I’m a member of the Comanche Nation I am related to the last known chief of our Tribe Quannah Parker. Watching this show made me fall more in love with my culture even more I am really greatful that it is apart of me
I'm in love with the storyline. and I love the Native American actors so authentic that it tells our footsteps in history and our fight to be free to live and go where the buffalo roam. I am the real American Indian. My grandmother from my father's side was English and my grandfather was Hunkpapa Sioux. Thank you Taylor Sheridan for your creative genius and love.
@@nathantallar8967 Sorry. That wasn't my goal. I'm from Poland. We used to play cowboys and Indians when we were kids. It was in deep communism. Relatively recently, people in Poland began to realize what happened to the indigenous inhabitants of the USA. In Poland, when we say Indians, we mean indigenous peoples, mainly from the USA, and there is nothing racist about it. It's rather something to be proud of.
@@NicCageForPresident2024 Yes. I am from central Poland. I hope I didn't offend you by using the term "Indians." When we say that, we always mean Native Americans, and there is nothing racist about it.
@@przemysawrozycki3342 It obviously doesn't matter what you guys say or mean in Poland or Polish. If you are speaking or writing in English about the indigenous people of the Americas, please refrain from using the word "Indian". Simple as that.
I watched 1883 in like two days I binged out on it, late nights and early mornings, I cried and cried and laughed and cried, and was devastated when it was over ! I love it's historical accuracy and I hope many people see the truth, and honestly I think every "American" should watch this show, so they can remember where they came from and that we at one point in our DNA were too immigrants.The struggle the native people have gone through and what was taken, and how the immigrants too suffered a great deal to give future generations a better life.
@@donniemarler3909 Not really, 3rd-4th generation or more cannot be called immigrant. Btw if everyone immigrant, than the natives are immigrant too, since humankind came from Africa or Asia as we know.
@@donniemarler3909 Kızılderililer avrupalı degil asyalı Kızılderililer asyalı olduklarını bile kabul etmiyorlar biz amerika yerlisiyiz biz bu kıtaya aitiz diyorlar
I am finish watching 1883 this night, this is masterpiece movies. And I cry in the last episode. I am Indonesian but i know that a lot of indonesian peoples love the stories about Indian tribes, their struggles, pain and amazing cultures is great history.
@@vickiic.r5032 I wonder when they will do a truthful representation of how violent the tribes actually were. Killed off entire tribes including killed women and children, roasted babies and practiced cannibalism. They attacked settlers mercilessly unprovoked. The Commanche were masters of torture and if they didn't kill you on a raid they would bury you up to their heads cut their eyelids off so the sun would burn their eyes out while they starved to death slowly
This brought tears to my eyes. Watching 1883 you can see the truth, honesty and authenticity Taylor brings to our collective history and many cultures. It's a beautiful thing. Imagine if history was actually taught to us accurately how different things might be. But the powers that be prefer to lie and keep us divide. It boggles the mind. Thank you Taylor for what you are doing.
@@adamsmith6389 it’s actually the universal sign of distress, and it’s my opinion that America is in great distress. And I’m expressing my displeasure and my freedom of speech and expression. Thank you kindly.
@@wildlyunrulyadventures3942 I 100% agree that we are in distress, but nobody is coming to save you, or us. It is up to us, there is nobody to signal to. I struggled with the same sentiment. Had a conversation with a good friend, who we were in the same company together. Deployed to OEF III & OIF I together. I was considering flying the flag upside down at my house. My Brother said, doing that is a kin to admitting defeat. Veterans, Proud American Citizens, LEOs, and Civil servants are the fabric that keeps the flag together. We are the flag. We hold the line. We don't need help.
@@adamsmith6389 you raise the white flag in surrender and defeat. The upside down flag declares that we are in dire distress. It’s always meant that. It’s a symbol that you (we) are in trouble. And we are in dangerous peril. And I am fully aware that “We The People” must make change but I’m afraid people have lost faith in the democracy of voting in America because of the denial from the previous administration and president. He lowered credibility in a functional system that has worked for centuries. He planted a seed in the minds of millions that he won and tried to steal the election. Because of this, fewer people will vote because they distrust the system due to the actions of the former president. That being said, I’m 47 and have voted religiously in state, local and federal elections since I was 18. I have never aligned myself with any party and voted as I saw the candidates to be fit. The last few years have been extremely difficult and challenging as the candidates running have all been junk. Finally, democracy in America is not the democracy that it once was. The system is corrupted. Within our government and by outside influences. As a Vet yourself you already know this. You aren’t paid for the service you provide based on your life’s value. You don’t get the benefits you deserve to have based on your service and life’s value. The government loves a soldier but hates a Vet. I could go on and on, but I will digress for now. And I will continue to raise awareness and fight for democracy in America until I die.
