hemisphere is in shambles. The fingers all point back to one people. The same people who own Blackrock, Vangard, and everything that you know and love from the media you’ve enjoyed, the products you’ve consumed, and more than likely the people you’ve looked up to. They have always been implementing the ideas of the current downfall into our minds, they’ve just dumbed everyone down enough to do it more openly now and sold it to the people as being “progressive”. Remember Weimar? Or are you unaware of what was being orchestrated in Weimar by the “chosen people”. The world is not sunshine and flowers. Some realities are harsh, and one of those harsh realities is that maybe we have been lied to for a long time and are currently being lied to.
@@ironfist4457found a fascist.
why dont you put on the armband already maga fascist
@@ironfist4457 People who defend f@scism are desperately searching for a boot to lick.
This film honestly aged really well. It's almost as if it was produced yesterday.
Because they are running the same psychological operation on the people today!
They don’t tell you about central banking and unplayable debt that we’re put on German people.
The pornography and transgenderism put on the Germans by liberal 🇮🇱. When they burned books ,it was books pushing that typ of propaganda!
The topic is as relevant today as it was in the past. Fascism has been on the rise for several years already, the wish of many conservatives to turn the clock back to the time "when everything was so much better" for "us", but not for all people.The MAGA movement in other words.
@@Yeggman communism and fascism are different sides of the same coin!
There both on the tyranny spectrum!
@@Yeggman Wow, people still believe that tyranny is started by people who want to limit government power. Unreal. Tyrants always want big government. Idk if it's lack of intelligence or brainwashing
Today we have far-right lunatics who label everyone who disagrees with them conspiracy theorists or nazis or anti-vaxxers. We are ruled by the interests of huge corrupt corporations, pure fascism.
I was coming in expecting something like the "identifying communists" PSAs of the 60s, but not only does this all make sense from a modern lens, it still completely holds up to today's standards. Way to go, 1947!
Keep your antennas up.
They were lucid for a few years, but then they wanted to go back to before the war.
Strange how people always attempt to slide back into their old ways after a great awakening. Its been documented since the plagues
@@sandshark2 Unfortunately yeah, that’s just the nature of human beings as a whole
Yes it's a very gay video
The post WW2 era was very BASED. There was a lot of sense during that time after so much life lost. People woke up to the reality of war worldwide the cost it has. Not to mention the depression.
"There are no other people in this country, only American people." What an amazing line, and one needed to be said more often.
Not anymore we believed that lie and it was useful until 2020 now it’s open season on certain people, and we get it. I never deployed but my kids won’t join or be drafted America is done with us so let the ones who benefit from it’s existence fight for Israel.
I see now. Every person on American soil then becomes an American. Now I get it!
Watches a propaganda film. Doesn’t grasp the concept it’s a propaganda film
@@okayz00mer11 Is it propaganda to tell a kids that washing their hands is good for them? Just admit you like the n*zi's, man.
@@okayz00mer11 ^^ Doesn’t grasp the concept that it’s warning us against harmful and persuasive ideologies
I will link this for the next 4 years it would seem.
I will not go gentle into the goodnight.
*Braaaaaaaaaaaaaap* *Braaaaaaaaaaap* *PHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHBTT*
Rage against the dying of the light!
"Remember when you hear this kind of talk. Someone is going to get something out of this. And it won't be you."
What a great quote.
Republican Party in a nutshell
I like the part when he points out how cowardly and barbaric it was that they went into other countries without first making a formal declaration of wore.
Exactly!
@@drew8570fed
Wow, as a US citizen I was concerned. Now I am terrified. My dad who fought in World War II must be rolling in his grave
@@jasongorr3975 Something something “I don’t know why we are stopping at Berlin, when we all know the enemy lies further beyond.” - Some history dude circa 1945.
What was most profound for me was how many times they mentioned that the people needed to be separated before the nazis could have power. And it doesn’t take long to think of similarities in our current government.
@@jasongorr3975 found the sucker
@@SvenDzahov said the guy who believes what he was spoon fed in middle school by the state
@@SvenDzahov you must be looking in the mirror pal
"And Hans, who was going to rule the world, got only a little patch of Normandy."
Damn, cold line. 15:23
Relevant.
"First they came for the Communists, and I did not speak out- Because I was not a Communist.
Then they came for the Socialists, and I did not speak out- Because I was not a Socialist.
Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out- Because I was not a trade unionist.
Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out- Because I was not a Jew.
Then they came for me, and there was no one left to speak out for me."
Martin Niemöller
We are clearly regressing into a collective state of mind where this film bounces back from appearing quaint to feeling acutely relevant and effective. /:
aka be a racist zionist sucker
it's not an issue relegated to left or right in my opinion, but this polarizing behavior is typical of modern politics now. especially in Eastern Europe, but also present in the West.
@@whitewolf6605 Antifa & BLM & Democrats are the fascist of today
@@whitewolf6605 it's wild how clueless both sides are. you are just as much of a pawn as the extreme liberals. the only difference between you and them is that their proposed bills aren't oppressive. have fun with your great replacement you fascist weirdo.
@@whitewolf6605 nice try adolf. I see you
Here is one quote that I will now be using on a daily basis…
“Somebody is going to get something out of it… and it isn’t going to be you.”
Basically BLM leaders getting tons of money and mansions while normal black people get nothing.
You can really say that about most ststems of Gov. Facism grew out of the great depression when the whole world had been ripped off with the aid of democracy
The country was ripped off from greed
@nickjohnson3619 lol
@@Analwreckage Found the Fascist sucker.
I could never have imagined America could produce such a sensible and virtuous video so long ago in 1947. Makes me think that past isn't necessarily a more naive perspective.
Sadly the Democrat Party has used the Nazi tactic of Identity Politics to divide America
It's frightening that the Democrat Party have brought Nazism back to life
Yup, and did you also notice that the narrator mentioned America's greatest strength, almost in passing... People of all religions and skin colors together as Americans, living free. Three-quarters of a century later, and I think we are the ones with the naive perspective.
To think so would be naive…
It's from the generation that fought and defeated actual Nazis. They had more sense and virtue. People today are more concerned about nothing while the US government is trying to become fascist under the guise of "more inclusive".
If you're a young person I'm very happy you've realized. If so you are truly maturing and that's something to commend you on 👍👍
Pay attention, people. Many of the comments indicate that the division is happening again.
Happening again? It's been ongoing since the dawn of the cold war and corporate war profiteering ... Left vs right, whites against minorities, the threat of the "lazy poor", the war on people who want to do drugs to escape it all ...
It's just a gigantic "us vs them" circus ...
If I was an advanced alien species or an interdimensional/time traveler I would laugh at it all. But seeing as how I can't leave and need to live here, it's just a ridiculous nightmare to have to endure until I die.
As it should. Everything the fascist warned about; happened or is happening. These propaganda pieces brainwashed millions. The West is dying, and globalist imperialism will swallow up and enslave the world.
i love ur pfp
I think this film needs to be shown over and over again all over the media. People need to be reminded of it's important message. Unfortunately we are seeing history repeat itself.
The media will NEVER show this as it goes against their narrative
Thanks to rightwingers.
This looks like the Biden administration and MSM tactics used today to divide the nation .
No the right is trying to separate us, but we're more together than they believe...
As a "right winger", I'll happily have an open discussion with any of you. If you're willing to keep it civil.
Even in this film, we see that it only takes 30 seconds for the man to fire up, disillusion, and trick the crowd into racism and false information. Yet it took a whole 16 minutes for the film to provide the truth and better judgement.
