This is the genius of MJK. His lyrics open so many doors as to what they may or may not be about. He could be singing about tying his shoes, and we'd all think it's metaphorical for something else. Ya gotta love it when a person can command that much debate with a single phrase.
The semi-tones and blue notes that Billy uses in this song are so brilliant and so haunting. It really sets the mood along with Maynards amazing vocals.
I PERSONALLY THINK that the solo from this song is one of the best examples of amazing guitar playing. Sometimes I just listen to the song for the solo
the version going around over a decade ago on winmx/s**ls**k has always been my favorite; it was live, but the perfect speed (a little faster/more urgent, less acid-y) and quality, much better and louder/more treb than the album version. i been looking for it on YT for a while now, i may have to take the task upon myself. thanks for uploading this though, the song always sounds better life imo
The song is whatever you want it to be. that's the whole point. Maynard has his own meaning, and it's up to us to find our own meaning in his words. That's the beauty of song.
Hozaak Labias I'm laying in bed right of in the dark blasting a Vape filled with some bud, and I'm pretty sure this is the most intense music ever created. At least this is what I think right now lol
oh man, yall are all so wrong. it takes every single member of the band to create that one true melodic, beautiful, enlightening sound. SUre, maynard is the best vocalist alive, but the band wouldnt be the same without each and evey individual aspect. the same with tool such a beautiful song
Its actually a coming full circle of feminine and masculine energies.. thats what the triunity is. Its all about the perfect balance and finding peace with yourself. it has nothing to do with "people who complete one another"
@BGuss Now that they are back together.. for the time being... Maynard and Billy were on the radio today and they were talking about releasing more songs.. but probably in Singles mostly.
I completely agree with you. But remember that the name is an abstract concept, therefore it is open for interpretation. Some things don't just have one meaning. Btw my previous comment is cited from a past interview with APC.
lol. seeing this video I remembered that, when Jeordie jumped in, I thought "he's perfect. He has Paz' hair"...but he cut them. Still today, as I see her, my irrational thought is...."wow, Twiggy".
So pure, so rare, to witness such a god-like guitar solo.
agree totally
What??!!
I see what you did there 🤘🏻
I'd sell my soul, my self-esteem, one dollar at a time...just so I could go back time and be at that concert. haha
I was there. It was everything you dream
i really cannot believe maynards voice on this song. its surreal. I think a lot of people dont know how hard this song would be
This song truly transcends genres. Total fucking masterpiece
That "one kiss" lyric is so well sang...makes my skin crawl
This is the genius of MJK. His lyrics open so many doors as to what they may or may not be about.
He could be singing about tying his shoes, and we'd all think it's metaphorical for something else.
Ya gotta love it when a person can command that much debate with a single phrase.
The semi-tones and blue notes that Billy uses in this song are so brilliant and so haunting. It really sets the mood along with Maynards amazing vocals.
Absolutely love this song! Maynard's voice is so haunting its like sex for my ears lol
Dorothy Hodge same
new organ: eargina
@@benitogrd eargasms everywhere
Billy Howardell is just phenomenal
Indeed
A fucking beast playing a banshee wailing guitar!!!
Yes
Also you are just beautiful
@Mystic1zzzhey thank you 🥹
That's MJK in peak form. The best rock singer of all time.
This is one of the best live performances you will ever see. They are so perfectly in sync it's unbelievable!
I PERSONALLY THINK that the solo from this song is one of the best examples of amazing guitar playing. Sometimes I just listen to the song for the solo
Love Billy's Solo @ 2:12 Min. Goosebumps.
exactly ! ffs he is well known for his ability to sing like an angel inside AND out of the studio. he's amazing.
there's so much special bout this band...love this song
The way Maynard swaggers around the stage with a bottle reminds me of a drunken pirate in a Johnny Depp/ Jack Sparrow kinda way
Perfect vocals and guitars. Also Paz headbangs are amazing.
ive been to a perfect circle live. there is no other feeling like it. theyre amazingly talented musicians.
I'm jealous! I'd have given anything to be at a Perfect Circle concert!!!! ❤💯💥
This full concert was my prized download in limewire with dial-up. Worth all the wait and viruses.
2:55 The guitar and the drums are execut€D so perfectly it's a masterpiece.
And I BEAR
I would have sold my soul to be there. Words cannot express how wonderful this is.
Man, this solo, i get furry
A Perfect Circle - Magdalena (live)
the version going around over a decade ago on winmx/s**ls**k has always been my favorite; it was live, but the perfect speed (a little faster/more urgent, less acid-y) and quality, much better and louder/more treb than the album version. i been looking for it on YT for a while now, i may have to take the task upon myself. thanks for uploading this though, the song always sounds better life imo
That freaking guitar solo. Almost overshadowed by Maynard ❤ omg the entire song was amazing 👏
Better than the one on the album. Love this live version.
Billy's guitar style is so amazing. Never heard anything else like it. A true artist
James keenan is a living legend,,,
Maynard gotta hydrate.
I said it once, and I’ll say it again. Seeing them touring Thirteenth Step was one of the best live performances I’d ever seen.
just incredible, I have full body goose bumps from that
I decided long ago that if I ever became a stripper my stage name would be Magdalena because of this song.