From watching Yellowstone to 1883, I've learned so much that wasn't taught in schools because they didn't want us to know. Billy Jack, was only true one to learn from until now.
1883 is highly inaccurate. Timelines don't make biological sense, they show items which didn't exist during at the supposed time, they also show unrealistic events occurring. It is entertainment, not education.
Maybe! In 1883 you would have NEVER seen an indian woman on a horse, ever. People like to think '1883' is somehow accurate, but its just revisionism. The native americans were 100% patriarchal, and werent above whipping females, if they were "insolent." I only say this to prevent the 400 million americans who are "part Cherokee" from being misled.
Also, when the tribes followed the migrating buffaloes, the warriors rode horses, and the women had to drag the teepee along the ground. Of course no dreamcatcher wants to hear this. In addition to 1883, and bucking Billy Jack, why not Martha Quinn, Medicine Woman for realism?
Google what the Indians went through and still do today. Like the intentional sterilization of hundreds of pure blooded Indian woman recently.You will walk away with a healthy distrust for this gov both then and now
@Frank Farmer I do not deny that there are violent and horrendous acts that were committed by the native American tribes, as with every other culture and people. I am in this case referring to the practices and mythology of their people, which I apologize for not being more precise on. I will definitely be reading more about this. Feel free to recommend any documentation on the Comanche people 😀
@@tanyaroberts919 I wonder when they will do a truthful representation of how violent the tribes actually were. Killed off entire tribes including killed women and children, roasted babies and practiced cannibalism. They attacked settlers mercilessly unprovoked. The Commanche were masters of torture and if they didn't kill you on a raid they would bury you up to their heads cut their eyelids off so the sun would burn their eyes out while they starved to death slowly
When you say "the Native American tribes" which tribes do you refer to? Name them! And also which sort of "horrendous acts" do you refer to? Name those too! Please bring in some REAL evidence on your words and not only your entitled-white-righteousness..@@tanyaroberts919
Else’s character would not have been as interesting without her relationship with Sam. With that in mind, I think that Martin Sendmeirr should be listed in the credits.
Not to mention natives were attacking other tribes for centuries before any boat full of oppressed Europeans fleeing poverty, war, religious oppression and starvation showed up.
Awesome stuff! Elsa would have lived IF: 1. Her mum hadn't guilted her to leave Sam. 2. If her mother had stayed put like her husband told her to when they found the dead family of Lakota. 3. If her mum didn't make her change into that awful dress.
The plains indians and the horse created a unique culture that for some time stood against the ever encroaching glacial wall that was the white people....homage to the brave warriors who knew it was inevitable yet still fought to the end...
Never saw that series. If it’s the comanche depicted here they were known for making raids on other tribes and they used to torture their enemies. I guess we won’t see that...
They hint at it. When they come across a Comanche village that had been raided. The first reaction by the two experienced scout/wagon train leader, Shea, is to get them as far away as possible before the Comanche warriors came back.
@@Editnamehere I wonder when they will do a truthful representation of how violent the tribes actually were. Killed off entire tribes including killed women and children, roasted babies and practiced cannibalism. They attacked settlers mercilessly unprovoked. The Commanche were masters of torture and if they didn't kill you on a raid they would bury you up to their heads cut their eyelids off so the sun would burn their eyes out while they starved to death slowly
Seriously?! Mr. Lee who wrote a book about being kidnapped and held hostage 3 years by the Comanche tells of their brutal savagery. He might beg to differ with your portrayal of them.
Exactly the reason I roll my eyes at this show. They show the white people very tough, no nosense, proud of their land and their way of life and hatred toward outsiders but they themselves took this land away from the Natives that had inhabited it for many generations.
I know the show doesnt even TRY to represent reality, that its just pure revisionist fantasy, but i wish they would show Lakota or Cheyenne warriors without all their 'finery' on! 90 percent of the time, if 'indians' encountered white settlers, it would have been while hunting for game, or 'just another day' in native life. If an indian wore all his war bonnets and decorative shit, hed have been laughed at for a 'show off.' You may not know it, but Natives frowned on 'cheap display..' But like i said, its entertainment not documentary, so keep watching, Dreamcatchers!!