Truly shows that “A Lie Can Travel Halfway Around the World Before the Truth Puts On its Shoes” -Mark Twain.
Fun fact: Mark Twain didn’t say this quote but is often falsely attributed to it.
I see what you did there
Great observation, so many misconceptions remain even to this day from lies or errors made ages ago. We all tend to believe things far easier if it fits our preconceived world view or if said by someone we trust.
Negative Word of Mouth spreads 11x faster than positive WOM
You can sway a thousand men by appealing to their prejudices quicker than you can convince one man by logic.
Robert A. Heinlein, Revolt in 2100/Methuselah's Children
Twain is often quoted and like Will Rogers always had smart things to say that were on the mark.
Whether he said that quote or not, let him have it.
“I’ve heard this sort of talk before, but I never expected to hear it in America.” It is telling how this video reflects on us today.
time for some paradigm breaking revelations - the history of eurocentric culture is just different parts of europe doing the same general things. consolidating wealth, enslaving the world, pretending they own the world and feeling entitled to any wealth anyone else might be able to generate. the excuses they give themselves to justify these behaviors are nearly identical too. just replace the name of the country and their past will be filled with little more than copious slaughter and unnecessary suffering. turns out, when you let psychopaths direct society, it turns into a bloodlust murderfest. every single time. because they will go to any length to protect their stolen, undue power.
I think negro hating was invented in America.
But at that period in history the black in the USA were treated like the jews in nazi germany
I just realized... I think that guy's German. He's talking about Nazi speeches... Wow.
100% MAGA Trump message.
Oh hey look! A movie made in 1947 is showing Americans PLAY BY PLAY what a jackass would do to incite hateful scumbags. Welcome your new president.
Astonishing to see an old educational film that doesn't just seem like half-baked claptrap and actually makes a damn good point instead, and one that chillingly still holds up at that.
Nah this film is total garbage and not educational in the least
@@redacted428 How so? I found it interesting, and educational. Well presented, good music, and a good insight into fascist ideology. It was a bit naive about how free America was given they were still in the segregated south era though.
You sir are susceptible to outdated propaganda!
@@edgarwalk5637 oh, Redacted is just a butthurt Trumper.
@@edgarwalk5637 an earlier commenter said it best "This was a Warner Brothers film produced by Jack Warner in 1943, a notorious communist sympathizer. This same year, Warner Brothers made the film Mission To Moscow, in which the plot was essentially a US ambassador visits Moscow, realizes that all the negative things he hears about Stalin was untrue, he meets Stalin, and realizes he's a great leader and a kind man, and the film degrades to even showing actual footage of Stalin's late 1930's show trials with a narrator who supports the trials as justice against "fifth columnists", even though these trials were nothing more than made up charges and confessions derived from brutal NKVD torture sessions, and almost always resulted in the execution of one of the thousands of people Stalin perceived as a threat.
Seems as though you might be the 'sucker". Either that, or you're a Marxist, which would still leave observers to the same conclusion that you're a "sucker"."
Jack Warner interestingly enough was also a polish Jew
_“First they came for the Communists, and I did not speak out-because I was not a Communist._
_“Then they came for the Socialists, and I did not speak out-because I was not a Socialist._
_“Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out-because I was not a trade unionist._
_“Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out-because I was not a Jew._
_“Then they came for me-and there was no one left to speak for me.”_
-Martin Niemöller (1946), Adolf Hitler's “Personal Prisoner” of Dachau.
So well said 👏
THE MAGA NAZIS ARE COMING FOR THE SOCIALISTS AND THE UNIONISTS AND THE NON-CHRISTIANS, IT'S HAPPENING RIGHT HERE, RIGHT NOW!
Hoax
@@jpbefree Fun fact: 75% of American adults possess the literacy level of 6th-graders (11-year-olds) or less - 21% of Americans are functionally illiterate.
Thank you for providing proof of that statistic.
_“I love the poorly educated.”_ -Donald J Trump (2016)
Welcome to the _stupidest party_ in America: the _Repuglican_ Party-the *Stupid Peoples’ Party.*
Sad thing is, this still holds true today. If a struggle of people doesn't affect me, then I don't care and don't concern myself with it. Only when they come for me, I start to speak out. People then get a sense of, well, if you don't help to fix the problem, then you must be by default part of the problem. It's easy then to look at others as the "enemy". It's a sad thing to witness.
That was a 1947 educational film, and to be honest, it scared the hell out of me because it is so relevant to what is going on today in 2023.
yep, the same Jews who made this drivel are spewing forth their anti-white garbage today.
I loved how the film pointed out that fascism is a derivative of georges sorel's socialism, and national socialism is a branch of socialism, and communism is a branch of socialism
also I liked how the film differentiated between people illegally invading another country, and legal citizens who actually belong to that country
and I loooooooooooove how it pointed out that nazi germany had some of the first hate speech legislation in history (polish people aren't allowed to talk bad about germans)
really makes you think
Yeah seriously, everything the guy said about Jews, Catholics, and Freemasons is so on point even today. Wish they did something about that back then.
I found the fascist -> @@ApprovedOpinions
@@ApprovedOpinions Hitler tried.
I can repeat the same things as other commenters (i.e. “We should show this in schools!” “We need this film now more than ever” “We haven’t learned”) but I think you’ve already read enough of them if you’ve found my comment.
I’m tired. I’m not even an adult and I’m tired. I feel like despite all my hard work and effort, this world just wants to see me burn. I don’t understand how people can be so mean. I genuinely don’t get where people get off by villainizing minorities and other groups, and then say “well I’m a [insert political party here] and I think it’s the [opposite political party]’s fault that the world is broken and we’re all suffering from their greed and evil.” I don’t give a flying F about what political ideology you follow. I think we can all agree that politicians and politics in general are evil.
What I’m tired of is having my right to be a (living) person debated by a bunch of people I don’t know and didn’t vote for. I’m way too young to be worrying about my life. And before you go on a triad of “oh boo hoo you little snowflake. Quit crying about it and get to work!” I am working. I’m focused on staying ALIVE. I’m trying not to get jumped in the street by a bunch of people who would rather I go away because I’m of a certain minority. I just want to live.
I know you're tired. You're not alone. I'm tired too. I've been fighting for human rights and equality for 50 years. I feel like Sisyphus, everyday pushing that boulder up a hill and everyday having it roll back down. But remember, toiling to push the rock is only torture if you don't find meaning in the work. I've been doing this for a long time and every day I am able to help someone. However small a token of aid, it helps. Telling someone they're not alone helps. Connecting someone with a community that supports them helps. Changing one heart about one issue helps. And that's where I find meaning. There are millions of us who still dream of an America that isn't controlled by Nazis. Today we mourn, tomorrow we organize. We build our communities, we give support to each other, we stay resistant and resilient, we plant our feet and we push back. We are only 18 months from the midterms and if we can show that the future is better when we aren't subservient to a steaming pile of narcissistic feces then we can take back Congress and cut this fascist movement off at the knees.
Yes, things suck now. Things always suck, but it's what we do about it that matters. So do something about it.
@ that means a whole lot to me. Truly. I can’t imagine just how much you’ve seen in 50 years-that has to be A LOT!
I know I should find meaning in the little things, keep myself going as long as possible. I’ve been trying. I don’t plan on letting the fascists outlive me. (Imagine how funny the internet will be when that happens?)
Thank you again for your kind words. I hope that wherever you are, you have a pleasant day and find happiness in every moment!