Tilps that's actually pretty hot....
I actually named my amp "Magdalena" or "Maggie" for short! 😉
I’d tip you nightly just because of it!!!
Most beautiful song I have ever heard because it reaches my soul
HOW CAN THAT BE LIVE????? That is insane!
bass riff: h a u n t i n g
I saw this band on a double bill with Tool back in 2004. What a great show!!
surprised Tool let this band open for them, their singer is a total copycat ripoff of Tool's singer
One of the best base lines of all time. God I love this song.
so pure, so rare
WHOOT! A decent live video for once!
The song is whatever you want it to be. that's the whole point. Maynard has his own meaning, and it's up to us to find our own meaning in his words. That's the beauty of song.
brilliantly written lyrics and music woo
The Solo is fuckin great!!! This whole song is freakin cool!
This video has 300k+ views from the same 30 people watching this 10,000 times, and I’m one of them
super banda, una de sus mejores rolas, yeeeaaah!! \m/ °~° \m/
Sadly they haven't played this during their 2018 tour (just bought my ticket to the Atlanta show at the Fox).
Howerdel is a fucking beast 😈🤪
Love you MJK
I like the cat idea. Very deep... :P
Great Song. I love the middle solo bit with the floor toms. Major head banging session.
Smoke some weed to this song and then tell me how much more you like it cause damn I love this song.
classic
Hozaak Labias I'm laying in bed right of in the dark blasting a Vape filled with some bud, and I'm pretty sure this is the most intense music ever created. At least this is what I think right now lol
Steve Raff it's pretty intense completley sober, too lol 😉...but, music is always better enjoyed on marijuana. IMO, anyways.
Good point and yes it is
*cough cough*
No thanks losers. Weed makes you stupid.
my favorite apc song. love it. ^_^
No words to describe. Maynard is a fucking legend.
goosbumps!
Maynard, looking like Joey jordonsons mask, very creepy, great dark, and dank song!!
Such a sexy song 😮😍
Im dripping
a perfect perfect perfect perfect perfect circle
SICKEST live an EXPERIENCE you all should have APC&TOOL peeps!!!!
que bella!!!!! hermosa!!!!!! gracias a edoom
Josh is amazing here
billy howerdell is also amazing on guitar
a quite decent live version, thanks!
yeah, thats why they are called 'A Perfect Circle'. The name symbolising the coming together of people who complete one another.
Fantastic!!!!!
oh man, yall are all so wrong. it takes every single member of the band to create that one true melodic, beautiful, enlightening sound. SUre, maynard is the best vocalist alive, but the band wouldnt be the same without each and evey individual aspect. the same with tool such a beautiful song
dont think ill eva get tired of watching this
Its actually a coming full circle of feminine and masculine energies.. thats what the triunity is. Its all about the perfect balance and finding peace with yourself. it has nothing to do with "people who complete one another"
I came here for the solo. Suits the song so well.
maynard is magdalena that we are throwing our dollar bills at. gladly.
I named my bass amp after this! 😍
THAT IS AWESOME 💥💯❤
I feel sorry for people who havent seen or heard this.That Bass line is so chunky. Awesome song
Jc he doesnt miss
holy shit that was amazing
The mighty Josh freese on the drums
@BGuss Now that they are back together.. for the time being... Maynard and Billy were on the radio today and they were talking about releasing more songs.. but probably in Singles mostly.
Such a dark song
I completely agree with you. But remember that the name is an abstract concept, therefore it is open for interpretation. Some things don't just have one meaning. Btw my previous comment is cited from a past interview with APC.
i'm with you brother
lol. seeing this video I remembered that, when Jeordie jumped in, I thought "he's perfect. He has Paz' hair"...but he cut them. Still today, as I see her, my irrational thought is...."wow, Twiggy".
My name is Marlena Magdalena xD
i really cannot believe maynards voice on this song. its surreal
My Magdalena ✅🆒💯❤️
great song
OMG!!!!
Dang that was really good.
I have a chunk of Maynard's hair from this performance....I suckle it every night
BILLY HOWERDEL IS A BAD MAN.
love it
neil pert fuckin rules
Troy looks like Trent Reznor in Starfuckers clip.
Nice sound quality. 👍
Badass!!!
yeah billy howerdells great
Love apc
Please "A Perfect Circle", Please! MAKE ANOTHER ALBUM! Sorry, I love Tool and all, but I love A perfect circle 10x's more!
they did bro, 10 years later
@@blisstonia And then tool came out with a banger haha.
i actually said tri-u-nity. which is your mind, body, and soul.trinity is a completely different thing. the two half moons are a triunity symbol
When was this show? Must've been sometime on the Mer de Noms tour
音イイネ！これだけスゴイボーカリスト、ひさびさに聴いた。
Get that DVD out, APC! :[
HAHAHA! Nothin' like a little gold on gold! HAHA!
UCSD?
sounds good...makes me think, whatever happened to Pulse Ultra?
F*** love this song but I keep Judith over this one for a long shot!!!!
APC forever!