I'm so glad to find at least one person that doesn't believe this tripe is a good representation of our native culture, I mean how many prom queens do you think would have been trying to join to live on the plains with the Indians, only the ones forced to, she would have tried to change their whole culture from the inside
Thats a big 10-4! And how would she feel, first of all "get your ass off that horse" as soon as they got clear of the whites? And, even if the women from that 'Sam' characters tribe would have ANYTHING to do with a 'prom queen' who had no clue how to skin and dress an Antelope, how would she feel if, the first thing she saw was another white girl, with tangled hair, basically a slave? That guy 'Sam' (obviously a warrior of some standing) throw over the eligible women of his own people, just because a white girl 'laid for him!' Anyway, I'll stop now, it just kills me how (inadvertently) rascist the whole show is.
Oh yeah: by 1883, so many settlers would have passed through, the Natives would be used to it. The reason i say this is to ammend an earlier point, the braves would also go looking for settlers/wagon trains looking to get coffee, or whiskey, or even AMMO if they could find a white naive enough to give it up.
@@Skipjack7814 I wonder when they will do a truthful representation of how violent the tribes actually were. Killed off entire tribes including killed women and children, roasted babies and practiced cannibalism. They attacked settlers mercilessly unprovoked. The Commanche were masters of torture and if they didn't kill you on a raid they would bury you up to their heads cut their eyelids off so the sun would burn their eyes out while they starved to death slowly
Costner and Taylor have always tried to tell the Indians story in THEIR words. Thank you! As a White man i am humbled and saddened at the treatment of the Indian by Whites. We should have listened more and shot less. Maybe then America qould not be broken, as it is.
Sickens me that heirloom sacreds are being auctioned off. My family had shields and bonnets with quetzal feathers and abalogne that were stolen when my great grandparents were sent to assimilation schools because their parents only spoke the tekwapu. Those sacred were sold and destroyed and i have nothing but my pride which cant be bought or stolen or destroyed. Ah kah muh kuh tuh nuh numu pabi patsi sumu numu kehtu taibo
I wonder when they will do a truthful representation of how violent the tribes actually were. Killed off entire tribes including killed women and children, roasted babies and practiced cannibalism. They attacked settlers mercilessly unprovoked. The Commanche were masters of torture and if they didn't kill you on a raid they would bury you up to their heads cut their eyelids off so the sun would burn their eyes out while they starved to death slowly
@@svenkreft9784 Taylor Sheridan is the most genuine writer out there! Hollywood has a tendency to gloss over everything. Outlander is one of the few productions that actually uses indigenous people and that includes bringing them in from Canada all the way to Scotland!
I bet that if someone were to make an honest representation of Indians and their history amongst other tribes. They will be surprised at how violent they were in conquering each other’s lands.
Yep. Took scalp, killed women and children and ate people. They attacked settlers mercilessly unprovoked. The Commanche were masters of torture and if they didn't kill you on a raid they would bury you up to their heads cut their eyelids off so the sun would burn their eyes out while they starved to death slowly
Well I mean all the tribes were very different so grouping all native Americans into “Indians” it does a disservice and also Europeans were far the most violent and savage peoples on the earth with countless massacres and wars over petty disputes
By this point in time, as in the late 1800’s the tribes had essentially hunkered down to protect what they had. They did absolutely right in the portrayal
I remember Gram green from north of 60 . But Albert from the show, always hang around with carvers in Vancouver BC, no not Gram. I really miss those days when he was alive, some times he brought our carvings, I still carve, now I am in Gastown Vancouver BC. I don't want to Gram anyways, ok, he was one of my great heroes then. Anyways always looked down at us, so no disrespect we understand ,👍
I wonder when they will do a truthful representation of how violent the tribes actually were. Killed off entire tribes including killed women and children, roasted babies and practiced cannibalism. They attacked settlers mercilessly unprovoked. The Commanche were masters of torture and if they didn't kill you on a raid they would bury you up to their heads cut their eyelids off so the sun would burn their eyes out while they starved to death slowly
Wait a damn minute... weren't Comanche downright brutal to everyone they met? Or did I buy into the peaceful native American narrative like everyone else?