@@youruniquehandle2you have no idea how much I needed to hear that. You've proven your words with your actions, and the message is clear. Thank you very much!
I’m saving to buy land north of where I live now in Maine and go completely off the grid. Maybe we can start an egalitarian commune
Imagine how disappointed people in the 1940s would be if we went back and told them that this kind of film is still needed in the 2020s.
Indeed, you got Far Left Progressives causing the Culture War and trying to basically fight racism with more racism and some of them trying to make things so "safe" and non offensensive it's restricting,and rarely trying to find the middle ground, and some essentially causing mindless violance and chaos as seen by the horrific 2020 riots and just going into ideas that are so disturbing and morally wrong, and you got some on the Right trying to counter that chaos, but sometimes they go a little too strict on laws. One side causes chaos and occasionally censors thing, one tries to bring too much order, we got the parties going for the most extremes rather then trying to find something that works for most people. Thus both sides implement some elements of Fascism.
How is it needed nowadays when the world nowadays tells us we need the opposite?
Imagine how disappointed people in the 40's would be if they realized that there were people dumb enough in 2023 to watch this schlocky and banal 1943 war propaganda film made by Warner Brothers, which was written by an actual communist (who 10 years later was brought up on charges by House un-American committee's), and think that it was "needed". You know what other propaganda film Warmer Brothers made that same year in 1943? Mission To Moscow. I'll save you the time of laying out the plot (you can watch it since you're so enamored with pro-Marxist, anti-Christian propaganda), but its main points were pointing out what a great man and leader Josef Stalin was, and how happy people were in the Soviet Union under communism. Meanwhile, also in 1943, the Germans found the mass graves of over 20,000 Poles who were executed in mass graves, killed by the barbaric Soviet NKVD. Your own government knew the truth, and still lied to you and blamed the deaths on the Germans, all while producing pro Soviet films from Warner Brothers. It took 50 years for the US govt to admit the truth that it wasn't the Germans, which is still less time than it took to learn the lies about illegally arming the civilian passenger ship Lusitania.
This will never end
@@jackprecip5389 lmao ikr it is so shocking both sides committed war crimes not really governments are all shady ALL OF THEM ARE
I watched these films in basic training in the Army. I tell you it really strikes a nerve. Watch as many of these PSA films as you can. Because the message never changes.
@@miro6017 yep,....the message never changes, but you still didn't get it.
When was the Army still showing these old timey films? I thought they stopped showing these in the 80's?
@@miro6017 ...so why should the OP 'get help'?
@@mlauer the "op" 😂. Yeah like those wmds or bin laden threatened our right vote like he could penetrate the two party dictatorship so easily.
@@miro6017 ...why are you so certain the OP is a bot? Seems to me you're not to bright if you urging a bot to get help.
Damn this anti-racist film from 1947 is better than 99% of anti-racist ads in 2023
Edit: how the hell did this comment I made 2 months ago blow up?????
Yup
Anti-racist ads today are racist lol.
"F*CK YOU WHITEY!"
because its actually in support of freedom
That’s because it was presumably written by people who don’t live in a bubble.
@@Mr.Selyumorwow that a recent comment
Well we didn’t learn anything
Came right to this video three weeks ago huh? Yeah, it's been on my mind since then as well. 😅
More the economic inequalities within societies , more are the chances of history repeating itself
You didn't, I did. I didn't just learn I lived it , you should be terrified if somebody work money can target you and try and make you suffer, that's also a monopoly a dictator, I didn't do dictator s I can govern myself
Exactly
You have not yet.
The grave at Normandy while the rain falls is a pretty powerful image.
“...and Hans, who was going to rule the world, got only a little patch of Normandy that he could call his own.”
@@dauntless0711 that part really hurted
@masterofmycoc Got that right !!! Should have Showed Eisenhower the latest "WAP from Cardi B" video & he would have scuttled his own fleet !!!
@masterofmycoc I'd be more worried about my family dying when the Axis invaded and preventing that, do you think our ancestors were cowards or something? that they'd cower in fear because of a change you can't accept?
The world is an evolving changing place, old men like you are what kill armies because they can't adapt and think the world is always going to move at their pace.
Grow or get run over.
@masterofmycoc Your arguments here contradict themselves, you claim to argue for the founders, but look down on the founder's ideals. The founders were anti-authoritarian, you argue that songs and videos should be consored by authorities. You only decry autorotarianism when its a power figure you disagree with. When the first executive order enacting gun control, banning bump stocks, was signed by Trump you said nothing. You don't care about freedom or decency, just control.
The ending monologue at 15:27 is *chef's kiss*
Perfect way to end this knowledgable video. People talk about 'minorities' as if they're not a part of one, but literally _EVERYONE_ is a minority in one way or another-it doesn't have to be in race, sex, origin or religion. A threat to any minority spreads as a threat to _all_ of them. Just like MLK said: _"Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere."_
The problem is that some minorities are persecuted more than others. White Americans have been threatening and oppressing the freedom of Black Americans for centuries despite whatever "minority" group they come from.
Absolutely💙💜💚🇺🇸
It's for this reason that I believe very strongly in the principles of individualism. The individual is the ultimate minority after all...
didnt murica tortured the blacks right after ww2 even after they fought against the confederates and nazis?
@@pepelepew1227 isolated incidents aren't representative. the british and french ended the slave trade. look up the true story of 'the woman king' its a good lesson on reality and on how the media lies to u. and u can't trust mainstream anything. do some research on who actually controlled the slave trade. it was mostly joos.
Literally everything in this video can be re-contextualized for today. Extremely unsettling.
@blakethomas5637 the difference is at 4:20 when the Hungarian immigrant said that he is now an American and a U.S. Citizen. He assimilated into American society.
@@jamesjacobs5722Who is failing to integrate into American society at present?
Shows how much we haven’t learned nothing from history
@jamesjacobs5722 bro probably spoke Hungarian most the time, ate hungarian food, practiced Hungarian culture etc....
@@austinwilkerson84I love how this myth of “there are good ones, and there are bad ones.” That seems to persist. So easy to see through the ruse, but there are a lot of very impressionable people out there that fall for it. Truly sad to see.
It's good the older man had the guts to speak to the younger man. I wish I could talk as eloquently. Great message!
"if those people had stood together, they could have protected each other"
They did and they tried but USA invaded them
“A little patch of Normandy, that he could call his own.” That’s priceless.
They call it "educational" in the title. But let's not forget what propaganda is. Watch what they do to the language
well, i would say the price was his life.
@@clichepepycan7370 . I found the fascist.
@@alenparker3056then you have no place in America
@@alenparker3056 based
As an Indian, watching this is petrifying because the government here in India is literally following the Nazi Playbook step by step.
How so?
That’s alarming. Stay safe friend.
@@SonnyD223Basically, Modi is doing this whole Indian nationalism thing and has been supporting Muslim hate groups as India has lots of Muslims and they are often target by Hindus. And many of these hate groups are similar to the Nazis due to their nationalistic spirit and hateful ideas towards Muslims. And unfortunately, many people fall into them and hate towards Muslims is increasing in India and like in the film, Modi is simply dividing people up into groups so he can gain political support
Same with the government in Iran
@@Theonetrueerenyeagerhow is Iran government
This is why Nazism was dispised by the majority of people back then. Cause they just lived through it. This is the best anti Nazi film I've seen. It sucks how history is trying to repeat itself. It's easier to point the finger at someone else for your problems then to take responsibility for them yourself.