This is Montana dumbass. The Comanche are in Texas. U gonna complain about people in Switzerland being nice in a movie even tho people in France are dicks? What are u even complaining about
@@sandramorey2529 I wonder when they will do a truthful representation of how violent the tribes actually were. Killed off entire tribes including killed women and children, roasted babies and practiced cannibalism. They attacked settlers mercilessly unprovoked. The Commanche were masters of torture and if they didn't kill you on a raid they would bury you up to their heads cut their eyelids off so the sun would burn their eyes out while they starved to death slowly
So a Comanche darling, travelling away from his band comes acros a herd of buffalo in 1883, a rare occurrence that could have fed A LOT OF PEOPLE,, and just kills one cow, scaring away the rest of the herd just to give his crash a hunting tutorial, and this is an accurate portrayal? So in Samoset's chsracter, what precisely have we learned about the Numunu/Comanche except that they rode horses, hunted buffalo, wore colourful clothing and had long hair? Like what was did his character serve apart from being a plot point in favor of the rad and unconventional 19th century teenage gir's lifestyle? Insread of showcasing the Comanches within the historical cintext of the time portrayed, they just inserted a plain Indian, decided that he should be Comanche and used him to show that the Dutton girl sees no skin colour or minority and just follows her heart despite the norms of the time and her father's objections. What a woke fairy tale. They at least did a slightly better job with the Lakota and a slightly better still job with the Crow.
Yes, because a blond white teenager wearing leather chaps and commanche sleeveless bling in 1883, while having an affair with an English speaking warrior is so historically accurate! I hated the series.
But non the less it happened amd will for ever go down in history as a fight for new territory that was conquered and is now as we all know it to be America, the home of the brave!
From reading about the Comanche I have learned one thing, they were far from nice peaceful people. They were savage murdering rapists with a penchant for torture. A great series….. sugar coated though.
I’m a member of the Comanche Nation I am related to the last known chief of our Tribe Quannah Parker. Watching this show made me fall more in love with my culture even more I am really greatful that it is apart of me
May your people live forever. 🙏
I read that in my head in some type of drunk, Mexican accent, I don’t know why.
I'm in love with the storyline. and I love the Native American actors so authentic that it tells our footsteps in history and our fight to be free to live and go where the buffalo roam.
I am the real American Indian. My grandmother from my father's side was English and my grandfather was Hunkpapa Sioux.
Thank you Taylor Sheridan for your creative genius and love.
Известный актер Зан Токкиа-ку МакЛернон из ханкпапа-сиу
When she kept declaring her love. I cried
Had me sobbing 😂
I replay that scene over and over ..
Loved the character Sam,
You can clearly see the heart and soul of everyone involed. This movie is absolutely amazing.
It's not a movie
Vikings in Scandinavia, Samurai in Japan, Indians in America. Amazing cultures and amazing people.
Judging by your name you must be Polish. I am an interesting mix my mom is Polish and my father was Native American.
Stop say Indian, that's racist
@@nathantallar8967 Sorry. That wasn't my goal. I'm from Poland. We used to play cowboys and Indians when we were kids. It was in deep communism. Relatively recently, people in Poland began to realize what happened to the indigenous inhabitants of the USA. In Poland, when we say Indians, we mean indigenous peoples, mainly from the USA, and there is nothing racist about it. It's rather something to be proud of.
@@NicCageForPresident2024 Yes. I am from central Poland. I hope I didn't offend you by using the term "Indians." When we say that, we always mean Native Americans, and there is nothing racist about it.
@@przemysawrozycki3342 It obviously doesn't matter what you guys say or mean in Poland or Polish. If you are speaking or writing in English about the indigenous people of the Americas, please refrain from using the word "Indian". Simple as that.
I watched 1883 in like two days I binged out on it, late nights and early mornings, I cried and cried and laughed and cried, and was devastated when it was over ! I love it's historical accuracy and I hope many people see the truth, and honestly I think every "American" should watch this show, so they can remember where they came from and that we at one point in our DNA were too immigrants.The struggle the native people have gone through and what was taken, and how the immigrants too suffered a great deal to give future generations a better life.
Research the Bering Land Bridge, my friend...we are all immigrants
@@donniemarler3909 Not really, 3rd-4th generation or more cannot be called immigrant. Btw if everyone immigrant, than the natives are immigrant too, since humankind came from Africa or Asia as we know.
@@donniemarler3909 Kızılderililer avrupalı degil asyalı Kızılderililer asyalı olduklarını bile kabul etmiyorlar biz amerika yerlisiyiz biz bu kıtaya aitiz diyorlar
i couldn't find it on Netflix
I am finish watching 1883 this night, this is masterpiece movies. And I cry in the last episode. I am Indonesian but i know that a lot of indonesian peoples love the stories about Indian tribes, their struggles, pain and amazing cultures is great history.
What platform?
I did too, I cried like a baby, I still tear up thinking about it 🫣
@@vickiic.r5032 I wonder when they will do a truthful representation of how violent the tribes actually were.
Killed off entire tribes including killed women and children, roasted babies and practiced cannibalism.
They attacked settlers mercilessly unprovoked. The Commanche were masters of torture and if they didn't kill you on a raid they would bury you up to their heads cut their eyelids off so the sun would burn their eyes out while they starved to death slowly
This brought tears to my eyes. Watching 1883 you can see the truth, honesty and authenticity Taylor brings to our collective history and many cultures. It's a beautiful thing. Imagine if history was actually taught to us accurately how different things might be. But the powers that be prefer to lie and keep us divide. It boggles the mind. Thank you Taylor for what you are doing.
Well said, but turn that flag to its proper position. You admitting defeat. Patriots are strong
@@adamsmith6389 it’s actually the universal sign of distress, and it’s my opinion that America is in great distress. And I’m expressing my displeasure and my freedom of speech and expression. Thank you kindly.
@@wildlyunrulyadventures3942 I 100% agree that we are in distress, but nobody is coming to save you, or us. It is up to us, there is nobody to signal to.
I struggled with the same sentiment. Had a conversation with a good friend, who we were in the same company together. Deployed to OEF III & OIF I together.
I was considering flying the flag upside down at my house. My Brother said, doing that is a kin to admitting defeat.
Veterans, Proud American Citizens, LEOs, and Civil servants are the fabric that keeps the flag together. We are the flag. We hold the line. We don't need help.
@@wildlyunrulyadventures3942 th-cam.com/video/IdTMDpizis8/w-d-xo.html
@@adamsmith6389 you raise the white flag in surrender and defeat. The upside down flag declares that we are in dire distress. It’s always meant that. It’s a symbol that you (we) are in trouble. And we are in dangerous peril.
And I am fully aware that “We The People” must make change but I’m afraid people have lost faith in the democracy of voting in America because of the denial from the previous administration and president. He lowered credibility in a functional system that has worked for centuries. He planted a seed in the minds of millions that he won and tried to steal the election. Because of this, fewer people will vote because they distrust the system due to the actions of the former president.
That being said, I’m 47 and have voted religiously in state, local and federal elections since I was 18. I have never aligned myself with any party and voted as I saw the candidates to be fit. The last few years have been extremely difficult and challenging as the candidates running have all been junk.
Finally, democracy in America is not the democracy that it once was. The system is corrupted. Within our government and by outside influences. As a Vet yourself you already know this. You aren’t paid for the service you provide based on your life’s value. You don’t get the benefits you deserve to have based on your service and life’s value. The government loves a soldier but hates a Vet.
I could go on and on, but I will digress for now. And I will continue to raise awareness and fight for democracy in America until I die.
One of the greatest series I've ever seen
What's the second greatest series your have seen?
From watching Yellowstone to 1883, I've learned so much that wasn't taught in schools because they didn't want us to know. Billy Jack, was only true one to learn from until now.
1883 is highly inaccurate. Timelines don't make biological sense, they show items which didn't exist during at the supposed time, they also show unrealistic events occurring. It is entertainment, not education.
Maybe! In 1883 you would have NEVER seen an indian woman on a horse, ever. People like to think '1883' is somehow accurate, but its just revisionism. The native americans were 100% patriarchal, and werent above whipping females, if they were "insolent." I only say this to prevent the 400 million americans who are "part Cherokee" from being misled.
Also, when the tribes followed the migrating buffaloes, the warriors rode horses, and the women had to drag the teepee along the ground. Of course no dreamcatcher wants to hear this. In addition to 1883, and bucking Billy Jack, why not Martha Quinn, Medicine Woman for realism?
Google what the Indians went through and still do today. Like the intentional sterilization of hundreds of pure blooded Indian woman recently.You will walk away with a healthy distrust for this gov both then and now
@@Skipjack7814 Complete nonsense
Amazing, Love The Yellowstone Universe.
Beautiful written show and beautiful culture ❤️
Hello how are you doing today?
@Frank Farmer I do not deny that there are violent and horrendous acts that were committed by the native American tribes, as with every other culture and people. I am in this case referring to the practices and mythology of their people, which I apologize for not being more precise on. I will definitely be reading more about this. Feel free to recommend any documentation on the Comanche people 😀
@@tanyaroberts919 I wonder when they will do a truthful representation of how violent the tribes actually were.
Killed off entire tribes including killed women and children, roasted babies and practiced cannibalism.
They attacked settlers mercilessly unprovoked. The Commanche were masters of torture and if they didn't kill you on a raid they would bury you up to their heads cut their eyelids off so the sun would burn their eyes out while they starved to death slowly
When you say "the Native American tribes" which tribes do you refer to? Name them! And also which sort of "horrendous acts" do you refer to? Name those too! Please bring in some REAL evidence on your words and not only your entitled-white-righteousness..@@tanyaroberts919
Thinking of Cole Brings Plenty. RIP.