And yet today, Hitler is still idolized. It's Tragic
@@davenewsom5985there is a video where hitlers speeches were translated by AI and the amount of “he’s actually right though” makes me depressed to be a history nerd.
@@Mate-vg2ft So much for 'Never Forget'. 😔
_"you see, we human beings are not born with prejudices. Always they are made for us, made by someone who wants something. Remember that when you hear this kind of talk. somebody is going to get something out of it, and it isn't going to be you."_
true.
It's at 4:58 if anyone wants to hear it!
False. We still be simpler beings without complex socialpsychological processes (e.g., prejudices). I know this is a harsh reality, but true regardless. Read into evolutionary and social psychology.
@@ThomasMueller999 human beings are born with prejudices, you are afraid of the dark, you are afraid of heights. things you don't understand can harm you, so it's built in to protect you as a defense mechanism
safety until you can comprehend, and move away from prejudice with experience and knowledge
@@ihatecrackhead precisely.
@@ihatecrackhead Being afraid of the dark or cautious around heights isn't prejudice, especially in the context of this quote, lol.
This should be mandatory to be shown in schools. Especially with todays political climate
Thanks for the likes!
It's pretty obvious that the US is not striving to educate its citizens. Little to no curriculum discussing journalistic integrity, propaganda, or critical thinking.
Mandatory = Freedom ?
It would get labeled as "woke propaganda" and banned 🙄
Too late. Public education is now run by communists
I didn't recognize this psa at first. But I remember that the teens react channel had a video from 2017 after Charlottesville.
RIP Prof Boszormenyi who fled Hungary for another country and became a teacher to many other people. I had a better upbringing also because of you.
An awful lot of suckers in America tonight.
Damn right
Usually they’re people who tout about wanting socialism and equality when they have no actual solution or realistic way of approaching that kind of an outcome
@ angry troll is angry
Degenerate alert.🚨
It's pretty progressive for the era it was made in considering it's also subtly opposing racism
i dont think they are progressive, i think we (the majority) are simply not progressive enough
Subtly? The whole thing is about being against racism and how racism brings fascism
Also considering the nazis were inspired by American eugenics
@@FirstLast-bo7ef Most people are pretty accepting. It's the few that make the rest seem unnacepting or stupid.
@@mannyverse6158 notice how they didn't overtly say "hey maybe negros should be allowed to sit in front!" Back in a time where expressing that view does need to be spelled out.
"You see - we human beings are not born with prejudices. Always, they are made for us. Made by someone who wants something. Remember that when you hear this kind of talk. Somebody is going to get something out of it; and it isn't going to be you."
Damn.
Pretty much. I mean as a kid, I treated each new kid like a new friend. It's hard to keep that through adulthood. Or harder still to revive it. I try. Some days I'm better than others. I think we should celebrate our differences, but that doesn't mean we should do so based on heuristics like the color of our skin or our gender. So what if you're a woman, can you pass the physical? Then you're in. Who cares if you're black, do you have the education? You're in. White? Male? Do you have the qualifications? In. Otherwise come back when you've got yourself sorted. I'm of the political party that says trans/gays shouldn't be picked on... but I personally don't recognize more than two genders. The republicans kind of left me to do some weird fight against drag queens. Drag queens aren't a problem. Nut jobs shooting up schools might be a problem. I disagree with Dems on abortion and boys changing in girls locker rooms. I disagree with Reps on... well Jan 6th-style thinking and ignoring Covid. I just don't know what happened to my America. Everyone went extra crazy after Covid. Just accept each other's strengths instead of picking at each other's weaknesses.
"Always they are made for us" Yep! Made for us by propaganda like this video.
@@mugsofmirth8101 Read about the paradox of intolerance put forth by Karl Popper
@@mugsofmirth8101 ? how is this propaganda ?
whos making money from you ?
or do you mean knowledge is propaganda ?
which sounds kind of backwards ..
are you backwards ? or just a putin boy ?🥃
'Jhayynaa.. Mexicans.. They bring rapists, criminals, drugs.. them.. their people!' - *Donald J Trump*
This should be shown on every news station in Anerica. People need to be reminded as the " Greatest Generation" that fought this horror dies.
I also want to remind you that the Americans didn't join because of the holocaust. They didn't join to fight the Nazis. They joined because they were attacked. Not because of some ideal. Most people had no idea what was going on anyway. So do not tell me they went to war to end the holocaust. They didn't.
@Cloud Seeker All true, but those soldiers saw and experienced the horror of that war. NEVER AGAIN.
@@chiggins4399 So? You are saying they went to war to stop it. They didn't. That was a lie. That they found out that the issue was much more serious does not actually make what you said true.
The "greatest generations" witnessed evil for sure. But they did not go to war to end it. So do not lie about them.
There's a reason the news doesn't show this
Right, the hypocritical heroes who didn't believe in the rights of women and people with different skin colors. Makes sense
The age old mantra, divide and conquer has always been the playbook of the Ruling Class.
"Illinois Nazis...."
"I hate Illinois Nazis!"
I love blues brothers. That's my dad's favorite movie
Funny how it was generally uncontroversial to hate Nazis when "The Blues Brothers" was released. Now, the right wing would complain about the "Dems" curtailing the freedum of the Illinois Nazis.
@@HeathWatts you seem to want to lump "the right" as a group with no derivation in ideals and lable them all fascist and/or fascist apologizers. That seems close to Mccarthyism, just using fascism as the blame instead of communism. And the government coming down to imprison people for there beliefs (which Mccarthyism did) is fascist. So don't be a sucker and fall for that.
@@maxfinazzo2443 Not all right wingers are fascist, but all fascists are right wingers. It's the definition. That said, capitalism, the rich, and the right wing benefit from fascism.
@@HeathWatts I don't see how capitalism benefits from fascism. The only corporations that benefit are the ones that the government nationalizes in the name of the country/ethnicity/race. Any seemingly successful business is run out/given to a member of the fascist regime. In Nazi Germany, any successful business run by a jewish person would either be shut down or run into the ground by a german who has no idea how to run that business. I can see how some of the right benefit from fascism, being that fascism is right wing, but it wouldn't benefit any right winger who isn't fascist. Any libertarian capitalist who doesn't want the government to run his business is screwed. And, of course, any rich people who aren't part of the regime will have their wealth taken away. So only certain rich people benefit. To clarify, I hate fascism. I am not defending it. But I am a right winger, in the sense that I am a libertarian capitalist type. My argument is that fascism only benefits fascists, and the vast majority of right wingers have more in common with democrats than fascists. I'm sure the left, with stalinism is in the same boat, but I'm not a leftist, so I don't know.
I enjoy listening to 1940's era narrators. The voices of a bygone era.
That's exactly what I thought first when the video started. The narrator's voice is incredibly well trained and professional. Just like in the old movies. Today you can't hear such voices anymore, sad to say.
@@Butziwackel
That mid-Atlantic accent has been replaced by the more American basic, which sounds closest to the mid-west accent.
I sure don't miss the lady's singing voice from that era. Replay some Bioshock if you disagree.😄 Awful!
Yeah and they talked to you like a human being and not as a demographic group on a chart.
Yes. Excellent enunciation and I love the phrasing/emotion too. Almost impossible to misunderstand- even form a distance. Something to strive for!!!
That's actually a really well done film, and absolutely relevant even today.
Yup! Antifa spouting off intolerance and hate
@@mtlicq Yup you're absolutely right it's the people with zero power who are the problem lol.
Relevant today because this propaganda needs constant reinforcement because unlike the left would have you believe in group preference isn't learned it's deeply engrained in our biology. If they ever take their foot off the gas the 5% of the world that's not racist will immediately revert....and they can't have that while there is still wealth to exploit and infrastructure to process the third world through.
This film was literally made at a time when the USA was subject to strict racial segregation, racism was no less than in the Nazi Germany, people were discriminated against on the basis of their faith or origin, and the dominant and most influential group were white, Anglo-Saxon Protestants, while Catholics, Negroes and other groups were subjected to harassment. Freedom of speech and personal freedoms existed only in theory, in practice prejudice was common. This film is just a propaganda bullshit commissioned by the US War Department, which was supposed to encourage Americans to fight against Germany.
@@michaoborodo931 I think they are more saying that America has so much freedom to run home the point that fascism has no freedom. This film is post world war II. They aren't fighting Germany they are fighting fascism. Even if some things are wrong or outdated, They did a pretty damn good job with the things they got right.
In 2024, this 1947 film still speaks to me.
yea? whats it sayin? that youre a gullible jew lover who hates questioning why his country is going to shit?
This is communist propaganda btw. Written by Richard Collins the member of the CPUSA
Yes the same lies are pushed today
@@lildonnie7607you mean like multiculturalism is our strength lmfao or any of the other obvious reasons.
*(Democrats, socialist, communist, Marxist, Liberals, Progressives, the left) have a long history of evil insanity.*
An educational film that applies so amply today. How quickly the lessons of the past are forgotten today.
Don't be daft , no one learned any lessons.
@@FreshGreenMoss And that is why we are repeating the same scenario over and over again. Enslavement of the mind and spirit through dictatorial forms of governmental and social control keep us in an endless loop of repeating this same play. The communist and fascist totalitarian gamebook divides the WE into "us and them", makes the past evil, and promises a better tomorrow if we just walk down the primrose trail. Isn't that what we see today, divisions between races, religions and genders. There are horrendous events in every nations past. There is not one nation that doesn't have innocent blood on their hands. We SHOULD learn from the past. We SHOULD be a WE. Listening to the rhetoric of those who are claiming to be "woke" are essentially, the same characters portraited in this film creating division. The prophet nailed it when he said "Come now, and let us reason together,' says the Lord."
Well when parents don't keep track of what's getting taught in schools then the government decides to leave these sort of things out...
@@cyemonkey1828 Agreed. One positive, though small, is that some parents got a quick reality check on what was being taught.
Today we have far-right lunatics who label everyone who disagrees with them conspiracy theorists or nazis or anti-vaxxers. We are ruled by the interests of huge corrupt corporations, pure fascism.
"Your right to belong to a minority is a precious thing"
Never forget that, people. Celebrate the things that makes us differ, defend the rights of every minority.
In the end, we're all minorities in one way or another.
I do. And I like it too. ❤
I’ve been trying to tell people this for so long ….and when I say it, I get nothing but a bunch of dumb looks😵💫🫤😖
And the most powerless minority of all is the single individual.
The problem is people are defending the rights of habitual criminals above law abiding citizens.
@@Kenneth-ts7bpand who are these criminals?
It saddens me to see that we seem to have forgotten these lessons so many years later.
Lessons? This is a cheesy war propaganda film made by Warner Brothers in 1943 (reissued in 1947 with a few minor edits). Warner Bros. made another war propaganda film in 1943 called Mission To Moscow, a longer form fictional film where Josef Stalin is portrayed as a great leader, and the people in the Soviet Union are portrayed as living happily under communism. Sadly, you're so far gone, you'd probably really think that was full of "lessons" also.
@@jackprecip5389 I was thinking the same and am happy to see your comment. Did not see many like it
@@jackprecip5389 we get it your a nazi and you dont like anti-fascist shit. get over yourself and become a better person
@@jackprecip5389 So because Stalinist communism was bad, you think Nazis were good? At the time, without communist Russia, we would not have defeated Hitler.
@@jackprecip5389 Look up the term "logical fallacy," and reexamine your statement.
Im not saying all propaganda is cool, but we would've greatly benefitted as a society if they made us all watch this in school.
The people who made the propaganda for Reagan, ie Lee Atwater, saw these sorts of films as they grew up. They took those lessons and began with paring the Tree of Party Politics in the 1980s. Lee Atwater , before he died, apologized to the American people for undermining the system.
Thank folks who saw these films then ran riot with their "messages" for the antediluvian policies created from them.
tribalism is real, race is real.
I dont need "prejudges" to be pro white intrest.
Yall are sooo f*cking dumb its unbearable.
Yea, but then people would start yelling about, "Communism being taught in our schools!" or something equally bizarre and inaccurate :/
It was taught. It’s why the entirety of the west is descending into a great darkness now.
@@lioncross1849 This short film about how Nazi's are bad and divide populations from within is... bad?
THIS is the America I support: one that supports freedom for all, whether black or white or religious or not, one that doesn't ban books, one that preserves rights for every minority, and one that accepts that we're all minorities in the bigger, singular majority: American.
its .....a propaganda reel. Read your history, in this exact period the US was banning things and discriminating like no bodies business.
@@BazzBrother True! You're exactly right! We were banning things, and that was totally wrong! But the ideal was what I said earlier, the ideal! What we were striving for, what we believed to be, etc. Were we perfect? No, not at all. But we WERE getting better. That's the America I want to see continue.
@@BazzBrother The US is a funny way of saying the south.
Too bad that america is only a fantasy. As a little child I thought US was actually a nice place but after decades of learning about it i know its shithole with a nice coat of paint on it.
@@BazzBrother The U.S. was improving, heading in the right direction, expanding rights, until the Reagan administration. Just because we hadn't arrived there yet, don't bash a time when people still wanted to. Now we're racing in the wrong direction.
edit: Our foreign policy was as awful then as it is now though.
Who have we become? Have we learned nothing in the last 76 years. I cried watching this because my father was the son of a poor Italian immigrant and he fought in the Normandy invasion. A war so horrible that it was said those atrocities could never again happen. But here we are. We have become those deluded people we fought against in the name of freedom and liberty. We must find it in our hearts to love one another and have compassion for those who struggle to simply be recognized and heard as equal and not less. And who are trapped in poverty by an unfair and divisive system. Our great country too can fall if we choose to avoid speaking out against inequity and hatred and place blame rather than take responsibility for being part of a more important whole than ourselves. Our future and our children's future literally depend on us finding love in our hearts for each other, our neighbors, and our beautiful planet. Peace, Love and Blessings to all.
The someone that wants something is the NWO/WEF. The hatred and inequity is caused by them and always has been
There is no equality with equity
You lost me at equity. America doesn't need socialism BLM bullshit etc.. equity brings everyone down to the same level, doesn't boost anyone up. My grandfather was also a poor immigrant. He got blown off a ship in the Pacific when a Zero crashed right next to him. He would agree with everything I'm saying 100%. Equity, just like socialism, is trash. 👍
@motleylou609 I said inequity. Very different. I hope that you can find love in your heart. Fear, hatred, and resentment just feed more. Once you put yourself in someone else's shoes, it's easier to see from their perspective. We all have challenges in our lives. They might be different, but we're all human on this rock together. The world is too small for hatred now. We're seeing that vividly.
@@johnatyoutube i guess were all on edge because they stole our language
This is American self criticism at its ABSOLUTE BEST, and it stays relevant today even more so then back then.
This needs to get as viral as possible.
It got lost in the red scare. And yes Stalin was a monster,no doubt. Just as murderous and repressive. Trump is the epitome of pitting one against other.