Else’s character would not have been as interesting without her relationship with Sam. With that in mind, I think that Martin Sendmeirr should be listed in the credits.
It’s nice to see Native Americans finally being portrayed appropriately.
A German Eskimo portraying a Comanche is appropriate and authentic ?
Not to mention natives were attacking other tribes for centuries before any boat full of oppressed Europeans fleeing poverty, war, religious oppression and starvation showed up.
@@tula1433do you know what tribe were attacking others? And what was the name of the other tribe that was targeted? I will like to do a research.
Awesome stuff!
Elsa would have lived IF:
1. Her mum hadn't guilted her to leave Sam.
2. If her mother had stayed put like her husband told her to when they found the dead family of Lakota.
3. If her mum didn't make her change into that awful dress.
And maybe if Sam had accompanied them part of the way.
Boundary lines for each tribe
Finally it's about time I so love this
Truly Sad And Happy To This Is Amazing Thank You For Sharing This Beautiful Episode❤❤❤❤❤
Thank you so much for sharing
Incredible show 👏
Thank you 🙏🧡
I am just mesmerised by these beautiful people and their culture xo ❤
The plains indians and the horse created a unique culture that for some time stood against the ever encroaching glacial wall that was the white people....homage to the brave warriors who knew it was inevitable yet still fought to the end...
read or audiobook “Empire of the Summer Moon”
Wish Mr Sheridan would do a series based completely on the first people of N. America during this time period.
Never saw that series. If it’s the comanche depicted here they were known for making raids on other tribes and they used to torture their enemies. I guess we won’t see that...
They hint at it. When they come across a Comanche village that had been raided. The first reaction by the two experienced scout/wagon train leader, Shea, is to get them as far away as possible before the Comanche warriors came back.
@@pogo1140 Thanks for the info!
@@pogo1140 They were Lakota Sioux.
Bless this culture to live and thrive forever our world is too commercialized..
Excelente serie.
That's why I love Taylor, we're finally learning the truth.
My grandmother was full blooded Cherokee I luck your work
Nice
@@Editnamehere I wonder when they will do a truthful representation of how violent the tribes actually were.
Killed off entire tribes including killed women and children, roasted babies and practiced cannibalism.
They attacked settlers mercilessly unprovoked. The Commanche were masters of torture and if they didn't kill you on a raid they would bury you up to their heads cut their eyelids off so the sun would burn their eyes out while they starved to death slowly
A superb show 👏
oh we love it 😍😍🥰
Какой потрясающий Дэвид в этом эпизоде, боже мой!!!!
Боже! Помоги мне! Я люблю Дэвида Митфандера! Без ума и без памяти!!!
Yooooo, im comanche and i saw a clip of elsa telling sam ah kuh tuh nuh muh and i was like did this white girl just tell him i love you? Lmaoooo
Seriously?! Mr. Lee who wrote a book about being kidnapped and held hostage 3 years by the Comanche tells of their brutal savagery. He might beg to differ with your portrayal of them.
thank god mr lee and co were humane towards the indians lol
On my first plant medicine journey, I saw the gatekeeper's...And yes they are Native American Indians...Ato ata hashe...
The american native was the real owners of the land must be respectfull
Native Americans massacred and went to war with each other. Stealing land from other natives by means of force. How is this different?
Not really, did it be occur to you that they also fought each for hunting grounds or lands?
@@DavidReyes-ot1rc entire tribes were disbanded due to intertribal war.
@David Reyes And how is that any different than any other nation state.
Exactly the reason I roll my eyes at this show. They show the white people very tough, no nosense, proud of their land and their way of life and hatred toward outsiders but they themselves took this land away from the Natives that had inhabited it for many generations.
I am a member of the Comanche tribe.
Hello how are you doing today?
I know the show doesnt even TRY to represent reality, that its just pure revisionist fantasy, but i wish they would show Lakota or Cheyenne warriors without all their 'finery' on! 90 percent of the time, if 'indians' encountered white settlers, it would have been while hunting for game, or 'just another day' in native life. If an indian wore all his war bonnets and decorative shit, hed have been laughed at for a 'show off.' You may not know it, but Natives frowned on 'cheap display..' But like i said, its entertainment not documentary, so keep watching, Dreamcatchers!!