But the people this film critiques will have the teachers who show it arrested for "indoctrination."
And Americans aren`t known for their self-criticism and modesty,they`ve always been known worldwide as loudmouths
@@mjh5437 A slight correction; we are more... Republicans then all of us! Most all of the Democrats I know are very pleasant calm people; most of the republicans as we. saw under dmfp; are angry, loud and detrimental to the over all health of our country!
I shared it on Twitter
We're watching a virtual rerun of this right now
The show just ended yesterday at noon
I usually just watch these old “PSA” type films for shits n grins, but this one actually was spitting facts.
ye shiet straight fact spitting shiet
This film is racist and transphobic. Not enough BIPOC in it and too many ciswhite males
spittin str8 f@ktz boii shieet yea shieet str8 foakts boi shiieett
Soros . What is he😂
@@ronalddaub9740anti-nazism film so it's only natural to find casual antisemitism in comments, and whaddabout dem commies, huh?
This should be shown in schools across the nation.
Across the world. It is relevant everywhere.
Ik
Let it be a nation of suckers lol whats the problem. Make your own country
It's unionist propaganda
@@cornixdemetrius7883Ok, Hans
It's amazing how relevant this film is today in the USA.
And, by the same token, it's dismaying how far the right has slid into authoritarianism.
In the world
The same people that made this film changed their mind. And here aw are.
Conservatives are two steps away from goose-stepping down the street heiling for Trump as they vote to keep themselves in poverty.
Meanwhile liberals don't want to engage in reality and refuse to see the warning signs.
We need to elect more scientists and fewer high school bullies.
Not just the USA. There is a palpable rise in right wing action in many places. Eastern Europe for one, which is a rare grain of truth in Putin's several 'reasons' to invade Ukraine (by sneak attack, same as Hitler). Meanwhile, the republican party in the USA (Trump) embraced the right wing/Neo-Nazi groups in order to grow their party and infect as many simple American sucker brains as possible - that's how Trump won in 2016. Simple fact is this is cyclic. Right wingers had their time in the sun back in the 50s. Then the liberals rose up, delivering more women's rights, legal abortion which rambled on a while as we wrestled with our war in Vietnam and the aftermath leading to a softer right wing reaction with Ronald Reagan Make America Great Again. First black President was a shot across the bow for the right wingers and worse, Obama basically tossed the keys to the kingdom to the gays, fruits and nuts his last 2 years in office and that was too much. And that's how we got Trump, who's an even dumber right wing reaction than GW Bush was. I never cared much for Joe Biden at any point, but I'll take him any day of the week over Trump, and twice on Sunday.
Chad teacher roasting the shit out of the Nazi leadership lmao
For real because none of them looked like the Perfect “Master” race they yapped about. Thats why it is important for people like teachers speak up against what is wrong and teach their students the truth.
@@politicsiswack8925 you do realize there wasn t really a master race. uncle h himself wasn t blond with blue eyes nor did he ever say that was the master race. the aryan race meant the european race, nordics, medditeraneans,slavs,etc. Loving your race doesn t mean you have to hate other races. Lear more real facts about the enemy before making stupid arguments.
@@politicsiswack8925 bc the aryan race theory never existed
@@politicsiswack8925"don't be a sucker"
The irony on some of you commenters
@@LizardOnAMushroom2358 can you elaborate?
Legit appreciate that this film also takes the time to show how terrible it feels to be other Ed by the fascists. The way it shows the black and foreign people in the crowd looking genuinely afraid for their lives. I had heard of this film before, but I didn’t realize just how raw and effective it is at showing the poison that underpins fascism.
its propaganda it's supposed to work like that
And as this comment section shows, people can see it's very telling of the times propaganda or not...
Immigrants are never victims, they make the conscious choice to go to a place and demand equality to the people who have lived there their whole lives. It's disturbing
@@shadowlord1418 sometimes propaganda is the cold truth.... sometimes...
Fascism was not based in racism but socialist Nationalism.
The German national socialists were based on racial identity. Very different
"you see, they knew that they were not strong enough to conquer a unified country"
Today in America, we have been split into feuding groups... This shit is happening right now, everywhere around you. The media is not your friend, there's something awful happening right now in America.
Trump is lying to you
Wow, a lot of familiar stars from that era. Well produced. The credit says 1947, but was actually made in 1943 during the war, then re-released in theaters again after the war. Paul Lukas played the Hungarian professor -- such a great actor. It contains a message as true today as it was back then!
How could they have talked about D-Day then if that was in 1944?
You're not wrong that it's equally true, but not for the reason you think.
@@Liam-uq7rb the 1943 date comes from IMDB, who are generally correct about these things. According to the IMDB page, the film was re-released in 1947 with a shorter runtime and updated to mention later events.
I'm 44 and I used to catch these kind of old films during daytime television at home on the weekend as a kid. The central character, that young man who says "I'm a mason!" I'm sure I recognise him too - was he pretty famous?
I recognized the great Ernest Borgnine as the Nazi speaker. Wouldn't surprise me if all these actors did this film for free.
Everyone wants to think of people from the past as dumb and racist but this is oneof the nicest things ive seen
Yea, the people trying to make people look shitty in history are the ones this video is warning about. They are trying to spin a narrative that divides people into sub categories and then pits them against each other. That's how republics are taken down, slowly over many years of repetitive and exhaustive effort.
It’s not the people of the past I blame, it’s the people of the present I see as dumb and racist.
Back then you had the excuse of lacking information and only reading propaganda. Nowadays we have infinite access to information yet people still choose the prejudice that was made for us by those who will profit from our hatred.
The part I loved the most is when they said that they were American and not a group to be seperated from minor differences. That is was ok to have physical differences or different Religions. Why can’t we have that now? Why can’t we unite as a people to solve our problems for the good of everyone. Why does everything have to result in a pointless debate with something that may not even matter in the end. I may sound Nationalistic but I just want for the better for everyone
Edit: 112 and counting replies, that went well with others lmao. Entertaining though.
wish people would embrace that idea now. Stop squabbling and actually make progress
@Ben The 40s and 50s weren't promising for every American, which is why they weren't good. Segregation isn't something you can just hand-wave.
@Ben "sure we had segregation etc but..." sounds like hand-waving to me.
@@tjones6277 Is recognizing a truth hand-waving?
Unfortunately, segregation tends to happen across cultures.
How many black people to you see in China, Japan, Pakistan, etc.
Look at borders of countries most countries are home to one primary race, and if there are others they are often segregated into Jewish communities, Kurdish communities, Sunni, Shai, Gypsy etc communities.
Humans tend to organize by cultural groups, New York had jewish, black, german, italian, hungarian, chinese, etc communities.
Hispanic restaurants employ mainly hispanic people. Chinese, sudanese, japanese, and african american restaurants often employ members of their familial/cultural groups.
African Americans evolved humanity forward. Segregation was the norm everywhere and still is. Most countries are not diverse.
America is the 1st and only country to allow a diversity of so many different races, religions, ethnicities, and cultures.
In the past, when cultures clashed, evil occurred, different people were often viewed as something to be feared.
Yes, the 1950's were bad, but videos like this, and writings from the past show that they were on their way to being more inclusive.
Its sad people ignore tribalism across humanity. The ability to see past it, is a very new, and unique gift. Thank MLK.
@@revolutionrising5592 Sadly my friend, some on the Left want to bring back segregation. To give blacks their own separate spaces. Happened to a cafe.
"And Hans who was going to rule the world only got a small patch of Normandy."
@Bike Trooper You also heavily miss the point of the video and that quote from the video.
@Bike Trooper found a sucker
@Chet Muggins What makes him a "loser" exactly? Define "loser" - I am just curious.
The definition of Loser is “Somebody who loses”
Just like Antifa will be sent to the Gulag when they have served their purpose
At Dodger Stadium, you'll find a statue of Jackie Robinson (the first black person to play in major league baseball). Underneath the statute is a quote saying, "There's not an American in this country free until every one of us is free."
@Brian Woods I love that saying!
It’s not true but it’s cute.
@@xkmmx2132 We know you guys think so. It's "not a democracy" either, right?
@@xkmmx2132 Except it's 100% true.
Jackie Robinson wasn't the first black player to play in the major leagues. He broke the color barrier that lasted from 1895 to 1947
2:53 is a tale as old as time. The classic, "Oh no, the face eating leopards are eating my face. How could this have happened?"
I teach 7th grade language arts. One of my students said “the US national film archives has less followers than many TH-cam gamers.” I’m still haunted by that.
Sad isn't it.
Why?
Teacher Unions are corrupt.
You know it.
You are probably part of it.
how do you "follow" the US national film archives though? by watching movies?
U wanna get really dark ask how many Americans have heard of the Film archives
Because nobody cares about past History. It doesn't mean anything to them. Because they don't care about anything. But what's in front of them.
And that's the truth.
"Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it" -- George Santayana
Frank D The EU says the Visegrad countries have one month to "normalize" their policy on immigration.
Sounds like Prag in -68.
Leftists calling on history to aid their stupid causes...
Twats...
Hate breads hate.
Nationalism, ignorance, fear, and hate leads to violence.
Nazi Germany wasn't created in a vacuum. Mussolini and Hitler capitalized on the same types of nationalism, ignorance, and fear that we are experiencing right now. Who will take their place? Duterte? Trump? Jong-un?
Frank D SEE WHAT TRANSPIRED AT THE MARCH OF NEO NAZI , KKK. THIS VIDEO TOO RELEVANT TO BE COINCIDENCE.
@Medovukha What the hell are you babbling on about? Those white supremacist, nazi scum buckets arrived ready for battle. They were dressed in military gear, carrying weapons, ready to fight!
They came from all around the country, threatening to take over Charlottesville.
They chanted nazi slogans!
They rammed a line of riot cops, pushing against them in an effort to breach the barricades!
They drove a car into a crowd, a terrorist act to be sure.
These white supremacist nazi scumbags are terrorists!
Enough with the false equivalency bullshit!
Frank D Reagan cut taxes. The result was a 15 year surge in our economy which went through the Clinton Presidency. The Clintons had nothing to do with it. Yet being the politicians that they are, they took credit for it. When taxes are cut Americans are free to invest invest and buy. It creates more jobs. More people are working so more people pay taxes. The economy surges in a positive way. That is the truth. High taxes stifle the economy.
It doesn't matter to you until they come for you, and they will always come for you.
Yes the Democrat Party has used the Nazi tactic of Identity Politics to divide America
It's frightening that the Democrat Party have brought Nazism back to life
ECHOESThey will
"At least it's not me" is what the last man standing says until he's in the ground.
They use you until they come for you. Fascism always has to have a domestic enemy in order for it to work, some group, or groups, to divide and conquer.
If they take from the initial target groups and run them off, kill them, imprison them, then they must have someone else to 'deal with' to turn the suckers against until it is their turn.
The only way it is ever able to work in the first place is for there to be enough people willing to sacrifice someone else in their desire to have more for themselves, right along with enough people it doesn't matter to.
You are left with people who are willing to do that to you either through greed or fear, depending upon where they fit in the scheme of things.
The fact that so many in the comments are trying to say that this is a propaganda film and therefore has no value is insane. The message itself is a great one that it doesn't matter what way it was told, but being technically propaganda just so happens to be how it's told.
The best propaganda is the one that contains the most truth
Propaganda just means something that's trying to convince people of something. It's not inherently bad.
“Those who don’t know history are doomed to repeat it while those that do are doomed to watch it repeat.”
@Kristopher Prime oh american values? You mean real americans right? Like the pawnee, Mohicans and the great tribes and civilizations that were wiped out?
@@Nodnarbero tell me a country and i’ll tell you a war crime they committed you do know that the indians were from russia right? there was no human from america
@@COLMECTIGAMINGANDMORE not like they lived their for hundreds of thousands of years.
Shut the fuck up.
Replace jew and catholic with white and Christian... and you have the modern progressive movement, sounding again like the 1920s "progressive" movement.
@@timothyarnold1679 yep lol
They literally need to put this in a primetime tv slot to show serious every American alive should watch this in today's political society it would open some of there minds
Yes the Democrat Party has used the Nazi tactic of Identity Politics to divide America
It's frightening that the Democrat Party have brought Nazism back to life
No it wouldn’t. They are brainwashed just as they were during WW2 .
Maybe they could take an english class too
MAGA are fascists.
They should air the anti-communist videos they made back then. That would be extremely relevant today.
4:14: "In this country there are no other people. We are American people"
Twitter: "Hold my beer."
America: hold my pack. Historically continues to separate Americans
@@onlyjuanhope ah yes, that one guy America who makes all the decisions.
America is just a singular sentient entity that thinks for itself and controls all the people beneath it and forces them to segregate.
No, America doesn’t do these things. America is founded on individuality and entirely free expression. If these rules are violated, it’s not American.
America isn’t some omnipotent entity in Washington that forces the people beneath it to go by its bidding. America is a bunch of people, some are the government, some are the public. The government and the public work symbiotically, not one way or the other.
You’re talking about when nasty people make the big decisions. This isn’t America. This is nasty people who exploit the American system.
@@dogol284 You have been duped into think freedom is a virtue that people choose but its not, you are told what is freedom and have it served to you over a mountain of corpses and debt.
@@scutumfidelis1436 That's always been the american way
@@StrangeScaryNewEngland Yes and its always been the position of the ignorant to assume they are individuals with sovereignty.
We always have masters and with the overthrow of the monarchs now we have no idea who they are or what they want.
1:39 One thing I didn't expect from a PSA from 1947 was appreciation of America's diversity and acknowledgement of racism, xenophohia, etc. as a scapegoat, a very pleasant surprise
What!? That's exactly the kind of smearing dirt in your eyes when things aren't much better in your own country than in other racist societies. Here oneself is presented better than reality. And the co-responsibility for the emergence of the Nazi movement, through a deeply unjust peace treaty of Versailles, is completely ignored. The failure of American politics in 1919 and the years that followed could hardly be better concealed than with a poor propaganda ham like the one we see before us. What happened when Germany laid down its arms in November 1918? The bulk of the German fleet was interned in England. The Imperial Air Force had been disbanded and the latest aircraft were in French hands. Allied troops had been in the Rhineland since December 1918 and had established large bridgeheads across the Rhine. Germany was no longer able to continue fighting. Despite this, the illegal long-distance blockade of the Allied fleet was not lifted. Not even for the urgently needed food. As a result, 850,000 Germans starved to death in the winter of 1918/19. The blockade was not lifted until the end of June. Then 1 million Germans fled from the separated parts of the country to escape the repression of the new masters. And at the end of the day, everyone in Germany lost their money due to a hyperinflation that is unique in the world untill today. And now please tell me again what kind of message the film has and how true these statements are...
The founding fathers would laugh at your egalitarian ass as they lined you up for the firing squads.