I'm so glad to find at least one person that doesn't believe this tripe is a good representation of our native culture, I mean how many prom queens do you think would have been trying to join to live on the plains with the Indians, only the ones forced to, she would have tried to change their whole culture from the inside
Thats a big 10-4! And how would she feel, first of all "get your ass off that horse" as soon as they got clear of the whites? And, even if the women from that 'Sam' characters tribe would have ANYTHING to do with a 'prom queen' who had no clue how to skin and dress an Antelope, how would she feel if, the first thing she saw was another white girl, with tangled hair, basically a slave? That guy 'Sam' (obviously a warrior of some standing) throw over the eligible women of his own people, just because a white girl 'laid for him!' Anyway, I'll stop now, it just kills me how (inadvertently) rascist the whole show is.
Oh yeah: by 1883, so many settlers would have passed through, the Natives would be used to it. The reason i say this is to ammend an earlier point, the braves would also go looking for settlers/wagon trains looking to get coffee, or whiskey, or even AMMO if they could find a white naive enough to give it up.
@@Skipjack7814 I wonder when they will do a truthful representation of how violent the tribes actually were.
Killed off entire tribes including killed women and children, roasted babies and practiced cannibalism.
They attacked settlers mercilessly unprovoked. The Commanche were masters of torture and if they didn't kill you on a raid they would bury you up to their heads cut their eyelids off so the sun would burn their eyes out while they starved to death slowly
How beautiful they are 🔥❤️🪶🦅
Costner and Taylor have always tried to tell the Indians story in THEIR words. Thank you!
As a White man i am humbled and saddened at the treatment of the Indian by Whites. We should have listened more and shot less. Maybe then America qould not be broken, as it is.
I am white and have Native American ancestors and makes me wonder what their love story was like .
Sickens me that heirloom sacreds are being auctioned off. My family had shields and bonnets with quetzal feathers and abalogne that were stolen when my great grandparents were sent to assimilation schools because their parents only spoke the tekwapu. Those sacred were sold and destroyed and i have nothing but my pride which cant be bought or stolen or destroyed. Ah kah muh kuh tuh nuh numu pabi patsi sumu numu kehtu taibo
#BuryMyHeartAtWoundedKnee Taylor your writing will right the wrongs of the past! Thank you!
Hello how are you doing today?
I wonder when they will do a truthful representation of how violent the tribes actually were.
Killed off entire tribes including killed women and children, roasted babies and practiced cannibalism.
They attacked settlers mercilessly unprovoked. The Commanche were masters of torture and if they didn't kill you on a raid they would bury you up to their heads cut their eyelids off so the sun would burn their eyes out while they starved to death slowly
Nuh, it won't. It CAN'T.
@@svenkreft9784 Taylor Sheridan is the most genuine writer out there! Hollywood has a tendency to gloss over everything. Outlander is one of the few productions that actually uses indigenous people and that includes bringing them in from Canada all the way to Scotland!
I bet that if someone were to make an honest representation of Indians and their history amongst other tribes. They will be surprised at how violent they were in conquering each other’s lands.
Yep. Took scalp, killed women and children and ate people.
They attacked settlers mercilessly unprovoked. The Commanche were masters of torture and if they didn't kill you on a raid they would bury you up to their heads cut their eyelids off so the sun would burn their eyes out while they starved to death slowly
Well I mean all the tribes were very different so grouping all native Americans into “Indians” it does a disservice and also Europeans were far the most violent and savage peoples on the earth with countless massacres and wars over petty disputes
Indians? There wasn’t one Indian in this clip? Where’d you get Indian from dummy?
@@bootscuffmagee4199 open your eyes.
By this point in time, as in the late 1800’s the tribes had essentially hunkered down to protect what they had. They did absolutely right in the portrayal
I remember Gram green from north of 60 . But Albert from the show, always hang around with carvers in Vancouver BC, no not Gram. I really miss those days when he was alive, some times he brought our carvings, I still carve, now I am in Gastown Vancouver BC. I don't want to Gram anyways, ok, he was one of my great heroes then. Anyways always looked down at us, so no disrespect we understand ,👍
Where can I illegally stream this?
It's out on DVD in Walmart for 20 bucks and worth the price.
🤣🤣🤣
And still the heroine is a skinny very blond, white girl right out of central casting. WHY? What is wrong with telling it like it was.
What would you have done differently here?
@@BB12659 One-legged black lesbian
Let us hope in 20 years there are 30,000.
It’s waaaayyy past time the tribes of native Americans have their day and their stories and their history told.
I wonder when they will do a truthful representation of how violent the tribes actually were.
Killed off entire tribes including killed women and children, roasted babies and practiced cannibalism.