@@HYDEinallcaps Good thing the founding fathers are all dust now.
@@LauncherSpiderMk7 Wow, that's not very patriotic of you. You're not a true American, go wave your Confederate flag with the other losers, like the n*zis and Indians!
The funny thing is that many on the Right will call this film modern day wokeism. 😁
This is by far one of the most important videos I've ever had the privilege to witness on TH-cam.
in terms of brainwash and misinformation?
@@PhilSMonatsbinde How so?
@@Movedaccountlol U mean if we completly ignore the fact the whole continent was simply stolen from the "real american Americans" by europeans (mainly germans) who founded this, our joungest Nation by far. Wich is and was in war, ever since. Still the only one cold blooded enough to nuke a completely unprepared City. Additional polluting one of the most beatutyful places on earth with tons of radiation and bla and bla and bla... Founded on lies, financial system corrupted to the core... China own`s more physical Dollar than there is physical America....
@@PhilSMonatsbinde What? Could you please state that in a way I can understand?
@@Movedaccountlol Oh, i see.... just nevermind...
People of America We need to make this go viral!!!! We ALL need to hear this over and over . Please please send it to everyone you know! Specially those who are on the fence .
Men should be allowed to dress up like woman and go into woman's bathrooms/dressing rooms/woman's sports.
All this 💩 with gender is crazy.
They claim they are being oppressed.
I bet they started this BS because they wanted to take attention away from men's rights activist. But what do I know. I just thought of that after watching this video.
Bro....its literally a propaganda film....
I know. If fascists will get rid of communists like AOC then Im starting to warm up to fascism. I'd rather vote F than allow the continued mutilation of kids, abortion of innocent unborn, and mass invasion at the south border. If fascism will protect our people, then I'd vote for it. I'd vote for any other group that wasnt fascist but would turn off the migrant spigot, would end womb based murder, and would sto pthe trans communist ideology. But failing to have an alternative to fascism, I'll take fascism.
@@fishjohn014 As if being anti-Fascist was bad...?
@@fishjohn014 The Nazis are an existential threat to everyone, including themselves. Countries have a right and duty to warn their populations against them
This old video hit me differently. So much sense and wisdom was said in it. Thanks!
this needs to be shown again in America , people have seemed to have forgotten .
Yes the Democrat Party uses the Nazi tactic of Identity Politics to divide America
It's frightening that the Democrat Party have brought Nazism back to life
"They decided to abolish truth" could have been talking about your current incumbent.
@@maughan3061 (Since you went there first) you’re talking about Trump, right? But he’s not the “incumbent,” because he lost the last election
@@gregbors8364 I meant your current incumbent. It was his handling of Ukraine I was thinking of specifically. But enlighten me. How did Trump abolish truth exactly?
@@gregbors8364 Orange Man Bad!
Funny how history keeps repeating itself, isn't it?
jawa64ify all over the world
jawa64ify I like that
For something to repeat it first needs to end. Sadly racism has never ended. It's lessened, but it's never ended.
Daedra Did you miss the skinhead rally where a neo nazi took a fucking truck and ran it through a crowd of people?
Rook Valentine wtf are you talking about it was all over the news they were fighting for that statue to be taken down because it represents slavery and because those people protesting were "slaves" yes they are saying that they were born in the time African Americans were slaves
Every American should be required to watch this movie every year.
why ? so they can misunderstand it and apply it to whatever politician they personally dont agree with ? the dems are gonna say this is how trump is and the republicans are gonna say this is how the left wing deep state is accept its now reversed prejudice against white christians and conservatives .
Yes
The part about Hans wanting to rule the world but only getting a little piece of Normandy was so sad.
But true. Fascists tend to end up as worm food
@@itsallgoodman4108same with a lot of radical left ideologies too since at the end of the day though the ideologies may be different the outcome still the same
@@thecouncilofbrazilianchads5580”Both sides hur dur”
@@elricofmelnibone425Not both. All
We're all worm food in the end.
That's actually a really well done film, and absolutely relevant even today.. I was expecting something super corny but this holds up really well..
This is a short and sweet film, They got their point across. It's refreshing that this was made and is being viewed by so many now.
short and sweet?
It's literally against the only system that vehemently was against communism, and all the perversion that is rampant today.
Sorry to break it to you, but the good guys lost. And the evil communists won, just look at society; that proves (between good and evil) which side won the war.
Germany NEW if they lost, the world was lost; that's why they faught so hard.
1 nation, versus the most perverse, corrupt, and evil people on earth.
When you go up against the greatest liars in history, great lies will be told about you.
"You are of your father the devil, and your will is to do your father's desires. He was a murderer from the beginning, and does not stand in the truth, because there is no truth in him. When he lies, he speaks out of his own character, for he is a liar and the father of lies."
Suspicious more like.
@@FreshGreenMoss Oh do tell us how this is suspicious.
@@moondancer6488 People have been falsely told that Putin is the new Hitler.
This film might be about anti fascism but it's true purpose at this time is to feed the two minutes of hate.
@@FreshGreenMoss ‘‘Nazis are bad and unity through diversity is stronger than division’’ is not a suspicious message
I just met someone who proudly claimed to be a Nazi. I sent them this video. Hopefully they aren’t too far gone.
I'm sure they are too far gone. There's always a sliver of hope, though.
Bet you didn't show this to a far right zionist as he wants to exterminate Palestinians
The USA bombed the Nazis. They are losers. Bigots are losers.
Some actually do figure it out.
This short is even more valuable today than when it was released 70 years ago. Then, most of the vets who smashed the nazi war machine were still around and could tell us what they had seen. Now, most of them have passed on, and the country has come into the hands of those who sit up nights trying to take what we have ... and they've been very successful. But they're nowhere near finished!
I believe that I can speak for us all when I say that we're nowhere near finished either!
@@professorperry4790 Well now we are finished, buddy. Now we are finished.
@@nocturnaljoe9543 I'll bet you're fun at parties......
@@girlgarde I was dropping bombs at your m0m's party.
@@girlgarde Nobody's finished except YOU. You stay where you are.
Chilling stuff, and it's a shame we're actually back in this position again after all that bloodshed and all those years to reflect.
What do you mean?
@@kaylahills3760 He means the recent rise of things like antisemitism, restrictions of voting rights, more anti union sentiment, increase of extremist political movements, etc. Similar to what was happening in the early 20th century and what led to WW2, the Holocaust, etc.
@@Sashazur 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Those who can not learn the lessons of history are doomed to repeat them.
@@kaylahills3760 Are you an idiot 😂😂
This really needs to be shown in India where the current ruling party has leaders and supporters who target religious minorities, promote pseudoscience and use religious sentiment as a tool to seize power.
Are you from democratic republic of kerala somehow?
Because in kerala hindu temples are regularly targeted and robbed by commies.
In Bangladesh hindus are practically non existent because of systematic cleansing.
So don't go around demonize hindus for your islamocommie agenda
shhhh. . . you can't say anything bad about "people of color". You can only demonize huwhyte people.
I find it interesting how three of the four comments on this thread have been hidden due to ??? Any questioning of India's nationalistic government on US social media is immediately ridiculed by M0di supporters. I saw the turn among H1B visa holders in 2014 when M0di won the election. It's a bit spooky that even Ghandi is now considered "too woke" or even a traitor among Hindu Nationalists who now venerate his killer, Nathuram Godse, as a misunderstood patriot.
Remember folks, Americans understood what America was in the past. We have sadly lost that with Don the con.
"Let's forget about we and they and let's think about us"
He rings the bell