They attacked settlers mercilessly unprovoked. The Commanche were masters of torture and if they didn't kill you on a raid they would bury you up to their heads cut their eyelids off so the sun would burn their eyes out while they starved to death slowly
True that. But please not like this, with a German Eskimo portraying a Comanche perfectly fluent in English. 🤦♂️
Wait a damn minute... weren't Comanche downright brutal to everyone they met? Or did I buy into the peaceful native American narrative like everyone else?
Ever seen medieval europe The fucked up things that we did back in the day
@@Edwinthemountainman8454 I get your damn point. I'm just saying people still believe that all native Americans were peaceful.
@@DavidReyes-ot1rc you are 100% right Comanches where insane. So brutal in fact i don’t want to mention, some of the things they have done.
Yes, and no. They fought everyone, traded with everyone.
They took captives, tortured and killed them or they would incorporate them into the tribe.
This is Montana dumbass. The Comanche are in Texas. U gonna complain about people in Switzerland being nice in a movie even tho people in France are dicks? What are u even complaining about
Lol. My great grandfather fought the Comanche. I'm sure he had a pretty realistic perspective on them. Great show though.
Sometimes I just wanted to be born in Native American
Wish he had put this much energy into season 4 of Yellowstone, because that shit sucked.
European settlers wouldn’t have stood a chance in their westward expansion if it weren’t for Native Americans.
God N' Country: absolutely
@@sandramorey2529 I wonder when they will do a truthful representation of how violent the tribes actually were.
Killed off entire tribes including killed women and children, roasted babies and practiced cannibalism.
They attacked settlers mercilessly unprovoked. The Commanche were masters of torture and if they didn't kill you on a raid they would bury you up to their heads cut their eyelids off so the sun would burn their eyes out while they starved to death slowly
If I want accuracy, I'll watch a documentary.
is this on Netflix??
Paramount +
@@MicheleWalkerWebb no not gender enough for netflix
@@mickb44 Respectively. Wrong person.
It's out on DVD in Walmart for 20 bucks and worth it.
It's so disrespectful that a white woman is wearing that at all.
-COMANCHE NATION
That was her wedding "Dress", also her "passport" and had she been wearing it later, what happened would not have happened.
Cultural appropriation.
@@pogo1140 Correct, the Sioux may have thought twice.
It though they were Italian actors...😂
PENZERT MINDENT.TUDATOS BENSZULOT IRTAS.EZ LIMONADE.GONDOLJ BELE,MI VOLT!
So a Comanche darling, travelling away from his band comes acros a herd of buffalo in 1883, a rare occurrence that could have fed A LOT OF PEOPLE,, and just kills one cow, scaring away the rest of the herd just to give his crash a hunting tutorial, and this is an accurate portrayal? So in Samoset's chsracter, what precisely have we learned about the Numunu/Comanche except that they rode horses, hunted buffalo, wore colourful clothing and had long hair? Like what was did his character serve apart from being a plot point in favor of the rad and unconventional 19th century teenage gir's lifestyle? Insread of showcasing the Comanches within the historical cintext of the time portrayed, they just inserted a plain Indian, decided that he should be Comanche and used him to show that the Dutton girl sees no skin colour or minority and just follows her heart despite the norms of the time and her father's objections. What a woke fairy tale. They at least did a slightly better job with the Lakota and a slightly better still job with the Crow.
❤💛🤍🖤
They get real ones this time?
Yes, because a blond white teenager wearing leather chaps and commanche sleeveless bling in 1883, while having an affair with an English speaking warrior is so historically accurate! I hated the series.
Then what the hell are you doing here? Go away Kimmy.
Well, there was Cynthia Ann Parker, kidnapped and raised by Comanche Indians, and the mother of Quanah Parker, the last free Comanche chief.
But non the less it happened amd will for ever go down in history as a fight for new territory that was conquered and is now as we all know it to be America, the home of the brave!
Just the made-up good non of the bad. Useless.
Tuplage em português
❤❤❤❤❤😂❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
You all are going to get mad at me or not care and that's okay. Evolution is dead with this model.
obnoxious series...
Why to skinny!!!!!!!!!
I smell some inauthentic wokeness....
Whatever you say snowflake
Eeee he didnt say i love you the right way.
1883 ❤ 💋 😘 looking for an extra work S a m
The real Americans
That’s not what they call themselves.
So the story is about the indigenous tribes of north America?
From reading about the Comanche I have learned one thing, they were far from nice peaceful people. They were savage murdering rapists with a penchant for torture.
A great series….. sugar coated though.
You have to remember a lot of tribes where farmers as well as warlike so not all where as you described